In 1835 Chopin was about to start his maturity period. Nocturnes op 27 are dated 1836. Just to put Dobrzynski beautiful piece into the right context and give him credit about how independently on his more famous colleague he had obtained a robust and mature language
We have the same brain... i also immediately thought of the context in the sense of what Chopin did at that time.. but i didn't look it up.. thanks for doing that 👍
Yes but Chopin had already written his E minor and C# minor nocturnes in 1830 and then published 5 more (Op.9 and Op15) in 1832-33 so it's possible Dobrzynski was aware of them (and the C minor nocturne from fields that @randomusername248 mentions, which has a similar left hand)
А при чём здесь ор.27 Шопена? Ведь были уже ноктюрны ор.9 и 15!Поэтому ни о какой самостоятельности Добржиньского речь не идёт,а речь идёт о подтасовке фактов в пользу мало самостоятельного автора,занимающего достойное его место в истории музыки( где-то на задворках).
@Miraak themes are so uninspired, soulless - it sounds like a study of composition that is not ready. Frankly, I improvised better Nocturnes when I was 12. The genius of Chopin his Nocturnes is like magic and no other composer can project this sentiment and intensity.
@Miraak that's the problem: thinking. Music is about feeling. Chopin spoke the language of the universe. "Nocturne" is just a word, not a dance, musical form like a sonata, it is something more abstract and Chopin knew exactly what to do with it. Field's "opinion" on Chopin is just disgusting and ridiculous. I guess that Field had similar comments on Liszt's Nocturnes then. - good that not everyone shares my opinion.
In 1835 Chopin was about to start his maturity period. Nocturnes op 27 are dated 1836. Just to put Dobrzynski beautiful piece into the right context and give him credit about how independently on his more famous colleague he had obtained a robust and mature language
We have the same brain... i also immediately thought of the context in the sense of what Chopin did at that time.. but i didn't look it up.. thanks for doing that 👍
@@PianoScoreVids 😉💪🤲🍻
They are very similar to some of the nocturnes by John Field who lived 1782-1837. In particular the nocturne in C minor from 1812.
Yes but Chopin had already written his E minor and C# minor nocturnes in 1830 and then published 5 more (Op.9 and Op15) in 1832-33 so it's possible Dobrzynski was aware of them (and the C minor nocturne from fields that @randomusername248 mentions, which has a similar left hand)
А при чём здесь ор.27 Шопена? Ведь были уже ноктюрны ор.9 и 15!Поэтому ни о какой самостоятельности Добржиньского речь не идёт,а речь идёт о подтасовке фактов в пользу мало самостоятельного автора,занимающего достойное его место в истории музыки( где-то на задворках).
Какая превосходная пьеса!!! Чистое наслаждение...
Ноктюрн Dobrzynski- 'восхитительная прекрасная музыка. Прослышала несколько раз. Огромное спасибо.
What a wonderful Nocturne, played with such melancholy and full of yearning..
Прекрасно!все позабудешь все печали.Наслаждаюсь!!! Благодарю
Moderatissimo! Very interesting
Magnifique Nocturne. Impossible de comparer avec Chopin, je refuse les comparaisons! Interprétation très émouvante. Merci ++
Wow! It's so beautiful!
Absolutely beautiful.
Very beautiful piece! Thank you
Es impresionante como cada día puedes interpretar una obra con esa exactitud! Es un Nocturno maravilloso y difícil. Gracias por compartir tu música. 😍
Beautiful, once again, and a rare one this time! Love it!
Absolutely delightful. Thanks much.
Наслаждение-💖
His nocturne op 21 no 1 is good too👌
wow you know him? thanks for the tip.
@@PianoScoreVids I know of his nocturnes I came across them when I was listening to John fields nocturnes by Bart van oort
Belíssimo Noturno!
Parece gotas de cristal derramadas pela suavidade da Alma!
Как хорошо!
beautiful
It is worthy to be called Genius as Chopin
Można słychać bez końca❤
Поделитесь нотами пожалуйста!!
Julian, it is noticeable that you enjoy playing this nocturne. I really like how you execute it!
Отличная вещица!
💗💗
Bellissimo.... C'è vita al di la di Chopin
Moderatissimo!
Great stuff. I hear a bit of Field and Mendelssohn there.
Beautiful! Very Chopin-esque.
✌🎹🎹🎹👌🎶🎶🎶👍🎹🎹🎹👈
Beautiful piece of music but way too much 2-against-3. My little old brain can't make my hands do that. Kudos to you for being able to pull it off.
When you want play something, hear to it before many many times! So, it's come natural. Play, play 2 for 3 is not difficult!
4:12
Tierce de Picardie
Picardy cadence
tierce picarde
5th class music. Waste of time.
@Miraak themes are so uninspired, soulless - it sounds like a study of composition that is not ready. Frankly, I improvised better Nocturnes when I was 12. The genius of Chopin his Nocturnes is like magic and no other composer can project this sentiment and intensity.
@Miraak that's the problem: thinking. Music is about feeling. Chopin spoke the language of the universe. "Nocturne" is just a word, not a dance, musical form like a sonata, it is something more abstract and Chopin knew exactly what to do with it. Field's "opinion" on Chopin is just disgusting and ridiculous. I guess that Field had similar comments on Liszt's Nocturnes then.
- good that not everyone shares my opinion.