PotentialHistory does a good video breaking down why this scene is terribly unrealistic, but in summary: 1. It made no sense for a single tank platoon to be traveling by itself, without other tanks or supporting infantry. 2. The Tiger should have shot Fury first, being both at the lead of the column and equipped with the better gun (high velocity 76mm). 3. Fury was capable of taking out the Tiger the entire time (again, HV 76 mm) and there wasn't really a need for the entire platoon to charge. 4. The Tiger had absolutely no reason to advance. 5. None of the tanks should have fired while moving. 6. No way in hell Fury bounces the shot off the logs. 7. Again, Fury did not need to hit the Tiger from the rear to take it out.
@@BleakwoodProductions It's a great movie, and its message is one worth telling: "Ideals are peaceful; history is violent." (and human beings are their agents.) It does not need to subscribe to inaccurate and ahistorical myths about tank combat in WW2 (largely perpetrated by Nazis) to tell it.
@@aleks2703 consistently hitting moving tank sized targets center mass was already hard enough at the time, so almost certainly not intentional, tank commanders catching head wounds of different severity was quite common however as they always gambled with the risk of catching shrapnel with the possible reward of hearing or seeing surroundings better.
Always love the reactions, glad to see them keeping up I will leave the battle of Hardhome from GOT as a suggestion, even if it isn't modern stuff it is still something I think may be interesting Edit: auto correct saw hardhome and changed it to handsome I hate my life
funfact:the tiger they fought is THE last fully working tiger tank from the second world war the museum that had it said to the movie crew/producers/director they got 24 hours with it one that time was up that'd disable it again. making the gun unable to use rounds removing its engine so on.
3:25 That shot should've honestly pierced, but it was at an angle soooo. It's just that the Tiger 1's turret armor is dog water and the two 75mm smooth-bore M4A1 Shermans could've shot the nice and flat turret cheek armor of the Tiger and pierced. But, idk why the M4A1 Shermans, with short-barreled and smooth-bore guns got more accurate shots than the M4A3E8 Sherman with the long-barreled and rifled 76.2mm. The 76.2mm gun even has a muzzle brake to control the recoil better! Hollywood. Nothing you can do about it. (sorry for the whole essay lol 😆. I also figured out the Tiger 1's frontal turret armor varies between 80-100mm. The gun that the M4A1 Shermans had were the 75mm M3 guns, which could pierce 102mm of armor from 100 meters away. In the movie it seemed like the last 75mm Sherman was only a few meters away from the Tiger before it got killed.
That Tiger commander was very stupid. He could easily take out a;; of those Shermans without leaving his position. He gave up his advantages of armour and firepower. Americans do not make good war movies.
As a WW2 enthusiast, this video brings me both joy and infuriation (the infuriation on part of the movie than your video) Regardless, don't let 🤓 like me stop you for doing more WW2 stuff though.
Well given when fury supposed to take place I don't thing the jumbo was made yet so it's probably just the standard three stranded Shermans and a 75 for tiger hunting
Realistically speaking, that Tiger tank would not have moved from its position. Not only would most of its front have been covered by dirt due to being in a moat, but also because it is easier to fire while stationary. Additionally, they would have most likely targeted the lead tank instead of the rear one, or the tank with the better armament.
As much as I HATE this movie that is just full of "MURICA" bullcrap and shows the Germans as stupid (Panzerfaust boi not shooting when almost kissing the tank, Tiger being DUMB and not shooting the Firefly first AND MOVING FORWARD INSTEAD OF USING ITS RANGE ADVANTAGE, a WHOLE SS BATALLION NOT MANAGING TO TAKE DOWN AN IMMOBILIZED TANK.....), the reaction is pretty solid, the detail of Rory smirking during a "normal" gunfight compared to the tank fight instead is great
The lead American tank wasn't a Firefly it was a M4A3(76)W which is an American tank built in America given to the British (also used by the US Marines) the reason the Fury tank is British is because of it's engine using a different fuel type a fuel type that only the British used I'll try and find a video on it!
@@erianafoster yeah yeah I got it wrong but it not very easy to tell all of the Shermans apart there’s this guy called Eta320 who knows ALL of the Sherman type it’s kind cool!
No, tanks were designed to be hardest to kill from the front. So the front is always the strongest. The scene, will cool, makes no sense tactical wise. Fury should have penned its armor 30 seconds ago, the tiger had the better spot so it rushing forward makes no sense. If anything, the tiger just made winning 5 times harder. Plus the commander of the tiger wouldn’t have done that.
Realistically speaking the Sherman's would have lost and theres no chance the Germans would have untrained crew in a fucking tiger also while the Sherman shot 2 shells the tiger didn't even shot ones I mean wtf was the German crew doing and the tiger would have never came out of the bush seeing that the the Sherman's had the gun to penetrate their frontal armour
The Tigers front armor is about 100mm thick the Fury tank was a 76mm Sherman which could destroy the Tiger from the range they first started the fight the movie plays of the myth of you need 4 Shermans to kill 1 Tiger which is utter nonsense!
I just realized the commander who ate an 88mm to the face, got a round that ricochet off the ground into his face. Although to be fair I get a really iffed when the Easy Eight's 76mm ricochets off of the flat front plate of the Tiger at what looks to be less than 500m, that round has enough velocity to go through not bounce like that. And yes Fury is supposed to be an Easy Eight.
Loved the video @~Eriana Foster~! Can't wait for the next video Girl! I, For all of Hollywood's Streotyping, Loved seeing "FURY" since it had a lot of my Favorite Late-War World War Two Period Equipment like the M4A3E8 "Easy Eight" Sherman (FURY) or the M4A1(76mm) Sherman and even the Mighty Tiger I E Heavy Tank. Truth be told though, The Tiger is actually the Only Tiger Tank in the World that's in Running Condition. It's known as "Tiger 131" and is at the Tank Museum in Bovington, Dorsetshire. Simple History has a video dedicated to Tiger 131 on their Channel if you want GATE and Cold Star to react to that.
for anyone wondering: yes at 4:15 the sherman should have die but the movie decided to pull a plot armor on us and the dumbest tiger tank crew (they were hidden and with a perfect angle that allows to bounce every shot they could have just move to get out of the smoke and then just go for the kill) (also for them those ARE tank or iron elephants if you want just older then current ones)
You know i just relaized something...that Tiger tank got his Fury moment. What i mean is they stopped the advance of an entire tank squad and destroyed 95% of it alone. If Germans won the war we would have got a movie about them. Now im not rooting for nazi i was just doing a consideration that yeah when our protagonists do that we cry but those germans soldiers basically did the same thing and sure they are nazi but not all germans soldiers were SS fanatics some just wanted to serve their country.
I was referring to their reaction, not the actual turnout of tank on tank fighting during the war. If you watch Rory, she smiles when the Tiger goes down, but she goes wide-eyed as we see how many tanks they lost taking down the tiger.
The reason why the shells are making such a loud noises because they’re piecing the sound barrier and make it a loud whistle because they penetrate it through the sound barrier or maybe I am completely wrong and I’m just being stupid
The tiger one in this movie is actually the first real tiger to be on set well maybe not the first because the first movie that featured the Tiger one a real one was in there is glory this tiger tank was captured in north Africa by the British this thing took a real beating taking multiple rounds from British Churchill’s and not doing anything till they were able to disable the gun and the turret ring the crew had the bail out but forgot to destroy Tiger 131 every German tiger commander was ordered to destroy the tiger tank if it was either immobilized or completely destroyed
A tiger one is the most unlucky thing to run into if you’re in an M4 Sherman the tiger one can engage a M4 Sherman from kilometers away with its long 88 mm gun and the Shermans only having 75 and 76 mm guns is 76 mm is capable of penetrating the tiger ones armor from Ranger but is still vulnerable to other heavy tanks such as the king tiger an upgraded version and completely different model of the Tiger one but it’s it was made to replace the old tiger one is the tiger one head squared armor unlike sloped armor but the tiger 1 was still a big danger
Exactly the problem of this scene is Exactly that. Why the tiger is moving to them instead then moving backwards using the reach advantage or standing in his huding spot? Regardless is a cool scene and maybe is to show Germans boldness or desperation as they were loosing the war.
Could you make them react to the song Rylanor’s last stand there is a music video we’ll kinda of it it’s a very beautiful song I’m sure people would love it
I'd like to see them react to the final battle scene in Fury
They will cry i swear
Agreed.
That'd be cool
I hope the SS March is shown before hand, I love that scene
That would be very good
PotentialHistory does a good video breaking down why this scene is terribly unrealistic, but in summary:
1. It made no sense for a single tank platoon to be traveling by itself, without other tanks or supporting infantry.
2. The Tiger should have shot Fury first, being both at the lead of the column and equipped with the better gun (high velocity 76mm).
3. Fury was capable of taking out the Tiger the entire time (again, HV 76 mm) and there wasn't really a need for the entire platoon to charge.
4. The Tiger had absolutely no reason to advance.
5. None of the tanks should have fired while moving.
6. No way in hell Fury bounces the shot off the logs.
7. Again, Fury did not need to hit the Tiger from the rear to take it out.
For number 2 they did address that if the tiger tank action were realistic than there would be no more movie but yeah
.....It's a fucking movie. Chill.
@@BleakwoodProductions
It's a great movie, and its message is one worth telling:
"Ideals are peaceful; history is violent."
(and human beings are their agents.)
It does not need to subscribe to inaccurate and ahistorical myths about tank combat in WW2 (largely perpetrated by Nazis) to tell it.
@@BleakwoodProductionsEspecially when it takes the effort to have an actual functioning Tiger (Tiger 131) in this scene.
@@cl0vvntiem Well constantly complaining about a movie from 2014 won't fix it.
God, that part when than tank commander gets nailed by the 88mm cannon always shocks me, it's so sudden.
Jeez, even the demi-goddess (Rory) was shocked.
@@rafengamer6296 u know shits real when rory is shocked
I’m worried if it was accidental or the gunner targeted him
@@aleks2703 consistently hitting moving tank sized targets center mass was already hard enough at the time, so almost certainly not intentional, tank commanders catching head wounds of different severity was quite common however as they always gambled with the risk of catching shrapnel with the possible reward of hearing or seeing surroundings better.
That one dude got reduced to atoms
nah he go tturned into strawberry sauce
More like reduced to dust
More like reduced to dust
Thank you for this reaction. Very well done. Since you chose Fury, have them react to the last stand as well.
it'd be a good capstone to this I imagine.
On Jah that scene was epic
Always love the reactions, glad to see them keeping up
I will leave the battle of Hardhome from GOT as a suggestion, even if it isn't modern stuff it is still something I think may be interesting
Edit: auto correct saw hardhome and changed it to handsome I hate my life
funfact:the tiger they fought is THE last fully working tiger tank from the second world war the museum that had it said to the movie crew/producers/director they got 24 hours with it one that time was up that'd disable it again. making the gun unable to use rounds removing its engine so on.
Oh this is a good one.
2:43 my favourite 🙃
To my opinion this is the best reaction ever 😁👍🏼
Nice work my friend might I suggest they react to an Alamo battle scene I don't care which
Oh god this movie where the Germans don’t operate equipment correctly
3:25 That shot should've honestly pierced, but it was at an angle soooo. It's just that the Tiger 1's turret armor is dog water and the two 75mm smooth-bore M4A1 Shermans could've shot the nice and flat turret cheek armor of the Tiger and pierced. But, idk why the M4A1 Shermans, with short-barreled and smooth-bore guns got more accurate shots than the M4A3E8 Sherman with the long-barreled and rifled 76.2mm. The 76.2mm gun even has a muzzle brake to control the recoil better! Hollywood. Nothing you can do about it. (sorry for the whole essay lol 😆. I also figured out the Tiger 1's frontal turret armor varies between 80-100mm. The gun that the M4A1 Shermans had were the 75mm M3 guns, which could pierce 102mm of armor from 100 meters away. In the movie it seemed like the last 75mm Sherman was only a few meters away from the Tiger before it got killed.
Absolutely love this vid do you think they could react to band of brothers or the pacific think that would be amazing
Yep that's why I hate that goddamn tiger he blew up somebody's head off
Can you react to "End of the War: Final minutes of WWI"?
Could you make them react to "If Fury was a British Film"? And nice reaction
Whyd the turret fall off, the sherman didnt have any ammo around the turrets base and wouldnt pop the the turret off
Is the music at the beggining Cradles by Sub Urban?
i would like to see the reaction to saving private Ryan if they react like this to fury and Kelly's hero's maybe after go from low to high mood
This os just an Idea, maybe have them react to Resident Evil 2?
I mean they could watch the t34 snow battle
Hello miss Eriana can you make them reaction hoovydandy and how i get link
they used a m4a3e8 Fury
That Tiger commander was very stupid. He could easily take out a;; of those Shermans without leaving his position. He gave up his advantages of armour and firepower.
Americans do not make good war movies.
Fury e il mio film preferito sui tank
WARHAMMMER PLZZz
Path of hate please
i thought u react to furry
the movie is good but it's too exaggerated in this part
T34 movie
😢poor peterson
While the movies ok as a history buff, it is just annoying to me
Fun fact Saving Private Ryan was so accurate that WW2 ptsd help centers had to open up their lines to veterans that were shell shocked
As a WW2 enthusiast, this video brings me both joy and infuriation (the infuriation on part of the movie than your video)
Regardless, don't let 🤓 like me stop you for doing more WW2 stuff though.
I hear ya man. Hollywood should follow Band of Brothers example. These movies don't really go well.
I am assuming it's the part where the Tiger tank got out of hiding?
@@pasiaangelo6442 And didn't immediately target the Sherman with the biggest gun. Any commander would have taken it out first.
@@TheCreepercrusader Also the Sherman with the 76 would've shot the front plate of the Tiger and obliterated it if they didn't do that
@@mrmason2342 Perhaps but I agree. Hollywood just botched this scene so bad.
Fury was so good, great reaction as always
Is Roy's tank a Jumbo 75? It looks to edgy to be an Easy 8 let alone a 75.
Well given when fury supposed to take place I don't thing the jumbo was made yet so it's probably just the standard three stranded Shermans and a 75 for tiger hunting
Hear me out, they react to patient zero, made by TheParryGod, just saying,
Realistically speaking, that Tiger tank would not have moved from its position. Not only would most of its front have been covered by dirt due to being in a moat, but also because it is easier to fire while stationary. Additionally, they would have most likely targeted the lead tank instead of the rear one, or the tank with the better armament.
As much as I HATE this movie that is just full of "MURICA" bullcrap and shows the Germans as stupid (Panzerfaust boi not shooting when almost kissing the tank, Tiger being DUMB and not shooting the Firefly first AND MOVING FORWARD INSTEAD OF USING ITS RANGE ADVANTAGE, a WHOLE SS BATALLION NOT MANAGING TO TAKE DOWN AN IMMOBILIZED TANK.....), the reaction is pretty solid, the detail of Rory smirking during a "normal" gunfight compared to the tank fight instead is great
The lead American tank wasn't a Firefly it was a M4A3(76)W which is an American tank built in America given to the British (also used by the US Marines) the reason the Fury tank is British is because of it's engine using a different fuel type a fuel type that only the British used I'll try and find a video on it!
Video 1 ua-cam.com/video/6De-X6kO1V8/v-deo.html
Video 2 ua-cam.com/video/LIPG2_TOITo/v-deo.html
Video 3 ua-cam.com/video/Ifxmd-uMU5Y/v-deo.html
@@chrisbacon3071 It's actually an M4A2E8
@@erianafoster yeah yeah I got it wrong but it not very easy to tell all of the Shermans apart there’s this guy called Eta320 who knows ALL of the Sherman type it’s kind cool!
No, tanks were designed to be hardest to kill from the front. So the front is always the strongest. The scene, will cool, makes no sense tactical wise. Fury should have penned its armor 30 seconds ago, the tiger had the better spot so it rushing forward makes no sense. If anything, the tiger just made winning 5 times harder. Plus the commander of the tiger wouldn’t have done that.
thank you very much for the video I've been waiting for 6 years:)
Realistically speaking the Sherman's would have lost and theres no chance the Germans would have untrained crew in a fucking tiger also while the Sherman shot 2 shells the tiger didn't even shot ones I mean wtf was the German crew doing and the tiger would have never came out of the bush seeing that the the Sherman's had the gun to penetrate their frontal armour
The Tigers front armor is about 100mm thick the Fury tank was a 76mm Sherman which could destroy the Tiger from the range they first started the fight the movie plays of the myth of you need 4 Shermans to kill 1 Tiger which is utter nonsense!
Nice work!❤
Can we have the final battle from this movie?
I just realized the commander who ate an 88mm to the face, got a round that ricochet off the ground into his face. Although to be fair I get a really iffed when the Easy Eight's 76mm ricochets off of the flat front plate of the Tiger at what looks to be less than 500m, that round has enough velocity to go through not bounce like that. And yes Fury is supposed to be an Easy Eight.
Think you could do them reacting to the fight agaist the SS battalion
Loved the video @~Eriana Foster~! Can't wait for the next video Girl! I, For all of Hollywood's Streotyping, Loved seeing "FURY" since it had a lot of my Favorite Late-War World War Two Period Equipment like the M4A3E8 "Easy Eight" Sherman (FURY) or the M4A1(76mm) Sherman and even the Mighty Tiger I E Heavy Tank.
Truth be told though, The Tiger is actually the Only Tiger Tank in the World that's in Running Condition. It's known as "Tiger 131" and is at the Tank Museum in Bovington, Dorsetshire. Simple History has a video dedicated to Tiger 131 on their Channel if you want GATE and Cold Star to react to that.
As a history nerd I greatly approve this content
Me when sees a tiger while using M4A3 tank in wotb:
Nice work Eri, keep up the great work
for anyone wondering: yes at 4:15 the sherman should have die but the movie decided to pull a plot armor on us and the dumbest tiger tank crew (they were hidden and with a perfect angle that allows to bounce every shot they could have just move to get out of the smoke and then just go for the kill) (also for them those ARE tank or iron elephants if you want just older then current ones)
Oiiiiiii
You know i just relaized something...that Tiger tank got his Fury moment. What i mean is they stopped the advance of an entire tank squad and destroyed 95% of it alone. If Germans won the war we would have got a movie about them. Now im not rooting for nazi i was just doing a consideration that yeah when our protagonists do that we cry but those germans soldiers basically did the same thing and sure they are nazi but not all germans soldiers were SS fanatics some just wanted to serve their country.
Such a great victory, then you remember they traded three of four tanks to kill one tiger.
I'm pretty sure that was the point of shermans. drown them in iron.
@@johnj.spurgin7037 for that scene in particular, it was shit strategy
that's a myth of you don't need 4 Shermans to kill 1 Tiger...
I was referring to their reaction, not the actual turnout of tank on tank fighting during the war. If you watch Rory, she smiles when the Tiger goes down, but she goes wide-eyed as we see how many tanks they lost taking down the tiger.
@@chrisbacon3071 oh I know you don't NEED 4 shermans, but the more gun the better.
The reason why the shells are making such a loud noises because they’re piecing the sound barrier and make it a loud whistle because they penetrate it through the sound barrier or maybe I am completely wrong and I’m just being stupid
The tiger one in this movie is actually the first real tiger to be on set well maybe not the first because the first movie that featured the Tiger one a real one was in there is glory this tiger tank was captured in north Africa by the British this thing took a real beating taking multiple rounds from British Churchill’s and not doing anything till they were able to disable the gun and the turret ring the crew had the bail out but forgot to destroy Tiger 131 every German tiger commander was ordered to destroy the tiger tank if it was either immobilized or completely destroyed
Have them react to “What if the Tiger crew from Fury was smart” i may have misspelled/pronounced the title but yea
Fury final battle scenes or stalingrad 2013 red army crossing the Volga video
They all 1000% witnessed what a tank (Elephant in Princess Pina's terms) can do with the main gun
Hey eriana plis new recording tf the fight for sawmill plis 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
the germans were kinda dumb, they could've turned the hull as well to aim faster at the american sherman and not letting them see the rear ;-;
Fun fact: the tiger tank was 131
The last known functional tiger
4:39 Roy and Pina look surprisingly okay with that statement
UA-cam won't be pleased with this video.
A tiger one is the most unlucky thing to run into if you’re in an M4 Sherman the tiger one can engage a M4 Sherman from kilometers away with its long 88 mm gun and the Shermans only having 75 and 76 mm guns is 76 mm is capable of penetrating the tiger ones armor from Ranger but is still vulnerable to other heavy tanks such as the king tiger an upgraded version and completely different model of the Tiger one but it’s it was made to replace the old tiger one is the tiger one head squared armor unlike sloped armor but the tiger 1 was still a big danger
Exactly the problem of this scene is Exactly that. Why the tiger is moving to them instead then moving backwards using the reach advantage or standing in his huding spot? Regardless is a cool scene and maybe is to show Germans boldness or desperation as they were loosing the war.
I was waiting for them to ask who Roger is.
Oh no starting with this scene DC made me sad a lot that goddamn tiger
Yeah I want see final scene fury vs all billion German
I want them to react to Ser Arther dyne vs Ned Stark please
Bus to tanks along the way but killed a goddamn tank😢
Poor Mari reacting to it.
Cold Star full name pls
AAAYYYYY! MY GIRL TOOK MY SUGGESTION!
Not sure if she actually did but I'm rolling with it
Fiery is a really good movie
Sz Tiger 1
Could you make them react to the song Rylanor’s last stand there is a music video we’ll kinda of it it’s a very beautiful song I’m sure people would love it
Furys last stand?
2:36 ❤
Any chance of them reacting to Shepard's betrayal and death from COD 2?
TEMPLIN INSTITUTE THE TYRANIDS PLZLzzzZZZZ
"You do know that we get a $1.35 a day right?
Best job I've ever had."
+1 comment
Can you have them react to navy legends USS Texas BB-35
i saw this movie called t-34 and it's about a soviet tank
it's a beautiful ww2 movie it would be nice to make a reaction a
Fun fact: the tiger 1 was the only working tank in the movie itself
Based.
Might I suggest a video on them reacting to some of the skirmish battles in the movie T-34?
Dippity dappity his head went splatity.
The Tiger Tank a powerful tank which came out late war
I hope they can see more war movies based on Earth to see how war has progressed
You should make them react to the end battle scene
best video ever loved it 👍🏻
Deutsche panzer Kraft
The last stand of the fury
Great Job Eri, thanks for the vid I really enjoyed it.