Is North India Stealing from South India?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 кві 2023
- Download Xtra by MobiKwik
bit.ly/3ojYAFg
🎥 Learn how to edit videos like AevyTV:
www.aevytv.com
/ aevyvideoschool
📌Follow us on Instagram here:
/ aevytvdaily
/ achinamayya
Is North India cheating South India? South Indian states pay more tax but get less in return, despite better GDP, education, and lower population. For every 100 rupees of direct tax Karnataka pays, the state receives 13.9 rupees, while north Indian states get 333 rupees (UP) and 922 rupees (Bihar). The perverse incentive system increases population growth, limiting political power in the Lok Sabha and no say in money bills. The 15th finance commission divides tax revenue by income distance, which unfairly favors North India. South India must demand a direct democracy, like Switzerland, to achieve equal representation.
Being from Karnataka, I'm not upset about the revenue distribution thing. But the funds not being utilised properly in the northern states is painful
Why will local politicians support development when they can take center's money and fill their own pockets.
Finally A Smart Person in the Comments ❤
I feel so bad when people like u keep grouping all northern states as a single entity
@@Horopterwho TF imposing language on u ! In the world of advance translation system ! Literally live translation systems ! Language is not a barrier like in older times now ! U guys who cry about Hindi imposition and all so dumb ! I'm Marathi myself we some care ! We just care about the connection between people's !
Language not gonna go anywhere! Don't worry
@Amit Raj Hindi is our 3 rd language in school ( Karnataka )
I am from Tamilnadu and we don't feel bad for contributing tax.. But, we are so disappointed by the way the tax is utilized.. Is that really benefitting those north states?? Not at all.. The corrupted politicians invest them in polarizing people and not letting them get educated, focused on growth.. TN focused on education and social justice, we would be rather so happy if that tax really helps the poor people in those states..
Not completely fair, the Madras presidency, Mysore state and to a lesser degree Hyderabad/Travancore inherited large industries that the center invested into, something that did not happen to the same degree in the North. Just count the number of expansions Chennai and Mumbai ports got compared to Kolkata, Mangalore or even Cochin. The historical ports of KA, KL, GJ, AP and OR completely emptied due to the collapse of Myanmar and Freight equalisation. Even today you see concentrations of the coastal communities towards the three major ports Chennai hosting people from KA, KL and AP; Mumbai from KA, MH and GJ and Kolkata OR, BH, and AS.
If we were independent in the 1910's, People from the Bengal presidency would be complaining about us the same way. South India got surplus budget allocation starting from the recession of 1825 all the way till 1940's when the WW2 famines made parts of Oudh and BP(current state of BH) governance deficit
What tn is concentrating in education and social justice,tell me did government school infra good
@@HarishSrinivasan-fe1yxdo you APJ Kalam ...he is educated from tamil nadu government school only
@@nothingtosay2593 they have talent so why many talents comes from private rather than government school why all chose cbse instead of state board syllabus why rich go to private instead of government
@@HarishSrinivasan-fe1yx most of the talent people from tamilnadu they studied in our government school bro ..... there is nothing to do with CBSC
As i am from Kerala.. i feel it is a little injustice with us but if these funds will really be used for development of North India..than i will be more than happy...but these is not the case now it all just goes in the pocket of corrupt politicans 😢
And in the pockets of corrupt bureaucrats as well.
We need a separate country
@@freetamilnaduandsouthfromi2984 go for it but will get no support like those khalistani or Kashmiri.
@@freetamilnaduandsouthfromi2984 dmk urine dog 😂😂😂
@@navneetkumar1975 unless all of South india unite... Yeah well we'll see
Being a north indian , I completely agree with taxation problem but peoples of South India deserve more from tax
@@Mishra77 nope we are developed boz of our lliteracy we can build it again! can north do it 😂😂
@@lightingstar7316 FYI literacy and education are both different. I have seen alot of South indian people who are really dumb ( no offense). South india isn't a utopia you should know about unemployment issue in kerala, visa and IT corruption in Andhra pradesh, regional discrimination and rise of dravidian ideology in tamil Nadu same issue with karnataka speaks volumes about how high thinking individuals South Indians are. There are developed cities in North India too my friend.
@@raghavrathore3698 who says complete south india is educated! Even USA as some set back the ppls are dumb there the ppls are agressive there! The ppls in usa can even read analog clock there! Does it make usa dumb! No right? Same goes to south 🙂
@@lightingstar7316 come to UP, the rising tech hub in north can you imagine how a state full of mafias got ride of all mafias in just 50 days. can your govt finish the mafias of your state involved in illegal activities within this time
@@subhodutta6163 two mfs were shot dead on live tv yesterday and the entire state is celebrating it? Do you call that development? Lawless state it will doom the entire country
As a south indian I am ok to pay more taxes but where is the accountability...there is no development happening it is just going to the pockets of dirty politicians and in our own state north Karnataka is still underdeveloped...there is a saying in kannada "navu udara agala nimgu udara agake bidala"
People in north Karnataka should improve their mindset and should think about of being more opportunist
you are right. i am from bihar and i know that our politicians are most corrupt and they waste that money which belongs to you guys. but, up government is working very nice and soon they will also contribute a good share in centre's tax.
I am sorry 🙏 🙏 that we people are wasting your money.
@@abhinaysingh8306 I agree, at the end it all depends on the politicians elected by the people of the state. I hope places like Bihar have better representations.
@@alok.01 actually, this time we elected nda government so that corruption reduces in bihar but you know nitish broke the alliance and made alliance with rjd which is most corrupt party of this whole nation. Yadavs in bihar always give votes to them just because of caste. i don't know why they are so much castiest
during nda rule from 2020 to 22 , our per capita income increased from 43000 to 69000 but now pace will slow.
states like bihar and up will not be succesful until their politicians start thinking beyond votes and caste
ya exactly ig north India is still trying to develop, but south India is already developed, so maybe that's the reason.
p.s- north India is much behind than south India as u know in educations and stuffs, plus they have border connections so ya
Isnt tamil politics castist too?
UP is improving I guess
lol if politics was the sole reason then why does language politics never affected the south?
see the history too, history has favored many south states
Damn, the condescending tone the South uses for the North never fails to surprise me.
These guys think that their horse is so high that it's beyond the troposphere.😂
Worst part is even though south contribute so much for country yet north India based political parties will question about our patriotism towards the country ,impose the Hindi language,import thier mandir - masjid politics.
How Hindi is imposed on you 😂
Pls enlighten us 😂
@@vinaymann838 Many people think Hindi is the national language lol and many documents and exams are only conducted in Hindi and English.
Tum south indians hamesha rote hu rehte ho
@@vinaymann838this is always you question whatever's you want and always rude and come with non sense ,touch some grass lmaof,how about we ask you to speak in Malayalam,kannada,Telugu,Tamil in your north ? Will you be okay?but why are your people who are working here in south intentionally talking in Hindi with non Hindi speakers ? And expect us to speak in Hindi and when we ask them to answer in English they do annoy us continuously by speaking Hindi not all but most of them want to provoke intentionally all know that English is always been international language and easy for communication, stay mad crooks stfu
Import mandir masjid politics? Lol North Karnataka was the base for BJP even before their emergence in the Hindi belt. Everyone is forgetting that BJP won 18 seats in the 1983 Karnataka assembly elections.
This is not to mention the the Congress had its own factions due to being a big party. Large voterbases of the right wing congress(O), Janata party and Janata Dal along with prominent political personalities like Bommai, Urs family, SM Krishna, etc steadily moved to the BJP once historical neutrality turned into Tippu praise.
TN seen three major riots where RSS has no political footprint. Chennai 90, coimbatore 97 and 2016.
Let us South Indians have our own political parties to represent South India
❤
you guys already have lol
Wait, there are already separate parties for our states so, what do you mean by own political party to represent South India, i hope you don't mean breaking of South from North, I don't think that should be a topic of discussion
We need a separate country
@@masterz1848 north India parties bring a very bad identity politics into state
I'm from Karnataka and we feel robbed
North india includes Punjab haryana himachal,Delhi , j&k uttrakhand parts of up and Rajasthan .....we are not claiming up bihar.....
@@KS-py4lqfair enough. But at least UP is showing signs of progress.
Bihar on the other hand is f_ucked
Talk about fep(freight equalisation policy) how it has stolen eastren india and reduced it as mining ground...
@@chinanumbawun111 Yes , there is no sign of a bit development in Bihar , as a bihari I'm frustrated and sad at the same time ,while other states are developing, we only Tangled in , cheap politics like caste , religion etc etc .
@@chinanumbawun111 🥲
The fact that disappoints the south states isn’t the fact we get lesser returns but the fact that BiMaRu states aren’t using the surplus money to actually improve
Because leader's there are very corrupt just see Akhilesh Yadav and Lalu Yadav. There dirty politics
Who looted these states for decades
BiMaRu states?
@@dia01 All the cow belt states. Pseudo hindu states
@@dia01 Bihar,MP,UP,Rajasthan.Historically these states are the ones that got most tax returns.Rajasthan and MP have improved but the other states still don’t show much growth compared to the money they are getting
@@jaykoey3683 meaning?
North is the center off ditry politics no wonder they are looting south Indians,I wish to see more people like you actually stand up in real media and fight for such causes..thank you so much for standing up in such a informative video
Maharashtra is even worst condition compared to southern states
@Jhenkar R Maharshtra is ruled by north indians historically and present also lol
They are indo Aryan aren't they??
Haryana is far more developed than Maharshtra
Indian border os guarded by north indians. Else Pakistan would have attacked and made siuth induans their slaves. Ok south indians??? Will it be gois beef eaters?
@@khushalsingh819maharashtra always has been the land of northie indo aryans we and southies are literal opposite despite living in the same region
@@khushalsingh819 north india was ruled by southern kings and the Marathas as well .
And as for haryana , it's all because of the NCR region,and since the taxes are centralised, haryana receives a lot more funding. That's not the case with Maharashtra. Maharashtra receives the lowest funds (₹7.7) for every ₹100 and not to mention most of the projects in Maharashtra are state funded and not central government funded. No one gives a shit about haryana , it's delhi ncr which people care about.
Maharastra get only 7.7 rupees on each 100 rupee given to the central government. UP and other states are claiming to become No 1 state by using the money they get from maharastra.
true
So despite being richest state of India why there's so disparities in maharastra is Govt using all funds correct?
If those states got developed then we will get jobs in our own state
These days, there’s a lot of talk about how South India contributes to taxes used in North India, but Maharashtra's significant role in tax contribution often goes unnoticed. Maharashtra is one of the largest contributors to India's economy, accounting for around 38% of the direct taxes collected in the country. Despite this, its political leaders and Marathi people rarely raise their voices about the issue. It's sad that many cities in Maharashtra are ignored when it comes to development.
As a south Indian I feel betrayed and it makes me hate these ‘Vadakkans’ more now.
Hi Macha, I am a north Indian and request you to not form notions based on such diluted inferences as this video. They put titles and notions like this just to create a stir and garner more views.
The Union of States = India = Bharat was not created so swiftly as mentioned by the lady within a minute. The British plundered the North more than the South. These states were left to famine and drought and poor. Years of movements, fighting, struggle, and sacrifice got us Independence.
That is the problem of our colonial brainwashing and study of history from a British point of view which only continued after Independence thanks to various factors. So most of our convent-educated people (which includes me) have limited pride in Bhaarat and what unites us - that we are a civilization state as opposed to a Nation-state.
Give us 10 more years, we will be on par with the states in the South. And let's not hate each other and call names.
@@arpitrai1161 these words again make my blood boil take money and say to stay silent
@@arpitrai1161 💓
@@arpitrai1161 At the time of independence, South India was quite poor. States like UP and Bihar used to be in top 10 due to abundance of water and fertile land. You cannot blame Mughals for poor governance, right?
@@daredevil30000 Cool agree. But the problem is - the logic, which we are defying here, the logic of One nation, we are thinking as two parts of the nation.
Bengal, is largest producer of rice, UP is largest producer of wheat. Uttar Pradesh and Bihar produces the most Administrative officers alternatively. UP again provides the highest number of soldiers to Indian army. India's major electricity production comes from Fossil Fuels that's Majorly Coal, that happens to be majorly in other parts of India than South. And many other things.
So my friend, by that logic we can have this debate as long as live but is it the right idea?
For fact of the matter - I pay considerably high amount of taxes and belong to the unfortunate service class of the country. By the numbers, only 8 cr people contribute direct taxes to government for 140 Cr people. On a personal level this isn't fair. But will I ask any non-working family member to contribute to taxes even though they aren't earning and call them whatever, or I'll cover for them? Food for thought ?
People are talking about North & South India, but Maharashtra only receives 7.7rs per 100rs paid to the center, it is worse than any other South Indian state but no one is talking about it!!!!!!!
Actually even less it receives ₹2 now and Gujarat gets ₹30, karnataka gets around ₹12 whereas north up get about ₹333, Bihar gets around ₹800, Assam gets around ₹2000. Eastern states eat most of money. They get rupees in 4 digits whereas Gujarat gets it in 2 digits and maharashtra gets it in 1 digit. India needs to get separated into different countries.
No sir ....I am from Maharashtra.....why are talking about partition..? India is our mother 😢 don't divide it...if other states getting more money it's okayna our India is growing na 😢 bad politations need to sleep forever@@Nishant1207-
Tamilnadu minister PTR mentioned this. South and states who suffer due to this taxation model, all should raise voice.
@@Nishant1207- Bhai get educated.
Being from Karnataka, I feel political conditions in the North are horrifying
Not really they are living peacefully with our tax, it is us who have horrifying MP's who just dont ask anything in Parliament and let everything go to bihar
Correct bro we need Dravida Nadu
Maharashtra pay highest revenue and get nothing. What a tragedy.
Even this video is not talking about this !
@@koustubhavachat Disappointing.
@@koustubhavachat no body speak bro only south north , aapn kay zak martua kai? raise our voices
I am from jharkhand and I can tell that Providing money to bihar and jharkhand is useless. There's lots and lots of corruption going on here. I don't know what the hell they are doing after taking this much amount of money from the center.
. No jobs
. No infrastructure
. No IT companies
. No proper sanitation and roads
. Even though my state has an abundant amount of natural resources Hydro power still we face around 4-5 hours of powercut every day
Youth and businessmens should get involved in politics then only states start developing.
@@Maharashtrikno fing way that’s probably the worst thing to ever happen businessmen will always look to f you over to maximise their profits they could care less about things like accountability and justice
@@MaharashtrikEducated youth ❌
Businessman ❌
Youth who cares about long term gains that would help India ✅
Advice
Don't vote BJP cuz they don't bring any development
That's why BJP never won any election in tamil Nadu
If u have a new leader there may be a chance that he may be a good guy.
Being from Telangana, we are happy to pay more tax and get less returns, but it's should be utilised for good and not for weakening our states
Wtf is tac lol
@@pedo-momo.slayer tax*
Why is everyone saying they are happy to pay more and get less??? Isn't that plain robbing?? I'm angryyy, but don't get the logic?? Shouldn't we get more money to develop our villages???
@@mdhassan8176రేయ్ hyd లేకపోతే నీ బతుకు endira...😂😂
Ts మొత్తం బెగ్గింగ్ చెయ్యాలి
@@tanskye see that's is the fall we have to take for our nation to develop togather right, but it's true that it is being misused
The fact that both north and south ignore Maharashtra meanwhile we are the highest taxpaying and highest income generating state
For North, it doesn't matter to them, all they need is money and it may be from South, Gujarat or Maharashtra. For South, it couldn't care less, they are fighting their own battle, Maharashtra should too.
I hope my fellow kannadigas recognise this and stop voting for these interests
@Pavan edits nah JDS? They only do family politics and use that money to expand business. We made them win and they did nothing good. Hence it was taken down remember
@Pavan edits prajakiya anta helodu tumba kelidini....adre adara ideologies bagge clarity sigtilla....swataha upendra avrigu adanna express madoke aagtilla..
avre astondu buddhivanatroo athawa nave daddaro annodu tilitilla....😅😅
@@Horopter true, bere yaava paksha gu vote hakidre, nam jeevna inna hopeless aaguthe
So South India is "Aatmanirbhar" and North India is enjoying perks by increasing population. Hope this new equation of equilibrium will bring good outcome for people/vote bank of our country.
They import resources from Northern states. I don't understand how they are atmanirbhar
It's due to north india that india is Food surplus country other wise what you can grow in South other than Rice and coconuts🌴😂😂
@@Sauravme If South Indians are not there then North India will become another North Korea and even now you guys are depending on South Film Industries for your entertainment too so sorry about your situation feeling so bad.
@@Sauravme wrong. Southern states grow as much crops as northern states. And historically, they've never needed to import food from northern states just to sustain themselves. North and South have different weather conditions. Based on that, the diet of a South Indian person is different than that of a north Indian person. The kinds of crops that South grows are more than enough for its people to sustain their diet. Also, Southern India also has big chunks of fertile land that are amazing for farming. You saying that South only grows rice and coconuts clearly shows that you know very little about South. Also, the food grains that are being imported are not free. They are being purchased. They create a demand for those crops in the north, which in turn pays for the livelihood of farmers in the north. They are doing us no favour by letting us import crops. The same crops could be imported at similar prices from another country by signing a proper trade agreement. Sorry to say brother, but your argument is senseless.
@@Dr.Kraig_Ren for free?
I am from maharashtra and it's feels very bad even though Maharashtra and South India are paying highest tax and getting back lesser than we deserve. It's just a ironical. And what north is getting is being used in dirty politics instead of development.
are you saying south india and maharashtra doesn't have corrupt politicians
@@kanavdawra Ofc there are corrupt politicians in South India and my Maharashtra too but comparatively way lesser than those in North!! And the thing here atleast in my Maharashtra is majority of the corrupt leaders are from BJP and there were many corrput leaders in the opposition parties too on whom the BJP was accusing of doings crores of rupees scam but now the same leaders joined the BJP and have became fully clean out of those scams💀💀
If they can't pay the tax they should not collect the tax simple as that..and giving tax to those states which are not even paying anything is hopelesness..
@@kanavdawrawe have them but less on number compared to north
@@Loco_cat_ when was the last time you heard a corruption case
We pay more, we are being forced to learn Hindi. How long will this continue?
who is forcing you 💀
@@jaykoey3683so you don't know anything about hindi imposing?
@@thamizhselvanjayaraman1875 please enlighten us we're really unaware
If your mother father want you to learn your regional language, will you say that they are imposing the regional language on you 😂
No na, so 😂
Such a faltu and weak logic 🤣
@@thamizhselvanjayaraman1875 Hindi imposition 🤣, on you 🤣🤣🤣
Main problem- *Unwillingness* of the leadership in the underdeveloped states to develop their states, resulting in _corruption_ . Kudos to the states which have more or less achieved the development goals in their state. Keep up the good work. 👍
don't forget religion fights
@@monke3043true
It has nothing to do with politics it's their population..
Imagine what the south could achieve if this resource could be deployed for further development
Bro Don't you realise one of the main reasons for souths development is the underdevelopment for North the raw materials and workers funded your growth while because of having access to trade roots and tax benefits companies and industries were established there ...and then you say that we are stopping you guys
nothing imagine if north doesnt allow them to export thier product and services to northern centers what if north said we produce majority of cash crops so you have to literally buy them from us or north said produce your own coal in your factory or hey what about your own electricity look i dont wanna create any divide we are one we help each other thats how as a whole we grow dont take any offence i actually love every part of this country equally many southern ,might think we dont want their representation in lok shabha we would love to make and vote for any person who think about our country as a whole lets a guy from TN who is good administrator we would have no hasitation to vote him in power i dont think yogi or nitish can do same in south.
Imagine what will happen to Maharashtra n! 😂 ! We even get ultra less money 😅
But we don't cry like u guys does
@@krishnadwivedi3880that's what I also think !
@@Sunshine-jk9xd you have also said . Read all news properly. Maharashtra also asking why this inequality in financial distribution until bjp came to power in there.
I do get your point of video as North vs South, but why didn't you mention Maharashtra. Maharashtra gets the lowest (7 rupees) out of all. Even being the 2nd most populated state and a developed also WHY ?
At least a mention would have been fine... Man I'm disappointed
They mostly focused on only South Indian states.
Suppose I had 2 children of mine and let's call them B and M. Now I only had enough money to send just one of them to school so I made a decision/policy that benefits M and sent to school. Since B didn't went to school he had to work at home and provide food/resources which were utilised by all 3 of us.
Fast forward 20 years, now M has graduated and is earning good amount of salary, while B can't even find a job. Since I'm too old so I'm thinking of writing my will and I divide my will 70:B and 30:M which upsets M as he's more successful in life and has worked very hard. He tells me look at my salary and how hard I've worked to reach here while B just stayed at home and cooked food and washed dishes, which even a housewife could do. How can you give a housewife more share than me who earns 1000 times the amount a housewife can earn.
Maharashtra should decide if it wants to pretend to be north or join south and fight
@@dv9239 we are not at all north bhartiya. We are culturally and geographically integral part of south Bharat.
@@Maharashtrik this is not a fight between North and South but Maharashtra does not even gets a mention and we are in the West.
Logically speaking South India does not require the Northern part, what's the point in having a liability when we can survive on our own
go ahead defend your borders with less population, fight with china. As far as economy is concernd, their won't be any smart people coming to south to drive the economy, you have to import food from north like wheat and lentils, you have to create your own national policy indipendent of India. Its pathetic when people say they want to divide India.
Not a good thought!! There is better way to deal with this problem
😂 what about natural resources? Raw material come from north statea like jharkhand bhiar and coal and steel so on mind it bro
@@stophatrial yes , being a Indian from the south , I say together we stand strong!! Else Kashmir files returns !!
Average South idli Anna doesn't even know about raw materials and labour 😂
Promoting brands like this can put our money at risk, the hard earned money that we earn. Being a loyal subscriber of aevy we expect that you guys come with better sponsors.
FIX BIHAR = FIX INDIA
Its can't because mindset of people.
No, no matter how many fixed you do to Bihar, UP will always undo that and drag them down to their level.
@@unboxedbaba8598 first take a step mindset will gradually change khaali pehle se sochke haath pe haath rkhke baithne se kuch nhi hoga
My ancestors are from Bihar. I've been there once and the only observation I could make was that people just don't want to work. Those who want to, are focused on getting a job. Basically chasing stability. And it's not their fault completely tho. The government's corrupt and some people still support them. I mean, people still support Lalu, like WTF IS WRONG WITH THEM?
@@dp055 didn't get your point. how will UP do so?
At the time of India's independence, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka, along with Bihar and other states, were considered to be among the relatively less developed regions in the country. However, today, these southern states and Bihar along with other northern states have emerged as the opposite ends of the spectrum in terms of economic success in India. I wonder what factors have caused the differing trajectories of these states and the so-called BIMARU states.
It's disheartening to note that some of the northern states in India are performing worse than countries in sub-Saharan Africa. This underscores the need for political leadership in these states that is committed to promote economic growth and development.
If India is to achieve its goal of becoming a middle-income country, there must be a concerted effort to address the root causes of underdevelopment in these states. Just throwing tax revenue at them and expecting miracles is not going to work unless there is systemic change in how these states and its population function. It’s crazy that the population from these states have to travel thousands of kilometres to southern states to find a simple labourer job to earn less than Rs 500 per day, just shows how bad economic and job opportunities are in their own states. I hope these states stop doing religion, food and language politics and instead start focusing on education, health and economic growth.
One word answer: Freight equalisation policy
Central government policy of Freight equalisation is the reason due to which resource rich landlocked north Indian states became poor and factories from north India move to sea facing and port containing South India states.
And that's how wealth gap got widened in last 50-60 years.
Maharashtra gets 7 rs in return for every 100 rs tax paid. We are neither considered as north or south indian state, so maybe it wasn't mentioned.
@@vedantt855 not the corruption, low education levels, Mafia and rowdy control of politics and economy and thousand a of other issues? You guys think you would have been Singapore?
Maybe it is because Bihar is a landlocked state and poor leadership in state is also one of the factor
I am from Tamilnadu, i am okay with paying Taxes even if it's too high compared to our North Indian brothers only if it benefits the progress of under developed states. But Most of the money goes to pockets of corrupted politicians. People are still getting affected. I am paying Hard earned money to the person who is spending that money lavishly instead of person who needs that money to improve their standards and their life. There's already lots of issues going between 2 sides of India including linguistic issues which needs to be resolved. But This one is much more bigger and has impact on entire country.people need to realise this and come up with resolution that doesn't affect anyone and bring it into practice as soon as possible
I am Kerala and don't have issues with this problem. But if this situation was the other way around, North Indian states would not have been so gracious. Also the problem is not that the northern states are getting more in return but how they are utilising the funds
are you saying south india doesn't have corrupt politicians
@@kanavdawra apparently there are but not as blatantly selfish
More funds will not help north
Indians to get devloped. Because money will not help illiterates.
@@mohammedsaleem-dh8eq I agree ...I am not against it...all I am saying if the situation was in reverse north India would have been totally smug about it
@@mohammedsaleem-dh8eq see you can call us names, make fun, protest, do what ever you want, but tax code is law, if you have problem send some of your incompetent politicians to center to make the government. As far as the rest of India is concerned, south is not at all patriotic, all most all freedom fighters were north indians, you guys sat on your asses while we fought for the country. If it was up to south you guys would have sold the nation in return for development. The only reason south is prospers is because center's fright subsidies.
Even an illiterate knows that there is a reason regions with coast are more prosperous because its easier trade, not because you guys did some special magic. Don't forget China is slowing down because of low birth rate, every country wants immigration because of low birth rates and what dors south has - low birth rates. I am kind of tired knowing people don't understand how taxes work, the literal definition is tax the rich for betterment of everybody else, government doesn't tax poor guy and give it to rich for its good performance, its the opposite. If you got a problem go live in mars or something because no country can accommodate you unreasonable demands. And people who are saying if the situation was flipped, so let me enlightened you north had only two states that need assistance, UP and bihar, and its not just south that gives them money rest of north also gives them money.
1:03 how lightly you said "just a bunch of kingdoms" and showed Shivaji Maharaj !!!
I instantly get fumed there 😢 when she said that
@@user-wb8ql4ky7j New generation bro.. :(
That is problem of our colonial brainwashing and study of history from a British point of view which only continued after Independence thanks to various factors. So most of our convent educated people (which includes me) have limited pride on Bhaarat and what unites us - that we are a civilisation state as opposed to a Nation state.
Bruh I felt that too, it was such a stupid statement. Marathas were already uniting whole India by fighting against mughals even before british came.
@@sailendrapamidi True
Being from Bihar, i totally agree with you. I know our politicians are totally corrupt and every educated bihari knows all these things but we are contributing in the development of India a little bit. Take the example of vedanta group, it was founded by a bihari and he had established his office in south india. Is he not providing jobs to south indians?
One of the biggest pharma companies called Aristo is also owned by a Bihari and is established in Mumbai, brilliant man! I know him personally and have the deepest respect for him. They even hold the Guinness record for something, I don't remember what exactly as I was very young when they got it. The reason these people came to Mumbai and Banglore is bcz they couldn't get skilled labour force in bihar, they didn't go there to provide jobs but become millionaires from the human resources of other states, there's nothing wrong with that but just sayin...
I am from Telangana....my manager is from Bihar.
I admire the straightforward approach and strong inner strength of Biharis in many other cases.
No bro. You Biharis are not burden for us
Love from Karnataka
Bihari should come out of caste mindset. Actually all of North India gets blamed mostly because of you guys. You people still elect Lalu.
Whether it is bihar or up or whatever... We are brothers. Dont use the word again. Nobody is a burden to others in a family.
Love from Tamilnadu....❤
I don't want india to break, but when I think of politicians and their implementation of plans, I feel that south india should become own country and then it can grow very much
Of course without North indian labour 😂
@Uncertainty Eclipses india is our country we don't need any work permits. And it's u guys who r bhagaudas who do nothing other than talking 😂. u r just another self obsessed person 😆
NO
As a South Indian, this will damage both North and South India a lot.
I will leave india If this happens by the name of god
@@uncertaintyeclipses5936don't worry if same thing continue then in not so distant future it will happen no doubt 👏
I appreciate your courage to bring controversial and debatable topics into videos to make it simple and easy to comprehend.. 👏🏼👏🏼
I hate how the thumbnail promotes the stereotype about Southern dress code.
We have many different cultures and dresses in the South too.
Alas, they refuse to learn about our culture
I thought whether I was the only one thinking about that.also the way they shown difference between educated and uneducated was unacceptable
First video in awhile where from start to end I was unaware of this problem and it's impact on people . Kudos for bringing up such an important topic!!
Amazing 😐😐😐😐😶😶😶😶
Don't forget northern part of India also sacrificed after independence in 1960s by supplying all of the raw materials on free transportation due to which at that time every industries shifted to the coastline areas like Maharashtra, gujrat and southern states so it's not good to abuse northern people's and blaming him just be unite.
that is a small issue and not our fault the thing is we are giving you guys so much money but why are you guys not developing
St0p eating my m0ney
I come from Maharashtra, a state that has the highest share in tax, but it hurts to see that states like Punjab, WB and Delhi just give out free stuff to their people and have huge debt over it and then ask money from the center which then gives money to these states that were majorly collected from states like Maharashtra, Karnataka, TN, Kerela, etc. Why? It's fine if they use our money, but at least use it for development instead of giving free stuff.
Every 100₹ u get ₹2 back 💀, thsi is India's anti nepotism model 💀, I swear if indau was separated into many diff nations it'd be way better
@@Nishant1207- then paje*t from north will come and comment saar india unity saar family saar
Delhi GDP per capita is higher than Maharastra not only that it gives 1.2 lakh crore to center and receive 340 crore and freebies are distributed from state money which is miniscule and Marathi people don't pay tax because most of businesses in Maharastra is done by marwari and Gujarati and also southern people u don't have caliber to run business
@@AnitaAgrawal-rz3zfsapno me jina band karo kabhi aye bhi ho Maharashtra me mai bhi Marathi hu hamara petrol pump hai wine shop hai aur apne Gujarati marwadi logo se puchoo ki apna state chodd ke Maharashtra q ate hai q ki unhe bhi pata hai kii unke log capable nahi haii jo unhe devlopment dee sake aur aisi baat haii to aaj tak gujrat aur Rajasthan America ban jata without Marathi politician koii ek dukan bhi nahi bana sakta hawai bate karna band kardo bhaii aur kaam karoo😂
@@morishg2347 sorry if my comment hurted Ur feelings my intention was not to hurt any people I just got angry because of above comment that tax of Maharastra is taken by other states and I personally don't like centre giving too much money to bihar amd and UP but u can't deny marwari and Gujarati has tremendous role in india development marwari hardly contain 1% of India population and gujrati also hardly 2_3% the person who live in rajasthan are not marwari its baniya caste like Agrawal,maheshwari,jain who live all over India so marwari cant develop rajasthan because they have very mindful population
Stocks are pretty unstable at the moment, but if you do the right math, you should be just fine. Bloomberg and other finance media have been recording cases of folks gaining over 250k just in a matter of weeks/couple months, so I think there are alot of wealth transfer in this downtime if you know where to look.
yes, transportation, e-commerce among other sectors are expected to experience growth, but who knows, the market has been a basket of surprises.
Such market uncertainties are the reason I don’t base my market judgements and decisions on rumours and here-says, got the best of me 2020 and had me holding worthless position in the market, I had to revamp my entire portfolio through the aid of an advisor, before I started seeing any significant results happens in my portfolio, been using the same advisor and I’ve scaled up 750k within 2 years, whether a bullish or down market, both makes for good profit, it all depends on where you’re looking.
@@adenmall7596 True, we’re only just an information away from amassing wealth, I know a lot of folks that made fortunes from the Dotcom crash as well as the 08’ crash and I’ve been looking into similar opportunities in this present market, could this coach that guides yo help?
@@cloudyblaze7916 Having a counselor is essential for portfolio diversification. My advisor is Eleanor Annette Eckhaus who is easily searchable and has extensive knowledge of the financial markets.
Found her, I wrote her an email and scheduled a call, hopefully she responds, I plan to start 2023 on a woodnote financially.
I'm from Bihar,but one huge problem here is the caste.Literacy rate is also a big problem.Most of the educated people move out of Bihar for work.
No one gonna listen this reasons even after 75 years you guys getting more than what you deserve. Bhava, Kindly develop your states instead of migrating to every state, it's a high time.
I'm still staying in my state,and give employment to 100 other people.I can't really help if the government can't do anything and people don't want to help themselves really.
@@Maharashtrik are you going to say same line to those people who leave south and go out of country for better life? Brother, you are not one who made south developed, you are just privileged kid who just got birth in south part. Everyone in this world wants to live better life as based on the opportunities, someone moves to other state, and someone moves to other country. But fortunately, there are some people who do really hard work to improve other's life and we call them heroes.
@@uncertaintyeclipses5936 bro, you need to pay attention on other thought to understand. I don't know what bullshit you just typed and how're you connecting it to mine comment?
@@Maharashtrik bhava hate kahe karat ahe tumhi sagdana
I'm from Tamil Nadu, but we souths always find a way to rise even when the central gov is being an A hole to us
As a North Indian Delhiite, a very important but hard step to ensure North India's growth and ease its burdens on Delhi and South India is to bifurcate or even trifurcate large underperforming states like UP and Bihar, forming separate administration units and planning new large smart city in each of them.
These states are way too large for a state government to administer, let alone develop.
If the US, with 300M population can have 50 states, why do we, with 1.4B not have more?
UP being bigger than Pakistan in population and being run by a CM makes absolutely no sense!
IDIOT ; VISIT UP AGAIN and UP is 4TH in GST contribution
Do you know how fast UP is growing? I mean just compare it with 5 years earlier and what about about diaspora who goes in other states contributing to their economies measures you used are good but doesn't application on many stated like assam due to tough geography, bihar due to politics, odisha due to natural clamity and so many
Stupid did you check the size of US or just go look in map how big it is
Up and delhi is ok when compared to bihar bihar is underdeveloped
UP has hope. Casteism and caste politics will keep f*cking Bihar forever. It's becoming a burden. But Biharis will never vote for BJP so there u go.
I find these types of videos creating a divide between our brothers from South India and us of North India. 😑😑😑🤐🤐
This is actually the truth and truth should be shown to the public and problems should be solved rather than hiding it think like a civilised man here pal
Once it's divided and Hate destroy the unity.
It will be easier to govern colonies.
Some region will go to Vatican Some to Arab and Ummah Some will go to Chinese communists.
2024 is coming
Divide and Hate is needed more at this moment. Parties in South are Afraid of loosing their Political Power and hence the desire to create a wedge.
We aren't meant to be united. Islamic Arabs and British Chrustians have invaded us. They capture the whole region of Bhafat using the divide and Hate against other Kingdoms.
China America Vatican Arab Ummah is using the same formula again.
Their loyal coolies are using same tactics and one things is for sure. We learned nothing from last two invasions.
Hate more Divide more.
Meanwhile west india especially Maharashtra getting almost nothing. And current Govn is puppet of gujrat. Maharashtra gdp decreased First time since Maharshtra created (excluding covid years)
Yes
Time to reelect our local parties which prefers Marathi first
@@Maharashtrik no use. Bjp will buy all MLA and MPs🤣🤣
@@Dattebayo3089 sad but tru 😂🤣 n that horse trading will be done by our tax money😂🤣
UP wants to become No 1 state and replace MAHARASTRA by using the money they get from MAHARASHTRA. hippocracy 😅😅😅😅😅
Prime minister comes to Karnataka only during elections 😭
Iam from karnataka.. but iam indian i don't care people talk north south..
Really wise of you to say that.
However Karnataka does deserve a bigger share in taxes.
As a citizen of Madhya Pradesh as always nobody cares about us we're so ignored on internet 😢
istg we are neither too poor nor too rich, humesha ignore hot rehte hain
@@lakshyajain8240 bruhh we born mid in everything we're mid
@Jhenkar R you have any knowledge about us
for you every state not from south is UP
i meant come on man y r dum fk or what
here we have low crime rate ,low fertility rate, normal literacy rate, and above all we are the cleanest state in india understood (google it)
we here had holkar empire that ruled whole india
we have great forts nd culture
@@oknopepali6121 WhatsApp University 💀
Mp, Maharashtra, chhatisgarh, odisha are like middle child everyone ignores these states
I’m still surprised how south India is not asking for independence despite hindi imposition and even the unfair tax policies by the north.
Declaring every state as its own nation (or at least ones with a distinct cultural identity, Hindi-speaking states should probably be one country) and then adopting something like the European Union where the countries are "sovereign nations" yet they come under the union which has common laws and other things like currency and also allowing travel without visa anywhere inside Europe.
Please protest, demand for separate country. All time insult is not good
Easier said than done.
@@VishalSingh-gh7qz would you think south india(maybe include the west india too) can progress independently detached from north india?im from south and i support it but i would like to know about its various consequeces too?
Tbh as a Tamil that would be disastereous, we don't have our own army and probably will be more oppressed than ever.
It's a shame for us that we are not able to utilise the money we got from the South.....here in states like UP Bihar politics and politicians, government officials are so corrupt..... I genuinely support the concerns of Southern states.....
This is so wrong on so many levels. Terming only two states UP and Bihar (East) as North is misleading. Haryana, Delhi , Punjab and Himachal are also part of North India and gets lesser returns.
Even Gujrat and Maharashtra gets lesser returns and it is just not southern states.
You people are lying on face and it is so puzzling to think why ?. Is it because north vs south pilitics benefits state elections in southern states ?.
Learn current affairs
@@anands1021 You learn current affairs from genuine govt reports not from some state govt newspapers. 😑
@@abhishektanwar8576 Give few genuine govt reports you've read. One will be fine.
@@abhishektanwar8576 besides i only said learn current affairs because your questions seem to point out your missing a lot of context. I don't give a damn about where the source of your your news is as long it is from more than one source so you can fact check the basics at least.
As a South Indian, I feel remorse and anger when ever I see this,
1. I and many of my friends who are from south pay a lot of money as tax in return we get nothing back
2. All that fund collected goes to centre then to some other state, where that fund is lost in some politician pocket
3. Very little money is returned to us, as a result more debt is taken from banks to cover our development
4. North Indians are invading south and taking jobs away from us, mainly blue collar jobs like factory, restaurants, house maintenance and so on as North Indian work for very less money
5. Because of the point 4 now a days many South Indian (who couldn't) get educated are finding harder to get a job and lead a decent life
6. SOUTH INDIA had an extreme good culture which is getting destroyed by the north Indians. (not a big issue)
the thing that hurts me the most is that NORTH INDIANS LIVE ON THE SCRAPS AND DONATIONS WE SOUTH INDIANS GIVE AND THEY LOOK DOWN ON US
Point 6 is the BIGGEST issue...Our language is getting destroyed
Just a corrrection it's not the North indians it's catholic and muslim of our state that are destroying our culture
Keep crying
You're 100% right but you'll be termed "anti-national" for not remaining silent to facilitate *Hindian colonialism*
@@vishalsinghbaghel keep begging
The most painfull thing is if delimitation happen on population basis, kerela for its family planning will get 0 extra seats whereas as up will get 60+ more seats
Logic given by South Indian states is ridiculous ! It is like a taxpayer asking governement for more subsidies than poor people in exchange of tax he pays. Entire ecosystem of government is designed to take money from the rich and redistribute it among the poor.
Will these south indian states apply same logic in their schemes to by cutting expenditure on their freebies and revadis.
Also, a point to be noted is that South India is developed not only because of labor from the north but also at the expense of north indian states. Please read about freight equalization policy introduced by central government which led to economic fall of north and rise of south.
I love watching your videos.
Love the case studies, interesting skits as well as unique topics
While Maharashtra and gujju....chillin🙃
Ever heard of Maharashtra? Felt cheated 😢
One must share this video in good groups
We need to kick out this migrants from our Maharashtra, otherwise it will be big setback for us.
Jay Maharashtra 🚩🚩🚩
@@Harshit09877 they did business here in mh because they got security n safety, buying capacity was good, political envir. was good n supporting for ex. foxconn ceo who hails from bihar would have invested in bihar rather than in guj. unko fayde se matlab hai ar kisse se nhi...
businessman apni dukan danda wohi kholte hai jaha buying capacity acchi ho ar stability safety ho....
dus jayengey mh se 100 line laga ke khade rahengey don't worry 😂🤣
@@Harshit09877 then why can't they build their own state? If they are so much good at building things?
And we Maharashtrians toh "muft ki khaa rahe hai" right?
@@Harshit09877 Foreign investment bhi mh ki sabse jyada hai.....unko yaha laga growth toh yaha aaye....migrants ne apna business dekha safety dekhi toh yaha aaye dor ex : marwari log rajasthan ko he develop kar lete khud ke state ko par nhi hua na🤣😂....even sindhi community yaha partion ke waqt aaye ar mh ne unhe safely rakha settlements di....kashmiri pandits ko 5% reservation diya now they are contributing in mh eco.
bohra muslims (gujrathi) unko kabhi kisse ne pareshan nhi kiya ya unke masjid ke samne hungama kiya...they feel safe here
"yeh logo ne mh chor diya toh nhi tik paayega" bro even nagpur has more per capita gdp than patna n lucknow🤣😂
Most of North Indians live in south india, and do job and pay rent and pay taxes , so the tax is paid both by Natives living from different parts of country ,and so the tax collection goes up , higher than North Indians
"Most North Indians live in South India"
No they don't. Most North Indians live in North India and very few North Indians live in South.
You'd love to think all Indians are same and all are equally productive and contributing same to the country but we aren't the same. Average Bihari is not same as average Karnataka resident. One gives away almost 90% of tax money to the country and another takes 9 times more money from center than they contribute. Which one is which, you take a guess.
Migrant workers coming from other states drive wages down and increase cost of living in the states that are very disciplined with their management. Those states don't need that labour because it's not really high skilled non-replacable labour. States can't legally stop this migrants. So they can take advantage of other states while ruining their own state and making whole country miserable. It's a fuked up situation for good performing states. In our system corrupt and mismanaged states get rewarded while better performing states get punished.
Are you living on Mars???????
@@jeanpierre-st7rl i m also from North India ,we are paying taxes to karnataka, in most of scenarios Officers take up the 2-3 times bribe from us ,just bcoz of being a North Indian
@@sanket.solanke but if North Indian didn't migrate to south ,then the Economy of south would not have developed soo much, instead North India would have flourished
@@seemapurbiya128 why are you lying? Have you ever been to south India? Very few north Indian workers migrate to south India. Are you trying to suggest low skilled north Indian labour which makes fraction of workforce in south is responsible for all the development in south? High skilled migrants don't move to South India except for few places like Bengaluru and Chennai.
If the South Indian states are more developed than the northern states even while receiving so less money in return, there must be something about the leadership.
I am from South India, I have no problems of our money being sent to other states, because I dont states like Bihar to become like Somalia without or tax money.😂 Afterall, we are all Indians, BUT I HAVE A PROBLEM WITH THE DEVELOPMENT PROGRESS in these states. Even UP is slowly becoming better how West Bengal, Bihar, Rajasthan are all dead
LoL..UP 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Bihar is dead case their people don't vote for good government. Central Govt is wasting money on them.
LoL what??🤣😂 Bengalis are only 90 in return if we get 950 or 350 like Bihar and up, we will surely become a developed State+ illigal immigrants from Bangladesh are coming+ bimarus are also coming here to work. Fertility rate of Bengal is just 1.6 which is closed to a developed nation
And for your kind information, during the British era, the Bengal presidency has paid higher taxes to develop the Madras presidency 🤣😂
How about not having the “holier than thou” mentality and understanding equity. For the same ₹100 theory NE gets 1500-4000 (far more than Bihar) are they turning into somalia? (meanwhile they have far better literacy rates)
The Bengal you mentioned gets just ₹90 of the ₹100 ..so explain “dead”. Why because they work as labour in south (meanwhile the same south is serving as foreign labourers in Gulf)?
(I have lived a decade in Kerala and have personally faced racism in the name of northie, Hindi, and Bengali labourer so I know)
@@chimpuJain yeah i confused Jharkhand's 300 with West bengal sorry. but anyway your government is doing nothing to develop west bengal, hope you get a better CM🤣
Informative video... Still comic bits in the middle can be portrayed differently without demeaning fellow states ( Reddy using calculator for 5-5 calculation)..
Let me tell you guys a fact the states from western part of India(MH and GJ) pays more taxes than all five states from southern part of India combined.
And Gujarat is getting every project handed to them
Not the case in south
@@dv9239 That is debatable, but was this the case for all 75 years after independence? Check out the revenue share of guj and maha even before 2014 you'll find the same pattern.
@@Sumit-rp5mx north is bad people generally is reason. They got kashmir delhi huge supplies jobs and central govt jobs
@@Vijaymallya-cb2qz maharashtra is peninsular india below vindyas ranges
@@keralanaturelover196 how does that mattter?
Politicians in North India doing nothing and getting Fortuner with VIP number plates be like :- 🤤🤤.
Where politicians themselves are gundas like atik ahmed what can we expect from North.
amazing content! love the neutal outlook of the video, Keep up the Great Work!
A separate country for the south!💪
Chl😂
Jay Bharat 😎
Bharat always first ❤
@@vinaymann838u say that because north india wants south india but not vice versa. We are better off without north . But u will suffer without south 😂😂😂
India is a Youthful Country and it's the best time to leverage it!
As Ashneer Grover says, Youth must get into Politics. That is when Good Educated Leaders can keep up with the Technological, Educational, and Financial Reforms of our Country with the rest of the world.
This plainly and simply boils my blood. We south Indians are ignored in every way, from language to money 💔
Atleast Indian politicians are starting to talk about things that really matters, not just stupid religious politics.
Quite insightful thankyou!
Hey you guys are doing commendable jobs. Would love to work with you guys someday. God bless you guys. Grow as fast as possible ❤️.
Please make videos in vernacular languages because if you want maximum reach you have to publish same content in atleast 7-8 major languages.
Im from Maharashtra and its very frustrating to see northern leader giving out freebies to get votes
Taking a moment to Appreciate how neutrally Aevy TV has put forth this issue!
Beautiful visualizations of concepts/facts + Comedy + Good Oration 👉Aevy TV is an Emotion 💖
As a Western Indian/m.h citizen I think North Indian states don't make efforts because even North East Indian states are more literate and developing just like west n south but north Indians wants to play giga Chad role it's not finger pointing but they are facts '' problem toh hei sabke sath bus najariyeki hei baat ''
It's time to kick out northy's from Maharashtra, else they will not gonna bother to develop there states ever
North India is more developed. & listen bengali- up/ Bihar are not in North ok
@@AdiHaiKya what up is in north.
@@AllInOne-bv1ti uk Jammu punjab uttrakhand haryana
How about using southern/northern states instead of south/north India. These terms are thrown around so frequently that it starts to feel that we do actually have 2 countries. Just saying.
That's the plan aint it. Couldn't keep us under their rule. So they divide us based on region and language.
Top North Goes to Muslims.
North East Goes to Christians.
Lower Kerala and Tamil Nadu Goes to Communists.
Jarkhand Chattisgar Goes to British and American missionaries.
HALF Kerala Hyderabad and some Parts of Andhra and Tamil Nadu will be under Ummah Sulatanate.
Same for some parts of Bihar and UP.
The Cow Belt corridor
Karnatak Orissa Some areas of Tamil Nadu. Assam. haryana Gujrata and some areas of Uttarkhand and UP will be only
Dharmic Sanatani Hindu Regions.
This will happen because we hate each other based on Skin color Language and region.
A christian from Nagaland will call Christian from Kerala. Brother
Mulla from Tamil Nadu will call mulla of Kashmir Bhai Jaan.
A communist of DMK will support Communist of kerala and chattisghar.
But Hindu of Tamil Nadu will hate Hindu of UP Uttarakhand Gujrata. And Hindu of UP Uttarakhand will think he is better than Hindu of Karnatak.
At the end of the Day.
We aren't meant to be together.
No Bharat no India will exist.
Only Colonies of foreign powers Like Arab Ummah China Vatican American will exists that will serve the Politicians who will obey their non Indian Overlords.
Devatas Dharma Desh
Couldn't unite us because Language Politics and Region matter to us more.
Fk this Nation and fk everyone
We are stupid race of people. Having been invaded by Muslim Arabs British Christians Italian Christians and Chinese Communist. We don't learn our lesson.
Usse racist comments padha hu mai. South walo ko lag rha jaise pura Desh yehi chala rhe. Jyada hi superiority complex hai inko. Har jagah racist comments kar rhe bimaru bolke. Ek no ke racist hai
@@krishna-de2jb yes bhikari bimari stop begging for funds from south
Being a Marathi Manus this hurts us as well, but for how long this fragmentation will continue??
The same things said about North and South of India, can be said about North and South of Karnataka as well.
I am from Tamil Nadu .. We feel looted😢😢
Atleast check before commenting, just search in Google - Highest paying tax state. Improve your Critical thinking.
The sad part is after all of these stealing still they don't have enough toilets 😔 which is making me feel sad 😭😭😭
Indian division of taxation among states is the same as our Reservation policy
The underprivileged gets more while the So called privileged has to sacrifice
The hatred for the north will someday cost south dearly. Their horse isn't as high as they think. Someday when UP and Bihar capitalise on their massive population and become more developed than the South, this very system will feel good to them because then they'll be receiving more money.
So you mean you'll remain underprivileged for your whole life?
You have to realise that the main reason southern states were able to develop so swiftly is because of the ports and opportunities to trade because of which companies open there assembling units there while all the raw materials are extracted from bihar and up and the work force is also the migrants from there so basically one of the biggest reason for souths development is the underdevelopment of Bihar and up ..the political and economical system favoured this and after all that we Bihari's are being blamed for being poor what kind of logic is that!!!
@@Xinnie_The_Flu we have been waiting for that to happen since 50 years 😂😂😂😂
We don't mind paying taxes and can acknowledge our privilege. What's annoying is when North Indians don't respect our differences and impose Hindi on us
It's a worrying issue , it's good to help other states but when its became one sided it's not right . I from West Bengal and our states leaders are day by day exposing as cheater and they corrupting the state...... There's many things to say , but we should more aware by our ownself and thanks to you guys , for making such videos with thus simple way it's very engaging and intresting 💓
Demographic performance should be considered as the main factor while distributing the amount. Then only the politicians as well as people of states like UP & Bihar will try to grow.
Bjp Will always focus on one religion and one state (Gujarat) and always focus on one language (Hindi).they are not developing our South States please wake my South Employees
You South Indians after being developed also are so greedy
😂😂
Ya true bro they create more population without littracy only for vote bank andd they teach them how to handle weapones rather than pen and paper
South people don't support bjp then how they can do development?
@@kailuuusouth was developed on its own till now. we don't need bjpee
I m from Karnataka..and we should understand that north indian labourers also have hand in Karnataka's developement..
Yes saar 👧🏿🧕🏾🤲🏿👧🏿👦🏿🙏🏿👩🏿🦳👳🏿♀️
And you must understand that north indian states Development is done by kannadigas tax money
Such foolish comment
@@laxmidevi9514 go and see how tax is distributed among states
ua-cam.com/users/shortsQiLYBlSS_6I?feature=share
I'm from Maharashtra i also feel robbed.
Maharashtra is getting 7₹ back when we put 100₹ as tax revenue
तेच तर, एकतर या उत्तरेच्या राज्यांना जगवा अन् यांचे घाणेरड्या लोकांनाही जगवा. आपल्याला आपला आवाज उठवला तरच काही राहील, अथवा इथे हिंदी तर आलीय उरलेला विकासही जाईल.
one of the major factor is sea port which reduce transportation of raw material to northern part and then finished back to seaports, which company avoids hence major industries are close to sea ports. dedicated frieght corridor will reduce it. hencenorthern parts may see surge in industries in future.
starting I thought this channel is left but after watching lot of videos i can say this channel is best to learn the truth and increase our knowledge.
your videos are very usefull in order to understand the issues.
Great Video.
Just a correction
We will get new tax sharing formula only by 2026 and not by 2023
Will be announced this year, will be implemented in 2026
Just to clarify the chronology
2023 - Finance Commission Set up
It takes nearly 2 years to submit report
2025 - Submits report it is upto the govt to accept or not
2026-31 - recommendations are implemented.
Ah! This was the best infotainment therapy I needed during my dissertation drafting, which is based on the CFCs XIV and XV loosely. Loved every bit of the video, from the detailed research/facts/figures to the skit (will never forget the new TDS expansion 😂). Thank you, Aevy, you are a vibe! 🐒
content & specially editing did stunning..!
I am from tamilnadu and we feel robbed, our state would have been developed even more if the tax returns were fair enough
Atleast check before commenting, just search in Google - Highest paying tax state. Improve your Critical thinking.
Don't you guys think that India being the fastest growing economy is being overhyped 6% growth for 3.5 trillion vs 5% growth for china at 16 trillion or 1% growth for USA at 25 trillion we really are underperforming as Indians and our government just can stop praising themselves all the time and what do you think should be done regarding data skewing that happens affecting decision investments and policies ??
Aevy is a vibe ❤❤❤❤ and Achina's hairstyle is like friends 2.0 with Indian twist
Pls do not give your concocted knowledge on economics
@@pikachue602 he isn't wrong tho
Lol. Businessman growing. Not indians 😂😂. Businesses not sharing their profits with employees. Remember whenever middle class leaves india. He becomes rich in other countries 😂😂
*AMBANI invests 1cr in business & month later gets 1.10cr..a good profit % right?
*RAJU invests 10k in business & month later gets 30k
NOW you tell me who's doing more profitable business ..? 🙄 bruhhh
@@Dattebayo3089 waah! literally what a wonderful assessment , I'm amazed to witness such brilliance in yet cmmnt sec
being a North Indian from uttar pradesh i have seen corruption and the drainage of money and tax cheating.
Really it hurts a lot when we see cheaters with all the luxuries at the cost of hard workers. But at the same time govt is trying really hard to manage but the real loophole is in tier2 and teir 3 cities.these are real big problems and causes of money wastage
So don't waste our tax money, if you can't develop your states even after 75 years
Uneducated gandu. Uttar Pradesh does not come in the North
@@Maharashtrik we are your Aryan masters you Dasyu baboons should be thankful to upper caste Aryans
@@Maharashtrik mein thodi le rhi hoon
@@bhoomivarshney1369 तुझे राज्य तर घेत आहेत ना. अन् तोच पैसा तुझ्यावर वापरला जातोय गेली ७५ वर्षे.
A small Correction.. IGST is charged on inter state transactions and not on intra state 2.38
How many huge cities are there in North like Banglore, Chennai, Hyderabad, Kochi with each having an IT hub?
Really? "India, the land, was just bunch of kingdoms fighting amongst themselves"... We have always had an idea of the geographical land from the himalaya to the ocean as Bharata. And the British united Indians?
India is Union of states, correct, and not a federation of states like USA. This means the country was formed first and states are just made up for easy administration.
Introduction sucks but the rest of the video is good.
Proper distribution between country is important.
It's stupid. If after years of distributing the money equally, still if the north Indian politicians were incapable of developing their states why should south Indians work hard to fuel North India? If South Indians get the money they deserve they will develop souther Indian even more. Its better that way way then by wasting the money by putting into the mouths of North Indian politicians and few powerful people from North
@@AZ-pg8vd s
Leave North India and South India
Look at NE India
They Just Getting 10% of Tax Return
Well researched video, to explain this complex issues in such a short time, but there's a mistake where u praise demographic performance indicator with 12.5% share but it's just another face for populatiin
Thanks ...its 1 of the most informative Videos Seen in Recent Times >3
In Karnataka most of the state tax collected from the IT companies, house rent, property sales. And not only the native peoples also other parts of our country people are also participating in large numbers.
So it's unfair to tell only Karnataka people money is being distributed to other states.
Proud Indian and kannadiga. 👍🙂
You're right sir, But that is because of the infra the south states have. From NH to ports, airports etc. A lot of slow consistent process. SOme north states lack basic infra like schools, that too when they have the money to build infra like schools, hospitals, electric lines, water lines, roads etc. Infrastructure is far more important to a state as it brings companies and people into the state
@@avinash1347 sir north Indian civilians must try to understand that caste, religion based votes and development doesn't work to grow states.hope in future North India will develop in state and mind too
so what... You are working because you are getting salary... You can't say we will take salary and taxes.. 😡