#QOTD *Which parts of the Attack on Titan history are right?* 😮 *Did this give you any new ideas of theories . . .* 🤔 *Show your Colossal Support by leaving a LIKE! Thanks!!!* 👍 *Subscribe! Don’t miss out on this NEW Multi AoT series!* 😄 ►► bit.ly/AnimeFansUnite *Support my Videos on Patreon!* 🙂 ►► patreon.com/Foxen
Pokemon\Yo kai watch:Who needs ageing characters when you can keep them the same age so all the little kids of the new generation can shit out their money to us cuz fuck the old fans who want characters to age with them while still having something for the little ones! Digimon: Hold my beer
phro basically like the video said, there’s 5 version of titan history and no one knows which of them is true, not until isayama reveals the whole thing. I suggest you try understanding each of the history (if you have time) one by one instead of processing all of it from one video
@@locoroco2940 well at least we know that the first version " the one we that have been told in Season one " is 100% false because humanity outside didn't perished nor the walls been built because of the titans in other words it's just a lie created by karl fritz and been protected by the following kings
"There is no such thing as truth in this world. That is our reality. Anyone can become a god or a devil. All it takes is for someone to claim that to be the truth." - Eren Kruger, chapter 88
Is that a true statement? Yeah, there's a problem here alright. There is an objective truth, to what extent Eren and his friends are able to uncover and confirm that is the question. It will probably lie in unlocking all the titan memories from the founding titan or all of them, if they are ever combined in a single person again.
@@MikeTall88 same with Doffy in one piece. In that scene, pirates and Marines are having a war. He asked if pirates are automatically the evil and Marines are the good ones. He then answered his own question saying winners can change the meaning of evil. Kids who never seen peace and kids who never seen war have different view of Justice. But at the end of the day, the winners will be the Justice. That's why up until now, I've seen government more of a big organization rather than people who'll bring Justice.
I think the whole point of the story is that all of these versions are true to some extent, and that there exists no true heros or villains. Everyone commits atrocities with reasonable justification from their perspective. We are all victims of our circumstances and upbringing. The "villains" during the current arc have just been humanized to the point where we're not supposed to want anybody to lose or die, protagonists or otherwise. That's why the story works so well as a tragedy, because in the real world, no side is just born evil.
Aphrodite Deliphine Aphrodite Deliphine Aphrodite Deliphine Yeah, European history is very interesting. One guy I like to watch is Townsends. He makes videos about 18th century living and cooking. He’s actually what got me into reading and history in general, but especially European
When you think you finally know about the history of AoT, just remember this: *There is no such thing as truth in this world. That is our reality. Anyone can become a god or a devil. All it takes is for someone to claim that to be the truth.*
He didn't reveal the story in its entirety. The real story will be revealed by Isayama in a flashback of Ymir (the progenitor of the Founding Titan). How did she get the ability itself and what how the inheritors after her could have used or misused the Titan Powers to hurt others. Ymir must have predicted this, and spend the rest of her life to find a cure, as the Owl stated "the curse of Ymir" but Fail. Marley, Eldia, The Owl, Willy the Tybur Family as some speculation of the history though they may some truth in them. Grisha's and the Owl background gave us a middle ground of what the history was. (Marley made up a story of what happened as a form of propaganda for their own evil means). Willy gives more information on the story regarding King Fritz and the Made up hero "Helios". In my opinion, The Owl, Eren kruger's info on that history make more sense. Let's wait for The author's story to move forward and we the readers will decide.
long story short: a chick named Ymir obtained and spread the titan powers among Eldians, but everyone started fighting among themselves for power, so the king of the Eldians (Fritz) decided to hide on Paradis island among walls made out of titans to end all the conflict. He brainwashed his own people into thinking they were the only humans on Earth, and threatened the other nations to never disturbe their peace or else he would release the titans, using his founding titan power. But the Marlean nation still hated them from the war and sent titans there (former humans) in order to devour their people, and this is how Attack on titan begun. Now that Eren and the gang (the Eldians) found out that all the titan attacks were caused by the Marleans, they're fighting a war, to know how it goes read the manga lol. I hope this summary was helpful
bar no, there's Eastern, southern and western allies, technically there's hundreds of thousands of empires that got dominated because of the great titan war
zeke must know the truth and kruger history backs-up so eren is ending what kruger started that’s why kruger didn’t fight for marley and the reason zeke is disappointed of the war
I feel like every virsion is true to some extent. Everyone is just telling the story in a way that makes them look like the good guys. My theory is that the real history is just a combination of all the told stories or it could just be a bunch of misleading stories leading to a complete plot twist 😂
I think the most realistic course was that the Eldians unified under Ymir and allied with other peoples to fight against the Marley Empire. After overthrowing them, life improved to a degree but then the Eldians became complacent. The 145th King decided to move the capital to Paradis Island, maybe to establish a secondary base (I don't know), when the Marleyans attacked. Having lost the homeland, the King fortified his base and basically said you win but don't try anything with us. That's the one that makes the most sense to me but I'm not the one writing the story.
I thing Willy Taybur's version is completely correct. It tottaly clears up why the King of the Walls erased the memories of his people and did nothing when the 4 warriors attacked the Island. But what has me convinced is this: The Marley version made Eldians look like devils, the Grisha version made them look like angels; Both were biased but Willy's version had none. It wasn't a bashing nor favoring Marleyans or Eldians, just a detailed explanation of what happened and how it ties in with current events regarding Eren being able to potentially trigger the Earth-Leveling attack..
The reason why the Titans didnt rumble the earth after the 4 warriors were attacked is probably because Eren is not of Royal Blood and couldnt access the memories of King Fritz Will or the power to unleash the titans on to the world. Eren didnt even know those titans who infiltrated the walls were human titan shifters before.
Seth Gonzales When the four warriors attacked, Eren didn’t have the Founding Titan. Freida Reiss possessed the Founding Titan at the time, but Eren’s dad, Grisha Yeager, ate Frieda to steal the power from the Reiss/Fritz Family. Once Grisha found Eren, Grisha took him to the forest, and injected him with titan serum. Which caused Eren to transform, he then ate his father, and inherited his fathers abilities.
All of the stories probably have aspects of them that are right. Willy is a liar though. If the king fritz was sworn to pacifism, than why did willy allow marley to send 4 warriors to retrieve the founding titan, even though at the time the founding titan was still under royal family control. Did willy know all along that grisha would be able to aquire the founding titan? Or was he scared enough by the threat of grisha that he saw no other choice?
I was wondering about this too and a lot of others on the ch99 review vid brought it up. I was assuming that he never 'allowed' or prevented it since it mentioned how the Tybur family was in a position for them to watch Marley do w/e they wanted.
My theory is that we will get a whole chapter of eren flashing back to krugers memories and we will learn about this. The owls memories definitely have some potential answers
TheGerthax I think the 4 children breaking the walls was a signal to the royal family to follow through with the plan and give up the founding Titan , but Krueger/Grisha messed up the plan by taking it
Exactly, and still, even if Willy was indifferent of Marley's military endevours up until recently, the Tybur being the ruler of Marley makes them responsible for the consequence of Marley's actions. The story just doesn't make sense at this point - Willy could be trying to mislead the world to shine the spotlight away from Marley's militaristic ambitions. This also implies that the Tybur allowed Marley to believe in a false tale, which makes them even more responsible. Also, wasn't Marley at war with a lot of nations? How is there no animosity towards Marley itself from around the world?
What Attack on Titan did brilliantly in my eyes was they made a story and they made sure they got it wrong the first time, not saying that it was a mistake on their par, they did it beautifully, making the Titans seem like a natural occurrence to plague the world And using that as the spring board to hop into all this amazing lore
I think Ymir Fritz discovered how to control inorganic substance, hence the Titans. But it had a side effect, it shortened thier lifespan significantly since it uses lifeforce as a fuel hence, the 13yrs lifespan.
Well, the shortened lifespan is because somehow Ymir was killed 13 yrs after she got her power. It didn't say how, but I'm pretty sure it wasn't like aging or a side effect. The x on her neck in the manga suggests that someone found the nape/ or beheaded her and so the others who received the titan shifters are cursed/doomed to die after 13 years.
@Big-Bonkin-Head they should be able to do it in 24-25 episodes unless they add a lot more filler (which they might) Also keep in mine they have to go by cours, so if it's not 24-26 episodes, they'd have to add 11-13 more which is less likely
That’s what war is. As a German citizen with ancestor from WW2 and from Vietnam... I experience both sides of war through my grandparents. My grandpa from father sides was a fellow soldier during WW2 and he was 16 at the time... he said that everyone was kinda just living there lives under the propaganda of Hitler that time. No ones of course thought of the dark side of it. And only with the time going on the people felt the shame and the realization of their war crime. But to me he was a nice grandpa who was also got capture in Russia. My grandfather from mother side was also in war. Vietnam war. He suffered under the Army and the post war situation was hell for my mother. Some of their neighbors suffered under agent orange generation after the war. But even after that, he won’t tell me to hate the American even if they did bad things.... I am a offspring from both the “evil and the victims” but both was just suffered under the war and I’ve learnt that war doesn’t have a “true winner”. And every good can be evil to the others.... I’m sorry my English is bad but I hope you got my point. That why I love AOT so much because it has such a depths in it.
Hi there, love your content as always ^^ !!! Can you add subtitles to this one too please ? I have some trouble since you speak a little too fast for me. Thanks for reading me if you did ;) !!!!
Here after AOT season 4 episode 1 came out. Ive forgotten about the eldian and the marleyan plot so had to watch this. Was really confused about who's the bad guy in there and i dunno am still confused lol
I like the editing , you did it sort of like how a documentary will move across pictures to make it seem more like an actual video instead of a slideshow with audio nice job
I think it's fairly obvious that Grishas version is the most likely to be false as his version has almost zero credibility. I think King Fritz pacifistic version makes the most sense considering their vast and immense power. They have always had the power to crush any nation at any time regardless of how weakened they had become from infighting. So the Eldian guilt, shame, quest for peace, and resulting isolation obviously had to be entirely voluntary. I'm fairly sure the Marleyan version may be somewhat exaggerated but has most of the base truth in it. And Tyburs story probably clears up some of that exaggeration from both Eldia and Marley BUT may still be adding some of their own Tybur flavor of exaggeration.... But for Willie Tybur to be lying really doesn't make any sense. It has to be mostly altruistic and truth because much of his explanation is damning to the Marleyan and Tybur reputation....
The reason why I love attack on Titan so much is because there are no villains or heroes since its war. It's just whose side are you on. Yes they are all criminals but they fought to survive.
I think it does not matter which one is right but I would go with willy's version minus the part with eren as the bad guy also I'm waiting to see what eren does now
She was probably a scientist biologist etc but do to the time frame at the time it was considered witch craft and so it spread rumors of her dealing with the devil etc
SPOILER . . . . . . Actually she was just a child slave of the Eldian tribe (not even an Eldian herself) who accidentally discovered some sort of organism that she merged with, turning into a titan. After working for the Eldian king and defeating the Marleyans with her titan power, she was basically raped as a "reward". (Yes, the king actually called this a "reward".) She birthed three children, but died sacrificing herself for the king after an attack. Her three children then were forced to literally eat her corpse, so that they may inherit the power of the titans. She basically lived her entire life as a slave to the Eldian king.
Besides speaking about Attack on Titan, that probably happened in real life during the "Mediaeval" period when we were burning so called "Witches" and such.
Reminds me of OUR world history... the holocaust and now the ethnic cleansing of the rohingya people... wouldn’t be surprised if it turns out that titans did exist
@@KusKus1042 stfu ... you said "marleyians" ? ahahah really ? that has nothing to do with our world or the fucking jews or the fucking nazi ... wake up . Even isayama said that !
Christopher Holloman Yeah... I figured he was protecting the real shifter by letting everyone assume it was him but it was SOOO lame it turned out to be his damn sister who then got her ass handed to her by Eren....
Jaysann22 it kinda makes sense, the Warhammer Titan isn’t in use so she wasn’t as well practiced as the other Titan shifters. And the whole sister reveal is the same as the Eldian reveal that the Reiss family had the founding Titans not the fritz
Takagi-san Jozu yes, I’m assuming you didn’t or else you would’ve known that they split within the walls with the Reiss having the real power and the Fritz being puppet politicians
@@ineedmoresleep3728 Hahahaahah, Sorry for being late for the show but The fritz are not "Puppet Politicians", They are also the reiss, Historia reiss is a fritz, Frieda and rod reiss are a fritz. Karl fritz changed the bloodline name from Fritz to reiss, Just try to edit your thing or else people will get confused alr? Just try re-reading or re-watch the anime again.
I don't think we've heard the true story yet, and I'm positive we won't know what really happened until Eren tells us since he holds the founding titan. One thing I am sure of though, is that this anime is going to turn into an allegory for WW2, with the Eldians representing the Jews and the Marley's representing the Nazis. Maybe the Tybur family is the US or the Soviets. The latter makes sense if the Tybur family has Eldian lineage, but this might all be a lie too. Going back to the actual anime, I think it's a lie that only Eldians are able to turn into titans, and in reality, every human has that ability. I'm sure fooling the entire world into thinking only those with Eldian blood can turn into titans works as propaganda for the Marleys against the Eldians, and also for the Tybur family to make themselves seem more important than they really are.
Foxen Anime Yeah, I wouldn't be surprised if the direction he took with the anime changed after a few recent events. He changed the idea he had for an ending to the series because of how much fans loved the characters, so I would definitely understand Isayama doing the same with the state of the world.
@@kasvinimuniandy4178 I don't think any Marley person would gain from letting the world know they are a titan, and I also doubt any Marlian would want to become a titan in the first place, considering the history they've suffered-at least allegedly.
Paradise Island is also linked to Atlantis. Consisting of 3 rings and the existence of titans. Oh and its not about Germany or the Jews. Its linked to how the Western empires have a same way of influencing our worlds history and how we see people from outside 'our walls' as threats that look like titans but in all reality are the same people as we are.
Damn. This is a lot to take in. If I were to speculate as to which story is true, I'd be wrong. It's best to wait for the manga to tell us what's genuine.
Quite a lot of theories about the true history of The Great Titan War, slightly confusing, but thankfully your video cleared it up for me, haha. (Also almost at chapter 100, we're getting much closer to the end).
I don't know the history but this is what future I want. Collect all the Titans powers on paradise Island and die. This might change all Titans back into humans. And noone gonna be able to turn back into Titan. Titan power should be gone for good.
i feel like the true story was probably the eldian version by that i mean the ymir fritz teaming with a creature type thingy (idk what it is tbh but) and so she used her titan power to help the world. something he didnt cover was the curse of ymir or how the powers were passed down and also how eren got the powers of the founding titan . first ill say what the curse of ymir was the curse of ymir is a curse that makes u die after the age of 13 because ymir died at the age of 13 yrs old. this brings us to how ymir died and how the powers were passed down i dont really know how ymir died but the powers were passed down by ymirs daughter (maria rose and sina) which are also the names of the walls remember that it might be important but ymirs daughter need to be important if the walls are named after them they litteraly could've named the walls wall1 2 and 3.but anyways we are getting off topic.ymir daughters ate ymirs body to gain her powers and they kept doing that they kept eating and gaining eating and gaining. this comes to where we learn how eren got the powers of the founding titan. basically erens dad ate the founding titan and gain the powers. but then if u remmeber the flashbacks eren had his dad gave him spinal fluid with the spinal fluid eren turned into a mini titan and ate his father. thats all please like this comment i worked hard :)
I like your videos you gained i new sub. I think every version of the story has truth in it... also what are your though about helos? Do you think he is an ackerman? Or made up
welcome! 😄 Before the info came up about Helos being makeup, alot people thought he was an Ackerman & I think that idea seemed interesting. Now it seems that perhaps he may have existed but really wasn't this almighty titan slayer that he was made up to be, but he could still have been an Ackerman 🤔
So the Eldians abused the power over threw Marley and ran out of people to kill so they killed each other. The Marlians took advantage and reversed the rolls and turned the Eldians into titans to kill the Eldians. Correct me if I'm wrong
But apparently people like gabi or falcon are eldians “good eldians” So if I’ve missed something or only eldian become titan shifter or literally anyone can
I wonder if Ymir (from the Survey Corps) knew the old/ancient language. Remember how surprised Reiner was that she knew what what the old can they found in Utgard (?) castle?
Still a bit confused as I've only seen the anime up to a portion of season 2...so the mindless pure titans are basically banished Eldians, kin of the very people inside the walls who's recent ancestors had their memories erased by the 145th king so they don't know any better...and this would explain why the wall priests keep their mouths shut because they're in on this knowledge. I'd say this puts a combination of Morely and Tyber histories as the MOST true. It would also explain why the eight Morely-controlled Titans only sporadically attack the walls years apart. They're apprehensive and testing to see if the King's threat of unleashing the wall Titans is a genuine one. Interesting stuff. The anime version so far to me, is not unlike the movie Akira - it's engaging and fascinating, but unless you read the Manga, you miss out on much of the reasons why unfolding developments happen. One question though, is the current King, who has power of the founding titan even aware there's espionage occurring within the very ranks that protect the walls of his kingdom?
I like the idea that it is a future setting, Ymir was some kind of bio-engineer creating the solar powered titans as some kind of exosuit construction gear, and everything went to hell after. At this point everything has fallen to a neomysticism.
Lol, this information was already out on 2017.. I'm literally just watching final season and was confused by the politics but now I understand it all. Understanding the story just watching the anime is confusing
I'm still convinced that the Marleyans are the villains. After all, if they hadn't filled Paradis Island with Pure Titans and sent Reiner, Bertholt, Annie, Zeke, Marcel, and Piek in the first place, Eren wouldn't even have a vendetta and they're still trying to plunder Paradis for it's resources, only now they're tricking the other nations into giving them support.
@@simbasorariku3Marleyans want revenge for what the eldians did to them for 2000 years. Why is everyone forgetting the crimes of eldia before all of this?
Thank you so much for this video. Very well explained. I was hooked to this titan stories. I hope that Isayama will write a prequel story about the Great Titan War after Attack on Titan.
This is becoming too confusing for my brain to handle..... at first it was AAA TITAN RUNNNN and now its THERE IS A WHOLE ANOTHER FANCY LOOKING CIVILIZATION WITH EPIC TANKS AND GUNS WITH CARS AND MORE TITANS.....
Exactly like, Subjects oF YMir, and punishing people by turning them into a titan, and idk if that's still going on, the punishments or they just retarted titan shifters
#QOTD *Which parts of the Attack on Titan history are right?* 😮
*Did this give you any new ideas of theories . . .* 🤔
*Show your Colossal Support by leaving a LIKE! Thanks!!!* 👍
*Subscribe! Don’t miss out on this NEW Multi AoT series!* 😄
►► bit.ly/AnimeFansUnite
*Support my Videos on Patreon!* 🙂
►► patreon.com/Foxen
Foxen Anime still think that Eren Kruger's version is the truest
Sry can u make an ep about Marco s death and how it he died plz there r only Manga if u did a ep like always u do
If u do u can get many views becuz u r explaining it but others don't so plz I beg u
Pokemon\Yo kai watch:Who needs ageing characters when you can keep them the same age so all the little kids of the new generation can shit out their money to us cuz fuck the old fans who want characters to age with them while still having something for the little ones! Digimon: Hold my beer
Marley
I came here for answers.
All I got was more confusion.
But I am freaking loving it.
phro basically like the video said, there’s 5 version of titan history and no one knows which of them is true, not until isayama reveals the whole thing. I suggest you try understanding each of the history (if you have time) one by one instead of processing all of it from one video
@@locoroco2940 well at least we know that the first version " the one we that have been told in Season one " is 100% false because humanity outside didn't perished nor the walls been built because of the titans in other words it's just a lie created by karl fritz and been protected by the following kings
Same 😅😂
Currently watch s4 and recently understand abt eldians and marleyans
Me too, my brother explained it to me but I got even more confused. Time to rewatch I guess
And people say attack on Titan has a terrible story... they obviously don't understand how much depth and thinking was put into kt
Never heard people say that yet 🙂
Foxen Anime I hear all the time at my high school... it really makes me mad
Yh some people state that it's too "cliche". Which is complete BS
Lamz I can’t even believe someone said it was “cliche” I haven’t even seen another anime show with the same elements that I can relate to
Tbh it's kinda lame the idea is great but this just sort of gets rid of the horror aspect of the anime
one thing to be said: History is determined by the motherfuckin victor
Mr.Abed Fettah Battlfield 3.
Winston Churchill
Quoted by Captain Price
@@roxvkiri9707 the winners write history.
That means the last version is a lie... i agree but it’s probably the most broad and believed one
"There is no such thing as truth in this world. That is our reality. Anyone can become a god or a devil. All it takes is for someone to claim that to be the truth." - Eren Kruger, chapter 88
Is that a true statement?
Yeah, there's a problem here alright.
There is an objective truth, to what extent Eren and his friends are able to uncover and confirm that is the question.
It will probably lie in unlocking all the titan memories from the founding titan or all of them, if they are ever combined in a single person again.
loop
@IMAFRIENDLY NEIGHBOR i feel you
@@MikeTall88 same with Doffy in one piece. In that scene, pirates and Marines are having a war. He asked if pirates are automatically the evil and Marines are the good ones. He then answered his own question saying winners can change the meaning of evil. Kids who never seen peace and kids who never seen war have different view of Justice. But at the end of the day, the winners will be the Justice. That's why up until now, I've seen government more of a big organization rather than people who'll bring Justice.
That's some of the most bs pseudointellectual stuff there
I think the whole point of the story is that all of these versions are true to some extent, and that there exists no true heros or villains. Everyone commits atrocities with reasonable justification from their perspective. We are all victims of our circumstances and upbringing. The "villains" during the current arc have just been humanized to the point where we're not supposed to want anybody to lose or die, protagonists or otherwise. That's why the story works so well as a tragedy, because in the real world, no side is just born evil.
That makes sence thanks:)
It seems like aspects have been exaggerated over one central narrative to suit the purposes of the storyteller
U just explained every war that happened in real world
Both sides are fighting for what they think is right
Except King Fritz
I remember attack on titan history better then American history
LMAO
That’s because it’s not as extensive
Aphrodite Deliphine what kind of history do you like?
Aphrodite Deliphine Aphrodite Deliphine Aphrodite Deliphine Yeah, European history is very interesting. One guy I like to watch is Townsends. He makes videos about 18th century living and cooking. He’s actually what got me into reading and history in general, but especially European
Ye now I know why i have bad grades
When you think you finally know about the history of AoT, just remember this:
*There is no such thing as truth in this world. That is our reality. Anyone can become a god or a devil. All it takes is for someone to claim that to be the truth.*
DBZ Macky Fair point except the Teiber family just revealed the true history in the latest chapter.
He didn't reveal the story in its entirety. The real story will be revealed by Isayama in a flashback of Ymir (the progenitor of the Founding Titan). How did she get the ability itself and what how the inheritors after her could have used or misused the Titan Powers to hurt others. Ymir must have predicted this, and spend the rest of her life to find a cure, as the Owl stated "the curse of Ymir" but Fail. Marley, Eldia, The Owl, Willy the Tybur Family as some speculation of the history though they may some truth in them. Grisha's and the Owl background gave us a middle ground of what the history was. (Marley made up a story of what happened as a form of propaganda for their own evil means). Willy gives more information on the story regarding King Fritz and the Made up hero "Helios". In my opinion, The Owl, Eren kruger's info on that history make more sense.
Let's wait for The author's story to move forward and we the readers will decide.
DBZMacky also remember this, this is a fictional story
I seriously think eren kruger's version of titan history is true !
Normal Person No the real world and everything in it
long story short: a chick named Ymir obtained and spread the titan powers among Eldians, but everyone started fighting among themselves for power, so the king of the Eldians (Fritz) decided to hide on Paradis island among walls made out of titans to end all the conflict. He brainwashed his own people into thinking they were the only humans on Earth, and threatened the other nations to never disturbe their peace or else he would release the titans, using his founding titan power. But the Marlean nation still hated them from the war and sent titans there (former humans) in order to devour their people, and this is how Attack on titan begun. Now that Eren and the gang (the Eldians) found out that all the titan attacks were caused by the Marleans, they're fighting a war, to know how it goes read the manga lol. I hope this summary was helpful
That definitely was helpful. Tis shit got me really confused but ur comment did explain tho. Thanksyaa.
Finally i understand, you summary really2 help me a lot. Thank you.
Ty
Manga expensive
omg i was so confused tysm
Yeah she just found some titan weed thats all...
Imagine at the end of the story the founder Ymir wakes up and says
"Damn! I won't do drugs again"
@@RedditorGogeta would be funny but I don't think that's what Isayama has in mind...
@@vali69 hes 4 Parallel Universe Ahead Of us
@@RongDMemer lol
Wait for s4 pov
Basically the anime is based on conflict between two empires.
Plus the whole world
@@pauldee7504 the whole world is Two empires
bar no, there's Eastern, southern and western allies, technically there's hundreds of thousands of empires that got dominated because of the great titan war
Basically eldians are fighting w marley vs the eldians that were sent away right
@@antvenomn8343 there's also people from other countries that are not marleys and eldians that the marley empire are trying to conquer!
I feel like this animes came from undentified History lol such a great creator, God Bless Hajime Isiyama.
name profile pic =P
Foxen Anime 😝
Cute Gabi fuck you lmao you killed our potato
Isayama blesses himself?
Gabi sucks
zeke must know the truth and kruger history backs-up so eren is ending what kruger started
that’s why kruger didn’t fight for marley and the reason zeke is disappointed of the war
hmm good theory, Zeke is supposedly super smart 😮
I like as well
I feel like every virsion is true to some extent. Everyone is just telling the story in a way that makes them look like the good guys. My theory is that the real history is just a combination of all the told stories or it could just be a bunch of misleading stories leading to a complete plot twist 😂
I got a feeling there's more false info than the true, but I'll expand on this in upcoming vids for this series 😄
Foxen Anime looking forward to them :)
I definitely agree! I think Isayama sensei is going to blow our heads off our bodies... I'm terrified lol.
I think the most realistic course was that the Eldians unified under Ymir and allied with other peoples to fight against the Marley Empire. After overthrowing them, life improved to a degree but then the Eldians became complacent. The 145th King decided to move the capital to Paradis Island, maybe to establish a secondary base (I don't know), when the Marleyans attacked. Having lost the homeland, the King fortified his base and basically said you win but don't try anything with us.
That's the one that makes the most sense to me but I'm not the one writing the story.
L
I thing Willy Taybur's version is completely correct. It tottaly clears up why the King of the Walls erased the memories of his people and did nothing when the 4 warriors attacked the Island.
But what has me convinced is this: The Marley version made Eldians look like devils, the Grisha version made them look like angels; Both were biased but Willy's version had none. It wasn't a bashing nor favoring Marleyans or Eldians, just a detailed explanation of what happened and how it ties in with current events regarding Eren being able to potentially trigger the Earth-Leveling attack..
The reason why the Titans didnt rumble the earth after the 4 warriors were attacked is probably because Eren is not of Royal Blood and couldnt access the memories of King Fritz Will or the power to unleash the titans on to the world. Eren didnt even know those titans who infiltrated the walls were human titan shifters before.
Seth Gonzales Nigga.... have you been watching the anime or read the manga at all cause it seems that you atleast havent been watching the anime LOL
Seth Gonzales When the four warriors attacked, Eren didn’t have the Founding Titan. Freida Reiss possessed the Founding Titan at the time, but Eren’s dad, Grisha Yeager, ate Frieda to steal the power from the Reiss/Fritz Family. Once Grisha found Eren, Grisha took him to the forest, and injected him with titan serum. Which caused Eren to transform, he then ate his father, and inherited his fathers abilities.
@TigerClaw! who allowed?
*100k Special!! 10 Sword Art Online OS FACTS!! Iron Reference??* 😄
►► ua-cam.com/video/GNQAwNI0ANs/v-deo.html
Why is this not pinned sir Fox?
All of the stories probably have aspects of them that are right. Willy is a liar though. If the king fritz was sworn to pacifism, than why did willy allow marley to send 4 warriors to retrieve the founding titan, even though at the time the founding titan was still under royal family control. Did willy know all along that grisha would be able to aquire the founding titan? Or was he scared enough by the threat of grisha that he saw no other choice?
I was wondering about this too and a lot of others on the ch99 review vid brought it up.
I was assuming that he never 'allowed' or prevented it since it mentioned how the Tybur family was in a position for them to watch Marley do w/e they wanted.
My theory is that we will get a whole chapter of eren flashing back to krugers memories and we will learn about this. The owls memories definitely have some potential answers
TheGerthax I think the 4 children breaking the walls was a signal to the royal family to follow through with the plan and give up the founding Titan , but Krueger/Grisha messed up the plan by taking it
Exactly, and still, even if Willy was indifferent of Marley's military endevours up until recently, the Tybur being the ruler of Marley makes them responsible for the consequence of Marley's actions. The story just doesn't make sense at this point - Willy could be trying to mislead the world to shine the spotlight away from Marley's militaristic ambitions. This also implies that the Tybur allowed Marley to believe in a false tale, which makes them even more responsible.
Also, wasn't Marley at war with a lot of nations? How is there no animosity towards Marley itself from around the world?
@Dunebuggy12 the guys from the nation they were at war with seemed mad at the festival pre-party 😮
What Attack on Titan did brilliantly in my eyes was they made a story and they made sure they got it wrong the first time, not saying that it was a mistake on their par, they did it beautifully, making the Titans seem like a natural occurrence to plague the world
And using that as the spring board to hop into all this amazing lore
I think Ymir Fritz discovered how to control inorganic substance, hence the Titans. But it had a side effect, it shortened thier lifespan significantly since it uses lifeforce as a fuel hence, the 13yrs lifespan.
Well, the shortened lifespan is because somehow Ymir was killed 13 yrs after she got her power. It didn't say how, but I'm pretty sure it wasn't like aging or a side effect. The x on her neck in the manga suggests that someone found the nape/ or beheaded her and so the others who received the titan shifters are cursed/doomed to die after 13 years.
@@barnalibehari1118 organic substance * not inorganic
The 13 year lifespan is surely apart of her pact with the supposed 'devil'.
Who knows lol
Science can't explained the paths
Science can't explained the paths so no
Wow how did I never find this channel it's awesome. I was watching all your video's. There's alot of anime news.
welcome Malahy ! Glad you enjoy 🙂
This amount of depth makes AoT the greatest anime ever don’t @ me 💯
"history is written by the victor" general shepherd
ɪ ᴛʜɪɴᴋ ᴘʀɪᴄᴇ sᴀɪᴅ ᴛʜᴀᴛ
@@user-ec9yy2fz2e :o
ᴏᴋ
@@user-ec9yy2fz2e Nah, it was Shepherd im pretty sure
@@josephuuqt wrong
AOT stay being LIT🔥At least we don't have to wait 4 years, but half a year for Season 3! Can't wait😄
yeah cannot wait for s3, really hope it's 24 episodes 😄
Foxen Anime it should be, the 15 second Japanese season 3 trailer has a snapshot of eren at the ocean which is chapter 90. So 24 or more is likely
Zade 24 - 30 most likely, it depends on how much they cut down from the Uprising Arc.
@Big-Bonkin-Head they should be able to do it in 24-25 episodes unless they add a lot more filler (which they might)
Also keep in mine they have to go by cours, so if it's not 24-26 episodes, they'd have to add 11-13 more which is less likely
Foxen Anime they said it would be 25 episodes that's why s2 had 12
shit, I dont know who to believe anymore. but I think none of them are 100% correct. there's gotta be some lie part on every version
That’s what war is.
As a German citizen with ancestor from WW2 and from Vietnam... I experience both sides of war through my grandparents.
My grandpa from father sides was a fellow soldier during WW2 and he was 16 at the time... he said that everyone was kinda just living there lives under the propaganda of Hitler that time. No ones of course thought of the dark side of it. And only with the time going on the people felt the shame and the realization of their war crime.
But to me he was a nice grandpa who was also got capture in Russia.
My grandfather from mother side was also in war. Vietnam war. He suffered under the Army and the post war situation was hell for my mother. Some of their neighbors suffered under agent orange generation after the war.
But even after that, he won’t tell me to hate the American even if they did bad things....
I am a offspring from both the “evil and the victims” but both was just suffered under the war and I’ve learnt that war doesn’t have a “true winner”.
And every good can be evil to the others....
I’m sorry my English is bad but I hope you got my point.
That why I love AOT so much because it has such a depths in it.
This sht is confusing🤦🏽♂️
You don’t know the half of it 😂
Eric Dodson-Ross ya wtf
But it makes it more interesting
Well yeah when there's three different stories...
Holy shit i thought i was the only one who's dumbass that can't get the story
Hi there, love your content as always ^^ !!!
Can you add subtitles to this one too please ? I have some trouble since you speak a little too fast for me. Thanks for reading me if you did ;) !!!!
Hi! Glad you love my stuff 🙂
I add all subtitles to all my videos, UA-cam is just delayed on adding them to this video today 😮
Holly molly man thanks a lot xD !!! Never thought that you would reply to me ^^ !
Thanks again and keep going ;D !!!
of course I'll reply to my viewers 🙂
Even 100K of them :O ??
yup 😉
Brother i can't thank you enough.. Thanks for this I was struggling to understand this theory
Here after AOT season 4 episode 1 came out. Ive forgotten about the eldian and the marleyan plot so had to watch this. Was really confused about who's the bad guy in there and i dunno am still confused lol
I too just watched it, i am really confused right now
The bad guy is marley
@@DhirC35 nahh cant say marley is the bad side. They hv reasons too. I aint supporting them just tellin.
Can't wait for season 3
8 more month . . . 😮
shady
Me to
Same
Same
Wzzzaaap season 3 just arrived Wzzzzaaapp!
I love how there is basically no right or wrong side, it's so fascinating
I wish more stories had this sort of thought put into it
So could hitler be looked as a good guy in someones elses depiction of history?
Micks NotNice yes
If he had won the war history would be rather different.
From a civilian nazi back then, yes.
@Best Dad Ever fr
A quick look at /pol/ will tell you that’s true, lol. Neo-Nazis have been around since immediately after WW2.
My theorie is that Captain Livaï is gonna rule this bitch world.
Airfly exactly
Anyone here after the release of season 4?
yessir
Yess
I like the editing , you did it sort of like how a documentary will move across pictures to make it seem more like an actual video instead of a slideshow with audio nice job
Great video as always!
Keep up the good work
thank you Sweet Gamer Kitty! 😄
Oh, don't thank me, just telling the truth ^^
Thanks for making another episode (ur the best)
np Arafat Amin 😉
I NEEDED this video, I got all mixed up in the manga.... so thanks a lot 😄
yeah np prob! it can get confusing 🙂
I think Eren Krugars is correct
When I finished aot I wasn’t confused, but when I watched s4 ep1 it had me confused💀
I think it's fairly obvious that Grishas version is the most likely to be false as his version has almost zero credibility. I think King Fritz pacifistic version makes the most sense considering their vast and immense power. They have always had the power to crush any nation at any time regardless of how weakened they had become from infighting. So the Eldian guilt, shame, quest for peace, and resulting isolation obviously had to be entirely voluntary. I'm fairly sure the Marleyan version may be somewhat exaggerated but has most of the base truth in it. And Tyburs story probably clears up some of that exaggeration from both Eldia and Marley BUT may still be adding some of their own Tybur flavor of exaggeration....
But for Willie Tybur to be lying really doesn't make any sense. It has to be mostly altruistic and truth because much of his explanation is damning to the Marleyan and Tybur reputation....
The reason why I love attack on Titan so much is because there are no villains or heroes since its war. It's just whose side are you on. Yes they are all criminals but they fought to survive.
Hi foxen Great video thanks
I think it does not matter which one is right but I would go with willy's version minus the part with eren as the bad guy also I'm waiting to see what eren does now
We all are pranked guys.
Aot isn't anime. It's a legend adapted into anime.
She was probably a scientist biologist etc but do to the time frame at the time it was considered witch craft and so it spread rumors of her dealing with the devil etc
whoa! that's really good
Juan Elias this!!!!
SPOILER
.
.
.
.
.
.
Actually she was just a child slave of the Eldian tribe (not even an Eldian herself) who accidentally discovered some sort of organism that she merged with, turning into a titan. After working for the Eldian king and defeating the Marleyans with her titan power, she was basically raped as a "reward". (Yes, the king actually called this a "reward".) She birthed three children, but died sacrificing herself for the king after an attack. Her three children then were forced to literally eat her corpse, so that they may inherit the power of the titans. She basically lived her entire life as a slave to the Eldian king.
Besides speaking about Attack on Titan, that probably happened in real life during the "Mediaeval" period when we were burning so called "Witches" and such.
What if Helos was an Ackermann
That.... would be mind blowing.
And Marley people can't turn into titans like Ackermans. So the Marleys and Ackermans are tied in with eachother?
I would shit my pants
OH MY GOD!!!!!!!!!!! but.. according to the latest Tybur story, they just chose a random Marleyan.
But NICE THEORY!
Oh shit
7:04 egger Kruger 😂🤣
Geisha really looked the the funny pictures and made up his own cannon. True king.
Reminds me of OUR world history... the holocaust and now the ethnic cleansing of the rohingya people... wouldn’t be surprised if it turns out that titans did exist
Nur yeah no slavery at all
Im pretty sure if you kill a certain race for a certain reason, its genocide. So, uhh.
@@Jaysann22 People forget people that the Jews were invloved in slave trade of the black race.
Nur are you a rohingyan brother?
@@KusKus1042 stfu ... you said "marleyians" ? ahahah really ? that has nothing to do with our world or the fucking jews or the fucking nazi ... wake up . Even isayama said that !
Attack on titan lore history could easily be as deep and fleshed out as the game of throne books.
Theres like over 120 eldian kings to explore
Its crazy because plot twist his sister is the war hammer titan
Christopher Holloman Yeah... I figured he was protecting the real shifter by letting everyone assume it was him but it was SOOO lame it turned out to be his damn sister who then got her ass handed to her by Eren....
Jaysann22 it kinda makes sense, the Warhammer Titan isn’t in use so she wasn’t as well practiced as the other Titan shifters. And the whole sister reveal is the same as the Eldian reveal that the Reiss family had the founding Titans not the fritz
@@ineedmoresleep3728 The reiss family is the fritz family. Dude, did you even read or watch properly?
Takagi-san Jozu yes, I’m assuming you didn’t or else you would’ve known that they split within the walls with the Reiss having the real power and the Fritz being puppet politicians
@@ineedmoresleep3728 Hahahaahah, Sorry for being late for the show but The fritz are not "Puppet Politicians", They are also the reiss, Historia reiss is a fritz, Frieda and rod reiss are a fritz. Karl fritz changed the bloodline name from Fritz to reiss, Just try to edit your thing or else people will get confused alr? Just try re-reading or re-watch the anime again.
So no ones here after season 4 release ??
Season 3 is sooo near ....I am soo excited I can almost taste it.......😋😋😋😁😁😁😁
Thank you for this video. I needed a refresher 😊
I don't think we've heard the true story yet, and I'm positive we won't know what really happened until Eren tells us since he holds the founding titan. One thing I am sure of though, is that this anime is going to turn into an allegory for WW2, with the Eldians representing the Jews and the Marley's representing the Nazis. Maybe the Tybur family is the US or the Soviets. The latter makes sense if the Tybur family has Eldian lineage, but this might all be a lie too. Going back to the actual anime, I think it's a lie that only Eldians are able to turn into titans, and in reality, every human has that ability. I'm sure fooling the entire world into thinking only those with Eldian blood can turn into titans works as propaganda for the Marleys against the Eldians, and also for the Tybur family to make themselves seem more important than they really are.
seems like Isayama draws from alot of world history, even current stuff happening in recent years
Foxen Anime Yeah, I wouldn't be surprised if the direction he took with the anime changed after a few recent events. He changed the idea he had for an ending to the series because of how much fans loved the characters, so I would definitely understand Isayama doing the same with the state of the world.
but I think they would have tested the spinal fluid on non-Eldians right?
@@kasvinimuniandy4178 I don't think any Marley person would gain from letting the world know they are a titan, and I also doubt any Marlian would want to become a titan in the first place, considering the history they've suffered-at least allegedly.
Paradise Island is also linked to Atlantis. Consisting of 3 rings and the existence of titans.
Oh and its not about Germany or the Jews. Its linked to how the Western empires have a same way of influencing our worlds history and how we see people from outside 'our walls' as threats that look like titans but in all reality are the same people as we are.
Foxen; you are the best 👍🏻 I think that the truth is yet to be revealed, and it could be a sum of those different stories.
This was my first Anime
And hows that experience?
Woah hahahaahahah good luck
Same :| and it's my favourite so far
Same. Glad i started with this. It made me fucking love anime
Same
Thank you sooo much I get it now this was a big help❤️
Damn. This is a lot to take in. If I were to speculate as to which story is true, I'd be wrong. It's best to wait for the manga to tell us what's genuine.
They should make a prequel series about eldian empire and their oppression
Im just waitin for them just say aliens did this to humans.....
happy 400k subscribe men
Quite a lot of theories about the true history of The Great Titan War, slightly confusing, but thankfully your video cleared it up for me, haha. (Also almost at chapter 100, we're getting much closer to the end).
Awesome work
3:20 the wall titans were like human giants but when they see them in the current aot they dont look the same
Thank you for explaining this, i dident understand season 4 before you explained.
3rd I think. Oh well great video I'ma going to finish watching it.
thanks Preston! 🙂
Can't wait for more! !!!
But if you think about it
Before the show ends
SOMEONES GONNA DIE
LIKE SOMEONE
IS DYING
AND IM NOT READY FOR IT
yeah I think a lot of people will go down from all sides
I bet that Marley high commands and possibly the foreign ambassadors likely to be the first to die.
SOMEONE DIED **sobs** Not the potatoesssssssssss!!!!!!!!!
quality content!
I want a Game of Thrones-style Titan War prequel series. Game of Titans?
Great explanation tnx for it
All I wanna know is how did the Uchihas go across time and space and spread their clan without sharingan, under the surname "Ackerman"
Uchiha's are so badly written
@@crystxlzx6442 I think the Uchiha's are written good, just heavily overrated.
Am I the only one who finds when titans crunch human's bones satisfying?
Who is here because of attack on titan season 3 part 2 ?
I’m still confused, all I remember was a kid wanting to see the Ocean.
I don't know the history but this is what future I want.
Collect all the Titans powers on paradise Island and die. This might change all Titans back into humans. And noone gonna be able to turn back into Titan. Titan power should be gone for good.
Thx broo ....details......👍👍👍👍👍👍
Hello People Scrolling Down the comment sections
Hello
@Jose Manuel Balod hello
Hello 1 year later 😄
Hello brother from another mother 🙌
Sup
WoWzErS 😱😱great vid ❤️❤️
Thank you Anime Is life 🙂
Me: *binge reads aot manga and finishes all chapters in a day*
....ok but wtf
I can't wait for the Marley Arc to be animated! It will be amazing!
i feel like the true story was probably the eldian version by that i mean the ymir fritz teaming with a creature type thingy (idk what it is tbh but) and so she used her titan power to help the world. something he didnt cover was the curse of ymir or how the powers were passed down and also how eren got the powers of the founding titan . first ill say what the curse of ymir was the curse of ymir is a curse that makes u die after the age of 13 because ymir died at the age of 13 yrs old. this brings us to how ymir died and how the powers were passed down i dont really know how ymir died but the powers were passed down by ymirs daughter (maria rose and sina) which are also the names of the walls remember that it might be important but ymirs daughter need to be important if the walls are named after them they litteraly could've named the walls wall1 2 and 3.but anyways we are getting off topic.ymir daughters ate ymirs body to gain her powers and they kept doing that they kept eating and gaining eating and gaining. this comes to where we learn how eren got the powers of the founding titan. basically erens dad ate the founding titan and gain the powers. but then if u remmeber the flashbacks eren had his dad gave him spinal fluid with the spinal fluid eren turned into a mini titan and ate his father. thats all please like this comment i worked hard :)
I like your videos you gained i new sub. I think every version of the story has truth in it... also what are your though about helos? Do you think he is an ackerman? Or made up
welcome! 😄
Before the info came up about Helos being makeup, alot people thought he was an Ackerman & I think that idea seemed interesting.
Now it seems that perhaps he may have existed but really wasn't this almighty titan slayer that he was made up to be, but he could still have been an Ackerman 🤔
So the Eldians abused the power over threw Marley and ran out of people to kill so they killed each other. The Marlians took advantage and reversed the rolls and turned the Eldians into titans to kill the Eldians. Correct me if I'm wrong
Very much
But apparently people like gabi or falcon are eldians “good eldians”
So if I’ve missed something or only eldian become titan shifter or literally anyone can
I wonder if Ymir (from the Survey Corps) knew the old/ancient language. Remember how surprised Reiner was that she knew what what the old can they found in Utgard (?) castle?
Love the video
Awesome! 🙂
Wow this is so very interesting
I think eren kruger knows something.......
Or he probably doesn't btw nice video
Good video
thanks Kswlogic! 🙂
Foxen Anime you're the reason why I watch this show dude...thanks
Still a bit confused as I've only seen the anime up to a portion of season 2...so the mindless pure titans are basically banished Eldians, kin of the very people inside the walls who's recent ancestors had their memories erased by the 145th king so they don't know any better...and this would explain why the wall priests keep their mouths shut because they're in on this knowledge. I'd say this puts a combination of Morely and Tyber histories as the MOST true. It would also explain why the eight Morely-controlled Titans only sporadically attack the walls years apart. They're apprehensive and testing to see if the King's threat of unleashing the wall Titans is a genuine one.
Interesting stuff. The anime version so far to me, is not unlike the movie Akira - it's engaging and fascinating, but unless you read the Manga, you miss out on much of the reasons why unfolding developments happen.
One question though, is the current King, who has power of the founding titan even aware there's espionage occurring within the very ranks that protect the walls of his kingdom?
The current monarch is Historia.
I like the idea that it is a future setting, Ymir was some kind of bio-engineer creating the solar powered titans as some kind of exosuit construction gear, and everything went to hell after. At this point everything has fallen to a neomysticism.
Lol, this information was already out on 2017.. I'm literally just watching final season and was confused by the politics but now I understand it all. Understanding the story just watching the anime is confusing
this was a must watch before season 4, thanks
Great video so far I'm going to finish watching it. But I died when I found out season 3 got delayed.
Thanks Mike^2 😄
MIKE MIKE me to I died.
I'm still convinced that the Marleyans are the villains. After all, if they hadn't filled Paradis Island with Pure Titans and sent Reiner, Bertholt, Annie, Zeke, Marcel, and Piek in the first place, Eren wouldn't even have a vendetta and they're still trying to plunder Paradis for it's resources, only now they're tricking the other nations into giving them support.
Wait why are they trying to kill everyone in paridas island
@@isaidthis5038 Because the island is rich in natural resources, which the Marleyans are running low on.
@@simbasorariku3no thee marleyans want vengeance for what Ymir did. so that's why Marley wants to destroy paradise
@@simbasorariku3Marleyans want revenge for what the eldians did to them for 2000 years. Why is everyone forgetting the crimes of eldia before all of this?
Isayama should reject Spa idea, and make a prequel series of Great Titan War.
i feel bad for eren :(
Mikasa just needs to pick him up again and rock him like a big boy 😉
Foxen Anime IM NOT HER KID OR LITTLE BROTHER!
*cringe*
Thank you so much for this video. Very well explained. I was hooked to this titan stories. I hope that Isayama will write a prequel story about the Great Titan War after Attack on Titan.
This is becoming too confusing for my brain to handle..... at first it was AAA TITAN RUNNNN and now its THERE IS A WHOLE ANOTHER FANCY LOOKING CIVILIZATION WITH EPIC TANKS AND GUNS WITH CARS AND MORE TITANS.....
Exactly like, Subjects oF YMir, and punishing people by turning them into a titan, and idk if that's still going on, the punishments or they just retarted titan shifters
@@isaidthis5038 My lil br ocommented this im sorry his 12. AoT is confusing?? It does not seem that complicated too me tbh