It's very telling that our institutions hardly ever, if at all, mention the atrocities under these regimes. The schools do not teach it at all, it's incredibly rare to see it in media and the government never references it.
Our govt is attempting to do the same to us by removing farmers. There's a reason they don't want us to know history. The British govt did the same to the Irish during the potato famine, they took all the food and exported it, leaving the Irish to starve. Same to the Scots during the Clearances.
They would never allow their precious ideological dream to be associated with all the nightmares it inflicts upon civilization. If that happened, people would reject it and it would fall into the dustbin of history, and that is something they can never allow to happen.
That's because many many people in academia, government and polite society were sympathetic to Communism and actively supressed the atrocities. Only now do you get lessons about it because Russia is the bad guy again, so it's used for that purpose when in fact many of the rulers of the USSR weren't even ethnic Russians.
I've always said childrens' education is continuous. Teaching has always been open to political bias. It is up to their parents to add to their education. Likely as not, they are not teachers, but they are able to pass to them what they have learned themselves.
David Irving once described how his house was broken into by a group of masked men. He said that if he identified them he would be accused of being anti semantic.
I'm 38, I was not taught explicitly about Communist regimes until I went to college. Nonetheless my peers and I picked up much from the culture at the time - we all knew about Mao and about the U.S.S.R. Reading Russian literature was were the rubber met the road - not just numbers of dead but the story of how the light drained from their eyes. The start was always propaganda- and here we are in 2024!
We don't think there are in the present government bureaucracy people of a Soviet mindset prepared to move gradually along the road towards a police state built upon the bones of millions?
I've been subscribed to NCF for well over a year now, but Peter has become one of my favourite political commentators of late. Smart, respectful, dignified 👌🏻
Now becoming a textbook for the non hate crime policing. The very conversation from Gulag Archipelogo went "admit your crime, you have been accused by someone anonymous, no we cannot tell you what the crime is, just admit to it, This has no happened to Allison Pearson . But it now appears they may have got the wrong Allison Pearson . Can it get more ridiculous?
Thank you for this valuable interview and introducing James Bartholomew and the Foundation and website. What a very worthwhile endeavour and resource. It is absolutely a forgotten episode in history as far as schools are concerned but reminders of how it can come about and what is entailed is so vital for education of the young just now as they are being brainwashed by the state in various ways.
So true. Starmer certainly holds the white working class majority in utter contempt and blatantly so. He's already twistedly labelled everyone who might protest about the mass open influx of illegal migrants into the UK as 'far right' thugs' . He's also released thousands of criminals and instead locked up many generally law abiding citizens for daring surmise that the Southport stabbings had been committed by an Islamic terrorist, (which was really just obvious pattern recognition.) Not a single person locked up for spreading such supposed 'misinformation' has yet had their sentence over-turned. However, it's now open knowledge that that the Southport killer attends the mosque in Bel Marsh prison and that , prior to his rampage, he had downloaded Al Qaeda terror instruction documents . All those convicted for predicting that the Southport killer would turn out to be an Islamist therefore ought to be justly exonerated.? But not so under 'two tier' Keir. PS I predict that 'non=crime' hate investigations will also proliferate under Starmer. (I just hope I don't get a police visit - or worst - for posting this.
The fact that the UK was allied with the Soviet Union during WWII has nothing to do with it. Here in Sweden, we were not allied with the Soviet Union, but still the evil of communism is completely unknown to the majority of people. And it is completely socially accepted to be a communist.
The City and Wall St funded Stalin knowing that atrocities were being committed. They funded technology transfers to the Soviets and helped build massive armament factories in the Urals. They sucked the Germans in to Moscow and Stalingrad and then unleashed. The Germans were Nationalistic,Family orientated and religious,rather like the UK. That could not be tolerated and it had to be obliterated to make way for the EU/Marxist structure we now have. ( Brexit was never going to be allowed ). We are in big,big trouble,history has been deliberately hidden and changed as the brave new world unfolds. Starmer gives a tame insight to the future. Also,the kind hearted allies killed 1.7 million Germans in Conc camps from the 1945-1947. Most of these were civilians who died from disease and starvation as huge quantities of food were in ships in the European and British ports. Evil unbounded,the instigators are still about weaving their total power with abandon.
For some reason very few Western movies are made about the Communists while loads are made about Hitler. This is probably one reason that younger people have no idea about all of this.
The Muslim brotherhood came out of Nazism and many were in the Waffen SS. The SNP supported Nazism without history how do the young know What's going on. Many concentration camp victims were taken by the Russians suffering an even worse fate
Why do you think that is? It seems Hollywood is missing out on a highly lucrative venture by avoiding the subject.
12 годин тому+3
Exactly. Name one movie about what the USSR did to the kulaks, to the Ukrainians in the 1950's and 1960's? Name one movie in which the main character, real or fictional, had to deal with the horrors of the Soviet gulags by being a prisoner in one? I bet no one can name one movie about those subjects.
I think that part of the reason for this is the lack of visual records. The Nazis documented their own activities in great detail -written and filmed - so that we all have a mental image of WW2. But the millions who died in Russia left no traces at all.
The Gulag Archipelago is a very hard read, but very grateful to Solzhenitsyn for his narrative of these events. Was taught of the 5 Year Plan in the early seventies, but not much else.
If we are forever forced to remember the Holocaust and the evils of Nazism, the evils of Communism are at least as worthy of our attention and need to be taught to our young so that we can be certain when we say 'never again' that we are not forced to relive the same nightmare every second generation as we forget what has gone before.
The ignorance of the evils of Communism and the reasons for our ignorance are quite clear. That our enlightenment of it does not serve the narrative, which is that all Christian morality and patriotism is in fact suspect and protofascist, and that we need Communism (disguised, temporarily, as socialism) to guard against and destroy it.@MattLund-i6i
“Never again” is an empty slogan. These atrocities occur time and time again while the international community watches on without taking any meaningful action.
You were taught about the Germans in School in fact you had it rammed down your throats you were never taught about the Russians or the Chinese, I dint know they existed until I was in my 20s and don't get me started on Islam never heard of it until about 10 years ago
The film version of Alekandr Solzhenitsyn's novel ' One day in the life of Ivan Denisovich ' is available on youtube in English . Its a bit grainy but if anything this adds something to the visulal representation of life in the gulag
The current 'Prime Minister' of Cambodia, Hun Sen, is a former Khmer Rouge officer, who defected to the Vietnamese after he found out he was going to be arrested. He still runs the country with his X KR cronies. and buy running, i mean gradually selling it off to the Beijing regime.
In the early 80s I was left a leaning socialist, in fact we'll on my way to being a communist. Then my Aussie uncle visited us in the uk and brought his new wife with him. She was a sweet quietly spoken Cambodian women. I asked her about how she ended up in Australia. Over the next half an hour sitting at my mother's kitchen table this quietly spoken middle aged woman opened my eyes. My Step Aunt is the only surviving member of her extended family. She lost them all in the Cambodian killing Fields. Their crime was essentially to wear glasses. He was a university professor and she was a primary school teacher. They were split up and she later found out he was hacked to death where he stood outside their home as soon as she turned the corner and was bundled with their children into the back of a lorry. He wasn't even worthy of a bullet. She and their four children, were eventually force marched into the countryside where over the next year they were all, apart from her, worked and starved to death. She barely survived and has had ongoing severe physical and mental health problems all of her life as a result. She lost 15 members of her family and her story is far from unusual amongst the 2,000,000 that they murdered for this ideology. But no, that wasn't real communism.....
No such thing as real communism. Why? Because the ideology denies human nature. Would you seriously expect someone who worked hard all their life, to hand everything over to you personally?
So glad I found the new culture furum Thank you Rafe, Peter and all else involved but a huge shout out for Amy . Amy you have restored my faith in young people.
That was one of the most riveting interviews I've ever watched. I've always dismissed Guevara as a silly faux-rebellious fashion icon - I had no idea of the depth of his depravity. People need to know about these matters. Could the lessons taught by the the teacher mentioned by James not be published on social media?
Raphael Lemkin defined the term & criteria for genocide in 1944. He wrote Soviet Genocide in Ukraine which includes the Holodomor (death by starvation of the Ukrainian peasantry), the extermination of the Ukrainian intelligentsia, destruction and mass murder of the Ukrainian church/clergy & mass deportations of Ukrainians to Siberia. The Holodomor Genocide and Great Terror purges of the 1930s & 40s have been covered up in the UK by the press, main stream media and successive governments for decades. Millions of Ukrainians murdered by soviet communists. Estimates go up to ten million and beyond. Not taught in British schools, not commemorated alongside other genocides on Holocaust Memorial Day and not officially recognised by the British government despite the House of Commons voting to do so in May 2023. Forbidden history! Never again? WTF!!!
The Labour Party were always acolytes of Stalin, they protected the Soviet regime when it came to light that vast timber imports from the USSR were being harvested by Gulag labour in the most inhumane of conditions. The imports continued.
Those who believe that same evil will do whatever it takes to rewrite history and cover up the evil perpetrated in the name of their ideological beliefs.
I would like to recommend a very revealing book on the brutality of Khmer Rouge rule in Cambodia: The Lost Executioner by Nic Dunlop. It tells of Nic Dunlop's determination to track down Pol Pot's chief executioner, one Comrade Duch, a man utterly cold and dutiful in his torture and murder of anyone who might conceivably be non-revolutionary. After Pol Pot's downfall Comrade Duch disappeared into obscurity and converted from communism to Catholicism!
@@FEiSTYFEVER I stand corrected. It has been a few years since I read the book so I should have said "Christianity" rather than Catholicism. I also misspelled his name. It should be Duch not Durch. I have correct that but left Catholicism in place as a correction would make your comment puzzling to others.
@@K-GuamYou can still change it and leave an edit note in another paragraph below your original. You're assuming that someone will want to view the replies, most people dont, they just scroll and soak up whatever they glance at. It would be best if it was changed.
katyn woods. effing monsters and brutes. as luck would have it after the implosion of the ussr it came out of raided kgb archives about nkvd-gestapo/ss cooperation before barbarossa: it was the soviets who taught the germans how to establish and "run" concentration camps. usually the unknowing world has always tried to hang that one on the necks of the british from the boer war.
We don't really need to be reminded of it. Labour are well on their way to introducing it to the UK. So everyone will get a chance to experience left wing terror and oppression first hand.
The Labour party in Britain aligned itself with the Soviets that were committing these atrocities as they shared a similar ideology. Britain was the biggest importer of timber harvested by men who were worked to death in the Gulags.
I learned about near all of this in school in Ireland in the late 1980s. We were also as Catholics asked by our priest to pray for the peoples living under communist regimes. My father said, when we asked him to explain communism in one sentence, that under communism everyone is expected to be a replica of everyone else, not allowed a personality and all have to have the same thoughts. He called it 'death by sameness'. I remember many stories the teachers told us, here is one such story a teacher read from a book: Stalin and one of his political comrades were been driven through a town in a carriage. On seeing the streets filled with starving and emaciated people from the window of the carriage, Stalin's comrade said 'look at those starving people, we need to do something for them', Stalin replied 'close the curtain'. Besides what Stalin said, another remarkable thing about this story is that Stalin's communist party comrade did not see what was happening until he was, as it were, sharing a cosy freindly space chatting away to the devil himself.
I worked with people who believed that Communism was a good idea which had, inexplicably, gone a bit wrong. Their discussions were arcane , and never persuaded me. I decided to find out about the subject, but didn't trust the various detailed histories available. I chose to read the autobiography of Nabokov (inventor of the term "Communazi") and also the two volumes of memoirs of Nadezhda Mandelstam. I'd recommend these to anyone interested in the period under Stalin.
And their followers and enablers are so sick, stupid or low in self esteem that they trail along behind hoping for crumbs of recognition or delegated power thrown their way by their idols.
They should teach it in school and maybe young people would not be going along with What is happening at the moment?what is going on in the countries going along with communism?
The SPHE, social, physical, health educations "new" curriculum in Ireland is the beginning of the communist agenda. The government, department of education, teachers minister for education are very well aware of what this new curriculum is all about and are eagerly going along with it.
What stops people from reading up on these things?! One can't simply lay the blame for ignorance at the door of the educational system. Access to information is widely available on different platforms.
I think we have to be very careful about engaging the imaginations of youngsters because they may have more appetite for these things. As an ex teacher I cant think how to safely frame such shocking revelations
What many people don't understand is that the current Russian government under putin not only refuses to denounce Gulag, but also works hard to re-establish its "values". The Gulag museum in Moscow was closed just the other day.
Nazino Island, otherwise known as Cannibal Island brutal beyond human conception. People were literally being eaten alive. The Bolsheviks were not majority Russian which is why this and the Holodomor are not constantly being force fed to the public.
Communism says 'from those according to their abilities and to those according to their needs'. But the problem with this is that human needs are continually changing giving changing circumstances. The more we have the more we need. This creates a situation where those who produce are trying to keep up with the needs of those who are less productive. The fact is the human needs always outpace the human ability to satisfy those needs. The result is suffering. The way capitalism solves this is by giving the strong and smart productive people the ability to reap the rewards of their efforts, which efforts attempt to satisfy the needs of the less productive.
You could look at the communist manifesto by Marx, that might be a good start. He is idolised by many, there is a picture of one of his greatest fans now in Rachel Reeves office.....think about that....
The local Socialist Alliance headquarters in Newcastle (Austalia), has an image of Geuvara on their building. It is horrifying that they believe that a murderous thug was a hero.
Dear old Che! Maybe he has his counterparts in Haiti etc or Gaza with Hamas. But drugs have played a part in these and maybe even more so now. Nationally we underestimate how much drugs affect the gangs and just ‘ordinary’ people in our day. But no one listens to me on this. We stand hopeless
The atrocities of the Russian totalitarian State, the cruelty and complete disregard for the sanctity of life and the uniqueness of each person, makes you think just how fortunate we are to be living in a Christian country which both values God’s moral law and individual freedom. Oh, then again…….
There are lots of things that aren't taught in schools. Because they have finite time available. If you want this taught, what would you like taken out?
There's more to it than that. It was due to the UK's Corn Laws - tariffs on agricultural imports which benefitted landowners. The laws applied all over Britain
@@neilg4208 Nope, they stole our land, food, faith, education and native language, how many in the UK had to emigrate or die of starvation, , why did the Irish have to emigrate, Elis island etc.......? No Irish, no blacks, no dogs in the UK......!! Do your research......
Liberal Reformer Sir Edwin Chadwick was responsible through the designing of 1832 Poor Law Reform Act and then its enforcement was caused more deaths then any other man in 19th Century UK and one overlooked factors in the famines in the UK between 1845 and 1850 is the way this Poor Law was enforced.
Read Vladimir Bukovskiy this man describes the true nature of communist - socialist ideology. He spent 20 years in gulag. Very sad to hear his prediction about rusing socialism among European elites which became true.
And lets not forget to teach our children about the horrific hegemonic crimes of democracies against their own people and also foreign nations. Millions have been and are still being killed and harmed by criminal democratic politicians.
You kommies just cant handle that your beloved ideology just dont work in practice. It has to resort to brutal authoritarianism to keep people in line, once they realize that 'some are more equal than others'.
The 'Reds' just cant handle that their beloved ideology just dont work in practice. It has to resort to brutal authoritarianism to keep people in line, once they realize that 'some are more equal than others'.
It's very telling that our institutions hardly ever, if at all, mention the atrocities under these regimes. The schools do not teach it at all, it's incredibly rare to see it in media and the government never references it.
Our govt is attempting to do the same to us by removing farmers. There's a reason they don't want us to know history. The British govt did the same to the Irish during the potato famine, they took all the food and exported it, leaving the Irish to starve. Same to the Scots during the Clearances.
The establishment is run by communists.
They are faaaarleft
They would never allow their precious ideological dream to be associated with all the nightmares it inflicts upon civilization.
If that happened, people would reject it and it would fall into the dustbin of history, and that is something they can never allow to happen.
That's because many many people in academia, government and polite society were sympathetic to Communism and actively supressed the atrocities. Only now do you get lessons about it because Russia is the bad guy again, so it's used for that purpose when in fact many of the rulers of the USSR weren't even ethnic Russians.
We need to do everything we can to stop this happening again.
If only we could identify the "group" behind it...
I've always said childrens' education is continuous. Teaching has always been open to political bias. It is up to their parents to add to their education. Likely as not, they are not teachers, but they are able to pass to them what they have learned themselves.
@@evolassunglasses4673 - Officially such identification is immediately smeared as "anti-Semitic"
Stop the globalists and the EU.
David Irving once described how his house was broken into by a group of masked men. He said that if he identified them he would be accused of being anti semantic.
I'm 38, I was not taught explicitly about Communist regimes until I went to college. Nonetheless my peers and I picked up much from the culture at the time - we all knew about Mao and about the U.S.S.R.
Reading Russian literature was were the rubber met the road - not just numbers of dead but the story of how the light drained from their eyes.
The start was always propaganda- and here we are in 2024!
We don't think there are in the present government bureaucracy people of a Soviet mindset prepared to move gradually along the road towards a police state built upon the bones of millions?
Congratulations NCF on reaching 300,000 subs.
Thank you!
Absolutely
I've been subscribed to NCF for well over a year now, but Peter has become one of my favourite political commentators of late. Smart, respectful, dignified 👌🏻
"But real communism has never been tr... BANG......."
it has, many times. And it always ends the same way.
Gulag Archipelago, difficult to read without tearing up.
Now becoming a textbook for the non hate crime policing. The very conversation from Gulag Archipelogo went "admit your crime, you have been accused by someone anonymous, no we cannot tell you what the crime is, just admit to it, This has no happened to Allison Pearson . But it now appears they may have got the wrong Allison Pearson . Can it get more ridiculous?
Thank you for this valuable interview and introducing James Bartholomew and the Foundation and website. What a very worthwhile endeavour and resource. It is absolutely a forgotten episode in history as far as schools are concerned but reminders of how it can come about and what is entailed is so vital for education of the young just now as they are being brainwashed by the state in various ways.
Both my grandads spent in GULAG 10 years each. Survived by a miracle.
Parents’ stories about their childhood made me cry.
Write it down and tell the world.They are trying to whitewash history.
Don't let Starmer get hold of a copy, the only lessons he has learned from Stalin is how to emulate him.
Sadly, true. I hate starmer
Political Ponerology: A Science on the Nature of Evil Adjusted for Political Purposes
by Andrzej Lobaczewski
So true. Starmer certainly holds the white working class majority in utter contempt and blatantly so. He's already twistedly labelled everyone who might protest about the mass open influx of illegal migrants into the UK as 'far right' thugs' . He's also released thousands of criminals and instead locked up many generally law abiding citizens for daring surmise that the Southport stabbings had been committed by an Islamic terrorist, (which was really just obvious pattern recognition.)
Not a single person locked up for spreading such supposed 'misinformation' has yet had their sentence over-turned. However, it's now open knowledge that that the Southport killer attends the mosque in Bel Marsh prison and that , prior to his rampage, he had downloaded Al Qaeda terror instruction documents . All those convicted for predicting that the Southport killer would turn out to be an Islamist therefore ought to be justly exonerated.? But not so under 'two tier' Keir.
PS I predict that 'non=crime' hate investigations will also proliferate under Starmer. (I just hope I don't get a police visit - or worst - for posting this.
It is our duty to inform particularly in these times.
The fact that the UK was allied with the Soviet Union during WWII has nothing to do with it. Here in Sweden, we were not allied with the Soviet Union, but still the evil of communism is completely unknown to the majority of people. And it is completely socially accepted to be a communist.
The City and Wall St funded Stalin knowing that atrocities were being committed.
They funded technology transfers to the Soviets and helped build massive armament factories in the Urals.
They sucked the Germans in to Moscow and Stalingrad and then unleashed.
The Germans were Nationalistic,Family orientated and religious,rather like the UK.
That could not be tolerated and it had to be obliterated to make way for the EU/Marxist structure we now have. ( Brexit was never going to be allowed ).
We are in big,big trouble,history has been deliberately hidden and changed as the brave new world unfolds.
Starmer gives a tame insight to the future.
Also,the kind hearted allies killed 1.7 million Germans in Conc camps from the 1945-1947.
Most of these were civilians who died from disease and starvation as huge quantities of food were in ships in the European and British ports.
Evil unbounded,the instigators are still about weaving their total power with abandon.
this is because leftism is a disease of western modernity.
“…picking them off one by one” Sound familiar to us in Britain today?
It certainly does
"Death by a thousand cuts."
For some reason very few Western movies are made about the Communists while loads are made about Hitler. This is probably one reason that younger people have no idea about all of this.
The Muslim brotherhood came out of Nazism and many were in the Waffen SS. The SNP supported Nazism without history how do the young know What's going on. Many concentration camp victims were taken by the Russians suffering an even worse fate
Why do you think that is? It seems Hollywood is missing out on a highly lucrative venture by avoiding the subject.
Exactly. Name one movie about what the USSR did to the kulaks, to the Ukrainians in the 1950's and 1960's? Name one movie in which the main character, real or fictional, had to deal with the horrors of the Soviet gulags by being a prisoner in one? I bet no one can name one movie about those subjects.
I think that part of the reason for this is the lack of visual records. The Nazis documented their own activities in great detail -written and filmed - so that we all have a mental image of WW2. But the millions who died in Russia left no traces at all.
Hitler makes such a good cartoon character.
Then there's the awkward fact that the USSR was our ally.
The Gulag Archipelago is a very hard read, but very grateful to Solzhenitsyn for his narrative of these events. Was taught of the 5 Year Plan in the early seventies, but not much else.
Try "200 Years Together".
His follow up.
Hi, Evola. You’re not the first to recommend that one, but the Gulag was enough for me. 😬 Thanks, anyway.
Absolute power corrupts absolutely. We've also seen it in religions. True democracy is a thin veneer.
If we are forever forced to remember the Holocaust and the evils of Nazism, the evils of Communism are at least as worthy of our attention and need to be taught to our young so that we can be certain when we say 'never again' that we are not forced to relive the same nightmare every second generation as we forget what has gone before.
Fair comment. I tell my daughter just because they tell you one is a demon doesn't mean the other is an angel.
The ignorance of the evils of Communism and the reasons for our ignorance are quite clear.
That our enlightenment of it does not serve the narrative, which is that all Christian morality and patriotism is in fact suspect and protofascist, and that we need Communism (disguised, temporarily, as socialism) to guard against and destroy it.@MattLund-i6i
They all came out of marxist theory communism, national socialism and fascism, look closely at the woke left mob you'll soon recognise it
Common mode - authoritarian control regimes.
“Never again” is an empty slogan. These atrocities occur time and time again while the international community watches on without taking any meaningful action.
I first heard about this from Peterson. Never understood why he's so vilified to such an extent. This helps.
You were taught about the Germans in School in fact you had it rammed down your throats you were never taught about the Russians or the Chinese, I dint know they existed until I was in my 20s and don't get me started on Islam never heard of it until about 10 years ago
Stalin Starmer.
Two tier. No idea. Sharia. Free gear. Up the rear. Get out of here. Kier.
@@JohnconnoYou can only speak for yourself.
Greasy Palmer's catchprase - Mao then, Mao then. Mao's about that then.
@@popgoesthestoat V. Good. Starmer fixed it for Jim.
@@Johnconno Struggling for ideas?
The film version of Alekandr Solzhenitsyn's novel ' One day in the life of Ivan Denisovich ' is available on youtube in English . Its a bit grainy but if anything this adds something to the visulal representation of life in the gulag
Tom Courtney ❤
This is the kind of stuff that should be show on the BBC, not just on UA-cam!
The current 'Prime Minister' of Cambodia, Hun Sen, is a former Khmer Rouge officer, who defected to the Vietnamese after he found out he was going to be arrested. He still runs the country with his X KR cronies. and buy running, i mean gradually selling it off to the Beijing regime.
In the early 80s I was left a leaning socialist, in fact we'll on my way to being a communist. Then my Aussie uncle visited us in the uk and brought his new wife with him. She was a sweet quietly spoken Cambodian women. I asked her about how she ended up in Australia. Over the next half an hour sitting at my mother's kitchen table this quietly spoken middle aged woman opened my eyes.
My Step Aunt is the only surviving member of her extended family. She lost them all in the Cambodian killing Fields.
Their crime was essentially to wear glasses.
He was a university professor and she was a primary school teacher. They were split up and she later found out he was hacked to death where he stood outside their home as soon as she turned the corner and was bundled with their children into the back of a lorry.
He wasn't even worthy of a bullet.
She and their four children, were eventually force marched into the countryside where over the next year they were all, apart from her, worked and starved to death. She barely survived and has had ongoing severe physical and mental health problems all of her life as a result.
She lost 15 members of her family and her story is far from unusual amongst the 2,000,000 that they murdered for this ideology.
But no, that wasn't real communism.....
The Khmer Rogue were brutal and possessed by a truly evil ideology. I'm glad you had your eyes opened to it.
Political Ponerology: A Science on the Nature of Evil Adjusted for Political Purposes
by Andrzej Lobaczewski
No such thing as real communism. Why? Because the ideology denies human nature. Would you seriously expect someone who worked hard all their life, to hand everything over to you personally?
So glad I found the new culture furum
Thank you Rafe, Peter and all else involved but a huge shout out for Amy . Amy you have restored my faith in young people.
Funny how this is NEVER talked about on MSM, featured in movies, commemorated in various ways.....
Thank you both.
Remember how happy everyone was when the Soviet Union collapsed but then the EU came and the misery continued.
That was one of the most riveting interviews I've ever watched. I've always dismissed Guevara as a silly faux-rebellious fashion icon - I had no idea of the depth of his depravity. People need to know about these matters. Could the lessons taught by the the teacher mentioned by James not be published on social media?
And the woke university students want it here 😊
"EDUCATE YOURSELVES" they scream at us.
We are, oh we are!
They know nothing...and I mean NOTHING.
cos they have been taught by them
Raphael Lemkin defined the term & criteria for genocide in 1944. He wrote Soviet Genocide in Ukraine which includes the Holodomor (death by starvation of the Ukrainian peasantry), the extermination of the Ukrainian intelligentsia, destruction and mass murder of the Ukrainian church/clergy & mass deportations of Ukrainians to Siberia. The Holodomor Genocide and Great Terror purges of the 1930s & 40s have been covered up in the UK by the press, main stream media and successive governments for decades. Millions of Ukrainians murdered by soviet communists. Estimates go up to ten million and beyond. Not taught in British schools, not commemorated alongside other genocides on Holocaust Memorial Day and not officially recognised by the British government despite the House of Commons voting to do so in May 2023. Forbidden history! Never again? WTF!!!
Holodomor was everywhere. Russia proper, Ukraine, Kazakhstan.
Good morning everyone
When I read about cannibal island in Gulag Archipelago I was horrified at the barbaracy
And the photos of the Holodomor are truly horrific
The Labour Party were always acolytes of Stalin, they protected the Soviet regime when it came to light that vast timber imports from the USSR were being harvested by Gulag labour in the most inhumane of conditions. The imports continued.
Academics promoting totalitarian regimes always ends well for them.
Then never seem to learn
Those who believe that same evil will do whatever it takes to rewrite history and cover up the evil perpetrated in the name of their ideological beliefs.
I would like to recommend a very revealing book on the brutality of Khmer Rouge rule in Cambodia: The Lost Executioner by Nic Dunlop. It tells of Nic Dunlop's determination to track down Pol Pot's chief executioner, one Comrade Duch, a man utterly cold and dutiful in his torture and murder of anyone who might conceivably be non-revolutionary. After Pol Pot's downfall Comrade Duch disappeared into obscurity and converted from communism to Catholicism!
Wrong. He was baptized by an evangelical pastor.
@@FEiSTYFEVER I stand corrected. It has been a few years since I read the book so I should have said "Christianity" rather than Catholicism. I also misspelled his name. It should be Duch not Durch. I have correct that but left Catholicism in place as a correction would make your comment puzzling to others.
@@K-GuamYou can still change it and leave an edit note in another paragraph below your original. You're assuming that someone will want to view the replies, most people dont, they just scroll and soak up whatever they glance at. It would be best if it was changed.
Thank you for doing a marvelous job
Academia has been charged with projecting the image of Che Guevara as a revolutionary hero.
The power of imagery is amazing. One sexy photo and that maniac is Elvis.
The many Polish Army officers - shot by Stalin after capture 1940
katyn woods. effing monsters and brutes.
as luck would have it after the implosion of the ussr it came out of raided kgb archives about nkvd-gestapo/ss cooperation before barbarossa: it was the soviets who taught the germans how to establish and "run" concentration camps. usually the unknowing world has always tried to hang that one on the necks of the british from the boer war.
We don't really need to be reminded of it. Labour are well on their way to introducing it to the UK. So everyone will get a chance to experience left wing terror and oppression first hand.
Everyone should read The Gulag Archipelago. It should be mandatory!
Creeping normality.
Evil in the extreme.
Don't. bring children into this system.
If humanity ceases to be...so be it!
Labours playbook/ wetdream
Europa - the greatest documentary on the subject
yep but one that many cannot get their head around.
The Labour party in Britain aligned itself with the Soviets that were committing these atrocities as they shared a similar ideology. Britain was the biggest importer of timber harvested by men who were worked to death in the Gulags.
I watched this video three times... taking it all in.
It's a fine line. The truth will set you free?
I learned about near all of this in school in Ireland in the late 1980s. We were also as Catholics asked by our priest to pray for the peoples living under communist regimes.
My father said, when we asked him to explain communism in one sentence, that under communism everyone is expected to be a replica of everyone else, not allowed a personality and all have to have the same thoughts. He called it 'death by sameness'.
I remember many stories the teachers told us, here is one such story a teacher read from a book:
Stalin and one of his political comrades were been driven through a town in a carriage. On seeing the streets filled with starving and emaciated people from the window of the carriage, Stalin's comrade said 'look at those starving people, we need to do something for them', Stalin replied 'close the curtain'.
Besides what Stalin said, another remarkable thing about this story is that Stalin's communist party comrade did not see what was happening until he was, as it were, sharing a cosy freindly space chatting away to the devil himself.
I worked with people who believed that Communism was a good idea which had, inexplicably, gone a bit wrong. Their discussions were arcane , and never persuaded me. I decided to find out about the subject, but didn't trust the various detailed histories available. I chose to read the autobiography of Nabokov (inventor of the term "Communazi") and also the two volumes of memoirs of Nadezhda Mandelstam. I'd recommend these to anyone interested in the period under Stalin.
I noticed that all dictators are narcissistic, sadistic and mentally ill. But the folks like these traits. They can see it as a strength.
And their followers and enablers are so sick, stupid or low in self esteem that they trail along behind hoping for crumbs of recognition or delegated power thrown their way by their idols.
They should teach it in school and maybe young people would not be going along with What is happening at the moment?what is going on in the countries going along with communism?
The SPHE, social, physical, health educations "new" curriculum in Ireland is the beginning of the communist agenda. The government, department of education, teachers minister for education are very well aware of what this new curriculum is all about and are eagerly going along with it.
Hi James, hope you are well. GREAT WORK as always!
What stops people from reading up on these things?! One can't simply lay the blame for ignorance at the door of the educational system. Access to information is widely available on different platforms.
I think we have to be very careful about engaging the imaginations of youngsters because they may have more appetite for these things. As an ex teacher I cant think how to safely frame such shocking revelations
What many people don't understand is that the current Russian government under putin not only refuses to denounce Gulag, but also works hard to re-establish its "values". The Gulag museum in Moscow was closed just the other day.
Incredible
Even that book is a massive underestimation
Nazino Island, otherwise known as Cannibal Island brutal beyond human conception. People were literally being eaten alive. The Bolsheviks were not majority Russian which is why this and the Holodomor are not constantly being force fed to the public.
Thank you. 👍👍👍
Communism says 'from those according to their abilities and to those according to their needs'. But the problem with this is that human needs are continually changing giving changing circumstances. The more we have the more we need. This creates a situation where those who produce are trying to keep up with the needs of those who are less productive. The fact is the human needs always outpace the human ability to satisfy those needs. The result is suffering. The way capitalism solves this is by giving the strong and smart productive people the ability to reap the rewards of their efforts, which efforts attempt to satisfy the needs of the less productive.
Always remember that "Nazi" comes from the German for "National Socialist". The Fascists were from Italy under Mussolini.
GULAG is an acromym for "Glavnoye Upravlyenye Lagierey" = Main Administration of Camps.
Out of Capitalism, Socialism and National conservatism.....only choose NATIONAL CONSERVATISM from now onwards
Amazing video, thank you for mentioning Witold Pilecki, he was not known in Poland for decades, only recently historians talk about him
Are we allowed to talk about the ethnicity of the majority of the Bolsheviks?
Are you asking for my permission ?
Not granted .
Get back and face the corner again .
No more impertinence from you my boy !
No just cohenidence
Pattern spotting.
Today's media is in the hands of this group.
The majority? Lenin, Stalin?
See the history in Spain.
I remember a Polish friend telling me about his grandfather who was sent to the gulag and somehow survived.
People ate tree bark to survive.
Always missing who exactly were the inventors of Communism? There were many followers, but never about authors, their specific origin?
✡️
You could look at the communist manifesto by Marx, that might be a good start. He is idolised by many, there is a picture of one of his greatest fans now in Rachel Reeves office.....think about that....
Gustaw Herling Grudzinski - "A World Apart" - memories of a Polish writer imprisoned in Gulag during the war
It is no accident that Karl Marx is buried in Highgate Cemetery, London, England.
A book of British history for the future?
I can't see Comrade Starmer liking this book one iota.
The local Socialist Alliance headquarters in Newcastle (Austalia), has an image of Geuvara on their building. It is horrifying that they believe that a murderous thug was a hero.
A duopoly. We become what we fight. The description of the enemy is a faithful self portrait.
Listening to this story my head is running into what happened in China in the last century. I still have post trauma fear.
Dear old Che! Maybe he has his counterparts in Haiti etc or Gaza with Hamas. But drugs have played a part in these and maybe even more so now. Nationally we underestimate how much drugs affect the gangs and just ‘ordinary’ people in our day. But no one listens to me on this. We stand hopeless
The atrocities of the Russian totalitarian State, the cruelty and complete disregard for the sanctity of life and the uniqueness of each person, makes you think just how fortunate we are to be living in a Christian country which both values God’s moral law and individual freedom. Oh, then again…….
There are lots of things that aren't taught in schools.
Because they have finite time available. If you want this taught, what would you like taken out?
sex education
Really enjoyed this distressing subject. I have The Killing Fields on BluRay. It's a brilliant film.
Forced starvation in Ireland too under UK rule 1800's one million died, ship loads of grain sailed to the UK and land stolen...
There's more to it than that. It was due to the UK's Corn Laws - tariffs on agricultural imports which benefitted landowners.
The laws applied all over Britain
@@neilg4208 Nope, they stole our land, food, faith, education and native language, how many in the UK had to emigrate or die of starvation, , why did the Irish have to emigrate, Elis island etc.......? No Irish, no blacks, no dogs in the UK......!! Do your research......
Liberal Reformer Sir Edwin Chadwick was responsible through the designing of 1832 Poor Law Reform Act and then its enforcement was caused more deaths then any other man in 19th Century UK and one overlooked factors in the famines in the UK between 1845 and 1850 is the way this Poor Law was enforced.
Who are the Bolsheviks?
The new " Government" that took over Russia in 1917
Embryo Gulsg camp
Read Vladimir Bukovskiy this man describes the true nature of communist - socialist ideology. He spent 20 years in gulag. Very sad to hear his prediction about rusing socialism among European elites which became true.
No worse than the horrors of capitalism and colonialism
"Гла́вное Управле́ние исправи́тельно-трудовы́х ЛАГере́й" (Main Directorate of Correctional Labour Camps)
And lets not forget to teach our children about the horrific hegemonic crimes of democracies against their own people and also foreign nations. Millions have been and are still being killed and harmed by criminal democratic politicians.
Exactly
Which countries are you referring to with ..''millions are still being harmed by criminal democratic politicians'?.
Which countries are you referring to that are still doing that to Millions?
You kommies just cant handle that your beloved ideology just dont work in practice. It has to resort to brutal authoritarianism to keep people in line, once they realize that 'some are more equal than others'.
The 'Reds' just cant handle that their beloved ideology just dont work in practice. It has to resort to brutal authoritarianism to keep people in line, once they realize that 'some are more equal than others'.
WWII narrative should be decentralized for the sake of accuracy.
I can help with the organizing software
34:24 Start with a discord and a zoom lessons or yt channel
Cmon
Traveling around can come later
This is 2025!
If you read about the invasions over 900 years of the Indian sub-continent by the Islamic empire it has very familiar ring to it.
Alot of ideological sympathy is why we don't hear about it.
I'm re-reading Night by Eli Wiesel
Tough going
👏👏👏
Hmm sounds strangely familiar, cattle cars, no food, drink, packed in, many dying on the way, but they blamed the Germans for it
Nonsense, this is well covered in both GCSE and A Level history.
What is Starmers pyramid of corpses???
And what is the reason for the Holbein painting ?
Starmer
Same happened in Ireland but it was the ruling elite.
Now here comes Fascist America.