So, how are you feeling, chat? I'd say my current emotion is Click the Join button or join here: ua-cam.com/channels/r9dAaPfxCBJS1oaeJWDtaQ.htmljoin Everything Wrong With CinemaSins: Godzilla x Kong: ua-cam.com/video/NcvO3blObnk/v-deo.html Twitter: twitter.com/Th3birdman15 Instagram: instagram.com/Th3Birdman15/ Discord Invite Code: nQZRn5m Subreddit: reddit.com/r/Th3Birdman
Brother, im going thru it right now in my personal life, and i can tell you how much Joy i feel seeing your videos. So from the bottom of this mans heart i say Thanks for the feels
You got it wrong bird man we say glizzy because it’s gay Like that meme where a guy cooks food and a picture of 2 men kissing comes on screen for a second
@@vanillaicecream2385 You must be confused. I pronounced the word with the correct English pronunciation. The silly way you pronounce it is a mispronunciation.
Ya know I actually wonder if Riley will change her opinion on them. I mean I too hated broccoli when I was younger, but hitting 16 I didn't mind them and eaten them regularly. I guess what I'm trying to say is how does Disgust react to change in taste opinions?
@@raymaikeru , I'm nearly 30 years old, and I only like cauliflower in the breading of pizza, and even then I get extremely sick off of it, so I kind of see where Riley is coming from whenever it comes to broccoli 🥦 🥦 because even I myself get extremely disgusted from broccoli and cauliflower.
Its so funny that Jeremy is all like "1 positive emotion and 4 negative ones" when the whole point of the movie is that that conceptualization of emotions as purely positive or negative is harmful. Joy can be negative, sadness can be positive.
@@Hero_2222 , disgust also keeps us alive from us not digesting inedible foods, so even though Inside Out 2 is the first Inside Out film I watched even I could follow the plot of Inside Out better than Jermery.
Or when he sins the movie for “Joy being a dick” when the point of that moment (or maybe the whole movie) is not to push other emotions away by forcing yourself to always be joyful.
3:44 God you have no idea how much I hate the idea that sadness, anger, fear and disgust are all "negative emotions". Feeling those things is a hell of a lot more healthy than not. It's almost like that's part of the movies message or something.
@@Raindrop_2401 To the point, a lot of self respecting behaviors like not taking abuse and not letting yourself be taken advantage of cannot exist without anger. A lot of personal growth comes from that
We had a group talk in CBT about emotions and how they're all linked (without sadness you wouldnt know what joy felt like and so on), thery're healthy and healing isnt about eliminating the "bad" ones (as again, they're all needed and compliment the more pleasant ones), its about finding balance between them so one emotion isnt overtaking the others majority of the time. That's when it becomes unhealthy (even too much joy is unhealthy as it can become forced at certain points... as demonstrated by Joy the character)
He misunderstands this movie so bad calling every emotion except Joy bad and doesn't understand that the point of it is that all of the other emotions have their uses and that it's bad actually to try and just be happy all the time when you aren't.
Spoiler Warning for Inside Out 2 (even tho it’s been out for a while now) Isn’t that kinda what Inside out 2 shows? Joy tries to cover up the new emotions initially, trying to pretend she’s happy and covering/hiding the bad stuff
One thing I always remember about CinemaSins' Inside Out video is when the emotions are planning to ride the Train of Thought and Jeremy says something along the lines of "The movie just keeps inventing new solutions for our characters". The Train of Thought was first mentioned in one of the first scenes of the movie, so this would be considered a Chekhov's Gun rather than a Deus ex Machina. This was one of the first CinemaSins videos I ever saw, and that moment made it clear to me that these guys really aren't good at paying attention to the movie they're sinning
@@hearmeout1767if a gun is placed on the wall, it ought to be fired during the runtime of the movie. It’s the film nerd’s shorthand for set-up and pay-off, as the concept is especially important in film. Movies don’t have a lot of wiggle room, and everything needs to be important, so even small background things needs to be important to justify their presence. I.e, a gun hanging in the background at the beginning of the movie gets fired during the climax. Or, characters mention the Train of Thought in the beginning and ride it during a moment of action.
@The_Trident_Master really the animation style is top tier. On top of that Pixar adding the fine details like shadows and water effects. What part didn't you like.
I don't think the parents "in charge emotions" are meant to signify anything bad about their characters (i.e. the mum is sad or dad is angry). Not only are their control rooms neater with the emotions sitting around and seemingly working well together, but we know from Riley's hockey game in the second movie that emotions aren't exactly literal. During the hockey game, anger is in control for a moment, but it seems less that she actively becomes angry and more just very determined. So I think Sadness being the mum's "in control emotion" is less that she's sad and more that she's sensitive, well meaning, fairly mild, whilst dad (with anger in control) is more proud, boastful and headstrong. With someone as young as Riley in the first movie, sure, take the emotions as literally as you want, but the older folks definitely have more nuanced emotion.
Considering at the end of the movie, it's shown that Riley expressing Sadness brings the people she loves closer to her to comfort her, it could also mean that Mom is a bit more tender and empathetic.
The thing with only five emotions also has another explanation: in psychology Joy, sadness, anger, disgust and fear are the 5 primary emotions that humans gain after birth and all the other emotions (called secondary emotions) come later in life and are usually a mixture of one of these five. There's also the sixth one that's surprise, but I guess it would've been hard to implement in the movie...
You're right. Pixar worked with psychologists while making this movie. So Jeremy is literally sinning scientific research. Besides, in early drafts of this movie Surprise was implemented but was later cut because she was too similar to Fear.
0:58 You know, I don't think I've ever seen Cinemasins tackle a completely silent movie. I mean, wouldn't it be perfect? No narration, no exposition, the audience just has to watch the movie to get it and can't turn their brains off. Ah, wait, Cinemasins' audience does have to turn their brain off to watch their videos, so I guess this wouldn't really work.
@@pietrocatalano4285 I know I've seen some silent films with them, no idea how widespread that was It was meant mainly as a joke about CinemaSins and how they craft their 'sins' since they also sin movies for utilizing text
By the way, this is so real in real life. We disagree and argue with people, but we forget that the things we argue about are parts of what they are. So sometimes we just dislike people for being themselves, but we don't admit it.
I saw this video some time ago where a girl said that she partially blames Cinema Sins' impact on the reason why media literacy seems to terrible now...and this video adds fuel to that fire because my goodness...he completely missed the main message of the whole movie when he said Joy was the only good emotion.
I blame him, too. Fifteen years ago, if a movie isn't well loved, it's forgotten very shortly, like Tim Allen's "Zoom". Nowadays, it's needlessly ridiculed and mocked for months on end. What happened during that time that effected multiple people in such a way?
1:19 Okay, so regarding this sin, the movie shows later on that the older a memory gets it begins to fade and trying to play it back becomes increasingly difficult, to straight up impossible. Once that happens, the faded memories are then thrown away into the memory dump and eventually vanish. So, this entire sin by Jeremy is pointless.
What I love about the emotions as a whole, is that these aren’t the only 5 emotions Riley can feel, they are able to kinda combine in a way to do other emotions (at least, a headcanon) Joy and anger could make competitive for example
This Prometheus school of running trope needs to die. Basically what Jeramy is saying is that people have to be thinking clearly in a very stressful situation where they have to run for their lives in a life threatening situation.
That thought needs to die in general. “Why is the terrified schoolgirl going into the dark basement if a serial killer is chasing her?” I don’t know bro, how much logical function did YOU have left when you were being chased by a serial killer??
@@eileensnow6153 , there's three different types of adrenaline 1. The flight response which the one I have where run immediately away from the large animals like a bear 🐻 🐻 or boar 🐗 🐗. 2. The fight response where most Europeans fight off the wild animals, and 3. Freezing in place like deers, so the fact that Jermery fails to understand that is completely ridiculous on his part.
@@eileensnow6153 That is the exact reason I HATE those "How to defeat/escape (thing) in (movie)" because it's always some complex, detailed plan that you definitely wouldn't be able to do if you were actually in that scenario.
So for this part 12:08 I remember that someone made a response to this video way before you did and they brought up a really good point for this part. They said that, even if they won’t kill off joy, her being stuck down there has major consequences that could be potentially life ruining. If Joy isn’t there to make Riley happy that could cause things like depression or maybe even worse. And if sadness isn’t there either, it can make it hard for Riley to feel empathy or cry, and potentially mess her up mentally. Let’s not forget that Riley is literally running away up to this point on a bus when this is all happening, so can you imagine if joy and sadness didn’t get back in time? Like literally when they get back sadness helps Riley realize how much of a big mistake she’s making and goes back to her family, and joy helps her realize how much she loves her family and how much she’s happy to see them. It’s almost like CinemaSins just doesn’t wanna really pay attention, which is all the more funny when he acts like he’s making movies better and calling out Hollywood. And if you’re curious to who said this good point, I think the name of the channel was captain vader.
Fun fact: The selling of popcorn took off because the original way they made popcorn was able to mask the smell of drugs being sold in the dark theatres.
@@CrackedPropane , I don't know about all movie theaters, but the theaters where I live at sells alcohol, and the popcorn 🍿 🍿 that's sold there masks the smell of booze people drink whenever they watch films alone or with their family.
He'd whine about that, too. Let's be honest here. Jeremy's ideal film has no characters, no setting, no dialogue, no conflict, no PLOT, and no resolution. It's just a blank screen.
That jab at the end towards Critical Drinker and Nerdtronic was just *chef's kiss*, also i dare you to tackle Jeremy's video on Nimona, also someone tell Lee of CinemaWins to cover that film and GDT's Pinocchio
@@therondanielson9962I don’t know about the other guy, but I love Critical Drinker’s reviews. I can’t understand why people hate him besides politics. 🤷♂️
@@JamesP7 Well I think you've answered your own question there. Drinker's videos would be markedly better had he decided to stay out of the political realm, but that's what apparently makes him the most money, so here we are. His videos are very thinly veiled racist, misogynistic and bigoted. He clearly doesn't like seeing Black people in prominent roles, dislikes non-straight people in film, and thinks anytime a woman is in a role that is less than a damsel in distress, she's a part of "The Message". How can anyone watch this perseverative rhetoric over and over and over without getting tired is beyond me.
CinemaSins doesn’t want to understand movies. They only want to mock them, and the only reason they remove sins on occasion is not due to the film’s actual quality but instead how popular a moment in the movie is with the audience. Also, the reason Bing Bong has his name is because Riley was three when she made him. Toddlers don’t exactly have the most complex naming conventions.
Hi, gen Z here, if someone unironically calls a hot dog a "glizzy" in my presence, they will no longer have the ability to call a hot dog anything by the time I've finished with them.
9:29. I have seen this film multiple times and I just now realised the colours of the flower on bing bongs jacket are the colours of each emotion, nice detail animators o7
3:23 Jeremy says this despite the fact that they showed the islands are powered by core memories. And Riley gets all of her memories because of the emotions.
The “These are the only emotions” sin pisses me off a lot for some reason. I bet if there had been more emotions he would have complained about not being able to keep track of all characters. Heck, that’s probably gonna be a sin in the Inside Out 2 video.
Jermery also hates flashbacks too, so I don't know really what he wants his games, films, and tv shows to have if people can't chat with each other like superhero films, and there isn't flashbacks to convey the convey the characters motivations.
Your sixth Pixar video in the EWWCS saga, and I can tell you had some fun here and there while making this, especially when you drew a thick line through Riley's dad's mouth at 6:53 😂 I imagined his head flapping when I saw it!
If my ability to recall things serves me correctly, the "triple dent gum" memory is a yellow memory, meaning it is a HAPPY memory. So yes, I do believe while she's humming that tune she is happy, as it would make sense for the happy memories to make you, well.. happy. How does Jeremy not even THINK of that?
1:44 holy shit I just thought I was really dumb for saying manga the first way, cuz I kept hearin ppl say “mayn-gah” and was starting to think that they were saying it right and I’m just really fucking dumb, thank you for making me realize I’m not losing my marbles
the beginning disclaimer is so funny, each color represents the emotions he actually has on that part of the disclaimer. anger at the disclaimer cuz it’s goofy that he has to make it anxiety from the “I love cinema sins” (he doesn’t he’s lying) happiness for the “I am only” cuz it’s talking about himself disgust at the “poking fun at” cuz it’s how he feels when ‘poking fun’ (he’s not poking fun he’s disgusted) sadness at “some of”, cuz he’s probably gonna be making these for a long ass time and fear at “their mistakes” cuz he’s scared at what future mistakes they will make
One thing I'd like to point out that I think was a fantastic detail in the movie (and is one I see that people misinterpret entirely too often.) is the emotions that Riley's parents are led by. It's a representation of how our emotion's roles become more complex over time, as we do with age. As a result, Riley's mom isn't led by Sadness, but Empathy, and Riley's father isn't led by Anger, but by Protectiveness. (Or masculinity if you wanna go down that route as I think that Riley's dad is a positive example of such.) I'm tired of people trying to posit that Riley's mom is depressed and Riley's dad is abusive because they clearly aren't. It's even more braindead to see these takes when you see Riley's sadness take on the role of empathy IN THIS MOVIE.
Even if you want to argue that CinemaSins is all in good fun, I don't see the fun of sins like the one at 2:35. There's no joke being made, they're just over-analysing a really funny sight gag. They're not adding anything to an existing punchline.
It baffles me how he managed to miss the entire point of the message. Like…it’s straight up trying to tell you that Riley can’t always be happy and that her other emotions are necessary to go through. How did he miss that!?
Jeremy out here acting like if every single emotion ever doesn’t have a little head critter to go with it, it means the emotion can’t exist. When the whole movie’s about them learning that emotions can work in tandem to create new thoughts and feelings (shown by the multicolored memory balls at the end). Plus him being like “how is she doing anything if your emotions aren’t driving” as if he’s never just felt kinda neutral before
I know many ppl hate broccoli. I personally have no problem with it, in fact I love it. I think Jeremy fails to take into account that other people have different preferences.
I can kind of agree with the logos sin, since too many logos makes me go “start the movie”. But Disney logos? Those are always a must. It’s not an animated Disney movie without that castle.
I honestly hate how he sins the logos for just existing, like you said if they were overly long logo sequences that stretch out the runtime it makes sense to sin that, but he sins all logos no matter if they are there for 2 seconds or 2 minutes.
@@shinyagumon7015 , I only hate logos if the film or tv series has the logos lasting from 10 to 30 minutes, but since I've never seen any movies or tv series with extremely long logos screen I don't hate logos at all like Jermery does.
I honestly can't believe he sinned this beautiful movie.I think he should leave animation alone. 8:29 I'm a gen z and I say hot dog,not glizzy. Someone else asked this in the comments and I think this is a great idea. Everything wrong with cinemasins:Titanic
Whilst I'd use Jon Stewart's joke about "Deep Dish Pizza" being a casserole (Wtf Chicago?) Jeremy's entire ignorance on emotions "One positive, 4 negative" which if you're younger I can understand that logic but ARRGHHHH Cinema Wins' video on Inside Out is fantastic as it explains really well how here we see the film represent depression not as sadness as some erroneously think, but as absence of emotions.
I mean wasn’t Riley like 3 or 4 years old when she had her imaginary friend? That could contribute to the ridiculousness of it. But yep still not as ridiculous as that fake ass laugh.
The sin over Riley only having a small array of emotions is even more useless given inside out 2, the sequel movie, literally exists for the purpose of expanding Riley's emotional range
Just wanted to point out that 7:26 Riley is actually Gen Z. The first Gen Z was born in 1997 and I once made a theory that Riley is 11 years old and turns 12. The year is mostly between 2012 to 2014. I also met with a Pixar executive that told me that Riley was born around 2002. So she’s not a millennial she’s too young.
You can tell Jeremy didn’t take the film seriously because he puts Sadness as a negative emotion when the point of the story is to teach Joy that Sadness has just as important a role. Anger and Fear are the fight or fight instinct, while Fear also works for self-preservation, all of which are crucial to ongoing development and survival.
Birdman that Korean pizza comment hurt. As someone who just went there for a month I thought that Korean pizza was garbage. I tried 3 diff places and all were amazing. The craziest flavor I had was bulgolgi, chicken, corn, red and green peppers, honey mustard and bbq. I ate all of that in one sitting. Absolutely amazing and you have to try it when you go
12:21 Also, he’s not understanding the film. That memory of class isn’t something Joy found in the forgotten memories heap, that is the Core Memory that formed that started the whole mess and why Joy is even out of headquarters right now.
I'm a Canuck, and I'm really glad I watched this video in the privacy of my own home because when you said, "Jeremy sins Canadians" about the hockey thing, I hadn't expected that and I burst out laughing. That was a good one!
I once read, I can't remember if it was a news story or something else, but basically, for the first Inside Out, they boiled it down to 5 emotions because there are 27 of them and they couldn't fit all of them in there and took them down to the most important ones for Riley's life SO FAR. Of course they added 4 more in Inside Out 2, which makes sense.
6:26 Also with how long it takes to get from San Francisco to Minnesota by car, odds are Joy and Sadness would have found their way back before Riley's family crossed the Minnesota state line.
12:21 To me, this reads as Jeremy asking why Riley would have forgotten the memory as if it was sent there like the other faded memories and not because it's a core memory that was in the bag when Joy fell down. It hasn't faded yet, so it isn't officially forgotten. Am I assuming Jeremy was too dumb to remember things that were outright stated and made obvious in the movie? Yes. The alternative is the usual gimmick of him just misrepresenting a scene to pad the run time
Never watched Inside out, never planned to either tbh (was 17 when it dropped) but now I quickly watched it before watching your video and reeeaallly liked it. Gonna watch Inside Out 2 rn
So, how are you feeling, chat? I'd say my current emotion is
Click the Join button or join here: ua-cam.com/channels/r9dAaPfxCBJS1oaeJWDtaQ.htmljoin
Everything Wrong With CinemaSins: Godzilla x Kong: ua-cam.com/video/NcvO3blObnk/v-deo.html
Twitter: twitter.com/Th3birdman15
Instagram: instagram.com/Th3Birdman15/
Discord Invite Code: nQZRn5m
Subreddit: reddit.com/r/Th3Birdman
Brother, im going thru it right now in my personal life, and i can tell you how much Joy i feel seeing your videos. So from the bottom of this mans heart i say Thanks for the feels
You got it wrong bird man we say glizzy because it’s gay
Like that meme where a guy cooks food and a picture of 2 men kissing comes on screen for a second
why is cinemasins still a thing
im feeling disappointed in your disgust of the english pronunciation of manga
@@vanillaicecream2385 You must be confused. I pronounced the word with the correct English pronunciation. The silly way you pronounce it is a mispronunciation.
Whether you enjoy broccoli of not, it doesn't matter. The movie isn't saying that broccoli sucks, it is saying that RILEY hates it.
Exactly
Ya know I actually wonder if Riley will change her opinion on them. I mean I too hated broccoli when I was younger, but hitting 16 I didn't mind them and eaten them regularly.
I guess what I'm trying to say is how does Disgust react to change in taste opinions?
@@raymaikeru I assume that if Riley does have a change of taste of broccoli. I would assume Disgust wouldn't react to it as she did as shown
@@moonbased7796 Maybe if we get an Inside Out 3 she could be shown to now like broccoli
@@raymaikeru , I'm nearly 30 years old, and I only like cauliflower in the breading of pizza, and even then I get extremely sick off of it, so I kind of see where Riley is coming from whenever it comes to broccoli 🥦 🥦 because even I myself get extremely disgusted from broccoli and cauliflower.
Its so funny that Jeremy is all like "1 positive emotion and 4 negative ones" when the whole point of the movie is that that conceptualization of emotions as purely positive or negative is harmful. Joy can be negative, sadness can be positive.
Even then I wouldn't call any of them negative. They each have a purpose for Riley. And flaws. That's realistic!
And Joy even explains the positive aspects of Fear (keeping her safe), Anger (Keeping things fair), and disgust (Keeping her from being poisoned).
@@Hero_2222 Also you need anger (sometimes) to set boundaries.
@@Hero_2222 , disgust also keeps us alive from us not digesting inedible foods, so even though Inside Out 2 is the first Inside Out film I watched even I could follow the plot of Inside Out better than Jermery.
Or when he sins the movie for “Joy being a dick” when the point of that moment (or maybe the whole movie) is not to push other emotions away by forcing yourself to always be joyful.
3:44 God you have no idea how much I hate the idea that sadness, anger, fear and disgust are all "negative emotions". Feeling those things is a hell of a lot more healthy than not. It's almost like that's part of the movies message or something.
@@Raindrop_2401 To the point, a lot of self respecting behaviors like not taking abuse and not letting yourself be taken advantage of cannot exist without anger. A lot of personal growth comes from that
Literally. I fact, since all the emotions are necessary, many argue that negative emotions don’t actually exist and are rather a made up concept
@Snowie7826 digust saving us from poisonous and toxic things help also
@@quixotic_077 , I just mentioned how disgust keeps us alive as much as fear does.
We had a group talk in CBT about emotions and how they're all linked (without sadness you wouldnt know what joy felt like and so on), thery're healthy and healing isnt about eliminating the "bad" ones (as again, they're all needed and compliment the more pleasant ones), its about finding balance between them so one emotion isnt overtaking the others majority of the time. That's when it becomes unhealthy (even too much joy is unhealthy as it can become forced at certain points... as demonstrated by Joy the character)
He misunderstands this movie so bad calling every emotion except Joy bad and doesn't understand that the point of it is that all of the other emotions have their uses and that it's bad actually to try and just be happy all the time when you aren't.
A great lesson we are taught in the brilliant second movie. Well deserved billion dollars.
Spoiler Warning for Inside Out 2 (even tho it’s been out for a while now)
Isn’t that kinda what Inside out 2 shows? Joy tries to cover up the new emotions initially, trying to pretend she’s happy and covering/hiding the bad stuff
@@waz207 That's literally what Th3 Birdman just said in the reply just before yours.
@@Th3Birdman in both movies huh?
@@richardkirkland6805They were likely still writing their comment when his got posted since their posts are about 2 minutes apart
One thing I always remember about CinemaSins' Inside Out video is when the emotions are planning to ride the Train of Thought and Jeremy says something along the lines of "The movie just keeps inventing new solutions for our characters". The Train of Thought was first mentioned in one of the first scenes of the movie, so this would be considered a Chekhov's Gun rather than a Deus ex Machina.
This was one of the first CinemaSins videos I ever saw, and that moment made it clear to me that these guys really aren't good at paying attention to the movie they're sinning
What's a Chekhov's gun
@@hearmeout1767if a gun is placed on the wall, it ought to be fired during the runtime of the movie. It’s the film nerd’s shorthand for set-up and pay-off, as the concept is especially important in film. Movies don’t have a lot of wiggle room, and everything needs to be important, so even small background things needs to be important to justify their presence. I.e, a gun hanging in the background at the beginning of the movie gets fired during the climax. Or, characters mention the Train of Thought in the beginning and ride it during a moment of action.
CinemaSins hated the representation in the movie because his only emotion is anger
No, it’s apathy. An angry person would at least care.
@@jexelbur6872 Real.
Don't forget disgust.
I hate that I have something in common with cinemasins.
If he acted this negatively to Inside Out, what's he gonna be like when he sins Inside Out 2?
Inside Out honestly has one of the best Pixar themes. Right up there with Incredibles
Both composed by the same dude who also did Up
@bullwinkle524 incredibles 2 was also a amazing movie
@@grantpowell4135I wouldn’t call it amazing
@The_Trident_Master really the animation style is top tier. On top of that Pixar adding the fine details like shadows and water effects. What part didn't you like.
@@grantpowell4135lazy movie imo
The fact that "Everything Wrong With" shortens to "Eww" is too funny to me XD
I don't think the parents "in charge emotions" are meant to signify anything bad about their characters (i.e. the mum is sad or dad is angry). Not only are their control rooms neater with the emotions sitting around and seemingly working well together, but we know from Riley's hockey game in the second movie that emotions aren't exactly literal.
During the hockey game, anger is in control for a moment, but it seems less that she actively becomes angry and more just very determined. So I think Sadness being the mum's "in control emotion" is less that she's sad and more that she's sensitive, well meaning, fairly mild, whilst dad (with anger in control) is more proud, boastful and headstrong. With someone as young as Riley in the first movie, sure, take the emotions as literally as you want, but the older folks definitely have more nuanced emotion.
Considering at the end of the movie, it's shown that Riley expressing Sadness brings the people she loves closer to her to comfort her, it could also mean that Mom is a bit more tender and empathetic.
That's very well put!
Precisely
well put and I believe that's how emotions tend to be irl as well.
The thing with only five emotions also has another explanation: in psychology Joy, sadness, anger, disgust and fear are the 5 primary emotions that humans gain after birth and all the other emotions (called secondary emotions) come later in life and are usually a mixture of one of these five. There's also the sixth one that's surprise, but I guess it would've been hard to implement in the movie...
You're right. Pixar worked with psychologists while making this movie. So Jeremy is literally sinning scientific research. Besides, in early drafts of this movie Surprise was implemented but was later cut because she was too similar to Fear.
Well They removed Surprise because they think it doesn't exist and is just Fear
0:58 You know, I don't think I've ever seen Cinemasins tackle a completely silent movie. I mean, wouldn't it be perfect? No narration, no exposition, the audience just has to watch the movie to get it and can't turn their brains off. Ah, wait, Cinemasins' audience does have to turn their brain off to watch their videos, so I guess this wouldn't really work.
Didn't a lot of silent movies have text for people to read?
Cuz he would be sinning the shit outta that
@@dammagrilla Some of them did, but I personally haven't watched any of those, so I can't say for certain which ones.
That would be the majority of Wall-E
@@pietrocatalano4285 I know I've seen some silent films with them, no idea how widespread that was
It was meant mainly as a joke about CinemaSins and how they craft their 'sins' since they also sin movies for utilizing text
Everything Wrong With "Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat"
This entire EWW really was just Jeremy sinning Riley for being Riley, wasn't it?
Pretty much
Hope he doesn’t ever have a daughter if he doesn’t have one now. He’d probably hate her
By the way, this is so real in real life. We disagree and argue with people, but we forget that the things we argue about are parts of what they are. So sometimes we just dislike people for being themselves, but we don't admit it.
I saw this video some time ago where a girl said that she partially blames Cinema Sins' impact on the reason why media literacy seems to terrible now...and this video adds fuel to that fire because my goodness...he completely missed the main message of the whole movie when he said Joy was the only good emotion.
I blame him, too. Fifteen years ago, if a movie isn't well loved, it's forgotten very shortly, like Tim Allen's "Zoom". Nowadays, it's needlessly ridiculed and mocked for months on end. What happened during that time that effected multiple people in such a way?
9:55 if anyone’s wondering, the coloured letters spell out “this is a metaphor”.
I genuinely cannot comprehend thr plane of existence cinemasins is on. Like, legitimately.
Maybe they do too much of the 840 (just divide by 2 to get what I mean)
1:19 Okay, so regarding this sin, the movie shows later on that the older a memory gets it begins to fade and trying to play it back becomes increasingly difficult, to straight up impossible. Once that happens, the faded memories are then thrown away into the memory dump and eventually vanish. So, this entire sin by Jeremy is pointless.
something something "jeremy doesn't edit his sins when he receives an answer to his questions that are somehow sins cliche ex machine"
What I love about the emotions as a whole, is that these aren’t the only 5 emotions Riley can feel, they are able to kinda combine in a way to do other emotions (at least, a headcanon)
Joy and anger could make competitive for example
This Prometheus school of running trope needs to die. Basically what Jeramy is saying is that people have to be thinking clearly in a very stressful situation where they have to run for their lives in a life threatening situation.
That thought needs to die in general. “Why is the terrified schoolgirl going into the dark basement if a serial killer is chasing her?” I don’t know bro, how much logical function did YOU have left when you were being chased by a serial killer??
@@eileensnow6153 , there's three different types of adrenaline 1. The flight response which the one I have where run immediately away from the large animals like a bear 🐻 🐻 or boar 🐗 🐗. 2. The fight response where most Europeans fight off the wild animals, and 3. Freezing in place like deers, so the fact that Jermery fails to understand that is completely ridiculous on his part.
Exactly, when you have something bearing down on your your fight or flight instinct is stuck in flight to get the heck away from the something.
@@eileensnow6153 That is the exact reason I HATE those "How to defeat/escape (thing) in (movie)" because it's always some complex, detailed plan that you definitely wouldn't be able to do if you were actually in that scenario.
So for this part 12:08 I remember that someone made a response to this video way before you did and they brought up a really good point for this part.
They said that, even if they won’t kill off joy, her being stuck down there has major consequences that could be potentially life ruining.
If Joy isn’t there to make Riley happy that could cause things like depression or maybe even worse.
And if sadness isn’t there either, it can make it hard for Riley to feel empathy or cry, and potentially mess her up mentally.
Let’s not forget that Riley is literally running away up to this point on a bus when this is all happening, so can you imagine if joy and sadness didn’t get back in time?
Like literally when they get back sadness helps Riley realize how much of a big mistake she’s making and goes back to her family, and joy helps her realize how much she loves her family and how much she’s happy to see them.
It’s almost like CinemaSins just doesn’t wanna really pay attention, which is all the more funny when he acts like he’s making movies better and calling out Hollywood.
And if you’re curious to who said this good point, I think the name of the channel was captain vader.
Channels like his and movie studios basing their whole movie mindsets on their "reviews" have ruined many movies over the past 6 years
Fun fact: The selling of popcorn took off because the original way they made popcorn was able to mask the smell of drugs being sold in the dark theatres.
were drugs weaker then?
@@CrackedPropaneYeah like all drugs were made stronger then they were in the past.
@@CrackedPropane , I don't know about all movie theaters, but the theaters where I live at sells alcohol, and the popcorn 🍿 🍿 that's sold there masks the smell of booze people drink whenever they watch films alone or with their family.
@@CrackedPropane no, it was just that the scent was stronger and able to mask them
The scent of popcorn is now just a spray which wears off, but it used to stick around
2:16 "No other emotions [...] like logic." Jeremy. Logic isn't an emotion. It's quite the opposite of an emotion.
"Facts don't care about your feelings"
@@dhans9662Based.
I'm not surprised Jeremy is unfamiliar with how logic works.
Well how could he possibly know what logic is, he’s never used it in his life
Well now I'm just picturing a little cartoon Spock showing up to shove the emotions out of the way.
Jeremy is mad that the movie wasn't literal brain cells sending electric signals to each other.
He'd whine about that, too.
Let's be honest here. Jeremy's ideal film has no characters, no setting, no dialogue, no conflict, no PLOT, and no resolution.
It's just a blank screen.
@@ohilevoeauca789and even that movie would be sinned because he wouldn’t know what’s going on
9:55 like the creativity of using the coloured letters of ur subtitles to spell out "This is a metaphor." Very subtle
That jab at the end towards Critical Drinker and Nerdtronic was just *chef's kiss*, also i dare you to tackle Jeremy's video on Nimona, also someone tell Lee of CinemaWins to cover that film and GDT's Pinocchio
Oh dear God WTF did he say about nimona
Was so happy to see that, those two are a cancer to good film review/criticism on UA-cam
@@therondanielson9962I don’t know about the other guy, but I love Critical Drinker’s reviews. I can’t understand why people hate him besides politics. 🤷♂️
@@JamesP7 Well I think you've answered your own question there. Drinker's videos would be markedly better had he decided to stay out of the political realm, but that's what apparently makes him the most money, so here we are.
His videos are very thinly veiled racist, misogynistic and bigoted. He clearly doesn't like seeing Black people in prominent roles, dislikes non-straight people in film, and thinks anytime a woman is in a role that is less than a damsel in distress, she's a part of "The Message". How can anyone watch this perseverative rhetoric over and over and over without getting tired is beyond me.
@@Th3Birdman Idk why you’re parroting woke talking points, but ok.
Day 219 of telling th3birdman I appreciate his content
Day 5 of saying correct to you sir
Bro is consistent
I legit scroll until I see your comment, that's how I know I've read enough of them and can stop whenever
10:16 I honestly never got the joy and sadness being in the abstract room thing. I thought it was just a cool way of showing parts of Riley’s mind
CinemaSins doesn’t want to understand movies. They only want to mock them, and the only reason they remove sins on occasion is not due to the film’s actual quality but instead how popular a moment in the movie is with the audience.
Also, the reason Bing Bong has his name is because Riley was three when she made him. Toddlers don’t exactly have the most complex naming conventions.
I legit named my teddy bear “peek-a-boo” when I was three I think this says something
For anyone wondering, the colored lettters in 9:47 spell: 'This is a metaphor'
Me: sees the Birdman will sin a CinemaSins video on a movie about EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE
Also me: *gets popcorn ready* This'll be great
CinemaSins commentary sounds like he’s using his parents’ computer at 12 AM and is trying not to wake them up
This is an older CinemaSins video.
@@InfiniteFury2KSo?
I love how even the sound effects at the beginning are calm from the gorgeous theme of inside out
The fact that I giggled at the mental image of a Skittle on a plate scares me.
Hi, gen Z here, if someone unironically calls a hot dog a "glizzy" in my presence, they will no longer have the ability to call a hot dog anything by the time I've finished with them.
Thank you! I was trying to find another gen z who had no clue about people saying “glizzy” lol
Ain’t glizzy a slang term for a man‘s meat whip?
11:08 "You dream about acquiring intelligence?" Lmaoo 😂 Police, I'd like to report a murder 🤣😭
God the piano music always makes me tear up everytime i rewatch this movie
Hey. My IQ can't be counted on a Ninja Turtles hand! It can be counted on a cephalopods.
And Jeremy’s can be counted on a centipedes legs! We just might not use _all_ the legs
Then that creates the dilemma of whether you count each individual sucker as a finger
13:51 YOU KNOW HOW LONG I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR DIS?
9:29. I have seen this film multiple times and I just now realised the colours of the flower on bing bongs jacket are the colours of each emotion, nice detail animators o7
3:23 Jeremy says this despite the fact that they showed the islands are powered by core memories. And Riley gets all of her memories because of the emotions.
Welcome to another episode of „Oh my god Jeremy it‘s supposed to be a metaphor“!
The “These are the only emotions” sin pisses me off a lot for some reason.
I bet if there had been more emotions he would have complained about not being able to keep track of all characters.
Heck, that’s probably gonna be a sin in the Inside Out 2 video.
Jermery also hates flashbacks too, so I don't know really what he wants his games, films, and tv shows to have if people can't chat with each other like superhero films, and there isn't flashbacks to convey the convey the characters motivations.
He sinned the emotions one because he only has one.
Does Jeremy not know how fast the brain works? Of course Anger's newspaper would have no dessert. It was written by Riley's brain.
Your sixth Pixar video in the EWWCS saga, and I can tell you had some fun here and there while making this, especially when you drew a thick line through Riley's dad's mouth at 6:53 😂 I imagined his head flapping when I saw it!
I knew you would get that one, of all people haha
9:54 “This is a metaphor” In case you didn’t notice the colored letters in that sin. You’re Welcome
If my ability to recall things serves me correctly, the "triple dent gum" memory is a yellow memory, meaning it is a HAPPY memory. So yes, I do believe while she's humming that tune she is happy, as it would make sense for the happy memories to make you, well.. happy. How does Jeremy not even THINK of that?
1:44 holy shit I just thought I was really dumb for saying manga the first way, cuz I kept hearin ppl say “mayn-gah” and was starting to think that they were saying it right and I’m just really fucking dumb, thank you for making me realize I’m not losing my marbles
the beginning disclaimer is so funny, each color represents the emotions he actually has on that part of the disclaimer.
anger at the disclaimer cuz it’s goofy that he has to make it
anxiety from the “I love cinema sins” (he doesn’t he’s lying)
happiness for the “I am only” cuz it’s talking about himself
disgust at the “poking fun at” cuz it’s how he feels when ‘poking fun’ (he’s not poking fun he’s disgusted)
sadness at “some of”, cuz he’s probably gonna be making these for a long ass time
and fear at “their mistakes” cuz he’s scared at what future mistakes they will make
Love the energy and thought process put behind this. But the conclusions you came to are unfortunately wrong. Great hypothesis though.
@@Th3BirdmanIt’s the thought that counts, like we love to give more understanding on things that aren’t intentional for the artist. 😅
One thing I'd like to point out that I think was a fantastic detail in the movie (and is one I see that people misinterpret entirely too often.) is the emotions that Riley's parents are led by. It's a representation of how our emotion's roles become more complex over time, as we do with age. As a result, Riley's mom isn't led by Sadness, but Empathy, and Riley's father isn't led by Anger, but by Protectiveness. (Or masculinity if you wanna go down that route as I think that Riley's dad is a positive example of such.) I'm tired of people trying to posit that Riley's mom is depressed and Riley's dad is abusive because they clearly aren't. It's even more braindead to see these takes when you see Riley's sadness take on the role of empathy IN THIS MOVIE.
The writers of the movie said that the only reason they made two of Riley's emotions male was just that they thought it was funny.
3:13 since when is "hockey" an emotion 🤣
Even if you want to argue that CinemaSins is all in good fun, I don't see the fun of sins like the one at 2:35. There's no joke being made, they're just over-analysing a really funny sight gag. They're not adding anything to an existing punchline.
4:43 this did something that cinema sins never did. It made me LAUGH OUT LOUD 😂
That jab at Nerarodic and the Critical Drinker was genius!!!!!!
From what I know/understand, children go through childhood amnesia, hence why we do not remember anything from our childhood when we were like 5.
"1 positive emotion and 4 negative emotions"
Did Jeremy fucking WATCH the movie?
Of course not. He sinned it.
Watched? Yes...okay, well maybe. At the very least he had it on in the background while he played on his phone. Understood? Clearly not.
No
You know its a good day if birdman does your favorite movie
It baffles me how he managed to miss the entire point of the message. Like…it’s straight up trying to tell you that Riley can’t always be happy and that her other emotions are necessary to go through. How did he miss that!?
Jeremy out here acting like if every single emotion ever doesn’t have a little head critter to go with it, it means the emotion can’t exist. When the whole movie’s about them learning that emotions can work in tandem to create new thoughts and feelings (shown by the multicolored memory balls at the end). Plus him being like “how is she doing anything if your emotions aren’t driving” as if he’s never just felt kinda neutral before
The fact i laughed when he brought up the skittle on the plate. my humor is in shambles
I know many ppl hate broccoli. I personally have no problem with it, in fact I love it. I think Jeremy fails to take into account that other people have different preferences.
Birdman tears CinemaSins a new one from the inside out
I can kind of agree with the logos sin, since too many logos makes me go “start the movie”. But Disney logos? Those are always a must. It’s not an animated Disney movie without that castle.
And it's not a Marvel movie without those comics
And it's not a Pixar film without the lamp
I honestly hate how he sins the logos for just existing, like you said if they were overly long logo sequences that stretch out the runtime it makes sense to sin that, but he sins all logos no matter if they are there for 2 seconds or 2 minutes.
@@shinyagumon7015 , I only hate logos if the film or tv series has the logos lasting from 10 to 30 minutes, but since I've never seen any movies or tv series with extremely long logos screen I don't hate logos at all like Jermery does.
Most logos are boring but the Disney castle is the goat
8:34 This rant has been rent-free in my brain ever since I first heard it 😂
I honestly can't believe he sinned this beautiful movie.I think he should leave animation alone.
8:29 I'm a gen z and I say hot dog,not glizzy.
Someone else asked this in the comments and I think this is a great idea.
Everything wrong with cinemasins:Titanic
Also the reason riley sounded happy when singing the gum commercial is because it's a happy memory.
Whilst I'd use Jon Stewart's joke about "Deep Dish Pizza" being a casserole (Wtf Chicago?)
Jeremy's entire ignorance on emotions "One positive, 4 negative" which if you're younger I can understand that logic but ARRGHHHH
Cinema Wins' video on Inside Out is fantastic as it explains really well how here we see the film represent depression not as sadness as some erroneously think, but as absence of emotions.
I mean wasn’t Riley like 3 or 4 years old when she had her imaginary friend? That could contribute to the ridiculousness of it. But yep still not as ridiculous as that fake ass laugh.
The Italians are gonna hate me for thinking those pizzas look good.
Tell them that you want a ketchup on pizza and they will kill you
Greetings from the Infinitiverse
4:44 I actually LIKE broccoli, but I HATE the idea of it on pizza… that’s just one of those mixes that should not exist.
The sin over Riley only having a small array of emotions is even more useless given inside out 2, the sequel movie, literally exists for the purpose of expanding Riley's emotional range
Just wanted to point out that 7:26 Riley is actually Gen Z. The first Gen Z was born in 1997 and I once made a theory that Riley is 11 years old and turns 12. The year is mostly between 2012 to 2014. I also met with a Pixar executive that told me that Riley was born around 2002. So she’s not a millennial she’s too young.
You can tell Jeremy didn’t take the film seriously because he puts Sadness as a negative emotion when the point of the story is to teach Joy that Sadness has just as important a role. Anger and Fear are the fight or fight instinct, while Fear also works for self-preservation, all of which are crucial to ongoing development and survival.
Promise us that when he makes Everything Wrong With Inside Out 2, you'll make your response to it your top priority.
Birdman that Korean pizza comment hurt. As someone who just went there for a month I thought that Korean pizza was garbage. I tried 3 diff places and all were amazing. The craziest flavor I had was bulgolgi, chicken, corn, red and green peppers, honey mustard and bbq. I ate all of that in one sitting. Absolutely amazing and you have to try it when you go
Did they sprinkle sugar on it? I heard they do that to some of their pizzas
Q and Steel were loyal…they were just loyal to Raheem and not to Bishop
Exactly
I've been waiting for you to do this one.
I still don’t get why Jeremy assumed she forgot the first day of school memory when it is NOT FADED
I won't lie. Joy was having a thrill ride with this video! And Disgust was outright READY!
9:47 I really like what you did with the captions here
The shot at critical drinker was so so appreciated. Thank you for the videos
Ngl, that intro hits h a r d
11:34 i actully love broccoli lol
12:21
Also, he’s not understanding the film. That memory of class isn’t something Joy found in the forgotten memories heap, that is the Core Memory that formed that started the whole mess and why Joy is even out of headquarters right now.
I'm a Canuck, and I'm really glad I watched this video in the privacy of my own home because when you said, "Jeremy sins Canadians" about the hockey thing, I hadn't expected that and I burst out laughing. That was a good one!
Will you give Jeremy a sin off for this being the only video where his laugh is genuine?
I've been waiting for you to cover this one
13:21 edging TF outta us
That hot dog clip is always funny 😂
6:49 is something cinemasins does often. Besides the “It makes sense to me” part
13:46 bro’s got beef with all grifters now🗿 respect
What are those channels?
@@Kirs.. Good question.
@@Kirs.. Nerdrotic and The Critical Drinker. They’re basically just grifter channels who embody the stereotypical movie critic bigot
I once read, I can't remember if it was a news story or something else, but basically, for the first Inside Out, they boiled it down to 5 emotions because there are 27 of them and they couldn't fit all of them in there and took them down to the most important ones for Riley's life SO FAR. Of course they added 4 more in Inside Out 2, which makes sense.
6:26 Also with how long it takes to get from San Francisco to Minnesota by car, odds are Joy and Sadness would have found their way back before Riley's family crossed the Minnesota state line.
12:21 To me, this reads as Jeremy asking why Riley would have forgotten the memory as if it was sent there like the other faded memories and not because it's a core memory that was in the bag when Joy fell down. It hasn't faded yet, so it isn't officially forgotten. Am I assuming Jeremy was too dumb to remember things that were outright stated and made obvious in the movie? Yes. The alternative is the usual gimmick of him just misrepresenting a scene to pad the run time
I assumed bing bong knew joy because he made Rilley happy soo he is most familiar with that emotion
Never watched Inside out, never planned to either tbh (was 17 when it dropped) but now I quickly watched it before watching your video and reeeaallly liked it. Gonna watch Inside Out 2 rn
I believe there’s a very popular fan theory that Riley might be enby
Maybe Riley was in a New York subway when she named her imaginary elephant friend
9:00 laughing just thinking about it
me too lmfaoo