Very sensible analysis..... comprehensive merits and demerits explained as per requirement categories. Indeed you have put in good efforts to make buying a suitable car easier.....based on specific needs.👍
Excellent choices. I would like to add Maruti Suzuki Ignis as a value for money city car. Great engine, good stability, hardly any body roll. Personally I have both Tiago and Ignis but Ignis within city is better and Tiago on highways is better.
Poor crash test safety rating, small fuel tank of 32 litres and rear shape were some reasons for dropping Ignis and preferring Tata Punch. Maruti parts quality has also deteorated over the years. The gear lever knobs of my 2 Dzires crumpled, rear plastic door handle broke, suspension gives up at about 50k km...Service centres fleece you.. just my observations, drove and owned nothing but Maruti in last 30 years
@@vipulgoelcs which city do you live in .. I am from Kolkata and traffic is quite heavy here.. avg speed is approx 20-30 kmph during peak hrs. But prompt start , good pick up from 0 is a good to have. In this low speed safety is not a big requirement. But small and compact and with good mileage is more preferable..
@@sudiptokundu3257 But when you have a car, u will definitely go for a ride out of city once in a while. If one want to have a secondary city car, then it's fine to ditch safety. But most ppl have single car.
@@phanindra40 well.. to be honest reliability, economy is on one side and safety is on the other side. If your car usage is not that frequent and highway usage is more than city usage go for an ultra safe car from house of Tata. But if you are relying on your car for your daily commute then you will perhaps feel the pinch in your pocket due to the high fuel usage and maintenance. Then probably a car high on economy is preferable. So all depend on your lifestyle and preferences!!
IGNIS has got 1 star in GNACP rating. That means It will not be allowed to be on the road in Europe, the US, etc. But for Indias, milage and features matter more than safety lol
Baleno over Altroz?? Well i respect your choice.. In my opinion - Altroz has to be the better one if one is buying for family.. it is as practical and spacious as Baleno.. infact it looks more practical considering its build quality (safety) .. The only edge i feel that baleno has over altroz is 4 cylinders.. Difference in the mileage is well compensated by other factors (build/premium look and style/stability/handling) in Altroz .. If baleno is 3.5/5. Altroz has to be 4.5/5
Using altroz bs6 phase 2 petrol from past 11 months Excellent car to drive.... Highway and city ..... Dynamics are soooooo good stability and handling are rock solid..... Engine is also refined and Torquay after bs6 phase 2..... But due to it's heavy weight... Baleno feels more faster in this segment.. but other than that it's very satisfactory that i choose altroz over baleno
For Family car safety rating should be the first priority I understand that Quid oil sump is made of Non metalic Composite material where as all other cars have metalic oil sumps.
I have tigor great riding quality, firm build best in class space chilled AC even at 45°c outside and good milage and best boot space of 420 ltr, I like the design compared to Amaze as it gives coupe shape back with top mounted Taillamp which visible from miles on Road
Rust sab hote hai, paint ki quality German brands me jyada acchi hai. Care aapko hi karni padegi German hogi to bhi. Humid area me rahate ho to rusting jyada hoti hai
From when did you start keeping safety rating 'aside' ? Now there is now no difference between you and other car enthusiasts recommendations. Strike out any car which is not safe and we will be left with very limited but the True options only ! And let that mindset be spread to every customer.
@@autocritic your words can save families, people's lives if you suggest safe cars only! Bcoz people make car buying decisions based on your words ! That is the value your knowledgeable words hold🙏 ! We may drive safe but others on road don't and can cause accident risking everyone's lives..
It's safer to switch from bike scooty to a car, any car, even paper thin cars are safer than scooty. Any advice that makes people switch from 2-w to 4-w is raising overall safety.
Best entry level car for both city and rural use is Maruti Spresso VXI Plus AMT. Instead of Alto, Celerio, even Wagon R, this is the best car with great ground clearance, good visibility, great driving position, good mileage, can be used rough. Next to this rang, its better to buy Punch, for bith city and highway.
@@ProfessorJack_IIM lmao Hyundai gets 2 by not even trying , this car was advertised to be safe for the first time by Hyundaicso it should be ATLEAST 3 , I'd go with 4.
Hi Auto Critic, What is best car in term of Highway and City both considering safety comfort and space? Tata Tigor, Punch, Altroz , Nexon? or any other car?
I have been using tigor petrol automatic since 4 years, and i absolutely love it because you dont have to wait in long queues for cng, petrol almost no queue in city limits, for intercity travel as well cng pumps are limited Also engine gives good performance on hill drives which is essential when you will do intercity travel, especially with more people And lastly my car is always parked in the sunlight on the street so i feel cng tank may get very hot and poses a risk Consider these points before making final choice All d best😄
PLEASE SUGGEST: I20 asta (around 10L) and toyota glanza v (around 10.50L) petrol Manual.......which one to buy...... Situation: 1. I want a car for a family of 4-5 people. Will own it for long term say 8-10 yrs. 2. Upgrading from alto k10 2011 model. Yes, I've had that car for more than 12 yrs now. (1st hand). 2. I have test driven baleno and i20 both. I20 feels more premium. It has many features. It has sunroof as well. (Don't know if that would be useful or not). 3. Baleno feels less premium. It doesn't have any vibrations but i20 is better in terms of vibrations and engine refinement I guess. 4. Engine- I think engine is obviously better for baleno since it provides better power with a better mileage. 5. Long term built issues - what i have noticed from owning k10 alto for so long is that the long term durability of the built of maruti cars is not that great....awaz aaney lgti hai fittings mein se.....unecessary vibrations shuru ho jati.....ia hyundai better in terms of build? Particularly these two? I am more inclined towards i20 coz of features and build....but is it worth compromising on the mileage and engine of baleno? PS- Why have i written glanza in heading is coz looks are important to me and if i drop the idea of buying i20 i would go for glanza and not baleno. Also- Hows the after sales service of toyota?
Go with Tiago NRG xz model. Ex showroom price is 7.26. Ground clearance is 181. Excellent features of a fully loaded car. No doubt you will enjoy the ride with 4 star safety rating
good choices, well explained, soft speaking. subscribed 🎉 and followed . looking for a second car for city drawing but automatic. budget constraints. please suggest or make video for exclusively automatic cars city driving. thanks
I planned to buy amaze but disappointed with new ncap rating. Budget is for amaze range Safety Mileage Rattling sound nhi ho Please suggest if amaze is still better than other cars in this segment??
EXTER is not COMFORTABLE as much as PUNCH for 5 HEALTHY PERSON and SUSPENSION are way better of PUNCH and SEATING HEIGHT is Very low in EXTER if compared to PUNCH 👊
Honda amaze 2019 model 116000 km running jisme 56000 cng pe running osm mileage very smooth drive ek cylinder mileage highway on ac 250 se 290 tak aur local 200 se 225 tak aur ye mera 1 year experience he cng ka
सर मैं यही दोनों कार ही देख रहा था कुछ दिनों से लेकिन अभी 1 महीने पहले मैं एक्स्टर ली क्योंकि एक्स्टर अभी अभी लॉन्च हुई है लेकिन उसमें वही नियोस वाला इंजन आता है जोकि ट्रस्टेड है और ग्राउंड क्लीयरेंस काफी अच्छा मिला मुझे इसमें इसीलिए मैंने यह ली मैं मेरी फैमिली के साथ पांच लोगों के साथ यह गाड़ी चलाता हूं लोग कहते हैं कि दब जाती है नीचे से लेकिन सिर्फ दिखने के लिए दबती है अंदर फेंडर के अंदर बहुत जगह है एक महीना हुआ है मुझे लिए हुए और 1100 किमी चलाई है आज तक कितने भी खराब रास्ते में बड़े बड़े बम्प में कभी भी टच नहीं हुई नीयोस के कंपैरिजन में सस्पेंशन काफी अच्छे हैं बहुत कंफर्टेबल रहती है चलाने में
I think you are a super expert in this regards, so why don't you design a car which is perfect from all aspects. It is very easy to find out / analyses some machines pros and cons but very difficult to design a good one according to our expectation within a very affordable price bracket / safety / fuel economy....etc...etc...
Sir I have purchased Tata Punch accompolished 10 days back. Earlier anti theft immobilizer light was not blinking. Now it keeps on blinking even when car is off. Kindly guide if it is normal? If not how to stop it from blinking.
Very sensible analysis..... comprehensive merits and demerits explained as per requirement categories. Indeed you have put in good efforts to make buying a suitable car easier.....based on specific needs.👍
Excellent choices. I would like to add Maruti Suzuki Ignis as a value for money city car. Great engine, good stability, hardly any body roll. Personally I have both Tiago and Ignis but Ignis within city is better and Tiago on highways is better.
But what about the cheap plastics in Ignis?🤔
Poor crash test safety rating, small fuel tank of 32 litres and rear shape were some reasons for dropping Ignis and preferring Tata Punch. Maruti parts quality has also deteorated over the years. The gear lever knobs of my 2 Dzires crumpled, rear plastic door handle broke, suspension gives up at about 50k km...Service centres fleece you.. just my observations, drove and owned nothing but Maruti in last 30 years
@@vipulgoelcs which city do you live in .. I am from Kolkata and traffic is quite heavy here.. avg speed is approx 20-30 kmph during peak hrs. But prompt start , good pick up from 0 is a good to have. In this low speed safety is not a big requirement. But small and compact and with good mileage is more preferable..
@@sudiptokundu3257 But when you have a car, u will definitely go for a ride out of city once in a while. If one want to have a secondary city car, then it's fine to ditch safety. But most ppl have single car.
@@phanindra40 well.. to be honest reliability, economy is on one side and safety is on the other side. If your car usage is not that frequent and highway usage is more than city usage go for an ultra safe car from house of Tata. But if you are relying on your car for your daily commute then you will perhaps feel the pinch in your pocket due to the high fuel usage and maintenance. Then probably a car high on economy is preferable.
So all depend on your lifestyle and preferences!!
Been using Tigor since a while and I personally recommend everyone that it is the best possible option out of all these
Me too,
Except engine, I like everything abt it
bro what about ground clearance is it ok ?
Tiago
Tigor
Altroz
Punch... ❤❤
Is tata tiago Amt worth buying?
Ignis is the best budget car under 7L with massive discounts, greatmileage, 4 cylinder. No regrets buying IGNIS
Absolutely
IGNIS has got 1 star in GNACP rating. That means It will not be allowed to be on the road in Europe, the US, etc. But for Indias, milage and features matter more than safety lol
Perfect Analysis for Honda Amaze of which im a proud owner past 5 years,hassle free,premium feel,strong body,nice service by dealership.
Strong body? Honda Amaze has got 2 star rating. But yes better than Maruti cars.
I have booked tata punch adv rythem ing. Im confused, should I wait for new facelift or go with existing model?
What's ur view on Fronx...
Baleno over Altroz??
Well i respect your choice..
In my opinion - Altroz has to be the better one if one is buying for family.. it is as practical and spacious as Baleno.. infact it looks more practical considering its build quality (safety) ..
The only edge i feel that baleno has over altroz is 4 cylinders..
Difference in the mileage is well compensated by other factors (build/premium look and style/stability/handling) in Altroz ..
If baleno is 3.5/5.
Altroz has to be 4.5/5
@@hardikkataria7615 Tata's build quality is poor. You will realise after 3 years.
Using altroz bs6 phase 2 petrol from past 11 months Excellent car to drive.... Highway and city ..... Dynamics are soooooo good stability and handling are rock solid..... Engine is also refined and Torquay after bs6 phase 2..... But due to it's heavy weight... Baleno feels more faster in this segment.. but other than that it's very satisfactory that i choose altroz over baleno
Thanks bro, I am going to buy Tigore now.
For Family car safety rating should be the first priority
I understand that Quid oil sump is made of Non metalic Composite material where as all other cars have metalic oil sumps.
Excellent 👍
Hilly areas k liye b batao
One cannot keep safety rating aside.. because being alive is important to drive a car 😅
Tell that to millions of two wheeler commuters
@@Jannat-io3xe Tarzan ke car ko ek bhoot bhi chala sakta tha
After seeing many comparison i can say this video is best.loved it ❤
Sir best resale value car other then wagon r (amt )
Bought Amaze CVT and Punch Pure in the last 5 months, after 30 years of Maruti cars. I live in Delhi, so CVT was preferred for convenience.
Suzuki fronx price at 8.4 lac delta manual petrol, is it a good buy?
best video i have ever seen, related to car purchasing guide
Why Hyundai i10 nios is not in this list
Feature + gear box + price makes it worthy to be in this list
I have tigor great riding quality, firm build best in class space chilled AC even at 45°c outside and good milage and best boot space of 420 ltr, I like the design compared to Amaze as it gives coupe shape back with top mounted Taillamp which visible from miles on Road
Need your comments on Tata chassis being prone to rusting. Is it still the case of have they improved it now.
Rust sab hote hai, paint ki quality German brands me jyada acchi hai. Care aapko hi karni padegi German hogi to bhi. Humid area me rahate ho to rusting jyada hoti hai
I have tigor and believe me its a best car under 10 lakh
From when did you start keeping safety rating 'aside' ? Now there is now no difference between you and other car enthusiasts recommendations.
Strike out any car which is not safe and we will be left with very limited but the True options only ! And let that mindset be spread to every customer.
I agree with your point
@@autocritic your words can save families, people's lives if you suggest safe cars only! Bcoz people make car buying decisions based on your words ! That is the value your knowledgeable words hold🙏 ! We may drive safe but others on road don't and can cause accident risking everyone's lives..
It's safer to switch from bike scooty to a car, any car, even paper thin cars are safer than scooty. Any advice that makes people switch from 2-w to 4-w is raising overall safety.
What car did Princess Diana die in? Safety is how you drive, not what you drive.
Bhai city ke andar drive krne me utna safety issue matter nhi krta. Any small car is better than 2 wheelers.
Why you not include grand i 10 nios
Your opinion on Hyundai Aura? Isn't it affordable and feature rich.
Exter is a better option.
Very Good analysis. Amazing. Excellent technical info for common people. Easy to understand
Thanks ,its as informative as needed!
Very good summarize all categories of car
Guys suggest an economical car...which runs 100km every day!!!
Why did you miss out Maruti S-presso bellow 8l & Nissan Magnite 1 lt turbo AT/ CVT
Celerio offers more features than spresso
The Kiger AMT RXL non-turbo variant has not been mentioned.
Ignis❤❤
Been a Tata owner for the past 10 years and now I don’t even feel like using any other brand
Tata ka after sales kharab hai sunaa hai??
@@poison_kettle this is just targeted hatered. It's more than 13 years using tata cars and fully satisfied except some niggling issues
Sir tiago kaisi car h.
Best entry level car for both city and rural use is Maruti Spresso VXI Plus AMT. Instead of Alto, Celerio, even Wagon R, this is the best car with great ground clearance, good visibility, great driving position, good mileage, can be used rough. Next to this rang, its better to buy Punch, for bith city and highway.
Gareebo ka suv s presso
I booked exter, is it a good choice?
Amazing car
@@sahtarwars8386 Not a solid safe car. It's based NIOS platform and they have jacked it up. My guess would be 2 stars at best
@@ProfessorJack_IIM lmao Hyundai gets 2 by not even trying , this car was advertised to be safe for the first time by Hyundaicso it should be ATLEAST 3 , I'd go with 4.
What about Tiago AMT? Is there a problem with Tiago AMT? Please respond
What's your views about grand i10 nios.. Should i buy it, as i am planning to..pls rply
Go for it, i also purchased it and it is best.
Hi Auto Critic, What is best car in term of Highway and City both considering safety comfort and space?
Tata Tigor, Punch, Altroz , Nexon? or any other car?
How is tigor cng automatic? I need cng automatic. Want to keep for long time
I have been using tigor petrol automatic since 4 years, and i absolutely love it because
you dont have to wait in long queues for cng, petrol almost no queue in city limits, for intercity travel as well cng pumps are limited
Also engine gives good performance on hill drives which is essential when you will do intercity travel, especially with more people
And lastly my car is always parked in the sunlight on the street so i feel cng tank may get very hot and poses a risk
Consider these points before making final choice
All d best😄
@@ClintonGajmal how is rear seat cooling and space for 3 persons
When will they update Honda amaze ? Any idea ?
This year
Why is kiger not included in the list?
How about suzuki EEco 5 seater Ac ?
PLEASE SUGGEST:
I20 asta (around 10L) and toyota glanza v (around 10.50L) petrol Manual.......which one to buy......
Situation:
1. I want a car for a family of 4-5 people. Will own it for long term say 8-10 yrs.
2. Upgrading from alto k10 2011 model. Yes, I've had that car for more than 12 yrs now. (1st hand).
2. I have test driven baleno and i20 both. I20 feels more premium. It has many features. It has sunroof as well. (Don't know if that would be useful or not).
3. Baleno feels less premium. It doesn't have any vibrations but i20 is better in terms of vibrations and engine refinement I guess.
4. Engine- I think engine is obviously better for baleno since it provides better power with a better mileage.
5. Long term built issues - what i have noticed from owning k10 alto for so long is that the long term durability of the built of maruti cars is not that great....awaz aaney lgti hai fittings mein se.....unecessary vibrations shuru ho jati.....ia hyundai better in terms of build? Particularly these two?
I am more inclined towards i20 coz of features and build....but is it worth compromising on the mileage and engine of baleno?
PS- Why have i written glanza in heading is coz looks are important to me and if i drop the idea of buying i20 i would go for glanza and not baleno.
Also- Hows the after sales service of toyota?
@@Tts60253 After sales service of Toyota is excellent and Glanza V is a good choice in my opinion, as I have one and it gives very good performance
But safety rating of Glanza is like zero. That is one aspect to be considered while buying a car
“Amaze” but it doesn’t amaze me at all
In automatic, there is no choice except for Amaze CVT.
Most underrated car Ignis
.... and also the best
Celerio vs Wagonr which is better, highway plus city drive???
Go for Tiago CNG
Where is ignis n altroz,..??
1) TATA TIAGO
2) wagon - R
3) CELRIO AMT
__________________
4) tata tigor
5) honda amaze - update coming
__________________
6) EXTER
7) tata punch -
8) BALENO - NO. 1 CHOICE / fronx
___________________
9) KWID AMT
10) alto AMT
________________
11) wagon R
12) Baleno - SAFETY ZERO
________________
City and HIGWAY CAR
13) punch
14) AMAZE
15) togor
________
HIGHWAY
16) amaze
Loved the content & efforts you put to make categories and accordingly placing those vehicles is flawless
Thank you
Good work 🎉🎉
Kwid AMT doesn't hv crawl function and also no option to switch to manual gear, alto k10 amt is better option
रेनोल्ड ट्राइवर & काइगर?
What about i10?
Tata Punch the best car performance wise
Magnite bhi list me hai
My budget is 7 to 7.50 which can buy punch or grand i10
Go with Tiago NRG xz model. Ex showroom price is 7.26. Ground clearance is 181. Excellent features of a fully loaded car. No doubt you will enjoy the ride with 4 star safety rating
Is Tiago not good for both city and highway?
good choices, well explained, soft speaking. subscribed 🎉 and followed . looking for a second car for city drawing but automatic. budget constraints. please suggest or make video for exclusively automatic cars city driving. thanks
Good vedio, need a detailed vedio on amt with hillhold gear system
I planned to buy amaze but disappointed with new ncap rating.
Budget is for amaze range
Safety
Mileage
Rattling sound nhi ho
Please suggest if amaze is still better than other cars in this segment??
Sir kya Tata 2024 me apna rusting issues p koi kaam kiya ?
Sir triber is not best cat plz
Should i buy triber because my budget is tight plz suggest me should I buy
Triber sir ? why not included - considering space
What about Nissan Magnite CVT? Can you comment on this please?
Bhaiya tigor me tyre puncture ka koi issue hai kya???
Pichle 3 saal se to face nahin kiya tyre related issue
Ignis laughing in corner😂
Same here
Tigor is the best 🎉🎉🎉
tata needs to improve its logo
EXTER is not COMFORTABLE as much as PUNCH for 5 HEALTHY PERSON and SUSPENSION are way better of PUNCH and SEATING HEIGHT is Very low in EXTER if compared to PUNCH 👊
Wagnor a bs car.. but Indians cannot outof the box .. comfort is important and engine performance is crucial for city roads
Just couldn't understand you didn't add Magnite, kiger, in this list
Very practical video for everyone who wanted to upgrade from old vehicle ❤❤❤❤❤
No ignis??
i wish to go for dca under 13 lakhs, please suggest a comfortable car fro a family for 3 members
Altroz DCA
The comfort Tata gives, no one else can
Honda amaze 2019 model 116000 km running jisme 56000 cng pe running osm mileage very smooth drive ek cylinder mileage highway on ac 250 se 290 tak aur local 200 se 225 tak aur ye mera 1 year experience he cng ka
Amage me company fitted cng aata hai kya??
@@mrjj6887no, dealer fitted
Bro u forgot Nissan magnite
Whats the best between Grand I 10 Nios or Exter??
I10 brother
सर मैं यही दोनों कार ही देख रहा था कुछ दिनों से लेकिन अभी 1 महीने पहले मैं एक्स्टर ली क्योंकि एक्स्टर अभी अभी लॉन्च हुई है लेकिन उसमें वही नियोस वाला इंजन आता है जोकि ट्रस्टेड है और ग्राउंड क्लीयरेंस काफी अच्छा मिला मुझे इसमें इसीलिए मैंने यह ली मैं मेरी फैमिली के साथ पांच लोगों के साथ यह गाड़ी चलाता हूं लोग कहते हैं कि दब जाती है नीचे से लेकिन सिर्फ दिखने के लिए दबती है अंदर फेंडर के अंदर बहुत जगह है एक महीना हुआ है मुझे लिए हुए और 1100 किमी चलाई है आज तक कितने भी खराब रास्ते में बड़े बड़े बम्प में कभी भी टच नहीं हुई नीयोस के कंपैरिजन में सस्पेंशन काफी अच्छे हैं बहुत कंफर्टेबल रहती है चलाने में
If I have a budget of 8 lakhs, then Tata Tigor is my pick
Punch is built on a better platform, is safer and is more contemporary. High ground clearance has its advantages.
Tata Tiago NRG
Confused between Punch and Tigor. Both are good!
You will get better handling, corner stability and mileage on Tigor!!
इससे बेहतर तुलनात्मक अध्ययन करते हुए किसी को नहीं सुना❤
Did you miss out on Maruti IGNIS? IGNIS 1200 CC 4 cylinder, with 180 mm Ground clearance. Even the build Quality is good $afety rating
100 percent
I think you are a super expert in this regards, so why don't you design a car which is perfect from all aspects. It is very easy to find out / analyses some machines pros and cons but very difficult to design a good one according to our expectation within a very affordable price bracket / safety / fuel economy....etc...etc...
I 10 nios is also as good as Tiago , better in quality , lesser in highway stability than Tiago , still better than celerio..
Sir I have purchased Tata Punch accompolished 10 days back. Earlier anti theft immobilizer light was not blinking. Now it keeps on blinking even when car is off. Kindly guide if it is normal? If not how to stop it from blinking.
Its normal
Renault kiger ❤❤
Top 5 automatic cars family/highway/city..under 11 lacks
I m waiting brother 🙏🏼😍
I20 sports ivt
Tata punch best
Tigor the perfect family car I agree
Sir ..I want to buy second hand Nissan Terrano,what about engine,is it worth to buy? will you please make video on this?I'm your subscriber..
Triber - Where is it?
I am planing for Tata Punch accomplished on June 2024. Should I get it or wait for its facelift?
@@Bodymechanic4552 did u buy?
Pehli baar m hi itna achcha laga video aapka..... a subscriber now
Altros is the best option???
3 cylinder junk 😂😂😂
धन्यवाद, क्या आप होंडा अमेज cvt का शहर और हाईवे पर माइलेज बता सकते हैं?
Safety more than a bike ,