The British were beginning to understand that Afghanistan was no easy place to rule. In the last two millennia there had been only very brief moments of strong central control when the different tribes had acknowledged the authority of a single ruler, and still briefer moments of anything approaching a unified political system. It was in many ways less a state than a kaleidoscope of competing tribal principalities governed through maliks or vakils, in each of which allegiance was entirely personal, to be negotiated and won over rather than taken for granted. The tribes' traditions were egalitarian and independent, and they had only ever submitted to authority on their own terms. Financial rewards might bring about co-operation, but rarely ensured loyalty: the individual Afghan soldier owed his allegiance first to the local chieftain who raised and paid him, not to the Durrani shahs in faraway Kabul or Peshawar. Return of a King (Dalrymple) Still true?
Hello, dear all. I’m from Afghanistan🇦🇫and unfortunately, all Afghans people lost their hopes by coming Taliban. Me as a 17 boy lost his all ambitions and I lived one year under the rule of Taliban and saw that they killed people as no one in the world is informed about and had very bad attitudes with the people. Please (Pray For My Home land)🙏🏻🙏🏻💔🇦🇫💔 Love from Pakistan.
Once I learned just how deep rooted and how far back Afghanistan problems have come... It is really hard to see how they are ever going to resolve ALL of them.
When I get to know about such situation I always think what I can do but I don’t know. So I’m going to learn about that in university. Send a lot of love from Japan
The poverty crisis in Afghanistan would be resolved if the US gave back the billions of dollars of Afghanistan wealth they withheld and then distributed amongst US citizens. This is a problem caused by the US
yeah give it all back so the Taliban can have it... the people never will.... wake up and stop blaming US for everything.. if people do not like their oppressive government... then rise up.. but stop telling the US to do it then complain when they leave and you can't take care of yourself...
Unfortunately, the Taliban controlled at least 70% of Afghanistan the entire time the US was there. This has been a forgone conclusion for a long time.
US didn't exactly take the wrong approach, it is and was a very difficult situation, as we can see Taliban can not be in power . US had to fight them in order to have any chance to change anything. Trump made deals with the Taliban , he destroyed this like everything else he touches.
❤️❤️❤️. Loved this Ted Talk 👏👏👏 my best friend was from kendahar .. he left in 1997 because of Tban .. I learned so much from my friend ... It's the ❤️ for real life to rise above harsh realities ... Tytytyty! Tashakur 🎉🎊
El dinero es un tema que todo el mundo tiene para una vida mejor y lujosa. la vida era difícil para mí hasta que comencé con Bitcoin y ahora estoy ganando $9500 por semana.
Como inversionista por primera vez, comencé a operar con la Sra. Sonia con solo mil dólares, ahora mi cartera vale $ 16,650 a las pocas semanas de operar con ella.
Many protested against wars and occupation and arrest...yet government of any sort of course full of arrogant idiots never ending. Yet some do like to pretend things of all sorts any how and vote like it matters when it seems mostly it doesn't with continued stupidity.
They but a few like to go to school and some lime it if the mob I mean such groups don't blackmail. Though don't know many not corrupt. If they act like Saudi Arabia with public whipping and beheadings with no more bombings and planes into buildings...and so on they should be fine.
I'm by no means defending Taliban but what the US, UN, and NATO did in Afghanistan is far worse than this and we don't see you talking about it. Heh freedom of speech you say
A physical wound caused by grief? Can we please stick to reality...It's difficult to take anything else you say seriously when you believe nonsense like that.
Islam is not represented by terrorism, but terrorists are hiding under Islam cover. Islam in Arabic language means peace but social media always tries to distort Islam, that's the thing that I didn't understand.
Hahahahahahahaha delusional. Joe Biden literally took Trump's plans and tried them his own and blundered the whole thing leaving the country in more dissaray than if all contengencies we're followed under Trump's plan.
Kiana says "Welcome the people" BUT she DID NOT QUOTE CHAPTER AND VERSE FROM THE TRUSTED SOURCES TO SHOW WHY THE TALIBAN (Student of Islam) acts the way they do!!!! SHE DOES NOT SAY WHETHER SHE IS AN APOSTATE, AND IF SHE IS WHAT IS THE PUNNISHMENT FOR BEING AN APOSTATE IN AN Islamic society!!! HAVING 4 WIVES AND OUT BREEDING ANY OTHER RELIGION. AFGHANISTAN WAS NOT ALWAYS Islamic!!!
America lost the war to the Taliban
It never seemed they wanted to stop fighting in the first place
The British were beginning to understand that Afghanistan was no easy place to rule. In the last two millennia there had been only very brief moments of strong central control when the different tribes had acknowledged the authority of a single ruler, and still briefer moments of anything approaching a unified political system. It was in many ways less a state than a kaleidoscope of competing tribal principalities governed through maliks or vakils, in each of which allegiance was entirely personal, to be negotiated and won over rather than taken for granted. The tribes' traditions were egalitarian and independent, and they had only ever submitted to authority on their own terms. Financial rewards might bring about co-operation, but rarely ensured loyalty: the individual Afghan soldier owed his allegiance first to the local chieftain who raised and paid him, not to the Durrani shahs in faraway Kabul or Peshawar.
Return of a King (Dalrymple)
Still true?
Did someone say otherwise?
War on terrorism and war on drugs ...no kidding.
I really dont understand people who DONT come to this conclusion
Hello, dear all.
I’m from Afghanistan🇦🇫and unfortunately, all Afghans people lost their hopes by coming Taliban.
Me as a 17 boy lost his all ambitions and I lived one year under the rule of Taliban and saw that they killed people as no one in the world is informed about and had very bad attitudes with the people.
Please (Pray For My Home land)🙏🏻🙏🏻💔🇦🇫💔
Love from Pakistan.
Once I learned just how deep rooted and how far back Afghanistan problems have come... It is really hard to see how they are ever going to resolve ALL of them.
When I get to know about such situation I always think what I can do but I don’t know. So I’m going to learn about that in university. Send a lot of love from Japan
So sad… poor people…
We don't live in a fair world.
emotional, whatever the reason or aim of these militants or armies are but suffer the people like Hafiza, may god bless us wisdom to be human
The poverty crisis in Afghanistan would be resolved if the US gave back the billions of dollars of Afghanistan wealth they withheld and then distributed amongst US citizens. This is a problem caused by the US
The US can't solve poverty whatever party is most in charge for itself... Ask native Americans.
Trump probably spent it all on a gold toilet
yeah give it all back so the Taliban can have it... the people never will.... wake up and stop blaming US for everything.. if people do not like their oppressive government... then rise up.. but stop telling the US to do it then complain when they leave and you can't take care of yourself...
and the reason this happens is because the people are uneducated, unarmed and controlled... sound like a familiar direction close to home??
@@rascaldere9327 you clearly don't know how economics work
This is beyond sad. When will the world learn to help us assist those in dire need such as the Afghan people? The US took the wrong approach.
Why should the US help them when they can’t help themselves? The US actually try to help but the Afghans fail them
Unfortunately, the Taliban controlled at least 70% of Afghanistan the entire time the US was there. This has been a forgone conclusion for a long time.
US didn't exactly take the wrong approach, it is and was a very difficult situation, as we can see Taliban can not be in power . US had to fight them in order to have any chance to change anything. Trump made deals with the Taliban , he destroyed this like everything else he touches.
@B G often charity in US is not government funded or many places. Try religious institution and Malala fund...
@@aaron-n I figured any groups of the like would run things. Wonder if they will make opium farms again.
Kiana you have done a great work
2022(G) “Respect and dignity.” Furthermore:
This hurts in my chest to watch.
I hope gdp might increase too one day
2:38
We all know who is to blame for the Taliban taking control of Afghanistan, again!
Yes, the Taliban?
❤️❤️❤️. Loved this Ted Talk 👏👏👏 my best friend was from kendahar .. he left in 1997 because of Tban .. I learned so much from my friend ... It's the ❤️ for real life to rise above harsh realities ... Tytytyty! Tashakur 🎉🎊
El dinero es un tema que todo el mundo tiene para una vida mejor y lujosa. la vida era difícil para mí hasta que comencé con Bitcoin y ahora estoy ganando $9500 por semana.
Wow, estoy feliz de escuchar a alguien mencionar y recomendar a la experta Sra. Sonia.
Como inversionista por primera vez, comencé a operar con la Sra. Sonia con solo mil dólares, ahora mi cartera vale $ 16,650 a las pocas semanas de operar con ella.
Puedes contactarla fácilmente en WhatsApp 👇👇
+175
4223
Thumbs down. It's not the Taliban. It's the fact that most Afghans are fundamentalist muslim. So, the Taliban is what most of them want. Sad but true.
What about the minority there that would like to be free like the west ?
Maybe do you SJWs only care about those living in your own country?
@Irish Witch yep activistic on poverty ...Saudi Arabia style?
not all of them but most of them
I got the privilege of feeding Afghan refugees on a couple military bases. Good people,and food!
If the people are good, then how come there is almost never peace there? For centuries.
This could be said good people every where and none want American tourist or staying in reality.
@@andreasv9472 so people cannot be both good and war against each other? Need to check your history again.
America could not Wipeout Taliban in 20 years and they say we have the best soldiers , equipment blah blah . Literally they induced this situation.
Had to wipe them out when they can flee into Pakistan
Many protested against wars and occupation and arrest...yet government of any sort of course full of arrogant idiots never ending. Yet some do like to pretend things of all sorts any how and vote like it matters when it seems mostly it doesn't with continued stupidity.
You should know what politics means. I mean " not to do what you promised and do what you forbade."
good
great vid, now do the b4..
"A Photographic Journey through the USA Invation of Afghanistan"
They don’t want Americans in afghan. Give it up
They but a few like to go to school and some lime it if the mob I mean such groups don't blackmail. Though don't know many not corrupt. If they act like Saudi Arabia with public whipping and beheadings with no more bombings and planes into buildings...and so on they should be fine.
Interesting contrast to some of the useful idiocy that goes on in the media suggesting the Taliban is somehow a good thing...
thank to the "religion of peace"
I'm so sorry. I did not do it. But we all did.
What about the photographic journey of the US and its allies taking over Afghanistan mines, pipelines, ports and runways?
Same with china too .
I really appreciate your honesty. The United States has stolen millions of dollars from Afghanistan under the pretext of fighting terrorism
This was uploaded today? Wow! truly sad.
💥
I'm by no means defending Taliban but what the US, UN, and NATO did in Afghanistan is far worse than this and we don't see you talking about it.
Heh freedom of speech you say
You can talk about this, go make a video. It's called freedom of speech.
What did they do?
I understand that you are special and have a high expand knowledge. Thank you for showing the truth.
All for one and one for All 🗝 that is our device ⚖️ is it not 🏴 …….
TED~What'up~ really unreal .goodbye!! ;)
A physical wound caused by grief? Can we please stick to reality...It's difficult to take anything else you say seriously when you believe nonsense like that.
she's saying that the doctor didn't want to say the truth
Islam in all its forms seems horrific, as exemplified by those Countries...
Islam is not represented by terrorism, but terrorists are hiding under Islam cover. Islam in Arabic language means peace but social media always tries to distort Islam, that's the thing that I didn't understand.
God Bless Joe Biden for getting us out of that horrible mess, after Trump sold out the country to the taliban.
Hahahahahahahaha delusional. Joe Biden literally took Trump's plans and tried them his own and blundered the whole thing leaving the country in more dissaray than if all contengencies we're followed under Trump's plan.
@@tylermiller6532 the only plans Trump had were to flush documents down the toilet 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@kbanghart oh yeah just as evident as all the allegations that fell flat on their nose. 🐽
@@tylermiller6532 oh, the ones that he took documents from the White House he shouldn't have?
Great job Brandon…
Kiana says "Welcome the people" BUT she DID NOT QUOTE CHAPTER AND VERSE FROM THE TRUSTED SOURCES TO SHOW WHY THE TALIBAN (Student of Islam) acts the way they do!!!!
SHE DOES NOT SAY WHETHER SHE IS AN APOSTATE, AND IF SHE IS WHAT IS THE PUNNISHMENT FOR BEING AN APOSTATE IN AN Islamic society!!!
HAVING 4 WIVES AND OUT BREEDING ANY OTHER RELIGION.
AFGHANISTAN WAS NOT ALWAYS Islamic!!!