Edwardo is a boy who is feminine. The fact he said he was scared in the gender clinic speaks volumes. How would you feel if one of your other children “came out” and said they wanted to get tattoos? Would you put fake tattoos on them for 3 years and then decide that’s all you can do and leave it to the experts (tattooists). There’s a reason why children can’t consent, and gender isn’t the exception. You are teaching him that only girls are feminine and only boys are masculine. He is 9 years old. Have you even took into consideration that he may be more feminine or feel like a girl because the first 4 years of his life he had 2 sisters? One of which (Emilia) he was very close to? He is a child, not a teenager, not a young adult a CHILD. I remember being 9 and for a few years I was a tomboy. I liked football, I cut my long hair off, I resented the fact I was going through puberty before my friends, I felt uncomfortable in my body and wished I could just be a boy. Interestingly enough, I grew out of it, I started to embrace being a girl and have grown up being one of the most feminine women you’d ever meet, comfortable and loving being a woman. Had my parents took what I said as a 9 year old literally, and not realised I was just uncomfortable being a girly girl I’d of been put on puberty blockers, and more likely than not be a “de-transitioner” now with my life ruined. Changing his name, and taking him to a gender clinic is setting him up to be a fucked up adult. Why not just embrace you have a feminine son, or a potentially gay son instead of pushing this liberal, dangerous and disgusting ideology onto a 9 year old. I used to watch you guys, and loved seeing your family grow and thought it was adorable seeing Eduardo be a sensitive soul who just loved playing with his sisters but you’ve took it too far. I’m not religious but I pray Eduardo doesn’t agree to his parents sick games for views and just embraces his individuality without ruining his life.
@@chronicallyella1191 slowing puberty can actually cause a lot of issues for the body because you’re disrupting the natural cycle, this is a child and they shouldn’t be playing Frankenstein with a child’s body and mind
And people are wondering why American are banning this. It’s because their not ready their little bodies can’t handle it. Wait till their older. Let them dress up act like a girl but don’t do something THIS big.
@@chronicallyella1191 I do wonder what comorbidity is occurring here. Being trans may be a symptom of another mental health issue, it may not, but we can’t assume that 40% died because they were trans when we don’t have all the info. Not to mention the correlation between trans and autism, I wouldn’t be surprised to find it linked to some other neurological disorder.
Agreed... I'm not transphobic in the slightest but to me something seems off with this... let children grow up just because they like girly things doesn't make them transgender..
Also agree and I even saw some videos when the kid was still a boy and she didn’t even look like she hated it and a child can’t make decisions like that
People who are born as girls can like "boyish" things and people born as guys should also be allowed to like "girly" things without changing their identity.
Seriously. I enjoy a lot more "male" hobbies then female ones. Some days I wear dresses but most I prefer sweat pants but I'm not a boy. These parents are sick
@Gf bunny squad dances! How do they know it will make them happy?! Medical procedures, let alone on going ones, are not "happy" experience, and they have major life consequences! It's not the same as saying "ice cream or a walk in the park makes them happy." Children know nothing about these things, neither do most adults. But adults can comprehend the emotional and physical consequences and have the development to take further action needed.
To the core it upsets me that Edie does not have her privacy. Even if she’s given the choice to have her story placed on the Internet, she certainly isn’t old or mature enough to understand the gravity of what that actually means.
I support transgender people. Nothing wrong with them. But it has to be a BIG, careful decision for a person privately. It is a big,life changing one. You have to be mature enough to understand it. Not like this. Poor child,his brain is not developed enough to understand such complex situation. It is a big deal for 20,30 olds. Child need his parents to survive,so he will do anything to keep them. It is as simple as that.
I agree she shouldn't have to deal with the whole world's opinion on her decisions. imagine how she will feel starting high school or uni. She may be a well transitioned women by then who doesn't want her childhood known...who just wants to be another girl starting uni😢 shame on her patents They need to read the article about exploration of children by Teen vogue
My heart hurts for this poor child. Being paraded on the Internet and gender clinics and being pressured by her mother. These are life changing decisions being made on a second grader. History will not look kindly upon this trend. Seeing an innocent child right in front of us and 20 years from now being depressed, infertile, angry, co fused and all the innocence taken away.
I'm feeling exactly the same about this :( And there's many more kids who get "treatments" like this that will make them end up as traumatized and mutilated adults. I feel so sorry for them. Truly man-made horrors.
forcing your child to grow up on the internet is evil. forcing your child to grow up on the internet and forcing them to be transgender is a whole other level of evil
*people please listen by going to the gender clinic they mean going to gender therapy to make sure being trans was what she wanted gender therapy is apart of the gender clinic children shouldn’t get surgery or those hormone things (I forgot what it’s called) until they are adults*
When I was that age all I wanted was to be a boy. I acted and dressed like a guy and would tell my parents I didn’t want to be a girl. For a few years. Probably because I grew up around boy cousins and my brother and felt left out. But suddenly I stopped wanting to be a guy and just forgot about it. I personally wouldn’t allow my child to make this permanent of a decision unless they’re an adult and still feel that is what they want. Kids are constantly changing and adapting to their surroundings.
Exactly my daughter dressed like a boy, wore hair like a boy till she was 12 then started dressing girly wearing makeup, kids go through phases doesn't mean they're automatically trans smh
I was the same way as a child. Wanted to be a boy for years until I was 13. I thought it was cool. Then all of a sudden I was content being a woman. Started dressing girly and feminine. Now I’m married with 3 kids. So proud and thankful to be a woman. If my parents were to have done this to me at such a young age I would never have forgiven them. Most children go through these phases. Please oh please wait!
I was in edie shoes once. From young age I wanted be a boy and made my mum call me aman. Soon as I hit 13 I didn’t want to be a boy anymore and went back to being a girl. Hope they wait till edie is older for anything drastic
I was the same way as a child. Wanted to be a boy for years until I was 13. I thought it was cool. Then all of a sudden I was content being a woman. Started dressing girly and feminine. Now I’m married with 3 kids. So proud and thankful to be a woman. If my parents were to have done this to me at such a young age I would never have forgiven them. Most children go through these phases. Please oh please wait!
As a subscriber since Anna’s first video and the inception of the channel I don’t watch much since the last year or so but thought I’d check in. I’m shocked that you, as parents, aren’t reading the comments from so many people that have supported this channel, helped build your small but noteworthy empire and ignore what so many people have to say. How do otherwise intelligent parents give so little respect to the privacy of your child who CLEARLY is going through what might be the biggest struggle of her lifetime. As a mom to 3 kids in their late teens/early 20’s it’s difficult to watch Edie become a poster child for trans kids. This is her story to tell, when she’s old enough to understand the consequences of putting such personal information on the internet- which remains forever. You both need to take a long look in the mirror and ask yourself if this is worth it. I promise you this will be your biggest regret. This will affect your relationship with your child when she is old enough to get it all. What your doing is selfish, sad and one day might constitute as abusive. I wish you all the best of luck, especially Edie.
As an original subscriber you might remember Anna stating she didn’t want kids. These poor kids are simply used as props for views. I implore anyone with decency to unsubscribe from these two narcissists who are abusing their power of parenthood as losing their audience is the only way they will ever stop this absolute evil.
Have no idea why this was recommended to me, but I’m completely grossed out. Not because this child is transgender, but because the parents are exploiting it on UA-cam. This child cannot give consent for this at this age. This should not be allowed on UA-cam!
Yes!! She can say that she's happy for it to be filmed and shared all she likes. But because of her age she literally cannot give full informed consent for this very personal stuff to be shared online for millions of poeple to see. I really really hope that this all works out well for her, otherwise her parents are going to have to live with their mistakes for the rest of their lives.
Рік тому+1
And all I wanted was a good recipe for scones 😅 But this was suggested.
If my child came out as trans at such a young age i would sit them down and ask why and then tell them that they shouldn't make that decision now and really shouldn't worry about gender just think of yourself as a human being i would ofc support the child but i will tell them that takes a really really long time to fully figure out as a girl who liked girls when i was really young and never came out untill i turned 14
This dad is living out his own fantasy. Look at his 'I'm coming out' video and this action will make a lot of sense. Also he'll do literally anything for clicks. Poor kid
Honestly, I feel like the mother is the one who is being very pushy on this, Jhonatan even showed the little kid a spider man's clothes while the mother quickly dissmissed him as " we came here for eddie "
How easy is it to manipulate a child: I'll take you to this uncomfortable thing and if you comply you can pick out anything you want from any store....95% of children will agree to this set up.
I wanted to be the opposite gender when I was a child. The same way Edie does. Wanted to be a boy for years. I thought it was cool to be a boy. Then I turned 13 and a switch flipped. All of a sudden I was content being a woman. Started dressing girly and feminine. Now I’m married with 3 kids. So proud and thankful to be a woman. I would never wish to be a man now. If my parents were to have done this to me at such a young age I would never have forgiven them. I wouldn’t be able to have the birth experiences I have had. And I wouldn’t have found my path of birth doula. Most children go through these phases. Please oh please wait. Edie isn’t old enough to understand. Don’t alter her forever.
Yes you were a tomboy and that's cool, nowadays they say tomboys are the opposite sex in their head and should be transitioned. World is crazy I can't wait for Jesus to come back and punish these people.
Omg same. I was saying to my boyfriend the other day if I had other parents i might have been turned into a boy because I liked playing sports, looked short hair, liked blue and said I wanted to be a dad. I'm very happy I'm a woman and I was able to have my babies
It is SHOCKING to me how little certain parents know about kid's basic development. First of all kids at this age like to experiment themselves and the world, and they like to act out possibilities. You just need to accept and guide them. I was a tomboy as a little girl, I hated pink, I wanted to climb trees, hop on a bike with my brothers. And thank God nobody forced me to change my gender, because I turned out as a beautiful, confident woman at the end, who still hates pink btw. 😀 And the other important lesson is that child would do anything for their parents attention and love. It is their way of suvival. They would give up themselves completely to please their mom or DAD. So if this kid feels he only gets the attention and love from mommy and daddy when he dresses in pink, and acts like a girl...' Mommy and daddy love me because they are cheeringly make videos about me and I'm their centre of attention"...(And also selling me online) You can all imagine how sick and twisted this story actually is... 🤯 Poor child.
100% as a parent we understand the extremes of the need to have attention at all cost. Snd bragging rights to say I was out in London having hot chocolate while yall were in school. Shame sickening
You hit the nail on the head. That’s not a little boy wanting to be a girl. That’s a little boy who is enjoying the attention from parents who probably spend more time on their devices than parenting.
@Coda24_24 I know they have only social transitioned, but I feel there will be quite a lot of mental health damage in their later life because of doing it at such a young age.
The monetisation of this young child's incredibly personal journey, the pressure it places on her in the supposed name of advocacy and representation is maddening. Jonathan and Anna, please reconsider your choice to share this with the world. It's short-term gains against a possible lifetime of resentment from your daughter. And it might have a massive impact on her life in future. She has the right to privacy.
They not only need to reconsider making it public, but reconsider it in its totality. There is no such thing as a transgender child. Children have no idea what they are getting into and they cannot consent.
Kid: “first appointment, there’ll be more” Parent: “yes, but it’s a good thing” Kid: “okay”. Talking about an appointment for a thing the child is said to want.
It just goes to show this child has absolutely NO idea what is going on. They think they go to ONE appointment and boom they’re magically a girl. It’s degrading and it’s disgusting
She said she was scared…turn the damn camera off! She is a vulnerable child, not just an entertainment prop! The fact that she didn’t even know there was going to be more than one session says a lot!
Where's UA-cam? Someone needs to protect Eduardo's privacy as a minor if his parents don't. It's just not right. And this is hard to say as I've watched and enjoyed this channel for MANY years, but Jonathan really you need to stop being so exuberant about this. It just makes my gut feel like you're living vicariously through Eduardo. Stop the TikTok, the stories and reels please. Let it go. Just let your family work through this privately. Filming this child going to a clinic!!! I'm shocked. This is exploitation in it's purest form.
@@kellyperez9676 whilst i agree they are probably using the kids for views etc, please be respectful and use the correct pronouns, gender and name for Edie! She is a kid who needs support if her story is going to be publicly shown💜💜
I think the child’s concern (and lack of knowledge) that there will be “multiple” appointments should be a major clue to the parents. This is a major decision, not to be made lightly. But, wait, I forgot that the parents are more concerned about money and fifteen minutes of fame.
I’m sorry what? Just to put it out there I’m a gay man, when I was a child I wanted to play with babies, Anastasia dolls anything girly and my parents allowed me to which is absolutely fine. Just because I like to do girly things doesn’t mean that my parents should have acted on changing my gender to match that, I was too young to understand anything so acting and being girly was as far as it went and should get to. I am glad I had that free rain to be who I was and made me realise when I was a teenager/ young adult I was happy to be me a man as I naturally got to experience puberty which makes you realise who you are. It’s disturbing seeing these children going through this and is actually irresponsible of the parents. Your kid wants to dress like a girl and buy girls toys, fine but going to a gender clinic is too much. It’s actually disgusting
Completely agree I'm glad you got to explore every aspect of yourself at your own pace they should let the boy enjoy his interests whatever they are but do not try to change his gender and convince him hes a girl and wants to be a girl this kid had absolutely no say in this and it shows
What you said 100% right It's completely fine for a boy to do girly stuff ...look at his father big smile . He so happy abouts ,excited even ... it makes me sick .
i agree with you 100 percent. If this child is gay, he may want to enjoy his male identity and remain very female in lots of ways. No need for gender clinic now. I agree with your statement about experiencing puberty...very good way to put it !! I am a straight female and i understand what you are saying....there's alot of common sense that these two youtuber parents are lacking. IMHO
The most frightening part is that child protection services will only aid them in their abuse. Their is literally No one to intervene for the child sadly😢
In the guise of wanting to be cool parents and fit in, you are running the very real risk of ruining your child's physical and mental health. Edie was scared and confused in this video, it's beyond sad
@@miac2382 our brains aren’t fully developed until we’re like 27… but even still, there are reasons you can drive until 16 or drink until 21. You can’t legally consent to sex until 18… but somehow you can consent sex change- absolute insanity and nothing short of child abuse.
If Edie wants to be a girl in life good luck to her, but it feels like a drastic life changing decision at this age. I’m a gay man who played with Barbies and dolls,my mother found me covered in her make up one time, but it didn’t mean being taken to a gender clinic and I’m glad it didn’t. Allow puberty to happen and the rollercoaster of hormones that comes with it. Your child still has plenty of time to figure things out, I’ve no issue with people transitioning, it must be a huge decision and terrifying to tell the world, (it was scary enough for me to come out as gay) but it just seems too early at this age.
I was a tomboy back in my childhood, dressed like a boy, played only with boys etc. You would never know that I was a girl back then! Sometimes I told my parents that I wanna be a boy, but it changed Now I am a grown woman, I’m not into makeup and stuff, but it doesn’t bother me at all, it’s not what life is about. Give this child chance to live through his development without crippling procedures!
Me too!.. I played with boys, loved playing football... but now love everything girly.. so glad, I had a free childhood, with no parents pushing things like this!.. kids change daily.. modern parents just do not allow their kids freedom now..
Exactly! I too was a Tom boy growing up. Loved playing with cars more than dolls. Wasn’t into make up when I was in my teens but I knew I was a girl and wanted to stay being a girl. I’m so glad there wasn’t social media and all the noise to influence my thoughts and create doubts in my mind about my sexuality. I love being a woman and love being a mother.
same! i grew up hating my barbies and playing with GI Joes in the dirt, was a tomboy for ages. Now, i stillreally enjoy 'male' things such as surfing, camping' outdoors stuff. does not mean i want to be a boy. i am happy to be a woman and i am a (not that it matters) heterosexual woman. this is insane
This child will be in therapy for the rest of their life wondering why their parents shared such intimate moments in their life with the whole world. Wondering if it was for the money, for the attention? Dang this is so sad.
I think in ten years we are going to be seeing a lot of the family vlogger kids grow up and realize they were just content /cash cows for their parents...how sad and challenging that will be once they realize they were just expl*ited for content
There's many kids who grow up messed up because they had parents who put money before their welfare.... and had parents who never were around due to always working and were only shown any attention by being bribed or gifted cash etc. What could be worse than that? Parents that only care about mone, more than your actual welfare, and use you as the means to make that money :(
I felt so sorry for Edie when she kept saying she was scared and was shocked when she had to go back for more this is ridiculous should let her make up her own mind when she is older
Oh my God. This is seriously happening to children? Young minds being easily manipulated by adults, making them question themselves at such a young age. I am actually horrified.
It’s offensive to me as a woman to see a child basically be told that being a girl is simply just liking dresses and putting on makeup. Why is our gender being degraded to simply wanting to dress up in pretty pink clothes. Being a woman is so much more than that and shame on you Anna for not teaching your child this information. It’s fucking degrading
Yes. They tell him that being a boy is sport, blue and muscles and being a girl is dresses, pink and makeup. They tell him that feminine guys don't exist and masculine girls don't exist.
She grew up with camera and vlogging you are saying this makes her uncomfortable? If this is who she is why would she be uncomfortable she would be proud right
@@miac2382 look if you can read body language at all you can tell, anyone who leaves the house can tell that this child is not happy , it’s written all over her face
They're allowing this because America is a now delusional nation being ruled under woke people. I blame the government for not having a law against it. Also, if this reply is later deleted, it's probably the Sacconejolys cleaning the comment section.🤦♂️
This is incredibly sad. There needs to be an age limit in place. Wait until 18 or 21. This is far too young. This child will have so many things to say when they get older and get go back.
I have a child her age and you know what my child is doing: playing, learning two languages, discovering new things everyday, learning to love and be loved. Not of to some doctor to change the course of her life. What utter nonsense, let the child be a child.
I started watching your channel shortly after Emelia was born and I just loved it. I saw Eduardo wearing dresses and I thought it was weird (that you posted it for the world to see) but I understood. He was growing up in his big sister's shadow and wanted to be like her...a perfectly normal response that a lot of boys have. When you started encouraging all this trans stuff and when you talked about yourself wanting to be female it all made sense. What you're doing to this poor boy in the name of money is disgusting. If anything, this should be private for Eduardo's sake. I hope like hell that someone steps in before you put him on chemical sterilization and/or make him get surgery. It is just evil what you're doing.
Such an awful road to go down. This little boy has no idea the enormity of these decisions... so scarring, ESPECIALLY in his formative years. There's no doubt, in my mind, it will indeed, turn out to be a disaster. This is child abuse, that you, as parents, fail to notice, somehow. It's not going to turn out good. My heart goes out to this boy.
For your entertainment. This little boy will never know what it's like to be a little boy who is sentimental, who is soft natured, who loves creativity and beauty...and is neurtring...instead all these beautiful qualities his parents robbed him off for fame and called him a girl.
I only ever wore boy clothes and played with boys at this age. I can’t imagine my parents allowing me to fully become a boy based on that. I love being a woman
If she feels like a girl that’s fine but don’t deny her “guy” clothes like the spider man as she will feel like she has to be restricted just to girls things because she’s trans, and has to prove herself. clothes have no gender.
How much of this is Edie relishing in the extra attention from her parents, days out without her other siblings, gifts, parties for "gender reveal do overs" etc. than an actual gender dysphoria. She is still so young and this is such a huge, life changing decision for you to be publicising for the world to see. You both need to research Gillick Competence which is a term we use in the NHS for children. Yes, she's physically able to tell you she's happy to attend these appointments, but due to her age she is unable to fully appreciate what's involved in the treatment, which is evident in Edie's situation given she didn't realise this therapy would involve more than just one appointment. YOU as her parents are responsible for being her advocate and you are failing by publishing this all over the internet which can never be taken back, even if you later decide to delete these videos.
Please tell me I'm 🚫 t the only one who noticed Edwardo make a beeline straight for the spiderman /marvel hero outfits in the shop and notice Annas like "err Edie were here for you!" lol ....trying to encourage her to the girls clothes , when truth be told Edwardo followed what caught his eye first and it was there for all to see.
I noticed that too it was very odd. The kid can like whatever they choose to like. I don’t know why the mom was so pressed about the child wanting to look at the boy stuff?? I feel like they are definitely encouraging this child to be a girl it’s sad
@@likedionysus the parents seem very responsible in the way they are dealing with the situation and nothing permanent has happened to her. Growing her hair out and dressing how she pleases does nothing but make her feel more confident.
@@Guy_In_A_Tie HE IS LITERALLY 8 YEARS OLD. This is the opposite of responsible. This is a KID that didn’t even go through puberty yet, he doesn’t even know what identity is, his brain is barely developed. He has no idea what’s going on and how all of this is changing his childhood forever. I’m a girl and I used to dress “boyish” and play with cars when I was a kid. I hated makeup and “girly” things, and now I’m the total opposite. I can’t imagine what my life would be like today if my parents decided that I was actually a boy and that I needed to change my gender. You can’t make life changing decisions at that age. You can’t get a tattoo, you can’t vote, you can’t drive, but you are aware of the person you are going to be the rest of your life? This is insane.
When I was a little girl I wanted nothing more than to be a pirate. I'm sure glad my parents didn't take me to get my leg amputated and one of my eyes taken out...
The fact that Edie went straight to the marvel section and the mom instantly said “No we’re here for you” “Were here for you” Basically manipulating him into thinking that that’s not something he would want or pick out for him self. That was a literal signal from the mother to go to the girly section. You can tell that he picks out the girly items because he thinks that is what he’s supposed to do and what he’s supposed to want.
Imagine spending a special day with your parents and the camera being out constantly, with your parents interviewing you for content, the entire day. It’s like spending time with paid actors instead of parents.
So are they supposed to tell the child that no she is not a girl? If the child says they are they should support it or not? Once puberty a lot of things will change btw
@@miac2382Yes That's exactly what they're supposed to tell the child. The child can dress with and play with whatever they want, But you don't alter the child's identity and medical state! It's dangerous. This is a decision for the child to make once they're an adult, and it's also their decision if they want to make it public or not which is the most important matter here.
@@miac2382 my second is a boy. He likes to copy his sister. When he asks for girly things like dresses, we give him what he actually wants - a new special outfit, a fun hat, ect. He is a very masculine but gentle child and we nurture his masculine energy instead of affirming his every thought that comes out of his mouth. Little kids don't know very much about life and we as adults need to guide them. If an adult wants to make a life changing decision about altering their gender, that's their decision. But a child cannot and should not be making these decisions. That's terrible parenting. His parents should guide him in a respectful and appropriate way which allow him to explore his interests without telling him he is a girl. Liking girly things and actually being a girl are very different. Doing everything a child wants is terrible parenting.
It's worrying that this is still happening and you're making him do this. He is way too young for this decision. The fact that you're filming it all makes it clear who's choice this is.
3 years since “eddie socially transitioned” this is sick. This is cruelty to kids. Why you can’t be prosecuted for this nonsense is unbelievable. A kid develops. They dont know what they want. In school you were told to be realistic in work expectations. People said footballers and teacher always said think logically not fantasy. And yet a kid can say they wanna be a boy or girl and thats acceptable for transition? Fucking disgusting.
There is nothing wrong or harmful in social transition, if a kid wants to be a girl let them be a girl. The problem is the exploitation and lack of privacy of the kids who have their whole life on a social media.
@@Phoenix-ge7mh there is a difference between the kids who go through a phase of wanting to be the opposite sex, nearly every kid does. But transitions starting socially at that young age to become an actual other sex is ridiculous. And like u said their life is exploited by their parents online for eveyone to see. Im sure for the kid right now it is all fun but in years to come they might have a different change of mind once its too late
@@Phoenix-ge7mh My child wants to get tattoed at age 5. I guess i will make her do it shes grown enough to make her decision. Are you serious bro ? What kind of mental health disorder you have
@Phoenix-ge7mh Actually, growing evidence shows that social transition is NOT a neutral act. It makes it more difficult for kids to back out of transition and so they're more likely to go on to hormone treatments and surgery if they socially transition.
Edie will have to face puberty soon, and decisions will need to be made for the sake of her mental health. That said, as her parents you can absolutely film this part of her life but let Edie decide whether to post publicly when she’s older. She may not want to be the poster child for this topic and she’s def not mature enough to decide now.
Lol nice try. These parents know that. This a grift and a financially worthwhile one. This will continue until the eventual well........ 50% end this way and that's without parents profiting off their life
Regarding medical interventions, this innocent child has no awareness of the physical pain/complications that can come with gender surgeries. My heart breaks to even think of this child enduring physical suffering due to their parents' agenda. By all means, let your child express themselves, but give them the same right to puberty as you had!
What a sick world we live in. Parents forcing a child that being trans is all that matters and to top it off they only do it for money and don’t give as much attention to their actual daughter. People fr learn how to be parents and not filthy animals that are selfish and care about money
Parents like this need locked up. Let your kids be kids and decide when they are adults what they want to do without the parents constantly pushing it. All about the ratings though eh.
Not old enough to understand, but depending on what the doctors think might be ok to put her on puberty blockers until she’s old enough to decide if she truly is a girl ❤
@megan o connor puberty blockers have harmful side effects. Let's not mess about with children's bodies ffs. What is wrong with people these days? Like the old saying goes, "Leave the kids alone!"
I worry so much about the long term impact of all this on children in general, but to have it documented forever i imagine will cause untold psychological damage.
and look at the numreous "support" comments.. who tf is, in their right mind, okay with any of this?! this is sickening. poor boy. yeah, jonathan/anna (people like you dont deserve capital letters when mentioned), all of this is disgusting, earning money with this narrative of your child and not thinking about the impact on him in the future. and yes, he is not they, nor it, he is a normal boy who you use to buy LV bags and Teslas. also, Jonathan was bubbly and very much in the vlogs, why is he now this mysterious unreachable person making Anna do all the dirty work? cant wait for the new Dad Challenge Podcast episode about this
@@janesuoth spare me the story please. When Eduardo grows up and understands the ridiculous shitshow his parents made of his life I’d imagine he will be psychologically very keen to sue them. Jane, if you believe that a child should read UA-cam comments also whilst being the main subject in UA-cam videos, you might want to reconsider your life and boundaries. Its a child. He cannot give consent to anything.
My best friend growing up dressed like a boy, cut her hair like a boy, walked like a boy.. did everything she could to look like a BOY. She is now the most feminine woman and mother. Leave these kids ALONE! These parents are SICK
Even if your friend never turned out to be feminine, and remained masculine her entire life, she still would be a woman, not a "man born in the wrong body". Many people never "grow out of it" but they still shouldn't be told that they're the opposite sex because if it
I truly wish Edie the best, whatever the future holds- she seems like a great kid- but I think that certain things (ie this) should be kept private, and should not be put out there for the world to see. It is her story to tell, if and when she decides to tell it.
Either you are born boy or girl. Each to its own. Their child, their parenting style. Too young to make a serious decision it can be confusing at that age. It can be made old enough age decision.
Can’t believe even after all these negative comments these parents continue to do this to their son. They only care about themselves and making a story out of this.
I hope this doesn’t turn into a regret for your child and your relationship with them. This is a very permanent decision for a child who is still growing and finding themselves.
Edie clearly didn't understand that this would be a first of many appointments........It really does feel at times watching the videos that Edie is very happy to comply with what she thinks her parent's think/want and not what she does....maybe for attention idk....wearing pink/having long hair/not liking football doesn't mean you are a girl......I think Edie thinks that....hopefully all her issues will be resolved by the professionals her parents now have for her....and good luck ...
Unfortunately the professionals like psychologist are not allowed to go against gender issues, at least in America, can imagine it’s the same in Europe. They are only allowed to affirm their patients, aka go along with whatever they say, aka don’t actually provide much of a service except to agree with them. People should watch Jordan Peterson talk with Chloe Cole
Dystopian stuff. Hello to all the future lawyers and psychologists studying this horror. Yes, this is what some people did. No, we didn’t all think it was fine.
Why social services are not involved with this family.This poor child 😢it’s so shocking nobody is doing anything to stop this madness.And they force fake smiles and laughing.Deep down you know it’s wrong.Turn back before it’s to late 😢
Disturbing, these people are definitely possessed. Destroying their child publicly and proud of it. Don't forget to subscribe so we can cash in while we cause our child endless trauma for the rest of his life. What a disgrace
Oh multiple? Absolutely no awareness of what this actually is or entails. I have supported you for years. But I do genuinely think any issues like this, or when Amelia had anxiety etc are private. These really are videos that will never disappear. As adults we regret things, but you shouldn't be subjecting your child to this level of notoriety
Edie clearly was drawn to the Spiderman jacket! Just let them choose and be more fluid than so rigid. It's clearly Anna's idea of what a female is rather than how Edie feels.
Exactly, one of my sons currently loves to wear pink and purple and anything Elsa, as well as race cars and rough and tumble games. Our neighbour's son wears his hair long and wears only dresses while her daughter wants her hair short and wears only Spiderman and dark colours. I thought we had advanced enough as a society to give children a little more freedom of expression. Instead of forcing them into outdated gender roles.
@@annaf3915 Did you listen? She did not go there for Dre at all, Anna twisted it and said something about him looking for Dre. Edie said nothing about that until Anna made her feel bad for looking.
The mother wants a daughter...disgusting abuse of a child. He went straigth to the boys superhero costumes and the mother called him away " We are actually here for you Edie"..pathetic.
As long as these parents are making money that's all that really matters to them. It's a sick world!
Exactly!
😢😢😢
Yessss verry verry sick of them
Yes, I have a mommy vlogging channel that gets little views but will never use my kids to make money here
Noo it's not stop being rude. There are some people that love each other. Like this family
Edwardo is a boy who is feminine. The fact he said he was scared in the gender clinic speaks volumes. How would you feel if one of your other children “came out” and said they wanted to get tattoos? Would you put fake tattoos on them for 3 years and then decide that’s all you can do and leave it to the experts (tattooists). There’s a reason why children can’t consent, and gender isn’t the exception. You are teaching him that only girls are feminine and only boys are masculine. He is 9 years old. Have you even took into consideration that he may be more feminine or feel like a girl because the first 4 years of his life he had 2 sisters? One of which (Emilia) he was very close to? He is a child, not a teenager, not a young adult a CHILD.
I remember being 9 and for a few years I was a tomboy. I liked football, I cut my long hair off, I resented the fact I was going through puberty before my friends, I felt uncomfortable in my body and wished I could just be a boy. Interestingly enough, I grew out of it, I started to embrace being a girl and have grown up being one of the most feminine women you’d ever meet, comfortable and loving being a woman. Had my parents took what I said as a 9 year old literally, and not realised I was just uncomfortable being a girly girl I’d of been put on puberty blockers, and more likely than not be a “de-transitioner” now with my life ruined.
Changing his name, and taking him to a gender clinic is setting him up to be a fucked up adult. Why not just embrace you have a feminine son, or a potentially gay son instead of pushing this liberal, dangerous and disgusting ideology onto a 9 year old.
I used to watch you guys, and loved seeing your family grow and thought it was adorable seeing Eduardo be a sensitive soul who just loved playing with his sisters but you’ve took it too far.
I’m not religious but I pray Eduardo doesn’t agree to his parents sick games for views and just embraces his individuality without ruining his life.
It’s a girl actually I’m a trans and proud 10 year old s o I like watching these videos it makes me feel more comfortable being who I am
you are amazing well said! i was a tomboy for a long time im so glad my parents are smart and didn’t tell me i was a boy
okay well you shouldn’t be trans and your parents are horrible for letting you do that
@@DestinyNapier-ky3nlpreach, you can be be more of a boy when your a girl and theirs nothing wrong with that.
If I said i that i wanna be trans my family will murder me
Edie is far too young for this. These are life changing decisions and should not be made at this age!
I agree 100 percent.
@@chronicallyella1191 slowing puberty can actually cause a lot of issues for the body because you’re disrupting the natural cycle, this is a child and they shouldn’t be playing Frankenstein with a child’s body and mind
And people are wondering why American are banning this. It’s because their not ready their little bodies can’t handle it. Wait till their older. Let them dress up act like a girl but don’t do something THIS big.
@@chronicallyella1191 I do wonder what comorbidity is occurring here. Being trans may be a symptom of another mental health issue, it may not, but we can’t assume that 40% died because they were trans when we don’t have all the info. Not to mention the correlation between trans and autism, I wouldn’t be surprised to find it linked to some other neurological disorder.
@@chronicallyella1191 it's not reversible. That is a lie. You are fooling around with nature and a child.
For the love of god, can someone please step in and protect this child!!! These parents are taking this too far!😢😢😢
For the nonexistence of any god, can someone step in and protect the children of religious lunatics from getting brainwashed?
This should be classed as child abuse. Since when does a child have the mentality for life changing decisions? Sick times we are living in😢
Agreed... I'm not transphobic in the slightest but to me something seems off with this... let children grow up just because they like girly things doesn't make them transgender..
Also agree and I even saw some videos when the kid was still a boy and she didn’t even look like she hated it and a child can’t make decisions like that
what is the change exactly?
@@nikk6435 the change of the child’s gender?
@@elenakosseva5064 and the problem with it what exactly? I don't see surgeries or anything like that
People who are born as girls can like "boyish" things and people born as guys should also be allowed to like "girly" things without changing their identity.
Seriously. I enjoy a lot more "male" hobbies then female ones. Some days I wear dresses but most I prefer sweat pants but I'm not a boy. These parents are sick
preach i preferred boy clothes and toys etc when i was the same age and grew out of it
👏👏👏
@Gf bunny squad dances! How do they know it will make them happy?! Medical procedures, let alone on going ones, are not "happy" experience, and they have major life consequences! It's not the same as saying "ice cream or a walk in the park makes them happy." Children know nothing about these things, neither do most adults. But adults can comprehend the emotional and physical consequences and have the development to take further action needed.
Look at it.. its ALL ABOUT THE MOM
To the core it upsets me that Edie does not have her privacy. Even if she’s given the choice to have her story placed on the Internet, she certainly isn’t old or mature enough to understand the gravity of what that actually means.
Still looks like a little boy. His features are all boy, Long hair doesn't make someone a girl
I support transgender people. Nothing wrong with them. But it has to be a BIG, careful decision for a person privately. It is a big,life changing one. You have to be mature enough to understand it. Not like this. Poor child,his brain is not developed enough to understand such complex situation. It is a big deal for 20,30 olds. Child need his parents to survive,so he will do anything to keep them. It is as simple as that.
@@anahabat8210 sadly, the kids parents are only about the views and money.
He’s a boy. A child can’t make a decision focus on school. Too young.
I agree she shouldn't have to deal with the whole world's opinion on her decisions.
imagine how she will feel starting high school or uni. She may be a well transitioned women by then who doesn't want her childhood known...who just wants to be another girl starting uni😢
shame on her patents
They need to read the article about exploration of children by Teen vogue
This shouldn't be on the internet it's a private moment like yours kids journey is private stop exploiting your child
Amen
I totally agree 😮
They are very disturbed individuals.
They don't care, they getting more views which means more money
Agree.
My heart hurts for this poor child. Being paraded on the Internet and gender clinics and being pressured by her mother. These are life changing decisions being made on a second grader. History will not look kindly upon this trend. Seeing an innocent child right in front of us and 20 years from now being depressed, infertile, angry, co fused and all the innocence taken away.
I'm feeling exactly the same about this :( And there's many more kids who get "treatments" like this that will make them end up as traumatized and mutilated adults. I feel so sorry for them. Truly man-made horrors.
If Edie didn’t like it then the parents would’ve listened leave them ALONE GOD
HIS mother
His* mother. The child is a boy.
Yup
forcing your child to grow up on the internet is evil. forcing your child to grow up on the internet and forcing them to be transgender is a whole other level of evil
She's not being forced to be trans
@@rahnb4943 they wer manipulated into thinking so
@@ivanexell-uz4mvthat’s the way she wants to be just let her be
*people please listen by going to the gender clinic they mean going to gender therapy to make sure being trans was what she wanted gender therapy is apart of the gender clinic children shouldn’t get surgery or those hormone things (I forgot what it’s called) until they are adults*
@@1dk.1dc it’s a he, not she
When I was that age all I wanted was to be a boy. I acted and dressed like a guy and would tell my parents I didn’t want to be a girl. For a few years. Probably because I grew up around boy cousins and my brother and felt left out. But suddenly I stopped wanting to be a guy and just forgot about it. I personally wouldn’t allow my child to make this permanent of a decision unless they’re an adult and still feel that is what they want. Kids are constantly changing and adapting to their surroundings.
nobody asked you
@@peachylola Offering her own perspective that is actually not uncommon
Exactly my daughter dressed like a boy, wore hair like a boy till she was 12 then started dressing girly wearing makeup, kids go through phases doesn't mean they're automatically trans smh
Every Child is different.
I was the same way as a child. Wanted to be a boy for years until I was 13. I thought it was cool. Then all of a sudden I was content being a woman. Started dressing girly and feminine. Now I’m married with 3 kids. So proud and thankful to be a woman.
If my parents were to have done this to me at such a young age I would never have forgiven them.
Most children go through these phases.
Please oh please wait!
I was in edie shoes once. From young age I wanted be a boy and made my mum call me aman. Soon as I hit 13 I didn’t want to be a boy anymore and went back to being a girl. Hope they wait till edie is older for anything drastic
😮
They are using him for views and money
@@ISayMusicYouSayYes her
@@christerblitzer4349 He. He is a boy, will always be male. Always.
I was the same way as a child. Wanted to be a boy for years until I was 13. I thought it was cool. Then all of a sudden I was content being a woman. Started dressing girly and feminine. Now I’m married with 3 kids. So proud and thankful to be a woman.
If my parents were to have done this to me at such a young age I would never have forgiven them.
Most children go through these phases.
Please oh please wait!
Fancy not telling your child they are going to more than one session of gender therapy, something which they clearly did not even ask for.
As a subscriber since Anna’s first video and the inception of the channel I don’t watch much since the last year or so but thought I’d check in. I’m shocked that you, as parents, aren’t reading the comments from so many people that have supported this channel, helped build your small but noteworthy empire and ignore what so many people have to say. How do otherwise intelligent parents give so little respect to the privacy of your child who CLEARLY is going through what might be the biggest struggle of her lifetime.
As a mom to 3 kids in their late teens/early 20’s it’s difficult to watch Edie become a poster child for trans kids. This is her story to tell, when she’s old enough to understand the consequences of putting such personal information on the internet- which remains forever. You both need to take a long look in the mirror and ask yourself if this is worth it. I promise you this will be your biggest regret. This will affect your relationship with your child when she is old enough to get it all.
What your doing is selfish, sad and one day might constitute as abusive. I wish you all the best of luck, especially Edie.
😢
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Narcissists capitalizing on their child through exploitation & grooming. 🤮
Well said. Unfortunately arrogance is blinding and that’s what we see. Very sad.
As an original subscriber you might remember Anna stating she didn’t want kids. These poor kids are simply used as props for views. I implore anyone with decency to unsubscribe from these two narcissists who are abusing their power of parenthood as losing their audience is the only way they will ever stop this absolute evil.
I don’t think I’ve ever felt so bad for a kid in my life.
@@IndecisivegurrlAlexthank you. finally someone said it.
@@IndecisivegurrlAlex stop your just fueling my rage to hear that. But thanks for sharing
@@IndecisivegurrlAlexI would be dead by now if u were my parent
Why she is not being forced or is it something else
@@Lolzkey why should she?
Have no idea why this was recommended to me, but I’m completely grossed out. Not because this child is transgender, but because the parents are exploiting it on UA-cam. This child cannot give consent for this at this age. This should not be allowed on UA-cam!
Yes!! She can say that she's happy for it to be filmed and shared all she likes. But because of her age she literally cannot give full informed consent for this very personal stuff to be shared online for millions of poeple to see. I really really hope that this all works out well for her, otherwise her parents are going to have to live with their mistakes for the rest of their lives.
And all I wanted was a good recipe for scones 😅 But this was suggested.
@LydiaDeborah 10 months later hope u got ur scones lol
If my child came out as trans at such a young age i would sit them down and ask why and then tell them that they shouldn't make that decision now and really shouldn't worry about gender just think of yourself as a human being i would ofc support the child but i will tell them that takes a really really long time to fully figure out as a girl who liked girls when i was really young and never came out untill i turned 14
@@Hannah.Edwardsi envision a day when many children sue their parents for exploiting them like this and also youtube for allowing it to happen.
This dad is living out his own fantasy. Look at his 'I'm coming out' video and this action will make a lot of sense. Also he'll do literally anything for clicks. Poor kid
In 10-15 years this kid is gonna have a lot to say about his parents
I hope he understands sooner rather than later that his parents are narcs.
... to their therapist, yeah 😢
Yeah, and he will have video evidence of their abuse
how great they were she will say
@@christerblitzer4349 careful, don’t chug that koolaid too quick
Jonathan needs intensive therapy ASAP!!!! He’s living through his son !!
No, I think it's the mother who's being more pushy. Not just with the gender thing, but just in general with this whole fame thing.
Honestly, I feel like the mother is the one who is being very pushy on this, Jhonatan even showed the little kid a spider man's clothes while the mother quickly dissmissed him as " we came here for eddie "
Yup
@@GeenSamayup
He’s living his father’s dream!!!!
How easy is it to manipulate a child: I'll take you to this uncomfortable thing and if you comply you can pick out anything you want from any store....95% of children will agree to this set up.
I wanted to be the opposite gender when I was a child. The same way Edie does. Wanted to be a boy for years. I thought it was cool to be a boy. Then I turned 13 and a switch flipped. All of a sudden I was content being a woman. Started dressing girly and feminine. Now I’m married with 3 kids. So proud and thankful to be a woman. I would never wish to be a man now.
If my parents were to have done this to me at such a young age I would never have forgiven them. I wouldn’t be able to have the birth experiences I have had. And I wouldn’t have found my path of birth doula.
Most children go through these phases.
Please oh please wait. Edie isn’t old enough to understand. Don’t alter her forever.
So are they supposed to tell her no that she cannot transition and tell her no she is not a girl? Or tell her yes she is a girl and can be a girl
Why can't they just let him have his pretend and keep his regular hormones and parts when he gets to 12 he'll tell them just kidding I m a boy
Yes you were a tomboy and that's cool, nowadays they say tomboys are the opposite sex in their head and should be transitioned. World is crazy I can't wait for Jesus to come back and punish these people.
Omg same. I was saying to my boyfriend the other day if I had other parents i might have been turned into a boy because I liked playing sports, looked short hair, liked blue and said I wanted to be a dad. I'm very happy I'm a woman and I was able to have my babies
They don't give a shit. Honestly sickening.
"Sacrificing your kid for the glorification of your own compassion" - Jordan Peterson
That really does sum up this lunacy.
Anna is ok with this but deep down she’s not it’s all johns choice which is sad
Spot on
@@jamiesmith4245 totally. A woman who is letting a weak man guide her
It is SHOCKING to me how little certain parents know about kid's basic development. First of all kids at this age like to experiment themselves and the world, and they like to act out possibilities. You just need to accept and guide them. I was a tomboy as a little girl, I hated pink, I wanted to climb trees, hop on a bike with my brothers. And thank God nobody forced me to change my gender, because I turned out as a beautiful, confident woman at the end, who still hates pink btw. 😀 And the other important lesson is that child would do anything for their parents attention and love. It is their way of suvival. They would give up themselves completely to please their mom or DAD. So if this kid feels he only gets the attention and love from mommy and daddy when he dresses in pink, and acts like a girl...' Mommy and daddy love me because they are cheeringly make videos about me and I'm their centre of attention"...(And also selling me online) You can all imagine how sick and twisted this story actually is... 🤯 Poor child.
100% as a parent we understand the extremes of the need to have attention at all cost. Snd bragging rights to say I was out in London having hot chocolate while yall were in school. Shame sickening
You hit the nail on the head. That’s not a little boy wanting to be a girl. That’s a little boy who is enjoying the attention from parents who probably spend more time on their devices than parenting.
Edie wanted the Spider-Man jacket, and Anna redirected her to the girls clothes. This child is getting pressured to be something she’s not
Something *he’s* not.
@@hpotter2954 Shes*
@@NadiaRibbons3393 You’re missing an apostrophe and a sense of reality.
@@NadiaRibbons3393 he
This is horrifying 🥺
I'm so glad that my parents raised me right.
Bruh her parents raised her like a queen 👸 stop being a peasant
huh if your hating no they didn't i glad my parents learnt me to support people
they did, just cuz she is trans does not mean she was raised wrong 😑
But they couldn't help you learn grammar though? 💀@@Misszebyrobloxvideos756
I’m surprised this is legal. The government should step in and ban this form of child abuse
this is not child abuse. this child, edie, is transgender and she is perfectly normal.
@@-Syrus- it's not perfectly normal and they are far too youmg to be doing this
@Coda24_24 I know they have only social transitioned, but I feel there will be quite a lot of mental health damage in their later life because of doing it at such a young age.
@@-Syrus-no
The government only take the children of good parents. They fully support child abusers like these two
The monetisation of this young child's incredibly personal journey, the pressure it places on her in the supposed name of advocacy and representation is maddening. Jonathan and Anna, please reconsider your choice to share this with the world. It's short-term gains against a possible lifetime of resentment from your daughter. And it might have a massive impact on her life in future. She has the right to privacy.
They not only need to reconsider making it public, but reconsider it in its totality. There is no such thing as a transgender child. Children have no idea what they are getting into and they cannot consent.
Kid: “first appointment, there’ll be more”
Parent: “yes, but it’s a good thing”
Kid: “okay”.
Talking about an appointment for a thing the child is said to want.
It just goes to show this child has absolutely NO idea what is going on. They think they go to ONE appointment and boom they’re magically a girl. It’s degrading and it’s disgusting
" Every child deserves a parent, but not every parent deserves a child."
The look of horror on the poor kids face that there will be more appointments!.. he has ONE childhood.. just let him be a kid!..
She said she was scared…turn the damn camera off! She is a vulnerable child, not just an entertainment prop! The fact that she didn’t even know there was going to be more than one session says a lot!
Exactly !!
This is such a tough time for her, some things should be private! Poor kid is terrified!
This is exploitation.
Where's UA-cam? Someone needs to protect Eduardo's privacy as a minor if his parents don't. It's just not right. And this is hard to say as I've watched and enjoyed this channel for MANY years, but Jonathan really you need to stop being so exuberant about this. It just makes my gut feel like you're living vicariously through Eduardo. Stop the TikTok, the stories and reels please. Let it go. Just let your family work through this privately. Filming this child going to a clinic!!! I'm shocked. This is exploitation in it's purest form.
@@kellyperez9676 whilst i agree they are probably using the kids for views etc, please be respectful and use the correct pronouns, gender and name for Edie! She is a kid who needs support if her story is going to be publicly shown💜💜
I think the child’s concern (and lack of knowledge) that there will be “multiple” appointments should be a major clue to the parents.
This is a major decision, not to be made lightly.
But, wait, I forgot that the parents are more concerned about money and fifteen minutes of fame.
I’m sorry what? Just to put it out there I’m a gay man, when I was a child I wanted to play with babies, Anastasia dolls anything girly and my parents allowed me to which is absolutely fine. Just because I like to do girly things doesn’t mean that my parents should have acted on changing my gender to match that, I was too young to understand anything so acting and being girly was as far as it went and should get to. I am glad I had that free rain to be who I was and made me realise when I was a teenager/ young adult I was happy to be me a man as I naturally got to experience puberty which makes you realise who you are. It’s disturbing seeing these children going through this and is actually irresponsible of the parents. Your kid wants to dress like a girl and buy girls toys, fine but going to a gender clinic is too much. It’s actually disgusting
Completely agree I'm glad you got to explore every aspect of yourself at your own pace they should let the boy enjoy his interests whatever they are but do not try to change his gender and convince him hes a girl and wants to be a girl this kid had absolutely no say in this and it shows
I couldn’t agree to this comment more
What you said 100% right It's completely fine for a boy to do girly stuff ...look at his father big smile . He so happy abouts ,excited even ... it makes me sick .
i agree with you 100 percent. If this child is gay, he may want to enjoy his male identity and remain very female in lots of ways. No need for gender clinic now. I agree with your statement about experiencing puberty...very good way to put it !! I am a straight female and i understand what you are saying....there's alot of common sense that these two youtuber parents are lacking. IMHO
Being gay is abnormal and disgusting. This is not normal. Not how God made you
I wish I could wake up from this nightmare, what is happening? The world has gone mad. How are they getting away with this, it's literally crazy.
Anna's Dad is rolling in his grave right now, the blatant EVIL she and Jonathan are doing to this poor child is unfathomable.
The most frightening part is that child protection services will only aid them in their abuse. Their is literally No one to intervene for the child sadly😢
YALL IT WAS HER CHOICE TO BE TRANS
In the guise of wanting to be cool parents and fit in, you are running the very real risk of ruining your child's physical and mental health. Edie was scared and confused in this video, it's beyond sad
Edie's brain hasn't developed enough yet for these decisions.
When do t childrens brains develop enough to know they are t
@@miac2382 our brains aren’t fully developed until we’re like 27… but even still, there are reasons you can drive until 16 or drink until 21. You can’t legally consent to sex until 18… but somehow you can consent sex change- absolute insanity and nothing short of child abuse.
@@miac2382 27...that's basic knowledge.
@@miac2382
They are not trans. You are delusional.
Neither are the parents brain developed
If Edie wants to be a girl in life good luck to her, but it feels like a drastic life changing decision at this age. I’m a gay man who played with Barbies and dolls,my mother found me covered in her make up one time, but it didn’t mean being taken to a gender clinic and I’m glad it didn’t.
Allow puberty to happen and the rollercoaster of hormones that comes with it. Your child still has plenty of time to figure things out, I’ve no issue with people transitioning, it must be a huge decision and terrifying to tell the world, (it was scary enough for me to come out as gay) but it just seems too early at this age.
Because you didn't feel like you were a girl or stuck in the wrong body. No one will get it unless you are born transgender. Just a fact.
I agree. Beautifully said.
@@loraleepooley3669 no one asked
@@miagracewalsh8188 mind your own business. I wasn’t talking to you.
@@loraleepooley3669 mind my own business?💀💀 no one minded their business when u were commenting on a child being who they are did you. Stfu lmaooo.
They must say EDIEEEE a thousand times in this video, so incessant on making sure they call them the FEMALE name. This poor kid
It’s ok that’s she’s trans but I think she should get older b4 she go to gender clinic tho but I support her even I think she should be at least 15-20
I didnt even come out as bisexual till i was 14 and ive been attracted to girls for as long as i can remember
I was a tomboy back in my childhood, dressed like a boy, played only with boys etc. You would never know that I was a girl back then! Sometimes I told my parents that I wanna be a boy, but it changed Now I am a grown woman, I’m not into makeup and stuff, but it doesn’t bother me at all, it’s not what life is about. Give this child chance to live through his development without crippling procedures!
Me too!.. I played with boys, loved playing football... but now love everything girly.. so glad, I had a free childhood, with no parents pushing things like this!.. kids change daily.. modern parents just do not allow their kids freedom now..
Exactly! I too was a Tom boy growing up. Loved playing with cars more than dolls. Wasn’t into make up when I was in my teens but I knew I was a girl and wanted to stay being a girl. I’m so glad there wasn’t social media and all the noise to influence my thoughts and create doubts in my mind about my sexuality. I love being a woman and love being a mother.
same! i grew up hating my barbies and playing with GI Joes in the dirt, was a tomboy for ages. Now, i stillreally enjoy 'male' things such as surfing, camping' outdoors stuff. does not mean i want to be a boy. i am happy to be a woman and i am a (not that it matters) heterosexual woman. this is insane
This child will be in therapy for the rest of their life wondering why their parents shared such intimate moments in their life with the whole world. Wondering if it was for the money, for the attention? Dang this is so sad.
I think in ten years we are going to be seeing a lot of the family vlogger kids grow up and realize they were just content /cash cows for their parents...how sad and challenging that will be once they realize they were just expl*ited for content
There's many kids who grow up messed up because they had parents who put money before their welfare.... and had parents who never were around due to always working and were only shown any attention by being bribed or gifted cash etc. What could be worse than that? Parents that only care about mone, more than your actual welfare, and use you as the means to make that money :(
They want to look cool to their fellow far left friends, it's so trendy right now ya know.
I felt so sorry for Edie when she kept saying she was scared and was shocked when she had to go back for more this is ridiculous should let her make up her own mind when she is older
He’s a BOY!! Not a SHE!
He definitely should make up his mind when he’s older.
@@hpotter2954 yeah that's how I feel too
the father doesn't even know what the heck he wants for himself....how is the boy supposed to know?? This is all very disturbing.
@@Jendromeda exactly 👏👏
Oh my God. This is seriously happening to children? Young minds being easily manipulated by adults, making them question themselves at such a young age. I am actually horrified.
It’s mental abuse
Is really sad😢😢 and so many crazy people think this is normal it scares me to know what the world is now
@@megananne7744she’s showing who she truly is
Step in ASAP AND PROTECT THIS CHILD AT ALL COSTS 😢
Child abuse
@@fc849 I actually stepped in and reported this video as child abuse
It’s offensive to me as a woman to see a child basically be told that being a girl is simply just liking dresses and putting on makeup. Why is our gender being degraded to simply wanting to dress up in pretty pink clothes. Being a woman is so much more than that and shame on you Anna for not teaching your child this information. It’s fucking degrading
trans people do not "degraade" anything, were just trying to EXIST
Yes. They tell him that being a boy is sport, blue and muscles and being a girl is dresses, pink and makeup. They tell him that feminine guys don't exist and masculine girls don't exist.
Your baby does not look happy doing this :( it's so sad. We can tell it's not really your child's decision :(
She looks so unhappy and uncomfortable and I cannot believe they would film such a private moment
Poor boy
She grew up with camera and vlogging you are saying this makes her uncomfortable? If this is who she is why would she be uncomfortable she would be proud right
@@miac2382 look if you can read body language at all you can tell, anyone who leaves the house can tell that this child is not happy , it’s written all over her face
It's not a she it's a he
I can’t believe you can’t be prosecuted for this.
shut up omg
110% agreed
They're allowing this because America is a now delusional nation being ruled under woke people.
I blame the government for not having a law against it.
Also, if this reply is later deleted, it's probably the Sacconejolys cleaning the comment section.🤦♂️
why are you watching if you’re a terf
@@M-ft9od🤡
These parents are NUTS!!!
This is incredibly sad. There needs to be an age limit in place. Wait until 18 or 21. This is far too young. This child will have so many things to say when they get older and get go back.
There shouldn't be a age limit period. This whole thing is gross in the first place
I have a child her age and you know what my child is doing: playing, learning two languages, discovering new things everyday, learning to love and be loved. Not of to some doctor to change the course of her life. What utter nonsense, let the child be a child.
I started watching your channel shortly after Emelia was born and I just loved it. I saw Eduardo wearing dresses and I thought it was weird (that you posted it for the world to see) but I understood. He was growing up in his big sister's shadow and wanted to be like her...a perfectly normal response that a lot of boys have. When you started encouraging all this trans stuff and when you talked about yourself wanting to be female it all made sense. What you're doing to this poor boy in the name of money is disgusting. If anything, this should be private for Eduardo's sake. I hope like hell that someone steps in before you put him on chemical sterilization and/or make him get surgery. It is just evil what you're doing.
The dad wanted to be female? That explains it.
@@hpotter2954 yeah he made a video about it
i hope Johnathan gets arrested, this is legit child abuse
@@hpotter2954yup
@@ferret9263yup
Such an awful road to go down. This little boy has no idea the enormity of these decisions... so scarring, ESPECIALLY in his formative years. There's no doubt, in my mind, it will indeed, turn out to be a disaster. This is child abuse, that you, as parents, fail to notice, somehow. It's not going to turn out good. My heart goes out to this boy.
I concur. This situation (and others like it) break my heart.
We must pray for this family
The fact that there is nothing we can do to stop it is what makes lose hope in humanity, all authority figures in the western countries support this!
It's obvious little girl.
For your entertainment. This little boy will never know what it's like to be a little boy who is sentimental, who is soft natured, who loves creativity and beauty...and is neurtring...instead all these beautiful qualities his parents robbed him off for fame and called him a girl.
I only ever wore boy clothes and played with boys at this age. I can’t imagine my parents allowing me to fully become a boy based on that. I love being a woman
If she feels like a girl that’s fine but don’t deny her “guy” clothes like the spider man as she will feel like she has to be restricted just to girls things because she’s trans, and has to prove herself. clothes have no gender.
How much of this is Edie relishing in the extra attention from her parents, days out without her other siblings, gifts, parties for "gender reveal do overs" etc. than an actual gender dysphoria. She is still so young and this is such a huge, life changing decision for you to be publicising for the world to see.
You both need to research Gillick Competence which is a term we use in the NHS for children. Yes, she's physically able to tell you she's happy to attend these appointments, but due to her age she is unable to fully appreciate what's involved in the treatment, which is evident in Edie's situation given she didn't realise this therapy would involve more than just one appointment. YOU as her parents are responsible for being her advocate and you are failing by publishing this all over the internet which can never be taken back, even if you later decide to delete these videos.
He, Edie is a boy.
Ever since Edie came about all of the attention- especially from Jonathan - has been all about Edie.
Yes… and he gets rewarded if he goes along with it.
Cult-captured parents. Such a tragedy. We're facing at least two generations of confused human beings. What a mess.
Please tell me I'm 🚫 t the only one who noticed Edwardo make a beeline straight for the spiderman /marvel hero outfits in the shop and notice Annas like "err Edie were here for you!" lol ....trying to encourage her to the girls clothes , when truth be told Edwardo followed what caught his eye first and it was there for all to see.
@@christerblitzer4349 He is a boy,
@@christerblitzer4349 not on the birth certificate.
That was pretty odd, mom literally pushes everyone in a certain direction…they’re totally about free will and choice though…
I noticed that too it was very odd. The kid can like whatever they choose to like. I don’t know why the mom was so pressed about the child wanting to look at the boy stuff?? I feel like they are definitely encouraging this child to be a girl it’s sad
Yes this is awful what they are doing to their Son 😢😢😢😢
This is genuinely dangerous, if this kid regrets his transition he’s going to have a lot of trauma to treat
*her *she's
@@Guy_In_A_Tie he is a boy, and a boy that’s going to suffer a lot of trauma when he grows up
@@likedionysus and how exactly do you know what goes on in her head?
@@likedionysus the parents seem very responsible in the way they are dealing with the situation and nothing permanent has happened to her. Growing her hair out and dressing how she pleases does nothing but make her feel more confident.
@@Guy_In_A_Tie HE IS LITERALLY 8 YEARS OLD. This is the opposite of responsible. This is a KID that didn’t even go through puberty yet, he doesn’t even know what identity is, his brain is barely developed. He has no idea what’s going on and how all of this is changing his childhood forever. I’m a girl and I used to dress “boyish” and play with cars when I was a kid. I hated makeup and “girly” things, and now I’m the total opposite. I can’t imagine what my life would be like today if my parents decided that I was actually a boy and that I needed to change my gender. You can’t make life changing decisions at that age. You can’t get a tattoo, you can’t vote, you can’t drive, but you are aware of the person you are going to be the rest of your life? This is insane.
Please just let this child be a child and give these children privacy for the love
It's obvious the homosexual father runs the show. I have a feeling that the oldest child is gonna be the one to expose these weirdo parents
@Elaine well he’s 🗑️
Someone said it!
For the love of God wait until she is mature enough to make such a life changing decision!
What life changing decision
?
He! It's a he you fool!!!!!
@@ShaneFN13 changing their hormones and gender identity
Mature enough? Wait for what? None of this is normal . It's disgusting. What's next. Pple will do this to their dogs
Yup
When I was a little girl I wanted nothing more than to be a pirate. I'm sure glad my parents didn't take me to get my leg amputated and one of my eyes taken out...
LoL 🤣
your comment made me laugh 😂
The fact that Edie went straight to the marvel section and the mom instantly said “No we’re here for you” “Were here for you” Basically manipulating him into thinking that that’s not something he would want or pick out for him self. That was a literal signal from the mother to go to the girly section. You can tell that he picks out the girly items because he thinks that is what he’s supposed to do and what he’s supposed to want.
Imagine spending a special day with your parents and the camera being out constantly, with your parents interviewing you for content, the entire day. It’s like spending time with paid actors instead of parents.
I wonder if Edie will be getting a tattoo soon as well? After all she's old enough to decide these life-changing things according to these
So are they supposed to tell the child that no she is not a girl? If the child says they are they should support it or not? Once puberty a lot of things will change btw
@@miac2382 um yes!
@@miac2382Yes That's exactly what they're supposed to tell the child. The child can dress with and play with whatever they want, But you don't alter the child's identity and medical state! It's dangerous. This is a decision for the child to make once they're an adult, and it's also their decision if they want to make it public or not which is the most important matter here.
@@miac2382 my second is a boy. He likes to copy his sister. When he asks for girly things like dresses, we give him what he actually wants - a new special outfit, a fun hat, ect. He is a very masculine but gentle child and we nurture his masculine energy instead of affirming his every thought that comes out of his mouth. Little kids don't know very much about life and we as adults need to guide them. If an adult wants to make a life changing decision about altering their gender, that's their decision. But a child cannot and should not be making these decisions. That's terrible parenting. His parents should guide him in a respectful and appropriate way which allow him to explore his interests without telling him he is a girl. Liking girly things and actually being a girl are very different. Doing everything a child wants is terrible parenting.
@@miac2382that child doesn’t give a flying shit about being a boy or girl
It's worrying that this is still happening and you're making him do this. He is way too young for this decision. The fact that you're filming it all makes it clear who's choice this is.
3 years since “eddie socially transitioned” this is sick. This is cruelty to kids. Why you can’t be prosecuted for this nonsense is unbelievable. A kid develops. They dont know what they want.
In school you were told to be realistic in work expectations. People said footballers and teacher always said think logically not fantasy. And yet a kid can say they wanna be a boy or girl and thats acceptable for transition? Fucking disgusting.
There is nothing wrong or harmful in social transition, if a kid wants to be a girl let them be a girl. The problem is the exploitation and lack of privacy of the kids who have their whole life on a social media.
@@Phoenix-ge7mh there is a difference between the kids who go through a phase of wanting to be the opposite sex, nearly every kid does. But transitions starting socially at that young age to become an actual other sex is ridiculous. And like u said their life is exploited by their parents online for eveyone to see. Im sure for the kid right now it is all fun but in years to come they might have a different change of mind once its too late
That’s a grown up decision not a kid. This little boy.
@@Phoenix-ge7mh My child wants to get tattoed at age 5. I guess i will make her do it shes grown enough to make her decision. Are you serious bro ? What kind of mental health disorder you have
@Phoenix-ge7mh Actually, growing evidence shows that social transition is NOT a neutral act. It makes it more difficult for kids to back out of transition and so they're more likely to go on to hormone treatments and surgery if they socially transition.
What the hell is wrong with these people. The world is literally going crazy. I feel so sorry for that kid
The fact that I can’t find one comment on here that supports the parents’ decision says a lot… 😢poor kid
They way she keeps saying “Edie, Edie, come on Edie” honestly makes my skin crawl. That is a mom who controls her children.
Edie will have to face puberty soon, and decisions will need to be made for the sake of her mental health. That said, as her parents you can absolutely film this part of her life but let Edie decide whether to post publicly when she’s older. She may not want to be the poster child for this topic and she’s def not mature enough to decide now.
Lol nice try. These parents know that. This a grift and a financially worthwhile one. This will continue until the eventual well........ 50% end this way and that's without parents profiting off their life
They don’t care. They’re abusing their child and monetising it. 💰🤑💰. It’s horrific. In years to come this will be illegal and it should be now.
Children should be allowed to make ADULT decisions Any medications taken those things can not be undone. Once the damage is done it's done.
Regarding medical interventions, this innocent child has no awareness of the physical pain/complications that can come with gender surgeries. My heart breaks to even think of this child enduring physical suffering due to their parents' agenda. By all means, let your child express themselves, but give them the same right to puberty as you had!
I’m very very surprised that the comments are still open.
What a sick world we live in. Parents forcing a child that being trans is all that matters and to top it off they only do it for money and don’t give as much attention to their actual daughter. People fr learn how to be parents and not filthy animals that are selfish and care about money
Parents like this need locked up. Let your kids be kids and decide when they are adults what they want to do without the parents constantly pushing it. All about the ratings though eh.
Not just the parents, it’s probably school teachers pushing it on them too
Exactly
They are not old enough to understand
Not old enough to understand, but depending on what the doctors think might be ok to put her on puberty blockers until she’s old enough to decide if she truly is a girl ❤
@megan o connor puberty blockers have harmful side effects. Let's not mess about with children's bodies ffs. What is wrong with people these days? Like the old saying goes, "Leave the kids alone!"
I worry so much about the long term impact of all this on children in general, but to have it documented forever i imagine will cause untold psychological damage.
and look at the numreous "support" comments.. who tf is, in their right mind, okay with any of this?! this is sickening. poor boy. yeah, jonathan/anna (people like you dont deserve capital letters when mentioned), all of this is disgusting, earning money with this narrative of your child and not thinking about the impact on him in the future. and yes, he is not they, nor it, he is a normal boy who you use to buy LV bags and Teslas. also, Jonathan was bubbly and very much in the vlogs, why is he now this mysterious unreachable person making Anna do all the dirty work? cant wait for the new Dad Challenge Podcast episode about this
@@Theixoni I know it is mind boggling
I’d imagine the psychological damage most likely will come from the child reading these kinds of comments
@@janesuoth spare me the story please. When Eduardo grows up and understands the ridiculous shitshow his parents made of his life I’d imagine he will be psychologically very keen to sue them. Jane, if you believe that a child should read UA-cam comments also whilst being the main subject in UA-cam videos, you might want to reconsider your life and boundaries. Its a child. He cannot give consent to anything.
@@Theixoni omg WHO CARES. I don’t see them telling you how to live your life.
My best friend growing up dressed like a boy, cut her hair like a boy, walked like a boy.. did everything she could to look like a BOY. She is now the most feminine woman and mother. Leave these kids ALONE! These parents are SICK
Even if your friend never turned out to be feminine, and remained masculine her entire life, she still would be a woman, not a "man born in the wrong body". Many people never "grow out of it" but they still shouldn't be told that they're the opposite sex because if it
Read the book Irreversible Damage. This child is not old enough to make this life long decision . Very sad.
Mommy's little cash cow ❤
Yup
This is child abuse
100%!!
I truly wish Edie the best, whatever the future holds- she seems like a great kid- but I think that certain things (ie this) should be kept private, and should not be put out there for the world to see. It is her story to tell, if and when she decides to tell it.
His.
Either you are born boy or girl. Each to its own. Their child, their parenting style. Too young to make a serious decision it can be confusing at that age. It can be made old enough age decision.
@@Seashellstardust definitely too young.
No we need to see this to warn the parents that this is very wrong. Their destroying the child’s body at an early age.
Can’t believe even after all these negative comments these parents continue to do this to their son. They only care about themselves and making a story out of this.
Poor Eduardo. I really feel bad for this little boy.
I hope this doesn’t turn into a regret for your child and your relationship with them. This is a very permanent decision for a child who is still growing and finding themselves.
Edie clearly didn't understand that this would be a first of many appointments........It really does feel at times watching the videos that Edie is very happy to comply with what she thinks her parent's think/want and not what she does....maybe for attention idk....wearing pink/having long hair/not liking football doesn't mean you are a girl......I think Edie thinks that....hopefully all her issues will be resolved by the professionals her parents now have for her....and good luck ...
exactly! and now she knows that she'll get presents and special attention when she complies
@@lezgiddit he*
@@alexandramoyer8785 yes he he he
Unfortunately the professionals like psychologist are not allowed to go against gender issues, at least in America, can imagine it’s the same in Europe. They are only allowed to affirm their patients, aka go along with whatever they say, aka don’t actually provide much of a service except to agree with them. People should watch Jordan Peterson talk with Chloe Cole
This kids these nutjobs out their lives.
Dystopian stuff. Hello to all the future lawyers and psychologists studying this horror. Yes, this is what some people did. No, we didn’t all think it was fine.
Amen!!!! ❤
The kid doesn’t even know there is gonna be multiple appointments.. no freaking idea of all the consequences ( which is normal at that age!! )
I had no idea that decisions like this could be made whilst a child is so young
A child can have their breasts removed starting at 13.
There are kids younger than her that have gone through transitioning. The youngest person who was documented was 4
Isn’t it disgusting? Permanent medical sterilization before they are old enough to comprehend what they are doing
@@Julia-yj9qk they probably won’t do HRT or surgery until she’s old enough to make that decision. Transitioning isn’t just about HRT and surgeries
@@BeatlesPlotagonShow he’s too young to be starting the process with puberty blockers. And certainly 4 is.
Why social services are not involved with this family.This poor child 😢it’s so shocking nobody is doing anything to stop this madness.And they force fake smiles and laughing.Deep down you know it’s wrong.Turn back before it’s to late 😢
Disturbing, these people are definitely possessed. Destroying their child publicly and proud of it.
Don't forget to subscribe so we can cash in while we cause our child endless trauma for the rest of his life. What a disgrace
Reported as child abuse.
If UA-cam actually does something, goodbye to your video, *Sacconejoly.*
Oh multiple? Absolutely no awareness of what this actually is or entails. I have supported you for years. But I do genuinely think any issues like this, or when Amelia had anxiety etc are private. These really are videos that will never disappear. As adults we regret things, but you shouldn't be subjecting your child to this level of notoriety
Can someone please step in. I don’t want this child to absolutely hate his parents in the future. This is so sad.
Edie clearly was drawn to the Spiderman jacket! Just let them choose and be more fluid than so rigid. It's clearly Anna's idea of what a female is rather than how Edie feels.
Exactly, one of my sons currently loves to wear pink and purple and anything Elsa, as well as race cars and rough and tumble games. Our neighbour's son wears his hair long and wears only dresses while her daughter wants her hair short and wears only Spiderman and dark colours. I thought we had advanced enough as a society to give children a little more freedom of expression. Instead of forcing them into outdated gender roles.
Did you even listen at all? Edie went to the spiderman jacket for her little brother
@@annaf3915 Did you listen? She did not go there for Dre at all, Anna twisted it and said something about him looking for Dre. Edie said nothing about that until Anna made her feel bad for looking.
The mother wants a daughter...disgusting abuse of a child. He went straigth to the boys superhero costumes and the mother called him away " We are actually here for you Edie"..pathetic.
this is what happens when you give people too much freedom
who is giving freedom?
who decides what freedom you get or I get?
@@cailineireann1359 the law, common sense, and facts
Too much freedom...whaaaaa?? Are you speaking of children?
"Edie, go along with the whole gender Clinic stuff and we'll buy you whatever you want...😡
Poor Eduardo, he doesn’t deserve such vicious parents
Are there any other family members who can step in and save this child ?