From "If you talk to Rose" to "I love you," I had to blink really hard to keep from tearing. Really, really hard. This is beautiful and heartbreaking. And how much do *I* love *you* for using both 9 and 10? Lots. I'm so glad your vidding again!!!
I can feel my heart break a little bit every time I see this video (or anything with Doc/Rose actually...). This was beautiful, and the song really really fits.
Words can't even begin to describe how brilliant that was!!! I just finished watching season 2 but i've seen The Journey's End scene on the beach and was a little mad that The Doctor didn't say it but now with this video I can take his "Does it need saying" comment with a little more meaning. Fantastic job!
i bet a hundred of the views on this are from me alone.... this video is so amazing, it just takes my breath away every time. before, i was so angry that the doctor couldnt just come out and say he loved rose, but now i realize.... it didnt really need saying. such a beautiful video, i cant get enough of it!
Second place in some contest for best tear-jerker? Hell to the YES. Simply gorgeous and so full of emotion...you did a really lovely job with clip matching and clip selection, and I love the song too -it fits them PERFECTLY. And it's one of the best vids for DW I've seen in terms of use of voice-overs. Fantastic job!
wow. just wow. i loved the message in the song and how you incorporated it perfectly with the clips. (2:29 - 2:47 is a prime example!!) i loved how the ending just wrapped everything up. it was so achingly beautiful. thank you so much for creating this!
I'm afraid my exact thoughts were taken by skyborn, posted a few days ago. Absolutely brilliant video. Thank you so much for creating this. "Does it need saying?" No it really doesn't. And i've never truly appreciated that until I saw this video.
I actually can't properly express to you how much i love this video. It makes me feel happy but so sad and wistful at the same time. A celebration of their love but never forgetting the loss that the Doctor will have at the end of it all, no matter what. true enough, it didn't need to be said, he so so loves her, enough to let her go again. brilliant! 5/5
Ouch. This is really good, in a tear-jerker sort of way. Thank you. This video really highlighted for me the Doctor's love for Rose in the context of his repeated inability (refusal, etc) to say so. Ouch. Because obviously it did need saying, and showing, which he knew. Ouch again.
oh my goodness!! that was so beautiful!! i especially loved 2:30-2:46! it made me cry all over again. and the ending!!! i dont even know where to begin with the ending! that was the most perfect way to sum up the whole video.
I love this video. You know, I just found the Doctor a few weeks back and watched every single one of the new episodes up to the second season finale. That was when I found out that they are not going to be together and due to this stopped watching. Your video really got me crying and it is the perfect finish for me. I will keep this in mind as their actuall ending, because to me it is so much better. It gives you that hope, that he really doesn't need to say it to make it ok.
Hey Sophie... It feels rather odd sitting in your lounge room and commenting on your beautiful new video! =D It really is wonderful soph. I adore the song and clip choice (as you know!) It's just perfect. So sad to be leaving tomorrow, but thrilled that I had the chance to see the making of this video. Sarah (seduff) xx
Oh my gosh! That was amazing- no amazing isnt a good enough word! Seriously, Wow! That was so great to return to after my summer holiday- what a great home-coming! Thank you so much for uploading! You seriously rock! 5 *'s Just don't leave it so long next time! :P
YOU!!!! You have made it up for the last few months by making this. Also, having Seduff's help on this. Aww that's very sweet of her. The audio is awesome. Just GORGEOUS vid. :D
That was beautiful. The perfect video. I love what you did with the colouring vs. black and white. Brilliant idea and amazing effects. Lovely to watch.
how could i have missed this? i'm subed to to many people - so glad i found this - AMAZING - i've been waiting for your next amazing vid - i'm not disapointed - amazing and so sad :( ;) 5 stars and faved :)!
Hey it's Ewoke6096 I absolutley loved it . I always love storys about the doctors love for rose. I almost cried when the doctor is about to say I love you. :'( :) :P
GAH! *Clutches heart* This was GORGEOUS. Totally heart-wrenchingly GORGEOUS. *Sniffles* Can't believe this scene still gets to me... (Well, yes I can, but...)
I couldn't believe when I read that you and Sarah were going to meet. I actually squeed. Love the video btw. I hadn't made one in a while myself, but then suddenly within an hour I had one completed...except for the fact that my computer won't change it to a .wmv so I can't put it up.
The combined awesomeness of Doctor Who and TPOM made this the first time I've heard this song without thinking of Micheal Jackson (RIP) Absolutely brilliant! 2.45 gave me shivers!!!
Oh. No. I totally get the video. And yes, Rose should understand that in his own indirect way, the Doctor has told her that he loves her. It's just my preference that he should say it. I mean, if he said "Rose, I love you" I can just imagine that he's talking to me. :D
It was one shot straight 10/10. Lovely, intriguing, this a plot and good background music, and have a finish like a start. Just one of the best :) Good work. 1-2nd seasons is my favourite. Rassell T Davis is a genius:)) love it's a miracle to create. And your words about 3-4 give me a strength to continue watch :) Did you see 5 season? If yes,what about Rose and Doctor there? Excuse me for this question, I'm a bit curiously, oh, no, I have it a lot ;) Thank you for this vid again, it was great.
An absolutely fantastic video! Perfect work! And it convinces me that I have to make my videos with Avid as well... (I kinda hate that program... but unfortunately, it offers most possibilities in video editing *sigs*)
The first time they were on the beach, he said "Rose Tyler..." but was then cut off when his projected image shut off. I assume that was because the crack in the wall between worlds he was using to project the image closed. The second time, when she asked him what he was going to say, all he said was, "Does it need saying?" She then asked the other Doctor who, according to Julie Gardner, whispered "I love you" in her ear. I can only assume that's what he said by her reaction. ;)
Well, it was on the radio the day I found out he died, and I had had it in my head all day while it was on the news and things. I thought "Haven't we said it all?" was sort of appropriate when radio DJs were trying to find as many different ways as possible of saying "M.J's dead." :)
@Nystea - Yeah, I agree with THEpowerOFme, keep watching! If you want to end on a happyish note stop at the beginning of Journey's End. S3 wasn't a particular favorite of mine (though there were a few excellent episodes) but S4 was one of my favorite seasons. And both seasons had Rose references you'd probably like.
This is completely lovely! The song is really perfect for them, and I love how you started and ended it with the "does it need saying?" beach scene! I'm so glad to see you back vidding again! I can't wait for more! Also, random, but do you mind telling me the name of the font you used for the beginning and end titles? I love it!
Although I look forward to seeing Matt Smith's version of the Doctor. I will alway look fondly on the David Tennant / Billie Piper companion ship. I think the way Russell Davies wrote their subtle romance was fantastic. Well I am getting away from my main point. Thanks for the tears, it was a really moving movie.
I loooove take that, i am the biggest fan no question lolz.. The song is just 'said it all'. I had to sing this infront of my school last week (1500 people) LET ME MARRY YOU GARY BARLOW
You know, I just finished listening to the run of audio dramas from Big Finish with Eight and Charley, and I have a theory now why the Doctor couldn't tell Rose he loved her. After he and Charley said they loved each other, terrible things happened. And, knowing the Doctor, who at the best of times is dense when it comes to love, he probably became very afraid of telling someone he loved them, because it hurt so much the last time he did so. But that's just my way of making sense of it. ;)
From "If you talk to Rose" to "I love you," I had to blink really hard to keep from tearing. Really, really hard. This is beautiful and heartbreaking. And how much do *I* love *you* for using both 9 and 10? Lots. I'm so glad your vidding again!!!
I can feel my heart break a little bit every time I see this video (or anything with Doc/Rose actually...). This was beautiful, and the song really really fits.
Words can't even begin to describe how brilliant that was!!! I just finished watching season 2 but i've seen The Journey's End scene on the beach and was a little mad that The Doctor didn't say it but now with this video I can take his "Does it need saying" comment with a little more meaning.
Fantastic job!
i bet a hundred of the views on this are from me alone.... this video is so amazing, it just takes my breath away every time. before, i was so angry that the doctor couldnt just come out and say he loved rose, but now i realize.... it didnt really need saying. such a beautiful video, i cant get enough of it!
This is absolutely the best Doctor/Rose fanvid I have EVER seen... Ever. Gorgeous!
GAH! words can't describe! that has to be one of the best doctor/rose videos out there! wow, just.. WOW xx
Second place in some contest for best tear-jerker? Hell to the YES. Simply gorgeous and so full of emotion...you did a really lovely job with clip matching and clip selection, and I love the song too -it fits them PERFECTLY. And it's one of the best vids for DW I've seen in terms of use of voice-overs. Fantastic job!
wonderful david tennant clips combined with clips of the previous doctor. fantastic !
wow. just wow. i loved the message in the song and how you incorporated it perfectly with the clips. (2:29 - 2:47 is a prime example!!) i loved how the ending just wrapped everything up. it was so achingly beautiful. thank you so much for creating this!
Amazing! Love This Song, It Fits The Doctor And Rose's Relationship Perfectly! 5* And Faved!
x
I'm afraid my exact thoughts were taken by skyborn, posted a few days ago. Absolutely brilliant video. Thank you so much for creating this. "Does it need saying?" No it really doesn't. And i've never truly appreciated that until I saw this video.
I actually can't properly express to you how much i love this video. It makes me feel happy but so sad and wistful at the same time. A celebration of their love but never forgetting the loss that the Doctor will have at the end of it all, no matter what. true enough, it didn't need to be said, he so so loves her, enough to let her go again. brilliant! 5/5
Ouch. This is really good, in a tear-jerker sort of way. Thank you. This video really highlighted for me the Doctor's love for Rose in the context of his repeated inability (refusal, etc) to say so. Ouch. Because obviously it did need saying, and showing, which he knew. Ouch again.
Ive seen ALOT of Rose/Doctor videos but this is by far the best!
oh my goodness!! that was so beautiful!! i especially loved 2:30-2:46! it made me cry all over again. and the ending!!! i dont even know where to begin with the ending! that was the most perfect way to sum up the whole video.
Well, it's been a while since I've cried because of a DW vid, nice work, I am now in hysterics. Great great vid....
I've watched this four times and it's made me cry each time..
I've lost track of the amount of times I've watched and commented on this video! But it still gives me shivers!
I love this video. You know, I just found the Doctor a few weeks back and watched every single one of the new episodes up to the second season finale. That was when I found out that they are not going to be together and due to this stopped watching. Your video really got me crying and it is the perfect finish for me. I will keep this in mind as their actuall ending, because to me it is so much better. It gives you that hope, that he really doesn't need to say it to make it ok.
Hey Sophie... It feels rather odd sitting in your lounge room and commenting on your beautiful new video! =D
It really is wonderful soph. I adore the song and clip choice (as you know!) It's just perfect.
So sad to be leaving tomorrow, but thrilled that I had the chance to see the making of this video. Sarah (seduff) xx
The ending was really dramatic and really effective. Great video! :D
beautiful as always...
brought a tear to my eye.
feel like i need to watch all the dt and bp episodes all over again...
thanks for sharing.
Congratulations! You totally made me cry! Oh my this was so, so very good. Wonderful job, total tear jerker!
keep forgetting how much I love this! so amazing there's litterally no word to describe it! XxX
great song,great episode ,great vid!they made me cry........such a beautifull,sad,and happy in the same time love story....
Oh my gosh! That was amazing- no amazing isnt a good enough word! Seriously, Wow!
That was so great to return to after my summer holiday- what a great home-coming! Thank you so much for uploading! You seriously rock!
5 *'s Just don't leave it so long next time! :P
YOU!!!! You have made it up for the last few months by making this. Also, having Seduff's help on this. Aww that's very sweet of her. The audio is awesome. Just GORGEOUS vid. :D
That was beautiful. The perfect video. I love what you did with the colouring vs. black and white. Brilliant idea and amazing effects. Lovely to watch.
absolutely beautiful!! love it! this song is just perfect for the doctor and rose!
Stupid Doctor! Of course it needs saying!
GREAT video.
The clips and the lyrics and the different colors and EVERYTHING!
:D
Favorite and 5 stars!!
Brilliant! I loved it, one of the best Rose/Doctor videos I have seen!
OMG Doctor who and Take that
perfect
this is an amazing video!
love it
faved!
Back again, and it's still as awesome as the first time I saw it! :D x
Fantastic!! i love how you edited it and the song was a perfect fit for the Ten/Rose love story. Nice job!
aww absolutely PERFECT song choice, you're right, the lyrics went really well- well done on another wonderful video:)
this is brilliant and the song really fits them, good job! 5 stars!
Heartbreakingly BEAUTIFUL and even those words dont do it justice. Deffo tear jurking!!
Sophs thats amazing it was well worth the wait ly
Sally ღ
oh wow
the timing was perfect
the clips were perfect
the whole video was perfect
5 stars :D
This made me cry. Thank you, I've subscribed.
That was absolutely amazing!
The song is wonderful and really matches The Doctor and Rose!
I love 2:29-3:04
I had to keep watching that over and over!
Literally crying.
as allways 5/5 and fave.
each vid gets bigger and better :)
good job
I absolutely loved this!
So powerful!!!
Oh my gosh. I cried...amazing my friend!
I love, love, love this video!! You're great at editing!!!
Amazing job once again, very well edited and perfect song choice :D
WOW that was just....amazing!So beautiful and sooo sad.And...so about those two!
Still in love with this video... :)
Wow this is a very powerful music video. Am very impressed.
how could i have missed this? i'm subed to to many people - so glad i found this - AMAZING - i've been waiting for your next amazing vid - i'm not disapointed - amazing and so sad :( ;) 5 stars and faved :)!
damn that makes me almost cry everytime i watch it
i hate it but i love it gahhhhhhh Rose and Doctor are meant for eachother!!!
I love this video, everything about it. Well done!
Hell yes it needs saying! lol. utterly amazing video. A great tribute to an amazing couple:)
3.01-3.03 is amazingly beautiful
wow, great video ! Loved it !
I absolutely love your editing !
Hey it's Ewoke6096
I absolutley loved it . I always love storys about the doctors love for rose. I almost cried when the doctor is about to say I love you. :'( :) :P
i think i love you for making such an amazing video lol
omfg im gonna cryy soo mutch
this so beautiful and well done
GAH! *Clutches heart* This was GORGEOUS. Totally heart-wrenchingly GORGEOUS. *Sniffles* Can't believe this scene still gets to me... (Well, yes I can, but...)
this is a reli good video ty 4 making it !! x
Fantastic. Brilliant. (As said by the doctor.) Nothing else need saying. 5 stars and a favorite. :)
Hah... thank YOU for putting my exact thoughts down!
I couldn't believe when I read that you and Sarah were going to meet. I actually squeed. Love the video btw.
I hadn't made one in a while myself, but then suddenly within an hour I had one completed...except for the fact that my computer won't change it to a .wmv so I can't put it up.
Fantastic video!!! Glad to see you back!
yeh but we all wanted to hear it lol xx love the vid anyway watched it so many times!
The combined awesomeness of Doctor Who and TPOM made this the first time I've heard this song without thinking of Micheal Jackson (RIP)
Absolutely brilliant! 2.45 gave me shivers!!!
Oh. No. I totally get the video. And yes, Rose should understand that in his own indirect way, the Doctor has told her that he loves her. It's just my preference that he should say it. I mean, if he said "Rose, I love you" I can just imagine that he's talking to me. :D
It was one shot straight 10/10. Lovely, intriguing, this a plot and good background music, and have a finish like a start. Just one of the best :) Good work. 1-2nd seasons is my favourite. Rassell T Davis is a genius:)) love it's a miracle to create. And your words about 3-4 give me a strength to continue watch :) Did you see 5 season? If yes,what about Rose and Doctor there? Excuse me for this question, I'm a bit curiously, oh, no, I have it a lot ;) Thank you for this vid again, it was great.
you are excellent at this.
Simply...Wow.
xxx
*tear* *wipe* that was really awesome....*tear*
Love Doctor Who
Love Take That
Love the video
Great Work!!!
-x-
Omg, of course! Thank you! :D
it DOES need saying arghh
great vid xx
An absolutely fantastic video! Perfect work!
And it convinces me that I have to make my videos with Avid as well... (I kinda hate that program... but unfortunately, it offers most possibilities in video editing *sigs*)
The first time they were on the beach, he said "Rose Tyler..." but was then cut off when his projected image shut off. I assume that was because the crack in the wall between worlds he was using to project the image closed.
The second time, when she asked him what he was going to say, all he said was, "Does it need saying?" She then asked the other Doctor who, according to Julie Gardner, whispered "I love you" in her ear. I can only assume that's what he said by her reaction. ;)
wow le super montage !!! félicitations !! I liked it very much !! 5 stars ;-)
Wonderful.... this is fantastic. Gorgeous. Well done :)
Well, it was on the radio the day I found out he died, and I had had it in my head all day while it was on the news and things. I thought "Haven't we said it all?" was sort of appropriate when radio DJs were trying to find as many different ways as possible of saying "M.J's dead." :)
Waw! Fantastic work!!!
This is beautiful just like this fanfic I read :(
@Nystea - Yeah, I agree with THEpowerOFme, keep watching! If you want to end on a happyish note stop at the beginning of Journey's End. S3 wasn't a particular favorite of mine (though there were a few excellent episodes) but S4 was one of my favorite seasons. And both seasons had Rose references you'd probably like.
agh!! i keep watching it!!
hey it's me still lovin it
and can't wait for your next one
bye
This is completely lovely! The song is really perfect for them, and I love how you started and ended it with the "does it need saying?" beach scene! I'm so glad to see you back vidding again! I can't wait for more!
Also, random, but do you mind telling me the name of the font you used for the beginning and end titles? I love it!
:'( Beautiful, and so so sad :P
Well done :D
LOVE it... great, brilliant, fantactic, and *sigh*
holly shit that was good! sorry for the language but OMG that video was awesome, off the charts awesome!
fantastic ! brilliant ! epic !
Why didn't you win first place? This was amazing! I nearly cried, and I am NOT a cryer.
Very nice!!
Although I look forward to seeing Matt Smith's version of the Doctor. I will alway look fondly on the David Tennant / Billie Piper companion ship. I think the way Russell Davies wrote their subtle romance was fantastic. Well I am getting away from my main point. Thanks for the tears, it was a really moving movie.
Sometimes it does need saying.
I loooove take that, i am the biggest fan no question lolz.. The song is just 'said it all'. I had to sing this infront of my school last week (1500 people) LET ME MARRY YOU GARY BARLOW
i so love thsi video it so cool and sweet
You know, I just finished listening to the run of audio dramas from Big Finish with Eight and Charley, and I have a theory now why the Doctor couldn't tell Rose he loved her. After he and Charley said they loved each other, terrible things happened. And, knowing the Doctor, who at the best of times is dense when it comes to love, he probably became very afraid of telling someone he loved them, because it hurt so much the last time he did so.
But that's just my way of making sense of it. ;)
Oh my...You really captured it right there! Keep putting out the awesome videos! I hope one day I can be as good as you! What program do you use?