He needs you • The Human Doctor and Rose
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 лют 2025
- This video was 'Judges Choice' in Immortal Sparrows's & CILLEXD's 'Breathless Contest'
This is set Post-Journey's End.
Relationships are complicated - especially if you're with a man that looks, sounds and thinks exactly like the love of your life - except it isn't the same person. So Rose pushes him away but regrets it after a while...
My first Human Doctor/Rose AU got lost when my old account was deleted and I really wanted to do something like it again. I gave it a warm and sunny touch since the weather at home has been a bit grey the last couple of days. ^^
Anyway - I hope you'll enjoy. This is my first video on my 'new' channel and it's also my first video with Pinnacle Ultimate so I'm a bit nervous about it.
By the way - almost every single clip (and everytime Rose & 10.5 are 'talking') is a pure fake. I took the clips from various shows as 'Blackpool', 'Secret Diary of a Call Girl' and 'Secret Smile'. The only real Doctor Who scene's are the scene's at Bad Wolf Bay and the scene where Jackie comforts Rose... ^^
Feel free to fav, rate & share and please tell me what you think of it!
Take care
Andrea
Song: Hometown Glory by Adele
Honors for this video
13th of August 2009
#60 - Heiß diskutiert (heute)
#10 - Heiß diskutiert (heute) - Unterhaltung
#17 - Top-Favoriten (heute)
#3 - Top-Favoriten (heute) - Unterhaltung
#65 - Top-Favoriten (diese Woche) - Unterhaltung
#30 - Beste Bewertung (heute)
#4 - Beste Bewertung (heute) - Unterhaltung
#23 - Beste Bewertung (diese Woche) - Unterhaltung
i just relized,( i mean i know that the doctor loved Rose) but the 10,2 is a reflection of the doctor and that means that the things doctor 10,2 did was the things that the real doctor wanted to do! He wanted to have life with her, he wanted to say i love you, but he couldn't, so he made the doctor 10,2 do it instead!
What i'm trying to say here is that the doctor really loved Rose, and i think he always will...
10.2 has what 10 doesn't - he's part Donna.
ten too had all the same memories same thoughts same everything... the only thing he didn't do was regenerate... what makes it so sad is that the doctor really truly loved rose, but gave her a part of himself that loved her like he did, wouldn't hurt her, could have a life with her grow old with her while he was forever alone with only her memory as a part of him forever...
I just made myself sad....
twiggysangel13 Yeah but 10,2 talks a bit like Donna so he is a bit Different:)
This would be a great spin off show, meta crisis doctor and Rose finding a way forward and coping with the changes that brings❤❤❤
love the picture at the beginning with the kiss and 'he needs you'
love the creepy secret smile DT in the middle.
LOVE LOVE LOVE the smile at the end.
This is fab - thanks for sharing!
Its the middel of the night and I'm SOBBING at how incredibly this is edited, Rose and Human!Doctor is everything and this feels SO realistic to their story
I love this! Always very excited to see a new Human Doctor/Rose vid and yours did not disappoint. It was wonderful. I recognised a few of the set ups of the shots from other videos, but you changed them enough to make them feel fresh. Favourited and faved.
I just watched 'Journey's End'...and I'll admit that I watched this vid first. I almost wish I hadn't: you did this so well, the writers of the show could learn a few things from you. I love how you've edited this together -it really had me believing that we got to see the human Doctor and Rose coming to terms with being left on that beach. Seeing an episode like this, with tension and resolution and Rose's acceptance would have resolved the hurt of being left behind for me. Thx for making this!
This was really clever how you pieced together bits from their other work to say what the Doctor & Rose always wanted to say. Loved it. The editing was seamless!
Aaaw thank you so much, hun! I'm really glad you liked it! It really means a lot to me! :D
Even though I don't want you to cry, I have to say that this is really sweet of you, dear! ♥
Aaw. Thank you so much! I'm happy you enjoyed watching it!
Well, I take suggestions and if I get inspired I'll do it. Oh, and I have to like the song - which is hard buisness because my 'normal' music taste is... well... a little different. ;-)
Wow. Thanks a lot for your HUGE compliment! You made me smile. :D
I first heard the song in a trailer to a german movie 'zweiohrkücken' and instantly fell in love with it. You're right - I sped it up a bit because I wanted to avoid copyrith claims... ^^
Anyway - thanks a lot for your lovely comment! I'm so happy you enjoyed watching it! :-)
Wow. That is some skilled editting there!
Thank you so much! I'm really honored that I inspired you to finish your new video. Take care! :D
Good morning! xD
Thanks a lot for your lovely comment. I'm glad you enjoyed watching it!
Well, there are so many 10.5/Rose vids out there and were all limited to the same clips so it's always difficult to make a video that seems 'completely new' but I'm happy that you think it worked! :-)
Thanks a lot for the fav and the lovely comment!
Woah! There are so many fantastic AU-vids out there... Thank you so much for the huge compliment! xD
This video is in my favorites and I watch every 6 months or so and every single time it makes me insanely emotional! You did such a wonderful job. Some fanvids are just clips over music and it doesn't make any sense but this is what a real fanvid should be... a beautiful story! A++
Wow. Thank you! I'm immensely flattered that you still like it so much after all this time. That's quite a compliment!
Nyah86Production
You are very welcome :)
Aaw. Thank you so much! xD
I'm usually not the 'Happy-Endings-type' - except when it's about this couple. :D
@ DayDreamBeliever87
Thank you so much for your lovely comment! I'm glad you enjoyed watching it. :D
Thank you so much! I'm so flattered/happy/excited that you like my work!I can't tell you how much this means to me.
Thank you so much for your lovely comment, for the high rating and the fav. It means an awful lot to me! :-)
@ deBadWolff
Thank you so much for your lovely comment! I'm happy you enjoyed watching it! :D
I must say outstanding. Brilliant editing and beautiful video. Of my all-time favortie couple. 5 stars. Thank you for sharing it.
Oh my goodness. The editing... it's just so good. Absolutely wonderful. Brings back all the feels instantly. Well done!!
I loved that it was fantstic. especially how you had what they said on bad wolf bay echoing throught the vid. Also i've always loved rose and the human doctor vids.
I can't count the number of times I have re-watched this vid. I was so excited when i saw it in my subs box and I've been goingback to all the time ever since...even going so far as to watch it on my phone. Amazing job!
Thank you very much! I'm glad you liked it.
The scene you asked about is from 'Secret Smile'.
i've been watching a few human doctor/rose videos now, and thought Seduff had the best. Till I found yours...and realized this video of yours was wow...just as good. I love the way you did it, and after watching what feels like a hundred different 10.2/ rose vids, your video here is one of the tops I've seen.
Thank you so much for your lovely comment! I'm so glad you like it!
It's good to have you back! :D
Well, unfortunately I can't upload my old 10.5/Rose video because I didn't have a copy of it on my hard disc when my old account was suspended. *sniff* I lost it.
It's like watching a 3 minute movie and I LOVE that! Especially when it has a happy ending, that just makes me smile =). You are BRILLIANT and this video is just proof of that!!!! New video on the vlog and 5/5*s
@1Lestatslover Thanks a lot for the compliment. I'm happy you liked it! :-)
Excellent editing and I liked how you put his picture on her intercom screen. :D Very well done.
Aww. Thank you! *hugs*
I'm really happy you liked it so much!
It is my favorite! It gives me the comfort of knowing that in some way, love will always find a way to succeed
This love story makes me cry. I could not imagine that it could be so difficult to find together. I wish Rose this love so much, and I thank you for this beautiful video.
This is fabulous. It broke my heart over and over. I miss them sooooo much. Thank you.
Incredible? Seriiously? Wow.
Thank you so much for your lovely comment, the high rating and the fav! It means an awful lot to me!
@xcupcakesandbubblesx Wow. Thank you! That's quite a compliment! :-)
I'm really thrilled that you enjoyed watching it so much. Means a lot.
@3030jane I'm glad you liked it! Thanks a lot for commenting! :-)
This is incredible, as is every other video in your CRAZY impressive collection!! Please, please, keep it up! You're the best video editor I've seen, full stop.
Aww! That was incredible!
The editing was wonderful, you would think they had been in another show together! Love it! 5* and faved!
*goes off to watch again*
Aaw. Thank you so much! I'm really happy you liked it! Makes the whole vidding effort a lot more while! Take care!
I always wonder what I would say to my friends if I made a video like this... you must be so proud! And, if not, you sure as hell should be!! x
Wow. Thank you very much! I'm glad you liked it.
It feels good to vid again. Believe me, I had huge withdrawal syndromes. xD
Thank you! I'm happy you enjoyed watching it. :-)
*jaw drops* Wow. I don't know what to say. Seduff is an editing genious and to be compared with her is a HUGE compliment! Thank you so much! I can't tell you what this means to me. Wow. :D
This song went perfectly with this video. Well done.
@tinkerbellfanatic07 Thank you so much! I'm really happy you enjoyed watching it! :-)
Wow. Thank YOU!
I'm glad you enjoyed watching it so much!
Aaw. Thank you so much! I'm really happy you enjoyed watching it! :D
Have to agree with below. Absolutely on the same level as my favorite seduff. You one a new subscriber!
Thank you so much for your lovely comment! I'm glad you enjoyed watching it!
I first heard the song in the trailer to the German movie 'ZweiOhrKücken' and I instantly fell in love with this song. :-)
@xopinkmoonxo Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed watching it! :D
Good to see you back Andrea! Great video! Pieced together very well!
Aww so beautifully done! I really adore your videos, as do many people. Keep up the amazing work!
wieder einmal großartige arbeit. ich liebe diese rose/human doctor videos und deins ist wirklich wundervoll.
Aw. Thank you so much, hun!
I'm glad you liked it. xD
@CrazyGood88 Wow. That's quite a compliment since there are hundreds if not thousands of Human Doctor/Rose videos on UA-cam. Thank you so much! This really means a lot. :-)
There are some really crap versions off stuff like this, but this is incrediable the timing is spot on x x
Aaw. Thank you so much!
I'm really glad you like it! xD
Thank you so much for your amazing comment! Your feedback always means a lot to me. *hugs you back*
It was hard to do this video after such a long vidding break. I think I got a little out of practise so I'm happy that you think it's belieable. ^^
I tried to give the video a sunny and warm touch since the German weather has been a little weird the last couple of days... xD
Oh my God that was just amazing I loved every second of it all the clips fitted
together perfectly I just love it plus I was watching on my phone which makes it even better
Thank you so much! :D
I'm glad you liked 2:10 to 2:18. I was a bit unsure about that clips because I think they're a bit random. xD
OMG!!!!!!!!
What a wonderful vid! Excellent work! Oh my! Thank you so much!
ABSOLUTELY LOVED THIS VIDEO! it's one the the best i've ever seen for the Human Doctor and Rose!
OH MY GOSH all your suff is just too amazing for words! Thank you, you beautiful person for making the videos that you do!
Andrea, this video is fantastic!! It's so amazing!))
Thank you!!)
@StrawberyFreakTARDIS Hehe, thank you very much! I'm glad you enjoyed watching it! :-)
Hahaha! That's exactly what I intended when I made it! :D
Thank you so much for your lovely comment. I'm happy you enjoyed watching it!
Aaw. Thank you so much, hun! :D
I'm glad you enjoyed watching it.
Aaw. You're so sweet. Thank you so much! :D
@lusmeitli21 It's not a "real" Doctor Who episode. It's a manipulation of various scenes from different shows of Billie Piper and David Tennant. I used clips from Secret Diary of a Call Girl, Blackpool & Secret Smile. I cut it together so that it looks as if The Doctor and Rose are talking but it's in fact just a montage. :-)
Aaaw. Thank you so much! I'm really happy you think so!
This is so amazing. Like, I can't even explain how much I love this.
0:45. Rose, "I'm not ready to be your girlfriend." Doctor " Fine then, f*ck you." 'storms out of house'
favorite part
This is absolute GENIUS.
Wow. Thank you so much! I'm really thrilled that you enjoy watching it so much! Makes the effort worth a lot more while! :D
wuaaaaaaaa Lovely!!!!.. I loved it!! fantastic video!
five stars!
Thank you so much, Gabz.
I'm glad you liked it! xD
Thank you so much! I'm glad you liked it!
About the echo effect: I've never used Sony Vegas (I'm editing with Pinnacle) so I'm sorry that I can't help you.
Your work is like incredibly amazing and emotional and I love it
Aaw, Miriam du bist einfach die Beste!
Vielen, vielen Dank!
P.S. Ach, 5 Sterne reichen locker aus. *frech-grins*
I'm never sure what I think about Rose/Human doctor vids because I'm not sure that I agree with what would happen with them. Because I think that actually Rose would not really see any differences between them, she would only possibly have doubts because she knows the Doctor is alone without her...
That being said, I appreciate that this is AU and your interpretation, and it's one of the best if not the best edited Rose/Human Doctor vids i've seen so very well done! x
@Xx5matty5xX Thank you! I'm glad you liked it! :-)
WOW. *jaw drops*
Thank you so much!
Loved it ! I missed your vids and I'm so glad to see you're back !
Your manips and clips were perfect.
2:10 to 2:18 are genius ! ^^ 5*
I have no words for this video so just : awwww ❤️❤️❤️
Thank YOU! I'm glad you liked it so much! :D
aww so well done!!! I MISS THEM SO MUCH :3
Thank you!
i'm glad you enjoyed watching it! :D
Such A Brillaint Video, I Love It Strait To My Favorites And 5 Stars, Well Done! :D
Thank you! I'm thrilled you think so! :D
Yeah, I'm the same. I think Rose absolutely hit the jackpot. I wouldn't think about it even a second long. :D
Thanks so much for your lovely comment, hun. I'm glad you liked it!
Aaw, thank YOU! I'm so glad you enjoyed watching it! :-)
Still my favourite video on the Internet 😍
Wow. *speechless*
Thank you so much for the compliment! I'm so happy you like my videos. :D
Your comment had me beaming!
Wow. Thank you so much for your lovely comment, for the high rating and for putting it on your vlog! Means a lot! :D
Wow. Thank you! I'm happy you liked it! :D
Makes the editing effort worth a lot more while...
I definately wanna do a Human Doctor/Rose video again if I get inspired.