A very fair and comprehensive analysis and makes understandable the confusion over the supernaturalality of the apparitions. I find I’m in agreement with both his rationale and conclusion. My only question is his dismissal of the demonic in phase two. If the second phase is not from heaven, then surely there is only one other place it can originate from? I think we can’t underestimate the cunning subtly of evil to distract and confuse, or am I being too binary in my thinking?
A very fair and comprehensive analysis and makes understandable the confusion over the supernaturalality of the apparitions. I find I’m in agreement with both his rationale and conclusion. My only question is his dismissal of the demonic in phase two. If the second phase is not from heaven, then surely there is only one other place it can originate from? I think we can’t underestimate the cunning subtly of evil to distract and confuse, or am I being too binary in my thinking?
It's a demon. Anyone who knows Our Lady knows that's not her.