Promise for a Better City (1944-1964) - Philadelphia: The Great Experiment

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 9 лют 2025
  • For free educational materials, visit our website at www.historymakingproductions.com/philadelphia-the-great-experiment
    Promise For A Better City
    Part Three of documentary series
    "Philadelphia: The Great Experiment" 1944-1964.
    Watch more at www.historyofph...
    Check out our website! historymakingpr...
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 102

  • @JaneReRe
    @JaneReRe 3 роки тому +13

    18:35 My family owned an entire block of homes behind Dock Street. Most moved out during this push to rebuild a society Hill. Most moved to the newly built neighborhoods furthur north like Olney & Feltonville.

  • @drakkar91
    @drakkar91 9 років тому +23

    What tremendous history is contained within this episode (along with the others I have watched). While the primary focus is Philadelphia, many of the challengers of the times applied across our nation. Well done. Very journalistic in quality.

    • @JaneReRe
      @JaneReRe 3 роки тому +7

      I learned more about my city watching this than 12 yrs of education there. All young Philadelphians should be made to watch this, I'm sure they'd have more respect for it when they see the hard work it took to build such a city.

    • @seekingthemosthigh5978
      @seekingthemosthigh5978 2 роки тому +1

      evil history.

  • @BrianJasonTurner
    @BrianJasonTurner 10 років тому +10

    Very Good Documentary, you create history everyday, the choices you make today shape the future. Hopefully people learn from the good and the bad of the past.

  • @brandadavis2958
    @brandadavis2958 8 років тому +27

    They mention the beginnings of the new music scene and early Rock & Roll - in South Philly and North Philly - even noting Dick Clark and American Bandstand - without mentioning West Philly and the fact that American Bandstand was broadcast within a stone's throw of West Philly High ... arguably the hippest music and dance scene in the country!

    • @Mynamesalexa
      @Mynamesalexa 4 роки тому +4

      A guy I served in the Navy with Graduated there 1967

    • @tkso.philly3879
      @tkso.philly3879 4 роки тому +1

      You're right.Right up Market street.

  • @MrsCraigJrPhiladelphia
    @MrsCraigJrPhiladelphia Рік тому +2

    My father and his brothers were raised on 5th and
    G. avenue❤

    • @edwardpalumbo5237
      @edwardpalumbo5237 Місяць тому

      I worked for Airborne Express and that was my area...Erie Ave. Coca cola

  • @bmp456
    @bmp456 6 років тому +17

    It’s a shame that they had to trash so many beautiful 19th century buildings around center city and old city. Doing that to places like market Street honestly makes the city less bearable with all of these dreary modern buildings.

    • @TheMuveTube
      @TheMuveTube 5 років тому +3

      bmp456 agreed

    • @curtisgaither3625
      @curtisgaither3625 3 роки тому +3

      @@TheMuveTube I thoroughly agree, all for a Walgreen or a Starbucks. I miss the old landmarks

  • @futuregenerationz
    @futuregenerationz 5 років тому +5

    I love this!

  • @gortbot7748
    @gortbot7748 Рік тому +2

    My Mom was a secretary at the Navy Yard, she took the subway, then the bus to work. She talks about the day Roosevelt died, everybody on the subway was crying openly.

  • @briansmith9439
    @briansmith9439 6 років тому +6

    Great series though the name Society Hill goes back to colonial days when the Free Society of Traders made the area south of Dock Creek their headquarters; it was called Society Hill as far back as 1690.

  • @joesielskisr4911
    @joesielskisr4911 Рік тому +4

    My dad was not drafted because he welded ships😊

  • @kenlynch7639
    @kenlynch7639 9 днів тому

    It's amazing in these documentaries there's no mention of Frank Rizzo, who is both a cop a police chief and the mayor. Who cleaned up the city's crime like no other the way Giuliani cleaned up New York. That's why he had a statue.

  • @gregorybiche89
    @gregorybiche89 2 роки тому +2

    OK so at 4:11 that's Philly Joe Jones on the far left

    • @ghs5216
      @ghs5216 Місяць тому

      One of the best

  • @davidmccann9811
    @davidmccann9811 2 роки тому +2

    Do North Philly and South Philly still retain their own separate identities today?

    • @AB-wf8ek
      @AB-wf8ek 8 місяців тому +1

      I don't think you can really characterize Philly neighborhoods as broadly as you used to. At this point there are so many transplants (including myself) that there isn't as strong a mono culture in any particular area.
      In South Philly you definitely still get an Italian American vibe with businesses and older residents. The streets are generally more narrow and dense, but the character can change drastically between blocks.
      Up north, things are relatively more spread out. There are more empty lots and wild spaces, but there's been a lot of development in the past 10 years, so you'll see more newer buildings.
      At this point there are many Black, SE Asian, S American, and Caribbean neighborhoods that are mixed in with everything else.
      I personally think it's amazing. It can feel like traveling to another country sometimes just exploring the different parts of the city. It's one of the major reasons I've enjoyed living here for so many years.

  • @millertj27
    @millertj27 7 років тому +2

    What happened to the years 1872-1943? Not enough going on to warrant its own segment?

    • @CalvinsWorldNews
      @CalvinsWorldNews 7 років тому +5

      "We're currently in production on our final three episodes to span that time period. We have not produced the series in chronological order."

  • @Thomas-f3k5o
    @Thomas-f3k5o 5 місяців тому

    Whitehall park with the big concrete grandstands great softball league back then.

  • @ThomRealEstate-k1y
    @ThomRealEstate-k1y 7 місяців тому

    Bob Horn was the original host of Bandstand not Dick Clark. Penn Center was in the works as far back as the 1920s.and the first improvements were opened by 1930. However the Depression and WW2 had put the brakes on the work until Joe Clark.

  • @1Rhettsgirl13
    @1Rhettsgirl13 3 роки тому +17

    Now the Democrats have all the absolute power in Philadelphia. They know they'll never lose here and they act accordingly. I'm a registered Dem but I know that one party having decades of absolute power is a bad thing.

    • @beachbooxoxo
      @beachbooxoxo 3 роки тому +3

      It doesn't even matter anymore who is in office.

    • @paulremmey398
      @paulremmey398 6 місяців тому

      Bring back manufacturing,jobs
      Everything that comes from China ,we need to make it here

    • @mistyblue526
      @mistyblue526 4 місяці тому

      You are absolutely correct. ​@@beachbooxoxo

  • @samknight5553
    @samknight5553 5 років тому +2

    Grace Kelly, Tina Fey, Kevin Bacon, Veronica Hamel. All Philadelphia natives.

    • @edwardpalumbo5237
      @edwardpalumbo5237 Місяць тому

      I use to deliver express mail to Mr. Bacon on locust Street

  • @sonnypruitt6639
    @sonnypruitt6639 9 років тому +15

    1951 Philly elects the first Democratic mayor since 1872, and there hasn't been a Republican mayor since. Now the shoe is on the other foot.

    • @ztnjv
      @ztnjv 4 роки тому +2

      Yes. But you won’t hear about that in this documentary.

    • @sonnypruitt6639
      @sonnypruitt6639 4 роки тому +4

      @Club Soda @5:29 "When a party's is in power for a long, long time, it essentially writes the rules that it lives by". As corrupt as Philly was pre WWII, under Republican leadership, it is just as much corrupt today under the Democrats.

    • @GeneralAlex4
      @GeneralAlex4 Рік тому

      It's funny that when the Republicans ruled any city it was successful.

    • @AB-wf8ek
      @AB-wf8ek 8 місяців тому

      Seems like a very narrow minded perspective to always bring up political parties

    • @sonnypruitt6639
      @sonnypruitt6639 8 місяців тому

      @@AB-wf8ek Well what the F was the video about?! Better narrow minded than no minded! Moe Ron!

  • @dchang11
    @dchang11 4 роки тому +1

    Society Hill is an eyesore, but its almost a representation of architecture in that era. Think of the former World Trade Center in New York.

  • @craignunnallypurcell
    @craignunnallypurcell Рік тому

    Baltimore probably has a similar history which needs to be told.

  • @tommoore8726
    @tommoore8726 4 роки тому +4

    So we have the story of WASPS and Blacks but nothing about the ascendancy and accomplishments of Catholics in their overcoming Anti-Catholicism despite the institutional bigotry. This period was the time when Catholics really established themselves in the city. But story is totally ignored.

    • @caramia4143
      @caramia4143 Рік тому

      And if it was included, someone else would bring up another that group was being excluded, so on and so forth. Maybe they chose to focus on the bigger stuff and not nitpick every single group of people who did something. Search bar on the top; very useful for people like you.

    • @williamrogers9004
      @williamrogers9004 Рік тому

      Separation of church and state chief. What are you anti-constitution?

    • @tommoore8726
      @tommoore8726 Рік тому

      @@williamrogers9004 I do not understand. Please amplify.

    • @AB-wf8ek
      @AB-wf8ek 8 місяців тому +1

      Chinese have been in this country for hundreds of years, and Chinatown in Philadelphia has been a central part of the city since the mid-1800's. I never hear a single word about that either.

  • @pegmanning4540
    @pegmanning4540 8 років тому +1

    Oh, HELL, no! Bacon ruined the lives of thousands of people.

  • @musasmall302
    @musasmall302 5 років тому +1

    22:57 look just like lil uzi and he from down that way

  • @patrickdecaumette7055
    @patrickdecaumette7055 8 років тому +6

    Like it, or not.
    This is history, not your take on it.
    It is very sad to read such blatant racism.
    That too shall pass...with an open mind

  • @yingxiong9780
    @yingxiong9780 7 років тому +1

    Ed Bacon????????

    • @auapplemac1976
      @auapplemac1976 3 роки тому

      He was the Head of the city's Planning Commission and help design and/or redesign the city. Made the cover of Time Magazine (11/6/64) as a forward thinking official.

  • @alhall6700
    @alhall6700 5 років тому

    Margorie Margolas lecturing? Didn't she go to jail?

  • @johnbarroll1120
    @johnbarroll1120 9 днів тому

    Making Phildelphia aristocrats richer.

  • @ztnjv
    @ztnjv 4 роки тому +13

    I wasnt expecting a documentary about race. I’m sure the people who make these documentaries think it’s simply an unbiased reflection of reality but the over-emphasis on racial issues every 2-3 minutes is simply a reflection of the preoccupation and obsession of the storyteller.

    • @elainelane1119
      @elainelane1119 Рік тому +14

      In one word you weren't expecting Reality!

    • @AB-wf8ek
      @AB-wf8ek 8 місяців тому +12

      This comment proves that we need more discussion about the experiences that minority groups have had in this country.

    • @paulzappulla9770
      @paulzappulla9770 5 місяців тому

      ​@@elainelane1119use common sense, if a white kid went to school in jamaica, you think hes gonna be treated fairly.

    • @dealvalayton9961
      @dealvalayton9961 2 місяці тому

      Has to be a White person that made that original comment.....😢😢😢 They NEVER wanna talk about THE REALITY OF RACISM & THIS COUNTRIES HORRID AND HORRIBLE PAST & PRESENT WAYS OF DEALING WITH THE ISSUE.🤦🏾‍♀️🤦🏾‍♀️🤦🏾‍♀️ SAD‼️

  • @elviradonaghy5422
    @elviradonaghy5422 4 роки тому +1

    Dont believe this!

  • @VirginiaCook-lx1qv
    @VirginiaCook-lx1qv 4 роки тому +1

    Now they are burning the city!

  • @Bluemax54
    @Bluemax54 9 років тому +13

    Was a great city. Democrats now have run this city how long? Is this a propogada video?

    • @barbaraobach
      @barbaraobach 7 років тому +1

      Oh right because it wouldn't be the corrupt gop garbage who are corporate hookers- that ruined our cites and towns,
      bloody moron

    • @agw1965
      @agw1965 5 років тому +1

      Sam Katz is a republican. He made this series.

    • @McVet3
      @McVet3 5 років тому

      Anthony Williams What so if a Democrat produced the history would be different?

    • @AB-wf8ek
      @AB-wf8ek 8 місяців тому +1

      Comments like these are an indictment of how a lot of people who vote in this country can't see past labels

  • @Theapprapshow
    @Theapprapshow 5 місяців тому

    No wonder why we was sellin drugs n robbin people