Genetics can be quite a complex thing for me. I marvel at some of the strains we have come up with. Guppies truly are the "hidden in plain sight" gems of our hobby. I think both yours and his guppies have their own unique qualities. Yours are genetics from various lines whereas his has a select few DNA variations. Both have their strong and weak points. Good experiment.
Interesting comparison but not a fair one. The selection intensity and selection criteria of the colony probably differ (unintentionally) from the ones applied to the line bred version. But what choice do you have ?!:)
There are noticeable differences in body shape and coloration. Unless both strains are filmed under the exact and lighting it doesn’t really depict a true comparison. Would like to see his guppies from the store under your lighting. Thanks Jesse.
Thats Interesting Breeding of the Guppy the Fish that always attracts me because of their Natural COlors of their Tails...Thanks for sharing this and God Bless!
Can u do a videos on how to do line breeding and how to maintain that line . I hope you read this message and respond to our fellow hobbyist and your subscribers
I think that colony breeding reduces body shape, coloration and pattern. You'll end up with guppies that carry defective gene and pass it along the gene pool if they are inbred too much. So not only phenotype is compromised but also the genotype - crooked spines, crazy tail shapes etc. Some of they colony bred guppies will have longer slimmer body compared to one that is line bred that produces a thicker caudal peduncle and rounder body. In a colony tank, there will still be a few that carry the better genes which should be the ones pulled to get the line back to its original form. So if you are trying to perfect and enhance the pectoral fins on dumbo ear guppies, you end up pulling and breeding those that will throw that trait back into a line. As far as color comparison, it's hard to compare in this video since they both have different lightning and the store one has a blue back ground for the tank. Blue makes various colors pop so you'll notice a nicer darker red as well as yellow. Lots of people choose red fish or shrimp for a planted tank since you'll also notice that the red stands out and is very vibrant in heavily planted tank that has green plants. I need to brush up on my color theory from them good 'ole college days. lol Edit: On a side note. Not everyone looks at guppies the same way so its just personal taste. However, I do think that certain strains of guppies do extremely well in a colony raised environment.
This is a video that needed to be done by someone in the hobby. I'm glad you made this one. Good comparison.
It was definitely interesting to see the results
Very cool experiment Jesse!!!
Thanks Ed!
SOMETIMES US HOBBYIST ARE SOMEWHAT A RESEARCHER. GOTTA LOVE PROJECTS LIKE THAT. 👍💪
Yup, even when something is already known. It's nice to see it yourself sometimes.
Great project Jesse, noticeable differences, I really want some guppies now lol.
Get some
H.C. Aqua time to ask my parents for another tank 😅😂
Great to see these closer up nice one mate
Many thanks
Good experiment Jesse, you know there are clunkers in just about every batch of fry. So if they get to breed things happen. Well done!👍
Very true
Genetics can be quite a complex thing for me. I marvel at some of the strains we have come up with. Guppies truly are the "hidden in plain sight" gems of our hobby. I think both yours and his guppies have their own unique qualities. Yours are genetics from various lines whereas his has a select few DNA variations. Both have their strong and weak points. Good experiment.
Mine were from his line 1 year ago. It was just to proof how important line breeding is in order to keep the desired traits going in a strain.
Nice, I have a group of "mutt" guppies and a fancy line of rainbow jaguar endlers!!
Interesting comparison but not a fair one. The selection intensity and selection criteria of the colony probably differ (unintentionally) from the ones applied to the line bred version. But what choice do you have ?!:)
It was meant to show that you'll see a difference if you just let your guppies colony breed vs controlling which individuals you allow to breed.
So beautiful love the shrimp
Just wish there were more.
There are noticeable differences in body shape and coloration. Unless both strains are filmed under the exact and lighting it doesn’t really depict a true comparison. Would like to see his guppies from the store under your lighting. Thanks Jesse.
Great point!
Thats Interesting Breeding of the Guppy the Fish that always attracts me because of their Natural COlors of their Tails...Thanks for sharing this and God Bless!
Yes they are!
Civil experiment! Thanks for posting!
My pleasure!
Binge watching.... this was a great project.. really interesting seeing the results. Thanks for sharing😁🔥💚🌿🐟🌿
Yeah, very interesting wasn't it.
Nice guppies. I like the red and yellow... the sunlight helps i bet!
Yes it does!
Would a side filter be good enough for a collony of guppies?
doesn't sound like enough room
Got the notification!
I have Red Snakeskin guppies, beauties.
Awesome! Thank you!
If you have the time and space line breeding is the best way to go
I agree
Can u do a videos on how to do line breeding and how to maintain that line . I hope you read this message and respond to our fellow hobbyist and your subscribers
Great idea. I shall do that some day. Thanks for watching.
Nice . I'm gonna start getting into guppy more . 👍 ✌
Go for it!
dudeeee! really helpful video! im starting to get into guppy breeding!
Right on! Guppies can be really rewarding.
Are those cherries in a tub ?
Yup, and they're huge!
I think that colony breeding reduces body shape, coloration and pattern. You'll end up with guppies that carry defective gene and pass it along the gene pool if they are inbred too much. So not only phenotype is compromised but also the genotype - crooked spines, crazy tail shapes etc. Some of they colony bred guppies will have longer slimmer body compared to one that is line bred that produces a thicker caudal peduncle and rounder body. In a colony tank, there will still be a few that carry the better genes which should be the ones pulled to get the line back to its original form. So if you are trying to perfect and enhance the pectoral fins on dumbo ear guppies, you end up pulling and breeding those that will throw that trait back into a line. As far as color comparison, it's hard to compare in this video since they both have different lightning and the store one has a blue back ground for the tank. Blue makes various colors pop so you'll notice a nicer darker red as well as yellow. Lots of people choose red fish or shrimp for a planted tank since you'll also notice that the red stands out and is very vibrant in heavily planted tank that has green plants. I need to brush up on my color theory from them good 'ole college days. lol Edit: On a side note. Not everyone looks at guppies the same way so its just personal taste. However, I do think that certain strains of guppies do extremely well in a colony raised environment.
For sure, I noticed the reduced body shape.
I need some actually nice guppies.
Yeah, they're still not too bad for colony bred.
The itch is real
scratch um then