Well said. Their journey is so amazing and beautiful. I always envy the friendship they have, makes me wish I had someone who would never give up on me.
from this footage of her with solar unnie you will see how her company cut her wings for 9 years.. byul unnie really have that vocal vibe already but because she need be a rapper she sacrifice her dream of being a vocalist .. but like they said He has always a plan for them and so proud of her achievements🥺☺️🥰
i will never understand why RBW did that for 9 years man! you have 4 vocalist who are multitalented and you constricted the growth of one of them? seriously for what? Byulie's voice is so fucking unique that when people hear her, they immediately know its her man! seriously the Emperor has to win this, she's so damn good!
to be fair.. we wont get the mamamoo we love today without that decision as well. we wouldnt get that unique mamamoo music, we wont get one of the best korean female rappers in kpop and we definitely wont get the highest credited female artist in kpop. also, we dont get to see this incredible journey of seeing her constantly evolving and now tackling singing again in a more serious manner. its 9 years ago.. you cant change the past, but we can all enjoy the future.
@@Glee73 Agreed 100% with everything you said. Moonbyul has conquered rap & hip-hop, now she gets to explore her singing abilities, & we are blessed with another evolution of Moonbyul the artist with many more years of amazing vocalist growth
i dont think RBW constricted moonbyul's growth. i understand it seems unfair to suddenly change her "role" in mmm to rap, especially because she auditioned and trained to be vocalist. but she has been given a lot of work; she writes everything, and she participated in everything along with the rest of the members. we wouldnt have the mmm that we have today without this sudden change of lane. she finally found her singing style and she has done that in her solo works too. i just hope she is happy with how things turned out for her, because that's all that matters.
RBW makes a lot of questionable decisions, but the switch of Moonbyul from vocalist is not one of them. Personally, her solo debut effort Eclipse, which was released years after her group debut, was mere adequate, at best, and it was clear her vocal skills was last in her group. Nowadays, however, she is definitely on par with her other three mates, because she sounds great no matter what the song is. It is clear she never gave up and continued to improve her skills, and her journey of growth had been a treat for fans to witness. All the accolades she has received thus far are just the fruits of her labour that she richly deserves. Plus, if Moonbyul stayed as a vocalist, she will just be dragged as the weak link of the group and be seen as a hanger-on, because objectively, Solar, Hwasa and Wheein are just on another level even from their debut days. It really is for the best, because she became a great rapper and a prolific song-writer.
That guy gave really good advice. Byul really changes her hand placement on the mic. Her soft broken notes at the end of the song were also some of my faves from her.
I'm so glad Mamamoo was so hard working since the beginning, because we all got these gems to stan in the end. Byul unnie, thank you for your hard work as always. You're already a great singer and vocalist. I can't wait for the future in which you show even more of your great vocals.
Actually, Byul's been taking vocal lessons since 2021! She mentioned it on a YKBK VLive and even Solar was surprised. She really wants to sing more for us MooMoos and I'm hapoy she gets to showcase her improvements to the general public as well! *Edit:* Singer Moobyul usually shows up for solo songs and OSTs, so I hope people would check those out and support her solo work!
The fact that Byul's Refuge reminds me so much of how immersed I felt when listening to Hyunkyu singing Don't Worry in Sing Again is a testament in itself on how well Byul has moved everyone with this stage!!
☪️ Moonbyul and her pure soul, putting all she's feeling in the song amazes me. Also she's overcome so much that she deserves not only this win but the show 👑
Thank you for showing interest in Moonbyul!! She's an amazing vocalist who is really talented in showing the story of a song through the emotions in her voice when she sings. May I suggest you check out Moonbyul's covers as well as her most recent EP, 6equence? 6equence is a 6 song album (6 songs + 1 Eng version of the title song), it tells a full story just like a movie. Showing from the start of a love at first sight, through passion, tension, till the fallout and sadness of the love lost. Moonbyul was involved in the lyrics writing for most of the songs in this album (all songs except for the title track Lunatic). Also, all the songs in 6equence can be found as an MV or live performance video on the official MAMAMOO channel. :)
Now i understand more the frustration of moonbyul debuting as mamamoo's rapper. Imagine passing all that grueling elimination rounds as a SINGER and then suddenly asking to rap or else she wouldn't DEBUT. That's just some messed up sh*t.
I feel the words to use would be more of.. don't focus so much and the skills and techniques of singing well, because sometimes the little mistakes like broken voice and off tones display more emotions than when you sing perfectly as people might feel you're only concentrated on making the song perfect and it would become technical singing. I think that's what you're trying to say right? 😁🥰
We all know its a 5:0in the last round so they will hinder moonbyuo in getting first place in every round so theres going to have some remaining thrill
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: you don’t become the rapper of a 4-member group renowned for their vocals without being able to sing well. It felt practically unfair to have her in the show. All the girls had comparable vocals and performed very well, but the advantages Moonbyul had as a member of Mamamoo and under RBW are immense. She said that she hasn’t used her vocal training in nine years, but I don’t think that’s entirely true. Being the rapper of a vocal group, Byul has become likely the only person who can convincingly rap on a ballad and actually add something to the song. That requires no small level of musicality, lyricality, rhythm, and tune. I’m just hoping this competition has awoken Singer Byul enough to get some recordings outta her soon.
She’s originally a vocalist, she went to SM academy, she sings in her solo albums. She was forced to be a rapper to debut. Trained for a short time to be a rapper and excelled at that. But being a singer will always be her dream.
And now she won Second World 🥺💚 And Refuge was her best performance from the entire show!! But her company (RBW 🔪🔪) is now sabotaging the prize she won 😭😭😭 She deserves to perform the OST at GDA so much and that stupid company put the concert date the same day!!! They don't respect Moonbyul's hard work or the work of the fans that voted to give her that win!!!
![[ENG SUB] 220830 Second World E01 - Moonbyul cut](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/teWySuycAtY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG SUB] 220830 Second World E01 - Moonbyul cut](/img/tr.png)
![[4K] MAMAMOO MoonByul - Refuge](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xdg6jpzy_6I/mqdefault.jpg)
![When a big flirt meets another big flirt... 🤭 Moonbyul & Kimwooseok [SELF-ON KODE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LJVNdwRN2uA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] Funny game time! The Second World ep.9 #moonbyul #mamamoo](/img/n.gif)
the footage of solar playing the piano with moonbyul singing during their trainee days.. just how far they become now
Well said. Their journey is so amazing and beautiful. I always envy the friendship they have, makes me wish I had someone who would never give up on me.
from this footage of her with solar unnie you will see how her company cut her wings for 9 years.. byul unnie really have that vocal vibe already but because she need be a rapper she sacrifice her dream of being a vocalist .. but like they said He has always a plan for them and so proud of her achievements🥺☺️🥰
I'm so grateful MoonSunWheeSa were the chosen one for Mamamoo
They were destined to be. If 1 of the members was different, then they wouldn't be the Mamamoo that we now know and love so much.
i will never understand why RBW did that for 9 years man! you have 4 vocalist who are multitalented and you constricted the growth of one of them? seriously for what? Byulie's voice is so fucking unique that when people hear her, they immediately know its her man! seriously the Emperor has to win this, she's so damn good!
to be fair.. we wont get the mamamoo we love today without that decision as well. we wouldnt get that unique mamamoo music, we wont get one of the best korean female rappers in kpop and we definitely wont get the highest credited female artist in kpop. also, we dont get to see this incredible journey of seeing her constantly evolving and now tackling singing again in a more serious manner. its 9 years ago.. you cant change the past, but we can all enjoy the future.
@@Glee73 Agreed 100% with everything you said. Moonbyul has conquered rap & hip-hop, now she gets to explore her singing abilities, & we are blessed with another evolution of Moonbyul the artist with many more years of amazing vocalist growth
i dont think RBW constricted moonbyul's growth. i understand it seems unfair to suddenly change her "role" in mmm to rap, especially because she auditioned and trained to be vocalist. but she has been given a lot of work; she writes everything, and she participated in everything along with the rest of the members. we wouldnt have the mmm that we have today without this sudden change of lane. she finally found her singing style and she has done that in her solo works too. i just hope she is happy with how things turned out for her, because that's all that matters.
RBW makes a lot of questionable decisions, but the switch of Moonbyul from vocalist is not one of them. Personally, her solo debut effort Eclipse, which was released years after her group debut, was mere adequate, at best, and it was clear her vocal skills was last in her group. Nowadays, however, she is definitely on par with her other three mates, because she sounds great no matter what the song is. It is clear she never gave up and continued to improve her skills, and her journey of growth had been a treat for fans to witness. All the accolades she has received thus far are just the fruits of her labour that she richly deserves.
Plus, if Moonbyul stayed as a vocalist, she will just be dragged as the weak link of the group and be seen as a hanger-on, because objectively, Solar, Hwasa and Wheein are just on another level even from their debut days. It really is for the best, because she became a great rapper and a prolific song-writer.
That guy gave really good advice. Byul really changes her hand placement on the mic. Her soft broken notes at the end of the song were also some of my faves from her.
It is hard to sing with so much emotion and Moonbyul delivered 100% emotions and vocal skill in this performance
omg the vocal coach is so wholesome & supportive 😭👍🏼
It's so fascinating to see mamamoo. Very well rounded group. No group has this chemistry
I'm so glad Mamamoo was so hard working since the beginning, because we all got these gems to stan in the end. Byul unnie, thank you for your hard work as always. You're already a great singer and vocalist. I can't wait for the future in which you show even more of your great vocals.
I say it all the time, I'll say it again. I'M SO PROUD OF MOONBYUL!!🥺
im just so happy that with second world she gets to have vocal lessons again i hope she'll continue to have more opportunities to sing 🥹
Actually, Byul's been taking vocal lessons since 2021! She mentioned it on a YKBK VLive and even Solar was surprised. She really wants to sing more for us MooMoos and I'm hapoy she gets to showcase her improvements to the general public as well!
*Edit:*
Singer Moobyul usually shows up for solo songs and OSTs, so I hope people would check those out and support her solo work!
PARK HYUNKYU!!!! I really love it when Mamamoo and Vromance hang out together.
I miss them so so much😭😭😭
The fact that Byul's Refuge reminds me so much of how immersed I felt when listening to Hyunkyu singing Don't Worry in Sing Again is a testament in itself on how well Byul has moved everyone with this stage!!
moonbyul has really done everything she can by this point, it's down to us with the voting now! let's do this, moos, she deserves the win!
wow 9 yrs!? I guess thing happen for a reason. Thank you moonbyul for never given up and congratulations for winning SECOND WORLD!
I love how she picked up a song for the people not having a good time. She's truly a Moon Star ⭐❣️
☪️ Moonbyul and her pure soul, putting all she's feeling in the song amazes me. Also she's overcome so much that she deserves not only this win but the show 👑
I want moonbyul and solar to do a full cover of "billionaire" now
I love Moonbyul's voice. I really hope she continues singing for years! 💚
Thank you for the subs! Moonbyul loves challenge and improving herself. Love to see it
I think she made an amazing choice to cover this song. I had only listen to her from say yes but now I’m gonna also listen to some more of her songs.
Thank you for showing interest in Moonbyul!! She's an amazing vocalist who is really talented in showing the story of a song through the emotions in her voice when she sings.
May I suggest you check out Moonbyul's covers as well as her most recent EP, 6equence?
6equence is a 6 song album (6 songs + 1 Eng version of the title song), it tells a full story just like a movie. Showing from the start of a love at first sight, through passion, tension, till the fallout and sadness of the love lost.
Moonbyul was involved in the lyrics writing for most of the songs in this album (all songs except for the title track Lunatic).
Also, all the songs in 6equence can be found as an MV or live performance video on the official MAMAMOO channel. :)
Moonbyul singing 'Battlefield' at 2:59 is so uplifting, I wish there would be a longer version of this
Can I ask what song she and solar sing at the piano Scene?
@@adamfirdhaus6670 "Billionaire" by Bruno Mars
Our Moonbyul deserves to win!!! Come on moos we can do it, let's VOTE with all our hearts (and accounts)!!!!
Park Hyun Kyu’s tip of the wavering voice is exactly what the judge’s feedback (Eunkwang’s I think) was about ❤❤❤
Definitivamente Moonbyul esta evolucionando mucho y con esta cancion logro transmitir mucho... 💖
mamamoo moonbyul is special ❤
Moonbyul is the best, her voice is amazing and it's so cool to see her talent being so highlighted and recognized by other singers 💜
I really happy (a lot) to see Moonbyul as talented hard working vocalist-rapper-artist 🌝⭐💞
So proud of you moonbyul ❤️
Now i understand more the frustration of moonbyul debuting as mamamoo's rapper. Imagine passing all that grueling elimination rounds as a SINGER and then suddenly asking to rap or else she wouldn't DEBUT. That's just some messed up sh*t.
so proud of her 🤧🤧🤧😭
So proud of you moonbyulyi seriously 😢❤
Indeed, she ripped the stage off😭❤️💙
Its nice to see some of the vromance members.
As I see Moonbyul showing more vocal, I feel more proud 😍😭 YOU'RE DOING SO GOOD!!!
SO. PROUD.
You really won our hearts!!!
That really explaind why moonbyul doesnt like competions
Not oniy moonbyul, all mamamoo really hate competition
So proud of her ❤❤❤❤
3:00 Moonbyul, we need a full cover of Battlefield 🙏
Byulie is such a thoughtful person, wanting to sing a song that will bring joy to others and uplift their spirts. She's just so cool ❤
Necesito a Moonbyul y Solar catando ese cover otra vez que lindo
I want to hear her full
cover of "Battlefield"!
02:52 goddamnit moonbyul! 😳
That's really smart, to not concentrate on the vocals but on the emotions.
I feel the words to use would be more of.. don't focus so much and the skills and techniques of singing well, because sometimes the little mistakes like broken voice and off tones display more emotions than when you sing perfectly as people might feel you're only concentrated on making the song perfect and it would become technical singing.
I think that's what you're trying to say right? 😁🥰
So proud of her 💚
We all know its a 5:0in the last round so they will hinder moonbyuo in getting first place in every round so theres going to have some remaining thrill
Am glad they put the song better in the background
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: you don’t become the rapper of a 4-member group renowned for their vocals without being able to sing well. It felt practically unfair to have her in the show. All the girls had comparable vocals and performed very well, but the advantages Moonbyul had as a member of Mamamoo and under RBW are immense. She said that she hasn’t used her vocal training in nine years, but I don’t think that’s entirely true. Being the rapper of a vocal group, Byul has become likely the only person who can convincingly rap on a ballad and actually add something to the song. That requires no small level of musicality, lyricality, rhythm, and tune. I’m just hoping this competition has awoken Singer Byul enough to get some recordings outta her soon.
She’s originally a vocalist, she went to SM academy, she sings in her solo albums. She was forced to be a rapper to debut. Trained for a short time to be a rapper and excelled at that. But being a singer will always be her dream.
All cheering for you, show your voice to the world! 💗
I'm GLAD the greedy comment
didn't discourage her from
singing HER heart out. You're a
tough hamster, Byullie! ♥️😭🌊
And now she won Second World 🥺💚 And Refuge was her best performance from the entire show!! But her company (RBW 🔪🔪) is now sabotaging the prize she won 😭😭😭 She deserves to perform the OST at GDA so much and that stupid company put the concert date the same day!!! They don't respect Moonbyul's hard work or the work of the fans that voted to give her that win!!!
超棒的
Feliz por ti niña. Tu esfuerzo y creer en ti misma dio frutos
我只想说谢谢你坚持下来
Moonbyul 🥰🥰
So great to see Hyun Gyu looking well. 😀
🤗 .. 💞💞
Man from the past 🤣
Did she just manifested the 5-0 win. She actually did!!
💖💖💖💖
MWWA 🙂
Does anyone know what's the song MoonByul sing at 2:51?
I think it's called Billonaire from Bruno Mars and some other guy
the loss wasn't deserved in any way
can see why you never satisfied as you had to battle 3 groups to make mamamoo...one with 12 competitors every month...
@Gyomin your ID!!! Please