What if Jon Snow LEFT The Night's Watch and JOINED Robb Stark PART 2

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 135

  • @ThreeEyedTheorist
    @ThreeEyedTheorist  19 днів тому +5

    Part 3: ua-cam.com/video/1bl97ifxLnQ/v-deo.html

  • @joshuaford9714
    @joshuaford9714 Місяць тому +95

    Love how Baelish is to Cat what Lysa is to Baelish

    • @katieneubaum4284
      @katieneubaum4284 Місяць тому +8

      Bro I about choked on my coffee when I heard that shit

  • @jeffjohnson1966
    @jeffjohnson1966 Місяць тому +100

    My man came thru on his word with the Part 2!

    • @ThreeEyedTheorist
      @ThreeEyedTheorist  Місяць тому +14

      🫡

    • @TFAric
      @TFAric Місяць тому +4

      @@ThreeEyedTheorist So how mant likes for part 3 ;)

    • @BeppyTurnip
      @BeppyTurnip Місяць тому +1

      Hopefully he'll do it for the other stories

    • @Dmoney8787
      @Dmoney8787 Місяць тому

      Great video! Well done

    • @JTL1776
      @JTL1776 28 днів тому

      ​@@ThreeEyedTheorist how many likes for a part 3.

  • @wizmax1
    @wizmax1 Місяць тому +72

    Part 3? The arrival of Daenerys and the white walkers, pleeeaase

  • @jdgreen1802
    @jdgreen1802 Місяць тому +36

    “The only protest they get from the Veil Lords is that they weren’t there to witness it themselves”
    Perfectly describes how the Veil felt about little finger😂
    If your last name ain’t Arryn, they not supporting you being in charge

  • @zackarywhitson1132
    @zackarywhitson1132 Місяць тому +12

    Im so happy that this content is as good and constant as it is. Regular videos that are dope to listen to. The voices really take it to the next level.

  • @chandlerdoeswhatifs9399
    @chandlerdoeswhatifs9399 Місяць тому +35

    You must be a Lannister, because you always pay your debts

  • @BrainyBlonde21
    @BrainyBlonde21 Місяць тому +7

    I’m glad to get this continuation but I could have gone my whole life without the idea of the screaming on the wedding night lmao! Poor Robb trying not to listen.

  • @TheITinFIT
    @TheITinFIT Місяць тому +12

    Nice! Glad to see this reach its conclusion.
    Another idea: What if Ned believed the Night’s Watch deserter about the White Walkers coming and spared him?

    • @MartialArtsForY
      @MartialArtsForY Місяць тому +1

      Lowkey a great idea

    • @blainhunter4696
      @blainhunter4696 Місяць тому +3

      it was never about ned not believing him, he is honour and duty bound to execute the deserter, no matter the cause for his desertion.

    • @undead9999
      @undead9999 Місяць тому +2

      He didn't execute him because he didn't believe him. He did it because he dishonoured the black.

  • @chandlerdoeswhatifs9399
    @chandlerdoeswhatifs9399 Місяць тому +31

    What if Renly bent the knee to Stannis?

  • @nappayt5961
    @nappayt5961 Місяць тому +13

    Hey I would love to a decent mountain story. What if a yoiung The Moutain was sent as a ward to Starks? (I love your content btw)

    • @simonpierre8283
      @simonpierre8283 Місяць тому +2

      He have a bond with Ned benjen brandon

    • @undead9999
      @undead9999 Місяць тому +3

      With the Mountain at his Eddard would have never died in King's Landing

  • @Manterok
    @Manterok Місяць тому +8

    That Janos Slynt was a curve ball, fam! Lmao

    • @quadeong7453
      @quadeong7453 Місяць тому +1

      his friends in court kept him alive.

  • @danielsantiagourtado3430
    @danielsantiagourtado3430 Місяць тому +7

    Been waiting For this one!😊😊😊😊

  • @AlaskaBeary413
    @AlaskaBeary413 Місяць тому +3

    I needed “new” material soooo bad. You have made my 2024 ASOIAF/Christmas season!
    🙏🏽🥰🥂

    • @ThreeEyedTheorist
      @ThreeEyedTheorist  Місяць тому +1

      Hope to continue with that the rest of your Christmas season 🥂🤝

  • @talesyuki
    @talesyuki Місяць тому +2

    Ohhh hooray! I'm so happy this is out!!! Fun! Thank you, mate! :)

  • @unclet9825
    @unclet9825 Місяць тому +1

    A great part 2, splendid work!

  • @route1trainer
    @route1trainer Місяць тому +2

    Absolutely love this channel, keep it up 🎉

  • @thebono2415
    @thebono2415 Місяць тому +11

    Lord pinky finger 😂🤣

    • @LadyMinaMasters
      @LadyMinaMasters 9 днів тому

      I laughed loud enough to wake my cat at Lord Pinky Finger.

  • @danielsantiagourtado3430
    @danielsantiagourtado3430 Місяць тому +5

    Love your content ❤❤❤❤

  • @Godzilla00X
    @Godzilla00X Місяць тому +5

    Thanks the Gods and Bessie for a part 2

    • @TFAric
      @TFAric Місяць тому

      And her teets!

  • @davidsanford2843
    @davidsanford2843 Місяць тому +4

    Better written, thought out, & dedicated than anything D&D did!

  • @hellyeah3889
    @hellyeah3889 Місяць тому +5

    Love the vid man, i have kinda weird what if
    What if tywin took arya with him

    • @goozgaming9940
      @goozgaming9940 Місяць тому +1

      nothing would change, arya is already believed to be dead

    • @hellyeah3889
      @hellyeah3889 Місяць тому

      @goozgaming9940 how about Cersei?
      If she recognises her alot os stuff can change

    • @goozgaming9940
      @goozgaming9940 Місяць тому

      @@hellyeah3889 I doubt cersei would care about a cupbearer enough to talk to her

  • @Ghiscari
    @Ghiscari Місяць тому +8

    Suggestion: What if Young Griff wasn't cut from the show?

  • @nastycanastas1548
    @nastycanastas1548 Місяць тому +3

    THIS NEED A THIRD PART PLS!!

  • @willcoutts1323
    @willcoutts1323 Місяць тому +1

    The fact this channel doesn’t have vastly more followers is a crime against the old gods and the new

  • @TheLantoniou
    @TheLantoniou Місяць тому +6

    At last, TV!Cersei gets her elephants.

  • @darthkarroto2183
    @darthkarroto2183 Місяць тому

    This is amazing. Plz keep doing. These

  • @LordHavillain
    @LordHavillain Місяць тому +1

    Love your videos. Word of advice: don’t put that red line in the bottom right corner of the video because at first I thought I had already started watching it and was gonna scroll past

  • @joserobledo33
    @joserobledo33 Місяць тому +1

    Awesome thanks 🙏👍

  • @markpula91
    @markpula91 Місяць тому +1

    I love this channel❤

  • @DarkVeghetta
    @DarkVeghetta Місяць тому +8

    1:19 Peter, the _woman_ is supposed to do the screaming. A man should grunt or growl, but you're not supposed to scream... well, if you're the big spoon, that is. If you're not the big spoon, I suppose have at it.

  • @evan-bunch-of-numbers
    @evan-bunch-of-numbers Місяць тому +2

    This is gonna be the most outlandish of suggestions, but we know in the books all the stark kids have the potential to warg. What if they learned to harness that power?

  • @Emredaniel21
    @Emredaniel21 Місяць тому +1

    Love the videos

  • @drewhigbee815
    @drewhigbee815 Місяць тому +2

    Keep going, what about Dany and the night king

  • @BenHof
    @BenHof Місяць тому +15

    What If you retold all of Season 8

    • @jjriverahh
      @jjriverahh Місяць тому

      Fffffaaaaaacccctttttttt lol 💯💯💯

  • @snuts4944
    @snuts4944 Місяць тому

    Was waiting for this one wondering if we'd get it.

  • @fire1655
    @fire1655 Місяць тому +2

    What if Jon Didn’t swear his oath to the wall.
    So I had an idea a while back, what if for some reason he didn’t give his outh to the Nightwatch. Simply put maybe Benjen implies that he wants to be there when Jon says or straight up told him not to because I still believe that he knows. Or for some of the smarter members like Jor Mormont and Aemon realize that it’s more useful outside of the watch then inside of it. Yes, the a future leader commander they have people like Benjen for stuff like that. For any reason, have him delay, giving his oath to and out of emergency or as a favor for saving him, bring him on the great ranging to see what is be on the wall so that once he has seen everything, he can return to his family and report it then everything just happens to the way it did, except for he isn’t a member of the watch.

  • @BrainyBlonde21
    @BrainyBlonde21 Місяць тому +1

    What happens when Dany and the White Walkers show up?! This is great but I need more!

  • @ballisticautistic5398
    @ballisticautistic5398 Місяць тому +5

    What if Lyanna Stark survived?

  • @cainyo7938
    @cainyo7938 Місяць тому +2

    This makes me so interested in what would happen with Danny, the white walkers, the remaining lannisters, and I can't remember if jeyne westerling had a child in this one or if succession is still to bran/rickon (since at the start jon lost all lands and title and I beileve at the end of the last one he rejoined the nightd wacth)

  • @Tchaffer4896
    @Tchaffer4896 Місяць тому +3

    Where's Theon by this point?

  • @brunocardoso2092
    @brunocardoso2092 6 днів тому

    Cersei: “So, now the elephants can cross the sea😡”

  • @lovelyhatter
    @lovelyhatter Місяць тому

    This episode was specifically made for Quinn the GM 😂

  • @starking2162
    @starking2162 Місяць тому +1

    Part 3!! Where’s the white walker battle?!

  • @lostinthestorywithjeremymi9385
    @lostinthestorywithjeremymi9385 15 днів тому

    I really don't see Robb having his home and allies as a client kingdom, admittedly. I imagine he'd go for allies that are equals at the very least.

  • @waywardangeltina
    @waywardangeltina Місяць тому

    We need a part 3

  • @simonpierre8283
    @simonpierre8283 Місяць тому +2

    What if Viserys survied game of thrones. What if Viserys named Aegon heir. What if Robb joind Stannis What if Stannis won battle of ice. What if vale joind Robb. What if Edmure tully killed mountain. What if Stannis won battle of blackwater part2

  • @crib8760
    @crib8760 Місяць тому +2

    LEGEND

  • @jakefisher3328
    @jakefisher3328 Місяць тому +1

    Pt 2 let's gooooooo

  • @emten1584
    @emten1584 Місяць тому

    What is the background music at the start?

  • @Kingslayer54
    @Kingslayer54 Місяць тому +1

    Why would Mace be in the Stormlands if his children are prisoners in Kings Landing?

  • @vikctoryan15
    @vikctoryan15 12 днів тому

    I refuse to believe that Robb would settle for anything less that a free and independent North when he had the most support and numbers. He has the Vale, Storm's End, North, Riverlands and Stormlands under his control. That's 4 out of 7, no way would he settle to be under sovereign of the Iron Throne again especially when he doesn't even know Aegon.

  • @Edmures_rampant_manhood
    @Edmures_rampant_manhood Місяць тому +2

    What if Tyrion lost his trial by combat at the Eyrie?

    • @crimsonECH1DNA
      @crimsonECH1DNA Місяць тому +1

      Stannis wins the Battle of Blackwater Bay.

  • @spiidymolakimoss495
    @spiidymolakimoss495 Місяць тому +1

    This is what we want

  • @ryanwatt6706
    @ryanwatt6706 Місяць тому

    Is Shireen alive still?? I think she'd be an excellent addition to a part 3

  • @sceleratus955
    @sceleratus955 Місяць тому

    I feel like dorne should've played a role. Other than that great video

  • @andrerosa6470
    @andrerosa6470 Місяць тому

    If Jon Snow fights with Robb.
    The Starks are blind by honor. Ned Stark kills himself and his mercy kills king Robert when he confess to Cersei that he new the truth about her, Jaime and their children.
    The queen put something on Robert's wine, some kind of drug, offers the wine to Lancel Lannister, Roberts mind was crushed, and the wild pig did the rest. Then he refuses Renly's help because of the children, no army for that decision.
    Then Ned was always on Stannis side, even knowing that with him, the war has coming with Stannis, innocent people would die, and the country would suffer, and Baelis, Varys and Pycelle would be out of politics or executed, Cercei and her family executed or persecuted. Obiously they dont want tho get out of power, and Baelis convence Ned that the souldiers are for him. Uge mistake.
    But Ned thinks with the heart, not with the head, he was blind by honor, and in the end, that kid he saved because of his mercy, respondes with gratefull, by cutting his head off.
    In the case of Jon and Robb.
    If Jon goes to war joing Robb, what I thing that problably would happen is a troubled mind war on Robb's head, or not, because he would see him as his alf brother, Robb could behead him. Cat will support that decision. Or Robb goes with Jon and his army to the wall after the war and the execution of Joffrey and Lannister house. Then Jon is executed in castle black.
    If Robb choose mercy, and his love for Jon is a brother love, he exiles Jon to Dorne or another place and informs the wall that Jon is dead.
    Ned Stark lies to prottect his nephew Jon Snow, honored but not perfect, because her sister beggs for that. But that its one idea of mercy on part of Robb. Exiles Jon, making the Nights Watch believe he is dead.😮

  • @louiemeister9646
    @louiemeister9646 Місяць тому

    What’s the background music?

  • @michaelonak3356
    @michaelonak3356 Місяць тому

    Just started these today and man are they good so far. My favorite is whatbif khal drogo lived. Jon snow joining rob though is a close second.
    How bout what if The viper handnt been crushed by the mountain
    Or what if the hound took sansa instead of arya and baelish ended up with arya

  • @fran3ro
    @fran3ro Місяць тому

    You should use maps to show places

  • @saminator3563
    @saminator3563 Місяць тому +1

    My boys!

  • @Linkskyfyre
    @Linkskyfyre Місяць тому

    I like how in this world, Dani doesn't exist.

  • @alphik26
    @alphik26 Місяць тому

    by young royce u mean the son that was killed in the prologue or someone elase

  • @Tain950
    @Tain950 26 днів тому

    Thank God Jon didn’t leave the Nights watch because he would’ve just showed up to see Rob blinded by love and throw everything away. Probably would’ve got himself killed following Rob.

  • @rackstraw
    @rackstraw Місяць тому

    Wouldn't Jon execute Littlefinger? "The man who passes the sentence should swing the sword."

  • @itstaylor2137
    @itstaylor2137 Місяць тому

    I could see Dany marrying Aegon and bringing dragons back to the royal family

  • @Jonas-ij4td
    @Jonas-ij4td Місяць тому +2

    Is the voice over AI generated?

  • @jontayvious
    @jontayvious Місяць тому

    Does this channel have a sister channel or something? A channel called Visions of Valyria is extremely similar to this.

    • @TFAric
      @TFAric Місяць тому

      Darth Theorist is a sister channel that does the same thing but Star Wars

    • @ThreeEyedTheorist
      @ThreeEyedTheorist  Місяць тому

      Nope just Darth theorist right now

  • @kylejamessmithproductions7848
    @kylejamessmithproductions7848 Місяць тому

    Need a psrt 3

  • @ScholaroftheCitadel
    @ScholaroftheCitadel Місяць тому

    Part 3 with Daenerys and euron and part 4 with the white walkers

  • @katliit9442
    @katliit9442 Місяць тому +1

    Even if these are AI they are pretty good

  • @skullbones1014
    @skullbones1014 Місяць тому

    Umm no. We need part 3. What about Danny and the white walkers

  • @danishaiman8135
    @danishaiman8135 Місяць тому

    can someone explain how aegon can win with only 2 army? while rob has 3?

  • @undead9999
    @undead9999 Місяць тому

    What if Rhaego survives to carry his father's khalasar under the flaming stallion banner becoming the Stallion Who Mounts The World

  • @danielhaughey3095
    @danielhaughey3095 Місяць тому

    Have I missed something?where’s ghost

  • @Ardenator1
    @Ardenator1 Місяць тому

    A timeline where we could actually get an Aegon - Sansa marriage.
    What if Sansa and Theon were betrothed before Robert Baratheon came to Winterfell?

  • @kevineric9034
    @kevineric9034 Місяць тому

    Part 3???

  • @hanshawks5088
    @hanshawks5088 Місяць тому

    You can't leave the Night Watch 😭😭😭

  • @Mark-uh3un
    @Mark-uh3un Місяць тому

    I think Littlefinger would’ve demanded to marry Sansa right away, not Cat

  • @thomasredmond1337
    @thomasredmond1337 Місяць тому +1

    What if Jon snow became king of the seven kingdoms

  • @rowansmith4029
    @rowansmith4029 Місяць тому

    Part 3? Bran returns from the wall and the Others follow

  • @Tacozrule12
    @Tacozrule12 Місяць тому +1

    Let’s gooooooo!!!!!

  • @Carcrushers-u9t
    @Carcrushers-u9t Місяць тому

    So no Danny in any of these

  • @Latchedfrog-cv2tw
    @Latchedfrog-cv2tw Місяць тому

    What if one dragon stayed alive?

  • @KeyMasterX
    @KeyMasterX Місяць тому

    What if Middle-Earth was West of Westeros?

  • @zbvnkhutf9312
    @zbvnkhutf9312 Місяць тому

    What about daenerys?

  • @simonpierre8283
    @simonpierre8283 Місяць тому

    What if Renly bendt knee to Stannis. What if Tywin survied what if Joffrey survied. What if Tommen survied.

    • @iisomeoneii2091
      @iisomeoneii2091 Місяць тому +1

      The mannis wins. The lannisters win. The lannisters lose badly. Not much changes

    • @simonpierre8283
      @simonpierre8283 Місяць тому

      @@iisomeoneii2091 if Renly joins stannis dosnt mean Tyrells join Stannis. Tyrells only supported Renly cuz he was king

    • @crimsonECH1DNA
      @crimsonECH1DNA Місяць тому +1

      @@simonpierre8283 Yep.
      The Tyrell's goal was always to make Margaery queen. Their original alliance with Renly was on the basis that Renly would convince Robert to divorce Cersei so that he could take on Margaery as his new queen. And after Robert's death, he was convinced by the Tyrell's to declare himself queen and married Margaery. So in any scenario where Renly remains loyal to Stannis, he definitely loses the Tyrell support. If anything, just like in canon, what happens is the Tyrells (and much of the Reach) throws their support behind Joffrey and Joffrey cancels his engagement with Sansa in favor of Margaery.
      With that said, since Renly is the diplomatic of the three Baratheon brothers, maybe he manages to broker an Alliance between Stannis and Robb. Like maybe he sways Stannis to go with the deal that Renly canonically offered Robb in the story.

  • @anniebot_45-73
    @anniebot_45-73 Місяць тому +1

    what if the red wedding went in rob's favour?

  • @cornelius69
    @cornelius69 13 днів тому

    Not enough starks died imo

  • @kwesiBryant
    @kwesiBryant Місяць тому

    Pt3

  • @Sushi64
    @Sushi64 Місяць тому

    where is daenarys is this story?

    • @smartmouth4444
      @smartmouth4444 Місяць тому

      Her arrival is probably what part 3 is about if they do one.

  • @dylanh7600
    @dylanh7600 25 днів тому

    Aegon is a blackfyre

  • @eduardowollants820
    @eduardowollants820 Місяць тому +1

    I love u

  • @Josh199393
    @Josh199393 Місяць тому

    Which Aegon is the golden company fighting for? Jon Snow?

    • @jesselandgraab3386
      @jesselandgraab3386 Місяць тому

      No Aegon the Pretender

    • @Josh199393
      @Josh199393 Місяць тому +1

      @jesselandgraab3386 oh I must have missed the part where they said he survived

    • @joev8787
      @joev8787 Місяць тому

      I went back and looked at part 1 but didn't see a mention of Aegon. Did I miss something?

    • @Josh199393
      @Josh199393 Місяць тому

      @@joev8787 It said Rhegar showed up and said the Golden Company was fighting for Aegon Targaryen,