Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves PS4 vs PS3 Graphics Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 сер 2024
- John takes an extended look at how Bluepoint Games modernised and remastered one of the greatest games of the last-gen era for the new PS4 Nathan Drake Collection.
Read our full article: www.eurogamer.n...
Subscribe for more console and PC tech analysis: bit.ly/DFSubscribe
this game alone was worth buying a ps3 at the time
And now its worth buying a PS4 ;)
+LE0NSKA I bought my PS3 to play Uncharted
I picked up the ps3 with all three games last month for 52 bucks just to play them, and a few others
+princeviny17 Actually, it was $50. I fat fingered the 2.
:P
Got it with a controller, no OS or hard drive.
I threw in a spare 250gb drive I had and spent an hour or so and:
Schwing and Kaching!
I first bought my PS4 just for this game as I own a Xbox One, but then I seen the difference between 900p and 1080p and 720p and 900p and realized the PS4 looks a lot better in some games compared to what youtube videos show.
Uncharted 2 is simply one of the best games ever made!
Its aged so gracefully too
The atmosphere is simply fantastic in this game...
Something Greg Edmonson contributed a LOT to...
2:48 Now why would they change that magnificent hair?
Yeah....now his hair looks like shit XD
To me it looks like something went wrong with transparent textures...
Maybe it is an oversight. Because the last uncharted has him with the correct hair style. Something must have happened and the devs didn't notice.
@@DantesInferno96 They're working on details of a game and "they didn't notice"?... OK... You better believe it was intentional. They weren't reworking this massive hit of a game with one hand while checking their phones with the other.
@@michaelmonstar4276 stuff happens. Mistakes are made. I've played the remastered and it looks great on PS4 pro
If you have a ps4 (or will be picking up a ps3 this holiday) and have never played Drakes 2, you owe it to your self to give it a play. It's probably one of the most polished, most well crafted, truly cinematic(no bullshit) game experiences out there. It's so rare to find a game with both polished gameplay and a compelling story at the same time.
+thcollegestudent TRUTH!
I hate how linear it is, though. I kept trying to move forward, only to fall of the level or be insta-killed.
Eh, it's not for everyone. Don't play number 3 then, even I thought it was bad about that and I loved number 2.
One of my favourite games of all time...too beast for words.
+KrazyBean14 Agreed word by word. Needless to say much about it
Minecraft had a better story
LOL
😅*too best for words, R.I.P English...
I remember I bought this game on a whim. Just got bored one day and downloaded it on my PS3.
...then I played it like 30 times over. This game is an absolute BLAST.
Now THIS is how remasters should be handled if they want my money again.
I just finished it in 2019
It's a masterpiece
Same here, I've been playing them off and on this year, and I'm now in Syria on UC3. I've owned the collection since I got my ps4 in 2016 lol.
This is more weird i'm playing this on ps3 😅😅
I am currently doing it in 2022, amazing game! Pro patch would’ve been nice though
uncharted 2 is the best uncharted ever
One of the best if not the best game ever, Uncharted 2 is a masterpiece of the gaming world.
+Hugo Azevedo "The best game ever" (c) A console peasant...
+TheVanillatech
It is one fucking good game man, seriously.
WH250398
I bet it is! But best game ever? Don't be fucking stupid, original poster! XD
Jayquan Phifer
What? I have 12 consoles and 3 PC's (actually around 11 PC's if you count the ones in storage).
Moron! :)
TheVanillatech
It is a 9/10 game to me. Not the best game ever, but a really good game! You should play it.
They should have added uncharted golden abyss aswell.
absolutely.
Golden abyss is not Uncharted “canon” it’s “legends” so it not really true
( I love Star Wars )
Homeh Fool what? Yes it is canon, it’s a prequel to the first game. Leave your Star Wars shit out of this.
6644pmr it’s not. Ur family tree lgbt
Homeh Fool Amy Hennig and other naughty dog team members worked on uncharted golden abyss to ensure it stayed in certain parameters so that it stayed Canon. Look it up you fuckin idiot. People like you and your false information make the internet a terrible place.
They fixed Chloe's eyes! That super reflective look on the eyes in Uncharted 2 drove me insane. 4:03
Looked hot
Dude you quality videos is becoming so fucking great ! Nice Job DigitalFoundry.
Good thing I never played any Uncharted game by now, looking forward to buy the collection and uncharted 4! they did a great job with this!
Fendera I'm guessing you got them for Christmas? If so how are you liking them so far? :)
not yet :P but i downloaded the uncharted collection demo and played a little bit of uncharted 2, it's fantastic! as always naughty dog did a great job.
Fendera how's it so far? I'm buying tomorrow
I knew about how good bluepoint was the day I played Gow 2 remaster on ps3. Those guys are great ,I think now they deserve they own big project after that collection ,Get to it Sony .
+psyrakan hello
Fjolltzu hey bruh how you doing ?
psyrakan you still remember me?
Fjolltzu yes but vaguely sorry man :-(
psyrakan hmm vaguely ehh? You recommended to me that i watch natural born killers. That was like 6 months ago :D
Favorite Uncharted Game! Maybe Thief's End will change that.
+HandsomeRanger
Hope so!
+The Gaming Fox Shut up douchebag
It did for me.
Nope
Nope.avi
I see they took away the alien eye look of Chloe's eyes
+Ken Gevon Thank God! I was always so bothered by the way her eyes looked.
As someone who loved this game when I first got my PS3, I have to say that this game went through quite an amount of changes to graphics with *updates* on the PS3 version. I specifically remember the first sequence, where Nate is on the train, to look different with the way they used lighting. It seemed to be mostly downgrades, or changes in light intensities and locations. I remember being upset that my game looked *worse* after I updated it.
The amount of detail put into the original alone is a real testament to how much commitment Naughty Dog put into their games. The bamboo casting light on the train car is such a small detail that hardly anyone would have noticed, and yet it's still amazing to be there. The original game still looks awesome, but the new version is just incredible.
there is something in Uncharted 2 that was missing on it's 2 sequels. satisfying and diverse level.
this game always makes you like moving... always want you to be surprised, and the cenimatics has it's own charm that you can't find to it's sequels. they are great games but this one is the definitive Uncharted game.
One of the best games ever. Not trying to compare it with others tho.
+ELmaggo10 But Tomb Raider tho... :D
games ? this is movie - script , script , cutscene , cutscene and press x to win .. this is shit
+HandsomeRanger no one has given a fuck about tomb raider since the 90's. Only desperate fanboys wanna act like the franchise is all of sudden relevant again.
TruthHurts It was a joke
HandsomeRanger the statement still stands.
This is the holy of holiest Uncharted games. Man I can't wait to replay this!
Got this game when I was 10 or 11 years old when it came out. I'm 18 now. Time goes pretty fast and I seriously miss this game. Had such a good time platinuming it and playing the multiplayer!
5:43 is what bothers me about the remaster. No motion blur for pre-rendered cutscenes made the cinematic scenes feel less cinematic… and makes it look “cheap” even. Wish they would have addressed that via firmware update when they said “improved movie quality”.
Uncharted on PS3: 30 fps 720p
Uncharted on PS4: 60 fps 1080p ultra
Uncharted on PC: 0 fps 0p
siegeh25 1080p 60fps... on UA-cam
Ouch. Wow.
Well you can use an emulator for playing this game
Eni Sahatqija However only Drake's Fortune is working (for now), and it's still with framerate issues and graphical bugs.
PC doesnt need uncharted
I remember playing this for the first time in middle school,never hearing about it beforehand, and having my mind blown over how amazing it looked. The ps3 version still looks great to this day. I would get the remastered collection for my ps4 but I remember that part with the blue people, fuck that shit!
No mp or 4 player co op is the deal breaker
I'm about to finish it for the God knows what time, been hooked on this franchise since 2012 when I discovered it and up till this day it's the best adventure series ever made.
Wow, they really went all out. Looks like this surpasses TLOU Remastered... and it's three whole games included in one package!
Yeah, Last of Us remastered was really just s 60fps port.
God of War 3 and Uncharted 2 two of the best and best looking games ever on PS3
INSANE attention to detail! Awesome!
Just wondering, +DigitalFoundry, why don't you put PS3 on the left and PS4 on the right?
O bought a PS3 for Naughty dog games. And this was a masterpiece. lately I've been playing my Xbone and PS4 while ignoring my ps3 and 360. it is fun to play the old ps3 games again, God of War 3, Resistance, Ratchet and clank collection, Black Ops2 etc.. the ps3 still looks Damn good.
I started with 2. This game is so awesome and so fun to play. Really looking forward for the 3rd
My favorite ps3 game of all time. The day I beat the game, I immediately replayed the whole entire game. I have never done that with any game ever before.
1:36 nice transition. And 7:00 huge changes to DOF in these cutscenes as well, tied to resolution possibly?
amazing how well it holds up
At times on the remasters I prefer the ps3 look. Imagine the cell processor had been in the PS4 and developers learnt how to use it.
I prefer the PS3 in terms of pre-rendered cutscenes with motion blur. Big mistake to remove them. 5:43 is a good example. I know blurs were implemented later in game but it wasn’t so for cutscenes.
Got a PS4 yesterday just for this series, kingdom hearts, the last of us and God of War. Bye xbone!!
that train sequence man....
Played and finished this recently on PS4 - it's certainly the Definitive Edition of Uncharted 2 for sure! And the stand out game in this collection... DF looks nice but it's still dated even with new assets and upgrades. Uncharted 2 re-mastered is just gorgeous in every sense of the word! Didn't like some of the direction with Uncharted 3's art... the colour is also more realistic which loses charm imo.
The 60fps is a huge boost when shooting, climbing and in general moving around the environments. It looks incredibly fluid and smooth as butter.
The added specular effects shown in this video, during the museaum infiltration are actually applied to EVERY wall texture with art assets like those in the game, coupled with higher quality lighting it makes the scenes really stand out. The new icy sheen effect on the snow is very much visible in the remaster VS the old flat looking snow from the original game. Light effects the snow trails and creates deeper trenches in the newer version. Many added details on the train level and extra geometry on the environment in most locations really leaps out in the PS4 version - it just looks incredibly polished and detailed.
The eyes still bother me slightly, they look a little flat and not as rounded as the "bug-eyes" from the OG game, a small detail that doesn't detract from this impressive and worthwhile remaster imo!
A lot of those times where you thought they made new models or went back and improved them, like where an arch is more rounded, I think that is just the "normal mapping" or other geometry shader at work.. It accomplishes the same thing, but I don't think they went back and remodelled all those things and fixed all those things individually.
They definitely did. Normal mapping cannot produce a difference that dramatic.
I love this game so much, its my favourite game of all time. Hopefully UNCHARTED 4 can be my new favourite.
Also chloe and drake's eye's aren't as glossy on the PS4 as they were in the PS3 version, clearly one of the many sacrifices I'm sure Bluepoint had to make to get this to a constant 60fps on PS4... I actually think in a few cases the PS3 version overall looks better visually than the PS4 version, antialiasing, resolution and framerate aside
Not true
Anyone else think the train sequence actually looks better on PS3?
The colours were brighter and the PS4 version removed the shine for some reason, on PS3 it actually looked like metal with great bump-mapping but the PS4 version looks flat and murky
But then at 10:14 the paler look of the PS4 version allows more detail to be visible
I remember going to my distant cousins house for a birthday and coming down and seeing him playing the opening chapter of uncharted 2. Now nearly 10 years later (little late I know) I'm playing Uncharted 2 and I realized I was playing the same thing years later! It was crazy for me.
after seeing so many terrible "Remasters" that lazy developers and publishers shat out on on the PS4 and Xbox One, its nice to see a few that show actual *effort* behind them, let alone have a reason to exist
honestly, i dont like either of the Metro games (just not my cup of tea), but ill be damned if i thought that the Metro Redux bundle on PS4 and Xbox One didnt have a reason to exist, especially 2033 since that game was a bit of a hot mess on the Xbox 360 and PC when it came out. not to mention, Metor 2033 never came out on PS3, so you would only be able to play 2033 on the Redux version if you only had Playstation consoles
anyways i may just pick this up just to see Drake's Fortune in a much better condition. the first game was the only one i havent beaten on Crushing (i even beat Golden Abyss. *cringes at the memories of the QTE Final Bosses*), so itll be great to finally tackle Drake's Fortune on Crushing
Perhaps the reason they removed motion blur from the cutscenes is that they were running at 60fps. Maybe they felt it didn't need it at a higher framerate? Is it kind of odd, though. I'd personally just reduce it at a higher framerate, cut it in half
Just fyi for the train sequence, the train did actually move through the environment.
Naughty Dog will always have a special place in my heart.
Best graphic comparison video ever!
As a person who for a long time gamed only on crappy PCs, I finally got to a position in life where I could easily afford to buy any kind of gaming device - so I opted for a PS4... Couldn't see what the hype was about for Uncharted, but bought the collection - then started wit UC 1 - wasn't thrilled, but, then UC 2 - its a true rolllecoaster, the most finely paced game ever made... Just couldn't stop playing it. It tops UC 4 for all its technical prowess - the train setpiece remains the best setpiece in all of gaming...
Good to see DF spending a significant amount of time on great last gen tittles. Uncharted is undoubtedly the best gaming franchise in this planet at the moment. All the games had spectacular story and presentation. Thank you DF, wish you guys also included the Hotel ShangriLa Pool sequence!
this game and God of war 3 made me bought a PS3 in 2009. Uncharted 2 was the best looking game of the PS3 far beyond TLOU or Uncharted 3
The nathan drake collection games is a 3 games in only 1 disc ?
yes
I still wish that they would have brought over the multiplayer... One of the best multiplayer games ever.
For a game that's heavily focused on single player surprisingly had a very good MP. Had a lot of fun and enjoyed it while I had my PS3.
You want some eggs and bacon? Add some geometry to it. You want to read a novel? Add a bit of geometry with that.
loved this game so much, if they had multiplayer I would have bought it again so the multiplayer could be revived on 2. not seeing the point buying it now when I have all 3 on PS3 already.
This game background music insane,
It would have been a great port if it wasn't for butchered music quality
The music quality is the same if not better. At least that's my experience playing them now.
Where did you experience bad music quality?
John sounds so young!
Ps3 1182x720p@30fps
Ps4 1920x1080@60fps good texture and image quality
all 3 Uncharted games render at 1280x720p on PS3, not 1182x720p
the best improvement is Chloes eyes. She looked like a doll in the ps3 version. now she looks hot and human :)
overall not much improvement though. The biggest improvements clearly went to Uncharted 1 which looks noticeably better than the ps3 version.
Uncharted 2 is my favorite video game of all time. I played it when I was in a rough spot in my life. And I made a lifelong best friend from playing it with my then college roommate. So Bluepoint, you better fucking nail this I swerr ta GAWWD
Im receiving my PS4 tomorrow (hopefully) and the first game ill play is uncharted 4... I havent played any uncharted part yet. Is it worth getting the second one after playing the fourth? Or getting the third one after playing the fourth? Whats your opinion about that?
Nathan is in the snow, but he doesn't pull his sleeves down for warmth. I guess he's gotta look good no matter the conditions!
Uncharted 2 is the best of all series. I would give this game 11/10:) it's that good
I would LOVE to see Jak II HD along with Jak's other 2 remastered games given the same video treatment that you've done with the Uncharted trilogy remastered!
For console that came out in 2006, while definitely outdated hardware-wise, the graphics the PS3 is able to pull off still look pretty good even in 2016. I just finished The Last of Us, a 2013 PS3 game looks just as good as 2015 PC games run on high graphics setting.
+Pre114
LOL That's a good one...
But you know, April Fools isn't for a few days from now.
+UndertakerU2ber STFU PC Kid
GTPlanet1™
LOL Since when is the PC a kids platform? Last I checked, most kids don't even know how or where to put a stick of RAM into a PC. Why don't you go back to your kiddy console made of tablet bargain-bin components. I'll be enjoying cheaper games with Steam sales and buttery smooth 120fps at 4K resolution with all settings maxed out. Oh, and if I ever want to play your exclusives, I can fire up an emulator and play them all on my PC at higher resolutions with HD texture mods. B^3
@@UndertakerU2ber Hahahahah most of those emulators are buguu laggy broken and useless
+Expert Gaming HD
Not really. PS3 emulation is picking up steam, and Wii U emulation has already been a thing for a while. Also, all emulators from the Wii and below run games near perfectly, and play all the exclusive games due to the focus from the devs to get those games running.
I loved playing Mario Kart 8 and Breath of the Wild on my PC, and soon, I'll be able to play the entire PS3 library with even better graphical settings than the original console. I've already got Ni no Kuni and Demon Souls sitting on my SSHD waiting to be played once I get a CPU that has at least 8 CPU cores :)
I wonder if the added geometry in some cases is tesselation, rather than artists remaking the asset? Interesting thought.
Played uncharted 1 and 2 on PS3. Just finished 4 remastered on ps5 at 100fps. Just started uncharted 1 but it's a bit of a step back, might go to 3 then 2 then 1. One thing to note, apart from increasing the resolution and fps to 60 (necessary as I don't touch 30fps games anymore), I don't think it needed the improvements to models, it looks great already and making it look 5% better seems like a bit of a waste of time.
Here cause it's part of the free to play promotion. I'm definitely happy and so glad I'm got the opportunity to play this. It's absolutely amazing.
If you haven't played these games yet and you own a ps3/ps4... For shame!
how could you have not mention the missing beard in remaster...
I wanted to see the scenes from Hotel Shangri La.
I remember when I got there my first time. The scene completely awed me. I thought it wasn't possible to get more awed from what I have seen before but I was so wrong.
I'm surprised you guys didn't mention that they fixed the bugeye effect on every character in the PS3 version.
I think uncharted 2 had better graphics than uncharted 3
Waiting for the xbox fanboys to call DF biased.
haha yep
This was the first game I played on my PS3. I bought it for $300 dollars used from a friend. It was the BC version, the first version of the ps3. I had to get the new slim version after the blu ray drive quit working.
Take a shot every time he says 'added geometry/specular effects'. You will die of alcohol poisoning.
And here I thought all these years that video games were supposed to be played for the experience. This degree of navel-gazing about tech specs boggles my mind. Who goes to movie theaters and does this sort of thing?
When you're playing a game, you're so invested and focused that 95% of these points in this video aren't even registering.
You really do have to have them running side by side to notice any difference.
Videos like this are just proof that the industry pushing tech specs as a sales pitch has worked on some
I'm expecting a full remake from bluepoint before I jump into Drake's ship. Drake's Legacy should be their next project.
1- Uncharted 2
2- Uncharted 4
3- Uncharted 1
4- Uncharted 3
5- Uncharted: Golden Abyss
6- Uncharted: Lost Legacy
Surprised these games never got pro support.
Did you intentionally sync the bug with the music at 9:07 ?
NGL Uncharted 2 PS3 port looks bad for the most part if you actually play it. Despite the grittier atmosphere. The game is full of dingy textures, poor antistrophic filtering, dull surfaces, jaggies, despite being one of the best graphics on the console.
PS4 port looks great despite the fact all the characters have a weird noodle arms and hot dog fingers. I enjoy the increased polygon count, textures, better resolution,lighting, framerate.
The PS3 version wasn’t a port. It was made first before the PS4 version. That said, they both have something they lack. PS4 version lacking the motion blurs for the pre-rendered cutscenes is a big one for me. Really takes away the cinematic feel that I really loved from the Ps3 version. And Elena’s face was changed for the worse in the remaster for Uncharted 2. She looks like a whole different character, especially with the eyes, while everyone else looks the same with less glass-looking eyes (good fix). I played Uncharted 2 on the PS3 so much I can’t help but not notice the differences. PS4 version is a technical improvement but had questionable artistic changes.
@@ShMartinJo "I like the blurry version of cutscenes better." Wow
Every time he says geometry take a shot
Great analysis, but you said added geometry so many times.
The remaster without blur takes something away from the game but I understand the move
Not really a Remaster.
At least with TR:Definitive Edition it was night and day.
I didn't need to compare them to see the changes.
And before I get called out for being an "Xbox One Direction Fangirl".
Look at Sonic Adventure vs Sonic Adventure DX, that's a remaster.
You should watch NX GAMER's analysis of this collection.
+Sending Postcards From A Plane Crash Tomb Raider "remaster" was a port of the PC version without even adding all of the PC features.
+WelcomeToReality In a lot of cases people preferred the PC version. Global Illumination, depth of field and textures were a lot better on PC. Lara's new face doe.
WelcomeToReality Actually it wasn't the PC version.
Check it out for yourself.
They rebuilt the game and made it look better than the PC version.
Douglas Yeaman Really?
I thought she looked better in the PC version, and the environments looked better on the PS4.
To each their own I guess.
I've never enjoyed the uncharted games, but I might give the series a chance again.
...hmmm the snow looks better on PS3, on PS4 is more like fake shapes just to present some kind of snow interaction I mean it's OK but weird and all other details are great so that snow trails poke the eyes
It's weird that Drake took the jeep in for a bondo and primer job between the two releases, but must not have been able to afford a paint!
Wow that's a lot of stuff to go back and improve. Its too bad a lot of it wouldn't be noticed unless put under the microscope like it is here but its really nice to see all the real work Naughty Dog did.
The game already looked fantastic and this remaster will still impact people like the original did on release
Do you guys analyze the ntsc or pal versions of games?
Remasters are always darker...it's so pointless.
Love how this channel has basically become the Uncharted channel... For months now been spamming us with these videos while ignoring most other game releases...
Bluepoint Games is literally the best company for remakes and remasters of old games.
This video should be called "Bluepoint is godlike company part 2"