You have to remember that when Eminem sang that song he had a back up singer that together singing certain parts made the song sound even better and at some point gave Eminem get a few seconds of rest. I just watched him perform it on the 23 Grammy awards here on yt. check it out. Anyway Eminem is amazing. I am 68 and I heard a lot of his music due to having a 16 year old daughter who played his music. When I first heard him singing Slim Shady I thought he was a black guy. I am a music lover who comes from the 60's and 70's era so I am not your typical grandmother. lol. I enjoy music and dancing. It keeps your heart happy.
what breath control? She changed the rhythm a lot, i'm not criticising though I love her and Eminem equally! But i'm from Brazil and I can sing much better than this, matter of fact i can speed 93 eminem songs on x1.5 speed on youtube while i know all those lyrics by heart!
She is an amazing singer. She did this song with no back up singer like Eminem did. Watch the 23 Grammy's where Eminem sings this song but has a back up singer who fills in at time giving Eminem a few seconds to catch his breath. That is a difficult song to sing but a great song that I still enjoy listening too. I wish Kelly all the best as well as Eminem.
@@evieb6321 Sure, you can nitpick, but it's pretty corny. She literally learns these songs, memorizing the lyrics and arranging the melodies and production all in a day FOR her fans who are the ones requesting them. And that's amidst having to perform full set lists of vocally demanding songs majority of the industry can't hold a candle to day in and day out LIVE. She did an exceptional job...
Kelly is BRAVE. How many of you saying how bad this is would ever stand up in front of thousands of fans and cover a song you don't know all the words to? She's doing this for her fans, her love of music and to have fun!! Great idea and listen to the fans' reaction. Keep it up, Kelly. Your fans love you because of your amazing voice, your crazy, fun personality and your fearlessness!!
I have said many times that Kelly can sing anything but none of those times did I imagine her singing rap. Once again: Kelly Clarkson can sing anything. Love her.
I have new respect for her, whereas, I never did. It's one thing to rap, but to hold harmony AND actually sing is extreme talent. That girl is singing.
why did you never have respect for her before? She's a hard working, talented singer. Not being into her is one thing, not respecting her is something else. She's incredible.
I love this bad ass White girl she got real soul and a natural curvy shape. She can switch her Style up from country to pop to soul to hip hop..she's under rated.
For anyone who doesn't have time to read all 1200 comments, here is the summation: Kelly Clarkson awesome singer Eminem breath backup breath love amazing spaghetti spaghetti spaghetti spaghetti spaghetti spaghetti spaghetti.
Kelly is beyond AMAZING! Was it perfect, no. Do I like rap, no. But I love Kelly for tackling it. And she learns the covers the day of the performance. She will sing anything and in most cases she is brilliant! And if she wanted to put the effort out she could master this. Kudos Kelly!
RAYDi8OR Well he's uneducated af if he says it's not music since rap requires way more talent than any other genre (if you're a real MC of course, not like Nicki, Iggy, Drake, Lil Wayne, Kanye and so on)
Emil Bodsäter rap is not music. that's not to say that it doesn't require talent and isn't pleasurable to listen to, it's just not music. however as most people don't care about actual definitions any more it's classified as such. however it does not require "way more talent" that other genres. music all over requires talent. if i had to choose a genre that requires the most talent i would probably say it would be classical.
Other than sound quality issues, this was really good. She looks good and anyone who is calling her fat is no authority on weight classes. She looks good and sounds awesome.
Totally! I've always loved Kelly but now I have a new level of respect for her. She didnt try to be Em, she put her spin on it and I would buy that if it was a single.ACE!
I agree the band was loud but as i have mentioned before Eminem had a back up singer to help on certain parts of the song which gave it an exciting feeling. Kelly is the best! Eminem is also an amazing entertainer. Much love to both of these awesome singers.
I know it’s been a while since this was uploaded but I came across Kelly saying she covered this song and she said it was terrible, she said to go ahead and look it up. Seriously, I didn’t see anything wrong with this. She’s not a rapper so it sounded more like singing but what awesome breath control that took. I actually enjoyed it more than the original, but then I’m not much of a rap fan unless it’s BTS lol, so take that for what it’s worth. She was a good sport for even considering doing this, not many would even try.
I was not a fan, saw her in concert...loved her ever since. She does a lot of darker alternative. People made requests, she could do them on the spot. Her range is insane.
I'm shooked. She said it was a disaster and I was like... nahh you just exaggerating and she was. That's was AMAZING🔥. C'mon she rocks. The control and having fun is mesmerising. Can we have a collab please?🙏
Eminem couldn't even pull this off at the Oscars. He let background track say some of the words for him. After all, you cant catch a breath when youre singing like that non-stop no pauses. And its a lot of different lyrics to memorize! She kicked ass!
How can anyone dislike this? She borrowed her friends hoodie for it! Start by borrowing your friends hoodie! Do you even have one friend that would lend you their hoodie if they hade one?
His palms are sweaty, knees big, arms spaghetti, Theres sweat on his vomit already, moms spaghetti Hes nervous, but on the surface he looks calm and ready to drop spaguetti... The whole crowd gies out loud, he opens his mouth but spaghetti wont come out Thats pretty much what I sound like when I try to sing this
Some people might say that is is really bad. Thre thing is that is not supposed to be a "eminemcopy". This is her "cover", its a whole different take off this song! I love eminem though and fined the original better.
Stop hating. Her fans asked her to do this, most artists would not accept the challenge and just say no. She did awesome!
6 years where was I???
She is great!
OMG...Kelly can sing anything! Dammm YOU GO GIRL!!😁👍❤❤❤
Like, she even says so herself lol
Taylor Swifts version still better xD
Her breath control is so impressive!
You have to remember that when Eminem sang that song he had a back up singer that together singing certain parts made the song sound even better and at some point gave Eminem get a few seconds of rest. I just watched him perform it on the 23 Grammy awards here on yt. check it out. Anyway Eminem is amazing. I am 68 and I heard a lot of his music due to having a 16 year old daughter who played his music. When I first heard him singing Slim Shady I thought he was a black guy. I am a music lover who comes from the 60's and 70's era so I am not your typical grandmother. lol. I enjoy music and dancing. It keeps your heart happy.
OMG you are funny, ever tried stand up? You level of wit is outstanding! What a comeback, wow you really got me there.
Rafa Medina Breath contol, the key to rapping
Oz Media sounds like you're the one who knows how that works.
what breath control? She changed the rhythm a lot, i'm not criticising though I love her and Eminem equally! But i'm from Brazil and I can sing much better than this, matter of fact i can speed 93 eminem songs on x1.5 speed on youtube while i know all those lyrics by heart!
Literally what CANT Kelly sing?!? The world would be a better place if she sang every song. Pure talent. I love you Kelly!
This 😐 she can't fit the words in. She just skips them. Nope. She doesn't want to rap them. She'll just sing it but not make sense by skipping words 😁
She is an amazing singer. She did this song with no back up singer like Eminem did. Watch the 23 Grammy's where Eminem sings this song but has a back up singer who fills in at time giving Eminem a few seconds to catch his breath. That is a difficult song to sing but a great song that I still enjoy listening too. I wish Kelly all the best as well as Eminem.
S HF Opera?
@@evieb6321 Sure, you can nitpick, but it's pretty corny. She literally learns these songs, memorizing the lyrics and arranging the melodies and production all in a day FOR her fans who are the ones requesting them. And that's amidst having to perform full set lists of vocally demanding songs majority of the industry can't hold a candle to day in and day out LIVE. She did an exceptional job...
Godzilla...
I came here after watching Ellen interviewed Kelly.. Hahahaha
Me too! This is one of my fave concert covers she's done.
Hanafi H same 🙋🏻♀️
me too haha
Same..
Kelly is BRAVE. How many of you saying how bad this is would ever stand up in front of thousands of fans and cover a song you don't know all the words to? She's doing this for her fans, her love of music and to have fun!! Great idea and listen to the fans' reaction. Keep it up, Kelly. Your fans love you because of your amazing voice, your crazy, fun personality and your fearlessness!!
What can't this girl sing ? She's good at everything love her so much !
Ur right, she's singing, not rapping
+onemoreheartbreak she can't sing this it sucks and kelly is almost embarrassing herself
MUSIC FAN as long as you're not embarassing yourself ;)
And that's why she's making the song seem shit
I like it
I have said many times that Kelly can sing anything but none of those times did I imagine her singing rap. Once again: Kelly Clarkson can sing anything. Love her.
The fact that she can take a rap song and sing it and WELL shows just how good she really is
I have new respect for her, whereas, I never did. It's one thing to rap, but to hold harmony AND actually sing is extreme talent. That girl is singing.
why did you never have respect for her before? She's a hard working, talented singer. Not being into her is one thing, not respecting her is something else. She's incredible.
@@DjDan0014 Maybe other people don't have the same opinion as you.
@@AJ-cv9zf Rapping takes more talent
This was actually pretty decent. I didn't think that a pop rock singer could cover lose yourself but she did it pretty well.
I doubt many people could sing/rap this song who aren't rappers, It's so fast with so many words, hats off to the girl.
This was 8 years ago and I'm just seeing this now.... WTF lol 🤦
Same!!! I love both Em and Kelly. I'm just like what!!??? 🤯 lol
@@cindyw262 I was in shock when i first came across this lol
@@johnmolina607 it's awesome!!!
Just now
Me too
I love this bad ass White girl she got real soul and a natural curvy shape. She can switch her Style up from country to pop to soul to hip hop..she's under rated.
For anyone who doesn't have time to read all 1200 comments, here is the summation: Kelly Clarkson awesome singer Eminem breath backup breath love amazing spaghetti spaghetti spaghetti spaghetti spaghetti spaghetti spaghetti.
trysometruth
Kelly is beyond AMAZING! Was it perfect, no. Do I like rap, no. But I love Kelly for tackling it. And she learns the covers the day of the performance. She will sing anything and in most cases she is brilliant! And if she wanted to put the effort out she could master this. Kudos Kelly!
You said it all my friend. Kelly is a Star
I don't think someone who doesn't like rap should judge whether a rap song is good or bad.
That's why I just enjoy her having fun with this.
Woah, finally a version of Eminem my rap hating dad wont hate!
my dad hates rap too
Mine too. He says its not music lol
RAYDi8OR Well he's uneducated af if he says it's not music since rap requires way more talent than any other genre (if you're a real MC of course, not like Nicki, Iggy, Drake, Lil Wayne, Kanye and so on)
***** Who?
Emil Bodsäter rap is not music. that's not to say that it doesn't require talent and isn't pleasurable to listen to, it's just not music. however as most people don't care about actual definitions any more it's classified as such. however it does not require "way more talent" that other genres. music all over requires talent. if i had to choose a genre that requires the most talent i would probably say it would be classical.
OMG she actually pulled it off. That was so good!
This woman is so gifted...she literally can sing anything. I freaking love kelly clarkson
Other than sound quality issues, this was really good. She looks good and anyone who is calling her fat is no authority on weight classes. She looks good and sounds awesome.
People are idiots. She did great
Totally! I've always loved Kelly but now I have a new level of respect for her. She didnt try to be Em, she put her spin on it and I would buy that if it was a single.ACE!
"If this sucks you'd better still come to my shows!" Haha. Love ya Kelly
I came here after seeing her on ellen! She said this went bad - singing an Eminem song- I think she is great
The cover that showed me once and for all that is a genius! I can only imagine the amount of breath control needed for these endless lines.
I love the original and I think this is such a great COVER.
By far the best that ever came out of American Idol! Love your voice Kelly. Props for tryin.lol.
Holy sh!t i can't believe she pulled that off AND made it her own.
It actually takes more air and lung control to sing it like this than to rap it!
Oof *8 YEARS AGO*
Kelly Clarkson is amazing. What a musician!
I love how she gave the song her own twist and made it her own :)
I WAS AT THIS CONCERT!!! SHE WAS AMAZING!! I want to see her LIVE again this summer!
Very impressive! I think most singers wouldn't accept a challenge like that! Well done 👏
Best singer on the planet
I love this girl... Pure talent...
Glad I'm not the only one who SINGS this rap song. 🤣🤣
Kelly is AMAZING. Seriously LOVE her voice!
Only Kelly Clarkson could have pulled that off.She made it her own and killed it!
omg she amazing! im a huge eminem fan and i had no idea she'd be so good, especially since im not a big fan of her music.
Wow this is actually much better than I expected it to be. Not gonna lie.
FIRST TIME SEEING THIS.. AWESOME JOB, VERY TALENTED
She did well but the band was so loud it was kind of hard to hear her. She's got a lot of balls to do some of these songs.
I agree the band was loud but as i have mentioned before Eminem had a back up singer to help on certain parts of the song which gave it an exciting feeling. Kelly is the best! Eminem is also an amazing entertainer. Much love to both of these awesome singers.
Kendall Brown it isnt balls it called "thirsty", desperate, pathetic.
Matt Smith Fans asked her to do it she always does one request on tour
I'll give her this much. Girl's got range.
How could she say this was not good !!I loved it😍
But can Eminem cover Kelly Clarkson? Hmmm... 😂
😂😂😂😂 could you imagine😂
Why would he??!!
Damn right
God can do anything
Nope... He won't even try
"Texas to thug y'all, Texas to thug!"
LMFAO
Mic drop🎤 awesomeness 😎🤩 love it🥰😍🤗
I know it’s been a while since this was uploaded but I came across Kelly saying she covered this song and she said it was terrible, she said to go ahead and look it up. Seriously, I didn’t see anything wrong with this. She’s not a rapper so it sounded more like singing but what awesome breath control that took. I actually enjoyed it more than the original, but then I’m not much of a rap fan unless it’s BTS lol, so take that for what it’s worth. She was a good sport for even considering doing this, not many would even try.
Kelly her self brought me here when she said she should not do rap on and ep of the voice. All that said not as bad as i thought it would be.
Same here !!! Came running to check lol
Wish this cover was avaiable in studioquality
Surprisingly pretty damn awesome.....
That was a hell of a cover! A difficult song to translate into another medium, but she pulled it off!
this song makes me want to eat spaghetti...
me to
same
+Victor Robin mom's spaghetti...
Trout
Me too
She is so down to earth, I love it - so brave to do this song
She sounds awesome whatever she sings.
Ok, I loved her before but this just made my DAY!!
She is my Idol..Her family is beautiful.River Rose😢😢💜🌏😇🙌😶😶😶
I was not a fan, saw her in concert...loved her ever since. She does a lot of darker alternative. People made requests, she could do them on the spot. Her range is insane.
I didn't even know I needed this until I watched it
She's awesome for doing this! Amazing to attempt it and do it in the first place and then to do it THIS well, unrehearsed? Great job!
that was awesome. shot kelly. this proves how much you love your fans
That was great. Best lose yourself cover I have ever heard. RESPECT!
Kelly is so awesome! She can do no wrong.
SHE WAS AMAZING! So glad that we heard her rap for the first time!!! Was at the concert!! Amazing close up of her rapping! :D
I'm shooked. She said it was a disaster and I was like... nahh you just exaggerating and she was. That's was AMAZING🔥. C'mon she rocks. The control and having fun is mesmerising. Can we have a collab please?🙏
Niice. Kelly had done it for her fans, and that's fkn respectable. 💯💯
not just an American Idol but it should be the Idol already. An iconic singer, one of my favorite vocalist same with Pink. I love you Kelly!
When she breathed the first lines and I went "EYYYYY" and everyone stared at me perplexed. I'm in class.
She seriously can sing anything! I love Kelly this is just one of the many reasons she is my all time favorite singer
I'm more of an eminem fan, but this is awesome!
I think she is more badass then she really thinks! This was sick!!! She is good. And damn those black pants are just as amazing!!!
Best attempt i have ever heard
This is amazing. What a women. What a voice. What a performance. Well done Kelly🎉.
such a sport! lol love it!
alls i can say is WOW AMAZZING!!! :) you go girl Kelly you ROCK ♥
IDK why, but I was waiting for her to say "if this sucks, I'm sorry Eminem"
Amazing!!! Unbelievable! You both ROCK!
I loved it. Go Kelly!!!!
Eminem couldn't even pull this off at the Oscars. He let background track say some of the words for him. After all, you cant catch a breath when youre singing like that non-stop no pauses. And its a lot of different lyrics to memorize! She kicked ass!
How can anyone dislike this? She borrowed her friends hoodie for it! Start by borrowing your friends hoodie! Do you even have one friend that would lend you their hoodie if they hade one?
Yes I think Kelly done a wonderful job accepting the challenge.
That was good!
so freakin awesome!!
blew taylor swift out of the water. I want to hear an emenim duo
She is amazing
His palms are sweaty, knees big, arms spaghetti,
Theres sweat on his vomit already, moms spaghetti
Hes nervous, but on the surface he looks calm and ready to drop spaguetti...
The whole crowd gies out loud, he opens his mouth but spaghetti wont come out
Thats pretty much what I sound like when I try to sing this
Lol
Emiliano De La Torre Since when is spaghetti written with an u?
FreestylStudio Since in Spain its written like that, and I confused it
Emiliano De La Torre maybe you're really hungry thats why all you hear is spaghetti
Beezerk Haha maybe
Damn!!!!..goose bumps!!!!...that was awesome!!!!
This is freaking awesome:O
I'm just now seeing this. Ummm.... time for Kelly and Eminem to get together and do a remix of this. That totally rocked!! ❤
she was pretty good much better than Taylor swift
why are people comparing these two specific artists...
because they both tried to "rap" lose yourself
hamilton soosaimuthu except taylor was truly garbage at it's best
k ya but kelly clarkson did somewhat of a good job
Taylor only did it for fun.. she's not gonna make rap albums now or anything..
great cover!
Love it
I love that she attempted this! She's awesome!
tooo bad the music got too loud you couldn't really hear her from the middle to the end. LOVE HER ANYWAY!!!
Kelly always gonna thug it out regarless...RESPECT MAMA🏆🏆🏆
Some people might say that is is really bad. Thre thing is that is not supposed to be a "eminemcopy". This is her "cover", its a whole different take off this song! I love eminem though and fined the original better.
respect,one of the best covers.
Very nice cover, Ms. Clarkson. I wonder how Eminem feels now when an artists says "I GREW UP listening to Eminem."
A lot of pop stars grew up for eminem. I am big fan of eminem. Look ed sheeran
Thank You for being brave!!! This is 🔥. Love how you went all in playing the role.
She's good wow
She could sing the damn phonebook and I would buy that shit...
She is amazing That voice!!
I'm here after the ellen interview