What If Minecraft Had a Redstone Update?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 сер 2021
  • 19 New Updates Everyone Wants in Redstone Update! Minecraft redstone is a pillar of the Minecraft community, but there hasn't been a dedicated update for it since 1.5. In that case, it's time Minecraft redstone got some new updates and features the community has been asking for in the upcoming 1.18 and 1.19 releases. Whether that's adding movable chests like bedrock edition, automatic crafting, or even colorful redstone lamp disco floors, these are some of the most wanted Minecraft redstone features in this Skip the Tutorial list!
    ▪Want more? Subscribe Today! ▶goo.gl/ZDDJit
    OTHER LINKS
    ▪Follow me on Twitter ▶ / skipthetweets
    ▪Join the Discord ▶ / discord
    ▪Check out my Twitch ▶ / skipthetutorial
    ▪Check out my Instagram ▶ / skipthetutorial
    ▪Character done by MagnaGallina ▶ / magnagallina
    Research and map by Jonah Walters
    Edited by Jeenneette Wolfe
    Footage collected in part by Frankie Mundo
    ------
    The map used in parts of this video is a modified version of the world download in GeminiTay's survival let's play series, which you can watch from the beginning here: • An Epic New Minecraft ...
    ------
    Texture Pack: Vanilla Tweaks vanillatweaks.net/picker/reso...
    ------
    Some music used in this video is courtesy of Mewmore. Make sure to follow their tracks at / mewmore
    ------
    Portions of this video are copyrighted and owned by Nintendo, and their use is allowed by the Nintendo Game Content Guidelines for Online Video & Image Sharing Platforms (www.nintendo.co.jp/networkser.... All other original content, unless expressly noted otherwise, is ©2021, by the Skip the Tutorial creator, all rights reserved.
    ------
    Mods with some of these features:
    www.curseforge.com/minecraft/...
    www.curseforge.com/minecraft/...
    www.curseforge.com/minecraft/...
    www.curseforge.com/minecraft/...
    www.curseforge.com/minecraft/...
    www.curseforge.com/minecraft/...
    ------
    Other Credits:
    What if Minecraft had movable chests?
    • What if Minecraft had ...
    Minecraft with RTX | Official Full Game Release Trailer
    • Minecraft with RTX | O...
    Minecraft Ideas: Connecting Chain Blocks (Chainstone)
    • Minecraft Ideas: Conne...
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,8 тис.

  • @skipthetutorial
    @skipthetutorial  2 роки тому +2108

    Subscribe, or your redstone stops working
    I don't know why it stops working.
    It just...did.

  • @holegrain3233
    @holegrain3233 2 роки тому +1952

    I think a copper wire would be a good solution for vertical redstone.

    • @benjigoldstein8843
      @benjigoldstein8843 2 роки тому +36

      I agree

    • @manikuddin2540
      @manikuddin2540 2 роки тому +25

      Survival craft be like:

    • @benedictlim3028
      @benedictlim3028 2 роки тому +5

      thats lame

    • @davidoliver7510
      @davidoliver7510 2 роки тому +38

      Vertical slabs sideways stairs combinable slabs would be awesome. But who needs vertical red stone when wireless redstone is coming out. Sounds a bit dumb and uncreative. Whereas vertical slabs sideways stairs combinable slabs would improve the builds and creative options.

    • @hencygeorge8603
      @hencygeorge8603 2 роки тому +1

      True

  • @imcomingafteryou8685
    @imcomingafteryou8685 2 роки тому +536

    Mojang: spends forever making a good update
    Everyone: MORE I NEED MORE

    • @albertgaming9907
      @albertgaming9907 2 роки тому +20

      so true,every game never get perfect,always need more and more updates,because people never satisfied on every updates

    • @surprisedpikachu7550
      @surprisedpikachu7550 2 роки тому +3

      Hey

    • @domino5525
      @domino5525 2 роки тому

      @@albertgaming9907 not me.

    • @busybread2378
      @busybread2378 2 роки тому +1

      Just me a little bit

    • @erichargrove2287
      @erichargrove2287 2 роки тому +11

      @@albertgaming9907 well to be fair, they don't listen to the community enough 🤷

  • @SacsachCCABP
    @SacsachCCABP 2 роки тому +253

    The pistons break red stone bit isn’t inconsistent, that’s just a time when Minecraft actually obeys gravity. The red twine dust falls when the piston gets extended, but when the extender is on the other side it doesn’t affect it

    • @gdtargetvn2418
      @gdtargetvn2418 2 роки тому +8

      It's just simply because one side is non-transparent, while other sides are transparent when extending

    • @batukdi4778
      @batukdi4778 2 роки тому +1

      @Chemsekcake but it's actually Shuba Duck it doesnt matter because extension still makes that face of the piston non-solid

    • @emmanuelthegreat422
      @emmanuelthegreat422 2 роки тому +4

      Redstone doesnt break on bedrock edition

    • @theodoricoadlaon1448
      @theodoricoadlaon1448 2 роки тому +1

      @The man ethan bruh

    • @xMINIMx05
      @xMINIMx05 2 роки тому +3

      But that doesn't happens on bedrock tho

  • @demodorgon2505
    @demodorgon2505 2 роки тому +132

    For the last time bedrock can’t connect leads between two fences

    • @MrYogurtExists
      @MrYogurtExists 2 роки тому +8

      Yes

    • @Filipinjo7
      @Filipinjo7 2 роки тому +7

      aw man I got excited with a thing for a second :(

    • @timber4785
      @timber4785 2 роки тому +6

      Yeah idk why he said we could

    • @IkiruMist
      @IkiruMist 2 роки тому +1

      No it can connect it

    • @magma90
      @magma90 2 роки тому +5

      @@IkiruMist how

  • @EuropeanFella
    @EuropeanFella 2 роки тому +299

    "In the 1.16 update, we got a new button."
    *And the crowd went wild.*

  • @Kaiser897
    @Kaiser897 2 роки тому +226

    This man forgot about wireless redstone coming up with the Sculk Sensors.

    • @likethisvideo4560
      @likethisvideo4560 2 роки тому

      *Fact : My Vids Are Better Than Skip The Tutorial*

    • @netheritepickaxe8601
      @netheritepickaxe8601 2 роки тому +27

      @@likethisvideo4560 Fact: No one asked

    • @alphasquared
      @alphasquared 2 роки тому +4

      He didn’t?
      He brought it up later in the video.

    • @jaythephoenix
      @jaythephoenix 2 роки тому +6

      I wonder if the Goat Horn will be able to trigger the skull sensor?

    • @gearoid4660
      @gearoid4660 2 роки тому +5

      @@likethisvideo4560 Fact: nobody likes you!

  • @chickenbobbobba
    @chickenbobbobba 2 роки тому +14

    6:43 This is a consistency; redstone can't be placed on non-full blocks

  • @clovinsky_
    @clovinsky_ 2 роки тому +20

    Me using redstone: **places one piece and calls it a day**
    Other ppl: **makes a gun and somehow isn’t American**

  • @ro_2525
    @ro_2525 2 роки тому +280

    I would really love to be able to dye the colour of the sea lantern’s light! So instead of just a white glow, it can have multiple colours!

    • @smore9831
      @smore9831 2 роки тому +4

      But it is a sea lantern

    • @Xandros999
      @Xandros999 2 роки тому +5

      That would be nice. Sea lantern is very neutral looking so it's a good candidate for a coloured lighting block.
      Oh what else would be nice? Raytracing on PS5. That'd be nice.

    • @smore9831
      @smore9831 2 роки тому +2

      @@Xandros999 maybe we could find colored fish that could be conbined with a sea lantern

    • @ro_2525
      @ro_2525 2 роки тому

      @@Xandros999 Ooooh yes I agree with you PS5 needs raytracing

    • @smore9831
      @smore9831 2 роки тому

      @SwagMC never gonna give you up

  • @toast6998
    @toast6998 2 роки тому +611

    I'm not good at Redstone but I would appreciate this

  • @Pixelhurricane
    @Pixelhurricane 2 роки тому +49

    6:30 I have an explanation!
    When the piston head on the left goes out the top facing hitbox has to be updated to reflect the head not being in that tile anymore. the hitbox is quickly disabled and re-enabled to swap them out causing the redstone to have no block underneath it for a brief moment and breaks.
    could still be fixed though

    • @fabiofanf3e813
      @fabiofanf3e813 2 роки тому +1

      Nice

    • @rs_mind8352
      @rs_mind8352 2 роки тому

      Actually, the piston switches bounding box quickly enough. The issue is that the redstone’s bounding box is much bigger than it looks, leading to the redstone overlapping the empty space

    • @reenactable6
      @reenactable6 Рік тому

      wut

  • @DragonSkylander30
    @DragonSkylander30 2 роки тому +10

    Honestly, I'm pretty surprised nobody talked about this, but what about extendable pistons? You could use the crafting table or change it by right-clicking, and by doing so, the piston could move blocks by 2 or 3 spaces instead of the simple 1 space.

  • @Phosphorite05
    @Phosphorite05 2 роки тому +72

    No major redstone update since 1.5
    I would say even though they were not fully for redstone the updates that brought honey blocks and observers were really amazing for redstone, now all we need is honey pistons

    • @thegreatautismo224
      @thegreatautismo224 2 роки тому +5

      What would honey pistons do differently to sticky pistons? It could move mobs, sure, but only ones that are right next to it. Upwards facing ones wouldn't do anything different anyway, and downwards facing ones would only pick mobs up briefly, if they'd even work that way at all. Plus, very little, if any, mobs are an exact block amount tall

    • @chickenbobbobba
      @chickenbobbobba 2 роки тому +2

      @@thegreatautismo224 their hitbox just needs to be in the block in front. It would be useful for me at least.

    • @Voxonthetube
      @Voxonthetube 2 роки тому +4

      and what about sculk sensors I say wireless Redstone is pretty huge

    • @chickenbobbobba
      @chickenbobbobba 2 роки тому +2

      @@Voxonthetube they aren't added yet.

    • @SilverMSM
      @SilverMSM 2 роки тому +1

      @@thegreatautismo224 Maybe honey pistons could keep gravity blocks from falling, and maybe they won’t let other pistons push them away if they are touching the head of the honey pistons. They would also would not pull slime blocks back, but anything else could, just like normal honey blocks. You also can’t jump high on top of them

  • @Lifeless_Asian
    @Lifeless_Asian 2 роки тому +4

    1:23 you don't get the desire of bedrock players to have a debug stick/customize shields

  • @NickAndriadze
    @NickAndriadze 2 роки тому +48

    *0:36* Mumbo Jumbo has already covered that. I agree with him, this feature would be too overpowered and would ruin the fun of manually moving blocks with pistons to places you want them to go. I'd better pretend that this idea is bad, though it definitely isn't.

  • @czkosticka2333
    @czkosticka2333 2 роки тому +287

    Maybe rather than automatic crafting table something like Press which would turn 9 pieces of some material in 1 block/item (Gold nuggets > Gold ingot, Gold ingots > Gold block)

    • @czkosticka2333
      @czkosticka2333 2 роки тому +16

      @Dacky but for better automating Gold farms And connecting them with bartering farms

    • @justindolan7246
      @justindolan7246 2 роки тому +7

      I see what you’re saying, but an update that would allow you to automate a craft (assuming that all the needed materials are present, perhaps in a chest connected to a hopper) would be way more useful on an unimaginable level

    • @RiskierGoose340
      @RiskierGoose340 2 роки тому

      Similar to the custom Compactor item in the Hypixel Java Server for Skyblock.

    • @friedegg3732
      @friedegg3732 2 роки тому +1

      @@justindolan7246 i dont think mojang wants minecraft to reach a point where you dont need to play

    • @aiosquadron
      @aiosquadron 2 роки тому

      Similar to the packer and unpacker press from immersive engineering!? Great idea!

  • @toastybutondifferentacc5775
    @toastybutondifferentacc5775 2 роки тому +105

    Coloured Redstone lamps don't really need to emit different colour light, just make the lamp itself red and have it glow in the dark too like lichen and glow squid

    • @cartoox7
      @cartoox7 2 роки тому +1

      I also make сool videоs оn Minecraft, rate)

    • @iwaju9227
      @iwaju9227 2 роки тому +1

      @@cartoox7 nobody will watch them

    • @winterwellermcyoutube4953
      @winterwellermcyoutube4953 2 роки тому +2

      @@iwaju9227 I will if the video seems good

    • @dpkingyt
      @dpkingyt 2 роки тому

      @@cartoox7 i will if you give me 1B usd

    • @asasnat342
      @asasnat342 Рік тому

      colored lighting isn't that hard though, i've seen a guy do that in his minecraft clone and the way he did it was instead of having one brightness value (for each block face? i forgot the details), he implemented three (one for each primary color)

  • @traviscecil3903
    @traviscecil3903 2 роки тому +8

    I like them all, but if I could only live with one, the change that would make orientation of certain blocks like hoppers and observer blocks editable is a must.

    • @ocn_palm
      @ocn_palm 2 роки тому

      I don’t know how it works with other blocks but with pistons of Java if you place it the wrong way you can just left click and right click at the same time it will switch the rotation I think

    • @traviscecil3903
      @traviscecil3903 2 роки тому

      @@ocn_palm I've never heard that before.

    • @ocn_palm
      @ocn_palm 2 роки тому

      @@traviscecil3903 I think Skip mentioned it in one of his videos but I could be wrong

    • @antmess9789
      @antmess9789 2 роки тому

      Similarly, editable signs would be nice now with the addition of glow sacs. I don't like needing to break a sign and reapply the dyes and glow sacs to the sign just to edit text.

  • @penteractgaming
    @penteractgaming 2 роки тому +28

    if i had designed the redstone system, the daylight sensor would detect light level not the time of day, blocks with item frames with clocks in them would output to comparators the time as different strength signals, dispensors would sheer sheep, place liquids and blocks that obey gravity but not drop items, animals could be fed via a trough block or by picking up dropped food items. and maybe an ender chest like block that has an inventory tied to the name it is given in an anvil tgat can be accessed by hoppers which would allow for long distance/cross dimensional item transport

    • @apexamy11
      @apexamy11 2 роки тому +1

      If I owned redstone, I would just make it easier

    • @roykorteweg
      @roykorteweg 2 роки тому +3

      Genius ideas!

    • @emmettdja
      @emmettdja 2 роки тому +1

      There is a mod for everything you mentioned.

    • @penteractgaming
      @penteractgaming 2 роки тому

      @@emmettdja what mods output a redstone signal according to time, reworks daylight sensors and/or disables dispensor drops?

    • @emmettdja
      @emmettdja 2 роки тому +2

      @@penteractgaming just power a dispenser and it wont fire lol. That's vanilla

  • @MegaChickenfish
    @MegaChickenfish 2 роки тому +84

    8:40 Made even sillier that this already exists in datapacks, I think even vanillatweaks added in a wrench for this. Make it in the base game!

    • @necromancer147
      @necromancer147 2 роки тому +3

      it's even in vanilla with commands so idk why we can't get it :/

    • @cartoox7
      @cartoox7 2 роки тому +1

      I also make сool videоs оn Minecraft, rate)

    • @iwaju9227
      @iwaju9227 2 роки тому +1

      @@cartoox7 nobody will watch them

    • @pre-seso6516
      @pre-seso6516 2 роки тому +1

      @@cartoox7 eewww

    • @aiosquadron
      @aiosquadron 2 роки тому +1

      @@cartoox7 Umm... We need to talk. I understand you are a small UA-camr (and so am I) so I understand that, but commenting things like this in comment doesn't help your channel grows. This may be better if we have a forum for small MC youtubers to be together and discuss with each other thier contents and stuff. But this is no way to grow your channel. Work on making higher quality videos than before, keep trying! But don't spam the comments. Thanks!

  • @jthomson8645
    @jthomson8645 2 роки тому +85

    While I do like a lot of these ideas I doubt they’d be added simply since after these updates minecraft could be almost completely automated for the redstone genuineness, especially after seeing the amount of automation you can already do with redstone. Keep up the awesome videos!

    • @koma_wtl9828
      @koma_wtl9828 2 роки тому +2

      I think that's the point...

    • @jaylenhughes44
      @jaylenhughes44 2 роки тому

      @Hagsilva what will you do after there’s nothing redstone can’t do

    • @jaylenhughes44
      @jaylenhughes44 2 роки тому

      @Hagsilva what I mean is if red stone does everything in Minecraft what will you do after that?

    • @chickenbobbobba
      @chickenbobbobba 2 роки тому +6

      @@jaylenhughes44 you build stuff. Redstone and farms are for quality of life things, and making the game easier. Anyway, mojang said they want automation in a community panel.

    • @EnemyStandUser_
      @EnemyStandUser_ 2 роки тому +1

      @@chickenbobbobba they did? can i have the link

  • @michaelplantarich3375
    @michaelplantarich3375 2 роки тому +1

    I love how many ideas you seem to come up with. Keep up the hard work!

  • @qwerty222999
    @qwerty222999 2 роки тому

    Regarding elevating dropped items vertically, all we need is a dropper that functions like a hopper. It will automatically spit out, being it into the world or into the inventory it's facing at a dropper's rate. It will have so many other applications too. Automatically dropping items into the world, without the need of spamming a redstone signal to it, has huge applications, for vertical item elevators and so much else.
    I recently built a huge furnace array with redstone, and you would not believe how much of a nightmare it was, to simply get the droppers to eject all items fully. With the new addition, it would automatically spit out the items, as soon as they enter its inventory (like via a hopper).
    Place a chest with a hopper below it, facing sideways into this new dropper hopper, in a tower all facing up, and you have your item elevator, without the need of redstone spamming droppers to make items go up.

  • @unoyoshiblu700
    @unoyoshiblu700 2 роки тому +35

    I would really like a "Conductor block", its like redstone powder but its a block so it can transmit _vertically_ and in all the directions

    • @ThomasTheThermonuclearBomb
      @ThomasTheThermonuclearBomb 2 роки тому +3

      That’s what the redstone block should’ve been, but maybe we can make the recipe like this
      ⬜️⬜️⬜️
      ⬜️🔺⬜️
      ⬜️🔺⬜️
      ⬜️- Cobblestone
      🔺-Redstone Dust

    • @randompersondfgb
      @randompersondfgb 2 роки тому +1

      @@ThomasTheThermonuclearBomb I think it should be like this:
      ⬜️⬜️⬜️
      ⬜️🔺⬜️
      ⬜️⬜️⬜️

    • @unoyoshiblu700
      @unoyoshiblu700 2 роки тому +1

      @@randompersondfgb i think it should be... Like a redstone powder block
      🔳🟥🔳
      🟥🔴🟥
      🔳🟥🔳

    • @khiemgom
      @khiemgom 2 роки тому

      could have been observer

  • @a.9252
    @a.9252 2 роки тому +132

    Movable tile entity's opens the doors to a lot of duplication/delete bugs, I feel like that's a reason why they aren't giving it to Java

    • @likethisvideo4560
      @likethisvideo4560 2 роки тому

      *Fact : My Vids Are Better Than Skip The Tutorial*

    • @a.9252
      @a.9252 2 роки тому +6

      Did I ask?

    • @M_1024
      @M_1024 2 роки тому +11

      They are in bedrock

    • @notalongname9817
      @notalongname9817 2 роки тому +12

      @@M_1024 bedrock runs on a different system or engine

    • @ryanh744
      @ryanh744 2 роки тому +8

      @@likethisvideo4560 Nah

  • @Thalanir7
    @Thalanir7 2 роки тому +2

    Non-Stackable Item Filter
    A new block that can receive items through hoppers and dispensers.
    This block has a GUI interface with 2 slots. Slot 1 is where you will put a ns item (eg. shulker box) Once an item (ns) is placed in slot 1, it becomes ‘locked’ meaning you cannot remove that item by hand, with a hopper, a hopper minecart or anything. However you can break the block (with a pick) which will drop the block and the item. Because this item is now locked in the block, the second slot will ONLY be able to hold an item (ns) that matches the first item. Ie. a totem of undying in slot 1 means only a totem of undying can go in slot 2.
    However a hopper underneath this block can pull the item in slot 2, essentially allowing a ns item filter in Minecraft that is automatic but still requires redstone circuits to input and extract items. Can be incorporated into storage systems using skilled redstone expertise.
    Additionally this item will also be able to accept seconds slot items that have different durability’s. (eg a full durability wooden sword in slot 1 means that any wooden sword on any durability can be accepted in slot 2)
    This ns item block filter will also be able to accept items with different NBT data in slot 2. Ie. a bee hive in slot 1 with or without NBT data could accept a bee hive in slot 2 with or without NBT data & different number of tags. Finally this block could also accept enchanted variants in slot 2 (eg. enchanted bows)
    POSSIBLE crafting recipe: gold blocks in each corner, 2 redstone dust in middle column on seperate ends, 1 bucket in the middle (or another ns item or an expensive item such as netherite ingot) & 2 smooth stone in the remaining slots.

  • @nacoran
    @nacoran 2 роки тому

    I used to play a mod pack that had a funny combination of blocks that I exploited (the one about rotating blocks reminded me). The autonomous activator would right click for you. If you put the wrench in it whenever it activated it would rotate the block in front of it. There was also a mod that gave you a small chance of getting a trophy for killing different mods and each trophy, when you clicked on it, would give you a different effect. Open Blocks, I think, was the one with the trophy. Anyway, some just made sounds or gave you the mobs drop. The enderman trophy would throw an ender pearl, and if it hit you it would teleport you (more like a chaurus fruit does now). If you put the trophy on the autonomous activator with a wrench in it and pulsed it over and over the trophy would spin and throw pearls, teleporting anyone who they hit. It was downright terrifying in skyblock where there was a good chance you would get teleported into the sky.

  • @MinecraftPigee
    @MinecraftPigee 2 роки тому +65

    Me: Looks up a mumbo jumbo redstone build
    Also me: Where do I start?

    • @likethisvideo4560
      @likethisvideo4560 2 роки тому +1

      *Fact : My Vids Are Better Than Skip The Tutorial*

    • @pietervermeulen1125
      @pietervermeulen1125 2 роки тому +1

      @@likethisvideo4560 just shut up no-one cares

    • @pietervermeulen1125
      @pietervermeulen1125 2 роки тому +2

      @@likethisvideo4560 just shut up no-one cares

    • @techibuzz5464
      @techibuzz5464 2 роки тому +3

      @@likethisvideo4560 Fact : Everyone knows you are a poopy self promoter

    • @attackehh
      @attackehh 2 роки тому +4

      @@likethisvideo4560 Fact: Your 6 years old

  • @EGJMoorington
    @EGJMoorington 2 роки тому +13

    1:28 that's exactly why I don't want and end update or a redstone update next, I just want a parity update

  • @larra_bird6803
    @larra_bird6803 2 роки тому +8

    My question is, what would be the function of a heavy weighted button? I could see a purpose for a light one for multiple player confirmation, but it would require a ton of players to push a heavy one to actually make a difference

    • @bhull242
      @bhull242 2 роки тому +2

      I don’t think he’s saying it would be the same differences as with pressure plates. I mean, the differences between wood buttons and stone buttons aren’t that entities other than mobs can activate wood buttons but not stone buttons (which is the difference between wood pressure plates and stone pressure plates) but rather that wood buttons create a longer pulse than stone buttons. (Note that wood pressure plates and stone pressure plates don’t have different pulse lengths, either.)
      As such, I don’t think it’d be a matter of having gold and iron buttons being light weighted and heavy weighted buttons respectively but something else that would distinguish them from wood, stone, and blackstone buttons. Likely pulse length (since buttons in general can only be activated by players doing a particular action, so there aren’t really many variables involved), but it could be something else.

  • @soupbane1688
    @soupbane1688 2 роки тому +4

    I think instead of a auto crafter, we got two new hoppers. The first hopper would condense any item that goes into it into the block form of the block. The second hopper would uncondense any block item into its normal varient.

  • @abvd92840
    @abvd92840 2 роки тому +31

    Mojang: we gave them caves and cliffs update so they won't bother us anymore
    Mc community: *Redstone Update*

    • @Bingnhonho
      @Bingnhonho 2 роки тому +2

      *there will be a sky update im sure*

    • @afewofmycommentsarecringy.8646
      @afewofmycommentsarecringy.8646 2 роки тому +1

      Impatient Players: *Hello*

    • @gamerdragon8605
      @gamerdragon8605 2 роки тому

      I would agree, if not so many Important stuff of caves and cliffs update would be missing until now.
      e.g. Warden, Deep Dark, Goar Horn, Bundle
      As I see 1.19 is caves and cliffs update part 3, end it seems that some items e.g. the bundle is still missing there

  • @ZaneCold
    @ZaneCold 2 роки тому +18

    6:15 skip lemme help with that
    When you put redstone on the side of a piston it takes 1 block but when the piston extends 1 third of said block is gone so the redstone breaks

    • @astikach666
      @astikach666 2 роки тому +3

      That's because the redstone dust is one pixel too wide. Had it been one pixel smaller, it would've stayed on top.
      Redstone dust is not 1 block wide, it's approximately 10x10 pixels, and since the piston head is 4 pixels wide (which means it's one fourth of the piston, not one third), t breaks off.

    • @cartoox7
      @cartoox7 2 роки тому

      I also make сool videоs оn Minecraft, rate)

    • @crissis3263
      @crissis3263 2 роки тому +1

      me on bedrock: *signature look of sUpErIoRiTy

    • @iwaju9227
      @iwaju9227 2 роки тому

      @@cartoox7 nobody will watch them

  • @rainbowcats19
    @rainbowcats19 Рік тому

    I LOVE the upside down hopper idea!
    But for the auto crafting, things like wood planks can be turned into many different things.

  • @_P0tat07_
    @_P0tat07_ 2 роки тому +4

    I want redstone logic “blocks”. I know there’s mods for it but having them in vanilla would be so much easier for redstone engineers to make more compact builds.

  • @GrandAudio
    @GrandAudio 2 роки тому +15

    You know it’s a good day when GeminiTay and Skip post on the same day.

  • @jaythephoenix
    @jaythephoenix 2 роки тому +8

    Redstone master: walking house.
    Me: burns house down installing a redstone lamp

  • @yty1941
    @yty1941 2 роки тому +2

    3:59 The question is: How should we craft a gold/iron button should there be one?

    • @roykorteweg
      @roykorteweg 2 роки тому

      Nugget or ingot is the question
      And why not mini diamond-emerald crystals?

  • @gamerdragon8605
    @gamerdragon8605 2 роки тому +1

    Moveable Hoppers and chests would be cool, but many people would complain because they use w.g. furnance as cheap non moveable block for slime based technics.
    Detecting weather and blockTYPES would be great specially when you could use in itemsorters to differentiate between itemstypes by useablility in other technical blocks e.g. "burnable fuel", "furnance smeltable", "compostable", "brewing fuel", "brewing ingredient".
    "furnance smeltable" would be the most usefull, to avoid autosmelters getting hoppers on top stucked with non smeltable trash.
    And smeltable stuff like e.g. gold swords are not sortable with the classic item sorters, so we need something for that

  • @ThePotskur
    @ThePotskur 2 роки тому +39

    honestly all these features sound super op, i don’t want the whole game to be able to be automated

    • @7mzam7md48
      @7mzam7md48 2 роки тому +7

      What is op about colored lambs

    • @DestroyerOfWeebs
      @DestroyerOfWeebs 2 роки тому +1

      Exactly

    • @pepearown4968
      @pepearown4968 2 роки тому +1

      I think auto-crafting needs some expensive block to make it work, so that it would be very difficult to have an entire “assembly line” of auto-crafters.

    • @dmitriydrozdov1035
      @dmitriydrozdov1035 2 роки тому

      Most of the things can be automated anyway. The mechanics are just complicated enough to stop most of the players from playing with them. The way autocrafting is implemented into the carped mod seems reasonable. It's not op. Check Ilmango's videos about it

  • @TirakyneTripleA
    @TirakyneTripleA 2 роки тому +3

    1:55,
    I would like coloured sea laterns as well, because they look cleaner.

  • @naturalharmoniagropius4486
    @naturalharmoniagropius4486 2 роки тому +1

    Dispensers having the ability to dye sheeps is a must for me, since I need it in my wool farm.

  • @chi-chinkirby1051
    @chi-chinkirby1051 2 роки тому +5

    Skip the Tutorial: *Has an Idea.
    Mojang: Write that down, WRITE THAT DOWN!

  • @sethcataudella3146
    @sethcataudella3146 2 роки тому +3

    Maybe it would be cool if you had to craft sticky redstone with a slime ball and redstone dust, instead of just placing it on walls.

  • @dust0192
    @dust0192 2 роки тому +11

    6:31 That is because the hitbox of the left redstone is on the part of the piston that extends and with the right one, the hitbox is on a part that stays in place.

  • @Request_2_PANic
    @Request_2_PANic 2 роки тому +2

    Hoppers can be locked already which can work to have a specific path for items to take.

  • @y2k04
    @y2k04 2 роки тому

    I had an idea for a reverse redstone comparator. It really only works on containers such as dispensers and droppers. If an item is detected, it will give off a 1 tick pulse, and continue doing that until there is no redstone signal from the container. I don't have a big enough brain to build this as a mod, but I did make a model of what it could be.

  • @Mothrune
    @Mothrune 2 роки тому +9

    This actually might be useful, I always wanted inverse hoppers

  • @ghastfear78
    @ghastfear78 2 роки тому +16

    comunity: red stone update
    mojang:sorry i cant hear you

    • @afewofmycommentsarecringy.8646
      @afewofmycommentsarecringy.8646 2 роки тому +3

      hey, let them take their time, the community asked for a cave update, we got not only a cave update, but also a cliff one! they havent even annouced the next update yet you impatient dissapointment.

    • @MrYogurtExists
      @MrYogurtExists 2 роки тому

      @@afewofmycommentsarecringy.8646 But still smaller companies have major updates every month which is why mojang development needs to be faster. And don’t forget that they have Microsoft on their back.

  • @Papyrusking
    @Papyrusking 2 роки тому +1

    Congrats on 3 million subs skip! I knew you could do it!🎉

  • @josephg.1.130
    @josephg.1.130 2 роки тому

    I honestly wish we had more machinery stuff, i remember long ago watching a dude build a drill that drilled out a whole chunk and had pipes moving all the blocks to places, was so cool

  • @tash5186
    @tash5186 2 роки тому +6

    Would love some wires, like when I learnt that copper was being added I couldn't help but thing about copper wires, like mix some copper ingots with some redstone dust and there you have it, wires. Like they wouldn't power any components placed on the side but only at the ones they end on, also they could be Installed on walles

  • @EatthePizzaa
    @EatthePizzaa 2 роки тому +4

    6:27 that actually works in bedrock edition

  • @niakredle6920
    @niakredle6920 2 роки тому

    Yea, they should get more uses for Copper and Copper Wires would be awesome. I'm an see them possible carrying signals even further than Redstone other than using signal inversion.
    As for the block rotation, that would be awesome for changing tracks in a train system for rails. Imagine setting a signal that switches the pathways between multiple areas so you don't have to make multiple track likes between areas. 🥰

  • @nicocchi
    @nicocchi 2 роки тому

    Dang, a Pulse Extender made into a block would be HUGE. Look, if I want a pulse to last longer, it's not hard to do with what we have. But we could detect block updates without it and we got the Observer anyway (along with many, many new functionalities). I would love a Pulse Extender block.
    As for other suggestions? Blackstone button having a different function, I would love a "button but actually works like a lever". Face it, levers don't fit into every build's aesthetic as much as buttons, they're mostly steampunk-ish or medieval-ish thing, while buttons are more modern. If I build a piston door, I always wire it to a button connected to a T-flipflop so it actually works like a lever instead, just because it looks so much more modern that way. I do this for light fixtures as well. Sure, modern light switches are either a tiny lever or a crooked button, but Minecraft levers are too huge for this aesthetic.
    as for why redstone pops off from a sideways-facing piston, it's actually quite simple and also stupid. You see, when you activate a piston, it changes the size of its hitbox for the base. So the redstone doesn't have enough of a block below it (or maybe it simply doesn't count as a full block maybe that's why) because the redstone's hitbox is bigger than the graphic suggests. I think MumboJumbo at some point wanted Mojang to make the redstone hitbox thinner so it can stay on top of pistons.

  • @RoxNoAnne
    @RoxNoAnne 2 роки тому +9

    One more feature that might help make redstone more compact would be compact logic gates. Like the redstone repeater and the comparator, they would take up 1 block in surface area and they would be compact versions of the redstone components

  • @mekbok
    @mekbok 2 роки тому +4

    Oh my god. This is something i’ve been waiting for you to make for so long lmaoooo

    • @likethisvideo4560
      @likethisvideo4560 2 роки тому

      *Fact : My Vids Are Better Than Skip The Tutorial*

    • @iwaju9227
      @iwaju9227 2 роки тому

      @@likethisvideo4560 nobody will watch them

  •  2 роки тому +1

    Autocrafter is a litle bit OP but "the Auto Block Maker" which only can convert resources to it's own block would be so usefull and not so OP. It can work like a composter, if you put 9 of the items it gives you block of it.

    • @Yelocalhooman
      @Yelocalhooman 2 роки тому

      About the "autocrafter" that thing is already exsist on bedrock, you just need right and enough resources and available items will show on the left table, just choose

  • @watergood664
    @watergood664 2 роки тому

    For vertical signals, I just use observers and a block that reacts to it like redstone lamps or bells. It's delayed but it works.

  • @shweli4326
    @shweli4326 2 роки тому +6

    Mombo be like: Pathetic!
    I built the same exact thing in my back yard in 5 minutes only using simple redstone

  • @nikolimoon6165
    @nikolimoon6165 2 роки тому +27

    My idea for an auto-crafter:
    A new block that has a similar screen to a crafting table, but if you click a recipe it chooses that as the one you want to automate and the order that the items go in doesn’t matter once you select a recipe and to get new recipes you need to have already crafted it manually at least once in the auto-crafter and when you place it it faces towards you like a chest or furnace does

    • @cartoox7
      @cartoox7 2 роки тому +1

      I also make сool videоs оn Minecraft, rate)

    • @RucaDoo
      @RucaDoo 2 роки тому +1

      @@cartoox7 stfu

    • @iwaju9227
      @iwaju9227 2 роки тому +1

      @@cartoox7 nobody will watch them

    • @MaxwellDoesStuff
      @MaxwellDoesStuff 2 роки тому

      That’s an interesting idea however the reason people like systems like dropper auto crafting is because it still leaves a lot of creativity and challenge to be had when designing one of the systems.

    • @jhayardejose8474
      @jhayardejose8474 2 роки тому

      Auto-crafter would be too op

  • @sewykik5004
    @sewykik5004 2 роки тому

    6:42 its bc the hitbox of the redstone dust goes over the edge of the extended piston’s hitbox, whereas it doesnt on the bottom facing piston
    it used to pop off with a bottom piston too until 1.16, so theyre not changing that

  • @davidsommer325
    @davidsommer325 2 роки тому +2

    7:55 I build a machine that can do that in vanilla (Java). I only testet it for 1.14.4-1.17.1 but it should also work in older versions

  • @Brans1044
    @Brans1044 2 роки тому +6

    The update that everyone wants is to make redstone the same as java.
    Also Java people often complain that chests can be moved by pistons in Bedrock Edition and not in java, but i think bedrock deserves such function since the redstone here is weird

    • @apexamy11
      @apexamy11 2 роки тому +1

      YES. YES YES YES.

  • @toganium4175
    @toganium4175 2 роки тому +7

    I can’t say that I really care about redstone updates. I already thing that redstone is confusing already.

    • @user-um8iz9cb9g
      @user-um8iz9cb9g 2 роки тому

      Nice profile pic just watching my hero academai

  • @j4n.276
    @j4n.276 2 роки тому

    i had the idea for an autocrafger for a long time, good that someone figured it out in a good way

  • @Karnifel
    @Karnifel 2 роки тому +1

    hey you should definitly try out putting barrels under rails it looks so good

  • @radioarchives8019
    @radioarchives8019 2 роки тому +6

    Redstone is hard. Talk to Grian. He knows the pain about Redstone.

    • @ThatUser
      @ThatUser 2 роки тому

      @Tidesinger As simple as opening your inventory

    • @shweli4326
      @shweli4326 2 роки тому

      Mombo with redstone: It's very simple!
      Grain with building: It's very simple!
      See something in common

    • @radioarchives8019
      @radioarchives8019 2 роки тому

      @Tidesinger So true. I can't figure out how. XD

    • @TheHotBlade
      @TheHotBlade 2 роки тому

      So this is the comment Debo Gaming stole.

    • @shweli4326
      @shweli4326 2 роки тому

      @@TheHotBlade Yup

  • @muffin4682
    @muffin4682 2 роки тому +4

    Now mumbo jumbos gonna come hopping by on his auto- Redstone machine!!

    • @likethisvideo4560
      @likethisvideo4560 2 роки тому

      *Fact : My Vids Are Better Than Skip The Tutorial*

    • @iwaju9227
      @iwaju9227 2 роки тому

      @@likethisvideo4560 nobody will watch them

  • @arzeonmarze
    @arzeonmarze 2 роки тому

    I think that being able to place redstone under upper half slabs would be pretty nice. Would've saved me quite a bit of time reconsidering my redstone contraptions

  • @fulcrummc
    @fulcrummc 2 роки тому

    i love how Skip the Tutorial, loves Mumbo and uses his vids a lot

  • @TobeCG
    @TobeCG 2 роки тому +11

    The auto crafter is a must in farms.

    • @cartoox7
      @cartoox7 2 роки тому +1

      I also make сool videоs оn Minecraft, rate)

    • @iwaju9227
      @iwaju9227 2 роки тому

      @@cartoox7 nobody will watch them

  • @assassinlykiller3681
    @assassinlykiller3681 2 роки тому +3

    8:06
    ... skip
    Have you heard if the weather app?

  • @qazzii6959
    @qazzii6959 2 роки тому

    these are all pretty good suggestions tbh, great job!

  • @axekimbo3026
    @axekimbo3026 2 роки тому

    I agree completely with all of these new redstone ideas and I’ve been waiting for a new redstone update

  • @madhusingh2592
    @madhusingh2592 2 роки тому +4

    7:10
    Pink sheep

  • @aaronchung9838
    @aaronchung9838 2 роки тому +3

    Everyone wants this, except people who actually use redstone.

  • @ddylan4cats
    @ddylan4cats 2 роки тому

    0:28 that would be great but if you use a dispenser to give blocks then there should be a placer that places blocks instead.

  • @Voidwalker07692
    @Voidwalker07692 2 роки тому

    8:14 I was legit talking to my friends about this one time, this would be great for charged creeper farms

  • @MimikApe
    @MimikApe 2 роки тому +3

    I just wanna point out that if there where iron and gold buttons,how would you craft them because when you put an iron or gold ingot in a crafting table it give you nuggets so how would you craft it?

    • @crissis3263
      @crissis3263 2 роки тому

      4 Nuggets

    • @MaxwellDoesStuff
      @MaxwellDoesStuff 2 роки тому

      @@crissis3263 wat

    • @crissis3263
      @crissis3263 2 роки тому

      @@MaxwellDoesStuff "iron and gold buttons, how would u craft them", he said. 4 iron/gold nuggets to craft them

    • @MimikApe
      @MimikApe 2 роки тому

      @@crissis3263 maybe

  • @jarihoogendoorn5823
    @jarihoogendoorn5823 2 роки тому +3

    Fun fact: there are flying spiders

    • @potato.8139
      @potato.8139 2 роки тому +1

      i think i have found one lol

    • @pepearown4968
      @pepearown4968 2 роки тому +1

      They technically jump, not fly. Arachnids can’t have wings. The only arthropods that can are insects.

    • @alexanderm.635
      @alexanderm.635 2 роки тому +1

      No there aren't

  • @nursemom-71-psn80
    @nursemom-71-psn80 2 роки тому +1

    I feel like something that would be cool is propellant tnt and stronger tnt. Propellant tnt can change the strength of the explosion the more tnt you use, yet not destroy blocks, and stronger tnt would just have a larger blast radius

  • @Jandro_33
    @Jandro_33 2 роки тому

    0:32 Fun fact: in one version or snapshot (I don't remember clearly) you could place command blocks with dispersers, but for some reason Mojang remove this mechanic

  • @iambatman3091
    @iambatman3091 2 роки тому +3

    "Moving Dispensers and Droppers would be a dream"
    People who use Dispensers and Droppers for Elevators :

    • @TimmyTheTuna
      @TimmyTheTuna 2 роки тому

      Lol imagine not being able to move them

  • @samchassar2960
    @samchassar2960 2 роки тому +3

    Won’t lie, I play bedrock and only bedrock and it really annoys me when people in the Java community go on about the 1 thing that makes bedrock a ting bit better, which is moving tile entities. There are so many things in Java which arnt in bedrock and it just annoys me that people on Java don’t appreciate the features they do have!

    • @jared4575
      @jared4575 2 роки тому +1

      I have the opposite problem. Java kids in comment section keep flaming bedrock edition for not having Quasi connectivity and it being “inconsistent” which is false, there is an input bug where the first redstone tick of delay is ignored from an input. Contraptions work the same way every time, or works sometimes when it shouldn’t work ever if it was on Java. There are a few other false claims I hear a lot, even from new bedrock users.

    • @GamerCraft-sv6bq
      @GamerCraft-sv6bq 2 роки тому

      Bro same

  • @CATCHTHERAINB0W_
    @CATCHTHERAINB0W_ 2 роки тому

    6:20 that one makes sense though. The only side of a piston that has no change when it extends, is the back. The front obviously moves, and the sides have their dimensions messed with.

  • @willyomnom8400
    @willyomnom8400 2 роки тому

    There was an old mod Called "Hopper Ducts",I cant remember everything but they allowed for upwards transport and i believe it was cheaper too. Could be an excellent addition to vanilla.

  • @shardskye
    @shardskye 2 роки тому +6

    This is literally the only time I'm happy to play on bedrock edition.

    • @coolestkai5812
      @coolestkai5812 2 роки тому +2

      Bedrock is not bad. It's still a pretty good version.

    • @pepearown4968
      @pepearown4968 2 роки тому +2

      @@coolestkai5812 I’d say mob spawning and redstone are its two biggest issues.
      I feel like Bedrock mobs despawn even with name tags, or if they meet special conditions like fish and axolotls from buckets, or tamed animals.

    • @coolestkai5812
      @coolestkai5812 2 роки тому +1

      @@pepearown4968 I get it. But so many people hate Bedrock for no reason.

  • @domi_128dmx5
    @domi_128dmx5 2 роки тому +3

    7:05 What does he mean by this? I dont quite understand

  • @user-bq4tr9om5d
    @user-bq4tr9om5d 2 роки тому +1

    I remember some old block from an old version of mobile minecraft (pocket edition) , it looked like a crafting table, but it had a gear and hammer on it, and I thought why not return it in the form of a assembling machine (an automatic crafting tablr if its easier). Redraw the textures a little, script it, and that's it! and done! (to be honest, I dont know how difficult it is to make blocks like this one I described, especially in java, but at least it sounds interesting, specially for people who are good redstone engineers and love automation)

  • @dnooch2147
    @dnooch2147 2 роки тому

    Honestly what I’ve found I’ve been in need of to complete both farms I’ve been building or just sometning I’ve been working on in general is a block that can take a redstone pulse sideways and emmit it though. Like say a pressure plate on one side of a block that when stepped on emits a pulse to activate the red stone next to it.
    Also a vacuum block that can suck up items, there are awkward times you get drops but they go sideways and not down so hoppers aren’t all that useful anymore

  • @funtamilanallrounder2700
    @funtamilanallrounder2700 2 роки тому +3

    Skip the tutorial : click if 1.5M views
    Me: seeing 1.6M views
    I'm going to spoil this man's whole career 🤣🤣😂

  • @o.pjuanshenobi6645
    @o.pjuanshenobi6645 2 роки тому +3

    the create mod explains perfectly what minecraft would look like in a mechanical update

  • @vickyotters9207
    @vickyotters9207 2 роки тому

    I think if movable tile entities were added to java they’d probably remove tnt duping. Seen as you’d be able to make mining contraptions but with chests on instead of duper’s.

  • @somnvm37
    @somnvm37 2 роки тому

    5:35 you can make a redstone clock with 2 observers already, it's not as custom, but 2x3 for custom speed is not quite bad (i thinnk)

  • @robertpattison6729
    @robertpattison6729 2 роки тому +7

    Love this! I wish all of these were in the game... imagine what Mumbo could do. Before 1k gang!

  • @dawnsoisson3140
    @dawnsoisson3140 2 роки тому +3

    1:04 Let bedrock have its perks!!! You have enough features we don’t!!! You have a mod for it, we can’t use mods. Enjoy your mods and annoying features we can’t have.

    • @dawnsoisson3140
      @dawnsoisson3140 2 роки тому +1

      It makes me so mad when Java players complain about not having what bedrock has. Java has mods and other features bedrock does not. Let us enjoy our better speed bridging, piston movable chests, and big salmon. You can enjoy modding them in.

    • @ninjachicken8773
      @ninjachicken8773 2 роки тому +1

      O

    • @exterminator9676
      @exterminator9676 2 роки тому +1

      Y'all would make great game devs...

  • @fyrl8978
    @fyrl8978 2 роки тому

    Skip: Complains about immovable chests in Java
    Me: We don't have chunk borders, crappy redstone, limited commands and needing a shovel for a boat

  • @Mack443
    @Mack443 2 роки тому

    Man, sculk scensors are gonna be fun to play with