You know most of the comments are talking about RV's "visuals". There's no question that all 5 girls are stunningly beautiful! But in 20 years no one will remember their beauty, but they will remember the rich and wonderful vocal lines in their songs. In other words, they will become immortal through their music!
@@Chaerrybebe I know jsksk she says moonshine that’s the producer tag line which is always in the beginning of their songs. You can watch a moonshine tag line video or even sunny side up by red velvet. It’s again in the intro
@@Chaerrybebe oh jdkd then it’s probably a word play made by moonshine xd they always say the moonshine part themselves but now they used the word milkshake which sounds similar to let a rv member sing which is so clever
I'm fcking said this a hundred times, but I say it all again WHY RED VELVET HAS THE BEST MUSIC NOR KPOP GROUP NOR GIRL GROUP SONGS IN KPOP it's BCOZ red velvet has an essence of RYTHEM in every single they give. It's not typical Cooky Cutter were every grps would just sing song, but red velvet have a MAGIC that u can called a real MUSIC a real SONG. the flow, the Vocals, the rythem and stroke it's amazing all in one. It's kind of if u love music in different GENRA esp in kpop red velvet music will not boredom you bcoz RV music is TASTEFUL and u feel the vibes, jive, dance, sing a long.
All of them can sing well. They have distinct voice that once combine, brings out the best. All five members are so beautiful. We can see their different personalities too.
vance astrovik really?? i think it’s just how her stylists portray her eg with the bangs and hairstyles like at red velvet’s debut I couldn’t choose between irene or wendy as a visual
@@user-yf2jx9hk6j I think she's very pretty too, but korean tastes are hard to understand sometimes, I mean AOA's Chanmi is also considered the "ugly duckling" from her group, and she's gorgeous. www.koreaboo.com/article/netizens-criticize-aoas-chanmis-appearane-call-her-an-ugly-pedestrian/
I like how so many comments about how beautiful/cute/gorgeous/hot Joy/Wendy/Yeri/Irene/Seulgi look and I'm honestly surprised that you could actually single one of them out for this because jesus christ they *all* look absolutely stunning
(Before)Red Velvet: Ice Cream Cake and #Cookie Jar (After)Red Velvet: Milkshake SM: Ok next is Cupcake and Smoothie and your album will be named Kimchi
This song/video is hugely underrated and deserves way more views. The video is really cute and it's a great song. They all kill it as always but I particularly enjoy Wendy in this one.
Beautiful visuals are the norm in k-pop group don't you think? A group with all of the members that have beautiful visual and great vocals, now that's rare and do you know what's ultra rare? The perfect harmony when they sing together. Each one of them is like one colour of the spectrum, when together they form a rainbow. That Ultra Rare group IS Red Velvet. Happy 5th anniversary Red Velvet and Luvies. Only intellectual stans ultra talent.
Angie Kharpuri actually you are a sad excuse of life. I mean look at you, being bitter and pressed about Joy 🤣 Hate her all you want while she gets all the praises and blessings. Joyful Karma 💪🏻
This song is really refreshing! Good for kdrama's OST (romcom) and also for morning chill and exercise. Will definitely play this at my smart tv every MORNING. lol :)
Seulgi wish finally came true when she said that she wants a free and enjoyable mv for red velvet 😍😍 and you can see it in milkshake mv 😁😁😁 Edit: i didn't expect that my comment will have so much likes😁😁😁 Thank you so much 😘😘😘
Can you believe it irene, seulgi and yeri almost knew each other for ten years already? And it's seven years since they all known each other. I wish all of rv member happiness like their first debut song!
Red Velvet the prettiest weirdos Red Velvet the cutest murderers Red Velvet the talended girls Red Velvet they are my favorite ice cream cake Red Velvet, Let's power up toguether!!
I can’t take my eyes of joy she is so pretty
butterfly ٰ 💚💚💚
gecjin َ
--
I 100% agree
me too
SAMEE
Yea
Red Velvet is the kind of group where all of them are your bias, change my mind.
Yea, I literally just decided to chose my bias based off my favorite voice because I like then all so much lol
i have one bias, changed your mind lol butw they all are so beautiful & talented
True
I currently have 3 - Seulgi, Wendy and Yeri
I love them but not really, my bias is only Wendy and Seulgi
HOW DOES JOY LOOK SO HOT BY HOLDING A BLENDER
Helpful Croissant ikr. That’s my question too 😌
Because she’s joy
Same question here hahaha
Sexy Dynamite
spenser yaworsky right!!💚
You know most of the comments are talking about RV's "visuals". There's no question that all 5 girls are stunningly beautiful! But in 20 years no one will remember their beauty, but they will remember the rich and wonderful vocal lines in their songs. In other words, they will become immortal through their music!
Happy Red Velvet 5th Anniversary!
😻🧡🧡🧡이쁘다
Happy Anniversary 💗💗💗
now 9🎉🎉
now 9th🎉🎉
Irene is like a mom with her friends spoiling her daughter Yeri here.
Lol yeri child
irene is offcialy the mom after her and seulgi fight :>
Joy: 0:44 2:50
Wendy: 2:04 0:55 1:41 3:01
Seulgi: 1:07 1:52
For anybody looking for the "Ah ooh la la la like it" parts. Free of cost.
IZ*Eunbi Wendy’s part at 1:41 is so funny and cute to me lol
3:01 is Irene
@RaveyNoob idk-
Thanks
So happy to see My Joy being complemented so much but let's talk about whole of RV BEING ABSOLUTELY GORGEOUS VISUALLY AND VOCALLY!!
2:18 omg Seulgi you can't just kill me like that so suddenly. My heart nearly dropped.
Seulgisus same 😭😭😭😭😭
Seulgisus im going gay for irene
ikr 😩
SAME 😭
Ikr so unexpected lol
Are we not gonna talk about how gorgeous Wendy is????
She's really gorgeous. 😍
Of course she is...but i think the most beautiful is Red Velvet
Yess true others people only talking about Joy beauty without seeing all member Red Velvet😥😥
@@nahdazhafira3277 also Irene
Dusty Fred
--
Ugh honestly Wendy’s charisma is over top in such a good way . God I love that girl.
joy and yeri look so good in this mv
Ikrr
tbh they always look good
they always look good
Ikrrrrr yeriiiiiimiiii
And Irene too
Joy’s iconic “Milkshake” is so fucking CUTEEE
she said moonshine lmao
@@pinkinmybloodd No I’m talking about 0:09
@@Chaerrybebe I know jsksk she says moonshine that’s the producer tag line which is always in the beginning of their songs. You can watch a moonshine tag line video or even sunny side up by red velvet. It’s again in the intro
@@pinkinmybloodd … it’s literally in the lyrics she says milkshake
@@Chaerrybebe oh jdkd then it’s probably a word play made by moonshine xd they always say the moonshine part themselves but now they used the word milkshake which sounds similar to let a rv member sing which is so clever
Joy really can’t stop being a goddess for two seconds ugh
안녕하세요
She is so consistent about being that Goddess so yeah ☺️
Make her please. Huhuhu
ughhhh yess 🤯
Same😳
Ok is nobody talking about yeris little scene at the end
Ahoy Robin freaking adorable
She really brag her visuals here 💜💜💜
She is really cute;-; I'm really agree that at first red velvet is not my music style but somehow, i started to like rvv more and more uwu♡.
I think that's spoiler about Yeri Bang 😂
This is such a cute video but That's the cutest scene ❤
I can't get enough of Joy's "yumy yumy yumy yah !", my favorite part of the song
My fav part when joy says shake it shake shake it shake 💃
0:10 joy’s little milk shake shout is so adorable 🥺
Every group must have 1 visual but why red velvet has 5 ??!!
The same thing I was thinking about ..and 5 main vocalists
It is because they are GOD VELVET
I think every group has more than 1 visual 🤔
@@mikaremo8136 ye but do they have 5
I know im like "oh she's pretty, actually no She is, wait no that girl, no i mean her, oh no that one she is beautiful"
Joy's visual isn't lying, she's a queen
This video was so cute!! Wendy was killing me with her expressions and Joy with straight hair omg
Yeri's the cutest girl in the world. Bias forever.
SM: how sweet do you want your milkshakes?
RV: as sweet as our luvies.
Happy 5th everyone❤
@@miqua360 enough to give everyone diabetes 💀😂💕
Actually i need 'In & Out' MV too
YES
Omg yesss
yeahhh
Sunny side up as well
Yes also Pose to
The members' faces when Joy says "Milkshake" are like: "What are u doing , girl?"
Kpop Wonderland haha right
I'm fcking said this a hundred times, but I say it all again WHY RED VELVET HAS THE BEST MUSIC NOR KPOP GROUP NOR GIRL GROUP SONGS IN KPOP it's BCOZ red velvet has an essence of RYTHEM in every single they give. It's not typical Cooky Cutter were every grps would just sing song, but red velvet have a MAGIC that u can called a real MUSIC a real SONG. the flow, the Vocals, the rythem and stroke it's amazing all in one. It's kind of if u love music in different GENRA esp in kpop red velvet music will not boredom you bcoz RV music is TASTEFUL and u feel the vibes, jive, dance, sing a long.
Sunny side up, bing bing, LP, and parade deserves a MV too
OH I MEAN ALMOST ALL THE SONG OF RV DESERVES A MV!!!
every song in the album is such a bop!
Agreeeeeee
Dumb dumb doesn’t.
Stream hard guys
Feng Ye
Haha idk what your talking about. Dumb dumb is a bop
Joy’s “milkshake” in the intro is everything
Melissa Flores 💚
yessss!!!!!
its so weird bc it sounds both like milkshake and moonshine (the producer)
@@chriswastaken420 I think they did that on purpose 😝
who is beautiful?
irene - like
wendy - like
seulgi - like
joy - like
yeri - like
including yeri + joy!!!!!!!!!!!
All of them for sure!
Well then I liked it five times
ㅗ
I think all of them I choose Irene and Seulgi
이 뮤비는 다 이쁜데 웬디가 진짜 레전드
I ship Red Velvet with every table they sat in every their mv. Their signature.
And wendy wiped Yeri's fake sweat. DO THAT TO ME TOO!
Why is nobody talking about the QUEEN THAT IS YERI?!
No one is ready about this conversation. tsk.
Hail queen kim yerim
she’s so cute omgg
No Irene is queen
Mike Ali Theyre all queens
I need more B-side MVs like this! Here's to 5 more years!
😂😂😂
15 more years!
Every Reveluv deserves to know about this masterpiece MV
I can't take my eyes off Joy she's so beautiful. Yeri is so cute too, v i s u a l s.
Ikr
Irene is beautiful
Seulgi is beautiful
Wendy is beautiful
Joy is beautiful
Yeri is beautiful
Happy RV Day
#5thYearsWithRedVelvet
Irene is the most
A new meme is born 1:42
Happy anniversary, ladies!
Wendy being wendy
Wendy is nothing but a living meme 😂
I love her... She's my bias😅
All of them can sing well. They have distinct voice that once combine, brings out the best. All five members are so beautiful. We can see their different personalities too.
They literally have no visual hole. The first time I looked at them I couldn’t tell who was the visual.
vance astrovik really?? i think it’s just how her stylists portray her eg with the bangs and hairstyles like at red velvet’s debut I couldn’t choose between irene or wendy as a visual
Red Velvet literally has 5 main visuals. They are ALL equally beautiful.
@@user-yf2jx9hk6j I think she's very pretty too, but korean tastes are hard to understand sometimes, I mean AOA's Chanmi is also considered the "ugly duckling" from her group, and she's gorgeous. www.koreaboo.com/article/netizens-criticize-aoas-chanmis-appearane-call-her-an-ugly-pedestrian/
vance astrovik Don’t call Umji fat, why do you think she’s so unconfident, she also changed, look at her images now.
All Red Velvet members are pretty!
I love all of them 😘
I like how so many comments about how beautiful/cute/gorgeous/hot Joy/Wendy/Yeri/Irene/Seulgi look and I'm honestly surprised that you could actually single one of them out for this because jesus christ they *all* look absolutely stunning
Yes
2:44 PARK SOOYOUNG SMILE IS LIFE !!!
Rodrigo 💚💚💚
PARK SOOYOUNG, WHEN YOU SMILE, IM ALSO HAPPY!
When you can't Choose a bias ikrrr
When you can't Choose a bias hi im a new reveluv who is park sooyoung here
hitormisshuh it’s joy
Park Sooyoung is really the definition of beauty
why rv members are all pretty omg not even a fan of them but their beauty is different from other gg
JOY IS SO SMILING
YERI I LOVE HER HAIR AND HEART GLASSES
IRENE IS QUEEN
WENDY IS FJDJFVISJSJ
SEULGI IS CUUUTE ❤❤❤❤
trespass97 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Wendy??😂
Finally i heard joy rap again 🤧💖 happy 5th anniv to us reveluvs 💖🤧🤧🤧 uwu
I really like Joy rap's. She is so good.
the behind the scenes for this must be fun
(Before)Red Velvet: Ice Cream Cake and #Cookie Jar
(After)Red Velvet: Milkshake
SM: Ok next is Cupcake and Smoothie and your album will be named Kimchi
cookie jar
Mohito
Makanan semua🤣
Let's go back in this comment when it became real. Hahahahhahah
Candy, mojito, red flavor
2:17 is my favorite part..
Seulgi slay it..
I love them,pretty dorks
Happy fifth anniversary RED VELVET
Irene ♡
Wendy♡
Seulgi♡
Joy♡
Yeri♡
Forever with Red velvet
This is the 2nd b-side I heard from them and it made me crave for more so I digged deeper into their discography and found so many hidden gems 💗
You won't be disappointed. It took me a month but I'm almost through their discography.
We can’t get over with JOY’s visual...
best girlgroup, best fandom, best vocal, best charisma. Red Velvet is a complete group, we reveluvs are so lucky.
I love RV, but I’m not sure about any of those.
@@literallyjustbequiet8711 well I mean it's their opinion so.
chanyeol's squishy cheeks I know. i just don’t fully agree with it. but RV are a power group fro sure. :)
@@literallyjustbequiet8711 oh lol that's ok and true they are a power group :)
@@literallyjustbequiet8711 you didnt need to say that but ok
JOY!!! You look drop dead gorgeous omg omg 😭😍
This song/video is hugely underrated and deserves way more views. The video is really cute and it's a great song. They all kill it as always but I particularly enjoy Wendy in this one.
SM: You want to release MV of Milkshake?
RV: Definitely, for our reveluvs.
This could be a MV comeback, actually ! So perfect
i didn't expect this but yesssss 💕💛💙💚💜 Happy 5th anniversary 😘
3:32 she's our songwriter, producer, director, our very own maknae.
How come they're all visuals?!
Stan Red Velvet, a group full of
5 Visuals,
5 Vocals,
5 Dancers,
5 Rappers,
and an immeasurable amount of talent!
💖🧡💙💚💜
5 years
lol true.
Non dire cagate
5 weirdos 😂😂😂
Zero Hero yess lol
Every time I look at Joy I feel like she just gets prettier.
1:01: PARK SOOYOUNG! WHEN! YOU! LAUGH! I! AM! ALSO! HAPPY!🤣💕
irene’s beauty is out of this world. she is SO GORGEOUS 😩🤧
I can't take my eyes of Joy😍 Joy look absolutely fantastic! ❤
Park Soo-Young! When you're happy! I'm also happy! *insert the fanboy of Joy*
I love these babies so much! fighting for more years!!
cheers, luvies!
Marithe Mata it’s hard to read “Park Soo Young” and not hear the iconic fanboy screaming 😂
#5YearsWithRedVelvet 💗💛💙💚💜
Irene 💗
Seulgi 💛
Wendy 💙
Joy 💚
Yeri 💜
We ReVeLuvs will keep loving and supporting you!
xXKuraidoXx ❤️
ua-cam.com/video/ja3JPxUyqQc/v-deo.html
Come and see my channel❤💕
Yerii 💜💜
💙
Irene is pink
How does this masterpiece of adorableness have so few views? I watch this at least twice a day.
Wendy is my bias and she's so cute here... But Joy keeps bias wrecking me I swear 😭
Now I feel like my username and profile pic got people confused lol
Yeah , it really got me confused
I couldn’t choose between them so wenjoy is my bias
JOY, YOU'RE SO GORGEOUS, AT THIS POINT, IT'S ALREADY UNFAIR
Beautiful visuals are the norm in k-pop group don't you think? A group with all of the members that have beautiful visual and great vocals, now that's rare and do you know what's ultra rare? The perfect harmony when they sing together. Each one of them is like one colour of the spectrum, when together they form a rainbow. That Ultra Rare group IS Red Velvet. Happy 5th anniversary Red Velvet and Luvies. Only intellectual stans ultra talent.
I love them all so much but Wendy rocked this with her short hair! She's too cute!
ok but,, can we talk abt joy’s visual... she’s really so pretty, i love my bias
how do you even pick a bias in nct same she is my lovely bias
Sameee
😍😍
Same 💖
Angie Kharpuri actually you are a sad excuse of life. I mean look at you, being bitter and pressed about Joy 🤣
Hate her all you want while she gets all the praises and blessings. Joyful Karma 💪🏻
*JOY IS SO GORGEOUS AS ALWAYS!!! AND HER VOICE!*
*WENDY'S VOCALS*
*YERI'S CUTENESS*
*SEULGI AND IRENE'S VISUALS*
*THE CHORUS IS SO GOOD*
I didn't even know this was a thing, wow, SM really sucks at promoting.
Plushy makes cracky I think this is a video for their fans at their concert.
yes, I just saw this vid too 🙄
I mean if you subscribed to RV's channel you'd have definitely known it .. so yeah...
Lyf for music 🍵👀
Just a b-side, as luvies you must know
in Red Velvet, everybody is a visual and an actress, this video is the proof
STAN RED VELVET FOR CLEAN SKIN, GOOD GRADES AND A PERFECT LIFE
you tell me this now it's summer....;_;
When Red Velvet makes videos for their B-sides
me: *_OOH LA LA LA I LIKE IT_*
okay i saw this before listening to the song and i thought you were referencing exo xD
@@smileyface8434 🤣🤣
Thank for 5 years of HAPPINESS! LET’S TOGETHER GO UNTIL 100 YEARS 💗💛💙💚💜 STUCK ON YOU😭
우리 멤버들 5주년 진심으로 축하해~♥ 우리 앞으로 오래오래 함께하자♥ #5YearsWithRedVelVet
Stunning, visuals, vocal queen's and more!!!
Irene is so beautiful
Yeri is just so sweetly cute
Wendy is a beautiful angel
Joy is dropdead gorgeous
Seulgi is so stunning
Happy 5th anniversary 💕
同意
2:19 we need behind the scenes for this 😂😂😂 we know other members would be joking on Seulgi 😂😍
anne dla why?
🤣🤣🤣
This song is really refreshing!
Good for kdrama's OST (romcom) and also for morning chill and exercise. Will definitely play this at my smart tv every MORNING. lol :)
SAME . I always search for such refreshing sound and light mvs to play on smart tv while I make breakfast :)
Wow can’t relate:(
OMGGG JOY IS SO GORGEOUS!!!!
Seulgi wish finally came true when she said that she wants a free and enjoyable mv for red velvet 😍😍 and you can see it in milkshake mv 😁😁😁
Edit: i didn't expect that my comment will have so much likes😁😁😁
Thank you so much 😘😘😘
Check out the I Just MV!
I Just is just like that, check it out uwu
Oh i forgot the I Just MV 😁😁😁. Thanks btw 😊😊
Tbh I prefer it over choreography. Just them having fun
I'm your one-thousandth like, I'm honored 😂
i got goosebumps when joy shouts milkshake
Joy is too perfect this is why I wanna marry her lol and IM A GIRL!!!!!!!
Me too 😔😭
um girls can like girls to
She's mine
The joys of being gay fr
*frantic consumption of Crofters jam* yep 😌
Why is no one talking about the rap parts?
IRENE, YERI, JOY, WENDY AND SEULGI WE'RE PROUD OF YOU..
Can you believe it irene, seulgi and yeri almost knew each other for ten years already? And it's seven years since they all known each other. I wish all of rv member happiness like their first debut song!
RED VELVET IS MY LIFE BUT NOBODY WANTS TO EXCEPT THIS
RED VELVET IS THE BEEEEST K-POP GROUP IN THIS 🌎
Red Velvet the prettiest weirdos
Red Velvet the cutest murderers
Red Velvet the talended girls
Red Velvet they are my favorite ice cream cake
Red Velvet, Let's power up toguether!!
Pili - Kun ʕ·ᴥ·ʔ CUTEST MURDERERS I-
Red Velvet: Making murder fun since 2016...
The Wendy "I Like it" at 1:41 is PERFECT 😂😍
HAPPY 5 YEAR ANNIVERSARY TO YOU BEAUTIFUL GIRLS
Irene 💖🍉
Seulgi💛🍍
Wendy💙🍊
Joy💚🥝
Yeri💜🍇
Seulgi
Happy 5th Anniversary !!! We love you so much 💚💜❤️💛💙
Happy 5th anniversary Red Velvet
#5yearswithredvelvet
5 years of being happy because of red velvet
stop commenting that joy looks good in this mv, *my hands are numb because of liking all of your comments*
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHA
Happy 5th Anniversary to my ultimate bias group!
Irene 💗
Seulgi💛
Wendy💙
Joy💚
Yeri💜
Just wanna know do ya guys like Wendy with
Short hair: like
Long hair: comment
Long hair
Short !
I LOVE BOTH I LOVE WENDY
like and comment because she looks pretty with short and long hair :')
@@ylasflores1365 same both
*HAPPY 5 YEARS WITH RED VELVET* ❤️
The visuals😳❤️
Red Velvet Queen of Summer
Irene ❤ - Godly Pretty Face
Seulgi 💛 - Sassy Girl Next Door
Wendy 💙 - Quirky Beautiful
Joy 💚 - Sexy Dynamite (as always)
Yeri 💜 - Savage Cutest Overload
💙
💚
💜
❤️
💛
That came out of nowhere but i like It !!!!!! ....I like It like milkshake ✨
Happy 5th anniversary !¡!!!
💚💜❤️💙💛
Hahaha this was actually played as a VCR at their fanmeet as well, a few days ago
@@devakibhagwat6146 ohhhhhhh i didnt knew that , they look so cute
Joy is a visual goddess!!!
Happy days
Perfect Visuals + Vocals= RV
ua-cam.com/video/iQpWDo-fGCg/v-deo.html👈👈👈🤝🥺🥺🖤