coming from someone who fishes, fishing is all luck and probabilities. Like you arent gonna go fish irl and open up the menu screen of what you wanna catch 😭😭😭😭
all games have rng, a chance of something happening, thats like calling ranked games rng, because you haev a chance of playing against bad or good players
Cos in jojo games you can actually do something with stands but in this shitty excuse of a game your just stuck with these fish in your inventory doing nothing
I've played the game, but in my opinion it's incredibly overhyped. It is a great game, don't get me wrong, but people are making it out to be the best ROBLOX game ever, and to be honest, I don't see it. It's just a very well made fishing game.. that's it. Nothing innovative/hasn't been done before, nothing special, it's just a high quality fishing game on ROBLOX (which hasn't really been done before)
yuh i dont think its anything revolutionary, but when compared to the recent slop we’ve been getting its a nice and chill game to play. so thats prolly why it blew up so much (also because big fish go brr)
@@Lira_May casinos to rng if u lose money or gain money so its basically rng and fishing require skill mostly irl bc u gotta set stuff up correctly and must fish with great skill and accuracy.
I’ve been playing fisch for 2 weeks and it’s been fun the concept seems simple but finally getting a good fish and having to play a all out war with it is fun the quest are super fun to like the trident rod quest where you have to obtain 5 relics and catch all the desolate deep fish is really hard but fun as it’s an adventure if you haven’t played fisch I suggest playing it badly ❤❤❤
Another thing i like about fisch- There arent any NECCESARY gamepasses. For example, In most RNG games, there is a Quick Roll gamepass, which speeds up progression by a TON. but in fisch, the closest thing to p2w is double XP, which is only used for boats (you could argue its p2w as it could be used to get the No-Life rod at level 500, but thats really hard with and without double xp.) and the appraiser luck gamepass, which only really helps in appraising fisch, which, sure, maybe itll increase your mythicals price by like, 1.5x if your lucky but its not neccesary. Personally, ive gone up to level 60 COMPLETELY f2p (besides the emotes gamepass cuz i love the emotes), and i did not have any issues progressing. Love this game.
@@penguinspenguinspenguins Sell anywhere is absolutely useless, cause you have infinite inventory anyways. Quick roll in most games obviously isnt neccesary but its REALLY important if you wanna get stuff fast, otherwise your 4x as slow as people with quickroll, which means its p2w
for me, i don't really agree, it is basically sol's rng except the auras is replaced with fishes and you just have to do a minigame to get the fishes, for the other mechanics such as getting better rods, sol's rng also have, in sol's rng, it is basically crafting gears except you are using your aura to craft gear. I think that fish is also quite repetetive doing the same minigame over and over again. NOTE: I AM NOT DEFENDING SOL'S RNG, I AM JUST EXPRESSING MY OPINION.
yea kinda agree, but feel like they could add more action, like storms or sea beasts (like sharks or smt) to add some risk to driving a boat rent-free, and add a sea creature boss battle system.
The game is literally fishing, like what are u gonna do about it? Just open up a menu of what you wanna catch? One of the comments who is a fisherman/woman and says that fishing is all luck and probability. It is an RNG game but it ain't just clicking on a button.
all "RNG" means is "random number generator" so most games are actually RNG games or have RNG aspects and fisch is no different, it is very much so an RNG game just not in the way most people think RNG games are, it actually has some mechanics rather than just sitting and clicking a roll button theres also other rods to get witch are different and have unique abilities, there are a bunch of different islands with different types of fish but they all still require rng so its not like fisch isnt an RNG game it just actually has depth to it unlike what roblox players consider "RNG games".
I'm so happy someone brought this up and GENERALLY discussed it's sources and gameplay. This video should prove to the roblox community what a real active game is compared to an auto afk game manual. Love this idea and u earned me a subscriber ❤ Carry on Fischer's!
No idea why people care about either fisch being rng game or no, although they have the aprase system, the enchant or the new x2 luck gamble, but if you know what you are doing you know its not a big deal, you can just not buy the 2x, enchant system use ingame money that dont cost real life money and just aprase if you want. for example in real life, buying a expensive rod, fishing line, bait or even a boat just for catching a fish that may only cost 2 dollars or maybe its a big fish that makes you happy if u got it. its just a fishing game for us to feel clam, relax and just enjoy fishing. if you really have to call fisch a rng game then what is fishing in real life. no need to argue, just play if you want.
Too be fair, this game does have really annoying gambling mechanics that make me want to throw myself off the roof such as the enchant system, appraise system and 4x luck boost.
So does minecraft have enchantment system similar to it.. and appraise system is just a show off no one force you to do it to get shiny fish to show off and x4 luck boost is for an entire server
crazy how nobody knows that fishing simulator did all of this but its less popular because it's older, and even then it has more gameplay features and is actually fun to play, 5 years old and looks even better than Fisch.
when a roblox game is actually good and gets popular: omg this is an rng game don't play it it sucks when BIG GAMES releases another game: omg so sigma preston lemme syd
Just because you click more than a single button doesn’t mean it’s not an rng game, it still has the same core principle that is basically just gambling.
0:02 man i love fishing and bug catching in animal crossing, its so chill, and i have most of the rare stuff like aripaima, the sharks, ceoloanth, and alot of other rare stuffs
Fisch is just a game where there IS rng, but it impacts a minimal part of the game, where fishing and getting rare fish depends on your rod. You can CHOOSE your luck with rods but in Other RNG games, you just wait for the server to give you a rare item (aura,title etc). RNG is the main part of games such as Sols RNG, but RNG is a small part of Fisch ALSO in fisch, even the worst fish are worth SOMETHING like coins. In aura-rng games, bad auras or items get replaced by better ones so theres no point in getting the worse ones
@@ConeH34dd I haven't tried fisch before but I have played a bit of sols rng before. I think based off what you said they're still really similar. In fisch there are different rods which can change different stats like your luck or catch speed. While in sols rng you can craft gloves and brew potions which can boost your luck or increase rolling speed. In fisch you sell fish in order to buy better rods or boats to travel to different areas. And in sols rng you can use the "bad auras" to craft or brew gloves and potions which can increase your luck so there are points in getting worse ones. But this is just my viewpoint though, I can understand why some think they are the same and others think they aren't. I hope you understand my point and maybe have more counterpoints that prove me wrong.
I was about to start crapping my pants at yet another rng game but this actually looks quite well made,, definitely has enough gameplay and mechanics to count as an actual game.
@@cheese_enjoyer_ I'm just saying that this game would definitely appeal to at least some people (who aren't mindless kids). Doing the same thing over and over again is literally what makes a game, so it shouldn't be a problem. Though don't quote me on that since I haven't played the game (and probably won't)
@@cheese_enjoyer_ brotha,THATS THE HOLE POINT OF FISHING GAMES,You sit there,minigame time,pray for good fish,repeat,sols rng and a FISHING game should NOT be comparable,thats like saying casinoes are the same as actual irl fishing
Baits are useful for completing the bestiary, each fish loves diffrent/specific bait and with the correct bait a fish has a higher chance to spawn, also the 2 most important stats on the rod are not just speed and luck, control makes the bar on the 2nd minigame bigger, resilience makes the fish your trying to catch move less (usally needed for catching bigger fish), max kg is the max kg a fish can be caught at. Hope this helps 🙃
@@TheMaxGuyrng game with - an effort to make your time playing the game worthwhile - has passion and aould behind every game mechanic - progression doesnt SOLELY depend on getting rarer and rarer auras or items.
@TheMaxGuy it is a game with RNG in it, EVERY game has RNG in it. It's how games work. Sol's RNG just has you AFK in it. Fisch requires effort and actual engagement to play.
@@vuzarre okay? amount of playing doesnt change it. if the entire gameplay is "Do thing, RNG chance determines the random useless item you get" and there is ABSOLUTELY NOTHING else, its an rng game
@@jokerpunctre - not really - again not really the entire minigame and its sound effects are stolen from stardew valley - thats just completely false???
Fisch, by definition, is an rng game, but unlike most rng games, i actually enjoy playing it. It's a simple *engaging* game that i can hop on and vc with friends in the background. Ive met and gotten closer with quite a few people over this game, and i love its existence. Im glad to see it taking off :]
Someone gets it. Rng games can be goated if done correctly like fishc. The video creator and comments are flooded with people denying the fact that it is rng.
i used to play a lot of fishing simulator and just reached to a point where i actually needed to spend robux on the game however fisch can easily be progressed without spending any robux
@@sussyb969 yeah u get pretty good chances even without the x4 luck from the shop. u can just buy merlin luck or u can server hop for ppl who are doing x4 luck.
I'm gonna be SO honest.. when I first played fisch I thought I wouldn't be interested in it considering I never liked fishing in ANY game . But fisch was so fun it somehow made me enjoy fishing in MINECRAFT OF ALL THINGS how does this even happen no clue.
Fisch is what rng games should be. Not gambling just a game about running around, looking for fish and getting good rng. Thats what the term rng game should mean not souls rng.
For me, what defines an RNG game is what the main aspect of the game actually is. For MM2, the main aspect of the game is the sheriffs and the murders etc. Now obviously there is a random chance to become one of these roles, that said chance increases after every round. Me personally, MM2 is a very slight but still an RNG game. Fisch on the other hand IS an RNG game, because the main aspect is well fishing. Fishing in real life requires luck, but Fisch makes it so you can increase your luck, but at the end of the day, it is just a RNG fishing game (he isn’t wrong tho Fisch is peak gameplay, because in my opinion Fisch is the best RNG game by far)
@@pepsimulatorfisch has a lot of gameplay, including upgrades, quick-time mini games, quests, and more. If your claim is that fisch is too simmilar to slop rng games like void fishing, then yeah, but it isn’t the main problem with games like void fishing. Void fishing is a game in which you run in the background to get a good item, whilst the developers get large ammount is of money from doing nothing. This kills creativity in games, and overshadows actually good games with passion and love put into them, like fisch.
Fisch is r RNG but it works like a real game. It’s the kind of RNG game that you’re supposed to do something other than just do what you want while the game just plays itself at that’s what I love about fisch, i actually have to do smth to get what you want or to get something rare. Fisch is way different from Big game’s Pet Sim and Pets Go. Pets Go is just a copy and paste RNG game. Pet Sim is just making you go afk. Fisch on the other hand is making you actually do it yourself. Think of Fisch as a DIY project you want to do. It’s not like it’s already made, YOU have to Do It Yourself. Edit: Fisch isn’t that bad as Pets go, Sols RNG but the rods make a great impact on the game. Fisch is so relaxing I’ve been playing it for hours just to level up. Fisch is great, I recommend playing it 1000% worth your time. Small Fun Fact: If u hear a ding by the exclamation mark you’ll likely get a mythic/legendary fish. Red exclamation mark + ding = Mythical Yellow exclamation + yellow fish = legendary
@@alimehrabi519r2 the mods are defending pedos btw also how can u steal assets from a 2d game??? Cuz fisch is a 3D game last time i played it unless your talking about sounds (ps in my opinion mods of a discord server of a game should not mean the game itself is trash)
@@GameGlider-icannotsleep22122 they stole the whole fishing minigame from stardew valley.and I know that since it uses the same sound effects from stardew valley
I don’t know why people are so angry at these comment sections. It’s not really a gambling game, as the player has to work for a better chance, rather than a random chance in general. You have to do something with your keyboard, so afk-ing isn’t really possible; most of these players are actually *playing* the game.
YOU CAN ACTUALLY PLAY IT UNLIKE SOLS RNG JUST AFK POP POTION FOR RAREST AURA WHILE ON FISHING YOU ACTUALLY NEED TO PLAY MANUALLY TO CATCH SOME RARE ONES😭
Love ur vids! I just wanted to make a suggestion for you to play arcane odyssey! It's a really fun rpg adventure game where you sail to different islands and there is TONS and i mean TONS of side content and polish on absolutely everthing. (Maybe beside the graphics) and the game is only about 20% done, with there being 6 seas in the future. You can also fisch, if that tickles your fancy, although not as fleshed out as this game.
@@jokerpunctre Yes there are many ways to implement RNG and in this game it's through fishing which uses Rarities and there are chances which is % of the rarities and that % is the RNG aspect.
It is in fact skill based due to rarer fish being harder to catch but give more money and its even economic based (in some way or another) by having certain things adding to bigger possibilities or rarer fish, the game is even (slightly) compatible with friends by the radar letting you know your exact coordinates and even offering people fish or items
I will agree, fisch is a very enjoyable game. My friend introduced me to this game and I really enjoyed it. But one day, fisch just reset my data for no reason. I ended up grinding my levels back, but then fisch reset my data AGAIN. I ended up quitting fisch. Even though it was a really fun game, I just didn’t understand why my data kept on getting reset for no reason. Thank you for listening to my rant.
As someone who plays animal crossing as a hardcore fish collector, i got hooked on this game the day i found it on my recommendation page. Everything about it is just.. perfect, in a way. Though the gambling system on the enchanting makes me wanna throw myself out the window, this is peak game. This game reminds me of another game ive grown up playing, alot may dont know about it but its a game called “A Girl Adrift”. The system where you use a boat/raft to get to islands to exchange goods or buy stuff, or go to specific areas to get fishes is so similar, yet unique in its own way! The minigame system is also quite similar, tapping or clicking to catch the fish. What i like about fisch, is that you actually gotta work your ass off to climb up the rarity of fishes you could get. Afk-ing isnt really possible, unless you’ve got scripts or something, which makes everything fair and square. Its a repetetive game, yet so relaxing. Cant wait to see the next updates roll around.
I actually enjoy playing Fisch compared to other rng-like games, because it means you get to actually have a chance at talking to people and meeting new friends.
@ okay the game developer said that the company has no intentions to make the game p2w, but it is kind of scary that this is happening to a game like this.
Finally someone that explains me why everyone play that game 😮❤ thank you soo much for this video and i wish you good luck in ur Journey of catching a new fisch
a "cheap" rip of is crazy theres so much to it it has so mayn items rods enchants islands quest boats and also characters to talk to also the map looks way better with it even has seasons and fish you can get in diffrent seasons so uch more to it than theres in fisching sim
Here's a fun fact in the big cave room(the room where you have to get a ticket to access) You can get the same fish on the lake if you managed to reach it.
fisch is a rng game bestiary -aura index rods - gloves enchantments - boosts bait - potions shake button - the only thing different from any other rng game that makes it not an rng game
yeah, but you get rewards and cool animations for completing an island's bestiary, and there are multiple islands you can explore. The bestiary feels more like a collection than a linear graph of the lest common to the most rare auras, and the rods have more stats than just extra luck or extra speed, such as the resilience, max kilograms, control and it's extra feature if it has one
so far your one of my favorite roblox youtubers, your chill and your edits arent cnp like how most roblox youtubers do to have the better editing, i seen you from 21k i think and now your at 105k! So a late congratulations from me
It’s fine if you think that way. But as stated in the video it’s also a silly claim. Fisch is an rng game with progression, like sols rng. But keep in mind that sols rng is an afk game that requires the player to do nothing(this gives the developer free money). This game has a little more action with quests, quick-time events, a unique upgrade system, ect. It’s fine if you think it’s overrated, but I just wanted to clear up the statement.
Fisch is the game that Roblox has needed, and it’s great. Even if you don’t like rng games, you might like it. I mean it with my heart the person who made Fisch is a great person. Also a game I recommend to play next is parkor reborn. Just make sure you got 350 robux to get it but it’s great. It’s fine if you don’t like parkor reborn. Everyone has their own opinion. So I would be pretty glad if you tryed it out.
I'm glad I clicked on this video, as it's truly put my thoughts into words. Any time someone would compare Sol's RNG to Fisch, I'd always be bothered by the statement, but didn't really know what to say. Engagement, progression, and control. Those are what differentiate Fisch from Sol's RNG.
RNG is always trash; less is always better, having a game that's is 80% RNG is still 80% complete slop, and rest of the progression of Fisch seems just like mindless grinding. If anything, an auto roll feature would make the game better because you don't have to waste your own time lol.
Congrats on 100k!! You deserve it 100%! I’ve discovered new games I now love to play from your videos which I am very thankful for :) also phighting music W
I think the model for a good "rng" game is Terraria. To "roll" something like a drop from an enemy you need to go to his spawn area and actually kill him, instead of staying in one place. There are a lot of ways of progression like mining, fishing, killing, crafting. The drop chances aren't spelled out anywhere but the wiki (that really doesn't mean much because you surely are going to use the wiki at least once). And yes, you could make an AFK grinder for it to turn into an rng game, but building it takes a lot more effort than pressing one button and tabbing out, and with how much else there is to do in the game, using that would be pretty boring. Fisch accomplishes the goal of making an actual game with actual stuff to do, you have to choose your rods for what fits best, move to where the fish that you want is catchable, go through the MINIGAMES, sell the fish and buy new stuff. That's the gameplay cycle. Now compare it with Sol's RNG's gameplay cycle: press the roll button, check if you got anything useful for upgrades, repeat, with the only straying off the belt being potion and coin spawns around the map and the luck boost obby thing. That's a MAJOR difference. Wait did I just write a friggin' mini-essay
i LOVE the fact that this game uses the stardew valley's fishing mechanic. I'm surprised not many games use this type of mechanism. it's super addicting.
I really want fisch to add a more compelling update, like more lor including quests, fishing boss battles (maybe with harpoons or weapons or smt with dodging atk's and stuff), and maybe a way for your boat to collapse (maybe sea beasts, like sharks needed to hunt down and storms where theres a steering minigame or smt). Also, yes I got inspired by fishing sim.
7:55 Bro fr thats what i thought when i saw its description “400k+ types of fish!” thought it was a low quality fast made rng game , i played it once and now its one of my fav games
Also the exclamation point is a little attention check so if your not paying attention you may think you catches something but it’s actually someone else
This game reminds me of fishing simulator which I absolutely love. Its not often you find good fishing games on Roblox and I will most definitely be giving it a try.
Tip: Luck won't help you if your rod has no resilience. Resilience helps you catch your fisch easier. Tip2: Steady Rod is considered an S tier by the community. It will carry you from early to mid or possibly late game (Already Proven).
Fisch works like Fishing simulator , except theres more mechanics , like clicking the shake button , in fishing simulator u control the fish , but in fisch u control the rod and the fish is trying to run away , adding harpoons or spears to fight bosses like a whale or megalodon could be a good addition since FS also has a boss fight
It really reminds me of how more simple roblox games were back then. It's just fishing, it's on the page, and you won't be lied to or pushed to do other activities than what the game sells you.
What Roblox game do you want me to talk about next???
arent u gonna pin?
strongest battle grounds personally i dont like the battlegrounds genre but i wanna hear ur opinion
talk about the new block tales chapter
its lore is so fricking awesome
detriment.
A magicians excursion/ Arcane odyseey
It's almost like real life fishing requires...
...RNG
WOW!!!
real fishing requires randomly generated numbers??? tf???
@@alex-v8p4h RNG in roblox means something like a gamble thing
probabilities maybe
no it doesnt
coming from someone who fishes, fishing is all luck and probabilities. Like you arent gonna go fish irl and open up the menu screen of what you wanna catch 😭😭😭😭
@@fish_D45
"yo bro how many blue tails you got?"
"Bet lemme check my inventory rq"
"wtf"
@@thesandwich7151 lmaooo
Ye like I remember I went fishing with my dad and cousin and we didn’t catch anything. We were out for a few hours, still fun tho
@@thesandwich7151 lmao
once caught multiple fish while my uncle got none crazy rng
Fisch is a rng game. but unlike sols rng its actually a game. and I love it for that because of how relaxing it can be.
all games have rng, a chance of something happening, thats like calling ranked games rng, because you haev a chance of playing against bad or good players
@@Shadow-Gamesz okay but when the main game mechanic is "Do thing and get random chance item" thats an rng game
@@TheMaxGuy the main mechaning here is fishing tho
@@1goober-j2dAre you trolling? You have to be ragebaiting.
I guess by this logic Minecraft is an RNG game
Bedsheet, you have the most solid point out there 😭
nobody be calling jojo games "RNG games"
the item drops of the "modded" games kiinda make them rng games
You dont call them RNG games until you dont get the stand you want after the 37th arrow
@@Gamer-qr8ee it legit took me over a hundred shiny arrows to get neo twau
Cos in jojo games you can actually do something with stands but in this shitty excuse of a game your just stuck with these fish in your inventory doing nothing
@@groemar all i see in jojo games is people time stopping, posing and doing the quotes
1:53 Minigames... fish... ocean... pressure... deep-sea......... hadal.... hadal blacksite.... monsters...... minigames.... PANDEMONIUM.
I have Pressure brainrot 😔
All my homies love minigames
Expandable at door 30
MINIGAMES!
Ocean… pirates… one piece… blox fruits… 8 snowmans
I've played the game, but in my opinion it's incredibly overhyped. It is a great game, don't get me wrong, but people are making it out to be the best ROBLOX game ever, and to be honest, I don't see it. It's just a very well made fishing game.. that's it. Nothing innovative/hasn't been done before, nothing special, it's just a high quality fishing game on ROBLOX (which hasn't really been done before)
holy shit spit your facts
yuh i dont think its anything revolutionary, but when compared to the recent slop we’ve been getting its a nice and chill game to play. so thats prolly why it blew up so much (also because big fish go brr)
Escaping the internet is the most underrated piece of masterpiece Ive played.
You provided very good points, can't argue with that
@@pizzapizza759 no
you cant call fishing rng when fishing exists irl
so do casinos
@@1goober-j2d Flabbergasted
@@1goober-j2dwell some people fish to survive but what about casinos?
@@Lira_May casinos to rng if u lose money or gain money so its basically rng and fishing require skill mostly irl bc u gotta set stuff up correctly and must fish with great skill and accuracy.
@@nautiluschannel9197 wht skill and accuracy needed in irl fishing??? m8 itss mostly abt the probability/chances bro
Addicts will say ANYTHING to avoid therapy.
@Steakable Truest thing ive ever seen in a random youtube comments sectoon
Omg i found a sane human being in a bedsheet ghost video what
I’ve been playing fisch for 2 weeks and it’s been fun the concept seems simple but finally getting a good fish and having to play a all out war with it is fun the quest are super fun to like the trident rod quest where you have to obtain 5 relics and catch all the desolate deep fish is really hard but fun as it’s an adventure if you haven’t played fisch I suggest playing it badly ❤❤❤
Another thing i like about fisch- There arent any NECCESARY gamepasses. For example, In most RNG games, there is a Quick Roll gamepass, which speeds up progression by a TON. but in fisch, the closest thing to p2w is double XP, which is only used for boats (you could argue its p2w as it could be used to get the No-Life rod at level 500, but thats really hard with and without double xp.) and the appraiser luck gamepass, which only really helps in appraising fisch, which, sure, maybe itll increase your mythicals price by like, 1.5x if your lucky but its not neccesary. Personally, ive gone up to level 60 COMPLETELY f2p (besides the emotes gamepass cuz i love the emotes), and i did not have any issues progressing.
Love this game.
hello niko oneshot
Is that Niko One Shot
what about 2x chat and being able to sell anywhere? Also quick roll isn’t necessary lol
@@penguinspenguinspenguins Sell anywhere is absolutely useless, cause you have infinite inventory anyways. Quick roll in most games obviously isnt neccesary but its REALLY important if you wanna get stuff fast, otherwise your 4x as slow as people with quickroll, which means its p2w
@ you forgot of extra xp and cash! My argument still stands
Fun fact!: fisch is rated 7.27 (it dropped to roughly 6.15~ in slightly over 2 weeks lmao) on better discovery
Hah I appeared at 4:54
@@WinterToast0 Won't be for much longer, now that it got purchased 🫤
yeah but it deserves better
wysi
I wouldn’t trust EVERYTHING on better discovery. They rated Regretevator pretty badly.
Won't be there for long.
for me, i don't really agree, it is basically sol's rng except the auras is replaced with fishes and you just have to do a minigame to get the fishes, for the other mechanics such as getting better rods, sol's rng also have, in sol's rng, it is basically crafting gears except you are using your aura to craft gear. I think that fish is also quite repetetive doing the same minigame over and over again.
NOTE: I AM NOT DEFENDING SOL'S RNG, I AM JUST EXPRESSING MY OPINION.
yea kinda agree, but feel like they could add more action, like storms or sea beasts (like sharks or smt) to add some risk to driving a boat rent-free, and add a sea creature boss battle system.
The game is literally fishing, like what are u gonna do about it? Just open up a menu of what you wanna catch? One of the comments who is a fisherman/woman and says that fishing is all luck and probability. It is an RNG game but it ain't just clicking on a button.
all "RNG" means is "random number generator" so most games are actually RNG games or have RNG aspects and fisch is no different, it is very much so an RNG game just not in the way most people think RNG games are, it actually has some mechanics rather than just sitting and clicking a roll button theres also other rods to get witch are different and have unique abilities, there are a bunch of different islands with different types of fish but they all still require rng so its not like fisch isnt an RNG game it just actually has depth to it unlike what roblox players consider "RNG games".
fisch does not have some mechanics
The fish game that is actually fun because you can fish!
Why your UserNam "touhoutrash" what do you mean touhou trash?
Nah, fish hava something special.
actually Roblox have a lot of games with that Mechanic (fish lol)
I'm so happy someone brought this up and GENERALLY discussed it's sources and gameplay. This video should prove to the roblox community what a real active game is compared to an auto afk game manual. Love this idea and u earned me a subscriber ❤ Carry on Fischer's!
No idea why people care about either fisch being rng game or no, although they have the aprase system, the enchant or the new x2 luck gamble, but if you know what you are doing you know its not a big deal, you can just not buy the 2x, enchant system use ingame money that dont cost real life money and just aprase if you want. for example in real life, buying a expensive rod, fishing line, bait or even a boat just for catching a fish that may only cost 2 dollars or maybe its a big fish that makes you happy if u got it. its just a fishing game for us to feel clam, relax and just enjoy fishing. if you really have to call fisch a rng game then what is fishing in real life. no need to argue, just play if you want.
fisch has absolutely no point
fishing irl has a point
very big difference
But many people release the fish they just caught they fish for fun same as fisch
@@itstjxtjxi yeah because fishing irl has actual effort
@@TheMaxGuy The point is to enjoy yourself.
If you prefer real world fishing or ingame fishing is up to you, the result is the same regardless.
Too be fair, this game does have really annoying gambling mechanics that make me want to throw myself off the roof such as the enchant system, appraise system and 4x luck boost.
you can complete bestiary without using any of these tbh. I didn't even know I could appraise or use x4 luck until i finished bestiary
this game be makin pennies off premium payouts, its more then justified for them to add a gamepass or two to the game.
So does minecraft have enchantment system similar to it.. and appraise system is just a show off no one force you to do it to get shiny fish to show off and x4 luck boost is for an entire server
crazy how nobody knows that fishing simulator did all of this but its less popular because it's older, and even then it has more gameplay features and is actually fun to play, 5 years old and looks even better than Fisch.
@no1dea261 Fishing simulator has more saturated colours and that's why i prefer the look of fisch. Each to their own tho
The RNG isn't the problem. It's that there's nothing else to do making it a simulator game. (Without the pets)
11:46 yooo that was me, it was great meeting u in game and great vid as always
Nice bro :D
when a roblox game is actually good and gets popular: omg this is an rng game don't play it it sucks
when BIG GAMES releases another game: omg so sigma preston lemme syd
Yeah and a lot of people in this comment section are saying that it’s an rng game so it’s bad which I disagree too but whatever it’s there opinion.
Just because you click more than a single button doesn’t mean it’s not an rng game, it still has the same core principle that is basically just gambling.
it’s not good, it’s mid and overrated af
opinion v opinion, i like the game honestly
too bad i cant fish up ■■■■■■■■■
0:02 man i love fishing and bug catching in animal crossing, its so chill, and i have most of the rare stuff like aripaima, the sharks, ceoloanth, and alot of other rare stuffs
Fisch is just a game where there IS rng, but it impacts a minimal part of the game, where fishing and getting rare fish depends on your rod. You can CHOOSE your luck with rods but in Other RNG games, you just wait for the server to give you a rare item (aura,title etc). RNG is the main part of games such as Sols RNG, but RNG is a small part of Fisch
ALSO in fisch, even the worst fish are worth SOMETHING like coins. In aura-rng games, bad auras or items get replaced by better ones so theres no point in getting the worse ones
Also, an RNG "game" is based off RNG, like Sols "RNG". The whole game is about RNG. So stop considering Fisch an RNG game
@@ConeH34dd I haven't tried fisch before but I have played a bit of sols rng before. I think based off what you said they're still really similar. In fisch there are different rods which can change different stats like your luck or catch speed. While in sols rng you can craft gloves and brew potions which can boost your luck or increase rolling speed. In fisch you sell fish in order to buy better rods or boats to travel to different areas. And in sols rng you can use the "bad auras" to craft or brew gloves and potions which can increase your luck so there are points in getting worse ones. But this is just my viewpoint though, I can understand why some think they are the same and others think they aren't. I hope you understand my point and maybe have more counterpoints that prove me wrong.
I was about to start crapping my pants at yet another rng game but this actually looks quite well made,, definitely has enough gameplay and mechanics to count as an actual game.
"enough gameplay" 🤣🤣🤣
It’s just playing one minigame over and over again fym enough gameplay 😭
@@cheese_enjoyer_ong
@@cheese_enjoyer_ I'm just saying that this game would definitely appeal to at least some people (who aren't mindless kids).
Doing the same thing over and over again is literally what makes a game, so it shouldn't be a problem. Though don't quote me on that since I haven't played the game (and probably won't)
@@cheese_enjoyer_ brotha,THATS THE HOLE POINT OF FISHING GAMES,You sit there,minigame time,pray for good fish,repeat,sols rng and a FISHING game should NOT be comparable,thats like saying casinoes are the same as actual irl fishing
Baits are useful for completing the bestiary, each fish loves diffrent/specific bait and with the correct bait a fish has a higher chance to spawn, also the 2 most important stats on the rod are not just speed and luck, control makes the bar on the 2nd minigame bigger, resilience makes the fish your trying to catch move less (usally needed for catching bigger fish), max kg is the max kg a fish can be caught at. Hope this helps 🙃
Btw the head mod of Fisch is a pdf also plays condos so should learn that
Why is nobody talking about how this game is stardew valleys fishing minigame but its a whole game about just that
@@Leo-me5yt because it was based on that
Sol's RNG if it had more than three seconds of gameplay:
more like 3 yoctoseconds of "gameplay" lol
sols rng if people glazed it like it was revolutionary but at the end is just a mid fishing game:
Sols rng if its not a gambling game
Thank you man, I saw it on my recomended and ignored it because I was thinking it's yet another RNG game
hes lying tho its literally an rng game
@@TheMaxGuyrng game with
- an effort to make your time playing the game worthwhile
- has passion and aould behind every game mechanic
- progression doesnt SOLELY depend on getting rarer and rarer auras or items.
@TheMaxGuy it is a game with RNG in it, EVERY game has RNG in it. It's how games work. Sol's RNG just has you AFK in it. Fisch requires effort and actual engagement to play.
@@vuzarre okay? amount of playing doesnt change it. if the entire gameplay is "Do thing, RNG chance determines the random useless item you get" and there is ABSOLUTELY NOTHING else, its an rng game
@@jokerpunctre - not really
- again not really the entire minigame and its sound effects are stolen from stardew valley
- thats just completely false???
I saw you in game afk while you were filming this and I've been waiting for this video!
Fisch, by definition, is an rng game, but unlike most rng games, i actually enjoy playing it. It's a simple *engaging* game that i can hop on and vc with friends in the background. Ive met and gotten closer with quite a few people over this game, and i love its existence. Im glad to see it taking off :]
Someone gets it. Rng games can be goated if done correctly like fishc. The video creator and comments are flooded with people denying the fact that it is rng.
So fishing simulator is also by definition rng game
@@kuronya3582 never played it but if it fits the criteria, then yes, it is. If not, then it isn’t.
@@Mrstireast I've played it and gameplay loop is the same, Sol's rng are gave too much brain rot so people can't difference
shouldve said why roblox fisch is not a boring game instead of clickbaiting
Bro, the 100k subs are definitely earned!
Fisch is just a RNG game but with extra steps
The game is literally just fishing simulator but on the front page smh
i used to play a lot of fishing simulator and just reached to a point where i actually needed to spend robux on the game however fisch can easily be progressed without spending any robux
@@sussyb969 yeah u get pretty good chances even without the x4 luck from the shop. u can just buy merlin luck or u can server hop for ppl who are doing x4 luck.
true
Fr
Fisch was made by the same devs from fishing simulator bruh
Mb, an friend told me it and i tough It was true lol 💀
I'm gonna be SO honest.. when I first played fisch I thought I wouldn't be interested in it considering I never liked fishing in ANY game . But fisch was so fun it somehow made me enjoy fishing in MINECRAFT OF ALL THINGS how does this even happen no clue.
Fisch is what rng games should be. Not gambling just a game about running around, looking for fish and getting good rng. Thats what the term rng game should mean not souls rng.
For me, what defines an RNG game is what the main aspect of the game actually is. For MM2, the main aspect of the game is the sheriffs and the murders etc. Now obviously there is a random chance to become one of these roles, that said chance increases after every round. Me personally, MM2 is a very slight but still an RNG game. Fisch on the other hand IS an RNG game, because the main aspect is well fishing. Fishing in real life requires luck, but Fisch makes it so you can increase your luck, but at the end of the day, it is just a RNG fishing game (he isn’t wrong tho Fisch is peak gameplay, because in my opinion Fisch is the best RNG game by far)
Why is FISCH not an RNG game?
My answer: FISCH have gameplay
Edit: More gameplay than any rng game (i think) and also FISCH is a very relaxing game
Barely.
@@pepsimulatorfisch has a lot of gameplay, including upgrades, quick-time mini games, quests, and more. If your claim is that fisch is too simmilar to slop rng games like void fishing, then yeah, but it isn’t the main problem with games like void fishing. Void fishing is a game in which you run in the background to get a good item, whilst the developers get large ammount is of money from doing nothing. This kills creativity in games, and overshadows actually good games with passion and love put into them, like fisch.
@@pepsimulator it is a fishing game why are you surprised. not like you do much while fishing irl
@@pepsimulator Yeah bc in real life when you catch a fish you throw hands with him until you catch it, makes total sense.
no it doesnt
Fisch is r RNG but it works like a real game. It’s the kind of RNG game that you’re supposed to do something other than just do what you want while the game just plays itself at that’s what I love about fisch, i actually have to do smth to get what you want or to get something rare.
Fisch is way different from Big game’s Pet Sim and Pets Go. Pets Go is just a copy and paste RNG game. Pet Sim is just making you go afk.
Fisch on the other hand is making you actually do it yourself. Think of Fisch as a DIY project you want to do. It’s not like it’s already made, YOU have to Do It Yourself.
Edit: Fisch isn’t that bad as Pets go, Sols RNG but the rods make a great impact on the game.
Fisch is so relaxing I’ve been playing it for hours just to level up. Fisch is great, I recommend playing it 1000% worth your time.
Small Fun Fact: If u hear a ding by the exclamation mark you’ll likely get a mythic/legendary fish.
Red exclamation mark + ding = Mythical
Yellow exclamation + yellow fish = legendary
So fisch is just fishing simulator but newer?
lol pretty much both are awesome
*but with pedo mods and stolen assets from stardew valley
@@alimehrabi519r2 oh-
@@alimehrabi519r2 the mods are defending pedos btw also how can u steal assets from a 2d game??? Cuz fisch is a 3D game last time i played it unless your talking about sounds (ps in my opinion mods of a discord server of a game should not mean the game itself is trash)
@@GameGlider-icannotsleep22122 they stole the whole fishing minigame from stardew valley.and I know that since it uses the same sound effects from stardew valley
yay new bedsheet vid!! :D also when is the rblx star code👀
I don’t know why people are so angry at these comment sections. It’s not really a gambling game, as the player has to work for a better chance, rather than a random chance in general. You have to do something with your keyboard, so afk-ing isn’t really possible; most of these players are actually *playing* the game.
It’s a rng game
@@Erased_UnityXDX so it’s a rng game
@@Erased_UnityXDX a mid rng game
@@Erased_UnityXDX imo anything in the rng game genre is mid
@@RANDOM-GUY0987 yep, ive wasted my time once on sols so im not touching anything else including random ass fisch that appeared out of the blue
YOU CAN ACTUALLY PLAY IT UNLIKE SOLS RNG JUST AFK POP POTION FOR RAREST AURA
WHILE ON FISHING YOU ACTUALLY NEED TO PLAY MANUALLY TO CATCH SOME RARE ONES😭
Love ur vids! I just wanted to make a suggestion for you to play arcane odyssey! It's a really fun rpg adventure game where you sail to different islands and there is TONS and i mean TONS of side content and polish on absolutely everthing. (Maybe beside the graphics) and the game is only about 20% done, with there being 6 seas in the future. You can also fisch, if that tickles your fancy, although not as fleshed out as this game.
Isn’t this game just basically fishing simulator from 2019?
If there's different type of rarity then there will be RNG. Don't get it twisted.
@@LLNG There will be RNG, the thing that will be different is how its done.
@@jokerpunctre Yes there are many ways to implement RNG and in this game it's through fishing which uses Rarities and there are chances which is % of the rarities and that % is the RNG aspect.
Talk about stars align next nice vid btw
It is in fact skill based due to rarer fish being harder to catch but give more money and its even economic based (in some way or another) by having certain things adding to bigger possibilities or rarer fish, the game is even (slightly) compatible with friends by the radar letting you know your exact coordinates and even offering people fish or items
You dont play this game
I will agree, fisch is a very enjoyable game. My friend introduced me to this game and I really enjoyed it. But one day, fisch just reset my data for no reason. I ended up grinding my levels back, but then fisch reset my data AGAIN. I ended up quitting fisch. Even though it was a really fun game, I just didn’t understand why my data kept on getting reset for no reason.
Thank you for listening to my rant.
Yeah, sure hope the devs fix that
0:31 We all onow he aint listing to that lofi girl stuff😂😂😂
Are you?
Phighting ost
Ah yes, I love to play a relaxing game while Wait Of The World and Knock Knock by NoLongerNull is playing on my Spotify
good job for hitting 100k my happy for you :D
Bedsheet Ghost COOKING as usual!!
🙏🙏🙏thank you bro!
@@BedsheetGhost_ As an AI assistant I cannot help with your suggestion.
0:30 you so real for that, currently writing my research papers to the funny roblox ost as well
which song ?
@@icescickle all of em.
If fisch is so good then why do the devs and mods defend predators? like I think the games fine but i am NOT a fan of the people behind it
They do?
@@L1berat1on yes, I recommend searching it up, there’s a good video about it
@@Nobodythatyouknowloll If I search that my mom and dad are gonna kill me
show proof
@@Firemar there’s a video made about it, just search up fisch mod team or smth
As someone who plays animal crossing as a hardcore fish collector, i got hooked on this game the day i found it on my recommendation page. Everything about it is just.. perfect, in a way. Though the gambling system on the enchanting makes me wanna throw myself out the window, this is peak game.
This game reminds me of another game ive grown up playing, alot may dont know about it but its a game called “A Girl Adrift”.
The system where you use a boat/raft to get to islands to exchange goods or buy stuff, or go to specific areas to get fishes is so similar, yet unique in its own way! The minigame system is also quite similar, tapping or clicking to catch the fish.
What i like about fisch, is that you actually gotta work your ass off to climb up the rarity of fishes you could get. Afk-ing isnt really possible, unless you’ve got scripts or something, which makes everything fair and square. Its a repetetive game, yet so relaxing. Cant wait to see the next updates roll around.
I hate this stupid game play pets gooo it so good
Who wanna offer for my secret key?
me
bruv plz pets go is the most ass game ever
@@Lucas-vx4hf we have our opinions
I actually enjoy playing Fisch compared to other rng-like games, because it means you get to actually have a chance at talking to people and meeting new friends.
Fisch is in fact, an RNG game
But a god one with passion :D
@@Wheatly_Portal2 "with passion" It got sold to a scummy company bro 💀
@@Aeron_398 faust knows all
@@cratos315 wait what? What’s the company called
@ okay the game developer said that the company has no intentions to make the game p2w, but it is kind of scary that this is happening to a game like this.
Me, who has already played fishing simulator for countless hours:
those who know + those who fisch + those who + those +
Let me guess, the coummity fisch mod
(right?)
honestly your content is peak and you deserve every single one of those 106k subscribers
I can’t sub, because I’m already subbed yeah >:D
Truly the best problem to have 🤷♂️
Fr
Finally someone that explains me why everyone play that game 😮❤ thank you soo much for this video and i wish you good luck in ur Journey of catching a new fisch
I think fisch is just cheap rip off of Fishing Simulator. In my opinion Fishing Simulator is better, although it is five years older than fisch.
fisch is better made. fishing simulator feels like plastic
@@FoudMewith scummy devs and mods.
a "cheap" rip of is crazy theres so much to it it has so mayn items rods enchants islands quest boats and also characters to talk to also the map looks way better with it even has seasons and fish you can get in diffrent seasons so uch more to it than theres in fisching sim
@@xAquaDev "fichsing sim" is crazy disrespect. Don't ruin the name "fishing simulator" with a total copy.
@@Ghcyop fishing simulator sucks too dude
Here's a fun fact in the big cave room(the room where you have to get a ticket to access)
You can get the same fish on the lake if you managed to reach it.
fisch is a rng game
bestiary -aura index
rods - gloves
enchantments - boosts
bait - potions
shake button - the only thing different from any other rng game that makes it not an rng game
yeah, but you get rewards and cool animations for completing an island's bestiary, and there are multiple islands you can explore. The bestiary feels more like a collection than a linear graph of the lest common to the most rare auras, and the rods have more stats than just extra luck or extra speed, such as the resilience, max kilograms, control and it's extra feature if it has one
so far your one of my favorite roblox youtubers, your chill and your edits arent cnp like how most roblox youtubers do to have the better editing, i seen you from 21k i think and now your at 105k! So a late congratulations from me
only real ones know what that means...
Tbh it feels more of a simulator like fishing simulator but a little different
Steady rod enjoyers
👇
Fisch is sols rng but with extra step
8:21 let bro cook
When the fish start to crash out when trying to catch it I scream "SIR, YOU NEED TO CALM DOWN!!!"
Fisch is overrated. It’s literally sols rng but with more things(Fisch still better tho)
It’s fine if you think that way. But as stated in the video it’s also a silly claim. Fisch is an rng game with progression, like sols rng. But keep in mind that sols rng is an afk game that requires the player to do nothing(this gives the developer free money). This game has a little more action with quests, quick-time events, a unique upgrade system, ect. It’s fine if you think it’s overrated, but I just wanted to clear up the statement.
Listen to 10:50 for more info
so any game with probability is sols rng right?
@@FoudMe Yeah, fishing is the main focus of the game and when you fish you have a lower chance to get the rarer fishes. just like auras in sols rng
Did you watch the video and if you did, did you listen to him about what he has to say without having a biased opinion on your mind?
Fisch is the game that Roblox has needed, and it’s great. Even if you don’t like rng games, you might like it. I mean it with my heart the person who made Fisch is a great person. Also a game I recommend to play next is parkor reborn. Just make sure you got 350 robux to get it but it’s great. It’s fine if you don’t like parkor reborn. Everyone has their own opinion. So I would be pretty glad if you tryed it out.
Noooooooooooooo it's not an another sloppy slop rng game 😭😭😭😭😭
It is.
I'm glad I clicked on this video, as it's truly put my thoughts into words. Any time someone would compare Sol's RNG to Fisch, I'd always be bothered by the statement, but didn't really know what to say. Engagement, progression, and control. Those are what differentiate Fisch from Sol's RNG.
what progression my guy
@okgoose3305 Rods, boats, fish, money, levels.
@@AR05119 thats it?
@@okgoose3305 Lmao it's a Roblox fishing game bro what more are you expecting? It's more progression than Sol's RNG
RNG is always trash; less is always better, having a game that's is 80% RNG is still 80% complete slop, and rest of the progression of Fisch seems just like mindless grinding. If anything, an auto roll feature would make the game better because you don't have to waste your own time lol.
😐😐😐
Exactly
@@Pxzavr no
@@Robot345t how is it a no the game is just another simulator with more flashy lights or something
I like how the people hating this game and overreacting like its the end of the world, bruh.
Definitely is a rng game.
You didn’t even watch the video
@@Mag3.1415 as someone who has watched the video he is completely right and you are completely wrong
@@TheMaxGuy I didn’t say anything about them being right or wrong, I just think discounting an argument without listening to it is kinda silly.
Congrats on 100k!! You deserve it 100%! I’ve discovered new games I now love to play from your videos which I am very thankful for :) also phighting music W
I think the model for a good "rng" game is Terraria. To "roll" something like a drop from an enemy you need to go to his spawn area and actually kill him, instead of staying in one place. There are a lot of ways of progression like mining, fishing, killing, crafting. The drop chances aren't spelled out anywhere but the wiki (that really doesn't mean much because you surely are going to use the wiki at least once). And yes, you could make an AFK grinder for it to turn into an rng game, but building it takes a lot more effort than pressing one button and tabbing out, and with how much else there is to do in the game, using that would be pretty boring. Fisch accomplishes the goal of making an actual game with actual stuff to do, you have to choose your rods for what fits best, move to where the fish that you want is catchable, go through the MINIGAMES, sell the fish and buy new stuff. That's the gameplay cycle. Now compare it with Sol's RNG's gameplay cycle: press the roll button, check if you got anything useful for upgrades, repeat, with the only straying off the belt being potion and coin spawns around the map and the luck boost obby thing. That's a MAJOR difference.
Wait did I just write a friggin' mini-essay
i LOVE the fact that this game uses the stardew valley's fishing mechanic. I'm surprised not many games use this type of mechanism. it's super addicting.
IS THAT PHIGHTING OST!? but yeah uh fisch is awesome game - a rando main scythe
I really want fisch to add a more compelling update, like more lor including quests, fishing boss battles (maybe with harpoons or weapons or smt with dodging atk's and stuff), and maybe a way for your boat to collapse (maybe sea beasts, like sharks needed to hunt down and storms where theres a steering minigame or smt). Also, yes I got inspired by fishing sim.
7:55 Bro fr thats what i thought when i saw its description “400k+ types of fish!” thought it was a low quality fast made rng game , i played it once and now its one of my fav games
Also the exclamation point is a little attention check so if your not paying attention you may think you catches something but it’s actually someone else
love how Bedsheet is still using music from the phighting OTS
This game reminds me of fishing simulator which I absolutely love. Its not often you find good fishing games on Roblox and I will most definitely be giving it a try.
Tip: Luck won't help you if your rod has no resilience. Resilience helps you catch your fisch easier.
Tip2: Steady Rod is considered an S tier by the community. It will carry you from early to mid or possibly late game (Already Proven).
IS THAT PHIGHTING OST IN THE BACKGROUND
Bro is “pressured” to reference Pressure in every single one of his vids lol
the phighting music is making me instinctively attempt to start tricking on ledges in real life. help me
Fisch works like Fishing simulator , except theres more mechanics , like clicking the shake button , in fishing simulator u control the fish , but in fisch u control the rod and the fish is trying to run away , adding harpoons or spears to fight bosses like a whale or megalodon could be a good addition since FS also has a boss fight
It really reminds me of how more simple roblox games were back then. It's just fishing, it's on the page, and you won't be lied to or pushed to do other activities than what the game sells you.
imagine you go outside and start fishing irl,do you expect to pull out a collossal millenial titan shark?
"relaxing" those colossal squids and mythics you catch without a good resilience on you:
The owner was so passionate about his game that his passion was selling the game!
I started playing fisch, and welp, it brings back fishing simulator memories.