@@Lucas500ll “growl” is just a descriptor, “vocal distortion” is what it actually is. You wouldn’t correct someone for saying a guitar tone is really heavy and say “erm it’s not heavy it’s actually distortion 🤓”
@@brandonparker4719Well Adam stands on a pedestal that unfortunately not another singer alive currently can count in his form and practice of vocals, he stands alone hundreds of miles above the number two person for his form and practice of vocals that nobody is gonna be touching for centuries at this rate
ADAM! Honestly Adam sings with that grit that punches heavier with this kind of music. Matt is cleaner. I'm just not a fan of that clean, polished sound. I go to a rock concert, I expect to get a little dirty.
Matt is singing Adams songs to to keep the Three Days Grace fan base happy. I think it is so awesome that he does that. The newer songs that Matt sang originally are amazing. Lifetime is so beautiful ❤️
I think it's not about TDG or SA or even Matt, Adam is shines his own light, he's his own abel, he could sing solo and it'd be fine too, his energy overflows of any band he's in
Well guess they have different styles of singing then. I would really like to hear Adam try Painkiller or I am Machine tho, I'm shure I'll sound good@raymondcarter9810
No hate to Matt but no one will touch Adam's voice, tone, lyrics, or energy! The grittiness in his voice has a way of making u feel what my dude is sayin. 🤘🏻
Not only are we just used to Adam because we grew up with the old stuff, but the way he puts lyrics with music makes sense...Makes me wonder what would have come about if he stayed😵💫 When i listen to Saint Asonia I still hear "Three days grace". He took the best parts of the band with him when he left. #90's kid
They should have renamed themselves after switching singers. Just like creed went on to become alter bridge. Yes it may sound unfair but you can easily swap out almost any instrumental but a singer is the heart amd soul of a band. Unless you find somebody that at least sound similar to the original, all the previous songs dont sound right. Matt isnt a bad singer at all, but i've seen them live once and it was more than enough. It felt horrible when he sang adams songs.
I hate to be "that guy" Matt sucks at all Adams songs, I've also personally never really liked the new stuff with Matt and only really listen to Adams albums. It would be pretty cool if Adam and Three Days Grace would do reunion album or concert.
People have gotta stop comparing these guys, they're two different singers that cannot be compared *But it's true, Matt can't sing Adam's songs, he needs to stick to his own
I agree, they shouldn't be compared when they sing so differently. Except when they preform the same song in the same original context. Then it's fair to compare their performances. In my opinion anyways.
yeah! and of course, we should/could say so. but comment sections are kinda/sorta podiums for pretense ..ive always said so - to people who are smarter than me (but you cant prove it)
@@bluelight809 yeah thats my problem. The first song i ever listened to from them was Never Too Late, and thought it was great, but that was in 2015, after Adam already left. And listening to Matt's song, I loved them just as much. That's why I REALLY didn't understand why semo people were so devastated when Adam left or saying the new singer is awful. He sounds great to me.
Adam is still my all time favorite. Love him amd have hungout w him 2xs and he is amazing. He will never be replaced. I dont even listen to them after they changed singers.
Went to see them live yesterday for the third time and honestly Matt is a beast ❤ he sounds amazing when performing live (and on record), of course he and Adam doesn't have the same voice for the old songs, but they are two different people, I prefer Matt. You guys have to let it go, it's been 10 f*ing years since Adam left
How can you not pick between the 2 on this Song? Adam sounds like how a song should be sang and Matt sounds like me as a 13 year old voice crack singing in the shower
Unfortunately these sad losers still think making Matt look bad still does something even tho Adam reconciled with Neil recently, and is extremely proud of his brothers for continuing the band after his departure.
Matt and Adam are from 2 different eras of TDA and cannot be compared honestly. They are both amazing in many aspects and I love the both of them equally.
Can we at least be honest enough to say that Matt was filmed with a potato and the sound quality can be explained by the fact that the person was eating the potato at the time? They aren't the same sure but at least show a decent comparison
@@sinnaman-dj-atrain Yeah. There is Saint Asonia, Which is also not the same.. Tbh - when new 3DG plays their own new music, it sounds great.. when they play old music, they sound not very good at all.. but thats me. Not taking away anything from people who do enjoy both new bands.. but there will always be that original sound that we miss and which both bands will never live up too. 🤷♂️
@@Last4Life yeah. To me the second Saint Asonia album is the only one I'd even consider stacking up against any of those original albums. But definitely a different sound.
Matt can sing the songs he wrote fairly ok. But he cannot sing Adams songs. He doesn't have that growl that adam has. He just doesn't.
That’s not growl it’s just vocal distortion
@@Lucas500ll “growl” is just a descriptor, “vocal distortion” is what it actually is. You wouldn’t correct someone for saying a guitar tone is really heavy and say “erm it’s not heavy it’s actually distortion 🤓”
Ikr oh yeah 😎 ❤️🔥❤️🔥🤘🤘
because they are two "different" persons
We think exactly the same
Adam has that chainsaw growl in his voice, something Matt unfortunately can't touch.
Matt's voice is good for Metal, that's why, but i'm choosing Matt over Adam.
@@aleksandr_elkov I respect that as much as I do love Adam gontier way more your not wrong Matt does have more of a metal voice
@@tandynjohnson 💪
@@aleksandr_elkov naah Matts voice sounds really weak
@@aleksandr_elkov false. You are a mental midget. Matt has a soft pathetic voice. Adam has a nice effective harshness great for rock and grunge.
Matt's "vAmpire" gets me every time 😂😂😂😭
IM CRYING I CANT FUCKING BREATHE XD
he's horrible
@@vosoryan not horrible, just not as good as adam
@@Rxspyhe cant sing adam songs, but hes a good vocalist
@@vrykulh yep
Adam's unique voice can't be reproduced
Max Greens band violent new breed had a guy that sounded a lot like him. Whenever they come on I get them confused with saint asonia.
Face it, you can't beat Adam's vocals and energy!
Matt has more energy than Adam. Adam has more soul. I'm Adam all day but Matt gets an A+++ for effort. Also Saint Asonia!!!!
My name is Adam and I approve of this statement
Not a lot of singers can
@@brandonparker4719Well Adam stands on a pedestal that unfortunately not another singer alive currently can count in his form and practice of vocals, he stands alone hundreds of miles above the number two person for his form and practice of vocals that nobody is gonna be touching for centuries at this rate
@@pwnanubasaurus2950Chester bennnington is leagues above Adam, lol. Matt just has a different vocal style, wich doesnt suit the same songs Adam sang.
100% Adam!!!
Same
Agree
%100 true
Ever!
100%
Adam 100% No one can do Adam’s songs justice. The End.
Absolutely 💯
Adam Gontier always gave energy to the songs and you could hear that he sang them with soul and feeling.
Matt isn’t bad, but Adam is the true Three Days Grace Legend. And will always be the number one singer for the band. 🤘🏻
Matt sound like if you went gay in high school but still wanted to be emo. Go back and listen to when Matt says "vampire" lmao
speak for yourself
Adam is the best
FUCK YOU. MATT IS AMAZING
@@samuelthompson8080 lmfao
They both sing their own material great.
100%
Not Matt
Can’t replicate Adam!
Dude, Adam has a fucking amazing voice. He covered wicked games better than anyone has. And that song isn't easy to cover. That being said Adam 💯
Adam 1000%. But I do appreciate the stuff that Matt has done with the band.
Adam, always the original for me..
Fr
Dude Matt's dance moves are killing mee 🤣🤣
He’s so f’ing awkward
He just feelin the vibes
Not a question Adam slays. His voice is such a huge part of the band.
Just two words: Saint Asonia
Louder for the people in the back
@@sinnaman-dj-atrain SAINT ASONIA
three days grace 2.0 fr
@@literboltstraight up
@@literboltthat’s what I’ve been sayin 😂 even tho I feel like he’s found his voice with 3DG nowadays
No hay punto de comparación, mi rey, Adam cuanta falta nos haces.
por lo menos volvieron a hacer amigos todos y se siguen nuevamente ya tocaron hace 2 meses nuevamente
Bro tienes a adam en saint asonia 💀💀
Saint Asonia
I was like “ holy shit Jonny Depp sounds amazing
Really miss Adam please come back
ADAM!
Honestly Adam sings with that grit that punches heavier with this kind of music. Matt is cleaner. I'm just not a fan of that clean, polished sound. I go to a rock concert, I expect to get a little dirty.
Matt is singing Adams songs to to keep the Three Days Grace fan base happy. I think it is so awesome that he does that. The newer songs that Matt sang originally are amazing. Lifetime is so beautiful ❤️
For real!!
I think it's not about TDG or SA or even Matt, Adam is shines his own light, he's his own abel, he could sing solo and it'd be fine too, his energy overflows of any band he's in
Adam.
Every. Single. Time.
The ones Matt put out are good songs but he doesn't pull the same notes, Adam just kills it & sounds damn good doing it.
they shouldn't even be compared, Adam 🔛🔝
Nobody can replace the legend Adam...
Matt sounds like a drunk dude trying karaoke lol
Yeah I thought this was a joke. Him attempting this felt like a fucking parody 😐
Well guess they have different styles of singing then. I would really like to hear Adam try Painkiller or I am Machine tho, I'm shure I'll sound good@raymondcarter9810
No doubt! The dude couldn't carry a tune in a bucket! His pitch is all over the place. Thank God for retakes and over dubs!
Adam has that sound and energy for that kind of singing.
You can't replace Adam. Totally unique voice.
Adam every single time , i see no comparison
I don't think Matt is bad but he seriously doesn't hold a candle to Adam
Maybe because that's not his song? I think Painkiller sounds amazing
He is bad
Adam 100% energy
Can't beat Adam. This is my fave 3DG song.
Adam gontier
No hate to Matt but no one will touch Adam's voice, tone, lyrics, or energy! The grittiness in his voice has a way of making u feel what my dude is sayin. 🤘🏻
Adam will always be my favorite
Not only are we just used to Adam because we grew up with the old stuff, but the way he puts lyrics with music makes sense...Makes me wonder what would have come about if he stayed😵💫 When i listen to Saint Asonia I still hear "Three days grace". He took the best parts of the band with him when he left. #90's kid
I've been calling it, but by this time next year I think Adam will be back in the band. It's the perfect time for it to happen.
Always Adam Gontier 🥰💜💜💜🎼🎶🎼
They should have renamed themselves after switching singers. Just like creed went on to become alter bridge.
Yes it may sound unfair but you can easily swap out almost any instrumental but a singer is the heart amd soul of a band. Unless you find somebody that at least sound similar to the original, all the previous songs dont sound right.
Matt isnt a bad singer at all, but i've seen them live once and it was more than enough. It felt horrible when he sang adams songs.
1000% Adam. TDG isn't the same without him and the added guitar.
So true, wish he was still here.
Adam Gontier with TDG again!
Adam is a beast. But both are amazing. I listen to Three Days Grace on Pandora everyday at work.
Matt is great with his own songs.. but he just doesn’t come close when it comes to the power of Adams songs, you can just feel the emotion with Adam
Dawg, matt, i was actualy crying wtf
I hate to be "that guy" Matt sucks at all Adams songs, I've also personally never really liked the new stuff with Matt and only really listen to Adams albums. It would be pretty cool if Adam and Three Days Grace would do reunion album or concert.
Yup. Matt sucks. Also he looks mentally IL and his movements on stage make me cringe
Adam is an absolute fkn legend i miss when he was in his prime with the band man those days were fkn insane!! Take me back!! 😫
People have gotta stop comparing these guys, they're two different singers that cannot be compared
*But it's true, Matt can't sing Adam's songs, he needs to stick to his own
I agree, they shouldn't be compared when they sing so differently. Except when they preform the same song in the same original context. Then it's fair to compare their performances. In my opinion anyways.
When people do the same things, they get compare, its call life my guy
@@MikeAubin_Guitar oh yeah, good point mate
When its referring to the same band and similarities in vocals then there is hell of alot of room for debate
@@patrickchappell2595 yeah true
Cant we just say they are both talented?
They both have strong points and bring different things to the band
yeah! and of course, we should/could say so. but comment sections are kinda/sorta podiums for pretense ..ive always said so - to people who are smarter than me (but you cant prove it)
Well the whole bit is who did it better. I think it's fair to have an opinion, without shitting on the other artist.
No lol Adam’s talented idk wtf Matt is doing
@@bluelight809 yeah thats my problem. The first song i ever listened to from them was Never Too Late, and thought it was great, but that was in 2015, after Adam already left. And listening to Matt's song, I loved them just as much. That's why I REALLY didn't understand why semo people were so devastated when Adam left or saying the new singer is awful. He sounds great to me.
I like both of them the whole band rocks baby
Песни Адама для Мэтта - это песни. Для Адама - это жизнь ❤
The new guy does not sound like the original singer. It sounds like somebody trying to do karaoke of the song and they've had one too many
yeah Im rolling with Adam
No hay nadie como Adam
Adam is still my all time favorite. Love him amd have hungout w him 2xs and he is amazing. He will never be replaced. I dont even listen to them after they changed singers.
Matt’s “va-empire” gets me every time 😂
Both are good I’m just glad I got to see them before Adam left.
I'm jealous. Saint Asonia did me justice when they did I Hate Everything About You at least
Adam all tbe way hes the reason i started listening to them
I don't know how Matt got the job?!
He's the brother of Brad
Went to see them live yesterday for the third time and honestly Matt is a beast ❤ he sounds amazing when performing live (and on record), of course he and Adam doesn't have the same voice for the old songs, but they are two different people, I prefer Matt. You guys have to let it go, it's been 10 f*ing years since Adam left
I'm never giving it up, I miss Adam, I don't care how old I am. High school me is still sad.
I 100% agree
100% agreed
100 percent disagree. You saying Matt is better is objectively incorrect
@@MikeHoncho610 nowhere did I say he was better. I said I like him
I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS FOR YEARS AND I COULDNT BE THERE, PLEASE LET THERE BE A COLLAB ALBUM
Those were two different shows
Adam is always amazing
One actually wrote the song, the other is singing karaoke
Adam suena como un trueno cayendo con fuerza e impetu. Matt suena como Mickey Mouse en la casa Club. 100% Adam Gontier... 🔥🎶
Morí con tu comentario JAJAJA
Matt has definitely grown on me and much respect to him covering Adam's songs. Gontier is still the man!
Matt Walst "vampire" part makes me chuckle. He rolls up places on a tractor. 🤠
Honestly I stopped listening after Adam left. I only listens old three days grace.
Yo igual con matt siento que mato la banda porque ya no suena ni sonara igual
Adam has the monster growl
Was not expecting the floaty during Matt’s clip to come outta nowhere like that 😂🤣🤣
Really I like them both. They have each contributed hugely to this band and neither should be over the other.
Adam made all their iconic stuff. Matt has made well, not that.
People keep comparing them, it's just tiring. I'm glad that we have TDG with Matt and Saint Asonia with Adam, more bands to enjoy!
Respectfully disagree.
Adam is, was and always Will be The voice of any 3DG music I ever listen to !!! Period !!!
Both are great!
Nothing beats Adam
Adam.
I love Adam not just because he's OG, but because his voice sounds more angsty and my younger self appreciated that more at the time.
They both produce hits
I miss Adam I like him better than matt
if you miss you must know he have a band call saint asonia and some time plays three days grace song
@@leothewolf7574 I know, but him at 3dg was better
@@jacobschlecht5770 I understand
There both even with this song like adam is amazing Matt’s good I just can’t pick one over the other
How can you not pick between the 2 on this Song? Adam sounds like how a song should be sang and Matt sounds like me as a 13 year old voice crack singing in the shower
Not close to even
Matt is an awful replacment for Adam. They have totally different ranges and techniques
I remember getting tickets to see them I don’t remember what year it was but a couple weeks before the show they got Matt and I was devastated
Adam in our hearts
Three days grace has been dead since Adam left lmao
Matt sounds like a gay guy singing with a fem voice and then out of nowhere gets angry lol
Adam is the og no one can replace him❤❤
Adam Gontier is the ONLY Singer that can be on Three Days Grace for ever 🖤
Why do these clips always have a poorer quality sound for Matt, and everything is softer?? Matt is super underrated.
It’s on purpose lol
Unfortunately these sad losers still think making Matt look bad still does something even tho Adam reconciled with Neil recently, and is extremely proud of his brothers for continuing the band after his departure.
I saw Matt live, he sounded just like this if not worse. He really cracks a lot.
Matt and Adam are from 2 different eras of TDA and cannot be compared honestly. They are both amazing in many aspects and I love the both of them equally.
both of them are dope
Adam all the way! He was the BEST at his songs.
Adam's got this battle I've been listening to 3 days grace since the beginning Adam can't be replaced vocally
No competition, Adam won
Can we at least be honest enough to say that Matt was filmed with a potato and the sound quality can be explained by the fact that the person was eating the potato at the time? They aren't the same sure but at least show a decent comparison
Adam sounds amazing
1000% Adam
Let’s be real, Matt can’t hold a candle to Adam when it comes to singing his stuff. But he does the best he can I guess.
Adam is too good. 3DG is just not the same. So glad i got to see them perform together before he left the band
They're still good though. And there's Saint Asonia
@@sinnaman-dj-atrain Yeah. There is Saint Asonia, Which is also not the same..
Tbh - when new 3DG plays their own new music, it sounds great.. when they play old music, they sound not very good at all.. but thats me.
Not taking away anything from people who do enjoy both new bands.. but there will always be that original sound that we miss and which both bands will never live up too. 🤷♂️
@@Last4Life yeah. To me the second Saint Asonia album is the only one I'd even consider stacking up against any of those original albums. But definitely a different sound.
Got to see adam perform break live was incredible
Adam Contier is THREE DAYS GRACE seen him a month ago Corpus Christi and he was Amazing Saint Asonia Rocks
Adam was the goat an always will be
No one will ever be able to top Adam Gontier's vocals. All have fallen short to the glory of this rock God.