Season 4 Got a lot of cool things but it’s kind of annoying how I’m almost none of them ever came back in some way. Like for example they didn’t do anything with Stacy knowing that Perry is a secret agent even though that’s a really cool plot point
@@Devilishdroid No it wasn't the movie, there was an episode called Happy Birthday, Isabella where Stacy learned Perry was an agent, and didn't have her memory erased at the end.
I remember a moment with Ferb where Charlene asks him why he doesn't talk much, him replying that he only has a few lines an episode, her asking if that's actually true, only for him to not say anything because he used all of his lines.
Charlene: “And I finally got a cyborg that speaks!” Ferb: “Actually I only have 1 line per episode.” Charlene: “What do you mean?” Ferb: “...” Charlene: “What do you mean you only have 1 line?” Ferb: “……”
0:37 I know Phineas is referring to the memory wipe thing, but I like to imagine he's confused how the others know it when only him and Ferb were there
In many ways I felt like this lost something by not being a larger and longer special. It's such a great episode as it is, but it could have been truly memorable with a 40 minute run time. There are so many specials within Season 4, and a couple which I feel maybe didn't deserve as much precedence as they got (Save Summer). Yet this was one that truly deserved to be a real event and it missed out on that, doubly so due to the fact that it leaked and was relegated like so many Season 4 episodes to the sporadic whims of the Disney XD release schedule. Edit: Stop liking this comment and go like Brooke's comment. I refuse to let this have more likes than hers.
Agreed! I think that this episode feels like the first act of a second movie TBH. Like I could see them cutting from that ending back to the resistance with P&F and monogram, and the Doof family setting up a new lair. This ep works as the first act of a movie!
@@theautisticintrovertedluca3634 it just felt like a rehash of other special episodes imo. yes I liked the idea of it, but it just didn't feel right, like it felt more like the high stakes for a series finale.
When I first watched this episode, I was laughing about how Charlene was the villain because of how ironic it is and the shock factor. It's even funnier that she looks exactly the same as in the first dimension.
You have yet to see what Phineas and Ferb's Thanksgiving break was like, with Dr Mendel Stromm/Gaunt and Otto Octavious/Dr Octopus with help from David Cain and Phosphorus Rex forming a team comprised of characters throughout the series with a vendetta against either Phineas, Ferb, and company or their platypus, Perry, I'll list all the villains if you like
I thought this was a really good episode, but it sucks that we’re probably never going to find out what happened after the Doofenshmirtz family escaped. Even just an hour long special to wrap it up would be enough. As cool as it would be to see that plot turned into a whole 2nd Dimension spin-off show, I think it would be even cooler to bring the plot into a Doof and Perry spin-off show. Doof is trying to become Professor Time, but then Doof-2 shows up to try to get his help to take over the Tri-State Area. So then Doof-1 tries to convince him to turn good.
It feels like Disney just didn't think there was an audience for a spinoff at the time, but who knows? With the success of the new movie, they could easily change their minds.
This episode deserved 44 minutes imo. It was such a great concept for an episode that with extra time to develop all the plot points could have been much better than it was. Despite its shortcomings though, no lie I'd love a spin off mini series set in the second dimension. They could do ideas they'd never be able to in the main series due to everyone knowing of Doof and of course their pets being OWCA agents. They could even have a serialized narrative too which is also something the main show hardly ever did if it did at all.
A serialized P&F miniseries would've been so much fun! But yeah, this episode really needed 44 minutes (or just to rearrange the story so that this felt like a complete episode)
I remember seeing it on TV when it premiered, and I payed little attention to it. I enjoyed it a lot, but at the end of the day it felt like another P&F episode. Side note, congratulations on getting engaged!
@@The2ndDimension IKR, you seem to have better luck when it comes to romance than I do, it's been 10 years since my heart was broken so close to Christmas time, one good reason why I spend a lot of my time in December trying to drink myself into a coma
Im almost certain it was one of their backdoor pilots. Still PROBABLY would have preferred MML over this, but I would like for them to potentially revisit this since there is a lot of potential (maybe in the Second Dimension Love Muffin actually controls the rest of the world?)
It feels like it for sure! But I honestly couldn't see Disney greenlighting a 2nd Dimension only series. Tho there were development plans for the fireside girls series, so maybe Disney would've!
Love Muffin actually being a major threat would make a lot of sense, and would be a good way to expand on the 2nd Dimension lore. Doofenshmirtz remains a major villain but he's not the only threat to Danville and the Tri-State area. After all, Doof would have left a power vacuum after his defeat.
@@santosicThat would be cool but I hope they revamp the art style to resemble early 2000 action cartoons. I don't think id be able to take Candace's design seriously for a long period of time
I dunno if we will get another episode with the second dimension characters, or if we’ll even get more Phineas and Ferb content beyond this point. But what I do know is, it leaves a lot of room for people to come up with their own endings for the second dimension.
Yeah, but that’s not really a good excuse to leave it on a cliffhanger forever. “Remember that episode of DuckTales 2017 where NegaDuck showed up at the very end and then never got mentioned after that? You guys can just come up with your own endings.”
@@MiloMurphysLaw to be fair though it seems like the DT17 writers did want to do more with Negaduck and expand on the ending, but Disney didn't give them the fourth season they wanted. I'm assuming a similar thing happened with Tales from the Resistance. In fact I wouldn't be surprised if they initially wanted it to be a longer episode but were denied and had to condense everything. Disney do be weird like that sometimes
@@santosic But that’s the thing, DT17 didn’t really need a fourth season. NegaDuck was the only unresolved thing out of all the episodes of the show. Everything else already got wrapped up. So a fourth season would have to introduce a completely new plot line and then somehow have an even more epic series finale. It’s the same reason why it wouldn’t make sense for there to be a 3rd season go Gravity Falls, it would ruin the perfect series finale just to introduce a completely new, unnecessary plot, and then the new series finale probably wouldn’t be as good. Plus, it makes more sense to have NegaDuck be the villain of a Darkwing show instead. So that’s why I’m still hoping for a Darkwing spin-off show. But so far, Disney never officially confirmed those rumors from over a year ago claiming that there was going to be a Darkwing reboot on Disney+
I’m glad to see some talk about this episode, it’s weird how little people talk about this episode, with perhaps the exception of some mentions of “All The Convoluted Reasons We Pretend To Be Divorced”
When searching the song on UA-cam, I found tons of fan antimatics and edits of the song from other fandoms, so at least that has achieved some notoriety!
It's kinda suck that there's no other continuation of the 2nd dimension plotline. I love that in the second dimension, Phineas and Ferb finally get to interact with Perry's real identity instead of his "platypus" identity which was literally my childhood dream way back when and we get to see more of Perry the platyborg after he turned good which was pretty interesting so it's sad that there's no more continuation of that plotline
The ending of this episode is weird because when they were ending season 4 of the original series they were trying to find ways to make like a spin of show so they made several “pilot episodes” for these potential spin offs so like Doof 101 could have been a spin of show, OWCA files could have been a spin of show, and then tales of the resistance could have been a spin of show. So from that perspective the ending makes sense. Cause if a spin of series had been approved it would have problem followed up with Charline and Doof trying to take over again and the resistance now with the brought back agents would need to stop them. Candace and Jeremy would probably develop a relationship throughout the show. The second dimension kids would probably learn a bunch of things about the world that were banned by Doof. And Vanessa and Tony would also probably be important. And perry and panda would be like rivals. So yeah it would definitely have been an awesome series on its own.
Lo único que no me gusta de lo que dijiste es lo de Peter y perry sería mejor verlos como amigos cosa que se daba a entender en el programa pero nunca se desarrollo
I actually did watch this episode when it aired on TV and I loved this episode solely because it followed up on the 2nd dimension, which was my favorite Phineas and Ferb thing to come out at the time (and probably still is)
I always liked this episode. I like the idea of a semi-normal episode of Phineas and Ferb with the post-dystopian world of 2nd Dimension, with some of the flavor that comes along with the more 'aggressive' characters of the movie (for lack of a better term). Regardless of how kinda forgettable it might've been, it is a good episode.
With what I'm working on, a sequel to *Tales from the Resistance* will show that dimension's Candace being 9 months pregnant and parodies *Die Hard,* the episode starting with Candace waking up from a nightmare about the 2nd dimension's Doof slaughtering everyone in sight until she and her family is next and ending with that dimension's Doof falling to his death after she undoes her pants, causing him to take em with him, then she's wheeled out on a stretcher and goes into labor as she's loaded into the ambulance, at the hospital, Candace gives birth to a healthy baby girl who's then named Amanda
I think it’s a fun look back into the lives of these versions of the cast, getting to see them just doing a regular Phineas and Ferb big idea before going for more of the action they did while being the resistance. The big drawback is the episode could have had a longer run time to fully reach the potential of the idea as some people have pointed out, but as is, it’s still a fun, if short lived, return to this concept.
I recently rewatched this episode, and it's way more hilarious than I remembered, so I gained a new-found appreaciation for it. I mean I didn't hated it when I first watched it, but I thought it was just simply okay. The Divorce-song and Ferb's line were my favourite parts of the episode. Of course, there were other great jokes too. I wish we could have gotten some more episodes from this world. Doof and his wife had an interesting amd refereshing dynamic, and expending upon Candace's conflict beetween to be on the edge all the time and being a normal teenager was genuinely good.
And in the song that concludes the *Last Day of Summer* special, the memories of Phineas and company's time in the 2nd dimension started flooding back, as if the effects of the amnesia-inator started wearing off, there's no telling how long Doof's inators' effects would last
@@damianprock1650 i understood that as just a fourth wall break, and not that they were remembering cause in that same moment Phineas tells Isabela to just wait a few years till they get together
@@bluecadet8517 referring to the events of *Act Your Age,* the point where things started to seem hopeless, but you know when I'm right about Doof's inators, the effects on those things hardly ever last long *ashes a cigarette*
For the whole video I was absolutely sure I had never seen this ep before, missed it while watching the tv or sth like that. I was so sad I watched it so late... Until the "Hey yourself". It broke my mind because I remember this scene so accurately. The episode seems to be good but it didn't stay in my memory at all for some reason :(
0:36 theory: that song, as well as little brothers and gimme a grade, are already existing songs in the PnF universe, and they are singing covers of them.
Ironically, Terry the Turtle is actually one of the faster characters in Phineas and Ferb Across the Second Dimension for Wii. Also, glad you mentioned one of the best movie games of all time.
@@The2ndDimension Don't mean to plug but my most recent video is an original theme song I made for Terry the Turtle. I also own 45 copies of the game Edit: I'm sorry if this came across as shameless self promotion, it's just so hard to find other people who care about the game.
@@The2ndDimension I'm also currently working on programming him (as well as Phineas, Ferb, and Perry) into a Fighting game (The moveset is entirely based on the game) and made a remix of the song made for the game (Get Gone) as well (it's a good song). Needless to say I am a major Phineas and Ferb Across the 2nd Dimension Wii fan. It's a shame it's rarely mentioned.
11:45 So did Tails in Sonic lost world take inspiration from Ferb or did Ferb take inspiration from Tails? Or did they collaborate and share notes on how to get out of that special situation?
No joke, I think this is your best video yet. You're really starting to come into your style. You're definitely now adding more to the conversation about the stuff you talk about. Great job.
I also like the difference of the alternate doof and the main doof, with the main doof being divorced while the alternate doof is still married technically
Great video! I remember watching this special episode on TV when it aired! It was neat seeing the 2nd Dimension lives. What I wonder is, do the 2nd Dimension characters still remember 1st Dimension characters or did they have their mind erased?
Candace probably calls the agents “graduates” because they went through some sort of training taught by Perry about how to use their new cybernetic bodies to the fullest
I think that brief mention of Terry the turtle was the only time I've ever heard anyone talk about the 2nd Dimension Video game. I played that game so much when I was younger and always played as Terry the Turtle
@@The2ndDimension Plus, Monogram was Doof's slave- er, unpaid executive assistant- so I'm sure there was a major managerial upheaval. The "seeing OWCA agents results in memory erasure" thing is also a post-movie thing, especially since the whole thing relies on one of Doof's old inators rather than specialised OWCA equipment. Beforehand, they only had the relocation.
I think its because once Doof took over the 2nd dimension than he threw all the OWCA Rules out the window which is why Major Monogram was working for the 2nd Dimension Doofenshmirtz until the end of the movie
Oddly enough, Tales From The Resistance just so happens to sound like a title of a forgotten 90s cartoon & that's what I would've thought it was if you didn't say it was a Phineas & Ferb episode.
I did not even know this existed until today. I've watched the movie when I was younger and I was craving more of the 2nd Dimension, that was 2014. 8 years later, I saw this video and knew this special episode's existence, watched it and well, there could've been something more. Not that disappointed though, I'm glad that this special made me happy and filled the cravings that I've had back in my childhood.
I love this special because it was funny and I can't wait to see the video about the crossover specials Mission Marvel and Phineas and Ferb Star Wars!🌟✌❤😂🤖
"If I had a Nickel for every time Vanessa Flew me out in a Flying car after trying to be Captured or Imprisoned I would have 2 Nickels, Which isn't a lot but it's still weird it happened twice"
There’s demand for another sequel. I’ll just give my ideas. (Based on popular fanfic ideas) Phineas and Ferb the Movie: Return to the second dimension. Taking place after Act your Age, college aged Phineas and Ferb, and their friends, are summoned into the second dimension by their counterparts, who they don’t remember do the events of the end of the first film. After getting their memories back by one of Dr. Baljeet‘s inventions, they are told that Second dimension Dr. Doofenshmirtz, along with second dimension Charlene and Vanessa at his side, Phineas and Ferb, Perry, Isabella, and the rest of the gang must stop second dimension Doofenshmirtz once more. Planned elements: Phineas and Isabella are engaged. The characters do not get their memories wiped again, as Perry really doesn’t have a “host family” anymore. Everyone finds out Stacy was the only one who knew about Perry after the events of the first film. The Milo Murphy characters might appear or they will be referenced. Hamster and Gretel might appear or be referenced. Xavier, Fred, and Amanda (Candace and Jeremy‘s kids) might appear.
Yeah, a lot of people didn’t know that episodes from season 4 existed. Tales From the Resistance, Act Your Age, Last Day of Summer, OWCA Files, The Phineas and Ferb Effect, etc.
THIS IS WHERE ALL THE CONVELUDED REASONS WE PRETEND TO BE DIVORCED IS FROM? I THOUGHT THAT WAS FROM THE MOVIE, I HAVE LISTENED TO THAT SONG LIKE 20 TIMES!
I definitely remember being somewhat disappointed by this episode back when it came out but I wasn't sure why I was disappointed because I didn't remember the episode whatsoever. After watching a 17 minute video on it... I think I forgot again. This episode isn't real.
The sad part is that is how the episode ended and Doof and fam wasn’t finished and Peter excsaped and not good again. Also Peter is a reference to it’s about time and meep’s return
I honestly loved this episode back when I watched it and it's the same by now. It's not really that confusing to me, but I would like a longer episode or even more episodes like this
O.W.C.A Files is also the best. In the the destruction of Flynn Flecher's house, Imagine if Isabella see the destruction of Phineas And Ferb's house, what is her reaction for that ? I will never know.
3.9/10! Yeah, it’s no wonder why it was forgotten especially no one who’s talking about it. (And I was expecting that this it’s one of those sequels.) *Shudders*
Well, I remembered both the 2nd Dimension movie and its sequel. I made a Last Day Of Summer fanfic of the 2nd Dimension where Phineas-2D & Ferb-2D betrayed both of their safety, their sister Candace-2D, and the Doofenshmirtz-2D family and tookover the 2nd Dimension Tri-State-Area. Then I made a Candace Flynn fanfic about her 2nd Dimension counterpart needed her advice to bust the 2nd Dimension's Phineas & Ferb
A topic for a possible future video: The lost potential of Stacy knowing Perry’s secret identity. I’m sure a few stories coulda been made from that in future episodes.
Oh my god you just revived my memories of seeing this episode like once, thank you. I now have an extreme desire to rewatch the entire series, too. SHIT-
Well with the reveal that the series will be returning as a continuation series. It could be possible they might make use of this in that. Since it wouldn't make sense for them to make Doof evil again after promising his daughter not to be anymore, as well as Candace accepting her brothers as being themselves. BUT if the other dimension counterparts were to try to take revenge on Main doof, THAT could work. Oh and of course having it possibly allow for the classic family to be allowed to know about perry, Maybe involving the other dimension OWCA. Other things they could end up doing... Of course build on the whole Professor Time thing they were trying to do in Murphy's Law since THAT was cool. Maybe even have Charlene end up being in the same area as Doof when their other dimension counterparts show up. This ending up resulting in Main Charlene defending her Ex Husband when her counterpart insults him. Causing them to start to get back together slowly, which could include Doof asking perry to help him prepare for a makeup date.
12:18 Fun fact: Magnets and many devices don't play well together, as magnets if strong enough can wipe a mobile phone's data. And certain other devices too.
i really like the fact that candace still cant handle the fact that she’s free to do anything because she’s lived so long trying to defeat doof and protect her brothers it just feels realistic
If there was actually a Phineas and Ferb convention, I hope Dan would show up that way I can tell me did a great job at playing one of my favorite villains.
I truthfully only got around to watching it first time a week or so after this video was uploaded. It looked great when I saw sneak peaks but wasn’t interested enough for whatever reason for 8 years. Now I can say I love it. Just about convoluted enough to make a large amount of world building, showing how there are so much else to be told about this dimension. Of course the graduation scene(?) has been put into a new and yes a truly convoluted perspective now, and as nice as it was seeing the kids learn to have fun like actual kids, especially seeing them trying to work out which item was used for which sport, would’ve been nice to see rackets or footballs be used agains the borgs or something. In conclusion, 2nd dimension Dooflene my beloved.
Fiancée? Cool!
THAT'S YOU
@@The2ndDimension that's her
So y'all gonna pretend that your divorced 🤣
@@jackhammerjt that would be convoluted
@@D00MIC I don’t think I can guess all the convoluted reasons why that happened though
Season 4 Got a lot of cool things but it’s kind of annoying how I’m almost none of them ever came back in some way. Like for example they didn’t do anything with Stacy knowing that Perry is a secret agent even though that’s a really cool plot point
Agreed!!!
Yeah, it almost feels like the show should’ve gotten another season. I mean, Disney wanted to continue the show, but Dan and Swampy decided to end it.
Correct me if I’m wrong but it think she forgot about that in the first movie
@@Devilishdroid No it wasn't the movie, there was an episode called Happy Birthday, Isabella where Stacy learned Perry was an agent, and didn't have her memory erased at the end.
@@warlock984 The greasy grease girl form the basement
I remember a moment with Ferb where Charlene asks him why he doesn't talk much, him replying that he only has a few lines an episode, her asking if that's actually true, only for him to not say anything because he used all of his lines.
I'm annoyed he didn't mention it
@@spritemon98fr lmao
Charlene: “And I finally got a cyborg that speaks!”
Ferb: “Actually I only have 1 line per episode.”
Charlene: “What do you mean?”
Ferb: “...”
Charlene: “What do you mean you only have 1 line?”
Ferb: “……”
@@spritemon98 Wouldn't that take away from the joke?
0:37 I know Phineas is referring to the memory wipe thing, but I like to imagine he's confused how the others know it when only him and Ferb were there
🤣that’s a good point
I honestly thought that was the case until this video.
In many ways I felt like this lost something by not being a larger and longer special. It's such a great episode as it is, but it could have been truly memorable with a 40 minute run time. There are so many specials within Season 4, and a couple which I feel maybe didn't deserve as much precedence as they got (Save Summer). Yet this was one that truly deserved to be a real event and it missed out on that, doubly so due to the fact that it leaked and was relegated like so many Season 4 episodes to the sporadic whims of the Disney XD release schedule.
Edit: Stop liking this comment and go like Brooke's comment. I refuse to let this have more likes than hers.
Agreed! I think that this episode feels like the first act of a second movie TBH. Like I could see them cutting from that ending back to the resistance with P&F and monogram, and the Doof family setting up a new lair. This ep works as the first act of a movie!
What was wrong with Sace Summer?
I feel this should have led to a mini series with how the episode went
that’s what she said?
@@theautisticintrovertedluca3634 it just felt like a rehash of other special episodes imo. yes I liked the idea of it, but it just didn't feel right, like it felt more like the high stakes for a series finale.
When I first watched this episode, I was laughing about how Charlene was the villain because of how ironic it is and the shock factor. It's even funnier that she looks exactly the same as in the first dimension.
You have yet to see what Phineas and Ferb's Thanksgiving break was like, with Dr Mendel Stromm/Gaunt and Otto Octavious/Dr Octopus with help from David Cain and Phosphorus Rex forming a team comprised of characters throughout the series with a vendetta against either Phineas, Ferb, and company or their platypus, Perry, I'll list all the villains if you like
I thought this was a really good episode, but it sucks that we’re probably never going to find out what happened after the Doofenshmirtz family escaped. Even just an hour long special to wrap it up would be enough.
As cool as it would be to see that plot turned into a whole 2nd Dimension spin-off show, I think it would be even cooler to bring the plot into a Doof and Perry spin-off show. Doof is trying to become Professor Time, but then Doof-2 shows up to try to get his help to take over the Tri-State Area. So then Doof-1 tries to convince him to turn good.
One more visit to the 2nd Dimension as a Disney+ special would work SO well
@@The2ndDimension yeah, but that’s the thing that sucks. It’s probably never going to happen.
@DarthAnonymous dude its milo murphy. *by him being here it turn from a 50% change to a 0% chance.*
It feels like Disney just didn't think there was an audience for a spinoff at the time, but who knows? With the success of the new movie, they could easily change their minds.
@@Integrous_Melodies sorry, I didn’t mean to do that
This episode deserved 44 minutes imo. It was such a great concept for an episode that with extra time to develop all the plot points could have been much better than it was. Despite its shortcomings though, no lie I'd love a spin off mini series set in the second dimension. They could do ideas they'd never be able to in the main series due to everyone knowing of Doof and of course their pets being OWCA agents. They could even have a serialized narrative too which is also something the main show hardly ever did if it did at all.
A serialized P&F miniseries would've been so much fun! But yeah, this episode really needed 44 minutes (or just to rearrange the story so that this felt like a complete episode)
I wanted to see the Resistance before the movie with Phineas and Ferb wanting to bust Candice.
I remember watching this sequel a couple times and it was pretty good and still is
Me too
Same
It's far from bad! Just bites off more than it can chew imo
Same
@@The2ndDimension what did you say
I never actually knew where "all the convoluted reasons we pretend to be divorced " song came from. Thanks for this.
I remember seeing it on TV when it premiered, and I payed little attention to it. I enjoyed it a lot, but at the end of the day it felt like another P&F episode.
Side note, congratulations on getting engaged!
Thank you so much! :D
@@The2ndDimension IKR, you seem to have better luck when it comes to romance than I do, it's been 10 years since my heart was broken so close to Christmas time, one good reason why I spend a lot of my time in December trying to drink myself into a coma
Im almost certain it was one of their backdoor pilots. Still PROBABLY would have preferred MML over this, but I would like for them to potentially revisit this since there is a lot of potential
(maybe in the Second Dimension Love Muffin actually controls the rest of the world?)
It feels like it for sure! But I honestly couldn't see Disney greenlighting a 2nd Dimension only series. Tho there were development plans for the fireside girls series, so maybe Disney would've!
Love Muffin actually being a major threat would make a lot of sense, and would be a good way to expand on the 2nd Dimension lore. Doofenshmirtz remains a major villain but he's not the only threat to Danville and the Tri-State area. After all, Doof would have left a power vacuum after his defeat.
@@santosicThat would be cool but I hope they revamp the art style to resemble early 2000 action cartoons. I don't think id be able to take Candace's design seriously for a long period of time
@@The2ndDimension they'll need my help to make it possible then
I dunno if we will get another episode with the second dimension characters, or if we’ll even get more Phineas and Ferb content beyond this point. But what I do know is, it leaves a lot of room for people to come up with their own endings for the second dimension.
Yeah, but that’s not really a good excuse to leave it on a cliffhanger forever. “Remember that episode of DuckTales 2017 where NegaDuck showed up at the very end and then never got mentioned after that? You guys can just come up with your own endings.”
Perhaps that's how it's best left - you can make your own perfect ending to the story
@@MiloMurphysLaw to be fair though it seems like the DT17 writers did want to do more with Negaduck and expand on the ending, but Disney didn't give them the fourth season they wanted.
I'm assuming a similar thing happened with Tales from the Resistance. In fact I wouldn't be surprised if they initially wanted it to be a longer episode but were denied and had to condense everything. Disney do be weird like that sometimes
@@santosic But that’s the thing, DT17 didn’t really need a fourth season. NegaDuck was the only unresolved thing out of all the episodes of the show. Everything else already got wrapped up. So a fourth season would have to introduce a completely new plot line and then somehow have an even more epic series finale. It’s the same reason why it wouldn’t make sense for there to be a 3rd season go Gravity Falls, it would ruin the perfect series finale just to introduce a completely new, unnecessary plot, and then the new series finale probably wouldn’t be as good.
Plus, it makes more sense to have NegaDuck be the villain of a Darkwing show instead. So that’s why I’m still hoping for a Darkwing spin-off show. But so far, Disney never officially confirmed those rumors from over a year ago claiming that there was going to be a Darkwing reboot on Disney+
@@MiloMurphysLaw honestly that was meant to get a continuation BUT Disney cancelled it😅
It always felt like that episode was leading to something bigger, but it never went anywhere.
same here
The episode was probably supposed to set up a spin-off show, just like Doof 101 or OWCA Files.
For real! Such buildup for a cliffhanger ending!
I’m glad to see some talk about this episode, it’s weird how little people talk about this episode, with perhaps the exception of some mentions of “All The Convoluted Reasons We Pretend To Be Divorced”
When searching the song on UA-cam, I found tons of fan antimatics and edits of the song from other fandoms, so at least that has achieved some notoriety!
This is honestly one of my favourite Phineas and Ferb episodes
I love when they do weird and unique stuff like this! That's why S4 is my favorite
what do you mean forgotten? i've always loved this episode. but yeah, it is weird that they seemed to set up a threequel that was never made
The episode was probably supposed to set up a spin-off show, just like Doof 101 or OWCA Files.
My guess is if you asked everyone who watched AT2D as a kid, maybe 80% of them would have no clue this existed
It's kinda suck that there's no other continuation of the 2nd dimension plotline.
I love that in the second dimension, Phineas and Ferb finally get to interact with Perry's real identity instead of his "platypus" identity which was literally my childhood dream way back when and we get to see more of Perry the platyborg after he turned good which was pretty interesting so it's sad that there's no more continuation of that plotline
The ending of this episode is weird because when they were ending season 4 of the original series they were trying to find ways to make like a spin of show so they made several “pilot episodes” for these potential spin offs so like Doof 101 could have been a spin of show, OWCA files could have been a spin of show, and then tales of the resistance could have been a spin of show. So from that perspective the ending makes sense. Cause if a spin of series had been approved it would have problem followed up with Charline and Doof trying to take over again and the resistance now with the brought back agents would need to stop them. Candace and Jeremy would probably develop a relationship throughout the show. The second dimension kids would probably learn a bunch of things about the world that were banned by Doof. And Vanessa and Tony would also probably be important. And perry and panda would be like rivals. So yeah it would definitely have been an awesome series on its own.
Lo único que no me gusta de lo que dijiste es lo de Peter y perry sería mejor verlos como amigos cosa que se daba a entender en el programa pero nunca se desarrollo
Charlene:. I finally have an agent that can speak
Ferb: I usually only say one line per day
Charlene: really? Why?
Ferb:
Charlene: that was it?
I actually did watch this episode when it aired on TV and I loved this episode solely because it followed up on the 2nd dimension, which was my favorite Phineas and Ferb thing to come out at the time (and probably still is)
I'd like to state the divorce song despite all logic saying otherwise there voces both seem to actually mix together rather well
They really do!!
@@The2ndDimension new head cannon they met when doof made a cariokeanator
I always liked this episode. I like the idea of a semi-normal episode of Phineas and Ferb with the post-dystopian world of 2nd Dimension, with some of the flavor that comes along with the more 'aggressive' characters of the movie (for lack of a better term). Regardless of how kinda forgettable it might've been, it is a good episode.
I am so sad people don't talk about the tales from the resistance enough
More like TALE from the Resistance
With what I'm working on, a sequel to *Tales from the Resistance* will show that dimension's Candace being 9 months pregnant and parodies *Die Hard,* the episode starting with Candace waking up from a nightmare about the 2nd dimension's Doof slaughtering everyone in sight until she and her family is next and ending with that dimension's Doof falling to his death after she undoes her pants, causing him to take em with him, then she's wheeled out on a stretcher and goes into labor as she's loaded into the ambulance, at the hospital, Candace gives birth to a healthy baby girl who's then named Amanda
@@damianprock1650 huh
@@zlve you know what I mean
Season 4 as a whole is incredibly underrated and underappreciated
I think it’s a fun look back into the lives of these versions of the cast, getting to see them just doing a regular Phineas and Ferb big idea before going for more of the action they did while being the resistance. The big drawback is the episode could have had a longer run time to fully reach the potential of the idea as some people have pointed out, but as is, it’s still a fun, if short lived, return to this concept.
I recently rewatched this episode, and it's way more hilarious than I remembered, so I gained a new-found appreaciation for it. I mean I didn't hated it when I first watched it, but I thought it was just simply okay. The Divorce-song and Ferb's line were my favourite parts of the episode. Of course, there were other great jokes too. I wish we could have gotten some more episodes from this world. Doof and his wife had an interesting amd refereshing dynamic, and expending upon Candace's conflict beetween to be on the edge all the time and being a normal teenager was genuinely good.
Actually there are main characters who remember the events of the movie:
Perry, Major monogram, Carl, Linda ,and Lawerence.
And in the song that concludes the *Last Day of Summer* special, the memories of Phineas and company's time in the 2nd dimension started flooding back, as if the effects of the amnesia-inator started wearing off, there's no telling how long Doof's inators' effects would last
@@damianprock1650 i understood that as just a fourth wall break, and not that they were remembering cause in that same moment Phineas tells Isabela to just wait a few years till they get together
@@bluecadet8517 referring to the events of *Act Your Age,* the point where things started to seem hopeless, but you know when I'm right about Doof's inators, the effects on those things hardly ever last long *ashes a cigarette*
Dang, I forgot how much I loved this episode. Thanks for bringing it back to my attention!
You're welcome! :D
For the whole video I was absolutely sure I had never seen this ep before, missed it while watching the tv or sth like that. I was so sad I watched it so late... Until the "Hey yourself". It broke my mind because I remember this scene so accurately. The episode seems to be good but it didn't stay in my memory at all for some reason :(
I love when repressed memories suddenly appear - it's definitely worth watching again!
I never forgot this. The pretend to be divorced song is memorable.
0:36 theory: that song, as well as little brothers and gimme a grade, are already existing songs in the PnF universe, and they are singing covers of them.
Every now and then I walk around singing “The Convoluted Reasons We Pretend To Be Divorced” under my breath and people stare confused. Yeah
Ironically, Terry the Turtle is actually one of the faster characters in Phineas and Ferb Across the Second Dimension for Wii.
Also, glad you mentioned one of the best movie games of all time.
It's such a fun game!
@@The2ndDimension Don't mean to plug but my most recent video is an original theme song I made for Terry the Turtle. I also own 45 copies of the game
Edit: I'm sorry if this came across as shameless self promotion, it's just so hard to find other people who care about the game.
@@The2ndDimension I'm also currently working on programming him (as well as Phineas, Ferb, and Perry) into a Fighting game (The moveset is entirely based on the game) and made a remix of the song made for the game (Get Gone) as well (it's a good song).
Needless to say I am a major Phineas and Ferb Across the 2nd Dimension Wii fan. It's a shame it's rarely mentioned.
@@SuperIsaiah I checked it out that is AWESOME
@@The2ndDimension thanks
11:45 So did Tails in Sonic lost world take inspiration from Ferb or did Ferb take inspiration from Tails?
Or did they collaborate and share notes on how to get out of that special situation?
No joke, I think this is your best video yet. You're really starting to come into your style. You're definitely now adding more to the conversation about the stuff you talk about. Great job.
I also like the difference of the alternate doof and the main doof, with the main doof being divorced while the alternate doof is still married technically
I want to know what the rest of Heinz’s family is doing in the second dimension. Does roger have the sad backstory?
Great video! I remember watching this special episode on TV when it aired! It was neat seeing the 2nd Dimension lives. What I wonder is, do the 2nd Dimension characters still remember 1st Dimension characters or did they have their mind erased?
It didn’t originally air on Disney channel but I know now it occasionally plays on there now so it’s not forgotten at least not forgotten by me
I vividly remembered that divorce song and none of the rest of the episode
Candace probably calls the agents “graduates” because they went through some sort of training taught by Perry about how to use their new cybernetic bodies to the fullest
Wait, that episode was only 20 minutes?! It felt so much longer!
With a new season on the way I hope they can continue this story
I think that brief mention of Terry the turtle was the only time I've ever heard anyone talk about the 2nd Dimension Video game. I played that game so much when I was younger and always played as Terry the Turtle
Me: “Yes! I’ve finally finished watching every P&F episode and movie!
Me: **Sees this video**
Me again: **Sighs then turns on tv**
why can people in this dimension know about the secret agents without having their memories erased?
I think once Doof took over, they threw the OWCA rules out the window to build the strongest resistance
@@The2ndDimension Plus, Monogram was Doof's slave- er, unpaid executive assistant- so I'm sure there was a major managerial upheaval.
The "seeing OWCA agents results in memory erasure" thing is also a post-movie thing, especially since the whole thing relies on one of Doof's old inators rather than specialised OWCA equipment. Beforehand, they only had the relocation.
I think its because once Doof took over the 2nd dimension than he threw all the OWCA Rules out the window which is why Major Monogram was working for the 2nd Dimension Doofenshmirtz until the end of the movie
Oddly enough, Tales From The Resistance just so happens to sound like a title of a forgotten 90s cartoon & that's what I would've thought it was if you didn't say it was a Phineas & Ferb episode.
I liked it. I just thought it was another phineas and ferb episode. Nothing special just a nice peak back into the 2nd Dimension.
I did not even know this existed until today. I've watched the movie when I was younger and I was craving more of the 2nd Dimension, that was 2014. 8 years later, I saw this video and knew this special episode's existence, watched it and well, there could've been something more. Not that disappointed though, I'm glad that this special made me happy and filled the cravings that I've had back in my childhood.
We need to summon Dan Povenmire to get this expanded more.
I love this special because it was funny and I can't wait to see the video about the crossover specials Mission Marvel and Phineas and Ferb Star Wars!🌟✌❤😂🤖
I defo would have loved this to become a full series
Well this is my sign to binge all of the phineas and ferb episodes and specials…….. again
all the convoluted reasons we pretend to be divorced is one of the best songs in the series
I love this video so much and am looking forward to the crossover one with Star Wars, Marvel, and even Milo Murphy's Law.
8:05 Most Favorite Part! Thanks 4 Doing That!
13:20 One of my favourite parts of the episode. Saying nobody saw it cos it was a deleted scene
"If I had a Nickel for every time Vanessa Flew me out in a Flying car after trying to be Captured or Imprisoned I would have 2 Nickels, Which isn't a lot but it's still weird it happened twice"
was lowkey upset that he didn't finish the joke
There’s demand for another sequel. I’ll just give my ideas.
(Based on popular fanfic ideas)
Phineas and Ferb the Movie: Return to the second dimension.
Taking place after Act your Age, college aged Phineas and Ferb, and their friends, are summoned into the second dimension by their counterparts, who they don’t remember do the events of the end of the first film. After getting their memories back by one of Dr. Baljeet‘s inventions, they are told that Second dimension Dr. Doofenshmirtz, along with second dimension Charlene and Vanessa at his side, Phineas and Ferb, Perry, Isabella, and the rest of the gang must stop second dimension Doofenshmirtz once more.
Planned elements:
Phineas and Isabella are engaged.
The characters do not get their memories wiped again, as Perry really doesn’t have a “host family” anymore.
Everyone finds out Stacy was the only one who knew about Perry after the events of the first film.
The Milo Murphy characters might appear or they will be referenced.
Hamster and Gretel might appear or be referenced.
Xavier, Fred, and Amanda (Candace and Jeremy‘s kids) might appear.
The song is fire
All the convoluted reasons we pretend to be divorced
I love unbelievably specific songs
I didn’t even know the episode existed until I saw your video comparing across the 2nd dimension and Candace against the universe
Yeah, a lot of people didn’t know that episodes from season 4 existed. Tales From the Resistance, Act Your Age, Last Day of Summer, OWCA Files, The Phineas and Ferb Effect, etc.
THIS IS WHERE ALL THE CONVELUDED REASONS WE PRETEND TO BE DIVORCED IS FROM? I THOUGHT THAT WAS FROM THE MOVIE, I HAVE LISTENED TO THAT SONG LIKE 20 TIMES!
I actually fondly remember this episode! It used to be my favorite episode
Wait, did Buford say "I'd rather be breaking rocks for the state"?
A+ line right there.
I have a question? Why was Doof still doing evil in the Christmas specials if he turned good at the end of Summer?
Old habits die hard I suppose, you wouldn't even imagine what his Thanksgiving was like
Maybe it was a Christmas before summer. I don’t think we ever got an actual date
Congrats on your engagement dude
Thank you!
I have seen it several times on the DVD . Still a fun episode even all its flaws.
I definitely remember being somewhat disappointed by this episode back when it came out but I wasn't sure why I was disappointed because I didn't remember the episode whatsoever. After watching a 17 minute video on it... I think I forgot again. This episode isn't real.
SPORTS SPORTS! SPORTS IS FUN
OWCA agents go by “Agent _”, where _ is a letter of the alphabet. There are 26 letters in the alphabet. How many cyborg agents were missing?
I forgot how savage Charlene was. She just TOSSED Choo-Choo off the balcony of her penthouse!
the number of times this face at 6:44 pops up and zooms in is so ajskdlajda
The Phineas and Ferb Star Wars DVD was the first time I heard of anything 2nd Dimension-related. I didn't even see the original movie yet.
The sad part is that is how the episode ended and Doof and fam wasn’t finished and Peter excsaped and not good again. Also Peter is a reference to it’s about time and meep’s return
I honestly loved this episode back when I watched it and it's the same by now. It's not really that confusing to me, but I would like a longer episode or even more episodes like this
O.W.C.A Files is also the best. In the the destruction of Flynn Flecher's house, Imagine if Isabella see the destruction of Phineas And Ferb's house, what is her reaction for that ? I will never know.
She probably go like “Imma pretend I didn't see that”
Either that or Isabella joined the Flynn-Fletchers on their trip
3.9/10! Yeah, it’s no wonder why it was forgotten especially no one who’s talking about it. (And I was expecting that this it’s one of those sequels.) *Shudders*
11:00 I love how all the cyborgs are all so massive compared to Perry, since in the episodes they usually appear in they are of similar size to him.
Honestly, I would like to see another 2nd Dimension episode in Season 5 or 6.
Well, I remembered both the 2nd Dimension movie and its sequel. I made a Last Day Of Summer fanfic of the 2nd Dimension where Phineas-2D & Ferb-2D betrayed both of their safety, their sister Candace-2D, and the Doofenshmirtz-2D family and tookover the 2nd Dimension Tri-State-Area. Then I made a Candace Flynn fanfic about her 2nd Dimension counterpart needed her advice to bust the 2nd Dimension's Phineas & Ferb
It actually did appear on Disney XD if I remember correctly, because I do remember watching it on TV not DVD
Candance didt fully leave the resistance, as if they ever need her he can still call her
With Doof still on the loose, he could still be planning his revenge, what I'm working on will give it more to go on
Fun fact: This is the ONLY episode where Ferb's furthest eye is smaller in one shot.
A topic for a possible future video: The lost potential of Stacy knowing Perry’s secret identity. I’m sure a few stories coulda been made from that in future episodes.
With what I'm working on, maybe there will be more to it
Oh my god you just revived my memories of seeing this episode like once, thank you.
I now have an extreme desire to rewatch the entire series, too. SHIT-
I remembered the sequel Second Dimension
Well with the reveal that the series will be returning as a continuation series.
It could be possible they might make use of this in that.
Since it wouldn't make sense for them to make Doof evil again after promising his daughter not to be anymore, as well as Candace accepting her brothers as being themselves.
BUT if the other dimension counterparts were to try to take revenge on Main doof, THAT could work.
Oh and of course having it possibly allow for the classic family to be allowed to know about perry,
Maybe involving the other dimension OWCA.
Other things they could end up doing...
Of course build on the whole Professor Time thing they were trying to do in Murphy's Law since THAT was cool.
Maybe even have Charlene end up being in the same area as Doof when their other dimension counterparts show up. This ending up resulting in Main Charlene defending her Ex Husband when her counterpart insults him.
Causing them to start to get back together slowly, which could include Doof asking perry to help him prepare for a makeup date.
12:18 Fun fact: Magnets and many devices don't play well together, as magnets if strong enough can wipe a mobile phone's data. And certain other devices too.
They can't. That's a misconception from the analog and very early digital days.
Candace's first try at flirting was "Hey yourself", what a smooth genius.
I watched it on Netflix. Back in 2016.
7:16 You can tell this was made my Charlene, and not Heinz because its not an inator
14:29 why is there an NFT agent
This episode gave us one of the best songs - "Reasons we pretend to be divorced". I can't believe it's not on Spotify in any form, it's so good!
Congrats on the engagement!
Thank you!!
I remember this episode! I saw it on TV before disney channel got removed here.
i really like the fact that candace still cant handle the fact that she’s free to do anything because she’s lived so long trying to defeat doof and protect her brothers
it just feels realistic
13:21 You didn't mention how she says "But nobody saw it" Man, that is a good reference to deleted scenes. xD
I never relies until now how much the video game Ratchet and Clank Rifts Apart’s story took from Phineas and Ferb Across the Second dimension.
i honestly love how convoluted everything was since it was supposed to show how shows make everything so complicated for no reason
If there was actually a Phineas and Ferb convention, I hope Dan would show up that way I can tell me did a great job at playing one of my favorite villains.
I truthfully only got around to watching it first time a week or so after this video was uploaded. It looked great when I saw sneak peaks but wasn’t interested enough for whatever reason for 8 years.
Now I can say I love it. Just about convoluted enough to make a large amount of world building, showing how there are so much else to be told about this dimension.
Of course the graduation scene(?) has been put into a new and yes a truly convoluted perspective now, and as nice as it was seeing the kids learn to have fun like actual kids, especially seeing them trying to work out which item was used for which sport, would’ve been nice to see rackets or footballs be used agains the borgs or something.
In conclusion, 2nd dimension Dooflene my beloved.