Can Modi 3.0 beat Germany? : Indian economic case study
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 жов 2024
- 👉Leverage Edu is giving away free flight tickets to first 1000 Think Schoolers who start their study abroad journey using the link below
lvrg.in/dCv6W
⭐️ Think School’s flagship Communication course with live doubt sessions :
thethinkschool...
VIDEO INTRODUCTION:
The year is 1945. Hitler had just lost World War 2, and the Soviets, Americans and brits had taken over germany. The war had killed 6 million citizens, Germany was hit by rampant unemployment, major cities like berline and frankfurt had been bombed and 20% of all the housing in germany had been destroyed. And the German currency was in such a bad state that people were using cigarettes as currency instead of the German currency!! And just like Germany, in 1947, when the brits left India, even India was in shatters. 3 million people had died due the Bengal famine, 2 million died due to the partition and 80% of our population was living in poverty!!!
And in the next 70 years, while Germany went on to become the 3rd largest economy in the world, Modi ji has promised Indians that we will beat Germany to become the 3rd largest economy in the world!! But you know what?? We are far far away from Germany!!!
While the unemployment rate in India stands at 8.1%, Germany stands at 3.6% which is one of the lowest in the world, while our per capita income is 2730 dollars, German per capita income stands at 54,000 Dollars and most importantly, in spite of having over 16 times less population than India, while Indian exports stand at 468 billion dollars in 2024, the german exports stand at 1.6 trillion dollars in 2022!!
So if you see even though it looks like our economy is growing at a staggering rate, except for GDP, we are far far far behind in terms of exports, employment and even per capita income!!
And since India is now on its path to become the 3rd largest economy, as citizens of India, our benchmark to judge the BJP should not be congress or pakistan, our benchmark must be derived from legendary countries like Germany, Finland and singapore!! And more importantly, it is our prime responsibility to hold the MODI 3.0 govt accountable by using these benchmarks!!
So in this episode, today, let's dive deep and try to understand,
After the destruction that Germany faced with hitler and World War 2, How did Germany become the 3rd largest economy in the world?
What are the most powerful and revolutionary models of governance that turned Germany into one of the richest nations in the world?
And most importantly, as citizens of India, what are the lessons that we need to learn from Germany to hold the Modi Govt accountable??
Our Best Indian Business Case Studies:
1. Asian paints - • How Asian Paints Built...
2. Amul - • How Amul beat its comp...
3. Haldiram - • How did Haldiram Build...
4. Lijjat Papad - • How 7 Mumbai-based wom...
✅Study Materials:
1. www.chargeurs....
2. www.imf.org/en...
3. mises.org/mise...
Think School is a Digital School that we all deserved, but never had
►►Check out Think School's Online courses: www.thethinksc...
#thinkschool #businesscasestudy #geopolitics #germany #india #modi #economy #education
Credits: CNN-News 18, WION, NBC News, Money control pro, Business standard, TV18,Business Today, ABC news, CNBC, ET now ,Bloomberg originals, Financial Times, DW documentary, AL Jazeera English, BBC news, Firstpost.
👉Leverage Edu is giving away free flight tickets to first 1000 Think Schoolers who start their study abroad journey using the link below
lvrg.in/dCv6W
Honestly speaking, I don't get impressed when some poor country hits the headlines as being the fastest growing economy and such.
This is because, most of this so called growth is just paper growth with little to no real improvement in an average person's average income and standard of living.
Thanks to rapidly growing population, per capita income shows negligible growth.
Despite reporting high gdp growth, several of these poor countries don't have any improvement in basic amenities and infrastructure, don't have any major reforms Implemented, can't stop brain drain, sees worsening social order, sees increasing corruption, sees increasing income inequality, poor social security and don't have any plans for sustaining the high growth.
Average incomes of the people may increase, but the costs increase faster resulting in negligible improvement in purchasing power or savings. Increase in unexpected costs and weakening currency add further fuel to the fire.
There is no improvement in the quality and variety of products and services, education, healthcare and human capital development either.
A lot of these countries are destined to get stuck in the middle income trap and face resource shortages and climate change effects as well. Some of them are doomed to face some economic crisis as well.
Hence, before getting overhyped about a poor country being the world's fastest growing economy, dig deeper and find out whether these underlying issues are getting solved or not. Mere GDP growth does not make a country developed. It involves solving the underlying problems mentioned above as well. These overly long term economic forcasts by corporates and economic think tanks are ridiculous as well.
For an example, people who lived in the US in the 50s or the UAE in the 80s and 90s know what real growth and development is. This real development is not experienced by people who live in these so called fast growing economies.
the Most important thing is to keep Congress away from power. Otherwise, they will let us become a service sector economy, and we won't even get to apply those beautiful ideas in our society. We already wasted lots of our time because of congress.
I wonder where u guys are when congress in power??????? U never questioned when congress in power but bjp which out performs all aspects of india growth compared to congress, U make bjp accountable........
this video shows just how much better is the current govt. that all our previous standards of growth must be redefined and the benchmarks should be the greatest the world has to offer and not the same 1 to 2 % better than last govt.
Hehe you have little idea how Indian b2b business decide. They aren't like Germans opposite of that.
It's insane how many people judge the content of a whole half-hour video with just the Thumbnail, although the thumbnail was a horrendous clickbait.
@@hackermango buddy is spamming in every comment get a life.
@@NasticFool abey aesa nahi hota bhai even jab Putin bharat aaya tha toh PM nahi gaya tha hamara.
Masterclass when 😭😭😭😭
I was about to comment this😅
Well said 💯💯💯
I started watching Thinkschool back in 2021 in India and now I am studying masters in Germany actually this was the best Video on German economic case study. I am proud to consume this from an Indian UA-camr. All the details are true .
he forgot to mention one thing - once you receive the Kurzarbeit money (like during the pandemic), your taxes shoot up, when you are filing your income tax. The government refills its koffers after that. So it's not all sweet. :)
Please come back to Vishwa Guru
is this mocking 😂@@Stallion_1044
Is this something similar to our PF deductions in India?
Bro sarcastically described Pathetic condition of indian youths....❤
I'm a naturalized German citizen now. Came from India 11 years ago to Hamburg. Nice consolidated video about key areas in German society. I would like to add more: Indians as a collective civil society, needs change in mindset like prioritising discipline, integrity, equality and structure-system-rule following. When indians combine their hardworking with disciplined honesty they can go way forward.
considering the election result of 2024, i don't think we indians are ready for a mindset change in the next 10 years. votebank politics is still lingering around caste and the freebies are attracting the rural voters and women. the country may progress the same under nda 3.0 but the best we can achieve is a middle income trap and nothing above that.
@@AdityaRana-hc7ol People mindset are even degrading due to social media algorithms. As they promote content of few influences who support these freebies and cast based division. Demand of reservation is increasing in every part of county as some leaders promoting it by saying 'Jitni abadi utna haq'.
USA invented telephone network, India did better... invented call center scam... 🤣🤣🤣
@@Infinity_000_0 now politics turning from religious appeasement to Gender appeasement. no hope.
99.9% of Indian people's mindset is addicted to fake news and fake praise and this is being exploited well by the government through the media.
Bro literally made every engineer rethink their life for a moment who is an average IT employee.
Well idk but every single engineer in India should be scared of this kind of corporate slavery, but instead, they have romanticized it in a way that there priority have become working under someone rather than becoming a leader and support everyone on the frontline, that's something that can only be changed by changing their mindsets from the rats to the lion's.
wtf are you even trying to say? Your sentence makes no grammatical sense.
True
Sooo true man, especially the final year project wala case 🤣🤣🤣🤣
true
From comparing with Pakistan to comparing with Germany we have came a long way
Best comment
@@harlowidahow much is yours . And how much did you contribute to it
@@harlowidaBhai aata nahi mil raha tujhe tu ab India ke per capita pe baat karega.
Modi govt must realize this too, they seem to bring in Pakistan and compare and feel proud. We didn't go the Pakistan way because of our initial years of laying foundation stones of thousands of institutions. And yet Modi govt blames Nehru for everything. Indian politics is a sham, can't expect anything from them
LOL, most of our population has same thinking and culture as Pakistan. So no point in delusional comparisons. Besides there are at least 5 states in India who have more population than Germany. So not sure how German experience can be replicated here.
Here's a counter argument:
1) Germany works under the framework of EU which is a united body of ALL European nations with open borders and work permits, trade agreements & shared currencies & economic responsibilities. In India's case, we have 2 hostile neighbors who have waged wars against us and continue to do so till this day.
2) Germany's sovereignty & security is guaranteed by NATO or in other words UNITED STATES of America essentially so they do not have to spend big on military hardware of personnel.
In India's case, who is going to rescue us or help us? NOT a single nation will come to help, they have historically helped Pakistan and the same actors will do so again so we are forced to spend more than 3% of our GDP in defense.
3) Germany does not have a dubious & stupid democracy or by product of reservation quotas. They value meritocracy. In India, we cannot imagine doing so. No party has the balls to abolish reservation and bring out meritocracy. We don't just produce morons, we export our bright ones to these same developed nations while retaining the said morons who seek more reservation and freebies.
4) Our education system was willfully kept outdated because the idea is to keep us as servants and slaves. Not leaders or innovators. So the reservation, caste politics and all that bullshit is allowed in the system by design, not by laziness.
If you really are on a mission to educate people and bring change, make a video on what I wrote above. There's a much larger point to make. The points above are in context of Germany, but if you are as bright as I think you are, then you know what I am saying.
Bro has facts💯
To add to 3rd point, even in future if a party came up with a bill abolishing reservations, people won't support it.
TRUTH HAS BEEN SPOKEN 👏👏
Good points. This gives a viewpoint to see the whole picture before judging india.
Ur only valid point is of reservation and that too can't be abolished until we don't have better infrastructure and a good chunk of investment in this sector which is the most underrated thing in our country. U wrote correctly that their idea is to make us slave and for that things, solutions are discussed in this video.
For the rest of ur point, I would say that India needs to better our relations with neighboring countries. Only highlighting the savage reply of our external affair minister won't do much. There is very aptly said quote that u can change ur friends but not neighbors.
This is how an influencer should actually be contributing to the country!! Marvelous content! 👏🎇
This ia a bjp propadanda channel bro😂😂
@@anoopkannan4159average freebies voter
@@anoopkannan4159 sure, let’s assume that’s the case. What’s a good channel then Mr Rathee, Mr Bannerjee? Ganesh raises concerns about high unemployment levels and you think it’s a BJP propaganda seriously? You must be smoking the same thing that Raga is 😄
@@anoopkannan4159 proof becuase anyone who says good about gov then they are BJP propaganda channel you can see his video on tax in India then tell rathee can make this type of neutral videos you dont like that your country is progressing wtf happen to our citizen of our India ...
True 💯
Video I Imagined after seeing thumbnail 🤡🤡
Actual video 🗿🗿
Thank you guys for 1K+ likes❤
Yeah, I thought he would reveal the truth😂
@@maxverstapanfromkerala kid he's indeed showing truth and it's problems if you study in civil servant you will easily understand it
With Modi's image you can easily get more viewers that's why they use in thumbnail
I already consider this channel to be different from politics but now after the last election their focus has been changed
Please remain on your core content
@@mayankpanchal2889 Core is not business so no worry 🤝
@@maxverstapanfromkerala LoL my keyboard ⌨️ changed my word 💀
I am from Germany and agree to most of the points, Quality here is the best, They have education method where you can do Dual Studies, where they pay you and allow to study 3 days in College and work in Company for 3 days. Real time practical study and this is across all sector
Kindly write I am from India, living in Germany. That sounds good.
He could be born in Germany.@@korchageen
Wow, nice
@@korchageen but he is from Germany
USA invented telephone network, India did better... invented call center scam... 🤣🤣🤣
So basically, education is one of the sole reasons holding back India. Great!
I'm a student in Pune, and to be honest what Ganesh bhai has mentioned is absolutely spot on.
Due to pathetic education curriculum🎉, a super motivated person like me has now become a hopeless piece of cr@p, unwilling to do anything the college asks me to.
Guess the college (medical field). 😅
I understand you brother... I myself being an engineer on paper knew this and tried saying this to my teachers and mentors... guess what... I was their arch enemy - sort of a rebel... But I held my peace... And I am thinking of fighting the education system with a group of friends by bringing up an institution of academics outside of this obsolete system of academics
@@JosephK-DaSun0fMorninghey joseph
Been there bro, though I was lucky enough I knew about how pathetic the education practices are and moved on to internet to learn more things and more importantly practice myself however i could. Now I'm a game dev in UK which is Indian's have limited exposure to as their career. I would just say don't let your college define your future. Bit of a funny story, my BE project was roughly based on a game's research paper and my mentor didn't approve it as games weren't considered a project. My father suggested to just replace all mentions of 'game' and change of to 'software/tool' and it got approved :D
@@JosephK-DaSun0fMorning how can we connect ? i am also a person with similar idea .
Nmc made the attendance compulsory instead of relaxing it and is using biometric attendance to avoid proxies.
These are clowns of another level. They will never learn.
Brilliant video. I had the privilege to visit Mittelstand companies as part of my MBA on a study trip. The experience was fabulous. So most students in Germany are not even interested in engineering. They have a program whereby they go to the factory 3-4 days per week and to the university 1-2 days per week for 3-4 years of their undergrad. The syllabus is individually customized FOR EACH STUDENT so they specialise at 1 particular job which is probably the only job of the type in the country. Many Mittelstand employees are also 3rd generation employees as they are big on supporting local community and on continuity.
So, can our NEP 2020, solve this? Are there any case study about NEP?
Not everything that glitters is gold. Such type of over-simulated life and such economic model without disruptive environment may lead to lack of innovation and loss of excitement that uncertainty provides. Add to that, generational employment in same occupation, that's basically caste system bro. It can make them masters in that specific occupation, but it will fail miserably in face of new disruptive technology.
@@jeyarajpitchapillai6510 NEP is nothing, its like applying a bandage on a gunshot wound. We need to reform our education system from the GROUND UP.
Great video! Thanks 🙏
Hello from Europe! We love Indian people here and we're hoping for your improvement! ❤
Don't judge a book by its cover
Don't judge a video by its thumbnail
ANd my friend after watching the video, book turnedbout to be trash too lol😂
The thumbnail was used for the exact reason right ?
The idea behind that is that some book covers are plain or get damaged, this one was exactly what the creator wanted. And it wasn't just the cover but also the title and the intro
Don't judge a government by corruption
@@maxverstapanfromkerala don't judge a man by his comments
Cannot compare India and Germany. Post war Germany (and other European countries) as per Marshall plan got huge amount of Aid and investments. access to western markets to prevent communism from spreading.
India was struggling for atleast next 20 years just to prevent starvation.
Agreed still we can learn a lot from them
And we also had dumb socialist government at that time which really harmed us.
@user-SkmBeats Indian youth believe in khata khat money and no efforts
Germany inspire of war had high literacy rate but not India. Well the saying is true, "one can steal your wealth but not your knowledge "😊
@@prathameshkamble3349 The germans and french also had socialist governments during the same time
I agree 100% to what he has said after completing Bachelor's degree in India, Master's degree in Germany and starting to work in Germany.
my friend forgot the whole backbone of the argument. Germany during and after 2nd world war was still an industrial giant, such that even USSR and US literally brought their scientists to their country for their development. This shows how advance they were already, topped with mega industry that made equipment in the war. While on the contrary, India was LOOTED and made to live under FEMINE ON PURPOSE, were uneducated due to 200 years of slavery. This is where GERMANY had the upperhand, so even after the war, the country was mega hub, while here congress looted to fill their own pockets.
Are we gonna be victims complaining "We were Looted" for another 75 years
@@darknessincarnate138 not victimize but will surely outspeak for corruption that one did.
Thats the difference
@@darknessincarnate138True brother☹️
@@rahilptl639 yeah congress looted another 70 years but now BJP needs to increase budget in education and research and change our education structure and learn from these countries, which they aren't doing,our education minister has become a joke,we should criticize this govt. on this instead of victimization
Also after the first world war France might have won the war but their industry was damaged while German industry was intact and being loser in the war they had lot of debt and restrictions and had to increase their productivity which brought in even more advance capabilities and innovations
My congressi friend sent me this video by watching the thumbnail of it
Khata khat voters ne khata khat video share kar diya Bina video dekhe 😂
He would have been disappointed after watching the video, as modi is not called hitler or dictator in the video.
That's the boundaries of his brain can comprehend as of now. He can't anything beyond paw paw, dictatorship😡. That's all
Nobody sent you this video😂 Just Like this thumbnail this comment is also a click bait
Lol same, typical congress people mentality
We have to educate our people mainly about :
1) Cleanliness - This should be way more prioritised than orhers
2) Integrity
3) Hard work
4) The upper middle class (Who have more than 50 crores property) have to think outside the box. They have to invest/start industries compared to the middle class & poor.
And that's why we need more people like think school who can provide crystal clear situations and not be leftist, centralist or rightist such as druv rathi
Germany was left crumbled after 2nd world war, the war was 3 to 5 years long, before and after that development was there and the people were the same. The British exploited India for 200 long years, the Indian people were not in control of their development, instead British as a ruler gave all the horrific thing like Bengal Famine, Jalliwan wala Bagh Massacre for so long years which left people scarred, the colonial mindset was imprinted on them, to get out of the colonial mindset completely we might need another 2 generation (50 years)
That is all excuses. Even South Korea and Taiwan were exploited by the Japanese Empire. Yet both the countries became wealthy and rich in a few decades. Today South Korea and Taiwan both are doing much better than Japan in a lot of things.
Germany may have been left crumbled after WW2 but they were an industrial power before WW2 and so their experience of that industrialisation helped them recover quickly after WW2. Same with Japan. They were leading industrial powers before WW2.
True they were left crumbled, but the meer amount at which India was exploited it was no match for neither Germany or Japan, they are small countries with very less population. If you compare the loss of life due to WW2 or WW1 in either of the countries, none would be comparable to 1 bengal famines, and there were 3 or 4 major famines during the 200 years and 1 after
True , Our UA-camrs very smart and hide lot truth to suit their agenda… and of the money matters
Germany has it's own problems. Right now it doing ok. But India right now is not doing well. While the economy is doing better the per capital of income of Indians do not break the top 100 countries.
Living in Germany as an Indian with a German spouse has shown me some major cultural differences. Germans are very honest and follow rules even when no one is watching, both at work and on the streets. Indians, on the other hand, often find ways to bend rules, from everyday people to politicians.
Germans also love to read, and their universities are top-notch. In contrast, India's charm lies in its organized chaos. People live in the moment and don’t always plan ahead. Socializing in India is much easier because people are more spontaneous. In Germany, the strict and disciplined lifestyle can sometimes make people forget to have fun.
Comparing India to the US might make more sense since the cultural differences between India and Germany are quite significant and probably won’t ever fully align.
Oh, and by the way, Germany was a powerhouse during WW1 and WW2. They were already super advanced technologically and managed to cause serious damage to the Allied forces despite having fewer people and a smaller land mass. The German Luftwaffe was way more advanced than anything the Allies had. India has a lot of skills to catch up on in that regard.
That's a wonderful insights on the kurzabeit program
@@hackermango yes thumbnail is a bit of a click bait by the way I didn't understand what u just said
Dear Ganesh. I'm particularly impressed with your analysis of the Mittelstand companies of Germany and your explanation about the Kurzarbeit policy. I'm currently working in similar world giant from Germany and can say that it's extremely difficult for India to replicate something like this in the next 10 years. Our effed up education system is literally bleeding our society and the brain drain still continues!! With cheating scams and paper leaks rampant i think our country has a long long way to go. No wonder every single politician's kids are studying either in the US or Germany or some other European country. Modi 3.0 being a coalition government seeing any game changing updates in any field is highly unlikely! Seems like we may altogether miss the opportunity once again! The only stand out point for us as a country is our youthfulness! And maybe that will help us.
Not just Mittelstand, but also the smaller "Familienunternehmen" have better recruiting policies. It all starts with Mindset. As long as one thinks only for himself, there will be no societal improvement.
@@ISmellMusky People needs to support small business.
I have worked in india for 3 years and came to germany last year. After working for 1.5 years here, I can say the biggest difference is the work culture.
I remember carrying a "Made in Germany" pen with confidence as a kid.
I still have one😁
😮
renaluts
Häuser🤌🏻
@@kabyamtalukdar3066 yeah bro i got the same pen while i was giving my JEE Mains exams, first class pen
My communal colleagues shared me the video thinking that they're talking about PM Modi a dictator 😂😂😂
Modi out 2029 for sure. 😂😂
@@SoorajSuseelan10001 I think Tamilnadu will be out not Modi 😂😂😂
@Kshitij-jr6kd Need education in this too.
@daviddiveroli9331 what is communal about sanghi?
@@SoorajSuseelan10001 then India is gone too😊
Excellent case study. Living in Germany, I can confirm that every fact about the work culture and system structure is true. However, you missed mentioning that Indian engineers are highly reputed in Germany and the US, which is only because of our sheer dedication. Imagine retaining such talent in our own motherland; we could definitely create history. Also, in India, our society encourages you to take a safe job, but no one encourages you to become an entrepreneur. This mindset needs to change. Anyways, all the best to all the young talents out there! Jai Hind
bhai tu khud germany rehta kya ghanta history create karega india😂
@@anupgoswami9013 I didn’t say that I would create history I said “we could create a history” it’s a societal effort all our system and work culture needs to change then you can avoid the brain drain☺️
Quite disappointed with clearly intentional use of a misleading thumbnail. Thanks for the excellently researched content though.
Jo bhi thumbnail se mislead hua they deserve to be misled
@@arjavgarg5801🗿
😂 me too.@@hackermango
His very first sentence is wrong. "Excellently researched".
@@jackiecooper9439 your math is wrong. That’s not my first sentence :)
In india if Adani Reliance become india top company means people of opposition criticize Central Govt. Indian need world MNC companies to manage Indian economy 😂
Dont support anyone company, belive in competition. Because Airtel was bad Jio became good for us and ambani became rich. I would envision a new era where none would have to bad for people to innovate.
@@Krishna-pt3yu before itself ambani was rich,
@@Krishna-pt3yu because of ambani
internet is cheap
ask any student preparing for exams like jee,neet,etc
will tell you cheap internet profits
although airtel is also trying to pop up
Not by crony capitalism dear
@@mamtasingh2703Internet is not cheap !!! Many people like me are not even able to afford this 😢
Our PM, UNION MINISTERS,CM, STATE MINISTERS,MPs,MLAs MUST watch this video, if you really care about our country, pls implement
Ganesh Prasad...i give you lot of respect for your knowledge and communication skills. But, i am sure the thumbnail showcasing Hitler and Modiji together is not a mistake. This is by intention. Just to attract people, who are left leaning.
Also, the basic comparison itself of India and Germany is wrong. India has 140cr and Germany has 8cr. Population, hence growing to 54000$ per capita, would be impossible for next 100years, unless we do some miracle ...
But your suggestions are asusual fantastic.
China will cross 54000 in 50 years only.
unless we find oil or gas beds beneath our coast.
Agree with you when it comes to per capita income or other things it's hard to beat many countries... The best we can do is perform our best and grow
PPP per capita is a better measurement
@@Prashant_Pandey4 even then it is impossible to have a per capita income like germany because oil and gas profits are horded by rich few and employs very little.
Literally we the people of India need to understand these contents maturely. This dedication needs to be improvised by each and every citizen of India inorder to"politicalized" either than "REVOLUTIONIZED".
Dude ! You spoke my mind. Great content 👌
Germany recovery is due to Marshall Plan. West Germany to be precise. And second because of industrial nature of german people.
Finally someone said that. It's not just German people, and government, but largely the rivalry between the US and USSR, where Germany and Japan had unique positions.
I think its a bit childish to give all the credit to the Marshall plan the us only provided money worth of goods and services mainly shipping services. U see fam indias problem is not in the shortage of funds but a lack of commitment towards their work
@@anupsingha3071 agreed, it wasn't just the Marshall plan, but that plan and the geopolitical situation played an enormous role in fast recovery and boom of the economy of Germans, and Japanese.
And, as for problem with us (Indians), we know deep inside our minds that there is a huge problem in our mindset, and should acknowledge it, and rectify it. Like US had been built since start on "Entrepreneurship", like those were literal colonies (ventures) by the settles, in the US people ventured out, took big risks, and were not given feebies by the big brother. But our govt, being a more socialist one, didn't care about entrepreneurship, and free enterprise, but distribution of the pie of wealth before it even was baked properly, so our mindsets became that of poor, i.e. laziness and feelings of that nothing is under our control, what can I do, living reactive lives instead of a proactive one.
It is not the Marshall plan. Just count the number of scientists of German descent who have got the Nobel Prize. The education system in Germany is the best in the world and it's completely free. They are responsible and reliable at the work they do. Indians on the other hand try to do the bare minimum and always give out the mediocre output on anything and everything.
No biggest reason was that germany have all the industrial tech and talent which is there due to millitary industrial complex but in case of india we are under foreign occupation for centuries so all knowledge has lost and even people died
Absolutely correct ...Ownership is now on Modi and Nirmala madam ji ..😊Well said bro ...👏👍
Bros liking comments but ignoring 90% of the viewer sentiment
Just for clickbait purposes, the amount of people who'll just scroll past this but subconsciously solidify a certain opinion based on seeing thumbnails like these is a lot & this is just unethical in my opinion
Hoping you get a notif & see this since you liked the above comment, love your vids tho so nothing wrong with that.
This type of the video we really expect from Think School! And also from other youtubers.
Poorly selected thumbnail
It was a bait to scam-gress followers
I think you should focus on the powerful and useful knowledge he shared with us. Rather than thinking about the thumbnail..
Who care about the thumbnail. And why is it irritating u????
It's a good joke. I like it.
This is the best video I have seen in this channel. I have watched at least 30 videos on this channel
just amazing video got to know many things about the difference between india and germany...we cant just get to the third position by talking and big promising , we have to work on ourself and look into our education and skiiled people. This is an eye opener for many who just vote on big talks...🔥🔥🔥🔥
Oh man,,, you hit the ball out of the stadium......😮.... Really a wonderful study. Keep rocking.
First :- Unemployment rate is mostly contributed by UPSC aspirants and other students who wants something more. Second:- Their is no point in comparing GDP per capita as food prices vary a lot , for example :- Rs 100 can buy you Vada pav, Sev puri and other things if you are starving. Third :- In India people are taught to hate rich people, How can anyone increase export if such opposition is faced to create wealth. Blame the Government but also Blame yourself. Don't enter a victim mindset.
I agree with what you said but per capita GDP difference is 50 (2.7k to 52k) times. The price difference can be neglected if it's around 05 times but it's 50 times. We have to work on that and also improve education standards.
You must be living inside a jungle to say that unemployment is mostly contributed by UPSC aspirants. Sure, spending years in the cycle is sheer wastage of time but bro, get your numbers right. Solving the UPSC problem will not have a significant effect on the employment problem. We don't have jobs. That's the problem. Also, jobs should be as per the skillset developed and skillset should be as per industry demands. It is a 2-way street in that sense and we are miserable on both sides.
You are missing one important point. After world war II, Germany and South Korea were given grants (free money) under the Marshall Plan!. India got nothing from UK
Fantastic research and recommendations! Industry and education institutions collaboration is very important! Hope these messages fall into the right ears!
One important point missed here, which can be the topic for next video: Demand problem of India. Most Indians never buy quality products, we always go for cheap ones. Cheap quality products are a lose lose for everyone:
1. Company doesn't make much profits off cheap quality products
2. Customer gets a pathetic product and loses productivity or product fails completely
3. Company can't pay good wages because their income and profit margins are low, so only a few top people in company earn good, rest all are on minimum wage
4. Low quality products become the norm and this degrades quality of life for everyone in the society
5. It's harder to do business and many businesses fail because customer is so much cost concious
6. We are unable to compete globally, this we only export primary goods and IT services. Never good quality products and services
This means very low businesses survive and the quality of jobs is also low, our economic activity is abysmal. Even if we have top notch education, the students won't find matching quality jobs in India in enough numbers and thus go abroad (which has become a craze now)
@@pritishpatil7659 very insightful. I was thinking about the same. How can companies invest so much into creating a good product which will cost twice the average cost of same product in the market? Also even if they invest so much, there is always cheaper knockoffs and we Indians go for it. We Indians need to change our mindset and need to value quality over money and quantity.
But on the other hand, we can be global leaders if we produce good quality products and EXPORT it. There is very less scope for premium products in local market. Education system is also an underrated problem. Also, demonetization weakened Indian local businesses and strengthened all conglomerates. Government needs to understand few Billionaires cannot save the country. Politics aside, everyone needs to understand the importance of education & R&D for a country.
Not true. Low quality don't last long. I don't mind paying more for a very good product.
I agree with you. If you manufacture good quality products, it is hard to sell.
@@msdolly6101981 ur an exception in the Indian market. There are so many people who knew some cheap products are bad for health and still uses it.
Edit: I don't blame them. Circumstances force them.
This content is so relatable. It reminds me of my engineering days, especially the 75 percent attendance and personal grudge part. I have faced It got detained from college for one year.
Amazing work as always Ganesh and team! Thumbnail is catchy😅
Catchy and misleading😅
You perfectly summarised what's wrong with our education.
AGRICULTURE IS BACKBONE OF COUNTRY WE DON'T HAVE TO MOVE , WE CAN FOCUS ON QUALITY AND THEN ON QUANTITY, BOTH ARE VERY IMPORTANT.
This has to be one of your best video 😊
One of best analysis Bro keep it up..
Please also note even struggling Indian parents spent lots of money in kids education this is not the case in majority of europian countries. I live in France, and most of the kids go to government school and universities. I agree the education budget need to be increased, but it can't be calculated only comparing with other countries what shown in GDP number.
Quite relevant and logical examples, I can relate almost everything you said. The examples are so powerful and logical, that makes subject of thumbnail completely irrelevant. All the best Team!!
Donno why people like that Dhruv Rathee his videos are purely pointing out problems and entertainment. This channel is the perfect representation of unbiased and purely logical based analysis and solution for problems . Really hats off to you Ganesh Dada . Also Dhruv thinks spending money on highways is useless which is totally dumbo move brother , you might try to copy exact German model in India but it won't be the same India needs something which suits and works well for it.
I like how the thumbnail changed 3 times. Taking feedback and implementing it is great.
We already lost the battle as quality of our government education system is in 3rd class standards, how can we expect to deliver quality in products we make, if our thinking system is 3 rd class? Don’t get it wrong think about it twice. Germans are strict about timings, rules, delivery and service the value of which they have been taught from young age! We can’t make a full grown tree to bend but a growing tree.
Govt was literally saying that day that entrepreneurs don't need degrees. They aren't serious about improving the education system at all. Look at the paper leaks and education minister.
Who votes for illiterate ministers? Karnataka government came to power promising everything free. 6 months later no money for infrastructure and development, freebies stopped. Scams already started. If people are proper good ministers we get.
@@abhilashreddy9548 when govt was trying to change syllabus and curriculum, when they tried improving the system it's was opposition who just oppose for the sake of opposing.
If any govt trying to do something better u call for strike. Eg. UP govt asked govt school teachers to reach school on time. For the same the installed e-attendance for teachers. And it was the teachers and yadav family who opposed this. Now this might not be visible to u. Right??
@@sobhansarthak6000paper leak ,cmon another corporate labour why can't u change your mindset look how many of u can land a government job why don't u try other means I made around a lakh or more monthly during my 18s as i was working as a content writer. Even looking at the people why would anyone let u enter when u don't have a required skill . About 56% youth takes up science and only 1% goes in RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT most of them just want to be a corporate slave which changed India's population advantage into a mere complaint
@@Tum_Tum_ this very mentality comes from lack of education brother, you lost when you made this issue political by stating it’s some party’s mistake it’s a collective error and biggest blunder from both sides, this happened only because of incompetent uneducated politicians from both sides.
why the hell this photo is being used in thumbnail, ridiculous
For more people to attract
Great that these andhbhakt UA-camrs are being exposed.
Click bait
Clickbait
@@SathyaswamyS wtf weren't you guys the one who compared Modi to Hitler
amazingly informative 🤔🤔, this channel need to be more popular
Yes, 🇮🇳 will reach new heights. Germany and the worst part is many in India I.e. some Indians are very unhappy about India’s rise.
Man what to say! We have teachers who go on strike for petty reasons like marking attendance using bio metrics. We are doomed because of incompetency of government sectors to be honest. We need major revolution of government sectors with highly functioning system that doesn’t require any one to run. In that way we can reduce corruption and disciplinary issues. Until then we are doomed to be mediocre 😢
This was an amazing video, a lot of things to consider,
This is why the manufacturing sector is a deal breaker, and with regards to education its the last thing on the minds of leaders as an educated population leads to self governance and therefore cannot be fooled.
Solution : Gurukul
Disclaimer: Don't underestimate, Bharat was Golden Bird Because of this
Great content!
I am student at TUM and i can confirm it to a certain point.
Meaning there are many ties with great companies,but the professors and the companies hold you to a higher standard and indian students find it hard here.
Love the video bro keep making them.
Why are u using photo of hitler for Germany??? This is ridiculous
Bro chill, watch the video, then say whatever you like.
It's a bad choice. Very bad. Creator clearly doesn't understand history.
🫵🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I think you should focus on the powerful and useful knowledge he shared with us. Rather than thinking about the thumbnail..
Who care about the thumbnail. And why is it irritating u????
@@YogiLogicit's a GREAT choice actually. Only you believe it's bad no doubt due to false education about what really happened. HINT: The roles in real life were actually reversed. The so called innocent eternal victims are actually the criminals now and back then . Just look at Gaza. They can do absolutely anything they want to and then lie to the public . The people you think were bad in WW2 were actually very good 👍 and fighting to remove a cancer
Instead of thinking about Beating Germany, Praise them for bringing such technologies in the world which has caused betterment of all sectors, and learn from them.
If there is anybody here who is from a political background or the people working in the Government itself, they would better take these suggestions to the higher officials to bring them into action.
Specialized manufacturing of one product reminds me of tradesmen of India who were recognized with their Jati. I always said to my friends, that by destroying the Jati system in India, They/We have actually destroyed the skills that once made India the Industrial hub. The skillsets that were passed from generation to generation got lost in adapting to British education.
It was a blessing that the Britishers came India and put all the so called upper jati people at there place and taught them a lesson.
India was a dark clouded place. The Brits even though for their self interest and loot was a big help for the country.
Also I would suggest you to do manual labor and continue doing that for generations instead of giving lectures
@@SoorajSuseelan10001yeah because lower caste didn't suffer at all from British
Only the higher caste died in the 28 million people that died in Bengal because of starvation.
Right?
This simply helped me to realize what really education means for one's life and for a country to be a great nation.
Now since he is making videos on the PM "Some People" will call him an "andhbhakth"
This proves these anti-nationalist British Khangress party is anti-hindu too.
When the politicians irrespective of party leaving their ego join hands to develop the education system it automatically leads to better employment and economy automatically improves .
If they do reverse policys just for political gain the country growth will be stagnant
BRILLIANT!!
bro wtf is that thumbnail? what are you implying
Majority of people are ❄️ is what he is implying.
@@hackermangoJesus Christ, stop spamming.
I think you should focus on the powerful and useful knowledge he shared with us. Rather than thinking about the thumbnail..
Who care about the thumbnail. And why is it irritating u????
It's a joke. I like it. and will request him and support him to use more of such thumbnails.
Yes with a country 140 crore people should be able to generate more wealth than a country of 8 crore people.
population shouldn't matter in most cases, what matters is the education and skills, with good education even a country with 5 million people can be more productive than a country with 50 million.
Nicely crafted material, very good focus on the topic, very thoughtful to do counter questions why something works, and why something doesn't.
Very nice work. Keep up your good work Ganesh..
If you wanna compare two countries, just compare the top 6 cities gdp ppp.
Indian cricket team is defined by the caliber of the playing 11, not by 1.3 billion people.
Indian tier 1 cities are actually higher in gdp ppp than German tier 1 cities.
Only if we didn't have to spend on defence like Germany. Just being part of EU uplifts you. Not a fair competition.
Funds is not the issue here they gave 800crore for a bridge 💀
India is larger than the entire EU. Each of our states are equivalent or more in terms of population to a European country.
@@anibeto7well we don't have a protector like usa who will fund our defences and also we don't have peaceful neighbours like europe
@@adityapatil2644 Okay.. Polulation of North America and Europe combined is less than that of India. If an individual Indian can truly add value to the world then it is pretty much possible.
The problem is, Indians docnot have the scientific and artistic temper today. Europeans became successful because they cultivated the scientific temper, created art and business. Indian politicians have failed India hard. Kar to vo bohot kuch sakte hain, par karenge nehi.
No it doesn't. Germany is an occupied colony of the US regime and has the highest concentration of US regime troops after Japan. And that is why Germany has to participate in all the wars and sanctions that the USA regime asks them to do. and result is German economy has been declining in the last 2 years and is getting deindustrialised.
Being an Indian student studying at TUM, this video is spot on. Indian education system needs to come a long, long way to even come close to Germany in this regards.
Bro, I didn't expect this from you. I am an avid watcher of your videos, but this thumbnail makes me wanna question that
I think you should focus on the powerful and useful knowledge he shared with us. Rather than thinking about the thumbnail..
Who care about the thumbnail. And why is it irritating u????
@@Joebiiden hey sleepy joe. How are you
@@GeniusAjinkyaI don't get it why everyone is saying something is wrong with thumbnail please tell me what is it I don't get it?
@@FromA80 he changed the thumbnail. Earlier he put Hitler photo in it
@@GeniusAjinkya just Hit"/r or both modi and hit"/r
Ganesh prasad to dhoti khol raha hai engineering professor and curriculum ki 😅 recently I completed my engineering from pune university
great video brother. keep pointing out what actually matters for the society.
Loved when this used to be a business channel You guys should create a separate channel for your political content
This isn't politcal and think school's content was not just bussiness orieinted, i beliieve it comes under economics so these types of videos should belong here.
Did watch his old video, he explained politics and geopolitical is foundation of good strategy
without politics and government interventions , bussiness can't spur , Infact economics itself is understanding people choices and decisions , so politics , policy are as important for bussiness than technology or finance is .
Economics and politics go hand in hands. No exceptions. That is why all economists have political allegiances too whether left or right
politics is business
The education system is really a 🤡. Foreign universities are rated high due to the research involved, result is necessary but secondary
This is essential for exploring new things, that's why we hardly see any great research papers from India whereas some of the other country universities do it very regularly
@@technofete education system in India is the most ironical name I have ever heard coz it miss both the things education and system.
It's problem of Indian students too,
As there is hardly any crowd in conferences but huge crowds in fests!
@@abhimanyusolanki6822 that is because that type of learning is not inculcated from a young age. Basically our own Indian system of gurukul which was focused on learning is not implemented 😐
I'm a citizen of Singapore.
Thanks so much to this channel.
I would like to add that german has worked on building expressway , waterways which has reduced transportation cost.
2) in india there are people who abuse ambani , adani , tata . And say that tax on them should be high
3) in india people are apposing new port building in india . Saying it will harm environment .
4) in india people are cost centric and not quality centric
5) Germany provide cheap nuclear , wind , solar , energy
6) all europian country are rich. With people earning good money so they can buy German goods
7) all eu countries have policy and can send goods cheap with no restriction almost
Comparing Germany to India is like comparing OLED to CRT.
Our country is diverse in every aspects.. and at present scenario and in future Germany can't beat us..our graphs may be lower..it's because of largest number of population..
@@DRACULA_KING_ Germany can't beat us only in one metric. Population.
Inferiority complex@@PunyHulk
our country is better in many aspects unfortunatley we cant see it
@@Vimal227 It's realisation complex. Population is both our strength, as well as our weakness. There's nothing inferior in it.
Well done. I appreciate and totally agree with you. Keep it up.
Can you please remove the picture from thumbnail, it is very offensive!
Thank You
❄️
You find History Offensive?
Yeah I agree Hitler shouldn't be Thumbnail it should be Olaf😂
No
@@ChandranPrema123is this any video based on history?
@@ChandranPrema123 history always written by winners pen and power
Don't fall for propaganda
This video is gem and masterpiece for government, entrepreneur and students.
WTF is the thumbnail
Clickbait for the leftists.
I think you should focus on the powerful and useful knowledge he shared with us. Rather than thinking about the thumbnail..
Who care about the thumbnail. And why is it irritating u????
It's a joke. I like it. and will request him and support him to use more of such thumbnails.
*Boycott of Peacefuls should be permanent. Only temporary as a reaction will achieve nothing. We should calculate 1 years impact of economic boycott and from this consider the effect of it in next 10-20-50-100 years which will be tremendous.*
*Just like any other habit it will require deliberate conscious efforts for first few months/years until you get used to it. Your few months/years efforts to make this habit part of your life will have enormous contribution to ensure their complete economic destruction and unsustainability. This habit should be made as a part of our culture and maintained generation after generation.*
*Every aware hindu in their life needs to convince atleast 10 hindu houses to boycott them permanently.*
Peacefuls?
India may not have quality engineers as excellent as Germans, but we do have chapris like you who are as good as Pakistani radicals that can turn this nation into the next Pakistan.
What a great high quality video 🙂🙂🙂🙂 hats off to you man 💯💯💯💯
Thumbnail will boom the views
It's sad; these UA-camrs are worse than red-light Steeet girls. 😂
No he is not! @@Raj_1201
@@Raj_1201nah man
@@Raj_1201 They are not , they adapt to the youtube algorithim
clickbait videos can be used very usefully
It's a joke. I like it. and will request him and support him to use more of such thumbnails.
Bro you need to relax with the thumbnail
I think you should focus on the powerful and useful knowledge he shared with us. Rather than thinking about the thumbnail..
Who care about the thumbnail. And why is it irritating u????
focus on the content, not on thumbnail
Awesome as always
Just remove the thumbnail
I think you should focus on the powerful and useful knowledge he shared with us. Rather than thinking about the thumbnail..
Who care about the thumbnail. And why is it irritating u????
It's a joke. I like it. and will request him and support him to use more of such thumbnails.
@@Yogis_BitterTruth_Nirvan and why did you need to post this
What a great content ❤❤❤ just amazed… our education system should be reformed in various aspects😊
This is a mind boggling video.. Thanks for the great content.
Great explanation. Highly appreciated!!