Almost no rugby players have been confirmed as having CTE, whereas hundreds of American Football players have. That should speak about just how hard the hits are.
GusBusGaming rugby players hit much softer considering they do not have pads whereas football players completely lay themselves out with the mentality they cannot get hurt as much because they have pads on. Rugby is much more technical with their hits, because they do not want to get injured when they perform a tackle therefore softer than football.
Matthew Mahala I see it more as because rugby players aren't as big and most of them don't try to tackle each other (it's more strategic in terms of who to tackle and when), there was never a need for protective clothing, whereas you have concussions every single game regardless of protection in the NFL. I've never heard of players having that mindset, I've never heard of players thinking they're invincible from the shoulder and knee pads...
I love both Rugby and NFL but OC is straight wrong. Neither is softer than the other. NFL is more explosive and focuses more on strength and intense bursts of speed or flying into a tackle at maximum speed thats why they need pads. Rugby is more endurance and skill based yet can also produce some incredibly hard hits. Rugby is alot more fast paced action and NFL is stop start because it needs to be. You just can't carry that much muscle mass and expect to last for more than 2 minutes running time. Yet you see bits of everything in both sports though. Much respect too people who play either professionaly
Sdmn Fc Fantasy football league: Qb: Josh- Andrew Luck Rb: JJ- Adrian Peterson Fb: Ethan- Patrick DiMarco Wr: Simon- Dez Wr: Manny- AB Wr: Tobi- Obj Te: Vikk- Jason Witten K: Harry- Dan Bailey Defense line: SDMN Fc- Broncos D
These comments are so butthurt after the rugby comment lmao. The "pads" that NFL players use are used as weapons more than they are used for protection. Not only do they increase the strength of the hits, but since the players have these pads they never hold back with the hits. The NFL hits are way stronger than Rugby hits, and it's not even close
Of course there are harder hits if you have all that gear around you. Why not just jump in a car - then you can hit really hard! It's like how professional boxers don't have to worry about their own hands unlike bareknuckle boxers. Rugby takes so much more intelligence than handegg, and it's not even close.
that's the problem with football the players don't want to hold back the strength of the hits that's why there are so many concussions and injuries in football
The people in the comments are so dumb. Do your research before you start an argument. Pads are actually used more as a weapon during tackles, not protection. NFL play are generally bigger than rugby players too
There have been studies done that show the average nfl hit is harder than professional rugby. The pads trick your mind into thinking you can't get hurt, and that mentality allows them to hit harder.
Not a fan of NFL or rugby, but I'd say the hits are harder in the NFL. Both are rough and dangerous sports, but I'd feel safer playing rugby than I would American Football.
Yeah I realise that. I know there's rugby players that are just as fast as the NFL players but the hits in the NFL seem a lot more head on. It would be fun to watch if it was continuous play, rather than throw the ball and strategise with the manager for 10 minutes.
Even though they wear pads the force exerted on their body will be 3 times more powerful compared to rugby, and all that kinetic energy can't just disappear, it has to go somewhere (into the player). So technically American football hits a lot harder. But rugby has a lot more cardio. End of story
To be fair I love both rugby and NFL but sorry I think NFL is much more violent and harder as the pads don't protect you they are more like weapons and stoping and starting means they go all out at every play sorry rugby ( I am English )
a rugby player in american football would be the best american football player in the world, they are stronger. But I love both sports, and im not ofended of the comment in the video
NFL players wear pads for protection, but the same pads also allow them to hit with 100% power and not worry about getting injured. I play football and rugby and I can tell you that football hits are generally harder (not every single hit but on average) than rugby hits.
No they have to wear padding because back in the day when they wouldn’t wear helmet and padding people would get hurt almost every play and some people died from the sport
@@isaiahrosario7293 They used to die because they didn't have the technique that rugby players have, and they ran through without caring about anything at all, that caused them the death or any other strong lessions.
Rugby is soft? Rugby players don't wear pads, giant hard helmets, don't have a long break every 5 seconds, don't have big fancy stadiums with soft grass. American football is soft.
Our rules are different, we hit eachother much harder in American football. If you went to a game you could hear the clang of the helmets all the way up in the sands
But compare the protection between rugby and American football Rugby: scrum cap, gum shield, thin body armour and all of that is optional Football: a lot of pads that are compulsory
I love all the Rugby fans who think Rugby is better just because they don't wear pads. In my opinion that just makes them stupider for risking injury instead of protecting yourself.
Hristo To say that to me I've played for 8 years and have had 3 concussions plus 4 broken bones a fractured shoulder and a kid stomped on my ribs with his cleats
If NFL players didn't wear pads and hit like they do, the compression on the chest would 3x as much as the human body could take... so every hit you could practically die
football is tough but I'm sorry rugby is much more hard hits than football rugby in muscle on muscle where football is pad on pad yea it's still hard but rugby it's definitely more physical
have u played rugby no and if u say yes then it just means u scared because when I tackle some one I hit as hard as possible and if someone tries to tackle me I run as hard as possible sorry but new Zealand and south Africa will break any football team
I'm not saying, rugby players don't hit hard. I'm sure they do, it's part of their sport. What I am really saying is Football players with pads on will have kind of this mental edge, feeling sort of invincible. So they tend to put they're body on line, that's why theirs so many gruesome injuries in football. Most of the time in rugby I've seen there is a lot of technique into tackling, and I'm not saying football doesn't have tackling technique, but with pads you can make such crazy and powerful tackles you don't need technique some times.
He would get flattened by a rugby player ahaha, I don't even particularly like rugby but the difference is shown by the body armour both sports wear, rugby players wear a gun shield and that's it, American footballer wear a full body armour 😂😂
I have played both sports, american football and rugby at the same levels and i can say that football hits harder cause of the protections but you dont even feel pain in the impact most of the times and of course most people dont have any kind of technique while doing a tackle. On the other hand, while playing rugby you tackle a lot more and get tackle a lot more, and of course, impacts hurt more cause it is muscle vs muscle I my opinion playing football is more complex cause all the plays, routes, etc, but rugby is thougher and more demanding in terms of stammina And of course, I dont take seriously the comments of people who compare the two sports without having play both, so relax
You don't THROW them you grab them to the floor. I play both rugby and football and watch both sports, and I said that both sports hit hard but in terms of how often it's football.
Would love to see KSI try and take on JJ Watt
Watt would destroy him
he would kill ksi
Zac#TRUMP2
Watt would break him
There would be no more KSI
3:55 I think I've seen JJ Watt tackle like that.
lol
H TOWN!!
He probably doesn't even know who JJ Watt is
If they did a tackling contest 😂
@@hollows7224 rip
He definitely doesn’t
he should have brought him out
I wanna see Ksi play football then tea bag anyone who got tackled even if they were on his team
Gddhddhdhdhddhd jkdhddddhddhdv dhdddddhdhddhddh jhdhddhddhdhd
I don't think he knows who JJ Watt is LOL
4:10 I thought you guys were going to bring JJ Watt out lmao.
Almost no rugby players have been confirmed as having CTE, whereas hundreds of American Football players have. That should speak about just how hard the hits are.
GusBusGaming rugby players hit much softer considering they do not have pads whereas football players completely lay themselves out with the mentality they cannot get hurt as much because they have pads on. Rugby is much more technical with their hits, because they do not want to get injured when they perform a tackle therefore softer than football.
H
Matthew Mahala I see it more as because rugby players aren't as big and most of them don't try to tackle each other (it's more strategic in terms of who to tackle and when), there was never a need for protective clothing, whereas you have concussions every single game regardless of protection in the NFL. I've never heard of players having that mindset, I've never heard of players thinking they're invincible from the shoulder and knee pads...
GusBusGaming sick
I love both Rugby and NFL but OC is straight wrong. Neither is softer than the other. NFL is more explosive and focuses more on strength and intense bursts of speed or flying into a tackle at maximum speed thats why they need pads. Rugby is more endurance and skill based yet can also produce some incredibly hard hits. Rugby is alot more fast paced action and NFL is stop start because it needs to be. You just can't carry that much muscle mass and expect to last for more than 2 minutes running time. Yet you see bits of everything in both sports though. Much respect too people who play either professionaly
Lol the amount of banter from Osi xD
Poor Manny
i want to see jj try and tackle jj watt
JJ would just bounce off or break his own shoulder
ya
Ddfgghhhhgcc cvs
Not happening
FrostGaming fr 😂
DANG THAT WAS CRAZY LOVE IT AWESOME COOL VIDEO!?!??
JJs face when osi told him he was gonna tackle him hahaha
Why would you say JJ watt! He is a monster
This is amazing great job man
And NFL player played rugby league and after 1 game he said that is to hard and hurts to much so we he's chatting bare waffle
Yo what are you saying dawg
F B I it’s proof rugby players have no brain cells lol
True but he was talking about union not league
Sdmn Fc Fantasy football league:
Qb: Josh- Andrew Luck
Rb: JJ- Adrian Peterson
Fb: Ethan- Patrick DiMarco
Wr: Simon- Dez
Wr: Manny- AB
Wr: Tobi- Obj
Te: Vikk- Jason Witten
K: Harry- Dan Bailey
Defense line: SDMN Fc- Broncos D
Rugby is much better maybe not as physical but way more fun
Would've been so funny if jj watt really came out
love oc to say that to James Haskell
JJ playing football/in a football outfit 😍
These comments are so butthurt after the rugby comment lmao. The "pads" that NFL players use are used as weapons more than they are used for protection. Not only do they increase the strength of the hits, but since the players have these pads they never hold back with the hits. The NFL hits are way stronger than Rugby hits, and it's not even close
never thought of that but true
yes but they are more tackles in rugby which means, both are tough sport
Of course there are harder hits if you have all that gear around you. Why not just jump in a car - then you can hit really hard! It's like how professional boxers don't have to worry about their own hands unlike bareknuckle boxers. Rugby takes so much more intelligence than handegg, and it's not even close.
that's the problem with football the players don't want to hold back the strength of the hits that's why there are so many concussions and injuries in football
Ddd
"JJ Nott"
-Osi, 2016
The people in the comments are so dumb. Do your research before you start an argument. Pads are actually used more as a weapon during tackles, not protection. NFL play are generally bigger than rugby players too
For all you kids that think that the nfl is soft, look up nfl big hits
Look up Courtney lawes big hits…
I enjoy the nfl and im a seahawks fan but rugby is more hard because you dont wear any protection to reduce the hits
Rugby big hits are just as bad if not worse
There have been studies done that show the average nfl hit is harder than professional rugby. The pads trick your mind into thinking you can't get hurt, and that mentality allows them to hit harder.
Football hits are nearly 3× harder than rugby hits. Search up the sports science on it
HAHAHAHAH OSI IS cool he SEEMS AWESOME COOL VIDEO GREAT ?!?!? LOVE IT AMAZING!?!
at 1:41 Ksi had something else on his mind
Not a fan of NFL or rugby, but I'd say the hits are harder in the NFL. Both are rough and dangerous sports, but I'd feel safer playing rugby than I would American Football.
the reason the hits are harder is because they have pads, it allows them to tackle with more power
Yeah I realise that. I know there's rugby players that are just as fast as the NFL players but the hits in the NFL seem a lot more head on. It would be fun to watch if it was continuous play, rather than throw the ball and strategise with the manager for 10 minutes.
Scoobay i guess you can run faster in rugby because you dont have pads
I would as well, only because the nfl doesn't have anything saying you can't get tackled on the head and snap your neck
Even though they wear pads the force exerted on their body will be 3 times more powerful compared to rugby, and all that kinetic energy can't just disappear, it has to go somewhere (into the player). So technically American football hits a lot harder. But rugby has a lot more cardio. End of story
the way you tackled number 99 was so funny 😂😂
How people are getting butthurt over rugby, I play rugby myself and it's alot more softer than the NFL and that's why they have "so much padding"
If you think that rugby has bigger hits than look up NFL big hits
"Rugby is the toughest sport on the planet in terms of physicality" Dwayne Johnson
Rugby is worse cause u don't have protection
To be fair I love both rugby and NFL but sorry I think NFL is much more violent and harder as the pads don't protect you they are more like weapons and stoping and starting means they go all out at every play sorry rugby ( I am English )
osi is a savage
I want see Ksi take on the real JJ watt
Spitting pure fire
I would rather get hit my 20 rugby players at once ten times than get tackled by jj watt once
cole chit æ
cole chit JJ Watt
cole chit to
cole chit I have to agree with u there
I'm not scared of KSI
I love how jj has that face when he's about to take that yellow thing down..
if you are reading this have a nice day
Das just cold R I P manny
a rugby player in american football would be the best american football player in the world, they are stronger. But I love both sports, and im not ofended of the comment in the video
Nah
JJ used his head the first one. 😂
Rugby is not soft
Haskell vs Osi!!
NFL players wear protection rugby players don't. that's all that needs to be said
NFL players wear pads for protection, but the same pads also allow them to hit with 100% power and not worry about getting injured. I play football and rugby and I can tell you that football hits are generally harder (not every single hit but on average) than rugby hits.
Like how can you be serious its not for protection everyone uses pads as a weapon
@itsburntm
“Rugby’s soft” but we don’t we’re a a hole house for padding
yeah but high tackles are illegal in rugby but not gridiron
xd MadMelon4 that’s cause we don’t we’re padding
Ever heard of Courtney Laws? 😂
Sam Tai 👌😂
Ever heard of Jona Lomu
The real JJ Watts would destroy him completely
ohh this was before jj cut all his hair off
JJ TAKES THE /NFL PERSON DOWN!!!!!!
DO A VIDEO WITH J.J. WATT
The way he described tackling is just like rugby
Nfl is much better than rugby by 100000000000000 and nfl is stronger
U
your name is Australian patriot yet you reckon NFL is better wtf hahhaha
dis guy just gave the bag a concussion
I love how he said rugby is soft when every player wears padding and a helmet....yep rugby’s soft
No they have to wear padding because back in the day when they wouldn’t wear helmet and padding people would get hurt almost every play and some people died from the sport
@@isaiahrosario7293 They used to die because they didn't have the technique that rugby players have, and they ran through without caring about anything at all, that caused them the death or any other strong lessions.
Cuz if u play American football without pads...so many people have died
NFL has 15 rules that’s why they wear pads
Have you heard of cte that no rugby players dont get and nfl players get look cte up on google
Rugby is soft?
Rugby players don't wear pads, giant hard helmets, don't have a long break every 5 seconds, don't have big fancy stadiums with soft grass.
American football is soft.
Holly Wilkins try getting hit by JJ watt and tell me its soft
Rugby isn't soft, the players don't wear a ton of pads
That has nothing to do with it players get concussions every damn game look up the injury count it's bad
For football
+Weston Thunder rugby players get high tackles and they don't wear helmets like they do
did this guy call this rugby hold this L
+Alex Midgley he said rugbys soft buddy
Rugby is way better then nfl because it's a gentlemen sport and its controlled but American football is so uncontrolled even tho I like nfl
If that bag was jj watt it would go go the other way.
do ice hockey next
man just said rugby is soft
The end got me laughing so hard
Rugby soft we use no padding and nfl wear full padding with helmets
Because we actually die playing football and that's with using padding and even more died with no padding and we have a higher risk of cte.
Our rules are different, we hit eachother much harder in American football. If you went to a game you could hear the clang of the helmets all the way up in the sands
Yeah KSI is “definitely” the biggest UA-camr
Biggest UA-camr in the World, I dont think so Fam
honestly rugby isnt softer, but safer.
But compare the protection between rugby and American football
Rugby: scrum cap, gum shield, thin body armour and all of that is optional
Football: a lot of pads that are compulsory
Football is the sport with the most restrictions yet it has the most injuries so...
thats why its harder then rugby m8
If nfl players didn't wear pads, they could literally die from being hit
jjf
hi
KSI would be a beast at football
That final touchdown was so fake
Both rugby and American football have huge hits trust me I watch both a lot
rugby is softer than football for sure
Honestly I still can't get over his hair😂😂
I love all the Rugby fans who think Rugby is better just because they don't wear pads. In my opinion that just makes them stupider for risking injury instead of protecting yourself.
I mean i Play Football and pads are really used as weapons not as protection
Not really and I play football
Fastrocket37 football is for pussys
lmao
Hristo To say that to me I've played for 8 years and have had 3 concussions plus 4 broken bones a fractured shoulder and a kid stomped on my ribs with his cleats
OSI!!!! Ssh up man
If NFL players didn't wear pads and hit like they do, the compression on the chest would 3x as much as the human body could take... so every hit you could practically die
He destroyed it with his hair
football is tough but I'm sorry rugby is much more hard hits than football rugby in muscle on muscle where football is pad on pad yea it's still hard but rugby it's definitely more physical
Guys with pads on will tackle much harder and aggressive than guys who don't have pads on simple as that.
have u played rugby no and if u say yes then it just means u scared because when I tackle some one I hit as hard as possible and if someone tries to tackle me I run as hard as possible sorry but new Zealand and south Africa will break any football team
simple as that
+Jaydon Jones you obviously haven't played football, and if you say you did then you didn't hit or get hit hard
I'm not saying, rugby players don't hit hard. I'm sure they do, it's part of their sport. What I am really saying is Football players with pads on will have kind of this mental edge, feeling sort of invincible. So they tend to put they're body on line, that's why theirs so many gruesome injuries in football. Most of the time in rugby I've seen there is a lot of technique into tackling, and I'm not saying football doesn't have tackling technique, but with pads you can make such crazy and powerful tackles you don't need technique some times.
I would like JJ being in the NFL, it will be very entertaining
rugby is soft,
u dont wear pads for rugby
His gurdle was sideways 😂😂
osi is right rugby is for the weak
He would get flattened by a rugby player ahaha, I don't even particularly like rugby but the difference is shown by the body armour both sports wear, rugby players wear a gun shield and that's it, American footballer wear a full body armour 😂😂
Rugby players are soft? 😂😂😅 Hahaha nice joke.
I have played both sports, american football and rugby at the same levels and i can say that football hits harder cause of the protections but you dont even feel pain in the impact most of the times and of course most people dont have any kind of technique while doing a tackle. On the other hand, while playing rugby you tackle a lot more and get tackle a lot more, and of course, impacts hurt more cause it is muscle vs muscle
I my opinion playing football is more complex cause all the plays, routes, etc, but rugby is thougher and more demanding in terms of stammina
And of course, I dont take seriously the comments of people who compare the two sports without having play both, so relax
I don't even think he knows who J.J. Watt is!
1st tackle he looked like he head butted it
I Like willies in my bottom
I smell butthurt
*pads hitting against the body
people get paralyzed all the time in American football the tackles are so much harder look up tackle highlights and you'll see why people wear padding
rugby you through people to ground by their neck.
You don't THROW them you grab them to the floor. I play both rugby and football and watch both sports, and I said that both sports hit hard but in terms of how often it's football.
I like how he compares home self jj watt
maybe he should try and beat a rugby player.
he would easily
Thomas Bain lmao u dumb af. Nfl is way more dangerous
Thomas Harvey maybe u should try to beat an NFL player
He definitely know tackling because he's done it to Vikk so many times
JJ not 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
He says that when you all have a ton of armour on and we have a gun shield
i want all the people that say rugby is more physical than football to actually play in a football game😂
You think that ruby Is soft take off all that amour and we'll see I'm only eleven and I play contact and you guys wear pads.
lol i play both and they are both though but rugby is a little tougher
Fen4on Hutt if you did you would break a bone it should on sports sceince the strongest linebackers hit can break a door
Football is tougher those pads are like brick walls
Luis Mendez I've played in a game and it's difficult like really difficult but then so is rugby so why does everyone care
"Rugby's soft"
Me:"it's harder than American football
Everyone who is american is gonna say NFL is tougher and then almost everyone else on the planet is gonna say rugby is tougher
BOSSOTRON666 no one plays rugby
OSI isn't not from america.
BOSSOTRON666 not quite
It's called a bias, man. For both sides.
Jarky think ur wrong u got 13 likes :/
Who came here after ksi extreme sports nfl?
LOOOOOOOOOL
THE BAGS NAME WAS RICEGUM
The real jj watt is 6foot 5 and 295lb
Jordan Lawrence Ksi really compared himself to the best DE in the game.... what a joke
shots fired