Living Sin by ELP (An International Collaboration)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 99

  • @massimomarchesin8708
    @massimomarchesin8708 4 роки тому +1

    GREAT PERFORMANCE BY EL&P COVER !!!! From The album TRILOGY !!!!! Living Sin !!!! Congratulations !!!!! Very good job Ok !!!!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  4 роки тому

      Thank you, Massimo!

  • @ReitFans
    @ReitFans 10 років тому +8

    Absolutely amazing talented musicians. Incredible & Awesome collaboration!!!!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому

      Thank you, Sir!

  • @DearbornJohn
    @DearbornJohn 9 років тому +1

    Bravo! One of my ELP favorites also, Mihaly did a great job on the keys.

    • @17drums
      @17drums  9 років тому

      ***** Thanks, John. Misi, (Mihaly) is brilliant on the keys. It's been my great fortune to do these collaborations with him. I finally get to play in an ELP band, wherein the keyboard player actually cuts Keith Emerson!

  • @simonfuller6194
    @simonfuller6194 9 років тому +6

    Well done guys, keep em coming !!!!!!! Love your covers !!!!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  9 років тому

      +simon fuller Thanks so much from all of us!

    • @simonfuller6194
      @simonfuller6194 9 років тому

      +17drums You're welcome. Greetings from the Harz Mountains Germany :-)

    • @17drums
      @17drums  9 років тому +1

      Greetings back at you from Hungary, and the U.S.

  • @attiliobastosguarnieri5416
    @attiliobastosguarnieri5416 3 роки тому +1

    Ok. Vocês conseguiram mais uma vez !! ! !!
    Excelente.

    • @17drums
      @17drums  3 роки тому +1

      Muito obrigado por todos nós!

  • @TheCheez2112
    @TheCheez2112 10 років тому +2

    Great cover guys ! And seeing/hearing Len doing these vocals was an extra pleasant surprise !

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому +1

      Thanks, Cees. Yeah, Len did a superb job splitting his personality (and vocals) into Evil Len, and Good Len!

  • @tinman3012
    @tinman3012 10 років тому +1

    Nothing short of incredible on this collab! You all must have spent countless hours rehearsing this baby. Great job Dave and everyone!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому

      Thanks, Ron! We had finished the musical parts of this awhile back, but had trouble finding a singer who would take on these wide-ranging vocals. Len came up with a great solution, and saved the project.

  • @rushyeskansas
    @rushyeskansas 10 років тому +2

    Wow Dave, this was excellent from every point of view. Brilliant team for covering one of the most exceptional bands ever. Not an easy job, but you guys made it ... Misi's hammond sound is just perfect, his playing not less than that. Drums as precise as usual and true to the original, bravo my friend. Rock solid bass work and last not least ... it`s nice to finally see the dark side of Len .... awesome vocals!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому +1

      Thanks Rich, from ALL of us! I still can't believe how lucky I am, to drum for these guys. Never had this level of top-notch talent all squeezed into my neighborhood, (or within reasonable traveling distance), growing up in the old band days. So it's a dream come true to be in a band, (however virtual), with them now. I really am a 'Lucky Man'!

  • @amccann7
    @amccann7 10 років тому +1

    This is Brilliant! Great to see you all, and you sound AMAZING!!!!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому

      Thanks so much, Amy!

  • @victorcoral
    @victorcoral 9 років тому +2

    my brother in law who is a very gifted guitarist used to play the organ part re-arranged for guitar just for fun. A few years later when I had the chops to do it I taught it to myself by ear. Quite a challenge, but so much fun !!! :):) ... since the bass is playing unison 2 octaves below to the organ then that was what I did, only on thinner strings (easier ! )

    • @17drums
      @17drums  9 років тому

      +Victor Coral This is an often over-looked piece by ELP. The drumming is also quite fun on it. Thanks!

    • @victorcoral
      @victorcoral 8 років тому

      +17drums .. I don't know how overlooked it may have been by the masses in general, to me all this music was always so important and a part of my life. back then it was all about the records (albums) so you would try to have the complete collections by ELP, YES, Tull, Gentle Giant, King Crimson, etc. as long as the money would allow it. And then also trying to catch them live which was not always possible. This was before cassetes, CD's, Videotapes, DV D's and Computers so those albums were our religion, looking forward to the latest release and then bringing it home and checking out the artwork and pictures ..... those were the days ... LOL

    • @17drums
      @17drums  8 років тому

      Definitely a great period of time. Kids today probably think "records" are some sort of documentation. I was referring specifically just to this song from the album, as it never seemed to get much radio air-play.

  • @johncase2408
    @johncase2408 4 роки тому

    This song always reminded me of The Shining. I might not be the only one. Great playing!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  4 роки тому

      Thanks, John! We appreciate that.

  • @raphfox
    @raphfox 10 років тому

    Hello again! I love ELP! As such it is always a pleasure to hear their music played. Especially by such talented musicians! Now you have found a good vocalist, more ELP please?!! If you can catch the UK's finest of ELP tribute acts, Noddys Puncture, please do so. You won't be disappointed! Keep em coming lads! Your music is greatly appreciated!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому

      Thanks, Raphael! Yes, there is definitely more ELP on its way. The next one is completed, (without vocals, though), of the 'Blues Variation' from the 'Pictures...' album. On that one, we have Rachel Flowers playing the Hammond, with Misi on synthesizer. As for Noddy's Puncture, I'm YT "friends" with their old drummer Steve, going way back. Great band. Love their video of when Emerson showed up and surprised them onstage at the club by his home!

  • @JimLederer
    @JimLederer 9 місяців тому

    Wow, thanks for your efforts to bring this piece to life 🙂

    • @17drums
      @17drums  9 місяців тому

      Thanks for watching, Jim!

  • @GBWagner1
    @GBWagner1 10 років тому

    Glad to be the first commenter:)Thank for it! It,s one of my all time fave ELP hit, liked to drum(cover) it very much. The bass drum sounds excellently - best ever! -, the tom parts are very fine too. And the whole band and sound is perfect!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому

      Thanks, George! Great first comment.

  • @mmmzaarg
    @mmmzaarg 8 років тому +6

    Wow! Mr. Mihaly has one keyboard in every room of his house!!! LOL

    • @17drums
      @17drums  8 років тому

      But he loves his Hammond and Leslie the best!

  • @justsingit72
    @justsingit72 10 років тому

    Dave, as always it's a pleasure to work with you! I'm sure we'll be sharing the virtual stage again real soon!! Thanks everyone for the compliments!!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому

      You really saved us on this one, Len. The project had been on hold for over a year because no one had the b***s to attempt the vocals. Fantastic solution you came up with! Let's just hope now, that Evil Len is properly subdued, and buried in your sub-conscious, never to rear his evil head again!

    • @justsingit72
      @justsingit72 10 років тому

      17drums Ha Ha, I'll do my best.... But Evil is full of temptations, you know!!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому

      Yes, that's why we're included in the Big Three; Sex, Drugs, and ROCK AND ROLL!

  • @tdm1995
    @tdm1995 6 років тому

    Excellent!!!! I love it when i find well-done obscure ELP. Oh yes

    • @17drums
      @17drums  6 років тому

      Thanks! Yeah, you don't see this one done much by anyone--even live ELP cover bands.

  • @audiophile55
    @audiophile55 10 років тому

    Dave! This has to be one of the most magnificent things I've ever seen and heard! You guys sound *GREAT*!!!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому

      Thanks so much, Steve! The video is a little out of sync in places, but if you focus on the music, it works.

  • @WilliamWilsonEgoliGolf
    @WilliamWilsonEgoliGolf 7 місяців тому

    Outstanding..!

  • @hexagonalawareness3584
    @hexagonalawareness3584 3 роки тому

    Love it. Well done.

  • @roasyv13
    @roasyv13 9 років тому +3

    Great fun to see you guys. This is one of my favorites also. I envy you to contribute, and can give us this. I see you love this as much as me. Greetings from Roar,Norway.

    • @17drums
      @17drums  9 років тому

      Roar Syversen Thanks, Roar! Yeah, these collabs are real fun, and a great way to show our appreciation of these prog Masters. I'm very lucky to have hooked up with these excellent musicians from around the world. I had never been able to play with such superior talent in all the physical bands I've ever been in through the years. Geography used to limit the accessible talent pool for those bands. Not so anymore with these cyber bands! Greetings to Norway, (Edvard Grieg country!) from the USA!

    • @roasyv13
      @roasyv13 9 років тому

      Thank you very much. Nice to hear from you. Hope there will be more from you. I understand what you mean about the great talents you collabs with, but it demands a lot of skills and love for what you guys do. ☺✌Have a nice weekend.

    • @17drums
      @17drums  9 років тому

      I think the key word is LOVE for what we do. I've done some other collabs on other prog bands: Gentle Giant, Yes, Genesis, etc. We just finished one on Yes' 'Yours is no Disgrace'. The kid playing guitar is phenomenal. If you get a chance, (and you like Yes), you should check it out, For a young guy, he really knows his Steve Howe. As for ELP, we're finishing up 'Lucky Man' 'The Endless Enigma' and will be starting on Karn Evil 9. soon. You have a great weekend also! And thanks again!

    • @roasyv13
      @roasyv13 9 років тому

      I love Gentle Giant. Yes and Genesis as well, but Gentle Giant had that special effect on me, almost as much as ELP, sometimes. I am going to hear this and I am sure, with the same joy and pleasure.

  • @dhoudedrums
    @dhoudedrums 10 років тому

    GREAT work guys ! man, you choose a tought one. Félicitations les amis !!!!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому

      Thanks, Dan! The tough ones are the ones worth working on, right?

  • @gigio122
    @gigio122 8 років тому +3

    Bravissimi!!!!👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

  • @TheKingdave65
    @TheKingdave65 10 років тому

    Bravo, Bravo!!! Nice job by all.

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому

      Thanks Dave, from all!

  • @alexanderbleeser9784
    @alexanderbleeser9784 Рік тому

    Wow! This is so good 😊

  • @progdrummermark
    @progdrummermark 10 років тому

    Awesome as usual!!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому

      Thanks, Mark! You're generous, as usual!

  • @sergiolufernandes
    @sergiolufernandes 4 роки тому

    Excelente! Parabéns a todos!

  • @victorcoral
    @victorcoral 9 років тому +1

    Len is also doing a great job as always, he is quite the showman ... lol ..)

    • @17drums
      @17drums  9 років тому

      +Victor Coral Yeah, we were lucky to have had Len's evil twin sing on this one as well. Have you seen him in his sheriff's costume?

    • @victorcoral
      @victorcoral 8 років тому

      +17drums .... yeah, that was the first video I saw by the virtual band and I came across it just by looking for new videos by Rachel I hadn't seen before ... like I said, he's quite the showman and free of playing an instrument he adds quite a visual flare to ELP's monster music. I spent a lot of time watching your videos yesterday, I loved Karn Evil 9 and I can see how a young drummer getting into prog rock would get such joy from it. I didn't find part 2 (welcome back my friends) is it out there also?

    • @17drums
      @17drums  8 років тому

      Yes. KE9 1st Imp. Part 2 is the drum cover I did first, many years ago. Check my ELP playlist. Also, we're currently working on the entire KE9 composition with Rachel. Should be quite a production, (whenever it's finished). For now though, we're moving to complete 'Canario', (but without Rachel's participation). If you like Yes, you should watch the 'Yours is no Disgrace' collab I did with another incredible musician from Argentina, named July Valls.

  • @andrescitrino1660
    @andrescitrino1660 8 років тому +1

    muy bueno!!!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  8 років тому

      Muchas gracias!

  • @josb5884
    @josb5884 7 років тому +1

    Super !!

  • @huascarbenjesusquinonezbuj4345
    @huascarbenjesusquinonezbuj4345 7 років тому

    Bravoooo

  • @johndorohovich3367
    @johndorohovich3367 4 роки тому

    you guys really covered this perfectly
    I checked out Pino L
    unbelievable,
    some people have so much talent, i have enough trouble just with the drums 🙃🙃

    • @17drums
      @17drums  4 роки тому

      You should post some drum videos! (Btw, I like your playlists).

    • @johndorohovich3367
      @johndorohovich3367 4 роки тому

      @@17drums thanks Dave
      I never tried to video
      I'm not very technical
      I can't even set the clock on my stove without help 🙃🙃🙀

    • @johndorohovich3367
      @johndorohovich3367 4 роки тому

      I really enjoy your drumming, and thanks for telling me about Pino
      he's amazing

  • @HalJikaKick
    @HalJikaKick 3 роки тому

    I keep thinking how long it must have taken Greg Lake to learn that bass part. 😆

  • @noblehatred978
    @noblehatred978 6 місяців тому

    Great song and great job keeping ELP alive !!
    One thing I have to ask , maybe it’s me - but is this being played slower than usual ?

    • @17drums
      @17drums  6 місяців тому

      It's definitely slower than the original. I'm not sure why. I didn't do any of the mixing or editing.

  • @bettersteps
    @bettersteps 3 роки тому

    Where did you get the keyboard music for this? I've always wanted to play this but could ever find the music.

    • @17drums
      @17drums  3 роки тому

      I believe it was picked out by ear.

    • @bettersteps
      @bettersteps 3 роки тому

      @@17drums Think he wrote it down? Maybe I could get a copy? ...Pretty please. 🙏🏻

    • @17drums
      @17drums  3 роки тому

      @@bettersteps You could go to Misi's channel (the keyboard player-- ua-cam.com/users/mokusmisi) and find this video and ask him. Good luck!

    • @bettersteps
      @bettersteps 3 роки тому +1

      @@17drums Thanks brother!

  • @rts100x5
    @rts100x5 7 років тому +3

    great stuff though its kinda needs more syncopation ....

  • @sergios9664
    @sergios9664 8 років тому +2

    Qué gran error colocar el órgano debajo de la escalera, cuando la limpian cae toda la basura sobre el teclado... jajjajaja

    • @17drums
      @17drums  8 років тому

      No tengas miedo. Él cubre los teclados cuando él's no usarlos!

  • @alexandar7521
    @alexandar7521 4 роки тому

    Give me the lyrics!
    What's he singing about?

    • @17drums
      @17drums  4 роки тому

      Bad experience with a woman, I guess? www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/emersonlakepalmer/livingsin.html

  • @ae.zennie
    @ae.zennie 10 років тому

    The large amount of text at the end was a bit overwhelming because there was a lot to read and only a few seconds to read it. Yes, you can pause the video but I suggest you either break it up into small sections or make a separate video with each musician talking. Good job with the editing! I think it's cool that you formed an international band and made a cover together. :)

    • @17drums
      @17drums  10 років тому

      Thanks! Yeah, the bios are a bit lengthy. But as you said, if one wanted to really read them, then 'Pause" is always available. These virtual covers are great. I don't have to move any equipment, and I get to play with choice musicians from around the world!

  • @GBWagner1
    @GBWagner1 10 років тому

    Again:)

  • @uischirock
    @uischirock 6 років тому

    ok mates good job, but timing is not so easy :) speed up plz!

    • @17drums
      @17drums  6 років тому

      Thanks! Yeah, it should have been done a little faster.

  • @JJ-gz9ts
    @JJ-gz9ts 2 роки тому

    カッコイイ(・∀・)