They're all so different, but each change the song so much, Anette makes it a bright, pop song, uplifting, smile making, the other two make it something darker. ❤ All three.
ALL hale the REAL TRUE QUEEN 👑 of NIGHTWISH and of ALL FEMALE SYMPHONIC METAL SINGERS!!!, the very beautiful looking and very unique voice of the enchanting TARJA!!!😀👍👍🤘
💘❤💘 A very poetic song, a Masterpiece sung by three Goddesses, with different styles but all MARVELLOUS!!! 💘❤💘 And, of course, the Best Symphonic Metal (and not only!) band in the world!!! 💘❤💘
Nightwish is unfair to every other band on earth. For more than 20 years they have had one of the worlds best composer in Tuomas, kick ass drummers in Kai and Jukka, the guitar master Emppu, the most awesome male vocalist\bassist\guitar player alive with Marko and since 2012 Troy who seems to be able to play any instrument he's handed flawlessly. If this wasn't enough they have had not one but three gorgeous female lead vocalists each a fantastic singer that has brought their own unique flavor to the music. Tarja is a dark elven queen with soaring tones (Nemo). Anette brings a very strong main steam sound (Storytime). Floor is simply the Valkyrie Goddess whose range, power and versatility are unmatched (Poet and the Pendelum, How's the Heart (Acoustic version with Troy)). How can any band ever hope to even come close to such an all powerful combination as Nightwish has been over the years.
This might be my favorite Nightwish video yet :) amazing what you did here, thank you. Especially the mesh when all three of them are on stage. Bravo, take a bow
Nightwish con Tarja fue la génesis de un hito en la música , voz lirica y rock , fantástica . Annette no es nada personal , pero es un completo desacierto . FLOOR un completo acierto ❤
All trio are bloody amazing in their own right floor suits some songs as does tarja with her transition into operatics which is so damn easy for her and Annette her song was Storytime but lacked power for other songs but i love all 3 magnificent in their own right,i cant put one above the other all brilliant,damn great band not forgetting Marko i love all their songs
Que genio hizo esto, debio ser muy trabajoso, es una obra de arte, de ni parte diria que anette me trajo a nightwish y es la que mas me gusta, pero la voz de tarja es impresionante
I like all three because this is one of my absolute Nightwish Songs. But this is obviously written for Tarja’s voice. Floor has perfect pitch, as usual, but she has to scream too much in the last part to get up there. I swear I don’t know what Tuomas did to make that final verse so hard to sing. Even Tarja seems to have some trouble with it live. I still listen to all of them and enjoy all of them. I do like that they’re different.
@2 Ssj vocal What are you talking about? She sings it in a higher key? You don’t need to defend Floor, I love her and her version. She’s probably one of the best singers on the planet right now, but she’s not perfect. I don’t understand why you guys want to put that kind of pressure on her anyway. I have a preference on this particular song. Sorry you can’t handle it.
1- Tarja 2- Floor 3- Anette Thats my ranking, Tarja and Floor both can make crazy things with her voices, Anette is a really good singer (Storytime is a example), but is more limited
Anette has a sweet voice, but she's horrible live. Floor has the best stage presence and rock star personality, with a strong voice to boot, but Tarja's elegant and majestic vocals painted on the canvas that Tuomas set up for her was just magic.
Three beautiful girls with three different voices. Tarja Turunen with her lyrical voice and a bright and velvety timbre. Annette Olsson with a balanced and extremely harmonious, smooth and sweet voice. Floor Jansen with her powerful and striking voice. All three voices have their own power and their own brilliance. But here is my ranking of Nightwish singers: 1°) Annette Olsson. 2°) Tarja Turunen. 3°) Floor Jansen.
(off topic) And this verse here 2:14 shows exactly what NW is missing today without a male rock singer like Marko is. Hope they can fill this gap soon!
Me encanta esta cancion como dicen los de España me flipa,, que Hermosa Emperatriz Tarja Turunen,, Epico,, La QUEEN Floor Jansen , La PRINCESA Anett Olzon,, bellas vocalistas,,
All these songs would have easily stood out in the 80s and I still would be listening and at the top of my CDs or tape bloody timeless I love it like Xandria
Well...Tarja and Anette are definitely great singers in their own genre, but Floor is absolutely the best that could happen to Nightwish. She is just legendary and can do so much more with her voice than any other singer as far as I know. She can do so many genres...its just insane.
Lots of people arguing in the comments over who is best... I say it's pointless. All three are of different styles and backgrounds, and can do different things. They're all great in their own right. If I HAD to choose someone for this song, it would be Tarja, but only because she sang it first, just like how I view, say, "Amaranth" as Anette's song and something like "Perfume of the Timeless" as Floor's.
Like you, I think all 3 bring something different to Nightwish, but you can't argue that according to a 'best ever albums' website has the top Nightwish albums are 1- Once, 2- Century Child, 3- Dark Passion Play and at 4 - Imaginaerum. Personally I'd agree with that. I only 'found' the band last year, via Showtime - Storytime, thinking then that Floor was something special, especially after hearing her version of Phantom with Henk Poort. But I now think only Tarja can really do justice to the likes of Ever dream and only Anette with Poet. I'd also add that since leaving Nightwish, Tarja's solo efforts are all amazing, all equal to Nightwish, and Anette with her solo stuff and with Dark Element material are up there too - while Floor's sole effort Paragon - the warrior seems to have turned into a cabaret singer!! And after a disappointing (in my mind) Human-Nature, that Yesterwynde lives up to the standard of anthems set by the likes of Once and Imaginaerum
This has been out now for...what...4 years now and you guys still haven gotten it right when it comes to the proper order of singers! Well please allow me to set the record straight, from best to pretty darn great are: #1 Marko Hietala. #2 The Girls*. #3 and Troy Donockley is pretty darn great, too! Sheesh! Now on to more important matters, how do we fans create enough of a stir in each of Nightwish's talented musicians, past and present to come together for just one special evening in Tampere? Old songs, new songs, mix-and match of singers, drummers, bassists and... sorry Mr. Emppu Vuorinen looks like you might not get many breaks. (psst: I would love to hear the unthinkable: Poet and the Pendulum sung by...that ...um first girl who sang for Nightwish!) Nightwish is known for being EPIC well this show, imo, would dwarf Nightwish!!! (Of course it would need to be recorded for resale on DVD and CD and etc). At the end of this grand event the three ladies of Nightwish would stand alone, center stage and sing Ad Astra. *(Ok, so we all know who "the Girls" are, but we fixed the ranking system earlier, remember?) Nightwish Army, Outpost Eatonville USA
Marco is quite horrible to be honest... our music teacher in elementary school played Marco's previous band Tarot to us (they were a local band from the same city), didn't like him/them then, didn't like when he joined Nightwish either, I get someone had to do the growls on Oceanborn but then he got some clean parts.. yikes
@GreySectoid I liked him just fine with Nightwish. For instance, I liked him just fine on Phantom of the Opera with Tarja while both were with Nightwish. I did hear a recent version with him with Tarja and her band, which I didn't care for. I further loved his duets with Floor. I am not a music instructor, nor even a musician, but as a fan of music, I like his vocals just fine. Edited to add: You might have missed it but my placing Marko above "The Girls" was a deliberate touch of sarcasm. My larger point below that was suggesting that in one EPIC EVENT, all of the Nightwish members, past and present, having multiple opportunities to perform with each other.
they all sing great, yes BUT suiting Nightwish best is Floor I think. Tarjas Voice is powerful for sure but really for me more for more classic music. Anettes voice is very light, great though but it fades under the instruments a bit. would work totally great with electronic music I think. Floors voice is powerful and clear but not as dramatic as Tarjas so it fits this kind of music best for me. not trying to make say anyone else is wrong, just giving away my opinion.
It's pretty amazing how you mash up the 3 versions, it sounds really good. Thanks for sharing this
They're all nightwish, I like them all :)
Marko - the best!!!
Марко всегда хорош)
Ame este Mashup, que sueño sería que ellas tres cantaran está canción pero bueno jejeje son sueños jajajaja
Amo y disfruto las 3 etapas de Nightwihs estás 3 diosas le dieron sus diferentes toques cada una hermosa con sus respectivas diferencias.
Una gira con las 3… un sueño qué tal vez nunca ocurrirá, pero sería hermoso 🥲
Three TOP TOP singers and three different bands at each moment... yet my favourite is Floor. Gives me the chills to hear her sing.
They're all so different, but each change the song so much, Anette makes it a bright, pop song, uplifting, smile making, the other two make it something darker. ❤ All three.
ALL hale the REAL TRUE QUEEN 👑 of NIGHTWISH and of ALL FEMALE SYMPHONIC METAL SINGERS!!!, the very beautiful looking and very unique voice of the enchanting TARJA!!!😀👍👍🤘
Yes definitely right about tarja stands right out have a great day or night 😊❤
💘❤💘 A very poetic song, a Masterpiece sung by three Goddesses, with different styles but all MARVELLOUS!!! 💘❤💘 And, of course, the Best Symphonic Metal (and not only!) band in the world!!! 💘❤💘
Nightwish is unfair to every other band on earth. For more than 20 years they have had one of the worlds best composer in Tuomas, kick ass drummers in Kai and Jukka, the guitar master Emppu, the most awesome male vocalist\bassist\guitar player alive with Marko and since 2012 Troy who seems to be able to play any instrument he's handed flawlessly. If this wasn't enough they have had not one but three gorgeous female lead vocalists each a fantastic singer that has brought their own unique flavor to the music. Tarja is a dark elven queen with soaring tones (Nemo). Anette brings a very strong main steam sound (Storytime). Floor is simply the Valkyrie Goddess whose range, power and versatility are unmatched (Poet and the Pendelum, How's the Heart (Acoustic version with Troy)).
How can any band ever hope to even come close to such an all powerful combination as Nightwish has been over the years.
Well said and absolutely true!
Wow. Sin palabras. Un saludo.
Seeing all three on stage together... I could die happy.
2 would be enough!
@@andrevandinther3981 Nope, four.
@@bilgeoktem Correct, don't forget Marko
I wonder, all four, hmmm
Annette is too bitter to the band
Hats off to whoever made this combinations!!
Um dia num show veremos todos os membros atuais e antigos do Nightwish juntos, e por Deus que essas três cantem essa música juntas
Please!!! Tuomas need to play role in inviting both Tarja n Anette
This song is good for Tarja
Great piece of mixing work. Great singers, all with their own strengths.
Tarja, estilo , voz, movimientos en el escenario, es única.
Absolutamente!! Incomparable!!
Love them all 😍
Imagina um dia ver essas 3 juntas assim, numa turnê especial do Nightwish
Lo mismo pensé al escuchar el final de la mezcla lejos de quién es mejor y todas esas tonterías ese será nuestro Ever dream saludos desde México 🇲🇽
This might be my favorite Nightwish video yet :) amazing what you did here, thank you. Especially the mesh when all three of them are on stage. Bravo, take a bow
just love it.. nothing more to say! awesome
Not forgetting the amazing vocal talents of one Marko Hietala. 🙏
Love them 3s .they have their own unique voice..😍
😊😊😊😊three great singers, pure listening pleasure
Une superbe découverte de ce titre et groupe , trop heureux de le découvrir !
I love the three singing together!!! 🎉😊
Saw True Strays at Field View. Fabulous band. Bought the cd and my wife and I have booked to see them again.
Nightwish con Tarja fue la génesis de un hito en la música , voz lirica y rock , fantástica . Annette no es nada personal , pero es un completo desacierto . FLOOR un completo acierto ❤
Em nooo. Imaginaerum created just for her vocal
All trio are bloody amazing in their own right floor suits some songs as does tarja with her transition into operatics which is so damn easy for her and Annette her song was Storytime but lacked power for other songs but i love all 3 magnificent in their own right,i cant put one above the other all brilliant,damn great band not forgetting Marko i love all their songs
Tarja is as epic as possible. 🎉
Floor really killed this song at her introduction to the band at Waken Open Air.
Tarja - elegance
Floor - power
Anette - brightness
TARJA forevermore! The very, very, very best!
🤟
Que genio hizo esto, debio ser muy trabajoso, es una obra de arte, de ni parte diria que anette me trajo a nightwish y es la que mas me gusta, pero la voz de tarja es impresionante
I love all 3 singers. I prefer some over others as a main singer ... but that Anette "One dAYHeHeHAYHAY" will ALWAYS get me!
That was really neat how you did that! Great job!!
I would listen to this trio!
I like all three because this is one of my absolute Nightwish Songs. But this is obviously written for Tarja’s voice. Floor has perfect pitch, as usual, but she has to scream too much in the last part to get up there. I swear I don’t know what Tuomas did to make that final verse so hard to sing. Even Tarja seems to have some trouble with it live. I still listen to all of them and enjoy all of them. I do like that they’re different.
@2 Ssj vocal What are you talking about? She sings it in a higher key? You don’t need to defend Floor, I love her and her version. She’s probably one of the best singers on the planet right now, but she’s not perfect. I don’t understand why you guys want to put that kind of pressure on her anyway. I have a preference on this particular song. Sorry you can’t handle it.
@@vanessalore9942😅😂😂 🤮
Beautiful
This is the greatest thing ever made.
Can you do one for Ghost Love Score? The other ones on UA-cam don't cut it.
Si en vez de pelear por quien es la mejor, pudieramos escucharlas juntas en un concierto, seria maravilloso
Tarja...🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥...😊
I would like to see and hear them all on the same stage and sing this and other songs. It should be amazing😍😍🔥. Something like anniversary tour❤
Voice of Tarja, Goddess of Nightwish
🤟
Tarja e floor engoliram a anette
Não sobrou nada dela kkkk
1- Tarja
2- Floor
3- Anette
Thats my ranking, Tarja and Floor both can make crazy things with her voices, Anette is a really good singer (Storytime is a example), but is more limited
Anette has a sweet voice, but she's horrible live. Floor has the best stage presence and rock star personality, with a strong voice to boot, but Tarja's elegant and majestic vocals painted on the canvas that Tuomas set up for her was just magic.
@@banditkade Anette is a mediocre singer,and terrible live.
@@karenvandijk6606 ok professional singer
@@gianmarcoaxl2003 And you think karen is wrong? Anette is a pop singer, not a symphonic metal vocalist
@@banditkade meanwhile she did great. You just suck
Que fortuna de esta banda las tres son sensacionales Ojalá las tres en un mismo ahi
Grande nigthwuish
Reina👑...solo hay una....
Tarja I ....de Finlandia......
Floor : Metal
Tarja : Opera
Anete : Pop
Sorry bro Annette and pop it's bullshit
Tarja is the one who can sing it like no other. Even Floor and Anette are good, this is not the same feeling. Tarja is the winner for this song
Tarja 👏🏻 is perfect
Sin duda Tarja Turunen y Marko son Nightwish
Floor.
Three beautiful girls with three different voices.
Tarja Turunen with her lyrical voice and a bright and velvety timbre.
Annette Olsson with a balanced and extremely harmonious, smooth and sweet voice.
Floor Jansen with her powerful and striking voice.
All three voices have their own power and their own brilliance.
But here is my ranking of Nightwish singers: 1°) Annette Olsson. 2°) Tarja Turunen. 3°) Floor Jansen.
1 Tarja 2 Floor 3 Annette
1. Floor
2. Tarja
3.Anette
That's my opinion.
Excellent job with the edit!
Muy buena la edición.
Floor best 🔥
(off topic)
And this verse here 2:14 shows exactly what NW is missing today without a male rock singer like Marko is.
Hope they can fill this gap soon!
omfg! Marko s and floor s voices are from other planet!
Me encanta esta cancion como dicen los de España me flipa,, que Hermosa Emperatriz Tarja Turunen,, Epico,, La QUEEN Floor Jansen , La PRINCESA Anett Olzon,, bellas vocalistas,,
Tarja no tiene rival
Tarja is the queen
Floor 🔝🔝🔝
Both are good but (for me) there is just something about Floor that just raises Nightwish to another level.
Si Hellowwen pudo juntar a sus vocal en gira, porqué no pensar que algún día las 3 juntas estarán en un escenario :)
All these songs would have easily stood out in the 80s and I still would be listening and at the top of my CDs or tape bloody timeless I love it like Xandria
It's just a matter of which version you prefer... 3 good singers but with different vocal characteristics.
Algún día chicos algún día
Floor the best by far
Floor самая мощная!
Floor ♥️
Tarya the best!!!!
Only Tarja !
Well...Tarja and Anette are definitely great singers in their own genre, but Floor is absolutely the best that could happen to Nightwish. She is just legendary and can do so much more with her voice than any other singer as far as I know. She can do so many genres...its just insane.
Hahaha what a posser
@@ReedDistorsion Explain
Tarja ainda é a melhor voz do Nightwish.
Bye bye beautiful and Sahara.. Anette and tarja better than floor
They are all excellent singers - all different. But yeah there is something so strong in floors voice
and the winner is ... Marko Hietala!
Tarja canta muito ela e muito mais lirica !!
LOL
When i hear Tarja, i feel bad for the other two....
Tarja is the best.
Amazing :')
Lots of people arguing in the comments over who is best... I say it's pointless. All three are of different styles and backgrounds, and can do different things. They're all great in their own right. If I HAD to choose someone for this song, it would be Tarja, but only because she sang it first, just like how I view, say, "Amaranth" as Anette's song and something like "Perfume of the Timeless" as Floor's.
Like you, I think all 3 bring something different to Nightwish, but you can't argue that according to a 'best ever albums' website has the top Nightwish albums are 1- Once, 2- Century Child, 3- Dark Passion Play and at 4 - Imaginaerum. Personally I'd agree with that. I only 'found' the band last year, via Showtime - Storytime, thinking then that Floor was something special, especially after hearing her version of Phantom with Henk Poort.
But I now think only Tarja can really do justice to the likes of Ever dream and only Anette with Poet. I'd also add that since leaving Nightwish, Tarja's solo efforts are all amazing, all equal to Nightwish, and Anette with her solo stuff and with Dark Element material are up there too - while Floor's sole effort Paragon - the warrior seems to have turned into a cabaret singer!!
And after a disappointing (in my mind) Human-Nature, that Yesterwynde lives up to the standard of anthems set by the likes of Once and Imaginaerum
@@JP-lm9vi 1. Oceanborn 2. Angels Fall First 3. Wishmaster 4. Century Child 5. Rest who cares
Обожаю эту группу. На первом месте эта группа
Tarja wins hands down, Floor and anette were too weak for this song ! 🥰
Floor 🤩🤘
Anette ni llega a Floor, y muchísimo menos a Tarja. Tarja es unica en su tipo..
Floor Floor Floor. I like her voice and stage presence the most.
Tarja is the best.
floor tarja en deuxieme et dernier danette
Más videos así por favor 🙏 ❤️
All great singers but think and feel that Anette is the best and most versatile singer of Nightwish! She is build for greatness’s!!! 💛🌹🤘
Tarja siempre 🤘🤘🤘❤❤
Tarja😮
Floor! Floor! Floor!
This has been out now for...what...4 years now and you guys still haven gotten it right when it comes to the proper order of singers! Well please allow me to set the record straight, from best to pretty darn great are: #1 Marko Hietala. #2 The Girls*. #3 and Troy Donockley is pretty darn great, too! Sheesh! Now on to more important matters, how do we fans create enough of a stir in each of Nightwish's talented musicians, past and present to come together for just one special evening in Tampere? Old songs, new songs, mix-and match of singers, drummers, bassists and... sorry Mr. Emppu Vuorinen looks like you might not get many breaks. (psst: I would love to hear the unthinkable: Poet and the Pendulum sung by...that ...um first girl who sang for Nightwish!) Nightwish is known for being EPIC well this show, imo, would dwarf Nightwish!!! (Of course it would need to be recorded for resale on DVD and CD and etc). At the end of this grand event the three ladies of Nightwish would stand alone, center stage and sing Ad Astra. *(Ok, so we all know who "the Girls" are, but we fixed the ranking system earlier, remember?) Nightwish Army, Outpost Eatonville USA
Marco is quite horrible to be honest... our music teacher in elementary school played Marco's previous band Tarot to us (they were a local band from the same city), didn't like him/them then, didn't like when he joined Nightwish either, I get someone had to do the growls on Oceanborn but then he got some clean parts.. yikes
@GreySectoid I liked him just fine with Nightwish. For instance, I liked him just fine on Phantom of the Opera with Tarja while both were with Nightwish. I did hear a recent version with him with Tarja and her band, which I didn't care for. I further loved his duets with Floor. I am not a music instructor, nor even a musician, but as a fan of music, I like his vocals just fine. Edited to add: You might have missed it but my placing Marko above "The Girls" was a deliberate touch of sarcasm. My larger point below that was suggesting that in one EPIC EVENT, all of the Nightwish members, past and present, having multiple opportunities to perform with each other.
SF2
que puñal de tema y que voces la diosa Tarja ,,la Princesa Floor y la bella chaparrita de Anett
Tarja Cool❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
One must have really bad hearing if doesn't arrive to conclusion that Tarja clearly performs this song best.
1. Tarja
2. Tarja
3. Tarja
4. Annette
5. Floor
No.
Invece si
This video and many others are proof that you cannot have a pop singer perform a Nightwish song and hope it sounds anything like an opera singer.
Team Tarja ❤
nunca entederé como aguantaron tantos años a olson
they all sing great, yes BUT suiting Nightwish best is Floor I think. Tarjas Voice is powerful for sure but really for me more for more classic music. Anettes voice is very light, great though but it fades under the instruments a bit. would work totally great with electronic music I think. Floors voice is powerful and clear but not as dramatic as Tarjas so it fits this kind of music best for me.
not trying to make say anyone else is wrong, just giving away my opinion.