Reminder that the video is timecoded meaning you are able to skip to your favorite parts of the video! Want to request the next video: ‣ 𝐏𝐚𝐭𝐫𝐞𝐨𝐧: www.patreon.com/lintonwilson Link To Our Win: Who Is Next Series: www.patreon.com/posts/win-who-is-next-49927131 Treasure Map Playlist: www.t.ly/EbKo Treasure Box [Complete] Playlist: www.t.ly/TlYm
THIS SONG, I MEAN THIS SONG IS VERY MAJESTIC WHICH GOT ME INTO MMM but went very underrated, not only me but 80% of the moomoo will agree that this era has the BEST STYLING, MAKEOVER for ot4
The MV has a lot of references to Wong Kar-Wai films. Mamamoo has also stated the connection among each members' characters and stages of emotions after a break up. Solar - regret Moonbyul - reminisce Wheein - ambivalence Hwasa - acceptance There are twitter threads about this because the aesthetics and underlying meanings are just so good.
Also, I really want to say for you too: “I really love to hear your opinions or thoughts. I can see and feel what a great person you are. I’m so grateful for you as always. I am your fan too. Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts. I really enjoyed it as always.”
@@LintonWilson hi linton, are you aware that mamamoo will be first girl; group to sing live on "live now kpop" in new york concert on saturday may 1? you can buy tickets for $20 ?
Mamamoo is my fav group too like your favorite group btw my ultimate bias is incredible solar and bias wrecker is amazing hwasa i love this song and my favourite part is when moon rapping i like this part
Still don't understand how wind flower was mamamoo most underrated comeback song when its this amazing. Also i like other gril groups but no other group has captured me like mamamoo has so i get it. I really liked your explanations in this it made the reaction better.
Blue;S is literally my comfort album, whenever im sad i just sit down in my dark room and listem to the album and cry What i really liked about the album was that it was set to be like the 5 stages of grief and really whenever im sad my mood follows the stages the current song is playing so i get over things pretty quickly😂
I like all k-pop groups but the way I stan for BTS and MAMAMOO is so different.because they makes me loving myself more. Picking bias in BTS and MAMAMOO is like choosing between mom and dad.it's so hard for me❤️✨😘 Sry for my bad English😉
"They make me happy" yeah me too that's why I adore Mamamoo I feel connected to them in sm way that I can't explain but yeah I don't feel the same for any other gg or bg
Ask every moomoo and this song is probably on their top 5 Mamamoo songs. And the MV is their best MV for me. The MV is inspired by Wong Kar Wai movies. For comparison: ua-cam.com/video/si2s1envgkE/v-deo.html
I broke down when you started talking about allowing yourself to feel what you need to feel.. I've been trying to toughen myself up these past few days just to finish all that needs to be done. but honestly i can't handle it anymore and i always stopped myself from breaking down because i got no time for that lol. but i broke down with this :< ah, im tired.
I guess you can say they're each representing a different stage of a break up. Whee-in doesn't go out at all, stays in bed, even when she tries going out shestays isolated, (depression). Hwasa seems to be having a good time in that hair salon, but I guess she's got mood swings and becomes this closed off grumpy person in public (I guessaAnger). Moonbyul struggles to find an appetite, and seems to just wander around outside for no reason at all, needs the fresh air. Although she atleast goes out, so for her I haven't a clue y'all. Solar looks like it's JUST happened. She's straight up pondering what whent wrong, now that phone call she made (in the pearls) I guess she's either bargaining to her now ex partner, or the breakup had just happened over the phone. Ion know. Either way, I liked how they shot this. I think MAMAMOO did a great job conveying such frustrations and emotions! If you don't agree that they were different stages, would you agree that they were different reactions to a breakup? 2:15 it is pretty odd that different situations, can cause people to experience the same emotions.
MAMAMOO THE BEST FEMALE GROUP, they're underestimated for been part of a small company. They break beauty and style stereotypes of female kpop groups. Thank you so much for this reaction. 💜
Hwasa literally drunk cried because Wind Flower was her favorite Mamamoo song but it didn't get that much love from the public (no music show win). Moomoos know that this is one of the most underrated songs of Mamamoo.
Wind flower just hits different 💛 Please react to some Mamamoo’s Angel Line (angel line is what they call Wheein and Solar’s line), this is a good place to search if you want some Wheein and Solar “crackhead” moments
I think this it's their most beautiful mv they look so beautiful also windflower deserve more recognition as a song!!! The concert version it's so cool too!! It's time for you to watch Mmmtv on youtube!! There's 200+ episode of Mamamoo happiness 🥺
I think it's cool that just the preview caught your eye because windflower is such a unique mv. I love the color grading and the night scenes and the drinking and I can't think of another kpop mv quite like it. And windflower is such an amazing song too -- people who love the blue;s album had superior taste, that's all I gotta say. Mamamoo is my favorite girl group too and Wheein's comeback made me so excited for the future of mamamoo, just imaging what they're going to make with their next comebacks :) I can't wait to watch more of them with you!!
I appreciate all your commentary. I am very happy to find people with the same love towards mamamoo. This is the first time I stanned an artist this hard and thank you for bringing us all together through your videos.
Appreciate the commentary. It fit well with the song and its place in the cyclical concept of the 4 Color 4 Season project. Each title track presented a stage in a relationship and Wind Flower was obviously about the heartache of a breakup. You have to go through it but try to remember that grief has its season and it will pass but, to paraphrase what you said in terms of the 4S4C concepts, it's one of the intense emotional colors that paint our lives and make us who we are so we shouldn't try to avoid or repress those feelings. As someone else pointed out, each member portrays a different emotional stage in dealing with the breakup so you could think of it as 4 people at different points in the process or the members representing four stages of one person's experience. Then they come together towards the end of the MV. You'll see the same format in all the 4S4C title track MVs - I call it the four into one concept where all the different aspects of the emotion/experience are unified. Besides the cyclical life lesson symbolism this concept also reflects their belief that they were destined to be best friends, which they explicitly express in the follow up album to the 4S4C project, reality in BLACK, in songs like Destiny, 4X4ever and Universe.
6:53 exactly. Mamamoo and BTS are like big brothers and sisters who comfort me when I feel down and make me happy. Their music is really touching deep in my heart. I admire these 11 people very much and aspire to have their work ethic in the future.
Windflower Moonbyul is my favorite Moonbyul in all MMM songs, both visuals & vocal-wise. I can feel her pain (and because her lyrics, man. She wrote it and im 100% sure it's based on actual experience)
You should really hit Logos channel since my all time favorite shots of wind flower era was there. The song was the 4seasons outro but the vibe of wind era just fit perfectly somehow in that songs. Also the stages of this era just 😘👌 The vibe the stages the songs, overall this was one of many moomoo favorite era, but well maybe it was international moomoo tho, since the girls actually feel they dont receive many support and love when this songs come out. (They talked about it in the mnet comeback stage)
Your mamamoo's video reaction always so enlighten cause you really see trough everything seeking the lyrics meaning, or the mv itself. Analysis the music, instrumens and more. I love it, always love your reaction thank youuuu
Yeah, I love to listen to this song too. This era was JUST AMAZING. The stages of this song were awesome too. You will like it. I hope you make a reaction to their album as soon too 🥰. Thank you so much for this. I really enjoyed it as always.
Have seen so many other reactions but i'd stay for 14 minutes or so, knowing i'd hear your mind out. It's soo deep and it's soo good to keep digging in there. Your reactions are reflections at the same time. Keep doin what you doin man. Inspiration
Literally yesterday I started watching your Mamamoo videos and I was waiting so anxious for you to upload the reaction to Wind Flower, you heard my prayers mwkdmwmdk
Dude, I've been a whole Sunday's afternoon watching your arc with mamamoo lmao. I'm glad that I feel soooo relatable with your experience knowing them, Thank u for create such a great content
I noticed that about how Hwasa came in too. I also noticed that in a lot of songs, Hwasa goes in first and I think it’s really strategic because her voice has a certain captivating quality. Like a “wait, this sounds different. what is this?” type of thing. Then once you’re hooked, the other members come in and you go “heyyyy heyyyy them vocals”.... And then they harmonize and now you’re a moomoo 😂 That’s what happened to me
God Windflower is that song for me, timeless. Idk if they used Greek Mythology for this but i know Windflower is related to Adonis and Aphrodite's story and its very sad. Im an eng and lit major so i stanned extra hard when this was released
I swear it's 00:40 am but u already made me feel a 100 time better, ur words are so healing 🤍🤍& that's what I was telling myself but I guess we always forget things. Thank u tho & my fav group was there too so🤗
This song is underrated. I read somewhere in yt in other reactors in the comment sections saying that MMM was sad that this song didn't get any win(I think it was Hwasa saying) because they personally thought that this song is personal and one of their best.
"they make me happy" yeah boi. same here. my entire youtube recommendation is just mamamoo and gahd i just get sucked in everytime i open youtube because SEROTONIN BOOST RIGHT THERE
Pls react to Big Mama Dinggo Killing Voice! You won’t regret it. Created by YG and the pioneer of Big Bang & Blackpink. They recently have a comback and their vocals are out of this world.
![MAMAMOO (마마무 ) - Where Are We Now [MV] (REACTION + REVIEW)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JdWgMSe0uxI/mqdefault.jpg)
Reminder that the video is timecoded meaning you are able to skip to your favorite parts of the video!
Want to request the next video:
‣ 𝐏𝐚𝐭𝐫𝐞𝐨𝐧: www.patreon.com/lintonwilson
Link To Our Win: Who Is Next Series:
www.patreon.com/posts/win-who-is-next-49927131
Treasure Map Playlist: www.t.ly/EbKo
Treasure Box [Complete] Playlist: www.t.ly/TlYm
Mamamoo is your favorite girl group? Congratulations sir, you have impeccable taste 👏🏻
This song is a timeless classic 😭
Moomoos' open secret 💚
Best mmm song
yesss 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
THIS SONG, I MEAN THIS SONG IS VERY MAJESTIC WHICH GOT ME INTO MMM but went very underrated, not only me but 80% of the moomoo will agree that this era has the BEST STYLING, MAKEOVER for ot4
As a moomoo, I AGREE!!!!!! Everything was just.... perfection
100% agree!! the song, the theme, mv, styling, makeover, this album, everything.
I became a moomoo bcs of this song 😭😭😭 this song healed me
The MV has a lot of references to Wong Kar-Wai films.
Mamamoo has also stated the connection among each members' characters and stages of emotions after a break up.
Solar - regret
Moonbyul - reminisce
Wheein - ambivalence
Hwasa - acceptance
There are twitter threads about this because the aesthetics and underlying meanings are just so good.
Its because Mamamoo is so womanly just like alicia keys. They radiate that pure wholesome woman power
Also, I really want to say for you too: “I really love to hear your opinions or thoughts. I can see and feel what a great person you are. I’m so grateful for you as always. I am your fan too. Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts. I really enjoyed it as always.”
thank you for always leaving such kind words ❤️
@@LintonWilson 😍 ♥️
@@LintonWilson hi linton, are you aware that mamamoo will be first girl; group to sing live on "live now kpop" in new york concert on saturday may 1? you can buy tickets for $20 ?
Mamamoo is my fav group too like your favorite group btw my ultimate bias is incredible solar and bias wrecker is amazing hwasa i love this song and my favourite part is when moon rapping i like this part
Still don't understand how wind flower was mamamoo most underrated comeback song when its this amazing. Also i like other gril groups but no other group has captured me like mamamoo has so i get it. I really liked your explanations in this it made the reaction better.
There company RBW is known for there good melody and a lot of kpop group song is composed by There CEO Kim Do Hoon
Mamamoo is no ordinary girl group. They are so soulfull. Every album, every song, every performance was so dynamic. I love them ❤️
‘They make me happy’ I felt that deep . I just can’t find another artist that makes me feel like they do
I plead guilty I wasn't too into this song when it came out but it turned out as one of my ultimate favorite mamamoo's song!
i love this song ♡
I can see why ♡♡
@@LintonWilson already loved the little part of the Killing Voice video from Dingo(i think it's called dingo xD)
FINALLY!! The song that got me into mamamoo 💚🔥
Blue;S is literally my comfort album, whenever im sad i just sit down in my dark room and listem to the album and cry
What i really liked about the album was that it was set to be like the 5 stages of grief and really whenever im sad my mood follows the stages the current song is playing so i get over things pretty quickly😂
I like all k-pop groups but the way I stan for BTS and MAMAMOO is so different.because they makes me loving myself more. Picking bias in BTS and MAMAMOO is like choosing between mom and dad.it's so hard for me❤️✨😘
Sry for my bad English😉
I have 2 ult gg's, one is 2ne1 and the other is mamamoo. Talented queens.
"They make me happy" yeah me too that's why I adore Mamamoo I feel connected to them in sm way that I can't explain but yeah I don't feel the same for any other gg or bg
The Most Underrated Masterpiece of Mamamoo. Ugh! Its my all time favorite title track of them.😭❤️
Ask every moomoo and this song is probably on their top 5 Mamamoo songs. And the MV is their best MV for me. The MV is inspired by Wong Kar Wai movies. For comparison: ua-cam.com/video/si2s1envgkE/v-deo.html
Mamamoo is THE group for me I love them so much ❤
I broke down when you started talking about allowing yourself to feel what you need to feel.. I've been trying to toughen myself up these past few days just to finish all that needs to be done. but honestly i can't handle it anymore and i always stopped myself from breaking down because i got no time for that lol. but i broke down with this :< ah, im tired.
i'd like to send you a virtual hug
@@ohkeziah thank you! :>
I guess you can say they're each representing a different stage of a break up. Whee-in doesn't go out at all, stays in bed, even when she tries going out shestays isolated, (depression). Hwasa seems to be having a good time in that hair salon, but I guess she's got mood swings and becomes this closed off grumpy person in public (I guessaAnger). Moonbyul struggles to find an appetite, and seems to just wander around outside for no reason at all, needs the fresh air. Although she atleast goes out, so for her I haven't a clue y'all. Solar looks like it's JUST happened. She's straight up pondering what whent wrong, now that phone call she made (in the pearls) I guess she's either bargaining to her now ex partner, or the breakup had just happened over the phone. Ion know. Either way, I liked how they shot this. I think MAMAMOO did a great job conveying such frustrations and emotions! If you don't agree that they were different stages, would you agree that they were different reactions to a breakup?
2:15 it is pretty odd that different situations, can cause people to experience the same emotions.
way too underrated imo, i still listen to it a lot 3 years later
MAMAMOO THE BEST FEMALE GROUP, they're underestimated for been part of a small company. They break beauty and style stereotypes of female kpop groups. Thank you so much for this reaction. 💜
Moonbyul's makeup is just amaziiiing
This is my favourite Mamamoo song😩
Another great MMM review!
Hwasa literally drunk cried because Wind Flower was her favorite Mamamoo song but it didn't get that much love from the public (no music show win). Moomoos know that this is one of the most underrated songs of Mamamoo.
This song made me a MooMoo. Never letting go.
I know what you mean. Every time I see or think of mamamoo it instantly makes me a little lighter and happier
best gg in the world
Wind flower just hits different 💛
Please react to some Mamamoo’s Angel Line (angel line is what they call Wheein and Solar’s line), this is a good place to search if you want some Wheein and Solar “crackhead” moments
Mamamoo and Winner are my fave artiste! Their vocals esp are amazing!
they broke the fourth wall at the end and it was terrifying
I think this it's their most beautiful mv they look so beautiful also windflower deserve more recognition as a song!!! The concert version it's so cool too!! It's time for you to watch Mmmtv on youtube!! There's 200+ episode of Mamamoo happiness 🥺
Yesss ❤ finally my favorite Mamamoo song. This song has many meanings and each time it hits differently 😢
moon is her last name by the way 😂 loved this reaction
My favourite mmm song! Thanks for a great reaction 😊 Btw, it's "to affect" - verb, "an effect" - noun 😉
Wind flower is so underrated:(, is a master piece!
Please react to why mamamoo shouldn't host their own radio show its hilarious 😭 oh and their comeback stages for 1cm,waggy and sleeping in the car
I think it's cool that just the preview caught your eye because windflower is such a unique mv. I love the color grading and the night scenes and the drinking and I can't think of another kpop mv quite like it. And windflower is such an amazing song too -- people who love the blue;s album had superior taste, that's all I gotta say. Mamamoo is my favorite girl group too and Wheein's comeback made me so excited for the future of mamamoo, just imaging what they're going to make with their next comebacks :) I can't wait to watch more of them with you!!
I appreciate all your commentary. I am very happy to find people with the same love towards mamamoo. This is the first time I stanned an artist this hard and thank you for bringing us all together through your videos.
They are an amazing group. Can't wait for their online concert next week💕✨
Appreciate the commentary. It fit well with the song and its place in the cyclical concept of the 4 Color 4 Season project. Each title track presented a stage in a relationship and Wind Flower was obviously about the heartache of a breakup. You have to go through it but try to remember that grief has its season and it will pass but, to paraphrase what you said in terms of the 4S4C concepts, it's one of the intense emotional colors that paint our lives and make us who we are so we shouldn't try to avoid or repress those feelings.
As someone else pointed out, each member portrays a different emotional stage in dealing with the breakup so you could think of it as 4 people at different points in the process or the members representing four stages of one person's experience. Then they come together towards the end of the MV. You'll see the same format in all the 4S4C title track MVs - I call it the four into one concept where all the different aspects of the emotion/experience are unified. Besides the cyclical life lesson symbolism this concept also reflects their belief that they were destined to be best friends, which they explicitly express in the follow up album to the 4S4C project, reality in BLACK, in songs like Destiny, 4X4ever and Universe.
Mamamoo has an online concert on Saturday, at 9pm EST! Come join us Moo Moos in jamming and appreciating the ladies. 🥰
the views do no justice to the amazingly classic song
I believe this was produced and composed by Park Woo Sang and Kim Do Hoon. They work on a lot of Mamamoo's music
Mamamoo is deff one of those groups that just makes you smile and makes your day better. kinda like Pentagons song Shine
6:53 exactly. Mamamoo and BTS are like big brothers and sisters who comfort me when I feel down and make me happy. Their music is really touching deep in my heart. I admire these 11 people very much and aspire to have their work ethic in the future.
Windflower Moonbyul is my favorite Moonbyul in all MMM songs, both visuals & vocal-wise. I can feel her pain (and because her lyrics, man. She wrote it and im 100% sure it's based on actual experience)
Ohhh🥺🥺One of my favourite song rrom Mamamoo and in general 💝
Love hearing your thoughts as always! Thank you for supporting Mamamoo and sharing your reaction to Wind Flower :)
Wind flower its my fav mamamoo song and im always sad about the fact that it and was so underrated, its a fckng masterpiece
Hi I recommend their Sleep In The Car Comeback Stage! It’s definitely Moonbyul’s element.
this song should get atleast 1 win
You should really hit Logos channel since my all time favorite shots of wind flower era was there. The song was the 4seasons outro but the vibe of wind era just fit perfectly somehow in that songs.
Also the stages of this era just 😘👌
The vibe the stages the songs, overall this was one of many moomoo favorite era, but well maybe it was international moomoo tho, since the girls actually feel they dont receive many support and love when this songs come out. (They talked about it in the mnet comeback stage)
your reactions to Mamamoo are glorious
The vocals on this song are so damn good
Windflower such a bop!
I love everything about the girls and their music.
your words brings comforts. thank u bro.
Your mamamoo's video reaction always so enlighten cause you really see trough everything seeking the lyrics meaning, or the mv itself. Analysis the music, instrumens and more. I love it, always love your reaction thank youuuu
please react to Bumkey(범키) _ The Lady (Feat. Moon Byul(문별) of MAMAMOO
Moonbyul's vocal !
Yeah, I love to listen to this song too. This era was JUST AMAZING. The stages of this song were awesome too. You will like it. I hope you make a reaction to their album as soon too 🥰. Thank you so much for this. I really enjoyed it as always.
Love your reactions and love Mamamoo. They are my famourites❤️❤️
Hi, thanks for your reaction, they will have a comeback on 2nd June, trailer is out
Beautiful reaction and words brother! keep it up
Have seen so many other reactions but i'd stay for 14 minutes or so, knowing i'd hear your mind out. It's soo deep and it's soo good to keep digging in there. Your reactions are reflections at the same time. Keep doin what you doin man. Inspiration
You & your words 🧡
Mama moo killing voice
Literally yesterday I started watching your Mamamoo videos and I was waiting so anxious for you to upload the reaction to Wind Flower, you heard my prayers mwkdmwmdk
Dude, I've been a whole Sunday's afternoon watching your arc with mamamoo lmao. I'm glad that I feel soooo relatable with your experience knowing them, Thank u for create such a great content
6:18 i totally understand this feelings and agree to this! im an armymoo and these people lift my spirits a lot and i luv them so much for it
This song is perfect indeed, I always love the comentary too ❤
واوووو احبهم ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Gracias al infinito y al mas alla por hacer que estos 4 talentos coincidieran y formaran mamamoo sisi muy buena reaccion 😀😘
Best MAMAMOO title track.
I noticed that about how Hwasa came in too. I also noticed that in a lot of songs, Hwasa goes in first and I think it’s really strategic because her voice has a certain captivating quality. Like a “wait, this sounds different. what is this?” type of thing. Then once you’re hooked, the other members come in and you go “heyyyy heyyyy them vocals”.... And then they harmonize and now you’re a moomoo 😂 That’s what happened to me
Wow... I felt like I was in therapy. Thank you, the way you explain things smooth like wow 😲. But also thank you for the reaction of wind flower💚.
God Windflower is that song for me, timeless. Idk if they used Greek Mythology for this but i know Windflower is related to Adonis and Aphrodite's story and its very sad. Im an eng and lit major so i stanned extra hard when this was released
Lmao lengthy commentary had me cracking up 🤣
Omg when he said they are his favorite girl group im so happy! Hahahah for real
This Is a masterpiece 😊
I agree to all the things that you said. Very well said, my friend. 👌
I swear it's 00:40 am but u already made me feel a 100 time better, ur words are so healing 🤍🤍& that's what I was telling myself but I guess we always forget things. Thank u tho & my fav group was there too so🤗
Mamamoo queens ❤️
This song is underrated. I read somewhere in yt in other reactors in the comment sections saying that MMM was sad that this song didn't get any win(I think it was Hwasa saying) because they personally thought that this song is personal and one of their best.
She wasn't sad because it didn't get a win
She was sad because it didn't do well generally
Bro you are literally the wisest person I ever listened talk
I’m always early , no shame about it 😂
love early birds ❤
Loved that commentary, i think it is both about personal love and a breakup story :)
"they make me happy" yeah boi. same here. my entire youtube recommendation is just mamamoo and gahd i just get sucked in everytime i open youtube because SEROTONIN BOOST RIGHT THERE
Do you know that they have Japanese ver of this MV. You should check it out.
Dude - Music aside, your takes are really inspiring and positive. It's awesome to see.
Effect - a change that is a result or consequence of an action or other cause. Affect - touch the feelings of; move emotionally. 🤣
hommage Wang Kar Wai's movie. he was a legendary movie director before.
I’m in love with this channel 🥺
Pls react to Big Mama Dinggo Killing Voice! You won’t regret it. Created by YG and the pioneer of Big Bang & Blackpink. They recently have a comback and their vocals are out of this world.
this is the best title track on their four season project but I'm so sad that it got the least attention