@@sarahkulavoor7914 him dancing represents that he's lost in his own world. he's lost in his mind and sees his imagination as a safe place. a place he can run to, far away from reality and its problems, and stay there forever because he doesn't want to face the truth. him dancing into darkness however, explains how this will eventually lead him to his death. if he keeps ignoring his problems, his feelings and his reality will become so complex that he will get lost in the darkness he created for himself a.k.a the real world.
Wow, this analysis is amazing! And you just made me notice that... every txt mv since run away has portrayed the magic island of each member. Run away is Taehyung's, cysm Soobin's, Blue hour Beomgyu's and now Lovesong is Yeonjun's. So next mv must be about Huening Kai!
@@sunflowerinthect6576 I think them all have fallen into it but yeonjun and beomgyu are the ones who were more literal. But if you pay attention since run away they all start alone and the others join later, like tae at the school hallway and soobin at his home
@@michaeljacksonlover255 thanks fellow moonwalker lol we're okay :) But for real i really relate to this in a way, I always try to escape reality, i get depressed many times, life is just full of struggles and happy memories too, but TXT is my magic island that's why I'm very thankful for their existence in my life♡
@@raspberryvamp That is very heart wrenching to hear fellow moa.. just know that you are never alone, and that people who truly loves you will always be there by your side, and i know i am here too!! No one deserves to go through this, the only thing i could wish for right now is for you to stay strong and always remember that you are loved and cherished no matter what ♡
I get "I Need U" vibes from this song/MV... BigHit are absolute geniuses!!! Shout out to Bookish Theories for being able to connect these clues/metaphors into a linear/coherent plot line! As a nerd, I pick up on a lot, but I struggle to make the connections between different references, so I'm very grateful to Bookish as an ARMY with a HYBE bias.
I love how everything make sense now, the way every single thing in their lyrics, music video are connected to different concepts, series, movies, psychology, philosophy...it made me feel the same emotions which are actually real, i always try to escape this bad reality/problems by listening to TXT music or dreaming being with them (our magic island) "i know it's real i can feel it" i can feel the love that TXT and MOA share, we're each others' drug.. everyone wants to escape reality but don't want to lose ourselves in our black hole and eventually forget to live. i don't think that there's another artist that will make me question my confused self and relate to the messages they want people to get through their music. LOVE U TOMORROW X TOGETHER
After seeing this video, all I could say is WOW. TXT referenced to a lot of works. Such as fairy tales and books, it's actually very cool. And you explanation is very good and detailed. Loved it!
Ah! Thank you for making this! I'm not a MOA but i really enjoy some of TXT's songs including this latest release. I was wondering what certain things interpret as and now I do.
I just realized that black holes suck or pull things in but dont let anything out.....and if the theory is about imagination or fantasy which is compared to a black hole..... Iam just understanding everything now
Tysm dear for this explanation it was soo clear n kind of made me sad to know the meaning behind that song even though i knew that he was dreaming but still....
I really like your breakdown as usual, just wanted to share a couple of my thoughts. First of all where is the clip of Yeonjun bowling in the arcade world from?? I have never seen that before. I also saw the references to IT and I think that they are alluding to the Joker movie from last year with Joaquin Phoenix as well as that movie also deals heavily with themes of social isolation and self-destruction and YJ imagining his friends being there reminded me of how the Joker imagines the girl he likes being with him for much of the movie. YJ is also wearing a Joker earring in the "You" concept photos so that's another hint. I also think there is something going on with Huening Kai that you don't address in the video but I don't know what it is. The biggest clue is the scene where they are driving in the car and he looks out the window and sees a fish and clearly sees it as he reacts to it. He's the only other character who reacts to a fish besides YJ. Soobin, Taehyun, and BG may appear in scenes with fish but they don't indicate that they can see them like Kai does. Furthermore, Idk if you realized but I have been thinking about that scene with the animals from the Eternity concept trailer for a year now. There are 4 animals shown and they are VERY INTENTIONAL: a bunny (Soobin's emoji), a bear (Beomgyu's), a squirrel/wolverine (Taehyun's), and a fox (Yeonjun's). There is no penguin for Huening Kai and this is clearly meant to tell us that Huening Kai isn't in the fantasy. I'm not sure what that means though in the context of the story. My first thought is that Kai is actually dead which seemed to be the case in the Eternally MV and that in this video he's actually more of a ghost than a hallucination: he can see the fish and knows YJ is dreaming because he's already passed on? I would really like to know what you think of this. Thanks!
Totally waited many days for this! I already to the numerous references but this thorough analysis is always keeping me on-track everytime! Though it is really about their storyline, it does contribute to the psychological and state of those people who relates to TXT, us MOA of course! And I can really relate to the message context of this; alienation and growth as well as the metaphorical implications embroidered to this piece of art.
This is so well explained but my question is : Why Taehyun is the only one wearing cast? Is something gonna happen to him in +u mv just like Eddie in IT ?
maybe it's just to make reference to IT, but there has to be a reason why it was him and not another one who wore the cast, you're right. hum, it watched IT a long time ago, so i don't remember why Eddie got hurt nor what happened to him. in some situatuons he has been exposed to be hurt: Taehyun was attacked by Beomgyu in CYSM. he is the one who awakened the dragon again (maybe, since he found the easter egg). and he found yeonjun dead in Eternally and also in The Star Seekers, so the cat could have attacked him next. they're all losers who become lovers. the only reason that comes to my mind why he could be considered more of a loser, is because he's a true angel (he's looking for a clues that can lead him to beaking the loop and remembering the song of the star) and isn't recognised as one. instead, he knows more than the others about what is happening, he is more aware, so that could be the reason of his pain (??). in that case, the pain would be psycologic. in short: i have no idea. let's wait for our fav Italian to give us her opinion
it reminds me of the MV Can't you see me. where Beomgyu choked(?) Taehyun and in Beomgyu's hoodie was written LOVER. I think that's why he has a wound on his hand and wore cast.
woahh i just remembered in the teaser the camera angle with how it looked like yeonjun was dancing inside the aquarium may mean that he was inside his made up fantasies, it makes sense wow
Wow, I really like the way you connected all the bits with the references to other media and old clues. I wondered about the ending where Yeonjun woke up alone. Also I'm amazed how you predicted the space concept that we now got with the Magic MV :o Thank you for the video!
soo i did a little research regarding the ferris wheel seen in the MV and apparently : a ferris wheel can also represent something exciting or enjoyable in your waking hours- however it isn't consistent- there are regular pauses in this pleasurable experience. You may want something that is going well to have no end but are coming to terms with the fact that it will eventually. ; kinda feel that there's a connection with the other MV's and considering the title of the song ..........
Someone also mentioned that beta fishes are generally kept alone and in isolation since they don't do well with other fishes, so there was some symbolism there potentially too!
Your videos are so well made!!! You definitely put a lot of effort into them. I always enjoy your explanations because it makes me appreciate the songs and the boys more. keep going please, you are amazing!!!!
you are so underrated i love your videos ... me being a brainless moa I don't know anything!! i don't know what your name is but I love the way you connect the dots. its so mesmerizing hearing these all therios and connections...i don't know how hybe make's these storylines ... your videos are very informative and actually are SO DAMN CONNECTED!! my brain isn't currently functioning after hearing all the theories....
This is one of the most thoughtful and helpful analysis videos I've ever seen, thank you so much for bringing light to all these different elements in the video and concept!!!
thank you so much for this video, I had some similar interpretations as I watched the mv a few times and watching your videos made thing clear for me, thanks a lot!
so... Magic island isn't A specific place, but it's a world they created whenever they want to escape from this cruel world? god why am i feel so related :(
I, always wondering why am i so sad for this one comeback, why is it felt so deep yet i didn't understand anyword... Then i saw some reaction, read some moa's comment and saw this and at the end i realise... Yeonjun (in the story) is basically me, we suffer the same stuff with diferent cause, maybe for those who didn't felt it, it was just like a sorrow type of story... But in reality, it's like a curse for me yet, it was that beautifull... to the point if i let it go i feel die, the story when yeonjun just stealing the car, drive with his imagimary friends play along, dance along go crazy and ended up... Waking up in the reality it's an endless sorrow for me, yet it's so beautifull that i can fall for it like, forever... I know it's a lil bit unecessary to write it here, but i just think if i let it out i'll be loosen up my weight, hope ya'll who read my comment can take it to the positive side and learn from me okay~ Friends that you built and friends that build you it's diferent they maybe felt same but last in the diferent time, your real friends may not last as forever as your built friends.... But they are true, and you need them, so before you fall like me... go and shout it loud to your beloved one that you need help, you need their hands... otherwise like yeonjun and me you're gonna sink deep down dark and it's very very super hard to escape ^^ Luv you all~
who are You, genius? Your amazing theories are based on a deep knowledge of philosophy and psychology, as well as literature. Are you a professor? Plus, you're amazingly editing videos. Are you IT? Introduce yourself to YT.
![CAN'T YOU SEE ME? EXPLAINED 🔥 [TXT UNIVERSE THEORY]](/img/n.gif)
I literally got goosebumps when you made the connection with that vcr
Damn bighit be planning everything since the 16th century
that vcr is from their fanlive this year, and it was filmed on eternity era
i was so shocked too! the fish and everything!
IKRRR BIGHIT HAS PLANS MORE THAN THE PPL IN MY HISTORY BOOK
My sister when Yeonjun started dancing: *laughs wholeheartedly
Me when Yeonjun started dancing: *laughs nervously cause I knew that shit means sth
Same lol I was like
"This shit is sus"
I actually didn't understand that part, could you explain please?
Yeah i actually didnt understand to- what actually is happening?
@@sarahkulavoor7914 him dancing represents that he's lost in his own world. he's lost in his mind and sees his imagination as a safe place. a place he can run to, far away from reality and its problems, and stay there forever because he doesn't want to face the truth. him dancing into darkness however, explains how this will eventually lead him to his death. if he keeps ignoring his problems, his feelings and his reality will become so complex that he will get lost in the darkness he created for himself a.k.a the real world.
Wow, this analysis is amazing! And you just made me notice that... every txt mv since run away has portrayed the magic island of each member. Run away is Taehyung's, cysm Soobin's, Blue hour Beomgyu's and now Lovesong is Yeonjun's. So next mv must be about Huening Kai!
this is so exciting omg
So is Yeonjun the only one who has fallen into his darkness/fantasy? Are the other boys also lost?
@@sunflowerinthect6576 I think them all have fallen into it but yeonjun and beomgyu are the ones who were more literal. But if you pay attention since run away they all start alone and the others join later, like tae at the school hallway and soobin at his home
Taehyung is a BTS member :D
but can't you see me it's kind of dark tho,
They are litturally showing me my current life right now
i felt this
omg same here
I hope you are all okay:((
@@michaeljacksonlover255 thanks fellow moonwalker lol we're okay :)
But for real i really relate to this in a way,
I always try to escape reality, i get depressed many times, life is just full of struggles and happy memories too, but TXT is my magic island that's why I'm very thankful for their existence in my life♡
@@raspberryvamp That is very heart wrenching to hear fellow moa.. just know that you are never alone, and that people who truly loves you will always be there by your side, and i know i am here too!! No one deserves to go through this, the only thing i could wish for right now is for you to stay strong and always remember that you are loved and cherished no matter what ♡
Ok but this hit too close to home
I love the way TXT made me start learning about myself and exploring the confusion that I'm going through
Y-E-S
I get "I Need U" vibes from this song/MV... BigHit are absolute geniuses!!!
Shout out to Bookish Theories for being able to connect these clues/metaphors into a linear/coherent plot line!
As a nerd, I pick up on a lot, but I struggle to make the connections between different references, so I'm very grateful to Bookish as an ARMY with a HYBE bias.
4:34 yeah yeonjun steals a lot. The last time he steal moa heart and didnt return it yet
specially in BOY photos, omg
It's scary you ended this with saying they will probably be going into SCI-FI territory soon and then the Magic MV drops.
True.. Goosebumps all over
moas and stays are one of the smartest fandoms I’ve come across 😭
I love how everything make sense now, the way every single thing in their lyrics, music video are connected to different concepts, series, movies, psychology, philosophy...it made me feel the same emotions which are actually real, i always try to escape this bad reality/problems by listening to TXT music or dreaming being with them (our magic island) "i know it's real i can feel it" i can feel the love that TXT and MOA share, we're each others' drug.. everyone wants to escape reality but don't want to lose ourselves in our black hole and eventually forget to live. i don't think that there's another artist that will make me question my confused self and relate to the messages they want people to get through their music. LOVE U TOMORROW X TOGETHER
TYSM for this... i was really confusedd this cleared soo many things
After seeing this video, all I could say is WOW.
TXT referenced to a lot of works. Such as fairy tales and books, it's actually very cool.
And you explanation is very good and detailed. Loved it!
DAMN this song is hitting me hard, now that you’ve explained it so well, I am actually crying on how this also fits with my current situation
when yeonjun started dancing and the othr guys followed i started crying idk why
i'm proud i investigated myself, now i understand your explanation better!
Now that's why they have a Sci fi theme at magic's Mv Teaser!!
YES
You know this is what you wait for when a new mv is out!
What an amazing take! All i noticed was that Kai was wearing a shirt I saw on Shameless.. I appreciate how much you dive into each element 💕
This song totally wholesome ............a daebak producing .....love this best song forever. 💕
Ah! Thank you for making this! I'm not a MOA but i really enjoy some of TXT's songs including this latest release. I was wondering what certain things interpret as and now I do.
Who else is seeing this analysis after seeing the trailer of MAGIC remembering the sci-fi explanation for next video or comeback?
though i saw this vid for the first time, but yep what bookish theories was so on point
@@lovemazez yeah she is
I just realized that black holes suck or pull things in but dont let anything out.....and if the theory is about imagination or fantasy which is compared to a black hole.....
Iam just understanding everything now
Tysm dear for this explanation it was soo clear n kind of made me sad to know the meaning behind that song even though i knew that he was dreaming but still....
YAS GIRLLL WAS THINKING ABOUT YOUR LOVESONG UPDATE JUST AN HOUR AGOOO
I really like your breakdown as usual, just wanted to share a couple of my thoughts. First of all where is the clip of Yeonjun bowling in the arcade world from?? I have never seen that before. I also saw the references to IT and I think that they are alluding to the Joker movie from last year with Joaquin Phoenix as well as that movie also deals heavily with themes of social isolation and self-destruction and YJ imagining his friends being there reminded me of how the Joker imagines the girl he likes being with him for much of the movie. YJ is also wearing a Joker earring in the "You" concept photos so that's another hint. I also think there is something going on with Huening Kai that you don't address in the video but I don't know what it is. The biggest clue is the scene where they are driving in the car and he looks out the window and sees a fish and clearly sees it as he reacts to it. He's the only other character who reacts to a fish besides YJ. Soobin, Taehyun, and BG may appear in scenes with fish but they don't indicate that they can see them like Kai does. Furthermore, Idk if you realized but I have been thinking about that scene with the animals from the Eternity concept trailer for a year now. There are 4 animals shown and they are VERY INTENTIONAL: a bunny (Soobin's emoji), a bear (Beomgyu's), a squirrel/wolverine (Taehyun's), and a fox (Yeonjun's). There is no penguin for Huening Kai and this is clearly meant to tell us that Huening Kai isn't in the fantasy. I'm not sure what that means though in the context of the story. My first thought is that Kai is actually dead which seemed to be the case in the Eternally MV and that in this video he's actually more of a ghost than a hallucination: he can see the fish and knows YJ is dreaming because he's already passed on? I would really like to know what you think of this. Thanks!
Totally waited many days for this! I already to the numerous references but this thorough analysis is always keeping me on-track everytime! Though it is really about their storyline, it does contribute to the psychological and state of those people who relates to TXT, us MOA of course! And I can really relate to the message context of this; alienation and growth as well as the metaphorical implications embroidered to this piece of art.
This is so well explained but my question is : Why Taehyun is the only one wearing cast? Is something gonna happen to him in +u mv just like Eddie in IT ?
maybe it's just to make reference to IT, but there has to be a reason why it was him and not another one who wore the cast, you're right.
hum, it watched IT a long time ago, so i don't remember why Eddie got hurt nor what happened to him. in some situatuons he has been exposed to be hurt: Taehyun was attacked by Beomgyu in CYSM. he is the one who awakened the dragon again (maybe, since he found the easter egg). and he found yeonjun dead in Eternally and also in The Star Seekers, so the cat could have attacked him next.
they're all losers who become lovers. the only reason that comes to my mind why he could be considered more of a loser, is because he's a true angel (he's looking for a clues that can lead him to beaking the loop and remembering the song of the star) and isn't recognised as one. instead, he knows more than the others about what is happening, he is more aware, so that could be the reason of his pain (??). in that case, the pain would be psycologic.
in short: i have no idea. let's wait for our fav Italian to give us her opinion
@@naralopez8782 oh maybe you're right! thanks for your explanation ^_^
@@naralopez8782 how the fuck are y’all so smart 😔
In a reaction video txt did Taehyun said him taking the cast off symbolises breaking free so maybe the cast means they’re bounded by something?
it reminds me of the MV Can't you see me. where Beomgyu choked(?) Taehyun and in Beomgyu's hoodie was written LOVER. I think that's why he has a wound on his hand and wore cast.
you really read my mind! I was thinking about going to watch your 0X1=LOVESONG theories when it comes out and here i am 😂
yall i really need to know who comes up with these storylines and ideas bighit give them a raise
Whoa, you never fail to blow my mind!! 🤯 Thank you for making theories for us! ❤️
this makes me realize how much meaning there actually is to the mv and the song and i think it's so beautiful
i was watching this, chilling and fascinated by how smart you are, and suddenly : unstoppable tears
Everytime i heard this song. I cried. Like i cried. I find that this song is really really sad..
woahh i just remembered in the teaser the camera angle with how it looked like yeonjun was dancing inside the aquarium may mean that he was inside his made up fantasies, it makes sense wow
As always there's so much attention to the details... Is beautiful
Hey Bookish theories! aweeeeeeeeeee was waiting for you. thank you so much for the video!)
Wow, I really like the way you connected all the bits with the references to other media and old clues. I wondered about the ending where Yeonjun woke up alone. Also I'm amazed how you predicted the space concept that we now got with the Magic MV :o
Thank you for the video!
i literally got goosebumps! you just blown my mind! i love your brain! tysm for this!
thank God I started watching the videos I missed since two days ago because I understood everythinggggg here, bookish theories is my go-to no cap
Tysm for everything.. After watching this explanation everything is more clear thank you very much..
soo i did a little research regarding the ferris wheel seen in the MV and apparently : a ferris wheel can also represent something exciting or enjoyable in your waking hours- however it isn't consistent- there are regular pauses in this pleasurable experience. You may want something that is going well to have no end but are coming to terms with the fact that it will eventually. ; kinda feel that there's a connection with the other MV's and considering the title of the song ..........
Someone also mentioned that beta fishes are generally kept alone and in isolation since they don't do well with other fishes, so there was some symbolism there potentially too!
Producer: How many references do you want in yor MV?
TXT: yes
this video is so good and it wraps up so many things (lyrics, photo books and outer references) omg it is really underrated
11:33 I AM SO SHOCKED.
14:59 The HAPPINESS Chapter, I SEE YOU.
aaa thank youu,, ive been waiting
Thank you so much! I've been waiting for your video about their new song, you really explain things well!
Your videos are so well made!!! You definitely put a lot of effort into them. I always enjoy your explanations because it makes me appreciate the songs and the boys more. keep going please, you are amazing!!!!
Brilliantly presented in a thorough and detailed manner. Thank you, Bookish Theories, for all your hard work and in-depth research.
You and your videos are literally the best! Pls, never stop doing them
wahh this was so interesting to listen to, kpop stans are truly amazing coming up with such detailed theories
tysm!! your theories are always the best ㅠ^ㅠ♡♡
you are so underrated i love your videos ... me being a brainless moa I don't know anything!!
i don't know what your name is but I love the way you connect the dots. its so mesmerizing hearing these all therios and connections...i don't know how hybe make's these storylines ...
your videos are very informative and actually are SO DAMN CONNECTED!! my brain isn't currently functioning after hearing all the theories....
Your mind...I'm always so amazed!
Thank you for this video. I can really appreciate their story line thanks to you.
loved the analysis!!! another thing is that yj's hair is wet when he wakes up, so it makes complete sense!
Been waiting for you
I love them and I'm an army 💜 💕
15:26 >19:37 the way he wiggles out of camera sight is just to adorable and funny 🤣😂
Lets hear it..been waiting...i cannot process by myself.
I always cry for songs like these
I WAS WAITING FOR THIS
the way you predicted magic's mv and loser=lover cb!!!
This is one of the most thoughtful and helpful analysis videos I've ever seen, thank you so much for bringing light to all these different elements in the video and concept!!!
SUDDENLY MY DAY ISNT SO BAD ANYMORE🤩🤩🤩
this song gives me goosebumps
I've been waiting!😆🥳🥳🥳
thank you so much for this video, I had some similar interpretations as I watched the mv a few times and watching your videos made thing clear for me, thanks a lot!
YESS I WAS WAITING FOR THIS
This is basically an almost 20min explanation of what I am going through rn
Thank you, I've been waiting for these💙💙
so... Magic island isn't A specific place, but it's a world they created whenever they want to escape from this cruel world?
god why am i feel so related :(
I, always wondering why am i so sad for this one comeback, why is it felt so deep yet i didn't understand anyword...
Then i saw some reaction, read some moa's comment and saw this and at the end i realise...
Yeonjun (in the story) is basically me, we suffer the same stuff with diferent cause, maybe for those who didn't felt it, it was just like a sorrow type of story...
But in reality, it's like a curse for me yet, it was that beautifull... to the point if i let it go i feel die, the story when yeonjun just stealing the car, drive with his imagimary friends play along, dance along go crazy and ended up...
Waking up in the reality it's an endless sorrow for me, yet it's so beautifull that i can fall for it like, forever...
I know it's a lil bit unecessary to write it here, but i just think if i let it out i'll be loosen up my weight, hope ya'll who read my comment can take it to the positive side and learn from me okay~
Friends that you built and friends that build you it's diferent they maybe felt same but last in the diferent time, your real friends may not last as forever as your built friends....
But they are true, and you need them, so before you fall like me... go and shout it loud to your beloved one that you need help, you need their hands... otherwise like yeonjun and me you're gonna sink deep down dark and it's very very super hard to escape ^^
Luv you all~
I swear when i saw yeonjun woke up alone and the car not burnt my heart dropped
Damn, you are a genius.
you're so smart i love you
Thank you so much for sharing this with us, you are a true genius!
You are my favorite theorist 😭
thank you for an amazing explanation!!
I learn so much from these videos. Thank you.
God, you're a genius😭
Damm,the Hybe interns are really doing all the research for making a music video.
The story is more psychological that i thought…
Wow! I'm early! Thank you Bookish theories❤❤
This is so cool and deep thank you
Thank you so much! Your video made me perceive I didn't understand much about this song...
I love your channel
Wahhhh !! U did such a great work like it’s just so helpful,well explained and we just see how hard u worked, ty !
Tysm there's a lot of metaphor in the music video and i can't handle it that much , haha..
thank you for the help..
영어를 몰라 자동번역으로 보고있습니다. 늘 감사하고 있어요.
These are so clever!!! Thank you!!
who are You, genius? Your amazing theories are based on a deep knowledge of philosophy and psychology, as well as literature. Are you a professor? Plus, you're amazingly editing videos. Are you IT? Introduce yourself to YT.
Thank you I was confused at first
Thank you for another great video!!
I was looking forward to this. 💜👍
Whole fandom is waiting for sci-fi/space concept, but bighit music keeps teasing us... lol (Blue Hour JPN, Run away MV)/// SAVE US
i realized that yeonjun's scene in the fish tank is very similar to mima's scene in the fish tank in the film perfect blue
Omg!! I’m late!
Oh well, what a great time to get smarter-
In the middle of the night
Thanks for your explanation... now a lot things solve in my mind.
OH MY GOD I MISS YOU FINALLY! 💜 BTW DID YOU ENJOY THE MV TOO HEHE?...
Only thing that i don't have a group of great friends and I gotta deal with it untill i become independent