There is a man who has fallen ill, he has to be cured, research says it is a virus. This is creation, God is doing it, science says no, it is big bang, reason for bigbang, searching.....
Bhagat Singh nastik the aisa gyan aapko kisne diya? --- Britisho ne. Kyo ki Gore ye chahate the ki Bhagat Singh ko fansi dene ke baad jan aakrosh kranti me na badal jaye. Bhagat Singh ko nastik batane se jan aakrosh dab jaata. Gorone zoothe jawab aur patr jaari kar ke uski nastik chabi janmanas me basa di jo aaj bhi kai adhpadh murkho ko sach lagti hai.
इतनी शानदार बौद्धिक चर्चा को देखकर मन प्रसन्न हो गया और कमेंट्स को देखकर तो विथ ग्रेस ऑफ गॉड यही प्रार्थना करता हूँ भगवान से कि इंशाल्लाह भारत का भविष्य नास्तिक और वैज्ञानिक ही हो ! 😅
बहुत अच्छी चर्चा हुई । बहुत ही अच्छा विषय रखा गया । आस्तिकता एवं नास्तिकता चलती ही रहेगी । मेरे हिसाब से यह सत्य है कि ईश्वर नहीं होता है और यदि ईश्वर को हम मानते हैं अर्थात ईश्वर का नाम रखा गया है तो वह प्रकृति है । प्रकृति ही ईश्वर है । प्रकृति ही भगवान है और प्रकृति का संचालन विज्ञानिक तरीके से निश्चित नियमों के साथ होता है और यह नियम सभी प्राकृतिक हैं । प्रकृति का वास्तविक स्वरूप नहीं है । यह एक आदृश्य हो सकती है और प्रकृति में विभिन्न प्रकार के भौतिक पदार्थ हैं । वही ईश्वर का स्वरूप हो जाते है । इसलिए भगवान अर्थात प्रकृति का कोई स्वरूप नहीं है वह निराकार है । किंतु भौतिक पदार्थों के माध्यम से वह आकार के रूप में भी है। यह भी सत्य है कि मनुष्य ने ईश्वर को काल्पनिक रूप से गड़ा है।
SIR apne bahut achhi bat kahi lekin prakurti ko bhee bhgwan samjana aur usko dhanda banana ye bat puri traha se galat he kivaki prakriti me koi bhav (sense) nahi hota matlab uski puja karna aur usko gali dena ye dono bate murkhta he hum sirf uske prati moun raha sakate he jaise ki thathgat GAUTAM BUDDHA rahe
जब कोई व्यक्ति हॉस्पिटल में ट्रीटमेंट के दौरान मर जाता हैडॉक्टरों की देख रेख में वह तो सब साइंस तो क्यो मर जाता है वह और आदमी मरता क्यो है और खोज करने वाले वैज्ञानिक भी मर गए इसका मतलब मरना नही चाहिए था उसको पर में ये कहना चाहता अगर विज्ञान से जीने में आसानी हो गयी है और वह सब कुछ नही है अगर किसी का पैर कट जाए तो क्या विज्ञान उसका उसी तरह का पैर दे सकता है नही इसलिए विज्ञान भी पूरी तरह से सफल नही है और ये सब मशीनरी नही थी तब भी मनुष्य जिंदगी जी रहा था और अब भी जी रहा है
@@BeHappyBeKind07 Monotheistic religion's been ridiculed all over the world. The debate wasn't about if Hindu God exist or Allah or Jesus exist. Dude hasn't even watched the video and asking people to read Vivekananda, lol.
Acha bhai pehla bandar kaun tha uski photo hai ? Vigyan ke pass andho ko sury prakash nahi dikh sakta ab tum ab vigyani apne khud ke bal se nai prithvi (Mangal grah ka use nahi) apne khud ke matrial se naya prithvi grah kab bana rahe hai
@@Samir20112 pehla bandar ka photo kaise milega tab camera thodi tha...bandar ek din mei nahi bana matlab evolution nam ki bhi kuch chiz hei😂 haan par scientist ne fossils se uska structure habit cranial capacity zaroor bata diya hei..google p dekh le
@@buttercup2991 le accha akal ki andhi to bhagwan raste main chalta koi vigyan ni hai photo lade ya bat karle wah re doglo jab khud ke pass jawab na ho to ghatiya word use karo yahi sikhati hai science acha waisa hi dikhta hoga uska kya praman hai kuch bhi photo video dikhao kya hua jab khud ki bari main to pathhar ko fossils bol do hum kyun mane aise myths ko
Hindustan अकेला देश है। जहां पर 99%लोग झूठा जीवन जीते है। Pandey जी ने सही कहा यूरोप में 80%लोग nastik है। बहुत अच्छा जीवन जीते हैं मैंने इंटरमीडिएट के बाद धर्म की किताबे padhni सुरु की विज्ञान पढ़ा और nastik हो गया na मुझे भूत से डर na Bhagwan से
Main ek ladka hoon main Australia mein rehta hoon japan mein job karta hoon...USA ka president tha 5saal.. Jackie Chan mera bhai hai ... Roz zeher khata hoon... petrol Peeta hoon... Insari baaton mein sirf ek cheez satya hai "Main ek ladka hoon " .... Aapke anusar meri baaton mein 1% sachhai to hai toh kya meri baat satya hai.....aur aap aise hi sari illogical jhuti baaton ko satya maan loge ???
@@arupkumarjena5178 abbe he wanted to say ki agar 1% log bhi satya ko maane toh woh satya hi rhega! And you intertrepreted it as agar 1% bhi satya hai toh poori baat satya hai😑
विद्याधर जी, इतना आसानी से आपने लिखा कि "ईश्वर" झूठ है, इस पर मेरा कहना है कि "ईश्वर" एक "नाम" ( Noun) है , इस संसार में मौजूद सभी शक्तियों, सभी पदार्थों के सम्मिलित स्वरुप का , एक उदहारण दूँ - एक परिवार में एक "बच्चा" पैदा होता है, जब वो बच्चा दो - तीन दिन का होता है, और उसका नाम-करण नहीं हुआ होता है, आप ये तो मानते ही होंगे कि उस बच्चे में पदार्थों के रूप में हड्डी, खाल, बाल, आँखें, ह्रदय, आंतें, आदि आदि मौजूद होते हैं, साथ ही साथ उस बच्चे में कुछ system भी होते हैं जैसे- देखने का सिस्टम, Respiratory System, Digestive System, Excretory System, सोचने का सिस्टम आदि आदि, Q - सर, क्या आप ये मानते हैं ?? I will write more after your answer ...
ईश्वर को न चख सकते हैं न सूंघ सकते है न छू सकते हैं न सुन सकते हैं और न देख सकते हैं ईश्वर में स्पर्श गुण नहीं है रूप नहीं है | रस नहीं है | गंध नहीं है | शब्द नहीं है | सब चीज़ का प्रमाण चाहिए पर जिस की हम सब को ज्यादा जरूरत है उसकी प्रमाणा मत खोजो सिर्फ विस्वास करो कमाल है ना इंसानियत से बड़ा धर्म कुछ नहीं में एक नास्तिक हूँ और मुझे इस पर गर्व है
अगर इंसानियत सबसे बड़ा धर्म है। तो मनुष्य स्वयं को नहीं जानता तो वह कैसे बता सकता कि इन्सानियत सबसे बड़ा धर्म है।जो मनुष्य स्वयं को नहीं जानता वह वह बोलेगा कुछ करेगा कुछ। परिवर्तन सत्य नहीं है।
Very nice and rational debate. It was a pleasure to listen to these people. Nowadays I can't believe any news channel showing anything else than Hindu-Muslim debates.
Science kaise reality hai acha ye batao ki kuch ghatna jaise ki khud vigyani jisko sabit nahi kar pate wo ghatna tumhre hisab se hui hi nahi tum jan nahi sakte ya tumhri aukat se bahar hai wo exist nahi karti
@Raj Chanana what is reality did you read ved Or any book of old scripture, let's did know about ramanuja charya he said he's maths knowledge given by his kuldevi so ramanuja charya is wrong he is grate mathematician why science is always try to defame believe or gods
@@irfanmohmad1403 बिल्कुल नहीं भाई, यह कैसे बनते हैं इसको विज्ञान बता बता कर थक गया, पूरे दिन discovery चैनल पर यही आता रहता है की चाँद तारे कैसे बने, वहाँ से अच्छे से जान लो, विज्ञान की किताबें पढ़ लो पूरी प्रक्रिया पता चल जाएगी। बस ये वहम मत पालो की मुझे पता है की कैसे बने चाँद तारे। पढ़ाई करो और जानो, मानो मत।
@@Rjesh8 मैं कोई गुरु तो नहीं जो आपको सत्य के बारे में बता सकूं, पर इतना बड़ा सवाल पूछने के लिए धन्यवाद। इतना ज़रूर बता सकता हूँ की बड़े लोगों ने कहा है की सत्य को जाना नहीं जा सकता, वो निर्गुण, निराकार, अजन्मा, मन बुद्धि के पार और हमेशा "है" । पर जानना आपका स्वभाव है आप जानकर ही रहोगे, बिना जाने आप नहीं मानोगे, आपक कुछ करे बिना नहीं मानोगे, मेहनत करके ही रहोगे, तो ऐसा करो अपनी मेहनत को सही जगह लगाओ, और उसे जानो जिसे जाना जा सकता है, वो है झूट। झूट को जानो सत्य की छोड़ो, झूट को जानो और अपनी जिंदगी से निकालते चलो, झूट पर कोई दया मत करो, उससे दूर रहो, झूट को हटा दो क्योंकि सत्य तो है ही उसका कोई कुछ नहीं बिगाड़ सकता। झूट की पहचान है दुख, दर्द, चिंता और परेशानी। सत्य की कोई पहचान नहीं, वो हर पहचान से ऊपर है।
कभी दुनिया की भुखमरी, गरीबी, कुपोषण, भ्रष्टाचार इत्यादि के बारे में सोचना एक दिन धीरे धीरे ईश्वर पर से विश्वास कम होते होते एक दिन सच्चाई पता चल जायेगा!
@@omshankarchoubey4664 बात विलकुल सही है! भारत देश के साथ साथ विश्व के लगभग सभी देशों में भूखमरी है! क्या आपके और आपके भगवान के पास कोई एसा मंत्र या यज्ञ है जिससे इस विपदा से निजात मिल जाए!
Einsteins god letter said "the word God for me is nothing but the expression and product of human weakness" His god letter sold in 2.8 million dollars .
Are ham bhi naastik hai, par Jo log apna palha badalte rehte hai unse kaun Jeet payega...jaha galti pade vaha ye astik vale bol dete hai ye nahi ye vo nahi vo...par bhagvaan itna hi achha hai, to scientisto ko bomb banane me kamyab ho na hone deta...😂😂😂
@@TheGondwanaTimes1. jo original/Real Navayana Buddhism ko follow karega ve kabhi pakhand nhi karega na hi failayega 2. Yadi aap Non Religious person h to aapko insaniyat rupi dharm ki aavsakta qu h❓ 3. Atheist aur Non Religious dono me antar h kya❓ 4. Iss baat ki kya guaranty h ki koi Non Religious person koi pakhand ya insaniyat ke liy galat kam nhi karta❓ exp:- communist dictators, North Korea etc 5. Jai Bhim ✊
@@Hello_Nirbhaygalat kaam aur achha kaam, uski morality pe depend karta hai, faith par nahin. Aur dusri baate ye philosophies aur religion ko pakadkar rkhne ka koi faida nahin hai Duniya ki sabse achhi kitaab ko bhi ham follow karne lag jaaye to barbaad ho jaayenge Insaan tarkik jeev hai, uske paas dimag hai, usko kisi cheej ko follow nahin karna chahiye, use bas seekhna chahiye aur apna dimag use karkar jeena chahiye Ye ek dharm pe chipakne se kuchh nahin hoga
@@ThoughtfulVoyager नवयान बुद्धिस्म में कहा गया है *अप्पो दीपो भव* अपने प्रकाश स्वयं बने किसी को भी ना ढूंढना अकेले चले *be a leader not followers* Rat Race से बाहर निकलो *किसी की बातों पर तब तक यकीन ना करें जब तक वह आपके तर्क, विवेक,प्रयोगो पर खरी न उतरे* । चाहे वे बात स्वयं बुद्ध ने ही क्यों ना कहीं हो सबसे तार्किक व वैज्ञानिक धर्म कोई है तो वह केवल और केवल नवयान बुद्धिस्म ही है Philosophy दर्शन पढ़ने से आपको अलग अलग विचारधारा को जानने का मौका मिलता है एक्सपोजर मिलता है आपकी थिंकिंग broad हो जाती है etc अलग अलग धर्म को वैज्ञानिक चिंतन के साथ तुलनात्मक रूप से पढ़ने पर आपको सठी गली धर्म की असलियत सामने आ जाती है
@@Hello_Nirbhay Han but usko follow karne ki jaroorat nahin hai ye bol rha hoon, ye saari baatein koi dimag wala insaan boldega, koi aisi baat nahin hai jiske liye in purane grantho ko pakad kar baith jaaye
In pagalon ko Ranchi me hona chahye dharam ke waja se mar kat hota hai to 1st aur 2nd world War dharam ki waja se nahi hua aur karodon log mare gaye aur 3rd World war bhi dharam ke waja se3 nahi hoga aur pura pirthivi ka the end hoja jaye ga due to scintific culture
Vigyan bhai Mangal main kitne log hai kyunki kuch chaman landure vigyani o ne managl main Pani dhundha hai kuch ne waha koi jivit alian dhundha hai per sabit nahi ho paya ? Matalab chodu banne ka trika Stephen Hawking sala khud to ungli bhi nahi hila paya aur big bang ki theory ka gyan jad raha tha
@@languageofpraiseeng यह बात तो एक धार्मिक ही बता सकता है उसी के धर्म ग्रंथों में लिखी होंगी यह सब चीजें नास्तिकों से क्या पूछ रहे हैं उसकी तो रिसर्च अभी चल रही है वह तुम्हारी तरह सीधे सीधे कोई चीजों को मान नहीं लेता पहले वह सर्च करता है फिर जाकर किसी धारणा पर पहुंचता है धर्म विश्वास पर खड़ा हुआ है जिस दिन विचार पर खड़ा हो जाएगा तो ज्यादा दिन तक धर्म रह नहीं सकता
I'm watching this show in 2024, and I'm actually appreciating this, it should be a proud moment to you guys because you kept that a rational and intellectual perception at that time, which this time's media lacks..
@@nextlevel7322 but they are not at any official debate as in this case where these INTELLECTUAL are trying to prove something in a way called Heckling. When in Debate, follow the rules of debate by keeping Equal opponents and then you are eligible to be called intellectual at least, keeping aside who's right or wrong.
@@ketanchaudhary6323 absolutely right , it's like they have invited theist to show the majority in the forum. But unfortunately , person from audience destroyed all these so called INTELLECTUAL panelists 🤣🤣 and then we saw that how they got frustrated
Bhai corona hai savidhan dikhao corona bhago chua chut ka savidhan ne mana kiya hai ab sab savidhan ke hisab se chua chut nahi karni chahiye lekin kyun kar rahe ho
My dear, lt is eternal truth that there is God. Pls read Bible, bible says, foolish said in his heart that there is no God, so those do not believe in God they are foolish. The whole universe is proof of of God. Also that majority are correct.
Because people are afraid of how society if they don't agree with their beliefs system normal people want to go with flow Eg : in India if someone argues that God does not exist in a country where 98% of people are religious then his life could be in danger Other main thing is lack of education I am from nepal and my parents are Hindu and I view myself as atheist only in digital world because when I go out side and see that 99% of my country is religious and I lies in 1% then me arguing with other that I don't believe what 99% believes put me in danger
Par vigyaan to ek sanskrit ka shab hai... Aur sanskrit vedic language hai... Aur vedon me vigyan dhabh sanskrit me likha hai... Baby science aur God me behans kar... Science is not written in ny religious text.. But vigyaan is written in vedas.. So vigyaan is a part of sanatana vedic dharma🚩🙏
@@charmingdawn correct ! It's not science. And all sciences we know so far, are Theories and theories are Always open to being Disproved ... upon formation of new theory. I am merely using Logic. Christianity and Islam had Fkat earth static earth where as ancient Sanatan scriptures had earth as well as other stars and also Multiple universes. (I'm not talking about Puran). And That is Inclusion of Science in Dharm. We only use less than 3 percent of our brains... much more to understand. I can go on and on bro 🤗 but I won't bother you much 😂
@@Pktrader-kg4fy Vo tum murkh log ho jo abhi bhi jaati se aadhaar par desh ko बांटते rahte ho. And ramayan ke jitne bhi proof aaj tak dikhaye gaye hain most of them are conspiracies and there is no conclusive evidence to support the argument from the religious community. I am not a Muslim or anti hindu I just talk on facts
@@shivangsrivastava6024 you don't know anything about fact. Read about ramsetu.there are so many prouf which are showing the prouf of ramayan . God is everywhere need to open our eyes. I am talking about fact only not any community and cast
@@Pktrader-kg4fy Is this not like that logic, for example if new york city is shown in spider man and it really Exists, so giving an illogical argument that spider man might also have been in existence.
@@jeetparmar9 You are right, fact is that we have no written record of what was originally said in the Vedas, it was all transmitted orally and much was added and subtracted before it was all penned just a few centuries back. Moreover, during ancient times, knowledge and learning was limited.
@@EverydayLifeandScience aisa kuch nahi hai bhai chaye jo bhi bolo mein dono ko hi maanta hu vigyan vigyan hai aur god vigyan se bhi upar jisko samjha nahi jaa sakta
कोई एक राय है ही नहीं क्यूंकि 'ईश्वर' एक मनगढंत वस्तु है! कारक परिणाम इस संसार का प्राकृतिक भौतिक सत्य है विज्ञान और बुद्धिवाद सही मार्ग है बिना किसी संदेह
@Vive la vida it depends on what people want in their lives and what they imagine god to be, if someone does something miraculously good for me, he's god for me at that moment in time, that's it
Anpad yug ko sat yug kaha h Q k pap kisi k pas itni Budhi nhi thi ki vo sahi aur galt prr sawal krta...aaj pda likh vyakti janta h ki kya kese hota h isi ko kalyug kaha h scientific yug ko kalyug ......
धर्म व भगवान के नाम पर पेट के पूजारियों ,पादरियों, कथावचकों,पाठियों, मोलवियों, आदि धर्म के ठेकेदारों की दूकानदारी व उसी दूकानदारी से इनका पेट पलता है और ऐशो आराम की जिदंगी जीते है ,,व भोली भाली जनता को बेवकूफ बना रखा है ,,,,,,इन्कलाब जिन्दाबाद ,,कडवा सत्य
Science is a very wide subject. Limiting it to only matter or material things is a great mistake. Physics, Chemistry , Biology etc are material science. But when we talk about God its altogether a different science ie, the science of spirit or spiritual science. The problem is that we try to understand Spiritual science through the prism of material science. It may help to some extent, but we may not get the complete picture. That is the limitation of material science. We must understand that both sciences are different and trying to understand one through the other leads to many misconceptions about spiritual science. There are different ways and methods in the material science itself to understand different aspects of our surroundings. The processes, procedures, tools and experiments used in Physics cant be used completely in Biology or Chemistry. To measure a small distance between two different objects, we may use a small measuring tape, but when the distance between sun and earth is to be measured we cant use the same methods and tools. We have to use different tools and methods to measure it ie Telescope. But we conveniently forget to acknowledge that Spiritual science also has a different set of procedures and tools. To try to understand God and spirituality through material process and tools is like measuring the distance between sun and the earth using a measuring tape, which is very childish and impossible. Where do we find the processes and tools? In the sacred texts of different religions ie Bible, Quran , Gita, etc.They provide the necessary tools and procedures and experiments to understand GOD. To understand physics we have physical experiments, for chemistry , chemical experiments, for biology - biological experiments. Similarly to understand God and Spirituality we have Spiritual Experiments. But the tragedy with people of todays generation is the they are very eager to conduct material experitments but arent ready to conduct the spiritual experiments with the same enthusiasm. Scientists put on their hardwork and energy for so many years or maybe even their lifetime to search after something or invent something. They keep on doing experiments for so many years to come to a proper conclusions. Thomas Edison spent 12 years of his life vigorously in inventing a bulb. He didnt think of anything else, didnt eat properly, didnt sleep properly till the day when he finally invented bulb. Examples of many other scientists can also be cited here. But have material scientists or even the people in this discussion have spent even half the time for understanding the Spiritual science through Spiritual processes and tools of time which they have given to material science? No. To understand GOD one must also approach a spiritual teacher. Just a plain reading of holy books wont do. Just by reading a book you dont become a doctor or an engineer. You need to approach a university , learn it through a teacher, read books, perform experiments, do practicals, remain under a doctor or engineer for some years as apprentice and then he or she shall become a doctor/ engineer. such a long process. The point is we cant understand material science independently. Similarly we cant understand GOD independently. The Question is are we ready to go similar lengths to understand GOD? Are we ready to go through the Spiritual Process and Practices? Are we ready to accept a spiritual master or teacher? Do we have the same enthusiasm to know and see GOD the way we learn material science. Dont accept anything blindly, but dont reject anything blindly either !!!!
@@arijitdey6193 scientist stay foolish and stay hungry for truth but I am saying a fact if the religions in the way they define religion as there is divine intervention everywhere which is not true they don't know anything about even nature how can they claim to know God not even a single piece of evidence or any logical thing just vague arguments whatever is disclosed about nature was by science which is true study of nature but religion claims it knows all
@Nihilist Existentialist Soul is reality, regardless what your beliefs may be. Experiments? Proof? But are you willing to enter the laboratory She said: Two hydrogen and one oxygen atom make water. He said: Atoms! Give me a break! These little things you can't even see. You put a few together, and out comes water … You expect me to believe that? She said: It's a fact. Two hydrogens and one oxygen make water. He said: I'll believe it when I see it. Prove it to me! She said: All right. He said: You're crazy. You can't prove it! She said: I can prove it to you. Just come into my laboratory and do the experiment. The first step is to look in this … He said: Oh yeah. Right. Good one. The laboratory. You want me to go into your laboratory and do your experiment your way that's brainwashing. She said: No … If you'll just take a look in this microscope … He said: I'm not gonna do any of your crazy rituals! What are you trying to do, convert me!? You people are nuts. You believe all these crazy things. Two hydrogens and one oxygen make water! Gimme a break! She said: I can show you if you'll look in this microscope … He said: I'll never follow your rules! You can't prove anything to me! * * * She said: God exists. If we focus our efforts and devotion on God, our lives will become complete. He said: God! Gimme a break! This mythological character you can't even see. Worship Him and you'll feel dandy … You expect me to believe that? She said: It's a fact. God exists. We become complete through devotion to Him. He said: Yeah right. I'll believe it when I see it. Prove it to me! She said: All right. He said: You're crazy. You can't prove it! She said: I can prove it to you, just come into the laboratory and do the experiment. The first step is to remove the blindfold of attachment to material … He said: Oh yeah. Right. Good one. The laboratory. You want me to come into your laboratory and do your experiment your way that's brainwashing. She said: No … If you'll just begin chanting Hare Krsna … He said: I'm not gonna do any of your crazy rituals! What are you trying to do, convert me!? You people are nuts. You believe all these crazy things: God and spiritual worlds and … Gimme a break! You can't show me God. She said: I'll show you. Let me just explain … He said: Just show me God! She said: I'm trying to tell you where to look. He said: I'll never follow your rules! You can't prove anything to me! Soul is reality, regardless what your beliefs may be. Experiments? Proof? But are you willing to enter the laboratory?
I agree the spiritual aspect of life must also be explored. But spiritualism in itself is not a science, and in many instances we have seen people who talk about spiritualism in that regard are basically selling pseudoscience
@@ex009adityarajsingh2 It only claims that it knows, that in itself doesn't make it true. If I claim to know everyone in the earth that doesn't make it true.
एक मामूली सी दुकान बग़ैर किसी आदमी के नहीं चल सकती तो इतना बड़ा अनंत ब्रह्मांड खुदा के बगैर केसे चल सकता है एक खुदा है जो इस पूरी सृष्टि का मालिक है ला इलाहा इल्लाल्ला
सर, बिजली के कारण पंखा चल रहा है और पेट्रोल की वजह से कार चलती है। तब हमें विश्वास करना चाहिए कि पेट्रोल और बिजली ईश्वर है। यह सही है कि पूरा ब्रह्मांड चल रहा है लेकिन भगवान के कारण नहीं बल्कि कुछ वैज्ञानिक अवधारणा के कारण
@@shivamssargam5722 Science is the synonym of peace, prosperity, health and overall happiness. It's science only which has facilitated you by providing you with modern gadgets so that you could utilise them in speaking against science and in favour of religion. "It's science alone which can solve the problems of hunger and poverty, of insanitation and illiteracy. Of vast resources running to waste and a rich country inhabited by starving people. Who indeed could afford to ignore science today? At every turn we have to seek it's aid. The future belongs to science and those who make friends with science." - Ex prime minister Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru
@@letscode5367 who forced anyone to follow Buddhism ? And Buddhism provide samething as any neutral or atheist want..as Buddha said.. " APO DEEPO BHAVA "
इस दुनिया में जो भी बात सिद्ध ना हो सके वो बिलकुल निराधार है.., अथात्र ईश्वर मात्र झूट फरेब है जिसे कुछ ग्धो ने अपने लाभ के लिये एस्टमाल किया है और आज भी कर रहे हैं.......🌘🌘🌘🌚🌑🌏
जब समझ दिमाग से बाहर की हो जाती है, तब हम ईश्वर या भगवान के नाम से दिमाग को भ्रमित कर आगे बढ़ जाते हैं और इसको आस्था बता देते हैं। जब विज्ञान द्वारा समझ आती है तो वही भ्रमित भगवान और आस्था की कोरी कल्पना रफूचक्कर हो जाती है।
It is not that you think that is why you are there, but you think only because you are there. You can doubt everything but not yourself. So knowing yourself is spirituality and not any religion. Knowing the Self is experiencing the God.
मैं आज ये वीडियो देख रहा हूं यह science की देन है, न कि God की,
i'm proud to be an atheist
Aur ye dekhane wala God h
@@krishandas1972 😂😂
Aur bhagwan ko banane vale hum hai
I am also proud to be athist 🔥
🔥🔥🔥❤️
@VAIBHAV MISHRA i am not hindu🙄🙄
Ghatiya dharma
Religion's source are: Trust me bro.
Science Source: years of reasearch using scientific methods.
🤟🤟
Do u agree with those scientists agaobst ur islam?
Yup buddy💯💯💯
There is a man who has fallen ill, he has to be cured, research says it is a virus. This is creation, God is doing it, science says no, it is big bang, reason for bigbang, searching.....
Are u a exmuslim
I am atheist because of bhagat singh...
I have no word to gratitude bhagat singh .who give me a dimension to see the world...
Right bro ❤️
Same
Bhagatsingh was keeping small one bhagavat gita with him every time this you know ??
Bhagat Singh ji ka pura Jeevan hi Dharmik hai
Bhagat Singh nastik the aisa gyan aapko kisne diya? --- Britisho ne. Kyo ki Gore ye chahate the ki Bhagat Singh ko fansi dene ke baad jan aakrosh kranti me na badal jaye. Bhagat Singh ko nastik batane se jan aakrosh dab jaata. Gorone zoothe jawab aur patr jaari kar ke uski nastik chabi janmanas me basa di jo aaj bhi kai adhpadh murkho ko sach lagti hai.
इतनी शानदार बौद्धिक चर्चा को देखकर मन प्रसन्न हो गया और कमेंट्स को देखकर तो विथ ग्रेस ऑफ गॉड यही प्रार्थना करता हूँ भगवान से कि इंशाल्लाह भारत का भविष्य नास्तिक और वैज्ञानिक ही हो ! 😅
Nice to meet you
बहुत अच्छी चर्चा हुई । बहुत ही अच्छा विषय रखा गया । आस्तिकता एवं नास्तिकता चलती ही रहेगी । मेरे हिसाब से यह सत्य है कि ईश्वर नहीं होता है और यदि ईश्वर को हम मानते हैं अर्थात ईश्वर का नाम रखा गया है तो वह प्रकृति है । प्रकृति ही ईश्वर है । प्रकृति ही भगवान है और प्रकृति का संचालन विज्ञानिक तरीके से निश्चित नियमों के साथ होता है और यह नियम सभी प्राकृतिक हैं । प्रकृति का वास्तविक स्वरूप नहीं है । यह एक आदृश्य हो सकती है और प्रकृति में विभिन्न प्रकार के भौतिक पदार्थ हैं । वही ईश्वर का स्वरूप हो जाते है । इसलिए भगवान अर्थात प्रकृति का कोई स्वरूप नहीं है वह निराकार है । किंतु भौतिक पदार्थों के माध्यम से वह आकार के रूप में भी है। यह भी सत्य है कि मनुष्य ने ईश्वर को काल्पनिक रूप से गड़ा है।
SIR apne bahut achhi bat kahi lekin prakurti ko bhee bhgwan samjana aur usko dhanda banana ye bat puri traha se galat he kivaki prakriti me koi bhav (sense) nahi hota matlab uski puja karna aur usko gali dena ye dono bate murkhta he hum sirf uske prati moun raha sakate he jaise ki thathgat GAUTAM BUDDHA rahe
@@kishorushir1333 good very good आप का कहना उचित है तथागत बुद्ध की बात बिल्कुल सही है लोगों को वहीं पहुंचता है
@@lordbuddhaphilosophy1930 to Swami Vivekananda galat the kya
जब कोई व्यक्ति हॉस्पिटल में ट्रीटमेंट के दौरान मर जाता हैडॉक्टरों की देख रेख में वह तो सब साइंस तो क्यो मर जाता है वह और आदमी मरता क्यो है और खोज करने वाले वैज्ञानिक भी मर गए इसका मतलब मरना नही चाहिए था उसको पर में ये कहना चाहता अगर विज्ञान से जीने में आसानी हो गयी है और वह सब कुछ नही है अगर किसी का पैर कट जाए तो क्या विज्ञान उसका उसी तरह का पैर दे सकता है नही इसलिए विज्ञान भी पूरी तरह से सफल नही है और ये सब मशीनरी नही थी तब भी मनुष्य जिंदगी जी रहा था और अब भी जी रहा है
The epic debate by RSTV
I consider myself as lucky to watch such intellectual video
Yes☺
Golden days were there before 2014
ALL THESE GATHERED HERE ARE NOBODY IN FRONT OF SWAMI VIVEKANANDA....GO READ VIVEKANANDA..
मुझे भगवान में बहुत ही आस्था और विश्वास था लेकिन सन् 2020 में जब मैं हर तरह से हार गया तो मुझे एहसास हुआ कि मैंने गल्त जगह से आशा की
आपके प्रारब्ध कर्मो के कारण आप हार गए दोष भगवान को दे दिया
@@dharmeshkumarpareekpareek5902 he is right 🤨
Yes brother... Bhagwaan nhi hote ☺☺
😂😂😂😂
@@dharmeshkumarpareekpareek5902 भगवान का होने का सबूत दो 😂😂😂
The existence of God prevails in human history with two reasons
1: limited knowledge
2: Unlimited fear
3. And to thug people and abuse women in the name of God
Science lover hit like plz....
There was a time when we could air such an intellectual programs on TV. Times have changed, haven't they?
Yah! seems like we are going back to stone age.
ALL THESE GATHERED HERE ARE NOBODY IN FRONT OF SWAMI VIVEKANANDA....GO READ VIVEKANANDA..
@@BeHappyBeKind07 And why would I do that? And besides the point, have you yourself read about Vivekananda or just blabbering here on the internet?
@@chakrapanigautam2519 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@BeHappyBeKind07 Monotheistic religion's been ridiculed all over the world. The debate wasn't about if Hindu God exist or Allah or Jesus exist. Dude hasn't even watched the video and asking people to read Vivekananda, lol.
I am an atheist. I agree with the intellectuals. And I believe in Science. You can not convince fools.
Acha bhai pehla bandar kaun tha uski photo hai ? Vigyan ke pass andho ko sury prakash nahi dikh sakta ab tum ab vigyani apne khud ke bal se nai prithvi (Mangal grah ka use nahi) apne khud ke matrial se naya prithvi grah kab bana rahe hai
Evolution is right. Science have fossils, traces and many more proof.
@@Samir20112 pehla bandar ka photo kaise milega tab camera thodi tha...bandar ek din mei nahi bana matlab evolution nam ki bhi kuch chiz hei😂 haan par scientist ne fossils se uska structure habit cranial capacity zaroor bata diya hei..google p dekh le
@@buttercup2991 le accha akal ki andhi to bhagwan raste main chalta koi vigyan ni hai photo lade ya bat karle wah re doglo jab khud ke pass jawab na ho to ghatiya word use karo yahi sikhati hai science acha waisa hi dikhta hoga uska kya praman hai kuch bhi photo video dikhao kya hua jab khud ki bari main to pathhar ko fossils bol do hum kyun mane aise myths ko
@@Samir20112 accha thik hei😂
Hindustan अकेला देश है। जहां पर 99%लोग झूठा जीवन जीते है। Pandey जी ने सही कहा यूरोप में 80%लोग nastik है। बहुत अच्छा जीवन जीते हैं मैंने इंटरमीडिएट के बाद धर्म की किताबे padhni सुरु की विज्ञान पढ़ा और nastik हो गया na मुझे भूत से डर na Bhagwan से
I am an proud atheist
But not gonna lie this debate actually was better than all the godi media news combined
I am proud atheist 😀
Astaghfirullah... Sister study about islam...
Bro i think you should study science😂
@@shivanshrajpandey2534 😂😂 ha bhai... Baat krna seekh le btw
Eithiest mahapurash nahi bane sakte.
Veda is science,veda is not blind
17:21 sahi bole ki satya koi democratic chiz nahi. Satya 1% bhi ho to wo satya hai 👌👌👌👌👌
Agree 🔥
Main ek ladka hoon main Australia mein rehta hoon japan mein job karta hoon...USA ka president tha 5saal.. Jackie Chan mera bhai hai ... Roz zeher khata hoon... petrol Peeta hoon...
Insari baaton mein sirf ek cheez satya hai "Main ek ladka hoon " .... Aapke anusar meri baaton mein 1% sachhai to hai toh kya meri baat satya hai.....aur aap aise hi sari illogical jhuti baaton ko satya maan loge ???
@@arupkumarjena5178 bhai samjhe nahi wo bolna kya chahta hai
@@arupkumarjena5178 abbe he wanted to say ki agar 1% log bhi satya ko maane toh woh satya hi rhega! And you intertrepreted it as agar 1% bhi satya hai toh poori baat satya hai😑
मुझे नास्तिक होने पे गर्व है, ईश्वर झूठ के सिवा और कुछ भी नही है
👍
Tumne naastik Bankar bhi kya ukhad liya😂😂😂😂
Aur tune sanatunni dharm hoke kya ukhad liya hutiya toh hutiya hi lagoge@@harishharishjaat3438
विद्याधर जी, इतना आसानी से आपने लिखा कि "ईश्वर" झूठ है,
इस पर मेरा कहना है कि "ईश्वर" एक "नाम" ( Noun) है , इस संसार में मौजूद सभी शक्तियों, सभी पदार्थों के सम्मिलित स्वरुप का ,
एक उदहारण दूँ - एक परिवार में एक "बच्चा" पैदा होता है, जब वो बच्चा दो - तीन दिन का होता है, और उसका नाम-करण नहीं हुआ होता है, आप ये तो मानते ही होंगे कि उस बच्चे में पदार्थों के रूप में हड्डी, खाल, बाल, आँखें, ह्रदय, आंतें, आदि आदि मौजूद होते हैं, साथ ही साथ उस बच्चे में कुछ system भी होते हैं जैसे- देखने का सिस्टम, Respiratory System, Digestive System, Excretory System, सोचने का सिस्टम आदि आदि,
Q - सर, क्या आप ये मानते हैं ??
I will write more after your answer ...
Bilkul sahi
ईश्वर को न चख सकते हैं
न सूंघ सकते है
न छू सकते हैं
न सुन सकते हैं और
न देख सकते हैं
ईश्वर में स्पर्श गुण नहीं है
रूप नहीं है |
रस नहीं है |
गंध नहीं है |
शब्द नहीं है |
सब चीज़ का प्रमाण चाहिए पर जिस की हम सब को ज्यादा जरूरत है उसकी प्रमाणा मत खोजो सिर्फ विस्वास करो कमाल है ना
इंसानियत से बड़ा धर्म कुछ नहीं
में एक नास्तिक हूँ और मुझे इस पर गर्व है
अगर इंसानियत सबसे बड़ा धर्म है।
तो मनुष्य स्वयं को नहीं जानता तो वह कैसे बता सकता कि इन्सानियत सबसे बड़ा धर्म है।जो मनुष्य स्वयं को नहीं जानता वह वह बोलेगा कुछ करेगा कुछ। परिवर्तन सत्य नहीं है।
ईश्वर GOD अल्लाह नाम की कोई चीज नहीं होती ।
ये सिर्फ धर्मिक धन्धे हैं
मानवता से बड़ी कोई धर्म नहीं होती ।
Allaah exist bro really blind ko khwab kese asakte hae search UA-cam plz
Kamjor log..
AMIT DRIWEDI I believe supreme power exist but I don’t believe any organised religion , especially Islam Allah always want to force himself on people
1%bhi stya hai
Mohammd ko ye nahi pata tha ki 7asmaan nahi hote use ye bhi nahi pata ki iman dimag me hota hai sine me nahi
Proud to be Athiest.
@VAIBHAV Well 100 % hindu mein 10 % toh god mein beleive hee nhi karte kyuki unhe unke parents ke karan bahana karna padta hai
Aaj ke waqt me is tarah ki debate news channel par karna asambhav hai
Bilkul sahi
Agar ye debate chala di toh sarkar doob jaygi na uska ghar kese chalega
Very nice and rational debate. It was a pleasure to listen to these people. Nowadays I can't believe any news channel showing anything else than Hindu-Muslim debates.
God is a hypothesis
Science is the reality
Science kaise reality hai acha ye batao ki kuch ghatna jaise ki khud vigyani jisko sabit nahi kar pate wo ghatna tumhre hisab se hui hi nahi tum jan nahi sakte ya tumhri aukat se bahar hai wo exist nahi karti
@@Samir20112 chl luade😂
@Raj Chanana what is reality did you read ved Or any book of old scripture, let's did know about ramanuja charya he said he's maths knowledge given by his kuldevi so ramanuja charya is wrong he is grate mathematician why science is always try to defame believe or gods
60 sec = 1 min
30 days = 1 month
Kayse hua ?
@@Samir20112 chutad ho tum
*_इश्क़ हो तो भगवान है, और अक्ल हो तो विज्ञान। एक का अस्तित्व भावनात्मक है और दूसरे का विचारात्मक_*
Bhawana ki wajah se Dhokha Diya ja rha
Wow
Vigyan tumhara karela har waqt kat ta jaise ki ye jiv vigyani ye dawai banaane wali company 2rs ki teblate sidha 200 rs main
@@vikeshmohanlalgond7467 bhagwan nhi h jo khta h m prove kr sakta hu bhagwan agr m glt hua to aj hi apna dharm chord dunga
@@yugamkukreja5681 prove kar do
Love science and technology
Proud of science ,without science our life (incomplete)can't imagine (run) in every step
Jb science nhi thi tb zada skoon tha
ALL THESE GATHERED HERE ARE NOBODY IN FRONT OF SWAMI VIVEKANANDA....GO READ VIVEKANANDA..
@@khalidismail2682 khuch bhii
@@BeHappyBeKind07 yes i red not special
@@khalidismail2682you were not there witness it . human doing big wars before science
I used to be an atheist. But after reading Richard Dawkins, Bhagat Singh, Periyar i am an atheist out and out.
विद्वान पत्रकार महोदया द्वारा सटीक वैज्ञानिक तर्को से सभी विचारकों को सम्हालते हुए अपनी कुशलता का ,अपनी धैर्यता का जो परिचय दिया वह क़ाबिले तारीफ है।
कोई ईश्वर नहीं है....
मात्र सत्य "है"
और जो लगे की "है" पर है नहीं उसे माया या भ्रम कहते हैं
तो क्या जमीन और आसमान खुद-ब-खुद वजूद मैं आ गए और यह चांद सितारे अपने आप बन गए
@@irfanmohmad1403 बिल्कुल नहीं भाई, यह कैसे बनते हैं इसको विज्ञान बता बता कर थक गया, पूरे दिन discovery चैनल पर यही आता रहता है की चाँद तारे कैसे बने, वहाँ से अच्छे से जान लो, विज्ञान की किताबें पढ़ लो पूरी प्रक्रिया पता चल जाएगी। बस ये वहम मत पालो की मुझे पता है की कैसे बने चाँद तारे। पढ़ाई करो और जानो, मानो मत।
'सत्य' क्या है?
@@Rjesh8 मैं कोई गुरु तो नहीं जो आपको सत्य के बारे में बता सकूं, पर इतना बड़ा सवाल पूछने के लिए धन्यवाद।
इतना ज़रूर बता सकता हूँ की बड़े लोगों ने कहा है की सत्य को जाना नहीं जा सकता, वो निर्गुण, निराकार, अजन्मा, मन बुद्धि के पार और हमेशा "है" ।
पर जानना आपका स्वभाव है आप जानकर ही रहोगे, बिना जाने आप नहीं मानोगे, आपक कुछ करे बिना नहीं मानोगे, मेहनत करके ही रहोगे, तो ऐसा करो अपनी मेहनत को सही जगह लगाओ, और उसे जानो जिसे जाना जा सकता है, वो है झूट।
झूट को जानो सत्य की छोड़ो, झूट को जानो और अपनी जिंदगी से निकालते चलो, झूट पर कोई दया मत करो, उससे दूर रहो, झूट को हटा दो क्योंकि सत्य तो है ही उसका कोई कुछ नहीं बिगाड़ सकता।
झूट की पहचान है दुख, दर्द, चिंता और परेशानी।
सत्य की कोई पहचान नहीं, वो हर पहचान से ऊपर है।
@@irfanmohmad1403 na tohar allah bnale hau,,,,cmnt likhela bhi allah hi sikhale hau
११ साल पुराना, इस era में तो ये दम संसद TV में नहीं है
I'm glad we got the freedom to discuss these topics
2014 से पहले की है भाई
कभी दुनिया की भुखमरी, गरीबी, कुपोषण, भ्रष्टाचार इत्यादि के बारे में सोचना एक दिन धीरे धीरे ईश्वर पर से विश्वास कम होते होते एक दिन सच्चाई पता चल जायेगा!
Bilkul👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Ghar mein baithe rahoge to bhookhmari to aayegi hi na
@@omshankarchoubey4664 बात विलकुल सही है! भारत देश के साथ साथ विश्व के लगभग सभी देशों में भूखमरी है!
क्या आपके और आपके भगवान के पास कोई एसा मंत्र या यज्ञ है जिससे इस विपदा से निजात मिल जाए!
@@hemrajkumar4754 sabdon se mt khlo
@@omshankarchoubey4664 शब्दों से ना खेलो!
क्या कुछ गलत कह दिया क्या❓
Einsteins god letter said "the word God for me is nothing but the expression and product of human weakness"
His god letter sold in 2.8 million dollars .
Einstein believe in god so do Newton go to Wikimedia never spread reumer
@@chiragsharma5624 read his god letter and then come again.
@@RajveerSingh-wb5or it is written for cristion god he believes in god is Spinoza (may be i don't spell it right)
@@chiragsharma5624 correct i agreed
@@RajveerSingh-wb5or and Newton belive in Bible also
Kon Kon Human with science Sir Ka channel dekhke edhar ayaa hai🤚
ऐसे डिबेट हर रोज होने चाहिए इनसे जागरूकता अभियान चलेगा और लोग god और धर्म जैसे सड़ी हुई चीजों के नाम पर लड़ेंगे नहीं
Ji aap shi bole 🙏🇮🇳,Tabhi log jagruk honge, 😊,,, kyuki ajj kll god ke piche apna pura jivan ke aadha time'issi me barbaad krr rhe hai 😢🥺🥺
Are ham bhi naastik hai, par Jo log apna palha badalte rehte hai unse kaun Jeet payega...jaha galti pade vaha ye astik vale bol dete hai ye nahi ye vo nahi vo...par bhagvaan itna hi achha hai, to scientisto ko bomb banane me kamyab ho na hone deta...😂😂😂
*I'm an Atheist but not a Non Religious* I follow Navayan Buddhism ☸💙
Ye bhi ek din pakhand ban jayega
insaaniyat se bada koi dharm nahi hota
jai bhim
@@TheGondwanaTimes1. jo original/Real Navayana Buddhism ko follow karega ve kabhi pakhand nhi karega na hi failayega
2. Yadi aap Non Religious person h to aapko insaniyat rupi dharm ki aavsakta qu h❓
3. Atheist aur Non Religious dono me antar h kya❓
4. Iss baat ki kya guaranty h ki koi Non Religious person koi pakhand ya insaniyat ke liy galat kam nhi karta❓ exp:- communist dictators, North Korea etc
5. Jai Bhim ✊
@@Hello_Nirbhaygalat kaam aur achha kaam, uski morality pe depend karta hai, faith par nahin.
Aur dusri baate ye philosophies aur religion ko pakadkar rkhne ka koi faida nahin hai
Duniya ki sabse achhi kitaab ko bhi ham follow karne lag jaaye to barbaad ho jaayenge
Insaan tarkik jeev hai, uske paas dimag hai, usko kisi cheej ko follow nahin karna chahiye, use bas seekhna chahiye aur apna dimag use karkar jeena chahiye
Ye ek dharm pe chipakne se kuchh nahin hoga
@@ThoughtfulVoyager नवयान बुद्धिस्म में कहा गया है *अप्पो दीपो भव* अपने प्रकाश स्वयं बने किसी को भी ना ढूंढना अकेले चले *be a leader not followers* Rat Race से बाहर निकलो
*किसी की बातों पर तब तक यकीन ना करें जब तक वह आपके तर्क, विवेक,प्रयोगो पर खरी न उतरे* । चाहे वे बात स्वयं बुद्ध ने ही क्यों ना कहीं हो
सबसे तार्किक व वैज्ञानिक धर्म कोई है तो वह केवल और केवल नवयान बुद्धिस्म ही है
Philosophy दर्शन पढ़ने से आपको अलग अलग विचारधारा को जानने का मौका मिलता है एक्सपोजर मिलता है आपकी थिंकिंग broad हो जाती है etc
अलग अलग धर्म को वैज्ञानिक चिंतन के साथ तुलनात्मक रूप से पढ़ने पर आपको सठी गली धर्म की असलियत सामने आ जाती है
@@Hello_Nirbhay Han but usko follow karne ki jaroorat nahin hai ye bol rha hoon, ye saari baatein koi dimag wala insaan boldega, koi aisi baat nahin hai jiske liye in purane grantho ko pakad kar baith jaaye
जय विज्ञान जय संविधान जय भारत 🇮🇳 🙏 🌺
सर आप अगर विज्ञान को जानते हो तो ईश्वर को भी मान सकते थे आप वेदों को नहीं जानते है अच्छे से स्टडी करो फिर बात करो
संविधान के पहले पेज पर है राम लिखा हुआ है क्या वो गलत है
अगर ईश्वर का अस्तित्व नहीं होता तो हम इस चीज पर बहस भी नहीं कर रहे होते। 🙏
In pagalon ko Ranchi me hona chahye dharam ke waja se mar kat hota hai to 1st aur 2nd world War dharam ki waja se nahi hua aur karodon log mare gaye aur 3rd World war bhi dharam ke waja se3 nahi hoga aur pura pirthivi ka the end hoja jaye ga due to scintific culture
@@MohammedIrfan-qw1wk yes
Nature is god and believing in god is not bad but believing in religious reject love
मुझे भगवान से डर नहीं लगता मुझे भगवान को मानने वालों से डर लगता है।
A time when we had luxury to see such debates , and now .
Not anymore bro now we are feeded nonsense and religious crap down our throats everyday.
विज्ञान सही है इन्सानियत होती तो ऊच नीच जात पात भेद भाव नहीं होता
ऊच नीच,भेदभाव धर्म द्वारा संचालित मान्यताएं हैं,विज्ञान तो केवल सत्य प्रकाशित करने का काम करता है |
@@P.K-lc6dga
@@P.K-lc6dg yes
@@none272
अरे , बीएसडी के गाली क्यों दे रहा बे ,
-महर्षि वाल्मीकि ने रामायण लिखा और बाबा साहेब ने संविधान दोनों ही दलित थे
फिर वो कौन से मूर्ख लोग हैं जो संविधान मानते हैं पर रामायण नहीं
नास्तिक बनो " इंसान " बनो,
बहोत " स्कोप " है इसमे
hello, Mr. Nastik give me the solution to today's problem that the world is going through?
Vigyan bhai Mangal main kitne log hai kyunki kuch chaman landure vigyani o ne managl main Pani dhundha hai kuch ne waha koi jivit alian dhundha hai per sabit nahi ho paya ? Matalab chodu banne ka trika Stephen Hawking sala khud to ungli bhi nahi hila paya aur big bang ki theory ka gyan jad raha tha
@@languageofpraiseeng यह बात तो एक धार्मिक ही बता सकता है उसी के धर्म ग्रंथों में लिखी होंगी यह सब चीजें नास्तिकों से क्या पूछ रहे हैं उसकी तो रिसर्च अभी चल रही है वह तुम्हारी तरह सीधे सीधे कोई चीजों को मान नहीं लेता पहले वह सर्च करता है फिर जाकर किसी धारणा पर पहुंचता है धर्म विश्वास पर खड़ा हुआ है जिस दिन विचार पर खड़ा हो जाएगा तो ज्यादा दिन तक धर्म रह नहीं सकता
Laura scope hai
@@SunilSingh-qc8sb kisme hai
Land bhkti mai
I'm watching this show in 2024, and I'm actually appreciating this, it should be a proud moment to you guys because you kept that a rational and intellectual perception at that time, which this time's media lacks..
1 theist against 4 INTELLECTUALS
Great intellectualism
in world 750 million atheist against 7 billion intellectuals , great intellectualism
@@nextlevel7322 but they are not at any official debate as in this case where these INTELLECTUAL are trying to prove something in a way called Heckling.
When in Debate, follow the rules of debate by keeping Equal opponents and then you are eligible to be called intellectual at least, keeping aside who's right or wrong.
No bro its 5 that dumb anchor is also his against
Likhne koi likh sakta
@@ketanchaudhary6323 absolutely right , it's like they have invited theist to show the majority in the forum. But unfortunately , person from audience destroyed all these so called INTELLECTUAL panelists 🤣🤣 and then we saw that how they got frustrated
SCIENCE ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
💛💚🧡🧡🧡💜💜🖤🖤❤️❤️
वैज्ञानिक उस ज्वाला को पर्दाफाश करने गये है लेकीन धर्म के अँधे लोग उन्हें अंदर नहीं जाने देते
Vha to akbar bhi gata tha uski bhi gaand fat gyi
धर्म और नफरत विलोम शब्द है ।
पंडिताः समदर्शिनः ।
श्रृष्टि का श्रृष्टि कर्ता कोई भी नहीं है। धर्म के नाम पर धर्म के ठेकेदार अपनी अपनी दुकानें चला रहे हैं। जय विज्ञान जय भारत जय संविधान।
Bhai corona hai savidhan dikhao corona bhago chua chut ka savidhan ne mana kiya hai ab sab savidhan ke hisab se chua chut nahi karni chahiye lekin kyun kar rahe ho
Are bhai jai sambhidhaan kyu yaar
सातवें आसमान पर रन्डीखाना चलाने वाले दल्ला के बारे में भी कुछ बोल
Agr profe krdiya ki bhagwan h to challenge h terkooo m proofe kr sakta hu bhagwan h
Chalange hai mera tuje
there are more than 75 crore aetheists ....
i am feeling good now..that m one of them.. :)
Ohh...u are too one of those fools...
It will not make your life easy
I used to be an atheist now an agnostic
I find that atheist and theist both r believer and lier ,side of same coin
My dear, lt is eternal truth that there is God. Pls read Bible, bible says, foolish said in his heart that there is no God, so those do not believe in God they are foolish. The whole universe is proof of of God. Also that majority are correct.
@@manassehdesai5298
Lol, Bible is most corrupted book. Full of scientific mistakes. How come universe is proof of God?
@@saurabh32able
Though I am an agnostic too but i didn't get it, how come atheist are believers and liars?
Gohor Raza 👏🏻👏🏻
"It's better to have a question that can't be answered than to have a answer that can't be questioned."
इंसान हर चीज विज्ञान की दी हुई उपयोग करते है तो फ़िर क्यों विज्ञान कि बजाय 99% पॉपुलेशन भगवान की पूजा करती है?
Because people are afraid of how society if they don't agree with their beliefs system normal people want to go with flow
Eg : in India if someone argues that God does not exist in a country where 98% of people are religious then his life could be in danger
Other main thing is lack of education
I am from nepal and my parents are Hindu and I view myself as atheist only in digital world because when I go out side and see that 99% of my country is religious and I lies in 1% then me arguing with other that I don't believe what 99% believes put me in danger
विज्ञान क्या है ???
Kyoki wo manna nahi chahte
Hii
Par vigyaan to ek sanskrit ka shab hai... Aur sanskrit vedic language hai... Aur vedon me vigyan dhabh sanskrit me likha hai...
Baby science aur God me behans kar... Science is not written in ny religious text..
But vigyaan is written in vedas..
So vigyaan is a part of sanatana vedic dharma🚩🙏
मै भी ईश्वर पर बहुत विश्वास करता था परंतु जब मेरे पुत्र का निधन हो गया तब से ईश्वर से विश्वास ही उठ गया है और अब मैं नास्तिक हूं
अमरीका:- हम जापान पर दो बॉम्ब गिरा रहे है अगर कहीं भगवान है तो उसे रोक ले, फिर भगवान जी आए और बॉम्ब को रॉक लिया 😜😁🤣😂😃
But tumhe kya lagta hain god nhi. Hain salo tumhare andar khun kha se aya or mass kha se aya socho bhau
@@Vaishu-h22 tum science padh lo plzzz😂😂🤣😂🤣🤣😂 school nahi jate kya tum?😂
Kitne pagal ho yaar tum
@@Vaishu-h22 aage se science class bunk mat karna 🙄
@@bamanevishwajeet baccho ke saath bacche bante ho use smjhane se behtar..
Young generation,have patience to listen try to konw,you are future of the nation.
काश प्रति दिन धार्मिक कार्यक्रमो कि जगह ऐसे ही तार्किक कार्यक्रम आयोजित किए गए जिससे भ्रतियो को दूर करने में सफल हो कर नेक इंसान बन सकें
Yes bro, well said ❤
"Dharm and science" is very helpful book 📚 written by wahiduddine Khan
Any topic about islam on that book?
@@itsanewday5219 dharm mai islam bhi ata hai gawar 🌚
@@BhagatSingh-gr6rp chutiye dharm means duty hota hai na ki religion
That's a famous quote of MORGAN FREEMAN :- All the things that our mind can not answer will become miracle ..
Or so called scientific theory.
@@aaryan_B055you should throw mobile which also a gift of science not god
@@charmingdawn the brain which made the phone is not created by science
@@ishanabhavsar thats the part of nature
@@charmingdawn correct ! It's not science. And all sciences we know so far, are Theories and theories are Always open to being Disproved ... upon formation of new theory.
I am merely using Logic. Christianity and Islam had Fkat earth static earth where as ancient Sanatan scriptures had earth as well as other stars and also Multiple universes. (I'm not talking about Puran). And That is Inclusion of Science in Dharm.
We only use less than 3 percent of our brains... much more to understand.
I can go on and on bro 🤗 but I won't bother you much 😂
भगवान को केवल प्रसन्नता बता दिया संत महाराज ने। जब संत ही गलत परिभाषा देंगे तो विपक्ष तो मजबूत होगा ही। श्री भगवान को ग्रंथों से समझना चाहिये ❤
Aapne kya samjha ग्रंथो se wo ज्ञान janta ko dijiye?
Gauhar Raza is a great man 👍
-महर्षि वाल्मीकि ने रामायण लिखा और बाबा साहेब ने संविधान दोनों ही दलित थे
फिर वो कौन से मूर्ख लोग हैं जो संविधान मानते हैं पर रामायण नहीं
@@Pktrader-kg4fy Vo tum murkh log ho jo abhi bhi jaati se aadhaar par desh ko बांटते rahte ho. And ramayan ke jitne bhi proof aaj tak dikhaye gaye hain most of them are conspiracies and there is no conclusive evidence to support the argument from the religious community. I am not a Muslim or anti hindu I just talk on facts
@@shivangsrivastava6024 you don't know anything about fact.
Read about ramsetu.there are so many prouf which are showing the prouf of ramayan . God is everywhere need to open our eyes.
I am talking about fact only not any community and cast
@@Pktrader-kg4fy Is this not like that logic, for example if new york city is shown in spider man and it really Exists, so giving an illogical argument that spider man might also have been in existence.
@@Pktrader-kg4fy For every proof in favour of the existence of God there are 100 proofs against it
Every religion teach don't kill anyone 'However religion is the only thing here is responsible behind almost All the killings' 💯
Harsh reality 🙏
Soo damn true
A debate on God and Science without *Philosophy* will always remain incomplete and unjust.
yes.
Exactly
आशीर्वाद से किसी का भला नहीं होता श्राफ से किसी का बूरा नहीं होता विश्वास नहीं तो मुझे देकर देखलो।
बहुत सही चर्चा हो रही है ऐसी ही चर्चाएं होनी चाहिए मीडिया में ज्ञान विज्ञान के लिए उत्तम सर्वोत्तम है और यह सही भी है!
Bhai ye sab charcha congress ki time ki hai
Ab ye sab nhi hota hai
Ab to aur dharmik conference krte hai
Swami Balendu ne 100 baat ki 1 baat kahi hai👌...aastikon se tark mat kijiye...tark ka scope science mein hota hai, religion mein nai.. period.
Sanatan dharma tark pe hi chalta he. Ved me khud likha he ke jab tak me aapke tark pe khara na utru tab tak mujpe vishwas mat kijiye
@@logicalbhakt4483 kaha likha hai bhai
Jara hame bhi batao
😂😂
@@jeetparmar9 You are right, fact is that we have no written record of what was originally said in the Vedas, it was all transmitted orally and much was added and subtracted before it was all penned just a few centuries back.
Moreover, during ancient times, knowledge and learning was limited.
Usliye to bekoof bante ho dharam ke naam par
@@EverydayLifeandScience aisa kuch nahi hai bhai chaye jo bhi bolo mein dono ko hi maanta hu vigyan vigyan hai aur god vigyan se bhi upar jisko samjha nahi jaa sakta
I was bigger theist in family but now I am bigger atheist in my family
अंत मे विज्ञान की चर्चा सफल रहा
ई बाबा तो ईश्वर को लेकर कोई एक राय रख ही नहीं रहे....कभी बॉडी, कभी आस्था, कभी प्रसन्नता का नाम दे रहे हैं☺☺☺
😅😀😀😀😀😀
Bhai sab dhram jhute hai... Science sahi hai...
Right
कोई एक राय है ही नहीं क्यूंकि 'ईश्वर' एक मनगढंत वस्तु है!
कारक परिणाम इस संसार का प्राकृतिक भौतिक सत्य है
विज्ञान और बुद्धिवाद सही मार्ग है बिना किसी संदेह
Kyuki ye baba bhagwan ko sirf manta h janta nhi h
Mujhe nahi pata par kuchh chije mujhe pahle se Anubhav ho jati thii.... Isliye main purn vishwas karta hu... Please aap sab log upnishad padho...
@ghost27611bhai tu bhi sabko reply kar raha hai iss comment section me 😂
The perfect answer is that nobody knows. For me, I'll believe if I see it. God is just a belief, not a being. God is different for everyone.
@Vive la vida it depends on what people want in their lives and what they imagine god to be, if someone does something miraculously good for me, he's god for me at that moment in time, that's it
@hajun What proof did he give? That's right. None. And I don't believe in god myself, just saying that maybe it's a possibility
@hajun People can decide who they want to worship.
@@Debator_Slayer its your point of view and its okay
Muje pura biswas he vagawan par....Jai Shree Ram, 🚩🕉️🙏 Har Har Mahadev 🚩🕉️🙏
Nahi hota bhai
Yahi kalyug Hai sahab Krishna ji ki ye baat Gita mai varnan Hai Jai shrii Krishna 🙏🙏
Na hi koi satyug h or or nahi kalyug
Ye sb dharm ke thekedaro ka hi purpganda h
Vinod mathur chutiye tujhe kaise pata tere bhagwan asli hai tu dhek kar aya tha ?
Anpad yug ko sat yug kaha h Q k pap kisi k pas itni Budhi nhi thi ki vo sahi aur galt prr sawal krta...aaj pda likh vyakti janta h ki kya kese hota h isi ko kalyug kaha h scientific yug ko kalyug ......
विज्ञान ही सत्य है धर्म ने तो मानवजाति का विनाश ही किया है
Kisi maulvi ko bhi bula lete,thode dange dekh lete
Hehe
🤣😂🤣😂
मवलैवी आया नहीं होगा?
🤪
17:50 जो देश जितने कट्टर h वो उतने ही बदहाल है
The line is true
Ex - Pakistan
धर्म व भगवान के नाम पर पेट के पूजारियों ,पादरियों, कथावचकों,पाठियों, मोलवियों, आदि धर्म के ठेकेदारों की दूकानदारी व उसी दूकानदारी से इनका पेट पलता है और ऐशो आराम की जिदंगी जीते है ,,व भोली भाली जनता को बेवकूफ बना रखा है ,,,,,,इन्कलाब जिन्दाबाद ,,कडवा सत्य
Right
Aap sahi bol rhe ho bhai
10000....
% right ❤️
धन्यवाद जी
धन्यवाद जी
I am a pantheist. I believe that universe and nature is God. I don't believe in Big Boss type of God.👍
Can be true....god is not like something they show in tv....its just a universe
But that's how the word God us used in common parlance. Pantheists and deists twist the definition of the word so as to fit to their narrative.
I like this debate
From Florida, USA
May 18, 2020.
U liked this debate 1 year before.
Apko nobel prize milega😄
One of the best debate on the existence of God.
Atheist or theists?
Sare scietist ko dil se samaal ❤❤❤❤
भैंस के आगे बीन बजाने से,
भैंस नागिन नहीं बन जाएगी,
haha
Kehena ka matlb kya he
You cannot argue against something that is not clearly defined. Here is GOD.
Science is a very wide subject. Limiting it to only matter or material things is a great mistake. Physics, Chemistry , Biology etc are material science.
But when we talk about God its altogether a different science ie, the science of spirit or spiritual science. The problem is that we try to understand Spiritual science through the prism of material science. It may help to some extent, but we may not get the complete picture. That is the limitation of material science.
We must understand that both sciences are different and trying to understand one through the other leads to many misconceptions about spiritual science.
There are different ways and methods in the material science itself to understand different aspects of our surroundings. The processes, procedures, tools and experiments used in Physics cant be used completely in Biology or Chemistry. To measure a small distance between two different objects, we may use a small measuring tape, but when the distance between sun and earth is to be measured we cant use the same methods and tools. We have to use different tools and methods to measure it ie Telescope.
But we conveniently forget to acknowledge that Spiritual science also has a different set of procedures and tools. To try to understand God and spirituality through material process and tools is like measuring the distance between sun and the earth using a measuring tape, which is very childish and impossible.
Where do we find the processes and tools? In the sacred texts of different religions ie Bible, Quran , Gita, etc.They provide the necessary tools and procedures and experiments to understand GOD. To understand physics we have physical experiments, for chemistry , chemical experiments, for biology - biological experiments. Similarly to understand God and Spirituality we have Spiritual Experiments. But the tragedy with people of todays generation is the they are very eager to conduct material experitments but arent ready to conduct the spiritual experiments with the same enthusiasm.
Scientists put on their hardwork and energy for so many years or maybe even their lifetime to search after something or invent something. They keep on doing experiments for so many years to come to a proper conclusions. Thomas Edison spent 12 years of his life vigorously in inventing a bulb. He didnt think of anything else, didnt eat properly, didnt sleep properly till the day when he finally invented bulb. Examples of many other scientists can also be cited here. But have material scientists or even the people in this discussion have spent even half the time for understanding the Spiritual science through Spiritual processes and tools of time which they have given to material science? No.
To understand GOD one must also approach a spiritual teacher. Just a plain reading of holy books wont do. Just by reading a book you dont become a doctor or an engineer. You need to approach a university , learn it through a teacher, read books, perform experiments, do practicals, remain under a doctor or engineer for some years as apprentice and then he or she shall become a doctor/ engineer. such a long process.
The point is we cant understand material science independently. Similarly we cant understand GOD independently.
The Question is are we ready to go similar lengths to understand GOD? Are we ready to go through the Spiritual Process and Practices? Are we ready to accept a spiritual master or teacher? Do we have the same enthusiasm to know and see GOD the way we learn material science.
Dont accept anything blindly, but dont reject anything blindly either !!!!
Correct bro..here both religious and scientists both are debating in there own way both are foolish both have no idea about other aspects
@@arijitdey6193 scientist stay foolish and stay hungry for truth but I am saying a fact if the religions in the way they define religion as there is divine intervention everywhere which is not true they don't know anything about even nature how can they claim to know God not even a single piece of evidence or any logical thing just vague arguments whatever is disclosed about nature was by science which is true study of nature but religion claims it knows all
@Nihilist Existentialist
Soul is reality,
regardless what your beliefs may be.
Experiments? Proof?
But are you willing to enter the laboratory
She said: Two hydrogen and one oxygen atom make water.
He said: Atoms! Give me a break! These little things you can't even see. You put a few together, and out comes water … You expect me to believe that?
She said: It's a fact. Two hydrogens and one oxygen make water.
He said: I'll believe it when I see it. Prove it to me!
She said: All right.
He said: You're crazy. You can't prove it!
She said: I can prove it to you. Just come into my laboratory and do the experiment. The first step is to look in this …
He said: Oh yeah. Right. Good one. The laboratory. You want me to go into your laboratory and do your experiment your way that's brainwashing.
She said: No … If you'll just take a look in this microscope …
He said: I'm not gonna do any of your crazy rituals! What are you trying to do, convert me!? You people are nuts. You believe all these crazy things. Two hydrogens and one oxygen make water! Gimme a break!
She said: I can show you if you'll look in this microscope …
He said: I'll never follow your rules! You can't prove anything to me!
* * *
She said: God exists. If we focus our efforts and devotion on God, our lives will become complete.
He said: God! Gimme a break! This mythological character you can't even see. Worship Him and you'll feel dandy … You expect me to believe that?
She said: It's a fact. God exists. We become complete through devotion to Him.
He said: Yeah right. I'll believe it when I see it. Prove it to me!
She said: All right.
He said: You're crazy. You can't prove it!
She said: I can prove it to you, just come into the laboratory and do the experiment. The first step is to remove the blindfold of attachment to material …
He said: Oh yeah. Right. Good one. The laboratory. You want me to come into your laboratory and do your experiment your way that's brainwashing.
She said: No … If you'll just begin chanting Hare Krsna …
He said: I'm not gonna do any of your crazy rituals! What are you trying to do, convert me!? You people are nuts. You believe all these crazy things: God and spiritual worlds and … Gimme a break! You can't show me God.
She said: I'll show you. Let me just explain …
He said: Just show me God!
She said: I'm trying to tell you where to look.
He said: I'll never follow your rules! You can't prove anything to me!
Soul is reality,
regardless what your beliefs may be.
Experiments? Proof?
But are you willing to enter the laboratory?
I agree the spiritual aspect of life must also be explored. But spiritualism in itself is not a science, and in many instances we have seen people who talk about spiritualism in that regard are basically selling pseudoscience
@@ex009adityarajsingh2 It only claims that it knows, that in itself doesn't make it true. If I claim to know everyone in the earth that doesn't make it true.
Brain is the creator of both positive and negative thoughts. We need to arrange and adjust it according to our life style.
Aaj kal aese interview kyo nahi hote😢😢😢😢😢
Bohot hi shandar charcha ...ese discussion or laiye channel pr
Being atheist is not actually easy for believers.
💯
Nice, Insightful. 🙏
एक मामूली सी दुकान बग़ैर किसी आदमी के नहीं चल सकती तो इतना बड़ा अनंत ब्रह्मांड खुदा के बगैर केसे चल सकता है
एक खुदा है जो इस पूरी सृष्टि का मालिक है ला इलाहा इल्लाल्ला
Mohd Shamil ..bahut sundar bhai...... Apka hi ek Hindu bhai.....
सर, बिजली के कारण पंखा चल रहा है और पेट्रोल की वजह से कार चलती है। तब हमें विश्वास करना चाहिए कि पेट्रोल और बिजली ईश्वर है।
यह सही है कि पूरा ब्रह्मांड चल रहा है लेकिन भगवान के कारण नहीं बल्कि कुछ वैज्ञानिक अवधारणा के कारण
@@raunakraj715 😂😂 tu abhi baccha hai,
Science rocks🤘🤘🤘🔥
Always
@@sureshbamaniya7864 🤘🤘
@@SpectreGR396 💌✌️
Can your scientists remove sadness from life forever not like in cycle of sadness and happiness only happiness for whole life
@@shivamssargam5722 Science is the synonym of peace, prosperity, health and overall happiness. It's science only which has facilitated you by providing you with modern gadgets so that you could utilise them in speaking against science and in favour of religion.
"It's science alone which can solve the problems of hunger and poverty, of insanitation and illiteracy. Of vast resources running to waste and a rich country inhabited by starving people. Who indeed could afford to ignore science today? At every turn we have to seek it's aid. The future belongs to science and those who make friends with science." - Ex prime minister Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru
Science is great
इंसान की सबसे बड़ी सकतीहै
अपना विश्वास
Uppo deepo up bhavah
💐💐 BUDDHAM SARNAM GACHHAMI 💐💐
No buddh because we're atheist
@@letscode5367 Buddha..never said
He is god..like others. He just show right approach towards life - living. So
BUDDHAM SARNAM GACHHAMI..
@@milanparmar4775 This is the problem if someone is netural you made slogan out of them. Just see the life without anyone's other eyes.
@@letscode5367 who forced anyone to follow Buddhism ?
And Buddhism provide samething as any neutral or atheist want..as Buddha said..
" APO DEEPO BHAVA "
@@milanparmar4775 I don't knwo anything about buddhism but No one can force anyone to do anything. Yea, but I don't know about buddha
There was a time when rajya sabha tv conducted thoughtful discussions
True
इस दुनिया में जो भी बात सिद्ध ना हो सके वो बिलकुल निराधार है.., अथात्र ईश्वर मात्र झूट फरेब है जिसे कुछ ग्धो ने अपने लाभ के लिये एस्टमाल किया है और आज भी कर रहे हैं.......🌘🌘🌘🌚🌑🌏
जब समझ दिमाग से बाहर की हो जाती है, तब हम ईश्वर या भगवान के नाम से दिमाग को भ्रमित कर आगे बढ़ जाते हैं और इसको आस्था बता देते हैं। जब विज्ञान द्वारा समझ आती है तो वही भ्रमित भगवान और आस्था की कोरी कल्पना रफूचक्कर हो जाती है।
Debate must be organised among scientists and Shankaracharya
सही कहा
Einstein also said he never believed in gods too
He was an agnostic.
Vigyan ko samjhna in pakhandi log kabhi nahi samjh sakte hai ..murkh to murkh hi rahenge ..vigyan jindabaad 🙏🙏🙏🙏
It is not that you think that is why you are there, but you think only because you are there. You can doubt everything but not yourself. So knowing yourself is spirituality and not any religion. Knowing the Self is experiencing the God.
धर्म पाखण्ड , बिज्ञान सतय खोज सिद्द लगा मेरेको , भगवान् सिर्फ शब्द है ईसका मतलब जो भी लगा सक्ा है धार्मिक गुरूलोग
What a great debate hat's off u sir...❤️ I'm listening in 20th century 😎
21st
Atma purnjanm kya hai
Excellent discussion!
Though this discussion has been closed in conclusively, yet Gurbani has its clearcut and conclusive answer.