Exactly. And I've seen a clip of Wonyoung without makeup on IZONE Chu and she deadass looks like 12 years old lol, she's only 14 but when they put makeup on her, it gives the illusion that she's like 16 which is so weird to me idk lmao
Unfortunately, most of the girls who were eliminated have a lot of talent and that is very sad because they deserve debut,Lee Ha Eun were one of them, I will wait for her I hope her debut soon.Come on Ha Eun!!
@king taeyeon Wonyoung has same age as her, but Wonyoung get the 1st position, Haeun is way better. Maybe because Wonyoung looks more mature or what? It's all about visual i think *no hate for Wonyoung
@@keilet8582 i believe mnh will take good care of her, I actually like her talent and both of the Wellmade Yedang trainees, Hwang Soyeon and Kang Damin. Now Hwang joined mnh, wish all of them will go through flower road.
I actually liked her since ep1 just as someone said earlier,because she doesnt put on tons of make up to change her face completely.She wasnt the youngest but she looks like the youngest and she has the cuteness of little girls too 👆this is why i like her a lot I hope she debuts and please do remember her 😣
I feel so bad for her, because at the end of the day what it really came down to was her look. I know we all know she's a cutie pie, and she definitely has charisma. But while some of the people who made the final cut had different talents (singing, dancing, etc.), I think what killed it for her was that she didn't meet their rigid standard of looks for the group. Even talented people like Chaeyeon BARELY scraped by with the final spot, which is INSANE considering how multi-talented she is. It's such a shame when you see really great people get overlooked, and I think that the fact that she kept ranking low despite her obvious talent really hit at her confidence a bit at times. I hope she keeps trying and gets a shot, she really deserves a solid debut.
even though chaeyeon was on the cutting edge, she’s in izone, and at least eunbi and yena (all rounders) managed to secure such high ranks. plus the girls got their first win, so there’s really no point in complaining.
@@kyooongie I don't deny at all that izone is INCREDIBLY fortunate to have some all rounders like those you mentioned. But people complain because these groups always end up with some people who strictly get into the group due to their visuals and not much else. It's hard to see young people like this kid go through so much, only to be shot down and overlooked just because they don't have a particular look that some of the K-fans like- especially when they're still adorable looking like this girl. So yes, there is a point to complain about.
People really are confusing talent to charisma. Her talent is top notch no question. The thing is, no one wanted to see her on stage. Don't even give me crap about koreans only caring about looks, because that is actually bullshit. Her looks have very little to do with her not debuting. Right now, at this moment, she had no "talent" in being an IDOL. She can dance and sing, but so what. An idol is to deliver their music in a way that allows audience to enjoy the stage and make their audience listen to their song by providing fan service or whatever. Being able to dance and sing just helps a person achieving popularity, it doesn't make you an idol. What is most important in stage charm and aura. Sakura and Wonyoung overflows with that, and Sakura isn't even pretty in Korean standards. What she does and her actions makes her seem as if she's the prettiest in produce48. I'm sorry, but until she works on her stage charm, I'm not gonna say she deserves to debut.
She would’ve been a better maknae than Wonyoung. She’s a lot more ready to debut than Wonyoung will ever be, but she still has a lot of opportunities, which gives me hope that I’ll be able to see her again soon.
Even chungha was underrated if we were to compare to her talent until she finally debuted.... haeun stillmis young and got a whole load of bigger things in front of her, so as long as we support her, i know she’ll one day be a staaaaaar
@@eggthehotdog935 I think she's very pretty. She looks more like a 14 year old than Wonyoung. Haeun just doesn't fit the typical Korean beauty standard.
She was one of the ones who stood out to me since the first EP, but the look she gives at 6:52 sealed the deal. I still can't forget it and came to this video just to watch it again. I'll be anticipating her debut!!
Vivien Diawani Rosevel yeah good thing seulgi can make debuted.. I have to say honest thing.. for me seulgi is not really pretty in red velvet but.. I love her more and more cause her talent is undeniable.. and I see her beauty in every RV performance.. I wish the girl ini this video can make her own debut.. she is so talented..
I didn't watch P48 but I watched some of the performances out of curiosity and when I heard her voice in Instruction, it sounded so clear and pleasant! It made me want to know about her. She's crazy talented!
Hana REmake you’re right and 7:36 is haeun’s vocals. Sometimes members just lipsync eventhough it’s not their part. But I may have misunderstood you’re comment if that’s the case.
Sorry..but this is my opinion ..i think that knetz just saw who is that have a very beautiful girl not the talented one ..sorry again this just my opinion
For me nako was the only one with the main dancer ( sorry i dont remember her name) , who was choose for their talent.( Nako her voice was Amazing during gfriend performance and now she is in izone) but i feel so sorry for other Girls who dont can shine because of time or because they dont have the opportunity..
B Sandra yea.. Well, i seriously don't understand what's the panel of judges (i mean those senior idol/artists) were for bcoz at the end it would be always based on the votes from fans.. And usually most of kfans/knetz will look at their idol faces first b4 talent.. This kind of survival program is bad actually.. I'm not bashing anyone + I'm just stating my opinion
She and Wang Ke is talented, i have to say that Wonyoung is nothing to compare with Haeun in vocal and personality. And Wang ke too, i think that she is more talented and beautiful than her sister Yi Ren
Ok, i have to admit that Wang Ke vocal is not good. But we have to admit that her visual is great, too. Wang Ke is great when you put her in any concept. Don’t put your opinion on me, because we have different opinion. And if you ask me “How dare you say that?” The answer is I’m free to give my opinion.
they aren't sisters... they're both chinese and share the same surname (which is fairly common) but they're not related. it's like saying haeun and chaeyeon are sisters
isn't there anyone want to make a petition to debut her with other pd48 trainee like the new jbj? honestly i prefer her, han chowon, wang yiren, kim nayoung, kim doah for the line up
For everyone hating on Wonyoung for this, please stop. I think we can all agree that this season wasn't very fair, but what's done is done. All the trainees on Produce48 were talented, it would've been a good group no matter what. Wonyoung did absolutely nothing except try her best, the same as everyone else, so please do not give her hate for this. Support both IZone and all the trainees who didn't make it!
YES HAEUN DESERVES BETTER but this doesnt mean that wonyoung doesnt deserve her position. We can also seek solitude in the fact that haeun is still young and definitely can debut its a matter of when
she’s the same age as wonyoung, yet she’s a lot more skilled in dancing and singing. the reason wonyoung got to debut instead of haeun is literally because she’s super tall and stunningly pretty lol
I don’t know what to say anymore, she’s my favorite in first sight, not just because her cute, but her dance and her voice. She’s the definition of IDOL . And I just hope she will get what she hopes, her future must be so bright with those talents. I put so much my hope on her , I hope she could be in the final line up but her destiny something different :’). I hope she’ll always gain loves from people 😁☺️
I don't get why everyone compare Ha Eun and Woonyong... Because they're both young doesn't mean they're comparable. I really liked her, she seems to be so pure, so true, you just have to love her ! But I don't see her in IZONE, I don't really like the lineup nor the concept they choose for the group, so I think it's not a bad thing for her not to be in
she deserves soo much more. She was seriously my fav from all those trainees. She srsly deserves better. I'm just waiting for her to debut and be a bop
I'm okay with her not debuting, she's very young and I know other idols debuted young too like taemin and Krystal but I want her to have her youth while she can because I know she'll EXPLODE once she debuts. :))) But if any one had to be the maknae, I'd prefer haeun, she beats wonyoung in every category: dance, vocal, and visual.
Wonyoung was the youngest and won the show... if you didn't know lol. YEs she beats her in dance and definetely vocal, not sure about visual though. Wy's visual is what made her win lol.
@@redfruit7723 no, at her audition they judges stated that wonyoung was the youngest in the show, and asked her age, everyone was shocked. Wonyoung was 14, haeun was 15
I followed Produce 48 since the beginning and tbh I thought she was one of those girls that is going to be very popular because she is really young and such a well rounded trainee. Such a shame she got eliminated:( I was rooting for her
see, so many trainees on pd48 deserve justice, like haeun and yunjin for example (i will probably never shut up about yunjin because bro she was like the best vocal on the show and y'all just-) they had so much talent in all the areas, stage presence, vocals, dance, but they got eliminated i'll never understand how haeun didn't at least make it to the finals, she was clearly born for a stage and her hard work makes her stage presence, vocals, and dancing that much better if she doesn't debut soon, i'll be surprised, she seems ready to go finally, all of y'all that are saying she doesn't look good, you need to get your eyes checked. she's beautiful and anyone can fight me on this
People be blaming either Wonyoung and Hyewon for Haeun not debuting when both of the girls never were the ones who decides who tf is gonna debut in IZ*ONE
Omg I was looking for a comment like this because I could never hate any contestant in the produce series because they are ALL talented and deserving of recognition
it is undeniable that looks matters in kpop industry, and for her to succeed i hope she finds her own style ( i mean make up style), it's such a shame if all that talents wasted because of appearence
This is the problem of produced 48 eh favotism and the blind audience and the wrong votes. So many talented like haeun gaeun yunjin nayoung miyu chowon sian yiren sihyeon etc got elimated. But the 12 winners is good too not hate i came here because of izone is disband on april
Many of the PD48 trainees are underrated but has a talent and passion. Maybe this wasn't their time yet to debut. God has plans for them so let's wait. God bless us all!😄😇😊
please do not compare to other member. you can like that member but not to understimated other member.. izone is the best group ever. they are not just visual but also they have many talent in singing and dancing. i know that someday other member will be debut soon. so please give support and love to izone ❤❤
She have better vocal and better dance skill than wonyoung I hope she will debut first but i think i'm wrong she doesnt debut 😭😭😭 If she debut she will be the best maknae better than wonyoung
Wonyoung will always be a better Maknae than Haeun. It doesn't matter if she has talent when no one wants to see her on stage. Haeun has nearly zero charisma on stage. If you think she does, you are confusing charisma with skill. She is skillful in dancing and singing, but that doesn't make you an idol. What Wonyoung has makes you a popular idol.
I was so impressed by her at first episode and I had beed always having an expectation on her, but somehow she couldn't rank high later and I also felt so hard to accept. Haen is just a little girl who is thinking about nothing overdone but only her dream of singing and dancing, on age of 14. Honestly I feel some girls in this program already lost the "pureness" that they supposed to have on their teen ages, but fortunately, Haen still has it. She is naturally cute, and she is just focusing on singing/dancing without any other thinking. She is just still too young but I do believe that her potential and talent are gonna be revealed very very soon in near future. Don't be sad, I never feel sad for her because she didnt fail at all. This program is just voting for teen girls who meet the visual standards that adults have, but way too ignored their age and what they suppose to have. I guarantee that if this program is not rated by fans but by the professional teachers, Haen will be top three.
Haeun built herself up on the show more as a soloist than in a group. The bad thing though is that mnh already have their money making soloist. If she won in pd48, she will still be outshined by her fellow members. She aint really a standout in a group, being a soloist would be better for her, but not at her current age. I dont think she would be able to handle the media alone at her age. Talent-wise she is ready but I dont think she is mentally ready for debut.
This video made me think of Kim Do Ah my 1st pick in Produce 48. I'm so happy she debuted already 💕 Hwaiting Lee Ha Eun!! She really deserves to debut. (btw I love her kick during the evaluation. That kick made me love her 😍)
Yo all 96 of them are talented, but its not possible for all 96 to debut yes? Lets all just support all of them, they all worked hard, they all deserve to debut, its not the end for the rest of the 84 girls 😊
i feel like it wouldve been her time to shine with 100%! the fresh and innocent concept really suits her. anyway, as the amazing and talented trainee that she is, i wouldnt be shocked seeing her become a successful idol one day
She was definitely one of the most well rounded and talented trainees, especially for her age. Honestly much better than Minju and Hyewon who only knew how to open their eyes wide and make cute faces.
![[C.C.] SOYEON gets furious after watching the trainee's performance #GIDLE #SOYEON](/img/n.gif)
Finally a 15 year old that actually looks like a 15 year old in PD48.
Really I thought she was 12 or 13 years old😅
Exactly.
And I've seen a clip of Wonyoung without makeup on IZONE Chu and she deadass looks like 12 years old lol, she's only 14 but when they put makeup on her, it gives the illusion that she's like 16 which is so weird to me idk lmao
@@natiandanet same she looks 12 to me
@@natiandanet same
Dasia She does look young too especially when you see her forehead :))
Unfortunately, most of the girls who were eliminated have a lot of talent and that is very sad because they deserve debut,Lee Ha Eun were one of them, I will wait for her I hope her debut soon.Come on Ha Eun!!
@king taeyeon Wonyoung has same age as her, but Wonyoung get the 1st position, Haeun is way better. Maybe because Wonyoung looks more mature or what? It's all about visual i think *no hate for Wonyoung
That's why I hate survival show. Because I think it's all about fame. Imagine Lee Chaeyeon is at Rank12. She is way better than other.
Yes including Cho Ahyeong, Yoo Minyoung, Huh Yunjin
Lee Kaeun too. She has lot of talent but not win. That make me feel so sad :'(
Yeah. Cho Won and Ka Eun also deserved to debut.
give her 2-3 years..she'll leave everyone in the dust.
Elena Galliani I wish same too.. I hope her agency not waste her talent
@@keilet8582 i dont think they will
Lol
@@keilet8582 i believe mnh will take good care of her, I actually like her talent and both of the Wellmade Yedang trainees, Hwang Soyeon and Kang Damin. Now Hwang joined mnh, wish all of them will go through flower road.
Omg yas she’s gonna *SLAY*
I actually liked her since ep1 just as someone said earlier,because she doesnt put on tons of make up to change her face completely.She wasnt the youngest but she looks like the youngest and she has the cuteness of little girls too
👆this is why i like her a lot
I hope she debuts and please do remember her 😣
she is actually the youngest, she was born on 30th october 2004 whereas wonyoung was the 31st august
mollie yeaaa i didnt know that before but thanks ٩( ᐛ )و
same fam 😔😔
mollie OMG she younger than me... I wonder what am I doing w my childhood life. XD
park haeyoons maid I’m sorry but during the show she’s 15 wonyoung was 13
I feel so bad for her, because at the end of the day what it really came down to was her look. I know we all know she's a cutie pie, and she definitely has charisma. But while some of the people who made the final cut had different talents (singing, dancing, etc.), I think what killed it for her was that she didn't meet their rigid standard of looks for the group. Even talented people like Chaeyeon BARELY scraped by with the final spot, which is INSANE considering how multi-talented she is. It's such a shame when you see really great people get overlooked, and I think that the fact that she kept ranking low despite her obvious talent really hit at her confidence a bit at times. I hope she keeps trying and gets a shot, she really deserves a solid debut.
Ikr :( It's sad how SOME koreans prize beauty over talent, and tbh I find Haeun really cute??!
even though chaeyeon was on the cutting edge, she’s in izone, and at least eunbi and yena (all rounders) managed to secure such high ranks. plus the girls got their first win, so there’s really no point in complaining.
@@kyooongie I don't deny at all that izone is INCREDIBLY fortunate to have some all rounders like those you mentioned. But people complain because these groups always end up with some people who strictly get into the group due to their visuals and not much else. It's hard to see young people like this kid go through so much, only to be shot down and overlooked just because they don't have a particular look that some of the K-fans like- especially when they're still adorable looking like this girl. So yes, there is a point to complain about.
I think she looks pretty and cute. Her face reminds me a little of Seulgi when she smiles.
People really are confusing talent to charisma. Her talent is top notch no question. The thing is, no one wanted to see her on stage. Don't even give me crap about koreans only caring about looks, because that is actually bullshit. Her looks have very little to do with her not debuting. Right now, at this moment, she had no "talent" in being an IDOL. She can dance and sing, but so what. An idol is to deliver their music in a way that allows audience to enjoy the stage and make their audience listen to their song by providing fan service or whatever. Being able to dance and sing just helps a person achieving popularity, it doesn't make you an idol. What is most important in stage charm and aura. Sakura and Wonyoung overflows with that, and Sakura isn't even pretty in Korean standards. What she does and her actions makes her seem as if she's the prettiest in produce48. I'm sorry, but until she works on her stage charm, I'm not gonna say she deserves to debut.
*_HAEUN DESERVES BETTER🤧_*
The audience were blind not to see how _talented_ she is! This season was just really unfair!😫😅
She's gonna get better, we just need to be patience
But a amazing girl group debuted
At least
Didn't you think that most of em were voting based on visual sometimes. Well not all but mostly
Well, now we know why it was unfair...
She would’ve been a better maknae than Wonyoung. She’s a lot more ready to debut than Wonyoung will ever be, but she still has a lot of opportunities, which gives me hope that I’ll be able to see her again soon.
IKNOW RIGHT??!😢😢😢
wonyoung is perfect in her role..?
I don’t agree.
I don’t agree
I agree😄 but wonyoung is good too. Just change hyewon
Even chungha was underrated if we were to compare to her talent until she finally debuted.... haeun stillmis young and got a whole load of bigger things in front of her, so as long as we support her, i know she’ll one day be a staaaaaar
Send Help chungha was underrated until the bang bang performance everyone starts to notice her talent in dance and singing skills
재능 있고 좋았는데 너무 어려보여서 떨어진게 없지않아있었지ㅜㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 원영이나 유진이는 제나이때처럼안보이는데 하은이는 너무 애기같이 생겼었다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 분량도 진짜ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
바실리스크 하 진짜 ㅠㅠ 등급 평가 제 기준으로 젤 잘한건 아니라도 젤 기억 많이 났는데 ㅠㅠ
제 원픽이였는데ㅠㅠㅠ
조금만 더 연습해도 채연이 만큼의 실력 될듯..
If she's in Iz*one, she will be the *Golden Maknae*
agreeeeee
Ostrigo do people always have to bring other people down like she didn’t choose herself to be in the group like give Wonyoung a break
Ostrigo at least learn to spell “Wonyoung” properly and correctly before trying to talk down on her :)
Zavulan Alexandra I agree wonyoung tried hard too!
Just because you say someone has more talent than someone that doesn’t mean you are bringing the other person down.
she don't even need tons of makeup her charismatic shows all , but sad people keep sleeping on her🙂
Better vocals and better dancing! Couldn't even make it to top 30. Swear I wanter her to take the Top 1 instead of Wonyoung :(
Right!
Agree... Wonyoung has nothing
i think because she doesnt have enough visual aura while wonyoung has it
@@eggthehotdog935 I think she's very pretty. She looks more like a 14 year old than Wonyoung. Haeun just doesn't fit the typical Korean beauty standard.
@@lights_off_4ever well if she just mature a bit i think shes going to be a good idol
finally a video showing what real talent on produce 48:)
She was one of the ones who stood out to me since the first EP, but the look she gives at 6:52 sealed the deal. I still can't forget it and came to this video just to watch it again. I'll be anticipating her debut!!
She keep reminds me to Seulgi :')
Vivien Diawani Rosevel yeah good thing seulgi can make debuted.. I have to say honest thing.. for me seulgi is not really pretty in red velvet but.. I love her more and more cause her talent is undeniable.. and I see her beauty in every RV performance.. I wish the girl ini this video can make her own debut.. she is so talented..
their faces almost same too
definitely! she's going to be a natural beauty when she's older! and super talented too
Now that you mention it, I see the resemblance!
For me, she's like a mini Eunwoo from Produce 101.
솔직히 하은이가 Instruction에서 6위 한 건 말도 안 된다..개인적인 생각이지만 3위 안에 들 줄 알았는데..너무 아쉽다ㅜ
Instruction입니다.
@@user-ym7kz5ub4n 알려주셔서 감사합니다!수정할께요:)
It’s sad that the contestants who are ACTUALLY talented barely get the recognition they deserve
Exactly and now knowing that the show was rigged makes me angry.
I didn't watch P48 but I watched some of the performances out of curiosity and when I heard her voice in Instruction, it sounded so clear and pleasant! It made me want to know about her. She's crazy talented!
They didn't sing in "introduction" 🙈
Hana REmake they did. They just didn’t sing live, they prerecorded it.
Hana REmake you’re right and 7:36 is haeun’s vocals. Sometimes members just lipsync eventhough it’s not their part. But I may have misunderstood you’re comment if that’s the case.
@@baosimaosi "Instruction" :-) and vocals were prerecorded
There were 3 of them pre-recorded the song. And haeun sang almost half of the song. I'm still addicted to that performance
She was one of real talent in produce48. I like her voice and innocent smile. I'm waiting her debut.
Sorry..but this is my opinion ..i think that knetz just saw who is that have a very beautiful girl not the talented one ..sorry again this just my opinion
you dont need to be sorry. I also agree with you. I think visual is more important than talent in pd48.
For me nako was the only one with the main dancer ( sorry i dont remember her name) , who was choose for their talent.( Nako her voice was Amazing during gfriend performance and now she is in izone) but i feel so sorry for other Girls who dont can shine because of time or because they dont have the opportunity..
It's true tho.. All they care first is appearance, talent can go second
@@anamiramin3613 true if they do something like the voice honestly i dont think sakura will be choose..
B Sandra yea.. Well, i seriously don't understand what's the panel of judges (i mean those senior idol/artists) were for bcoz at the end it would be always based on the votes from fans.. And usually most of kfans/knetz will look at their idol faces first b4 talent.. This kind of survival program is bad actually.. I'm not bashing anyone + I'm just stating my opinion
한글이 없네 하은아ㅠㅠㅠ 언니가 진짜 많이 응원해!! 15살에 엄청난 실력이 믿어지지가 않아ㅜㅜ 지금처럼 자신감가지고 하다보면 꼭 데뷔할 수 있을거야 힘내자❤❤
이 언니 나중에 데뷔하면 진짜 인기많을듯.... 춤 잘추고 노래도 엄청 맑아서 실력파될듯
She and Wang Ke is talented, i have to say that Wonyoung is nothing to compare with Haeun in vocal and personality. And Wang ke too, i think that she is more talented and beautiful than her sister Yi Ren
Who are you talking about, ma friend?
Ok, i have to admit that Wang Ke vocal is not good. But we have to admit that her visual is great, too. Wang Ke is great when you put her in any concept. Don’t put your opinion on me, because we have different opinion. And if you ask me “How dare you say that?” The answer is I’m free to give my opinion.
wang ke is yi ren's sister?
ahh. i thouht they are sisters because of Cherry Nguyen's comment. 😂
they aren't sisters... they're both chinese and share the same surname (which is fairly common) but they're not related. it's like saying haeun and chaeyeon are sisters
isn't there anyone want to make a petition to debut her with other pd48 trainee like the new jbj? honestly i prefer her, han chowon, wang yiren, kim nayoung, kim doah for the line up
Agus Sidhi Kim Doah already preparing for her debut.. i saw an article on AllKpop and KoreaBoo
Kim sihyun too. Doah is going to debut in a sub unit soon so idk but she was mad talented.
i want 96 of them to debut
i wanted her and noe to be top 5 but they didn't even get to top 12 jjgfdfhklgf
Add Go Yoo Jin and Park Seoyoung
웃을 때 가끔 슬기 느낌 난다
춤도 노래도 잘하니까 더 크게 될 듯
She would've fit right in New Jeans! What a pity she still hasn't debuted :((
But she still has good chance to debut at her age
i hate it when visual wins over the precious talent like this
For everyone hating on Wonyoung for this, please stop. I think we can all agree that this season wasn't very fair, but what's done is done. All the trainees on Produce48 were talented, it would've been a good group no matter what. Wonyoung did absolutely nothing except try her best, the same as everyone else, so please do not give her hate for this. Support both IZone and all the trainees who didn't make it!
Agreed
@@hajimerou i bet you will watch 😂 if there's another season
@@user-iz5yf8oh9j lol, not gonna happen 😂😂
Totally agree, world needs more people like u ❤
True
This is why it should be an international competition when it comes to voting. Talent would have won... god.
She and WangKe are actually one of my favorite trainees I just hope both of them can debut and that it will be successful
YES HAEUN DESERVES BETTER but this doesnt mean that wonyoung doesnt deserve her position. We can also seek solitude in the fact that haeun is still young and definitely can debut its a matter of when
SHE DESERVES BETTER
Won young is younger than her, hello!
@@aamenajariwala1740 wonyoung is 2004 liners. what about haeun?
@@fitrisadiah1228 i think they are born in the same year but wonyoung was born later im not that sure though
Aamena Jariwala
Wonyoung was born on August 31st while haeun was born on October 30th so HELLO haeun is the youngest in the whole show
Say it with me:
She. Deserves. To. DEBUT.
진짜ㅜㅜ하은이언니 꼭데뷔했으면ㅜㅜ실력도외모도다되눈뎅ㅜㅜ
박서영 딱 티나네 우아하게 할때 아무리 A라도 나보다 어린애가 가르치니깐 어이없는거지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
근데 박서영은 인성이나 사회성은 몰라도 댄스 실력 하나만은 이하은보다는 나은데 자존심 상할만도 함
@@user-vr2re1ui3u ? 그래서 D 받으신거?
솔직히 이하은 믿을만한 실력자인데 떨어진거 아쉽다 ..
小さくて童顔でめっちゃかわいいのに、、才能も努力も感じられるしほんとにいい子なんだろうな
また歌が聴きたい(TT)
lee ha eun and chaeyeon is my favorite contestant in produce 48 😘 ..
the real talented :)
SAME😭
Same with me...i am tried to find out where is she ...
With so much talent I think she would shine best as a solo artist. I'm not mad she's not in the final lineup because of that.
I also believe having a group for her will just slow her down. Yeah i agree with you that soloing would be the best path for her.
Fifka Amal she's only 14 wtf no
Ash Lee,she’s be on solo about 2-3 years maybe
@@ashlee8480 so?
I wish lee ha eun will debut in best group and best agency
I love her so muchhhh
i think she can debut solo like chungha
For solo she not ready because she still young
I think when she 17/18 she will Debut
실력은 다 갖추고 있는데.. 안준영때문에.. 안타깝고 아까움ㅠㅠ 언니는 계속 너랑 이채연, 히토미 투표해따ㅠㅠ
Time for my yearly comment: She deserved way better
She recently created an IG acc @l_ha.eun
@@a.esterial ooo tysm for telling me!
@@user-jv3zw1gf4w you're welcome
Ester Mejares did she leave mnh?
@@user-ku9ko5pv4p yes
she’s the same age as wonyoung, yet she’s a lot more skilled in dancing and singing. the reason wonyoung got to debut instead of haeun is literally because she’s super tall and stunningly pretty lol
Yeah. And got first place some more
She is my favorite
She has it all vocal , dancing skill and stage presence is good but she only lack fan vote thats all .
진짜 춤 줄 때 너무 멋있다.... 당신 너무 대박 쩔어...
I don’t know what to say anymore, she’s my favorite in first sight, not just because her cute, but her dance and her voice. She’s the definition of IDOL . And I just hope she will get what she hopes, her future must be so bright with those talents. I put so much my hope on her , I hope she could be in the final line up but her destiny something different :’). I hope she’ll always gain loves from people 😁☺️
how is she now? any news? she's a star I hope she debut soon
ハウンちゃん好きだった！この子数年後間違いなく更に化けるだろうから楽しみ。デビューして欲しい✨
I don't get why everyone compare Ha Eun and Woonyong...
Because they're both young doesn't mean they're comparable.
I really liked her, she seems to be so pure, so true, you just have to love her !
But I don't see her in IZONE, I don't really like the lineup nor the concept they choose for the group, so I think it's not a bad thing for her not to be in
Thanks!!!
천퍼센트가 2조가 있었구나. 여러모로 채연이랑 겹치는부분이 있었네
@아아 그럼 2차 순위 발표식에서 이하은님 탈락했나요 ?
she deserves soo much more. She was seriously my fav from all those trainees. She srsly deserves better. I'm just waiting for her to debut and be a bop
My eyes were glued to her since the first ep. Her playfulness and her charisma on the stage and her talents captured my heart.. she deserved better.
I really miss her she is so talented i wish there's a time that she will debut fighting!!!!
she reminds me a lot of seulgi. monolid eyes, has a nice voice and even a great dancer.
イハウンまじで好きだった本当に推してた歌もダンスも最高すぎる😅❤︎❤︎
イハウンとイユジョンの1000%舞台で見たかった！！！！！！！！！😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
When she's more talented than most of the girls who debut in izone !!
not most lah some only haha chaeyeon talented too haha
Haha lol i dont think she more talented than allrounder like chaeyeon, yena, eubi, yujin,
Maybe she's lacking the charm or idol aura? But it's sad because she's really talented tho
Andrea Martins
But Chaeyeon, Eunbi, Yena, Yujin, Chaewon and Yuri is more talented than Haeun
If not all
I wished I had discovered her sooner:( she seems like such a ray of sunshine and I’m kinda crying:,) I hope her company will debut her soon
I'm okay with her not debuting, she's very young and I know other idols debuted young too like taemin and Krystal but I want her to have her youth while she can because I know she'll EXPLODE once she debuts. :))) But if any one had to be the maknae, I'd prefer haeun, she beats wonyoung in every category: dance, vocal, and visual.
Wonyoung was the youngest and won the show... if you didn't know lol.
YEs she beats her in dance and definetely vocal, not sure about visual though. Wy's visual is what made her win lol.
Ellite Equine haeun is actually younger than wonyoung
@@jungwooz0607 haha no, wonyoung was the youngest in PD48. Ha eun was 15 i believe at the start, wonyoung 14.
@@elliteequine3785 wonyoung is older than haeun though
@@redfruit7723 no, at her audition they judges stated that wonyoung was the youngest in the show, and asked her age, everyone was shocked. Wonyoung was 14, haeun was 15
It’s sad that she’s only ONE of the people who are super talented but don’t get recognition because of the korean beauty standards
I followed Produce 48 since the beginning and tbh I thought she was one of those girls that is going to be very popular because she is really young and such a well rounded trainee. Such a shame she got eliminated:( I was rooting for her
She reminds me of that girl in The Unit that was about 13 years old... Both were amazing but they didn't won. :'c
see, so many trainees on pd48 deserve justice, like haeun and yunjin for example (i will probably never shut up about yunjin because bro she was like the best vocal on the show and y'all just-)
they had so much talent in all the areas, stage presence, vocals, dance, but they got eliminated
i'll never understand how haeun didn't at least make it to the finals, she was clearly born for a stage and her hard work makes her stage presence, vocals, and dancing that much better
if she doesn't debut soon, i'll be surprised, she seems ready to go
finally, all of y'all that are saying she doesn't look good, you need to get your eyes checked. she's beautiful and anyone can fight me on this
People be blaming either Wonyoung and Hyewon for Haeun not debuting when both of the girls never were the ones who decides who tf is gonna debut in IZ*ONE
Omg I was looking for a comment like this because I could never hate any contestant in the produce series because they are ALL talented and deserving of recognition
this was exactly what i was looking for
Brilliant comment, really true
I'm watching pd48 for the third time because of kaeun, haeun, yunjin, and chowon
この子が垢抜けてバッキバキに踊って歌ったら最強だと思う
これからが楽しみ☺
I'll wait for her
I like this littel girl.
it is undeniable that looks matters in kpop industry, and for her to succeed i hope she finds her own style ( i mean make up style), it's such a shame if all that talents wasted because of appearence
I can't wait to see how beautiful she is when she grows up.
One of the few Royal A's of PD48 💖 Waiting for you debut, Ha Eun! Fighting, my number 1 pick in PD 48!
This video just turned me into a fan💓 i really hope her hard work pays off and look forward to her debut!✨
I really love her. I really do!!
Those underrated talented trainee from introduction team...ah i miss them
Heo Yunjin, Lee Haeun, Wang Ke, and Lee Gaeun are those trainees with the best stage presence and expressions but didn't get to debut. Underrated af!
This is the problem of produced 48 eh favotism and the blind audience and the wrong votes. So many talented like haeun gaeun yunjin nayoung miyu chowon sian yiren sihyeon etc got elimated. But the 12 winners is good too not hate i came here because of izone is disband on april
You know what, sometimes she look like Red Velvet Seulgi. Her dancing skill, singing ability, and when she smile it's resemble Seulgi a lot.
Many of the PD48 trainees are underrated but has a talent and passion. Maybe this wasn't their time yet to debut. God has plans for them so let's wait. God bless us all!😄😇😊
She looks like lee joo hyun from lightsum, the way they smile..
Natty was in the same position as her :(
Natty wasn't in Produce 48
@@takahashijuri3255 I know, i meant Idol School
@@IamAcompleteBoredGirl I miss natty
I really like Natty. She has suffered so much. I think she will never join any survival show :'( watching her in idol school break my heart :'(
@@elijahpham8048 me too
Just let her debut, solo. She deserved it more. She deserves long lasting attention. :)
実力もあるし、何よりハウンちゃんの顔のあどけなさというか少女そのものって感じが凄く好き。
デビューしてねお願いね。
she is literally an all-rounder ppl really need eye glasses
please do not compare to other member. you can like that member but not to understimated other member.. izone is the best group ever. they are not just visual but also they have many talent in singing and dancing. i know that someday other member will be debut soon. so please give support and love to izone ❤❤
Sorry, I am crying. This little girl deserve so much..unnie will wait for you.
She have better vocal and better dance skill than wonyoung
I hope she will debut first but i think i'm wrong she doesnt debut 😭😭😭
If she debut she will be the best maknae better than wonyoung
Jessica Twice Stop talking about Wonyoung she did nothing wrong, she worked as hard as she could and people voted for her, she deserves.
@@btsenjoyer thank you.
Jessica Twice aren’t you a bit too late? The show is over since like 2 months lol
Wonyoung will always be a better Maknae than Haeun. It doesn't matter if she has talent when no one wants to see her on stage. Haeun has nearly zero charisma on stage. If you think she does, you are confusing charisma with skill. She is skillful in dancing and singing, but that doesn't make you an idol. What Wonyoung has makes you a popular idol.
why you comparing wonyoung?
이런분을 프듀48 끝나고 알아서 너무 늦게 알아서....그게 너무 후회스럽네요 하은언니! 앞으로 롱런하자!
She could've easily replaced Wonyoung or even Hyewon. Too bad that she didn't get the recognition she deserved.
I was so impressed by her at first episode and I had beed always having an expectation on her, but somehow she couldn't rank high later and I also felt so hard to accept. Haen is just a little girl who is thinking about nothing overdone but only her dream of singing and dancing, on age of 14. Honestly I feel some girls in this program already lost the "pureness" that they supposed to have on their teen ages, but fortunately, Haen still has it. She is naturally cute, and she is just focusing on singing/dancing without any other thinking. She is just still too young but I do believe that her potential and talent are gonna be revealed very very soon in near future. Don't be sad, I never feel sad for her because she didnt fail at all. This program is just voting for teen girls who meet the visual standards that adults have, but way too ignored their age and what they suppose to have. I guarantee that if this program is not rated by fans but by the professional teachers, Haen will be top three.
Haeun built herself up on the show more as a soloist than in a group. The bad thing though is that mnh already have their money making soloist. If she won in pd48, she will still be outshined by her fellow members. She aint really a standout in a group, being a soloist would be better for her, but not at her current age. I dont think she would be able to handle the media alone at her age. Talent-wise she is ready but I dont think she is mentally ready for debut.
This video made me think of Kim Do Ah my 1st pick in Produce 48. I'm so happy she debuted already 💕 Hwaiting Lee Ha Eun!! She really deserves to debut. (btw I love her kick during the evaluation. That kick made me love her 😍)
Yo all 96 of them are talented, but its not possible for all 96 to debut yes? Lets all just support all of them, they all worked hard, they all deserve to debut, its not the end for the rest of the 84 girls 😊
I feel like it's a bit much saying that *all* 96 were talented
@@syne777 agree
@@syne777 *cough cough*
@@syne777 Exactly. Not gonna say names but we all know exactly who.
she gave me lee woojin(s2) vibes, very young but so talented
하은아 몇년이 걸리든 데뷔하는날까지 기다릴게~!@~@
프듀에서 데뷔하고 각자의 자리로 돌오는 연예인들 중에 청하처럼 유명해지는 사람도 몇명 없는 것 같다
Chungha was relatively unknown/less popular during her produce/ioi days, look at where she is now! Give Lee Ha Eun sometime, she'll shine through!
i feel like it wouldve been her time to shine with 100%! the fresh and innocent concept really suits her. anyway, as the amazing and talented trainee that she is, i wouldnt be shocked seeing her become a successful idol one day
so sad that she hasn't debuted yet until now
in a few years, she'll be slaying like chungha, im telling ya'll
아 하은언니 사랑해요ㅜ❣
She was definitely one of the most well rounded and talented trainees, especially for her age. Honestly much better than Minju and Hyewon who only knew how to open their eyes wide and make cute faces.