Nako has improved, but now Wonyoung said that she’s scared that her voice might be too loud, eventually Nako is starting to hate herself, Wonyoung is trying her best to cheer her up always, and people think that Wonyounf and Nako hate each other, but still we need Nako to love herself!
Miyu strained her voice in ‘We Together’ I believe. Maybe not!! But the note was hard for her to belt, so she had I think Yujin and Haeyoon help with back vocals? Not sure who else though..
Anneloes Barth alto isn’t a voice type, and miyu is most definitely NOT a contralto (triggered voice student here lol) she’s a mezzo soprano at the lowest
Nasality is not a "style" y'all lol it's literally the symbol of bad technique and placement. You can still sound cute without being nasal, look at Twice or April
It's not necessarily bad technique. I can see if they are using it WAY excessively but nasality helps getting higher notes. But it's often thought of as completely bad cuz most times its not pleasant to hear
@@soobdoob say bts jin for example. over the years he has found a way to make his nasality an advantage in singing and now he sounds way better than his debut days where his nasal voice was unpleasant to hear live
Yes, it's a style, especially in Japan.It's a choice for many of them. It's actually known as cute and if you watched the season, the couches made comments on it as a cultural difference to sing with half air or more, over a full voice. As well a nasal voice is highly valued in Korea for rapping, such as soyeon from season 1 (currently in g-idle), specifically in the Korean language, it emphasizes specific tones in the language making it easier to pick up the words. JYP also values the half air nasal voices, and has been noted a lot in for example k pop star (the competition show).
Your voice naturally gets nasally as you go higher in your range because it’s easier to sing with the sound coming from your nose in high notes compared to low ones. Many of the J trainees use falsetto instead of belting which makes them sound more nasally in higher range...
nasal voice is normal in japanese, is their accent, and the concept of them is cheerful and funny, sometimes misterious, so.... in think more than mistakes, is an style of singing, but if they wanna be korean idols, they have to do it
@@ccsbm208 Um hi I'm from japan & been here all my life... Not true... nasal isn't am accent here and we don't use it on purpose soooo.... Please correct yourself before commenting things like this
@@kikilalatwinstarz i don’t think you understand what I meant. I wasn’t talking about this from a cultural point of view but from a grammatical point of view. I wasn’t saying if Japanese people have nasally voices or not. I was saying that you can’t have a “nasal” accent since by definition an accent is all about how you pronounce words whereas as a nasally voice is about how the voice sounds to the ear and the flow of air whilst speaking. So accent isn’t the right word to use linguistically speaking. I wasn’t trying to say anything about Japanese.
I love how you said Sakura isn’t stable but she said her whole audition song completely while dancing and no backing track. She was also praised for being stable.... She does have technique I mean the moment you sing you use technique. She doesn’t have bad technique it’s just not amazing.
sitinur fatihah personally I find her voice very squeaky and borderline unbearable in some parts even though her range is very good for a Japanese trainee also her voice wins in the cuteness position:D
Depends, because being nasal is really common since it's where people (specially untrained singers) tend to place their voices when they sing, nasality can also limit a singer a lot.
you can critique their style :/ it’s their opinion that’s the whole point of the video. they’re not inherently saying “this person is terrible bc they’re nasally” is how they perceive the way that person sings
My top 1. Takeuchi Miyu 2. Yabuki Nako 3. Miyazaki Miho 4. Shiroma Miru 5. Sato Minami 6. Honda Hitomi 7. Takahashi Juri 8. El resto (no me importa el orden)
I think the problem with the Japanese contestants is that they were all from the 48 line, and they have huge amounts of members. I feel like if the trainees for Japan were pulled as individuals they would’ve had a better advantage. If you take a look at smaller idol groups such as BiSH,Watsuta, Happiness, etc. They have actually really good vocalists, rappers and even dancers. I also notice that they happen to stray away from the all members singing and actually give the members individual lines. I think they should’ve picked trainees for Japan like they did for NiziU in which they were either independent or from a company.
the cameraman who pretended Miyu didn't exist on that final performance need to get fired. why would you take random shot of the stage when the singer is hitting a highnote in grand finale of big survival show?!!!
things that do not matter: tone (subjective and unnatural to change your tone, you should sing how you want to), stability (why would the ability to sing while dancing ever matter to vocalists, it’s not like vocal coaches teach you how to sing while dancing), and pronunciation (that one is obvious), edit: also high notes don’t matter cos you can just have a naturally deeper voice, doesnt make you a worse vocalist
u j u n g a r i Sorry, I am no longer taking in requests since I have already received too many. I did make the video on my old channel(my first video), but it got too popular(500k views) so it got copyrighted. I tried to reupload last week but it got copyrighted after a couple of seconds.
Please make: Produce 48 best dancers(top 10) Produce 48 best vocalists(top 10) Produce 48 best rappers(top 10) Produce 48 best visuals(top 10) (In a ranking)
You're so biased. Sakura has basically no talent, she is bad at singing, dancing and average in terms of stage presence, her only "talent" is to have a pretty face and that's only because of her face that she is in Izone.
Miho: *sings nasal letters like "n"and "m" in the extract* Curry: she is nasal. It's all about balance, there are some nasal sounds you can't avoid... Usually when someone add to much nasality in their note they tend to be flat and unstable. Miho did have some nasal issues but it moslty happened when she had to reach high notes that she was scared of. I don't agree entirely with you but your videos are entertaining so I might subcribed. ☺
Miyu's vocals really caught my attention since her audition on PD48, and Nako's vocals since Love Whisper. Sadly Miyu got robbed. I badly wanted her to debut tho :((
@@jgmjhs_martinezyana8567 She barely sang during that performance, actually I'm not she even did. You can't really rank someone if they sang only one line.
i feel like i’m the only who doesn’t like Miyu’s voice... i was vocally trainer for only a year or so, so i know i cant say much that and i’m from America so vocal training is way different over here than in Asia, but Miyu’s voice is extremely thick that sometimes her pronunciation isn’t very well and you can’t hear which vowels or consonants she’s trying to say at times if her voice wasn’t mainly a chest voice (more so of a throat voice, where it’s in the back of your throat) then her singing would be absolutely amazing! her range is well also
im not trying to be rude, but you said most of them are nasal and squeaky. im sorry, but this is how most of the japanese industry works and even if they sing nasally, theyre amazing
Mmm just cuz it works like that doesn't means it's good?? Like what sense does that have? An idol from Japan literally stopped being one after straining her voice and almost destroying her voice for signing nasaly. Tell me now, do you think THAT'S AMAZING!
Let's be honest, Miyu shouldn't have been the lead for the final song. She couldn't hit the note at all. They had to mix in vocals of stronger singers to make the note good. Don't get me wrong, I was a Miyu supporter, but that decision made me stop. The main vocal really should have been yuri, haeyoon, miho, or chaeyeon.
If you are going to rank them based on their Korean prononciation, I hope you would (or have already ?) also rank Korean trainees based on their Japanese prononciation ....
I slightly agree with the rank only some points 1) Just because J-trainees mostly using nasal, doesn’t make K-trainees are way better. They are using throat and pitch to get higher notes even riskier than using nasal. Don’t forget Celine Dion also uses nasal. 2) I know Nako is using nasal, but she deserved higher place. She already knows her range, so she doesn’t force it when she knew she cannot do it. She has control and power, Miyu is poweful but sometimes control-less. I think with a little bit training for control she’ll be very good. 3) lots of people underestimated Sakura. She was very fine in the audience. But after judges going very harsh on her we see her confidence slowly went down. She is in fact one of the most stable from j-trainees. She’s using nasal I know, but same like Nako, she can control it and actually she is a good alto. It’s her natural way. You can hear her talking and singing voice is similar. And she started singing live in Violeta for example. I don’t hate Wonyoung, but taking her for example, her voice in talking and singing is different. Her talking voice is so mature and deep while she’s so cute and high pitch while singing. That’s why she always whispering when singing. It’s hard to make that little cute voice stable in real stage. And yet you said K-trainees were better 🙄 4) some of the trainees are not using nasal. It’s only cameras capturing it like that. If you hear their voice in detail, some of them singing naturally. 5) Please find out more about these trainees and Japan way to sing before you judge. Some of them are actually good singers or dancers already. It’s just produce making them like immature trainees again. And aside from winning, their reason to go to Produce 48 is to get some learnings. So support them ok? Thank you~
Actually, japan trainees admitted that they never received vocal training. And k trainees received vocal training and even go to art school for studying music. That's why korean trainees mostly better than japan trainees in produce 48 but i do believe some of japan idol/trainee that didn't join the program are way more skilled than some of korean trainees/idol
Am i the only one who got annoyed by the fact that she always nags about the korean pronunciation even though this ranking is about singing. You can be a good singer even if you didn’t know how to pronounce korean like??????
That's what I'm saying. They probably aren't taught how to talk in Korean in schools. Unless they teach themselves, they aren't going to know how to pronounce it.
I Wish Shitao Miu Debut She Had A Good Voice Refreshing,Calming And Sad Vocal Projection:7.5 Technique:8 Tone:9.5 Stability:8 I Love Her Plz Support Shitao Miu
You are ranking their voices or their pronunciation? Like the fuck. Also being nasal doesn't mean being a bad singer. Jessica jung has a beautiful tone and she is nasal
loona the distribution Sorry, I have already received too many video suggestions to take in more. Either way, you are very inconsiderate to suggest that many videos. I officially dislike you very much.
Although miyu is the No.1 ( I agreed with that),in the last video you said it was videotaped (yes it was videotaped), but the reason is because she can't hit that high note, so she asked help from her group and their director said anyone who can hit that high note will be recorded and put together their voices so that they can help miyu. (sorry for my grammars😁😁😁)
I think that you should have specified that you judge them based on korean criterias (nasal voice, good/bad korean pronounciation). Otherwise, they can be very good singers but you classified them low because of bad korean pronounciation and nasal voice.
![[IZ*ONE 아이즈원] 실전 압축 원영듀스 # 1](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dP_afCPSgD8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Iz*One] Produce 48 - Performances from Worst to Best](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NJRYq6epsho/mqdefault.jpg)
![АЛАУДИНОВ у Скабеевой: эти их ВСУ нас НЕ ДОГОНЯТ 😁 [Пародия]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/an0anqU4WGQ/mqdefault.jpg)
this is how many times nasal was stated in the video
👇🏻
JAMM BEAT
Lol. Let's try to reach for 11k likes!!! 😆
curry curren LMAO okay
curry curren why what’s the last person not rank able?I think she has a good voice
Becuase Nasality is common in Japanese ...which isn’t bad and shall not be
[-Rosessy•Loli-] me too
Nako has improved, but now Wonyoung said that she’s scared that her voice might be too loud, eventually Nako is starting to hate herself, Wonyoung is trying her best to cheer her up always, and people think that Wonyounf and Nako hate each other, but still we need Nako to love herself!
people misunderstand wonyoung a lot! she's a very kind person and she's only 15 wtfff
I'm sad seeing this comment. And for both Nako and Wonyoung 😭😭😭😭
Wait!! Why people think nako and wonyoung hate each other? 😭😭😭
Farrah Laila Wonyoung and Nako are friends
@@starliqhts9019 i know
I agree that miyu is the best Japanese vocalist on pd48 but I’m pretty sure she strains
Eui Woo Eui Woo it said she rarely strains
Miyu strained her voice in ‘We Together’ I believe. Maybe not!! But the note was hard for her to belt, so she had I think Yujin and Haeyoon help with back vocals? Not sure who else though..
@@artsylae9927 yujin, haeyoon and yuri helped her in the backing vocals
She strains at times because shes an alto in kpop where all the songs are high af
Anneloes Barth alto isn’t a voice type, and miyu is most definitely NOT a contralto (triggered voice student here lol) she’s a mezzo soprano at the lowest
Nasality is not a "style" y'all lol it's literally the symbol of bad technique and placement. You can still sound cute without being nasal, look at Twice or April
Coni Q finally someone with brains lol.
People saying nasal is a style lol
It's not necessarily bad technique. I can see if they are using it WAY excessively but nasality helps getting higher notes. But it's often thought of as completely bad cuz most times its not pleasant to hear
bruu nasality is not always bad, if u do it right, then it sounds really good. just say yall dont know nasality and go
@@soobdoob say bts jin for example. over the years he has found a way to make his nasality an advantage in singing and now he sounds way better than his debut days where his nasal voice was unpleasant to hear live
Yes, it's a style, especially in Japan.It's a choice for many of them. It's actually known as cute and if you watched the season, the couches made comments on it as a cultural difference to sing with half air or more, over a full voice. As well a nasal voice is highly valued in Korea for rapping, such as soyeon from season 1 (currently in g-idle), specifically in the Korean language, it emphasizes specific tones in the language making it easier to pick up the words. JYP also values the half air nasal voices, and has been noted a lot in for example k pop star (the competition show).
I will forever be salty about Miyu not being in the final lineup
same, she was robbed
SAME!!!!
Me too. T_T
Im with youuu
Dont worry guys the votes were rigged and she was in the line up her position was robbed but one day the truth will revealed.
“but her tone is too manly(?)” THE QUESTION MARK SHAHAGAHHASVEV WHY DO I FIND THIS SO FUNNY
ERII WAS A SOLID 16 SORRY
Your voice naturally gets nasally as you go higher in your range because it’s easier to sing with the sound coming from your nose in high notes compared to low ones. Many of the J trainees use falsetto instead of belting which makes them sound more nasally in higher range...
mikaela guintu i don’t agree but it’s your opinion but i never use a nasal voice when i sing
anaïs mrn you naturally use your nose when singing in your head voice for higher parts lmao
jungoo juice i never notice it but maybe so sorry
...but why can't I hear it when korean trainees sing?
@@fushicore To me, the Koreans don't sound nasally is all I'm saying.
nasal voice is normal in japanese, is their accent, and the concept of them is cheerful and funny, sometimes misterious, so.... in think more than mistakes, is an style of singing, but if they wanna be korean idols, they have to do it
Nicki HerediaR nasal isn’t an accent
ok. it still doesn’t justify it or make them better
@@ccsbm208 Um hi I'm from japan & been here all my life... Not true... nasal isn't am accent here and we don't use it on purpose soooo.... Please correct yourself before commenting things like this
@@kikilalatwinstarz i don’t think you understand what I meant. I wasn’t talking about this from a cultural point of view but from a grammatical point of view. I wasn’t saying if Japanese people have nasally voices or not. I was saying that you can’t have a “nasal” accent since by definition an accent is all about how you pronounce words whereas as a nasally voice is about how the voice sounds to the ear and the flow of air whilst speaking. So accent isn’t the right word to use linguistically speaking. I wasn’t trying to say anything about Japanese.
@@its_ed but that wouldn’t be called an accent it’s the wrong choice of words
She is so nasal but tbh I loved Vivian in ddu du ddu du
Only us intellectuals appreciate the one and only Vivian! 🔥❤
Omg yes yes yes🔥🔥
Yesss
Same
Acctually it is:
1. Miyu
2. Juri (You can see in rocket punch that her vocals are not joke)
3. Miho
4. Nako
wait she's in rocket punch now? holy frik i missed a lot of stuff
BRUH I CAN BARELY EVEN RECOGNIZE HER
even suyun is in rocket punch i-
edit: and sohee? holy heck
@@tadokoropilled yes hahhahahaha
IZ*ONE você é BR?
miyu is a legend
@2d_simp8 she was my pick, I'm still salty
For me,Miyazaki Miho deserve to be in the top 3.Because her voice is high ranged and always stable.
ちよりは最後の最後で急成長したイメージ
先生の助言ですぐ出来るようになったのは先生もすごいけど本人の潜在的な能力も結構あると思う。
Juri was one of the most talented Japanese trainees and deserved a spot in the top 12. I’m happy that she was able to make her debut in Rocket Punch
I love how you said Sakura isn’t stable but she said her whole audition song completely while dancing and no backing track. She was also praised for being stable.... She does have technique I mean the moment you sing you use technique. She doesn’t have bad technique it’s just not amazing.
Miyu is amazing, I wished she was in izone, but it’s okay because I love their final lineup
If i was Sakura and i can choose 2 person to join Izone , i will able to choose Chaeyeon and Miyu
I'm not sure about Hitomi having "no nasalness", she's more nasal than Nako, Sakura and Juri. She is a good vocalist though and a great dancer.
But she's squeaky lol.
Silver Di Angelo I think that’s her natural voice that’s why it doesn’t count as nasal
*more nasally
CCS BM actually i think it is more nasal
seungwendy it should be an adjective
個人的に高橋朱里もっと上だと思うなー
大丈夫皆思ってるw
I think Minami deserves to be on the top 10, I like Chiyori’s voice because she sounds like a korean and it’s nice
1. Miyu
2. Miho
3. Nako
4. Chiyori
5. Jurina
6. Juri
7. Miru
8. Hitomi
Miho is not better than nako her voice are not stable at all
sitinur fatihah personally I find her voice very squeaky and borderline unbearable in some parts even though her range is very good for a Japanese trainee also her voice wins in the cuteness position:D
Nasal is not a reason. Singing nasal is a style and you can't critisize them because of their style.
I think nasal is a thing that hides the trainees' vocal potential. I think that's why OP is pointing it out.
@@ambientamben5059 Oh yeah.
Depends, because being nasal is really common since it's where people (specially untrained singers) tend to place their voices when they sing, nasality can also limit a singer a lot.
you can critique their style :/ it’s their opinion that’s the whole point of the video. they’re not inherently saying “this person is terrible bc they’re nasally” is how they perceive the way that person sings
clear stan it’s a style that isn’t working with the song- you should fit the song to the right style
びびあんもっと上でもいいとおもいま！！
My top
1. Takeuchi Miyu
2. Yabuki Nako
3. Miyazaki Miho
4. Shiroma Miru
5. Sato Minami
6. Honda Hitomi
7. Takahashi Juri
8. El resto (no me importa el orden)
Same
No hay forma de q Hitomi cante mejor que Juri :v
Yo pienso que Juri tiene mejor rango que Hiichan
Me:
No one:
Not even a single soul
Curry Curren: *Says Nasal a million times in the video*
岩立は無いwww
cy jj
ほんとにそれ 最下位でもいいぐらいだよね
ほんまにひどかった
そうですよね、同じ見解の方がいて良かったです。
The Truth Un Told の時は彼女だけテイスト違いましたしね、、
ひーちゃんやじゅりより上でびびったwwww
朱里より上は素人目にも変だわ。ひぃちゃんは好み分かれる声だから分からん。
I think the problem with the Japanese contestants is that they were all from the 48 line, and they have huge amounts of members. I feel like if the trainees for Japan were pulled as individuals they would’ve had a better advantage. If you take a look at smaller idol groups such as BiSH,Watsuta, Happiness, etc. They have actually really good vocalists, rappers and even dancers. I also notice that they happen to stray away from the all members singing and actually give the members individual lines. I think they should’ve picked trainees for Japan like they did for NiziU in which they were either independent or from a company.
Exactly!! Laso they didn't take their all of their most talented/famous members to pd48!
the cameraman who pretended Miyu didn't exist on that final performance need to get fired.
why would you take random shot of the stage when the singer is hitting a highnote in grand finale of big survival show?!!!
things that do not matter: tone (subjective and unnatural to change your tone, you should sing how you want to), stability (why would the ability to sing while dancing ever matter to vocalists, it’s not like vocal coaches teach you how to sing while dancing), and pronunciation (that one is obvious),
edit: also high notes don’t matter cos you can just have a naturally deeper voice, doesnt make you a worse vocalist
1. Takeuchi Miyu
2. Miyazaki Miho
3. Takahashi Juri
4. Yabuki Nako
5. Matsui Jurina
日本人おるーー？？
おるよ。
鶴房の宇宙人 鶴房好き
Since when having a "manly" voice is something bad poor Erii (and me lol I feel attacked 🗿✊)
I love these Top 3💖 Miru, Nako, and Miyu they deserve this top 3 ranking💖
can you pls do a izone vocal ranking? i will aprecciate it♡
u j u n g a r i
Sorry, I am no longer taking in requests since I have already received too many. I did make the video on my old channel(my first video), but it got too popular(500k views) so it got copyrighted. I tried to reupload last week but it got copyrighted after a couple of seconds.
@@currycurrenkpop is ok,thank u anyways!♡
@Elegance wtf? She is obviously in Iz*one. And Curry Curren being an intellectual complemented her lower register.
@Elegance I Don't Think She's That Bad Lmao.I Would Still Rank Her At 90 Though
竹内美宥ちゃんと宮崎美穂ちゃんと浅井七海ちゃんが好き
Definitely agreed, miyu deserve to debut, but hitomi skills deserve to in the top 3
If y’all have seen UHSN, Erii has improved in every aspect.
Miho and Miru are simply perfects in their singing.
Please make:
Produce 48 best dancers(top 10)
Produce 48 best vocalists(top 10)
Produce 48 best rappers(top 10)
Produce 48 best visuals(top 10)
(In a ranking)
Animaisinhos fofos
Invalid format
奈子は歌が上手いというよりもとの声が高いから高音が出しやすいっていうだけの気がするけどな…。
指原が嫌がるなこにボイトレさせてたらしいけど
元の声が高くても、声量がなければかなり厳しいんですよね…
大輝はん 声量ある＝歌が上手いじゃないけどね。なこは歌が上手い訳じゃなくて音域と声量だと思うな。技術はまだまだ。
まぁ、うまくはないよね。
なこちゃんもひとみちゃんもさくらちゃんもw
でも元の声が素敵なのも歌がうまいに含まれると思うけどなぁ
Chiyori is good, in the practice of Rollin rolling she did so good
leo santander
IN MY OPINION
3. Chiyori
2. Juri
1. Miyu
Miyu in The Truth Untold was amazing, I thought she was a Korean trainee omggg
My top 10:
1.Miyu
2.Miho
3.Nako
4.Rena
5.Miru
6.Hitomi
7.Chiyori
8.Asai Nanami
9.Juri
10.Aoi
hg
I love Nako voice so much she is one of my favorite in izone
My Top 12 Japanese Trainee
1. Sakura
2. Nako
3. Hitomi
4. Murase Sae
5. Miru
6. Juri
7. Miu
8. Moe
9. Eri
10. Minami
11. Nanami
12. Jurina
Sú 4D top 3 is in order that they debuted
You're so biased. Sakura has basically no talent, she is bad at singing, dancing and average in terms of stage presence, her only "talent" is to have a pretty face and that's only because of her face that she is in Izone.
@@insanity2171 yes
I am WIZ*ONE but i bias Eunbi
I like Sakura than Nako and Hitomi in IZ*ONE and in PD48 i really like her
I don't care Sakura talent
@@insanity2171 sakura have a lot of stage presence
Chiyori deserved better screentime? She seems to have the best vocals out of them all!
Miho: *sings nasal letters like "n"and "m" in the extract*
Curry: she is nasal.
It's all about balance, there are some nasal sounds you can't avoid... Usually when someone add to much nasality in their note they tend to be flat and unstable. Miho did have some nasal issues but it moslty happened when she had to reach high notes that she was scared of.
I don't agree entirely with you but your videos are entertaining so I might subcribed. ☺
i really love miho's voice.
Miyu's vocals really caught my attention since her audition on PD48, and Nako's vocals since Love Whisper. Sadly Miyu got robbed. I badly wanted her to debut tho :((
I don’t really understand how the pronunciation of Korean words that they had to learn for the first time matters in vocals?
And that’s on period.👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Miyu Trained For 10 Years ;-; I Love Her 😭💗
Me:
No one:
Not even a single soul:
Shinozaki Ayanae: *Not rankable*
Ikr I wheezed at that part lmaoooo 💀
@@Xgennn57 I don't get why it says not rankable
@@jgmjhs_martinezyana8567 She barely sang during that performance, actually I'm not she even did. You can't really rank someone if they sang only one line.
I honestly really like the voice of Aoi ! I'm really sad because she not show her full talent
miyu: sings her heart out during the finale
mnet: camera on the damn stage
Clearly they didn't want her in the final.
Nako will always be my favorite!
BTW, I realized how much I really prefer Japanese visuals.
i feel like i’m the only who doesn’t like Miyu’s voice...
i was vocally trainer for only a year or so, so i know i cant say much
that and i’m from America so vocal training is way different over here than in Asia, but Miyu’s voice is extremely thick that sometimes her pronunciation isn’t very well and you can’t hear which vowels or consonants she’s trying to say at times
if her voice wasn’t mainly a chest voice (more so of a throat voice, where it’s in the back of your throat) then her singing would be absolutely amazing! her range is well also
im not trying to be rude, but you said most of them are nasal and squeaky. im sorry, but this is how most of the japanese industry works and even if they sing nasally, theyre amazing
Mmm just cuz it works like that doesn't means it's good?? Like what sense does that have? An idol from Japan literally stopped being one after straining her voice and almost destroying her voice for signing nasaly. Tell me now, do you think THAT'S AMAZING!
ひぃちゃんもっと上だら！
Don‘t forget that AKB girls never had vocal training
why does that matter lmao the ranking still stands
How is a voice being manly a bad thing? Altos found crying when our parts usually are the hardest
みほみゆ奈子の3人がトップが正しい
ゆんち この三人は声が天才！
その三人最強
THANK YOU FOR ADDING QUEEN BABY JURINA IN
Let's be honest, Miyu shouldn't have been the lead for the final song. She couldn't hit the note at all. They had to mix in vocals of stronger singers to make the note good. Don't get me wrong, I was a Miyu supporter, but that decision made me stop. The main vocal really should have been yuri, haeyoon, miho, or chaeyeon.
@Golden Sone May he rest in peace..
Miyu is a legend ;;; but i dont get it whats the problem with Eriis voice, i really like it
If you are going to rank them based on their Korean prononciation, I hope you would (or have already ?) also rank Korean trainees based on their Japanese prononciation ....
Here are my favorite underrated vocals among Japanese trainees:
• Muto Tomu
• Iwatate Saho
• Mogi Shinobu
• Oda Erina
• Nakano Ikumi
• Nakanishi Chiyori
• Takeuchi Miyu
• Miyazaki Miho
• Murakawa Bibian
• Aramaki Misaki
• Sato Minami
• Kurihara Sae
• Asai Yuka
• Asai Nanami
• Goto Moe
So basically most of them.
noe is a horrible person but yes iwatate saho, sato minami, aramiki Misaki and Asai Nanami are great vocalists
7:40 is really wtf...
I slightly agree with the rank only some points
1) Just because J-trainees mostly using nasal, doesn’t make K-trainees are way better. They are using throat and pitch to get higher notes even riskier than using nasal. Don’t forget Celine Dion also uses nasal.
2) I know Nako is using nasal, but she deserved higher place. She already knows her range, so she doesn’t force it when she knew she cannot do it. She has control and power, Miyu is poweful but sometimes control-less. I think with a little bit training for control she’ll be very good.
3) lots of people underestimated Sakura. She was very fine in the audience. But after judges going very harsh on her we see her confidence slowly went down. She is in fact one of the most stable from j-trainees. She’s using nasal I know, but same like Nako, she can control it and actually she is a good alto. It’s her natural way. You can hear her talking and singing voice is similar. And she started singing live in Violeta for example. I don’t hate Wonyoung, but taking her for example, her voice in talking and singing is different. Her talking voice is so mature and deep while she’s so cute and high pitch while singing. That’s why she always whispering when singing. It’s hard to make that little cute voice stable in real stage. And yet you said K-trainees were better 🙄
4) some of the trainees are not using nasal. It’s only cameras capturing it like that. If you hear their voice in detail, some of them singing naturally.
5) Please find out more about these trainees and Japan way to sing before you judge. Some of them are actually good singers or dancers already. It’s just produce making them like immature trainees again. And aside from winning, their reason to go to Produce 48 is to get some learnings. So support them ok?
Thank you~
Actually, japan trainees admitted that they never received vocal training. And k trainees received vocal training and even go to art school for studying music. That's why korean trainees mostly better than japan trainees in produce 48 but i do believe some of japan idol/trainee that didn't join the program are way more skilled than some of korean trainees/idol
@@fudanshiakut5114 just see another 48G member that already has solo debut, like takamina/wasamin/yukirin/etc
ちよりもっと上でもいい気がする😃
they're in akb48 so they're required to sing in more cute way just say r ranking them by voice
Am i the only one who got annoyed by the fact that she always nags about the korean pronunciation even though this ranking is about singing. You can be a good singer even if you didn’t know how to pronounce korean like??????
That's what I'm saying. They probably aren't taught how to talk in Korean in schools. Unless they teach themselves, they aren't going to know how to pronounce it.
“miru is an exceptional singer for a japanese trainee” what do you mean with this???
I also want to know
Having a nasal singing voice doesn’t equal having a bad singing voice. I wish people would realize this.
excuse me?? you called erii manly?? just because of a low registered voice?
I Wish Shitao Miu Debut She Had A Good Voice Refreshing,Calming And Sad
Vocal Projection:7.5
Technique:8
Tone:9.5
Stability:8
I Love Her Plz Support Shitao Miu
You are ranking their voices or their pronunciation? Like the fuck. Also being nasal doesn't mean being a bad singer. Jessica jung has a beautiful tone and she is nasal
日本のAKB系統のグループは基本口パクだから歌唱力がない人がほとんだと思ってたけど結構上手い人もいたのが驚いた。その中でしっかり実力つけて受かったのが矢吹奈子。
みゆの声個性的すぎて無理
わかる
珍しいな
The top five are so good!
じゅり下過ぎん？
To some people, being nasal doesn't mean that they sound bad, it just doesn't sound too pleasant at some times when they're nasal.
Of course. No wonder. Its Miyu 😍
Ggs:
loona visual ranking (korean standars)
clc visual ranking (korean standars)
(g)i-dle vocal ranking
If you Stan bgs:
Stray Kids vocal and visual ranking
Sorry por my bad English
loona the distribution
Sorry, I have already received too many video suggestions to take in more. Either way, you are very inconsiderate to suggest that many videos. I officially dislike you very much.
curry curren LMAOOO THAT WAS SO SAVAGE I LOVE IT GOOO CURRY CURRENNNN
curry curren SAVAGE! YASSS SLAY they so immature to command you to do 5 videos. Hope ur not pressured :)
Azusa, Cocona, Amane, and Miku are glaring from the Eliminated graves.
miyu was truly undisputed
Miyu's high note cutting to a wall is her screen time in a nutshell on produce48
Miyu's voice is beautiful
It honestly feels like some of these trainees didn’t want to be there either which probably didn’t help
Yes the real main vocalist in japanese trainees is miyu because her voice is so powerful
Sorry but miyu's highnote was supported by other trainees.She could not handle it well but she didn't give the main vocal position to others.(Neutral)
So what's wrong with that? It's not doubling but just harmonization. Miyu still sing the higher note
Wth vivian literally sang rose's lines so good
miho가 앨범을 내준다면 ㅠㅠ 말하지못한진심은 최고였다...미유도 최고이긴하지만 미유는 이제는 한국 노래를 불러주니 갈증이 해소되는데 미호는 언제 다시 불러줄려나 ㅜㅜ
Although miyu is the No.1
( I agreed with that),in the last video you said it was videotaped (yes it was videotaped), but the reason is because she can't hit that high note, so she asked help from her group and their director said anyone who can hit that high note will be recorded and put together their voices so that they can help miyu.
(sorry for my grammars😁😁😁)
Miyu♡ vocal queen ♡
Miyu deserves better :-( ♡
I agree no 1 miyu she deserved that
I think that you should have specified that you judge them based on korean criterias (nasal voice, good/bad korean pronounciation). Otherwise, they can be very good singers but you classified them low because of bad korean pronounciation and nasal voice.
omd sounding nasal does not make you a bad singer. it is a style of singing and how to train your voice
Being nasal isn’t a style. It’s like the definition of bad technique and wrong placement ...
じゅりちゃんもっと上だと個人的に思います
みるたんかわいすぎ
RENA WAS SOOOOOOO UNDERRATED! SHE COULDVE MADE IT ALLLLL THE WAY TO BE HONEST! SO MUCH POTENTIAL