Dying Inside by Robert Silverberg: His Best Novel? [NO SPOILER REVIEW]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 40

  • @Flux799
    @Flux799 Рік тому +4

    The World Inside is my favourite sci-fi book of all time. I bought the book club edition hardcover at an antique shop many many years ago. Truly underrated!

    • @tokenblack7983
      @tokenblack7983 Рік тому

      Just previewed the plot of the World Inside…sounds amazing

    • @freedone.
      @freedone. 9 місяців тому

      The concert with the musician - transcendent!

  • @chrisw6164
    @chrisw6164 3 роки тому +5

    Silverberg is a boss, I only discovered him in the last couple of years, so now I have dozens of books to read.

  • @williamjackson6705
    @williamjackson6705 2 роки тому +1

    I read this about 40 years ago. My copy had the Murray Tinkleman cover. Loved it.Great review.

  • @obscuracrimepodcast
    @obscuracrimepodcast Рік тому +1

    I finished this tonight. It reminds me of Philip Roth. I can’t say I enjoyed the book in the classic sense. Half way through I grew tired of David. But I do respect the book. Can’t say I’ll read it again. Though I’m glad I did.
    Edit: Just saw that you brought up Roth in your review!

  • @Yergs
    @Yergs 2 роки тому +1

    Just came across your channel. Enjoying your reviews.

  • @christinewheelwright8096
    @christinewheelwright8096 2 роки тому +1

    I read it as a teenager and was very impressed. Now, in my 50s, I think it would be an interesting experiment to read it again. Just picked up a dusty copy from a second hand bookstore.

  • @sethball2475
    @sethball2475 2 роки тому +2

    My fave Silverberg is Up the Line, and then Dying Inside. Got my Up the Line signed, at TorCon 2003.
    Two Envelopes and a Phone, at GoodReads

  • @Andrew-lw3yo
    @Andrew-lw3yo 3 роки тому +2

    The bookcase is a win along with the plant. Maybe a legit plastic plant addition is in the works to showcase your depth of character? Good no spoiler review. I like the thumbnail book cover, and the living switch is a good hook.

  • @JackMyersPhotography
    @JackMyersPhotography 2 роки тому

    I’m on “Book of Skulls” and plan to read “Dying Inside” next. Thanks for the good review.

  • @MediaDeathCult
    @MediaDeathCult 3 роки тому +4

    This is on my next TBR

    • @MediaDeathCult
      @MediaDeathCult 3 роки тому +2

      Sorry, that didn’t make much sense, i make a new list of 10 books i want to read apart from the read alongs and chip away at that list, then i make a new one.
      That didn’t make much sense either

    • @Bookpilled
      @Bookpilled  3 роки тому +4

      I think you'll click with Silverberg. His other books are more hardcore SF. Huge scale, ideas-driven plots with smart prose. Looking forward to your review.

    • @MediaDeathCult
      @MediaDeathCult 3 роки тому +2

      @@Bookpilled I’m trying to cross off some “list of shame “ authors

    • @Bookpilled
      @Bookpilled  3 роки тому +1

      @@MediaDeathCult Your list is probably shorter than mine.

  • @kackljas
    @kackljas 2 роки тому

    I had my first introduction to Robert Silverberg today eith his novella "How It Was When The Past Went Away", a highlight of the "Mammoth Book of New World Science Fiction (Short Novels of The 1960s)" compilation. It was a great story, reminiscent of something Phillip K Dick could have written. It's a story about a terrorist attack on the San Francisco water supply with a memory erasing drug. It's a wild trip, and an unofficial advertisement for mountain spring water as well. Liquid Death could make a movie out of it to boost sales. I plan on reading more Silverberg in the near future.

  • @jay75.61
    @jay75.61 2 роки тому

    Just found your channel. This book sounds great! I'm gonna pick it up. Thanks. Subbed...

  • @learnaseyelearn166
    @learnaseyelearn166 2 роки тому

    I'm trying to join the bookcase backdrop club as well bro lol 😆

  • @joseelacasse3189
    @joseelacasse3189 Рік тому

    Watch out for that bookcase backdrop club! I'm writing this a year later and, sadly, the case no longer shows up

  • @garnetnewton-wade4091
    @garnetnewton-wade4091 Рік тому

    Bloody incredible book and read it about 40 years ogo but still stays with me.

  • @thecryptile
    @thecryptile 3 роки тому +3

    Have you read "The Book of Skulls" yet? For my money, it is Silverberg's best.

    • @Bookpilled
      @Bookpilled  3 роки тому

      No, never even heard of it

    • @JackMyersPhotography
      @JackMyersPhotography 2 роки тому

      Just started it yesterday. I think it’s being made into a movie.

    • @chriswright9096
      @chriswright9096 2 роки тому

      @@JackMyersPhotography I can't find any reference to a movie coming out. It is an interesting idea though. Masters like Silverberg produced so many fascinating stories that could benefit from a big-screen treatment. But I guess it is easier for studios to churn out superhero movies with a guaranteed profit to be reaped from an undiscerning public. Oh, and regarding Dying Inside; it is a masterpiece of creative writing.

    • @MoeOuan666
      @MoeOuan666 2 роки тому

      Agreed. Maybe not his best, but i put it together with dying inside as his 2 tops. BoS is I think especially nice to read for teenager or young adult males. I read it at this time, and gave it to a friend not really into reading nor SF... This one he read in one go though, and still mention it to me 30y later...

    • @MoeOuan666
      @MoeOuan666 2 роки тому +1

      Also: Book of skull is only borderline SF/Fantasy... It's by by Silverberg and gave me similar vibe as dying inside (which you already mention being quite mundane apart from telepathy), but Book of Skulls could be in the psychological thriller/coming of age/sect warning book section, at least as much as the sf section...

  • @thekeywitness
    @thekeywitness 2 роки тому

    I’m presently reading Dying Inside and finding it very funny. I didn’t expect to laugh so much.

  • @zdog34whatnow
    @zdog34whatnow 3 роки тому +1

    New setup looks good. Shamefully, I have 4 or 5 Silverbergs in my library and I haven’t read a single one of them, despite all the praise he gets. Great review!
    Ever thought about letter grades or number grades for reviews?

    • @Bookpilled
      @Bookpilled  3 роки тому +2

      Thanks. Yeah, I used to do an "out of ten" system but I think it's [lit major voice] too reductive.

  • @JamesTheWise_
    @JamesTheWise_ Рік тому +1

    A very depressing book with probably THE most unlikeable protagonist ever. I found the protagonist to be (outside of his love interest) pretty misogynistic. An interesting read though.
    I plan on reading Silverberg’s The Stochastic Man, that seems very interesting.

  • @Godovgrind
    @Godovgrind 2 роки тому

    If you not read it, The Dying Animal by Philip Roth I recommend.

  • @B0BsBooks
    @B0BsBooks 3 роки тому

    Bookcase backdrop club welcomes you.

  • @paznewis107
    @paznewis107 2 роки тому

    I did RS for my o level English 'show n tell' n what's the point of a library of books that you have read? 😁👍🙏

  • @StephaniaDonayre
    @StephaniaDonayre 2 роки тому

    Any recommendation based on this? One of my favourite novels of all time.

  • @jasonschubel1783
    @jasonschubel1783 2 роки тому

    So good : )

  • @musashi-san____1409
    @musashi-san____1409 Рік тому

    Of course you were going to have a Black angry man. This was during the Civil Rights, and Black Panthers era. Duh! How the hell is that not accurate with the time period?

    • @neighborhoodmusicsnob5517
      @neighborhoodmusicsnob5517 9 місяців тому

      The fact that that whole scene is cartoonish. The whole POV Silverberg chooses is such a cringy white liberal perspective.

  • @tectorgorch8698
    @tectorgorch8698 3 роки тому

    Okay, off to Book Alley now.

  • @chrisperry8220
    @chrisperry8220 2 роки тому +1

    The saddest book ive read.