Why I don't like the HK P30SK

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 97

  • @MiscGunnery
    @MiscGunnery 5 місяців тому +20

    Weird, I actually like mine. DA pull might weigh heavy on the scale, but there's no stacking so very smooth and accurate in my hands.
    Definitely not slim, but works for me.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  5 місяців тому +1

      I would agree the lack of stacking makes it over to me than most of the cz triggers

  • @HotelTwoFive-Sev
    @HotelTwoFive-Sev 5 місяців тому +50

    Lol...the P30SKS may be the BEST CCW pistol available straight outta the box. There's absolutely NOTHING wrong with the trigger on any HK I own. Either you're spoiled on aftermarket super light-pull triggers or there's something wrong with your trigger finger bud.

    • @992turbos
      @992turbos 3 місяці тому +2

      💯

    • @MooseKnuckleMike
      @MooseKnuckleMike 2 місяці тому +1

      Right. I have a p30 sks v3. I got one 2 years ago and been edc, its out for an optics cut at Langdon Tactical. Loved the p30 sk so much I bought a p30L and planning on buying 2 more p30 sks’s before politics get weird and cant import or quality / model redesign come.

  • @thundertmf
    @thundertmf 3 місяці тому +8

    on a quiet concealed carry DA / SA night you can hear a striker fire negligent discharge

  • @lunchandlearn
    @lunchandlearn 5 місяців тому +13

    The P30sk LEM is the best overall CCW I’ve found for myself. Very concealable, very low recoil, extremely high quality, reliable, safe trigger for CCW. I’ve tried G26, P365, P365X and XMacro, Hellcat, etc.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  5 місяців тому

      I feel like the regular p30 conceals as well for me so i didn’t think the sk was worth it

    • @lunchandlearn
      @lunchandlearn 5 місяців тому

      @@randyreviewsit that’s great. P30 is next on my list.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  5 місяців тому

      @@lunchandlearn yeah I have two one lem and one da/sa the lem one is getting sent to Langdon as soon as my p30l is back

    • @lunchandlearn
      @lunchandlearn 5 місяців тому +1

      @@randyreviewsit nice. I own 2 p30sks but want a p30 lem and p30l lem as well. Only thing that’s a bit frustrating is the lack of holster support.

    • @huey7437
      @huey7437 4 місяці тому +1

      @@lunchandlearni carry my p30sk lem with TLR-7a in a Ares AIWB holster from Legacy Firearms Co.
      Carry the sk daily for year and half with zero issues

  • @Alex1Tremo
    @Alex1Tremo 4 місяці тому +19

    I love the p30sk

  • @ResplendentRaider
    @ResplendentRaider 3 місяці тому +8

    Lmao this dude said the hellcat pro was better? I stopped the video after that. That snappy lil SOB is no where near better than the P30sk.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  3 місяці тому

      I had two other people shoot them back to back to see if I was missing something

  • @logstuff1
    @logstuff1 11 днів тому +1

    I have one. I couldn't shoot with it all that well when i first picked it up. I am used to the trigger now and shoot it really well. I love the sights. I was shooting softball +-sized rocks with it on a hillside at around 80-100 yards with several other guns along side of p 30sk. I hit more rocks and closer than my other full size pistols. I really love it and am confident with it. Just need to learn that trigger.

  • @carlopriori6649
    @carlopriori6649 Місяць тому +2

    Love my P30SK it fits my frame perfectly. I alternate with my LTT PX4 compact carry. It may not be for everyone, but I really like it a lot.

  • @992turbos
    @992turbos 3 місяці тому +2

    This always fascinates me. The DA pull is safer for CC. Plus the version with the manual safety you can carry SA, cocked and locked like a 1911. No heavy pull. But do you honestly think you’ll have a hard time pulling a trigger with a heavy weight in a moment of high adrenaline?

    • @wehrewulf
      @wehrewulf Місяць тому +2

      He is a range Fudd, not a tactical shooter.

  • @theguyinmaine
    @theguyinmaine 21 день тому +1

    Had the p30L, lem, loved it, had the SKv3 like that one and double tap no problem. Didn't like the decocker. Have two SKV1 lem, excellent. Conceal iwb with 13+1 no problem. Full 3 finger grip. Does 1/8" make a huge difference in width? I don't think so. Grip length, lights and dots make conceal miserable. Isn't the dot as wide as the pistol?

    • @theguyinmaine
      @theguyinmaine 3 дні тому

      Now carry the new 15+1 mag, same size as the older 13+1. They have a new 17+1 that is the same length as the old 15 rnd. Love the SK LEM, no need for a micro.

  • @adkodor
    @adkodor 4 місяці тому +5

    Own a 43X...took them both to the range after the first two magazines I knew which one I wanted to carry… I went through five more boxes of ammo just to make sure… It's not even a comparison… But you should not compare it against the 43x or a p365. It's a much fuller gun much easier to shoot and place rounds on target… Which is why it's my choice… To me it compares more closely to a Glock 19 but a shorter barrel so it doesn't hit my junk when I'm carrying appendix, with an LEM trigger you have a consistent trigger of a striker fired gun with a longer uptake Which to me is a safety feature and a bobbed Hammer to thumb when reholstering...Another safety feature ergonomically much more pleasant to hold easier to control and works like a fine piece of machinery I guess you have to decide whether you're willing to drive a Dodge charger or a Mercedes I get it it's a huge price price difference with cars and both get you to your job but with a PDW I'm willing to spend an extra couple hundred to have something that works like a Swiss clock. Guys are carrying 2011s and Glock 17s… If this is too thick for you stick a Ruger LPC in your pocket that's not a joke either… That's what I do when I don't have room for a full-size pistol
    Tell you what… Like it so much I just bought a P30L also with an LEM as my bedside gun. Will be sending it to Landon for a full slide mill and trigger job… Next is a threaded barrel for a can and… I like it so much it's replacing my FN FNX

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  4 місяці тому

      I just think the p30sk isn’t small enough that choosing it over a regular p30 makes any sense.

    • @RayDoyouagree
      @RayDoyouagree 21 день тому

      I agree much more comfortable to carry the P 30 SK appendix

  • @RayDoyouagree
    @RayDoyouagree 21 день тому

    Even with ambi safeties, it is very comfortable to carry especially when sitting in a car.
    Decocker and DA/SA
    Trigger action is NOT 14 lbs DA and 6 lbs
    What type gauge did you misread????

  • @zulusmith
    @zulusmith 3 місяці тому +3

    I agree with you about the trigger, as there are way better triggers out there. For reference, I currently own the P30SKs and L in the V3 model and previously owned the 3.9 inch version.
    I purchased the Grey Gun flat trigger and trigger reset for both guns and the difference is substantial. I love shooting my guns now and recommend the modification to everyone.

    • @JadedGLORY2689
      @JadedGLORY2689 2 місяці тому

      Did you install it yourself?

    • @zulusmith
      @zulusmith 2 місяці тому

      ​@JadedGLORY2689 I did not. Took them to my gunsmith. I can't remember what he charged, but it was less than $50 each. Was totally worth it.

    • @JadedGLORY2689
      @JadedGLORY2689 2 місяці тому +1

      @jayjuggrnaut Yeah I've heard alotta great things about it as well. I definitely don't mind spending money on it since the P30SK V3 is my favorite carry. I just wanted to try and smoothen up those trigger pulls. Thanks for the info boss.

    • @zulusmith
      @zulusmith 2 місяці тому +2

      @JadedGLORY2689 I'll give one more data point and then I'll shut up so you don't think I'm a shill. I didn't purchase the kit for both guns at the same time as I didn't know if it would be worth it. I wanted to get some rounds down range before spending more bucks. I purchased one and dropped it off with my gunsmith.
      When I went to pick it up, another employee at the gun range said, "oh, that was your gun? Josh (the gunsmith) let me shoot it cause I also have a P30. After shooting yours, I ordered the kit for my gun also!"
      Good luck!

  • @lilHeifetz
    @lilHeifetz Місяць тому +1

    Why send it off to Langdon when you can do it yourself? As someone who not only has a Langdon worked gun (px4 compact carry) but has run his courses as well, there's a lot to be said for simply breaking a gun in and then and only then deciding that you want to work the trigger yourself to your own liking. It's what I've done to my hk45c (match trigger kit, polished springs, lighter weight springs as well) but what I'll end up doing to the p30sk. I just believe in putting at minimum a few thousand rounds down range to see how it settles first. Usually that greatly helps, then any further modification is to get it exactly where I want.

  • @BERSERKERNA39
    @BERSERKERNA39 2 місяці тому +3

    The recoil is due to that stupid red dot. The added weight isn't helping.
    I bet the spring is shot.

  • @jakk9278
    @jakk9278 Місяць тому

    who did your slide milling

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  Місяць тому

      I bought it used with the cut, so not sure

  • @rt19187
    @rt19187 29 днів тому

    Hey man! Not joking at all, and I doubt you still have it, but if I gave you my info, can I buy that from you?

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  29 днів тому +1

      It’s been passed on lol

    • @rt19187
      @rt19187 29 днів тому +1

      @ 10-4 brother thank you for the reply:)

  • @rudrashakti108
    @rudrashakti108 5 місяців тому +14

    Sorry but you know nothing about what guns are for. No doubt you think HK’s engineers didn’t know what they were doing.
    In real life, with this gun, you can pull the gun out of the holster with your finger already on the trigger. It won’t go off. After shooting the first bad guy, you can decock the hammer while scanning for the second bad guy while there are other innocents around. Or in this case don’t decock it, your finger can still safely stay on the trigger and it still won’t shoot by accident. (Well ok maybe just decock it). That’s why the HK lem and Sig dak were created. Federal agencies were demanding safer combat triggers like the German police. And quite frankly all American police guns should be like those. But whatever I’m not in charge of this universe.
    With a stupid striker fired gun, you pretty much need to keep your finger on the slide and then slam it onto the trigger when you’ve decided you actually need to shoot.
    Oh and how many times are police giving themselves glockleg?
    The German police (and European police in general) want safe triggers that still get the job done.
    Now, as a range toy, fine, get a stupid striker trigger.
    I have a ton of dasa guns, one 1911, and a p365xl as a recent addition. However I’m seriously eyeballing a p30sk literally for the very reason you don’t like it.
    Oh and as an aside, a local store is selling a no longer made Sig p239, single stack dasa. Choices choices.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  5 місяців тому

      Then why do they make a p30sk with the lem? I don’t think you understand things

    • @star9732
      @star9732 Місяць тому

      So the 96% of civilians and agencies buying striker fired guns with light triggers are all wrong? Sure buddy

  • @stevenbailey968
    @stevenbailey968 3 місяці тому

    Out of curiosity. Would the attachable compensater fit on the sk?

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  3 місяці тому

      I don’t have the comp anymore but via memory I would say no. There would be a decent gap between the barrel and the comp.

  • @ericfuller2604
    @ericfuller2604 2 дні тому

    I have 2P 30 SK LEM variants and they are excellent. I like a thicker grip because it distributes the recoil over a wider area in the web of my hand. I would take the HK over a hellcat any day. I even bought a P 2000 SK with an LEM trigger because it was so cheap.

  • @mkbmkb5102
    @mkbmkb5102 4 місяці тому +9

    My P30SK ROCKS.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  4 місяці тому

      I saw another one at my lgs today next to the one I am selling. Someone else brought theirs in too.

  • @762x69
    @762x69 6 місяців тому +3

    Not "Size Queens". I'm dying here! :D

  • @BigNate021690
    @BigNate021690 6 місяців тому +1

    Im considering sending my p30sk lem to langdon. I got a good deal on a used one (470 otd with night sights).

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  5 місяців тому +1

      That’s a good price

    • @adkodor
      @adkodor 4 місяці тому

      Sending my slide to get milled for a dot. Leaving the trigger alone for the ccw.

  • @TheLegoJoker
    @TheLegoJoker 3 місяці тому +1

    I don’t notice the recoil being all that bad on mine but it’s definitely the least carried of my P30s. Mainly carry the P30.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  3 місяці тому +1

      Yeah to me it was “what does this do better than my p30?” The answer was nothing for me.

  • @deaneng8540
    @deaneng8540 5 місяців тому +2

    It's YOU but being 4 ft tall! 😂😂😂 The thickness has me concerned about trying to conceal it. I hate DA/SA but I'm thinking Condition 1 with the manual safety.
    But how did you like it after the 12lb pull first shot? How was the SA shots?

  • @Constantine1431
    @Constantine1431 5 місяців тому +3

    All a matter of opinion. For example, this one of only a few reviews that actually doesn’t like the weapon. Many love it. To each their own. Plus it’s all about what you want. You can’t find a better double action carry pistol for example. There are none. All of those criticisms of the trigger are exactly what someone might want as a matter of safety when carrying.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  5 місяців тому +1

      I love my hk’s I have 12 I think but the da is horrendous on all of them unless you have someone work on it. Which is why the lem is so popular. The regular p30 outperforms this by a significant margin and is still very easy to carry.

  • @darrenblake8990
    @darrenblake8990 17 днів тому

    I strongly disagree with you about the trigger on the sk. It took me all of 50 rounds to learn it.
    I shoot the sk just as well as the p30l. And i find the recoil on the sk to be preferable to that of the standard p30.
    That being said, my groups at 10 yards are a little better with the p30l, but not by much.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  17 днів тому

      I think the p30 is my favorite balance of things, it’s all personal preference I am sure

  • @midnightlaundry2800
    @midnightlaundry2800 11 днів тому

    I have an HK45, 2-P30L's and a P30SK.. The SK by far has the lightest DA Pull out of them all. I don't know who's been messing with that weapon..

  • @seandurns110
    @seandurns110 6 місяців тому +4

    So I’ve tried-and owned-numerous HK P30s and I think getting one that’s LEM or has a trigger job from Langdon, Lazy Wolf, GG, etc is a must. And if you get it from Langdon it’s not that much more expensive. The stock DA/SA on P30s is absolutely awful. As for the chunk, that’s certainly a legit complaint. For me personally, however, I much prefer thicker grips; I don’t care for the micro 9/slimline trend. Have a P30SK LEM from Langdon on the way which, I hope, might serve alongside my PX4 Compact Cary as a summer EDC.

  • @SLAINTE574
    @SLAINTE574 23 дні тому

    HOW MUCH U WANT FOR THIS MY FRIEND❓❓

  • @Shoop...
    @Shoop... 5 місяців тому +5

    Choosing the DA/SA model over the LEM was 100% user fail. Everyone points to the LEM and nobody points to the DA/SA. A tiny amount of research could save you this level of pain. Facts.
    LEM... LEM... LEM...

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  5 місяців тому

      I did a trade for this, the recoil isn’t going to change though

    • @brianrussi4328
      @brianrussi4328 5 місяців тому

      😂

  • @Alex1Tremo
    @Alex1Tremo 4 місяці тому +1

    After 1k rounds trigger eases

  • @willy4869
    @willy4869 6 місяців тому +1

    This is heartbreaking. I've been eyeing this model in lem as a new carry piece. Your video on the P30 and P30L were very positive. But this one was that much of a turd huh?

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  6 місяців тому

      Just seems like it didn’t carry that much better for a big trade off on grip and recoil

    • @cecilwilliams8709
      @cecilwilliams8709 5 місяців тому +1

      Try it before you make a decision. I can’t find anyone who doesn’t like this model. The trigger will break in and you can always get the lem. This guy wants the ease of tiny micros which are all junk. The hk is designed to last indefinitely and it’s exquisitely accurate and reliable. I took my p30sk lem out of the box and it had a really good trigger which is only getting better with use and it’s more accurate than my $1,800 trp.

    • @willy4869
      @willy4869 5 місяців тому +1

      ​@cecilwilliams8709 i wish i could have tried it. But i found a used 22' lem sk locally for a good price so i just went ahead and grabbed it. We'll see how it goes. And if i hate it, since i got it used, i won't lose my ass getting rid of it. And it is very gently used. If there wasn't a bit of fouling and brass on the breech face, i would have thought is was unfired.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  5 місяців тому +1

      @willy4869 yeah I just think the p30 conceals as well and shoots better

  • @Varego6
    @Varego6 Місяць тому

    This guy talking about "chunkster". 🤣

  • @wehrewulf
    @wehrewulf Місяць тому +1

    His shit trigger control, and finger on the trigger guard tell you what ever you need to know.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  Місяць тому

      Go tell Eric grauffel he shouldn’t have his finger on the trigger guard you muppet

    • @Catgat37
      @Catgat37 Місяць тому

      Finger wrapped around trigger guard is actually commonly used in Europe. I usually use this method, depending on the firearm.

  • @tymz-r-achangin
    @tymz-r-achangin 2 місяці тому

    A 14 lb trigger pool? It likely feels that way due to your weakness caused by eager laziness which obviously prevents your chubby fingers from being properly adequate to do simplistic tasks

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  2 місяці тому

      My guess is these weak hands would slam you down in arm wrestling and leave a big print on your wife’s dump truck after.

  • @defilade1066
    @defilade1066 22 дні тому

    Dunce said it was too chunky. Newsflash. Gripping a pencil like a micro pistol makes it all the harder to shoot accurately.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  22 дні тому

      @@defilade1066 hey idiot, I said it was to chunky in the slide for carry and that if I wanted something that thick I would just carry the p30 regular sized. You must have gotten your hearing aids at dollar general.

  • @kt2816
    @kt2816 2 місяці тому +1

    Who cares? Eat a pizza

  • @KrakenBolter
    @KrakenBolter 5 місяців тому

    H&k: their striker pistols have better triggers than their hammers

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  5 місяців тому +2

      The lem hammer ones win for me

    • @KrakenBolter
      @KrakenBolter 5 місяців тому +1

      @@randyreviewsit i think LEM is the best way to go with the HK's

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  5 місяців тому +1

      Agreed, I am getting rid of my da/sa p30 because I bought and lem one instead to send into Langdon. I am converting my usp’s to lem

  • @MooseKnuckleMike
    @MooseKnuckleMike 2 місяці тому

    I can’t stand the fact that he glossed over the fact that hk p30 series are combat designed. Of course it’s not one of those “pinky ring” micro 9’s. P30 sk’s will last a lifetime, handle better with a bit more mass and are way easier to spend time with at the range. There isn’t a single edc gun that comes out of the box with every style and feature that will suit everyone’s needs. Get over it.

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  2 місяці тому

      “Combat designed “ did you watch the video? My whole point was that instead of the sk the regular p30 conceals as well and has better handling. Why would you buy the worst p30 variant instead of a better one. You must work for the government with this kind reasoning

    • @MooseKnuckleMike
      @MooseKnuckleMike 2 місяці тому

      @@randyreviewsit Do you want to take a shot at reading your second sentence again?

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  2 місяці тому

      @@MooseKnuckleMike did you watch the video? The part where I say I am just going to stick to my p30

    • @MooseKnuckleMike
      @MooseKnuckleMike 2 місяці тому

      @@randyreviewsit Good for you.

  • @BioHorror
    @BioHorror 4 місяці тому +1

    Everyone else says the SK has the about the same recoil as the regular P30. Anyone else experience this? @randyreviewsit Since yours has optic cut and you don't like it, do you wanna sell it to me?

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  4 місяці тому

      It’s at the lgs on consignment now, and I doubt anyone that says the sk shoots as soft

    • @Sizmatrz2174
      @Sizmatrz2174 3 місяці тому

      @@randyreviewsit
      Sell it yet ?… Where’s it at ?

    • @randyreviewsit
      @randyreviewsit  3 місяці тому

      @Sizmatrz2174 Johnson city, message me on insta if you are interested in more.