What Was "Before" The Big Bang? [Urdu] | Kainaati Gup Shup
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
- #kainaatastronomyinurdu #astronomy #bigbang
What Was "Before" The Big Bang? [Urdu] | Kainaat Astronomy in Urdu
Our universe started 13.8 billion years ago in what astronomers call a Big Bang. But what was before the Big Bang? Is there a scientific way to think about this question? How do we scientifically approach such questions? What about the concept of Multiverse? Is it testable? Please join astrophysicist Salman Hameed in exploring these question in this episode of Kainaati Gup Shup. And if you haven't seen it already, check out an earlier episode on the "Evidence for Big Bang" here: • [In Urdu] What is the ...
![[Urdu] What is Dark Matter? Kainaati Gup Shup](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VQ2LK3wWEQc/mqdefault.jpg)
"We built the universe with great might, and We are certainly expanding it" Quran 51:47
Video Maker Likes all Comments epect a Quranic Vers. Very Shamefull.
@@mareezyt9831 you're right
Alhamdullillah Quran still is very much aligned with Big Bang theory, even after 1400+ years. GREAT!
@@mareezyt9831 maybe he is atheist
Now wonder what will you people say if big bang is proven wrong
I'm a student of accountancy and finance and yet I'm here watching a video on astronomy.
What you are doing is amazing. We need people like you who can introduce this subject to our youth in a language they understand and in a way that shows them how fascinating these things are. And most importantly, IMO, these videos need to be strictly scientific.
More power to you.
Thank you Anas!! I really appreciate your comment - and yes, I intend to keep this as a science and scientific channel... :)
ڈاکٹر صاحب آپ کی کاوش بہت خوب ھے اگر سائنس اللہ تعالیٰ کو مان لے تو ساری مشکل حل ہو جائے
Evidence
@@ms-zo3zb آپ قرآن کو ترجمعہ تفسیر سے پڑھے اپ کے سارے سوالوں کا جواب اپ کو مل جائے گا جو ک اج سے چودہ سو سال پہلے نازل ہوئی اور اپ کی سائنس آج بتا رہی ہے کے خلا میں کیا کچھ ہے جبکے وہ کتاب اپ کو پہلے ہی سب کچھ بتا چکی ہے اگر اسے سمجھنے کی کوشیش کرے
Sir salman main nay jab bhi apki videos dekhi aur samjhi hain mujhe us time Allah bhoat yaad ata hai aur main bas yehi kehta rehta hn k Subhan Allah, Subhan Allah mujhe aisa lagta hai k main ibadat ker raha hn. ye sab apki wajha se hai k Allah ki kainaat ko ye banda kitnay pyare andaz se humain bata raha hai. Sir Allah apko is ka bohat ajar day ga. Ye urdu main astronomy hum urdu zaban bolnay walon par apka ahsan hai sir.... thank soooo much
Bohat shukriya!
کائنات کے وجود میں آنے سے پہلے کیا تھا۔؟ اس کا جواب آج کی سائنسں نہیں ڈھونڈ سکی مگر اس کا جواب قرآن میں واضع موجود ہے ""جب کچھ بھی نہیں تھا تب صرف خدا تھا"" ❤️
agar scientist kabhi jaan payay to woh yeh nazara dekhengay jab ALLAH ne apnay noor se eik mutthi bhari thi aur kaha tha AEY NOOR MUHAMMAD BAN
Aaien ??? 😅
???@@huzaifabaig7028
beshak
Yajooz majooz की kahani
Finally something in Urdu about astronomy. Brilliant work.
Thank you Asad!
I am not a student of astronomy but I love it and studying it from youtube(like MIT and Stanford channels) and I am also watching your videos (even I know or aware of these concepts) just to support you because you are the first UA-camr on youtube who are doing fair and honest with science in Urdu honestly( by excluding theology).
But It will never make me surprise that some ignorant are there in the comments section who knows more than the Ph.D.'s because by luck they are Muslim Pakistani 😁.
Thank you Haseeb for your encouraging comment and for your support! I appreciate it.
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu Sir! We need people like you. Who explain science in an easy way in Urdu And your way of explaining is awesome even a beginner can understand.
So I don't support your channel financially right now but I will if I settle somewhere till that my support in the form of "view" and "share" is always with you.
Thank you so much Haseeb!! And your views and sharing is deeply appreciated!
@@haseebjan5938 what is your problem with theology? ??? DO THEY CREATE FROM NOTHING OR THEY ARE THE CREATOR OF THEMSELVES
اللہ ايک ہي☝
سائنسی چینل پر کمنٹس بھی “سائنس“ پر ہی ہونے چاہیں
Science does not teach self censorship
Allah ek hai poori kainat ka malik Allah o Akbar
Keepit up sir i love your videos blive kren my khud etni bari kainaat k baary my daily sochta hu or kht hu k hamara rab kitna bara ho ga jis ny ye banaya kitni dunyaen banai hwi han Allah ny
Is tarah ki knowledge urdu ma denay ka bht shukrya kafi time se asay kci channel ki talash thi ..bht bht shukrya with lots of respect
Shukriya Shaista!
اللہ مالک و خالق
V good explanation sir...
Perhaps hazaro sal bad ye pata chal jata hai ke big-band se pehle kya tha to wo log apki ye video daikh ke soche gay ke kash ye zinda hote aur isay daikh pate....
I never thought I would hear anyone discussing the multiverse concept in Urdu but here we are! Wonderful to land on your page! Subscribed. Godspeed!
Thank you Waqar!! Wait - we will talk about Magnetars in Urdu next week... :)
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu can't wait!
Excellent video. Hope this thing grows in Urdu. And I was expecting some theological discussions in the comments. Sure enough I saw some 😁
Thank you Ayub! But to be fair, most questions have stuck with science... :)
There was God- Allah * before & after Big bang. Who created Time too
Me hamesha sochta hun. Wo jo singularity tih kesay bani ya ayi wo kb say exist krti tih. Ur big bang kesay cause hoa. Ur ye sub ingeridinats jo universe me dekhte hain. Wo kesay us singularity me aye. Maybe in future we will find out. Ameen. Thank You Sir for Great Information 🌹
thankyou soo much sir apne itni effort ki sirf yeh batanay ke liye ke abi hamny kch bhi ni pata
ڈاکٹر صاحب قرآن پاک میں ان سوالات کے جواب موجود ہیں اس کا ذکر کیا کریں
If you know the answeres, then please ellaberate
Science God pr believe nahi karti so plzz
سلمان حمید. یار بڑا ہی اچھا کام کر رہے ہو آپ. ہمیں سوچنے اور سوال کرنے کی عادت نہیں ہے اور آپ سوچنے اور سوال کرنے پر اکسا رہے ہو. جیتے رہو اور خوش رہو.
And Yes. "I/we don't know", is the new excitement, a new horizon for all of us.
Keep it up man 👍
Thank you so much Adeel!! That is exactly the point.
Kya apko lagta hai k school main astronomy ka aik alag subject hona chaihe
Kitna exciting hogaa
Absolutely! I think this will lead to a broader interest in the sciences.
بہت بہترین تجزیہ اج سائنس کی بدولت ہمیں یہ بھی معلوم ہوتا ہے کہ کائنات کب اور کیسے بنا تھا 👍Good work sir and keep it up
Shukria aap ka!
This channel is a hidden gem❤️
Thank you Waqas. Tell others about the channel as well so it is less hidden... :)
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu sure sir.but don't be discouraged for being less familiar..apna time ay ga ❤️
@@waqasyousaf5318 Oh absolutely. I actually think we have great subscribers already. As I have said before, I would rather have a small number of thoughtful contributors rather than a large base that is largely here to make nonsensical comments. Thanks!! :)
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu good luck sir.. love you ❤️
ye wo sawal tha jo mea bohat dair sy tha.. aj ap is traf aye boht shukriya... 0:23 py comment.
Thank you Farhan - More than the answer it is the approach that is important. :)
You are one of the rare Muslim man because, you are selected a astronomical topic. i'm proud of you
Thank you Faizan!
I will be honest, i had my doubts clicking on this video as most pakistani experts bring religion into everything they cant explain and that makes the scientific person in me stop listening to them but i have to admit, your way of talking about a complex subject matter and your ability to stay objective is truly impressive. Great job!
Thank you - I appreciate it. And please do check out other videos as well. :)
Nice To See You Again Salman Sir I'm Always Waiting For Your UA-cam Video 🙂
Thank you Mehboob. Hope to provide you a video once a week... :)
سر بہت بہت بہت زبردست. اپ نے تو کمال کردیا. میں تو ہر وقت اپکے نئے ویڈیو اور لکچر کا انتظار. کرتارھتا ہوں.
Shukriya Shahroom!
pls make video thrice a week, we cant wait for 1 video in 1 week.
Ha! We are doing this out of extra time...and it is quite hard to get 1 video every week. But I appreciate the enthusiasm... :)
I like your videos very much. The way you explain things is amazing. One can not get bored while watching you explain things.
Ever since I started watching your videos, my interest in science has increased a lot. Now I read and watch scientific journals and videos everywhere.
Thank you and wonderful to hear that!
Such a knowledgeable man💞
Sir Beautiful way to explain
Much Impressed 👍
good work sir..
Thank you Manaj!
اللہ اکبر ❤️
You Should make a video on discoveries of medieval muslim scientists in field of Astronomy.
Absolutely - I'm currently teaching a class on history of science - and I will make a video on it as well. Thanks!
We will be looking farward for these islamic astronomers series.
I used to watched vides of a channel called There is No Clash.
They have a big colllection of Videos in which they discuss Quranic verse which talked about space and time
@Durden Tylerur bad at medieval islamic history
I love to watch professional people .. most of UA-camrs don’t know science and they just make videos to gain views . Thanks for uploading such a nice video .
Very interested
Thank you and my pleasure.
Sir please be regular with your videos. We eagerly wait for them
Look for them every Tuesday (unless there is a Live session). I have been trying for that. Thanks!
Ap ka samjhany ka andaz brilliant hai agar school colleges mei ap jaisy andaz mei Prof educate krain tou pak qom science mei bohot aagy ho gi
Shukriya Zain. I appreciate it! In videos ka maqsad science ka interest hee barhaana hay. I hope keh kam-az-kam kuch log to daikhain. :)
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu barish ka pehla qatra sabit ho gi ap ki videos khas kr hamary Jo schools k students hain un k liye bohot useful hain thanks.
@@zainalisheikh1088 Bohat shukriya!
Sir, well done carry on, spreading of such kind of amazing information.
Thank you Majid!
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu well we may or may not believe in God because Jin or human being were bestowed with free personality till end of this universe. This freedom demand the accountability of both species. This can done who was and will be présent always. I know every body knows it. Let us bélieve in it till we have better knowledge. Having some direction is surely better than being senseless. The emerging from divine source may put us on right direction.
فلکِیَت -> Astronomy
اِبتدائی الضِمہ -> Big bang
Do you know brother? you are the best person best teacher ever.
Thank you Yasir!
Maqam sy phly La Maqam ha... Ha sy phly tha, jo tha wo ha. Jo ha wahi tu tha😇💐 ... Astro scientist are the decendents of philosphers.
Sir you are doing best that converting this knowledge( Astronomy) in Urdu. Appriciated work... The answer of before big bang is difficult and for scientists it is again more tough . May Allah bless you . 💐
Thank you!
I love astronomy...
❣️
Asaan of faham Urdu main Astrology ya Astrophysics ko discuss karna k liye main apka Teh dilse Shukar Guzar ho. Professor Sb.
You are welcome - and astronomy (and not astrology...) :) Bohat shukriya!!
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu muazrat ghalati k liye or Shukriya thek karnay k liye bus yahi khobsorati hai is platform k ap islah bhi shafeeq andaz main kartay hai.
@@hzshortspk Aray - no problem at all!!
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu Sir, thanks a lot.
The part where you said that natural philosophers of their time didn’t even consider formation of the solar system a ‘scientific’ question and how not only that question today is scientific but the answer is taught to kids in secondary school - gives me hope when I ask questions about the origin of the Universe.
You know - this episode gave me hope. Optimism. To ask. To hope that there could be an answer to questions that may not make sense today.
Also - this episode gave some sense of fear; do we know what questions to even ask when it comes to the origin of the Universe? What if we aren’t asking the right questions? What if we aren’t looking at it the ‘right’ way? What if we don’t even know what we don’t know? That scares me.
Ha! Perfect. Hope and dread together! But this is the reason we have to keep on asking the questions and always be curious. At the same time, we should never put a limit on what we cannot understand - and yet we ought to stay humble. Thanks Roshaan for your comment.
I want to add something in simple words. there is no such concept of right and wrong question if your question is based on pure research(fair and honest) for example if some someone ask question about origin of the universe like who was before big bang because he wants to proof his God is right one then this thing is based on ignorance and unfair.
Really, ماشاءاللّٰہ ماشاءاللّٰہ
آپ کا کام قابلِ تعریف ہے،😊
Shukriya!
Sir,Great video and nice information .really love it ..keep it up.Be regular in uploading these amazing video.
Thank you Jaideep! I'm keeping to about 1 video/week. Keep checking... :)
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu thank you apka reply karne ke liye.that makes my day love from India .May God bless you..i watch your every video its very easy to understand because of your easy language and representation.
@@jaideepsingh2549 Jaideep - aap ka bohat shukriya!! I'm glad the videos are useful.
ap ka bat karne ka andaz kamal ka ha good job sir ji
Shukriya Farah!
My argument here being that "before time" is a paradox because in the absence of time, there can be no "before".
Yes - I mention this particular issue in the video...
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu But do we even understand what "time" actually is or if that is just another illusion? At the moment we just measure time relative to movement of something else e.g. movement of clock, earth around sun or cesium 133 atom cycles etc. but still we are measuring one movement against another. And this so called "time" seems to stop for an external observer at light speed or in black holes...
@@voiceguy554 Yes - time is a hard concept and it is discussed philosophically as well. But it is also a property of our universe (even if it is relative to different places).
Logic well done
نہ تھا کچھ تو خدا تھا کچھ نہ ہوتا تو خدا ہوتا
ڈبویا مجھ کو ہونے نے نہ ہوتا میں تو کیا ہوتا
Beshak jo kuch b zameen asman me he mere rab ka hi he. aur wo unki nigrani krte thakta nahi. aur wo ek kaali raat k andhere me ek kale pahar par chalte kali chunti se b waqif he. Mera rab Azaim or Aalishan he wo tamam izzato malik he. jise chahe izzat de aur jise chahe zillat.
Love You
Sir.Salman Hameed
ALLAH Ap Ko Zaroor Kamyab Kre ga inshaAllah Dua Hai Hum Sab ki Dil se.
Shukriya Tayyab!
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu
Welcome: Sir. Salman Hameed
does allah exists
@@abhijeetbhagat100
Of course not.
He is already kamyab..
Wow! I also felt afraid when I heard things like multiverse theory. But these videos inspire me to learn more about universe. Hopefully and InshAllah I will follow my inspiration. Sir thank you for such content. Really appreciate.
Hello Sir Salman, I really respect the way you explain complex topics in such a simple way.
I have a two part question
1) What is the nature of particles in quantum fluctuation? And
2) How come Black Holes evaporate when one of these two particles is sucked in?
Thank you Umer - and excellent questions:
1) I'm not sure of this. But mu guess is that it partly would depend on nature (especially in terms of its energy) and duration of fluctuations.
2) This is because energy is conserved. Normally, particles and antiparticles are created and they get immediately destroyed. But on the edge of event horizon, one escapes and the other falls into the black hole. There is a bit of a negative energy now in the budget of the universe - and hence the black hole loses some energy - until it evaporates. It of course takes a loooong time - and the it is mostly predicted for micro blackholes.
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu thank you so much for clearing that sir.
Law of conservation of Energy it is!!
Excellent.
Thanks...whoop when i started your video i thought you will go in religious ways to conclude it but thats good thing about you that you haven't...and its really great to see ya that you have researched on those theories and talked about those theories which is 100% true and i felt really nice by seeing this video about science bcz nowadays people's go just religious ways...just all religious...which closes our thinkings about science...think big...think about big bang...and really nice explanation by you....
Thank you Pratik! This is the point - how to think about these things from a scientific perspective. There are far more UA-cam channels with religious explanations and people can find those. But here I want to focus on the science part... :)
بہت دلچسپ اور خوبصورت انداز...
Shukriya!
نہ تھا کچھ تو خدا تھا ۔ ۔
Sub Han Allah, Allah is great
Sir 1 Question Aap say krna thaa
Agar koi b cheeze light ki speed say travel nahi kr sakti tu universe khud kesay light ki speed say expand ho rahaa ha ????? Universe b tu material ha
Great question. In fact, universe in the early phase expanding billions of times faster than the speed of light (it is called "Inflation"). The reason is that nothing can "communicate" faster than the speed of light. If the universe is expanding - everything within it expanding with itself - and cannot communicate faster than the speed of light. The universe itself has no speed limit!!
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu kia aap es topic per ayk video banaa saktya hain
@@shaheryarshafique5510 Yes - Inflation is a fascinating topic. At some point I will make a video on it...
Good question
@@dr.vedprakash3703 I will have a short video this Thursday that talks a bit about Inflation...
I had to wait till the very end to make sure you don't invoke religious explanations for, "what was before the big bang" and thankfully you didn't. Now I can tell you you're doing a wonderful job. People needed this content in Urdu. I am very glad to see you're doing this. Can't wait to see more of your videos and am sure, I will be watching the rest of your videos too. I'm a free-thinker based in Islamabad, a photographer and filmmaker. One day I hope to make something like Cosmos in Urdu and you will be my first choice for the host of that show.
Thank you Rizwan and wonderful to hear that. Here is my own connection to Cosmos: www.storycollider.org/stories/2021/11/10/a-magical-night-stories-about-when-science-was-magic
Allah Ta,ala ......Lord of all creation.
That's an unprovable hypothesis.
Just hypothesis
@@SomeBeautyfulArt i doubt if it is even hypothesis.
ALLAH sabb se bara hai Beshak
Great explanation of a topic virtually impossible to explain
Thank you Furqan!
Galaxy is getting away from one and getting closer to other .. like moving the train in the direction we will get faraway from one direction but closer in another.
Aha - Good point. But no. In whatever galaxy you will be on - you will see the other galaxies moving away. This is because the space between galaxies in increasing...
Absolutely right
Great video!
As you mentioned Einstein's Theory of Relativity not being compatible with Quantum Theory. How about make a video on a potential theory of everything. I'm talking about String Theory.
OKay - yes - may be in a few months. Thanks!!
Excellent
Sir!it was an amazing episode,I read somewhere that the laws of physics as we know them,cease to operate in singularity, means in singularity there're laws of physics which don't exist in our world,so how can we investigate the singularity before the big bang with the same laws of physics which we know today?so,do we have to invent "New Physics" that's different from our "Standard Physics" to explore this mystery?
Thank you and a great question. I would say that our laws of physics are incomplete and do not explain the condition of singularity. In that context, yes, perhaps we will new physics. But the laws themselves don't cease to exist - but it exposes the limited of the current laws.
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu Thank you so much Sir!I sincerely appreciate your efforts and energy to educate people about Astronomy and make them wonder about the universe and always replying to our cosmic queries and explaining the answers in depth.Bundles of thanks!
@@laibamasood6777 Thank you for watching the videos and asking great questions!!
Shayad ap ke sawal kisi aor univers me mil sakay hosakata ha ke dusri kainat ke physics laws aor dimensions hamari kainat se different hoN aor ye ke unki dimensions ki tadad ziyada ho
@@ABDULREHMAN-by7zk Absolutely! In fact, the laws of physics are expected to be different in other universes (if they exist).
Question is: from where the whole matter came from?
According to the 1st law of thermodynamics, matter can’t be created nor destroyed
What is the explanation of the matter which converged to the point and explosion happened of a Big Bang?
Why matter converged and explosion happened?
Looks like, we are still far behind of our explanation of the matter’s existence
Not only matter energy can also neithr be created nor destroyed
But millions of stars ,galaxies how can these came into existance from nothing
It's really good to hear a Pakistani thinking something scientific. Keep doing good work sir. Respect 🇵🇰
Thank you Waqas!
Sir, I've a question.actually I'm a physics and astronomy enthusiast.so my question is from where to study astrophysics in Pakistan??
Aysha - There are two answers to that. First, if you haven't done so already, please join a local astronomy society. There are some excellent ones on Lahore, Karachi, Islamabad, and Hyderabad (some other cities as well...). Then COMSATS has a program in space sciences that includes some astronomy, Karachi University also has a space/astronomy program, QAU in Islamabad and LUMS in Lahore have good physics programs - and physics is the foundation of astronomy.
Hey. Institution of Space and technology(Islamabad) offers Bechlors and Masters in Astrophysics and Astronomy.
@@asadkhanShahzada Thanks Asad. Here is they website: ist.edu.pk
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu sir i am doing my bs in physics form comsats islamabad and i want to do MS in astrophysics but i want to know what type of comsats have programmes about space?
@@mrx5750 Well...if you are already at Comsats - then you are in a better position to ask the question there. You should ask your physics professors....
masha ALLAH sir very good video
Thank you!
When their was no big bang only god was there..
And what was there before God?
@@pratyushpartyboy5806 only god was their before and after we all die
@P J Time of world and out of universe are different. It is also mentioned in Quran. Our 50000 years are equal to one day. Get some knowledge before you comment.
@@pratyushpartyboy5806 This question has not been answered and can never be answered. But whatever is around us are the signs of a creator. Logically we have answer that a thing can never be made without the creator. An intelligent system can never be the result of an accident cannot create itself. Y seeing everything around you, you can never assume things and creations without creator. But if you focus directly on the creation of that creator, it means you are going to find the answer of an infinite question. Because then you will ask who is the creator of that creator, then creator of the creator of the creator of the creator... And so on and at the end you would have no answer... I think No Wiseman would do that.
@P J In God's Throne time, Earth is 2 days old while the Heavens, Earth and everything in between are 6 days old. This makes the age of Earth to be one third the age of the universe (2/6 = 1/3). Similarly in Earth time, the age of Earth is 4.57 billion years while the age of the universe is 13.7 billion years; this is also one third (4.57 bln/13.7 bln = 1/3). So it is the same ratio in Earth time or in God's Throne time. The theory of general relativity explains why time at God's Throne passes slower than on Earth. General relativity explains why 6 days passed at God's Throne but we measured it as 13.7 billion years (that is each day at God's Throne measures around 2.28 billion years on Earth).
Shooting stars are thrown on Jinns because they try to steal the information. This is a Mata physical activity for which science is not so much advanced. Science hasn't seen even 16 km beneath the earth.
Good luck sir.
Imagine an empty room and comes out an explosion of big bang theory with raging 1 billion degrees... Jab room zero hai ussi chez mein infinite density does not make sense...multiverse doesn't make sense because contraction and expansion depends on energy and during this process energy gets utilized similar to a bouncy ball, it goes up and it will not reach same height every time it goes up... each universe is expanding hence it will collide with other universes, that means contraction will not occur when universes collide and explode... Allah.
Dekho bhai singularity ek eysi cheez jska size zero, phir usme infinite density phir usme se cloud nikalna phir usme etne properties rehna ki wohi cloud stars, planets, sari kayanath mein paejani wali har cheez clouds ki badolath hai...Allah.
Khaliq Syed bohat kushi hoi yeh jaan ker kai yahan loog Allah per mukamal emaan kai sath aur is ke tauheed ka khayal rakhtay hoe behas ker rahay hain. Masha Allah. Very good.
You have started wrong, there is no such thing as empty in space. Energy can neither be created nor be destroyed. So energy is always there, So imagining empty room is illogical.
We don't know anything about Multiverse, it's just an hypothesis.
And by writing Allah won't prove your Allah. Christian will write Jesus, Hindus will write brahma. So don't play God of the gaps. Science hafiz.
@@MrFahadaziz1980
Isko God of the gaps fallacy kehte hai. Isse Allah sabit nhi ho jata.
Big bang is already written in Quran 1400 years ago but humans discovered it now.So it means Quran is from God(Allah).Allah already knew that non muslims will argue about these things,So he already answered their questions long ago.Search Quran and modern science on youtube.
Case Closed.
Wonderful!
It all started with a "KUN"
بے شک
بے شک بے شک
I expected such nonsense from people.
@@realityfinder2929
who are you saying this words to ?
بے شک آپ نے ٹھیک فرمایا
اس بات کا ذکر سورۃ الانبیاء آیت نمبر 30 میں ہے
Many many thanx for doing all this in urdu
It's my pleasure Nadeem!
سلام سر! آپ کی اپنی تحقیق کے مطابق bigbang کو اسلامک نکتہ نظر سے کیسے جوڑتے ہیں؟
That we shouldn't.
Q nai bhai?
Hamain baat krni chye. Or har chiz islam se jori ja skti hai qk muslims have Quran or ye vo ilhami kitaab hai jis main bigbang se le kr black hole time travel se le kr kainat k expansion tak btlaya gya hai or hm hain k islam se jor nai skty. Or goron ko follow krty hain
Kabhi quran prho
@@usamatariq3111 bhai ye hum muslims ki badbakhti hai ilm sikhne k bjae adopt krne pr ziada foqiyat di hai.. Phr b agr history prhogay jo real hai apko buht sary muslim sciencedaan milege jin ki inventions ko published kisi or naam ya hoi ya base kisi muslim ki hain jahan tak baat Quran pak ki hai bhai main itna qabil nai jo Quran jaisi holy book main se ap ko kuch btaun. Ap qabil hain khud parhlo.
اَللّٰہُ أَکْبَرُ کَبِیرًا وَالْحَمْدُ لِلّٰہِ کَثِیرًا وَسُبْحَانَ اللّٰہِ بُکْرَۃً وَأَصِیلًا
Sir make one video on Theory of Evolution...
Is it true or not?
Sure. I talk about evolution a bit in my video on how to think about aliens: ua-cam.com/video/ADwRiDeoL08/v-deo.html . And yes, it is a foundational and well-established theory.
Evolution is real, lot of evidences from fossils, comparative anatomy, vestigial organs, and lot more. It's close to law.
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu but it very much denies the fact of intelligent designer or God
@@doosqamfita What about the formation of the solar system?
sir that is why I dont think evolution is true . we all have been created then to think we are evolve from a single cell
I was just reminding you of the fact if some one believes in evolution to be true then at the same time he disproves the creator
I personally request to all the people in Pakistan to must subscribe to this channel.RESPECT AND ALOTS OF RESPECT TO SIR SALMAN from swat .pakistan
Shukriya!!
Big bang se pehle sirf aur sirf a
*Allah* tha. .. aur wahi hai jo hamesha se tha aur hamesha rahega
I think you should make English version for each topic as well. So that people who can not understand Urdu, can get benefit from your Knowledge and concepts. 💓
Thank you for the suggestion. I do intend to - but at this time I have just enough time to get these videos out... :)
Answer is Limit of universe approaches to zero.. Problem is Didnt have the function of universe yet.l
Very nice
the intro gives me Star trek into vibes!!
Excellent!!! I loved the Star Trek intro as well.
Hi
your talk is sure and very beautiful❤️
😊 thank you!
what ever we expand our knowledge, we will find every where infinity.
This single word is tha answer for all questions.
no wonder why our country is not progressing , this channel subscribers/views shows our country interest in knowledge all we need gossip or entertainment channels anyway sir you doing great work keep it up may be one day we change our attitude towards knowledge
I'm not a pessimist. Look - people are subscribing the channel and there are also good thoughtful comments here. So I think we can make an impact!!
Very good topic Sir.. but please explain how smallest point create this Large universe.....mind can't accept.... there is more element's i more forces is acting there.... so you can say that iam the first who is rejecting the basic theory of big bang i mean there was some additional forces and reasons were there.... I offer you and all to discuss about this point.......
everything got out of that tiny dot, even our thinking,
everything is limited, so we will never be able to know what was before that tiny dot,
because ALLAH did that, and for ALLAH there is no such thing like time, he doesn't have future , present , past, Jibreel A.s tk ko ALLAH ne aus hadd se dur rkha hua jahan wo khud hai,
lekin sirf ek Insan hain is saare system mai, jo insani limited soch k b aus par gaye hue hain, wo hain Muhammad ﷺ :)
why can't we understand this?
hum q confuse rehte k, ALLAH k liye time wagaira kuch ni toh idhr q hai? ye kese ho skta hai? ye sb jo ho rha ALLAH k liye kese time nahi koi?
simple
ALLAH ne hame wo salahiat he ni di, ye sb hamare liye banaya,
:) so just , ye shok rkho k aus hasti ko dekhna hai bs aik baar or ye sb tbhi smjh aayega, or auske liye wo sb he shok se kro jo bataya ausne,
tc :)
Iam Biologist but I can understand all points you are explaining just coz of your way of describing. I wish I could teach like you to my students.
Thank you so much Rizwan and I appreciate your comment. I'm delighted to hear that you are a biologist and also teach!
Sochne ki zarorat nahi hy is kinat k end main bhi sirif allah hoga zayada dimagh pe zor nahi lagao
kia baat hai, shabash bohat khushi hoi yeh kam dekh kar
Allah tha aur koi nahi
Yeh astronomy ki channel hai. Imaginary characters ko lana se kuch prove nhi hoga.
Good information sar thanks.
Thanks Priyadeo.
I am too human but according to Allah I am kaffir.so this is one question from kaffir .
Big bang SE pehle Allah konse asman Parr tha?aur Tabb uska religen konsa that??
I think big bang ae pehlay Allah ksi asmaan pr nai tha..
Asmaan mere khyal se barriers hn q k Islam k mutabiq jb Jinnat is dunya me thay before the Adam, Un k pass aik limit thi asmaano tk pohnchnay ki siwaye Iblees k....
Or Allah ka koi religion nai h.. Islam starting se nai tha
According to Islam , Islam se pehlay boooht saray Peghambar aye, number 1lac20hazaar agar mjhay sahi se yaad h
Sb k apnay deen thay Maybe Hinduism usme se ho sb kay name Allah ne nai btaye just 4 k bataye hn...
To Allah ne shuru se Insan ki zaruryat k mutabiq Religion bhejay or akhir me Islam aya.. according to Islam....
@Vasant Ra-Thore
VASANT RA-THORE hi
Allah ka koi religion nhi hota.. religion insan ka liya hota hai.. tht is believing tht God is “one” and there no other God.
Secondly kafir means “he who rejects”.. its nt a bad word.. its jst how ppl percieve it.
Kaunsa asmaan pa tha?thts nt for us to knw and tht has nthing to do with us believing in a creator!
All this will be revealed to us whn we will meet Allah..
we r just told to obey Allah/God, believe in his oneness.. believe on judgement day and do Good deeds.. thn Allah gurantees us Heaven..
Our life in this world is incomplete.. ppl die while thriving in life, ppl r born poor, some live a misreable life etc etc
All this is jst a test and our real life will start after judgement day.
P.S; Allah has infinite creations.. its nt for us to knw wht holds in parallel universes, wht is their in different dimensions etc etc
Right nw our goal is jst to follow Allah/God’s command
Har paighambar ko apnay waqt k lehaaz se knowledge di gai....
Its like classes 1-10... Ap lvl to lvl jatay hn direct 1 class me 10th ki knowledge nai ati or 10th class me reh kr agar knowledge 1 class ki h to exams me pass nai hongay
U explain in an easy/understandable manner..I request u to give islamic touch...
Very interesting - my favourite subject 👍
Glad you enjoyed it!
I am proud of you
Good sir
Thanks!
Very interesting
Great work bro
Thank you Sarmad!
Sir your are my ideal teacher
Thank you - I appreciate it.
@@KainaatAstronomyinUrdu most welcome sir