Soil growers can't handle this video!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 сер 2024
- Or can they?
I had some fun testing out different ways of growing lettuce. I set up two wicking beds and two kratky totes. One of the hydroponic setups and one of the soil beds had Super Greensand added to them as a source of organic silica.
Buy Super Greensand on Amazon at www.amazon.com.... Check out their website at www.supergreen... for more info. I was monetarily compensated for including their product in this video.
The wicking beds had an unintended design flaw that gave the plants insufficient water. However, germination and seedling growth was better in the bed with Super Greensand. I think this is likely due to improved moisture retention from the silica.
Watch this video if you are interested in the nutrients I use or the overall process of growing plants this way • How to do Simple Hydro...
Music is "O Fortuna" by Carl Orff.
Growing lettuce to a war melody
Lmao.
what's this legendary song?
Lil Uwuzi o fortuna. It’s an old latin poem later made into a song
@@frigidowl6492 thank you Dwight
@@frigidowl6492 I didnt expect it to be that popular, but I heard it everywhere so
Lettuce not take gardening as easy, lest we become complacent
I have no clue what he is doing but it’s interesting
lol
@Sister Mary Clements why the oxygen tho ?
@Sister Mary Clements I'm actually growing marijuana with dwc and aeroponics, the dwc is just so much better though I love hydroponics!
@Sister Mary Clements Cheers! I use RO water so the filter is expensive but I need the low ppm for marijuana and I do indoor grows too but ya soil pisses me off to!
@Sister Mary Clements an RO filter will last for about 2 years so it pays for itself and I liked dirty gardening but just in my opinion I think my stuff produces better when I change my water and keep my temps and humidity pH and so on within the plants boundaries but then again it's just my opinion.
*intense music*
"This has a lot of peat moss"
*intense music continues*
yes keeps it interesting
I believe the correct title is: _This One Weird Trick Has Soil Growers Furious!_
Only dumbasses grow like that in soil. Basically a hydro fan boy trying to dogg soil grown when if u put 1/4 th the effort in the soil seeds you wouls see a real comparison. Dude is shitty as they come at soil growing fuck hydro
The part with the kid asking questions and your response was adorable
Yeah, I edit most of the garden chatter out, but it seemed like a real useful, simple explanation, so I left it in.
This is a very creative and inspiring channel. I hope to attempt growing plants hydroponically someday, preferably through the might of Kratky, so I'm going to keep watching and studying the videos to help get an idea of what to do when I get the materials to start. There are still a few questions I have, like where the water level should be at to start growing and what plants I should start with as a beginner, etc, so maybe you could make/recommend a more tutorial-based video, or something? Thanks!
Well actually I am now finding a few more videos of yours that are "how to" videos so I'll watch those first
Jeb Gardener kids can't learn things like that early enough. It's fundamental to other learning.
@@0xCAFEF00D did you know you can teach 4 year olds CALCULUS?
I am strictly a soil grower. Seeing this video made my internals implode. I will ascend in the after life and be strictly a hydroponics grower. Your knowledge has blessed me, Wise Jeb.
He never gave the soil ones a fair chance. No plant food for them while the hydro ones did get food.
you handled it well. thanks.
Hello Wise Jeb. I have ascended and my heavenly garden is flourishing with the information you so kindly gifted me. May you be blessed by the gods.
All of you are non-growers. Anyone who knew anything about growing would know this video is a sham. He puts one set of lettuce in a box with walls and no nutrients and the other lettuce out in the open with food where it gets sun. Now wake the hell up.
the most advanced growing system in the world is a soiless mix
This is the kinda UA-cam recommendation I’ve been looking forward to!
cool
@@JebGardener My grandmother grew her own vegetables. We still have sealed jars of her old green beans; held in a box promoting canning from the 50's!
I'm glad I found your channel, I have all this gardening gear used for magical plants, but since I don't smoke magic anymore it's just sitting there. Your channel inspired me to do some legal grows, thank you.
awesome
"The virgin soil grower VS the chad hydroponics master"
lol
*lol*
i've been searching forever for plant experiment...it started with me wanting to see a large fully grown type of plant...apparentl nobody really tries to grow beasts lol MY BUDS ARE BEASTS ;)
also thats really bad soil he used...if youre good it gets close to hydro FACT
mix a super soil and set up auto watering youre laughing more than a hydro grower ;)
It's funny because I don't even garden in real life. I just generally enjoy watching your videos! Jeb, you're awesome!
That’s great. You should try some jar hydroponics though too.
this is real life
@Gray Au, I would like to hear more!
@Gray Au, Hahaha, okay! I was just curious. I had no intention of trying to buy the seeds, as I don't even know what plant we're talking about. I just found the subject interesting. I can barely grow succulents. :P 😆
why not start? if you know someone growing tomatoes, steal a non-productive branch?
I love the humor of the soil lettuce of "these ones are doing better" and then BOOM!!! Hydroponic lettuce!!!
You can dip newspaper in ranch dressing and it will taste good.
Tr Whitford LOL!
I am tempted to try
ANTBALL18 no u
legalize ranch
I'm sure my daughter would agree with you. I guess Ranch is now the new caviar.
I was sad about not being able to watch Dexter cuz it ended ages ago but you've replaced him very nicely
Honestly so glad I stumbled upon your channel one day in the past. I sure am glad I subbed.
you made the right choice, quazii
I love the moments when he explains things to his son there so wholesome this guy's a good father
😁👍
Dramatic music+your sense of humor=funniest thing I’ve seen today. Simple math
thank you
YEAH THE MUSIC IS BACK
Crank it up!
Amazing videos!! Do you have any epic Playlist on Spotify or Dezzer you could share? Much thanks for all of your inspiring methods of growing! Greetings from Bolivia!
I'm trying to decide if it's a good idea to share my playlists or not.
FUCK YEAHHHHH!;
Jeb Gardener absolutely
Nice video Jeb. I planted 3 garlic cloves in February just to be a rebel. One is still alive and I have medium hopes for it.
hope it works out for you, shitbag
Jeb Gardener Hahaha...I think you responded just so you could type his name...😂
Jeb Gardener Love the videos...I’m a newer sub and trying my hand at basil in mason jars.
Jeb Gardener lol
Jeb Gardner. I cant stop laughing, maybe you should have Shitbag over for tea and he could fertilize your next project?
To be honest I know nothing about plants, this guy can just make anything entertaining
thanks i try
Now I want to grow something
good idea
that is exactly what I was thinking
Grow hydroponic weed
Read a poem to a horse.
this channel is what youtube should be like along with its great music
Yeah I've been saving this song for the right video.
It is what youtube is like seeing as how you saw it on youtube.
Bilthrow Fragins exactly
Jeb Gardener Hey are these music pieces all royalty free? I keep hearing these epic scores ...
Rajat Roy I'm pretty sure its part of the Death Note soundtrack
Our Lord and Saviour has praised us with more epic content
All praise Jeb
May your greens be forever grown
Okay, this is epic
@@CAPSSTROKE "Jesus tap dancing Chist! I HAVE SEEN THE LIGHT!"
Dumb asses the lot of you talking that smack about our LIVING WORD/JESUS/YESHUA
Beautiful video. I am planting my seeds in our balcony, not having a backyard in these years, and I was a little sad that my geraniums dried out during the winter, all dead, first time that that happens to me. I watched your video with so much joy, for different reasons. I love both gardening and music, you have got a taste to match the beauty of art and nature!. I also remembered my precious brothers, they are gardeners, builders, they are strong, even rude sometimes, but their souls are beautiful, and my soul loves them very much. I have worked with them and I thought that I was watching their hands, strong to manage the tools, and delicate to handle the tiny plants. You see, your video impacted everyone in different ways. Thanks.
thanks ines
Man I just love your videos my friend. Please never stop making them.
No we cannot handle it because it's miracle grow soil .
Joking bro
he grew like a kid lol this is not normal at all
3:42 Isnt it crazy how people first start out even smaller than a seed to becoming a 100+ pound multicellular conscious organism.
Ask Alotofquestions isn’t it crazy how those small cells are made up of tons of atoms, and the relative size of an atom to you, and the size of you to the earth, and the size of the earth to the sun, and the size of the sun to the galaxy, and you realize how insignificant and pointless the human being is.
Chad C
Significance has nothing to do with size you Nihilistic immature moron
Reggie Stickleback being a human is pretty ducking pointless and insignificant
TheBeastX1130
Why?
@@reggiestickleback7794 He watched Rick & Morty, duh!
I love this guys videos. No idea if they're any good for learning planting and growing techniques but his Bob Ross style monotones with his music selections is superb!
I'm loving how clear and vocal this version of O Fortuna is.
I love when people use there time to be productive and you used your time to make some that you can be occupied on have fun and have a little snack after you effort keep up the great work love u man 🌿🌱🌾♥️♥️
Edit: *realizing that I did not make this on the latest video oof* *feelsbadman*
youtube recommended this so now i'm watching a dude grow his soil at 3am
they are in charge now
When I really need to have a smile and a feel good moment, I play Any of Jeb Gardner's videos. Yes, even the re-runs.
The understated narration and music definitely makes this informative video way more entertaining!
thanks joy
His excitement level is through the roof
Amazing, Just Brilliant! Thats 4 yes's on to the next round. You're going to Hollywood baby! Great choice of music , thats why I subscribed.
thanks danny
The music you used made this video hilarious, but I also really enjoyed watching the experiments and growing process. Thanks!
thanks casey
Excellent choice of music, sir. Impressed with the hydroponic lettuce. Much better than my soil attempts!
yeah hydro lettuce is easy mode. i want to get the wicking bed working for carrots and such
Me: yeah this video was kinda interesting
Soil growers: I can't handle this video
No, he just did a shit job. I got my soil tested but didn't get the results back til I had already planted my lettuce. My soil was deficient in several nutrients, and I hadn't added any fertilizer and didn't weed them. They still grew much larger in the same time frame as what he grew under more controlled conditions. He just doesn't know anything about growing in soil it seems. You might be able to grow bigger plants on average in hydroponics systems but this video is just not a good representation of that.
Jeb, you are a film master.
Thanks. This one came out pretty easy.
Jeb, I'm so glad I finally found your channel, educational and perfectly hilarious. I know what I'm spending the rest of my day doing
For a fast harvesting veggie like lettuce, spinach hydroponic is the best option. But other than that, soil growing is still win.
Have you tried growing pepper, tomato, cucumber, melon, watermelon in hydroponic? They eat hell alot of water/ hydro nutrition and become 10 times expensive than growing in soil.
I do both hydro & soil growing.
Why 10 times expensive?
And since those plants you named use so much water and a huge percentage of the water evaporates from soil and not from mostly closed hydroponic containers which one ACTUALLY makes best use of the water you put on it?
@@xanadu1jw we are talking about the minerals that y'all have to mine and destroy ecosystems to have shipped around the world so you can grow hydroponically most of the world is actually covered by water I use collected rainwater on my plants I dont see how thats harming the environment the way you guy do.
@@thenormalyears I’m not doing it, at least not now. But your rainwater won’t provide everything your plants need, hope you have a plan for that and for pests. I don’t agree with pesticides, fungicides, etc. And I don’t know what I’ll do to protect against what they were designed for if I grow some food. I tried to grow a few indoor plants and a white fuzzy bug wiped some of them out despite my best efforts.
If a tree grew hydroponic Style, I would want to see the roots
Edit: nice hair cut!!!!
Thanks, I hope to do a fruit tree someday.
I'm growing a mango tree Hydroponically, the roots look really different than plants in hydroponics, they look like branches instead of roots. It's really cool to observe
Malia that is awesome
The Cookie check out my Instagram I will be posting pics of my Mango tree and roots if you're curious how they look. @gardenofwater
Travel to The north part of India close to Bangladesh too see hyrophonic trees in nature
The music seems like the video was timed around it at some points. LOVE IT. Glad the music is back ;)
Yeah it makes it much more challenging to edit, but it's lots of fun.
I didn't know I needed this in my life, but now I can't get enough of your content, wow.
That’s great
WHEN I WAS 15, MY MOM & I WENT TO SEE MY SISTER PERFORM IN A COLLEGE MUSICAL SHE WAS IN... IT WAS CALLED ""CARMINA BURANA"" 'TIS THE BACKGROUND MUSIC FOR THIS VIDEO. I RECOGNIZED IT IMMEDIATELY - IT WAS ONE OF THE MOST EXCITING CONCERTS I HAVE EVER BEEN TO AS FAR AS SYMPHONIC MUSIC!!! I LOVE YOUR IDEA FOR YOUR COMPOST BINS ~ THANKS!
glad you enjoyed it
This video triggered me, all the way to my soil bound roots.
Jeb will take some lettuce, and he will grow it!
Some of it grew lol
Most people wouldnt have gotten the reference lol
Deity Visuals that’s some next level reference
he need to grow some potatoes next
Kira
These videos get more interesting by the day. Keep it up!
Thanks
what a great dad - teaching his boy and expanding that brain
*Soil growers hate him, learn to grow HUGE lettuce in only one week!!!*
Lettuce thank the kratky gods for the bountiful harvest.
Yes, with my laziness hydro might be the only way now.
Planting growths, puts on dramatic music.
Amazing !!!
thank you
Your Awesome!!! I got super jealous of that last part. All this video got me hungry for lettuce!! Great work, I like your video style.
yeah it was real tasty. thanks
Another great video. Thanks for sharing, Jeb!
Thanks Zoe.
Thank god for the volume control
This dudes channel is awesome . I grew up on a property with display gardens and nurserys . I wish this music played full time while i worked there . I would of felt like a god
haha
First time I’ve seen hydroponics outside! Very cool! Thanks
glad you liked it
Surely that's as much as a poor setup vs good setup?
You let the soil dry out, what chance did it have?
Our Green Thumbed God has returned to us All Hail Jeb
The most epic gardening I've seen, ever
Thanks
Okay. I’m subscribing. New to gardening here 🙋🏻♀️. And clicked on a video out of curiosity. They are so entertaining and hilarious. I can tell this guy has a passion for his plants 🌱. I might not try my hand at this for a while, till I can get the basics down with soil, but I’m subscribing because he makes me happy and laugh.
Please more Videos. I like your Videos. Greetings fom Germany
Good idea
Definition of Soil:
The top layer of the surface of the Earth in which plants grow. Soil is composed primarily of disintegrated rock particles from the Earth's crust. Soil particles are classified by their diameter. Clay particles are less than 0.002 millimeters, silt is 0.002-0.05 millimeters, and sand is 0.05-2.0 millimeters in diameter. It takes 100-500 years to produce an inch of soil from rock of the Earth. A healthy garden soil should be more than 40% silt with good aeration, water retention, and 1-5% organic matter (humus and living organisms).
Peat moss is found in bogs and is an ingredient added to potting mixes. It isn't soil.
@The Senate you're correct. You actually need about ZERO. Your soil should be close to zero organic matter or at least under 5 percent. The organics matter should go on top of the soil about .5-2 inches thick. Organic matter around roots just begins to rot and takes oxygen away, causing to all sorts of issues. Some things just take longer to decompose. Bark works until it decays, but it takes a while for that to happen. Best soil is a mix of sand, clay, and silt. But nobody uses sand in pots because it's freaking heavy so they substitute it with slow decomposing stuff.
Matthew Kheyfets compost>organic matter. You can grow in compost only so I honestly don’t know where you got any of your info
The Senate that is exactly what I said?
@@dropbear2972 you actually can't grow in pure organic compost in most situations. In raised beds, you can. But in pots, very likely the plants will die. Clay is not really organic matter.
@The Senate oh vei
Sir, thank you for something to commit to memory. God bless you and yours throughout these trying times. Thank you for teaching us!
man you make gardening super entertaining for me please keep this up 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
thanks
Soil growers cant handle your ignorance of how the Soil Food Web works. "Its got a lot of Peat moss", well Jeb peat moss is Inert (meaning it has no nutrients in it). So you are basicly comparing a finely tuned high performance race car (bottled nutrients) to rust bucket with no engine that is up on blocks (lifeless soil). I don't want to come off as a hater but it has taken me years to sift through all the lies and misinformation that is out there about farming and gardening. So in conclusion; Jeb, I do not think you understand enough about horticulture to be teaching it. You are spreading dangerous misinformation and that helps no one. I'm am however glad that your project inspire people to get growing, that is priceless! But please be careful with your opinions and statements, you are speaking to a lot of beginner gardeners.
i knew you couldn't handle it
So you want to be the Trump of gardening? Good to know to avoid all your shit content like the plague. Nothing wrong with hydro but this is the worst comparison I've ever seen.
Hey man, funny video ive been a fan for a long time.
Hes got a good point though. When you gave all the white powder to the hydroponic ones did you give the same to the ones in the dirt? Because peat moss has basically no food in it for a plant, I work for a retail store that sells all this stuff and you really have to give them food to have them grow properly. Greensand is avaliable in lots of different brands the one we sell at my store is way cheaper than what you got. But its really more of a suppliment there is no nutriuents in there.
Its all fun and games till you manipulate the truth to get the outcome you wanted, instead of making it fair you either intentionally or inavertantly handicapped the soil ones, and gave the hydro ones an unfair advantage.
I love your content but really its not right to call this a comparison.
stix is speaking truth.
My only advice to any kind of beginner is to get your information from as many sources as possible. Listen to new ideas and compare them to other well tested ideas and just experiment, because in the end we learn best by doing!
...now I want lettuce
get planting!
Second video
Just heard the intro
Instantly subscribed
Just felt natural
welcome diego
I'm doing outdoor hydroponic this year for my first time. I'm planning to do 70% hydroponic of my chili plants. I am excited and can not wait until spring 🥰
10/10, would watch lettuce again
Watch it again late at night. So much better then.
I love your videos. You make a hard thing look easy! My strawberry in hydroponic blew off in the wind :(
My strawberries died last summer in the heat. They seem fussier than other plants.
Jeb Gardener yeah even the ones I have in pots have dry crunchy but green leaves
Strawberry in the wild don't grow vertical all the time they love shade
You explained comparison experiments with "green stuff" very very well to your boy. Perfect choice of words! 😆
yeah i didnt expect that to make it into the video originally
Very interesting and very informative and detailed
The music brought some drama LOL
Loved the Oops about the lettuce not getting roots to the water
thanks purple luna
I wonder how pot would work out with your methods
What do you think O genius one?
It kind of looks like you’re adding cocain to the plants!😂🤣
It's what plants need
Electrolytes ITS WHAT PLANTS CRAVE!
Porkchop Sandwiches And Cocaine!
am i the only one appreciating this video?
nope
i'm really enjoying your videos@@JebGardener
This video is amazing funny with the bgm and narration. Great video!
lol
Eu encontrei o melhor canal do youtube de todos os tempos!!!
(Translated: I found the best UA-cam Channel ever!!!)
gracias daniel
Great music and video. Wick would have done better with larger net cup or multiple ones was my thoughts.
Yes it needs to be deeper and it should have 3 wicks imho. It made for a good comparison with the plants starved for water though.
Your a legend man! So stoked the music is back!
Such a unique style to your videos!
You have inspired me to start growing hydro and it's awesome!!
Every time I watch your videos I feel I'm back In azeroth with these backgrounds
I don't think you watered the plants in the soil at all. Hydroponics is a better medium, but I don't think you know how to grow with soil
wasn't he testing also whether that wicking set up would work? It wouldn't be a fair test if you watered a system that was supposed to water itself.
@@Metqa "The wicking beds had an unintended design flaw that gave the plants insufficient water." this was a wicked bad comparison
devils lettuce
lmao are you stupid
420 grams of pest damage 😂
Tyler D devil's greens ;)
i have no idea what’s happening but i like it
time to watch more videos
Please make a beginners guide on how to do hydroponic farming and what mixture for optimal growth
Did you add nutrients to the Hydroponics?
Ohhhh hes back baby
yeah!
Jeb Gardener hi Jeb! I just wanted to say that your videos helped me through some rough times, and you always manage to bring a smile to my face!
That's great Zuko. Some of my best work comes from hard times.
Fricken AWESOME vid! Mahalo 4 the great info & music.
thank you
I really need to start my own large hydroponic system. Thanks for the inspiration
awesome
hot damn those hydro lettuce are great looking guuuuhhhhraet
Yes, it's kinda cheating with the unlimited water and nutrients.
Great video as always
Thanks paco.
Pretty cool video. I’m probably never going to use any of this information EVER BUT I LIKE YOUR VIDEOS.
that's great
This has to be the best thing on UA-cam
Thanks Toni
Awesome!
Can you do one on growing the Devils weed hydro?
With the same. Music, of course...
The ones in soil aren't getting as much light from the sides of the bucket.
Yes searched for this comment! It's not getting any light. You even see the shade at 6:07 min.. That's not a comparison. Do it again but pls same light and same care
I'm probably the only viewer here under the age of 35, but man I love the scores to your videos.
Most of this music is older than all of us
That's the way I like it. Love your videos Jeb, thanks for inspiring to plant fresh vegetables for my family. Even got my dad joining in on the fun.
that's great.
Thanks for the video! Now I want to learn hydroponics.
974 soil growers disliked this video
They grew like Shit because you have minimal fungal and nematode activity and probably little to no protozoa and arthropods. A bucket full of natural forest topsoil in each container would have made them keep up with the hydroponic plants.
Cadaver thehacker I couldn't agree more. He thinks a MircleGro product (even if it is certified "organic") is a "plug and play" solution. It's clear that he does not understand the living soil food web and the difference between that and chelated bottled nutrients (plant steroids).
@@stixglass8442 exactly!! Chelation forces the roots to absorb nutrients wether they're needed or not. A proper soil requires thousands of types of lifeforms to break down organic nutrients into water soluble form
I need to write this down
Compost tea or a sample of soil from a natural forest are good starter innoculants
Hydroponics will grow quicker than soil, especially organic as the feed needs to broken down before uptake, hydro has direct uptake, I'm not saying the finished product won't be as good but during growth the hydro will perform better
Bro, when you watered the first two soil ones and were like, this ones doing better though.
Then cut to the hydro plants and rolled the music. I genuinely laughed out loud haha. Amazing
good
i ve made an aquaponic system in my backyard, and my wife was surprised by the velocity the lettuce grew over two weeks. my fish tank is clean now, with all the filtering by the roots and bacteria.
neato