PYASA is quintessentially 'on poetry wings' carried movie- all of it Sahir Ludhianavi métier meat from start to end. I don't see how Dilip Kumar could have carried that 'Cross'. It is like Sahir himself insisting by the making of Phir Subah Hogi on Khayyam scoring the music for very express reasons known in the public domain. As such, Guru Dutt retains his natural actor credentials. Dilip K would compulsively have turned a 'staid' role into his styled histrionics 'hoopla' (some visible in Devdas scenes that substract from the raconteur gravitas). Besides, and so in all matters in life, destiny plays the Veto card. Hence PYASA- thank God- came on with Guru Dutt. The fine actor repeated his par excellence in Kagaz Ke Phool, leaving no doubt about his superiority in his chosen acting genre. PYASA, counted among the 100 world best, settles the argument for good.
Hello Satish Kumar Shukla... Thanks for writing to me. Very well commented by you in detail on Pyaasa - GuruDutt Vs DilipK comparison. I hope you are enjoying the videos on my channel. Do watch all the videos and comment when you want to say something. I will personally reply to you. Thank you & Take Care, Rahoul
Guru Dutt ji . Among the finest actors of Indian cinema , Guru Dutt’ s name is very much there. Rahoul sb , your IQ is sharp and your presentation sharp too. The way you placed the most difficult Q to viewers , my God as if we are on the day of judgment ! No substitute for Dilipkumar. We know . And Guru Dutt made the history !
Satish Kumar Shukla g Defined it very well. Guru Dutt sahb was ahead of his time, One of the greatest filmmakers of Indian Cinema, But he was also such a good actor, the innocent Bhootnath, cartoonist Preetam, taxi driver Kalu, poet Vijay and famous film director Suresh...,He will forever live in our hearts ❤
Thank God for Dilip Kumars refusal to play this role.Guru Dutt not only excelled but left behind a role only described as folklore.This has been one of my memorable movies to watch and everything just merged beautifully.Thank you bhai for this story.
Pyaasa is a master piece.I can't imagine anyone else in the role of Vijay except Guru Dutt.He was among greatest indian directors.But I think he under estimated himself as an actor.So he approached Dilip Kumar.Guru Dutt was an excellent actor undoubtedly.Aar paar,Mr & Mrs 55,Pyaasa,Kagaz ke phool,Chowdvin ka chand,Saheb bibi aur ghulam,Suhagan...in all those films he showed his class.
Jo hua, achcha hi hua kya bura hua, Toot gaya jhutha aetbar, jab wo na rahe. I am glad Dilip Sahb did what he did. GuruDutt Sahb probably did not know his own potential.
IT COULDN'T HAVEN BEEN BETTER THAN THE ICONIC FILM PYASA. GURU DUTT CAME OUT AS PERFECT CHOICE FOR THE HERO ROLE IN THE FILM. SOMETIMES NATURE TAKES CONTROL OF THINGS IN IT'S HANDS.
Hello Bhagwati Sharma... Thanks for writing to me. I hope you are enjoying the videos on my channel. Do watch all the videos and comment when you want to say something. I will personally reply to you. Thank you & Take Care, Rahoul
Don’t even want to imagine, Pyaasa was an epic which couldn’t have been without Gurudutt. Sometimes intensity kills people. He was so intense in almost everything around that it suffocated him unknowingly. Gurudutt was way ahead of his time and born in a wrong era. Filmmaking can be learnt by just critically watching all his classics, though some of them weren’t commercially successful.
Can’t imagine anyone except Guru Dutt in Pyaasa. One of my top favorites of all time. Don’t think Bollywood can make such a classic ever again. Each time I watch it, I wonder how the cast and crew could make something so pitch perfect. My dad in his late 60s is a huge fan, I at 40 am a huge fan, and am sure my son when he grows up will be a big fan of this movie too. Guru Dutt Saab🙏🙏
No one else, only Guru Dutt could justify that role. Guru Dutt was Guru Dutt. He had the vision how to direct the role and the movie. Guru Dutt has also directed the Super Star, The Dev Anand Saab. There was no other Super star in that era!
Thanks to Dilip Kumar for not doing this film! We got a masterpiece with the immortal performance by Guru Dutt. We cannot imagine anybody else in this role.
THANKS RAHOUL JI... DILIP KUMAR WAS A LEGENDARY BUT, GURU DUTT SAHEB WAS A MASTER DIRECTOR... INFACT, DIRECTOR OF DIRECTOR'S OF CINEMA WORLD... U CAN NOT IMAGINE ANY ARTIST OF THE WORLD BETTER PERFORMING THAN GURU DUTT SAHEB ON SONG 'JANE WOH KAISE LOG THE JINKE PYAR KO PYAR MILA ' 💝💯
The video is very comprehensive giving background of Pyaasa. It is no doubt that Dilip Kumar Sahab is tragedy King. But in this film Guru Dutt gets more than 100 marks . We cannot imagine anyone other than Gurudutt for Vijay Role. Distributors did a good role. Very good lucid video sir. 🙏👍
After hearing this....whatever happens it happens for the good...Can't imagine anyone apart from gurudutt doing this role...jo hota hai ache ke liye hota hain....
Sahi kaha tha Dilip Saab ne.Devdas jaise hi milta julta character hota 👍🏻But Rahul Pyasa me Guru Dutt ji ka role bht appropriate lagta h.unhone iss film me apne character ko jiya h.I can't think anyone else in the place of Guru Dutt for the role of Vijay.
गुरु दत्त ने प्यासा में विजय के कैरेक्टर को इतनी खूबसूरती से निभाया है कि यह फिल्म क्लासिक मानी जाती है। यह सोचने की जरूरत ही क्या है कि दिलीप कुमार होते तो क्या होता। गुरु दत्त का अभिनय दर्शकों को झकझोर देता है। वेरी वेल डन 👍👍👍👍👍 शानदार प्रस्तुतीकरण राहुल भाई 👍👍
I can't imagine Dilip saab in "Pyaasa". Guru Dutta saab was so perfect in this role. He was amazingly relatable in the role poet Vijay, none could fit in his shoes in this film.
According to me whatever happened it is good. Guruduttji was perfect casting because we could see the pain of the character was perfactly Brought out by Guruduttji
This is Guru Dutt's best film ever, as a Director and Actor.Had Dilip Kumar worked in it we would have missed Guru Dutt's histrionic ability which was confined only to crime flicks till then.Dilip Kumar would have given his same old style of acting of which public was familiar with.Fortunately he didn't turn up and we came to know about The Great Guru Dutt.What Guru Dutt gave to Indian Cinema is his short span of life of 39 years Dilip took 70 active years to reach the pinnacle of Indian Cinema
I have watched Pyasa...Guru Dutt was definitely way ahead of his time...his movies speak for it...Guru Dutt movies are always counted among the premier ones among the Indian Cinemas...and Guru Dutt's acting as well direction has always created history...So Pyasa is another example of it. May be Dilip Sahaab would have done it in his own way.Again Guru Dutt was no less.
Rahoul ji, In 2005, when my Dad (late now) came to live with me in Toronto, Canada after he retired. One fine evening he wanted to watch an old movie. Fortunately, I have a nice library. I asked my father, what movie he would like to see, so we can go, get it. He said hesitating, can we go to video store and get "Pyaasa". I was overwhelmed because I had that. That evening both of us watched it together in one sitting . I did not tell my father that I have already watched that before and knew everything about that movie and that I was a big fan of Guru Dutt ji. I did not want to break the excitement and joy of my father, who was so happy and so emotional at the same time. He was watching that movie years after since he was in University. In between he kept telling me about movie and Dutt Sahb. I very well acted and pretended that I bought it but still was looking for opportunity to watch it. Your video took me in the past. Thank you so very much Rahoul ji.
Hello Amita Tare... Thanks for writing to me. I hope you are enjoying the videos on my channel. Do watch all the videos and comment when you want to say something. I will personally reply to you. Thank you & Take Care, Rahoul
Guru dutt was a great actor. I understand halwai doesn't enjoy sweets he make. Maybe gurudutt was thinking dilip kumar could play the character better. But like they say "destiny has better plans". And we got an icon!
Guru Datt was the appropriate actor for film piyasa. The end scene was superb. The songs written by sahir sahib too good .thanks for uploading the video.
Wonderful. A very fascinating story on PYAASA. It’s a blessing in disguise for Guru Dutt that Dilip Kumar never came for the Muhurat. I have a strong inkling that this film would have remained unfinished if he had acted in the first few days of shooting. Guru Dutt would not have tolerated his interference. Dilip Kumar had this penchant to interfere in every film (after Aan & Andaz) as per his whims. Finally it was Abrar Alvi, Guruswamy, Sahir and others who advised Guru Dutt, not to wait for Dilip Kumar and you yourself continue with it. There are a few other stories also, pertaining to this. Thank you very much Rahoul. B.S. Narayanaswamy
i cannot imagine how the movie would have fare with Dilip Kumar. Also Pyasa without Guru Dutt. Genius shone in the Movie not only as an actor but in many respects.
Sir i have read different stories regarding Pyaasa Movie. This story was published in The Illustrated Weekly Of India under the title "The Thirsty man" a long time ago before the making of movie "Pyaasa". Mr Guru Dutt wrote this story before joining the Film Industry. I also read Dilip Kumar could not work in this movie because of the dispute between Madhubala and Vijayantimala regarding their role in the movie. The both actresses wanted to play the role of one character and i think that was the character of Gulabo. When it was not settled between the actresses then Dilip Kumar also did not work in the movie. Later on Mala Sinha and Waheeda Rehman worked in the movie. Being Ardent fan of Mr Guru Dutt i am very much happy to see him in the lead role. For me he was the best in this role.
Great condolences to Mr Dilip Kumar. RIP. 🙏 Only when you have a vision for tomorrow, you will find power and purpose in your today's work.. we always love watching your video. 👍😀
I can’t imagine any other actor then The Great Gurudatt. Not even Dilip Kumar. In Piyasa. I am a big admirer of Grudatt as Director as Actor his style. Just as he was.
Cant compare . In retrospect, Pyaasa was a block buster and popular for decades. It was a big saving of money to Gurudutt and Dilip Kumar had nothing to lose, as he was already a busy star. We cant imagine what would have happened after 60 years
अच्छा हुआ दिलीप कुमार जी ने यह रोल नही किया, नहीं तो गुरुदत्त जी के अंदर जो प्यासा छुपा हुआ था वोह हमें देखने को नही मिलता।उस प्यासे की परिणति, हमें कागज़ के फूल के रूप में देखने को मिली।
No Rahoul ji..I just can't imagine anyone else singing *Ye duniya agar mil bhi jaye to kya hai*and playing the role of Vijay in Pyasa except for Guru Dutt ji ...our misfortune to have lost such a legend so soon...wish could have witnessed more Indian cinema like Pyasa on our silver screen.... Guru Dutt Saab ko aur unke soch ko mera sat sat naman🙏🙏🙏
Gurudutt did an amazing job! Cant think of anyone else! What a legend! Dont think Dilip Kumar could hv done better. What use is ego with talent, if he wasnt decent.
agar dilip kumar ne pyasa ki hoti to logo ko usmein bhi devdas hi nazar aata aur pyasa ka jo actor chahiye tha jiski nayi aur fresh image ho woh nahi mil pata , isliye baiju bawra , devdas aur pyasa teeno ke liye first time new aur fresh image wale hi actor chiye thay , pyasa ko guru dutt aek naye dimesions par le gaye jo sochne se bhi kahi zyada tha , sirf dark character hi nahi tha woh usmein aek philosopher bhi chaiye tha , poet bhi chaiye tha , aur dilip kumar karte to fir devdas usmein mix or cross to hota hi , isliye guru dutt ne aisa amar role kiya ki pyasa is now a part of film making's text book in various foreign universities like france & uk , such a great honour for bollywood given by gurudutt ji .
Things that are happened are perfect Guru Dutt in Pyass is ultimate and if something that we can imagin that who can replace Guru Dutt betterly, but perfect things can not be replaced
Guru Dutt really played this role fantastical and he suited this role perfectly well. We are glad that Dilip Kumar did not play this role. This turned out to be one of Guru Duty's best played role and he really looked adorable in this movie. Only if he had lived longer and gi en is many more of such amazing movies!
gurudat perfom very good. And you have to move on , new talent will get chance. gadi kiseke liya rukti NAHI . WELL DONE GURU DAT SAHEB HATS OF FOR YOUR DESION.
Gurudutt has done well. He is the best Director of Indian films. There are only two legendary producers/ directors in Indian films. They are Raj kapoor & Guru Dutt.
Who knows Dilip sahab could have taken this film to even greater heights، he was more accomplshed actor،no offences meant for dutt sahab I'm a great admirer of his،but even he realised that Dilip kumar suited most for this role،this was his kind of role، ofcource this proved Dilip Kumar's greatest miss۔
It is not a surprising, at least to me, that Dilip Kumar did not do Pyasa. Dilip would not do any movie with a talented director who is also a good actor so that he will not allow Dilipsab to interfere in director's domain. Guru Dutt was a good director and a good actor too. Another example is that of raj Kapoor who wanted dilip Kumar to play any role (Gopal or Sundar) of his choice in Sangam. Dilip insisted that Raj should refrain from directing the film and someone else should direct this film. Who will accept this condition? Raj Kapoor? Impossible. And that's what happened also.
Only Guru Dutt ji could do justice to the role..not Dilip Kumar ji. Thank God Guru Dutt ji acted in the movie in the lead role. Will comment more later tomortow or day after. Have been watching many of your vdos since few days..with rapt attention. You speak ...present so well Rahoul...waah
प्यासा मे दिलीप कुमार होते तो फ़िल्म गज़ब की होती और इतिहास रच देती।उस समय दिलीप साहब को उनके डाक्टर ने ऐसे दुःखी रोल करने से मना कर दिया था और दिलीप कुमार कामेडी और दूसरे रोल कर रहे थे।
Believe me I saw this film with my mom about 40 years back & am sure dilip Kumar may be a actor pat excellence but gurudutt was superb as an actor & director both his camera always works on facial close up where expressions play great role no one can match him
Dilip kumar agar vijay ka role karte toh pyaasa phir pyaasa nahi reh jaati ...gurudatt ne is role ko isliye amar bana paaye kyunki woh khud pyaase the.
Thanks Rahoul for this great Content. Would be grateful if you could name the sources for the conversation between Dilip Kumar sb and Guru Dutt jee. Both were great personalities. Dilip Kumar also had unusual methods to motivate people to do something or to make them aware of their actual potential.
@@70mmwithRahoulthanks for this Information🏆🏆🏆. It's meant friendly and with big respect to your great commitment (and all the efforts you do). If possible, than kindly mention in your next Videos your source too. This Step will make a) your content unique than the others in UA-cam b) it would be easier to trust your content more when you show the source by your own c) that might be a bit more work, but you will reach a higher class with your videos. Especially people out of India / Asia would appreciate and value this a lot. Thanks Bro 😉👍🏆
@@ChangeStartsNowWithAhsanSaleem Thanks Ahsan... Guess you are right... will reveal about my background in the Rafi special on 31 July... watch ... watch... watch.. btw where are u based?
@@ChangeStartsNowWithAhsanSaleem regarding point 3... it won't be extra work actually because none of my content is hearsay... everything that i speak is based on a written documented source... will definitely start to mention wherever i can... in fact watch my DK-Madhubala episode today... will give my source ;)
Dilip kumar was not allowed to play any more depressing movies because he was under anti depression treatment ...We should not try to underestimate a legend after he is no more .This could have been said when Dilip kumar was alive or would not have bothered ...He was not aware to this world. for nearly 8 yrs ...Have some respect to the departed SOULS 🙏🏻
Dilip kumar is the greatest actor Bollywood ever had . Guru dutt is one of the best actor and director who started golden generation of Indian cinema . However there are differences in acting style . Dilip sahabs personality as a tragic rich and upper middle class lover who can argue and gives reply with other person ( quite talkative personality) not extrovert. However guru dutts character in movies depict a less talkative man who talks with his expression rather than dialogues . He depicts a talented underrated middle class personality in movies who is not getting appreciation and recognition in society. Guru dutt is perfect for Vijay in pyasa it depicts a person who failed in everything . 1: career 2: love 3: finance However Dilip sahabs character devdas failed in love only . Devdas is a rich guy with good zamindari career and wealth . So according to my opinion pyasa is more challenging role and difficult role to play . So guru dutt made justice in playing the role of Vijay .
Hello Anupama Kumar... Thanks for writing to me. I hope you are enjoying the videos on my channel. Do watch all the videos and comment when you want to say something. I will personally reply to you. Thank you & Take Care, Rahoul
अगर दिलीप कुमार प्यासा फिल्म में होते तो.... पत्ता नहीं क्या होता मगर गुरु दत्त साहब को प्यासा फिल्म में देखा तो अच्छा लगा हालांकि यह फिल्म मेरे जनम के पहेले की है जिसे मैंने दूरदर्शन पर देखी थी, और कुछ सालो बाद मैंने जब विडियो कैसेट की लायब्रेरी खोली थी तब यह फिल्म तकरीबन आठ से नव बार देखी है।
I heard Dilip Kumar himself saying....he has refused many movies and he regret for few movies which he refused Pyaasa was one among them....that itself says the story.
PYASA is quintessentially 'on poetry wings' carried movie- all of it Sahir Ludhianavi métier meat from start to end. I don't see how Dilip Kumar could have carried that 'Cross'. It is like Sahir himself insisting by the making of Phir Subah Hogi on Khayyam scoring the music for very express reasons known in the public domain. As such, Guru Dutt retains his natural actor credentials. Dilip K would compulsively have turned a 'staid' role into his styled histrionics 'hoopla' (some visible in Devdas scenes that substract from the raconteur gravitas). Besides, and so in all matters in life, destiny plays the Veto card. Hence PYASA- thank God- came on with Guru Dutt. The fine actor repeated his par excellence in Kagaz Ke Phool, leaving no doubt about his superiority in his chosen acting genre. PYASA, counted among the 100 world best, settles the argument for good.
Hello Satish Kumar Shukla... Thanks for writing to me.
Very well commented by you in detail on Pyaasa - GuruDutt Vs DilipK comparison.
I hope you are enjoying the videos on my channel. Do watch all the videos and comment when you want to say something. I will personally reply to you.
Thank you & Take Care,
Rahoul
U are awesome!
@@mehboobshaikh4293 thanks brother
All Dilip Kumar's loved actresses were taken away by other actors Nargis Waheeda
Guru Dutt ji . Among the finest actors of Indian cinema , Guru Dutt’ s name is very much there. Rahoul sb , your IQ is sharp and your presentation sharp too. The way you placed the most difficult Q to viewers , my God as if we are on the day of judgment ! No substitute for Dilipkumar. We know . And Guru Dutt made the history !
Satish Kumar Shukla g Defined it very well. Guru Dutt sahb was ahead of his time, One of the greatest filmmakers of Indian Cinema, But he was also such a good actor, the innocent Bhootnath, cartoonist Preetam, taxi driver Kalu, poet Vijay and famous film director Suresh...,He will forever live in our hearts ❤
Well said Aftab 👍 keep watching our UA-cam channel and commenting.
Thank God for Dilip Kumars refusal to play this role.Guru Dutt not only excelled but left behind a role only described as folklore.This has been one of my memorable movies to watch and everything just merged beautifully.Thank you bhai for this story.
🙏
ABSOLUTELY
Pyaasa is a master piece.I can't imagine anyone else in the role of Vijay except Guru Dutt.He was among greatest indian directors.But I think he under estimated himself as an actor.So he approached Dilip Kumar.Guru Dutt was an excellent actor undoubtedly.Aar paar,Mr & Mrs 55,Pyaasa,Kagaz ke phool,Chowdvin ka chand,Saheb bibi aur ghulam,Suhagan...in all those films he showed his class.
Ok
जो भी हुआ अच्छा हुआ । I can't imagine paysaa without Gurudatta ji. He is genius. It's all time Classic.
Agreed
Jo hua, achcha hi hua kya bura hua, Toot gaya jhutha aetbar, jab wo na rahe. I am glad Dilip Sahb did what he did. GuruDutt Sahb probably did not know his own potential.
Don't Imagine!
I think Gutudattaji has given full justice to the role in Pyasa,perhaps more than Dilip kumar.
ABSOLUTELY
Dilip was more over dramatic
Where guru dutt was balanced
Guru Dutt Already Played That Role Amazingly. So I Am Not Imagine Anything
👍
IT COULDN'T HAVEN BEEN BETTER THAN THE ICONIC FILM PYASA. GURU DUTT CAME OUT AS PERFECT CHOICE FOR THE HERO ROLE IN THE FILM. SOMETIMES NATURE TAKES CONTROL OF THINGS IN IT'S HANDS.
Legendary actor, director, producer, writer, dancer, Gurudutt ne pyaasa ko amar kar diya.👍He is the fittest for the pyaasa.
Hello Bhagwati Sharma... Thanks for writing to me. I hope you are enjoying the videos on my channel. Do watch all the videos and comment when you want to say something. I will personally reply to you.
Thank you & Take Care,
Rahoul
Thank God it was guru dutt .he fitted the role to the T. Guru dutt and pyaasa go together
Don’t even want to imagine, Pyaasa was an epic which couldn’t have been without Gurudutt. Sometimes intensity kills people. He was so intense in almost everything around that it suffocated him unknowingly. Gurudutt was way ahead of his time and born in a wrong era. Filmmaking can be learnt by just critically watching all his classics, though some of them weren’t commercially successful.
Can’t imagine anyone except Guru Dutt in Pyaasa. One of my top favorites of all time. Don’t think Bollywood can make such a classic ever again. Each time I watch it, I wonder how the cast and crew could make something so pitch perfect. My dad in his late 60s is a huge fan, I at 40 am a huge fan, and am sure my son when he grows up will be a big fan of this movie too.
Guru Dutt Saab🙏🙏
No one else, only Guru Dutt could justify that role. Guru Dutt was Guru Dutt. He had the vision how to direct the role and the movie. Guru Dutt has also directed the Super Star, The Dev Anand Saab. There was no other Super star in that era!
Thanks to Dilip Kumar for not doing this film! We got a masterpiece with the immortal performance by Guru Dutt. We cannot imagine anybody else in this role.
Gurudutt saheb himself was the best lead of Pyasa.None could have played that role better than him,It's my view.
🙏
Guru Dutt did 100 percent justification and what an amazing performance 👌👌👌
No doubt about it. Guru Dutt excelled in that role.
I watched this movie recently and loved it. Beautiful ending!
Phenomenal job by Guru Dutt Saab
THANKS RAHOUL JI... DILIP KUMAR WAS A LEGENDARY BUT, GURU DUTT SAHEB WAS A MASTER DIRECTOR... INFACT, DIRECTOR OF DIRECTOR'S OF CINEMA WORLD... U CAN NOT IMAGINE ANY ARTIST OF THE WORLD BETTER PERFORMING THAN GURU DUTT SAHEB ON SONG 'JANE WOH KAISE LOG THE JINKE PYAR KO PYAR MILA ' 💝💯
True about Guru Dutt Sahab 👍
Kia baat ! Siddhartha Desai ji.
The video is very comprehensive giving background of Pyaasa. It is no doubt that Dilip Kumar Sahab is tragedy King. But in this film Guru Dutt gets more than 100 marks . We cannot imagine anyone other than Gurudutt for Vijay Role. Distributors did a good role. Very good lucid video sir. 🙏👍
Thanks 🙏 Mr Subbarao
From Pak🕊 Dilip Kumar was the greatest but Guru Dutt Ji was also too good. Respect for both. RiP
Hey Yasmeen ... thanks for watching and writing to me... keep in touch!
After hearing this....whatever happens it happens for the good...Can't imagine anyone apart from gurudutt doing this role...jo hota hai ache ke liye hota hain....
Sahi kaha tha Dilip Saab ne.Devdas jaise hi milta julta character hota 👍🏻But Rahul Pyasa me Guru Dutt ji ka role bht appropriate lagta h.unhone iss film me apne character ko jiya h.I can't think anyone else in the place of Guru Dutt for the role of Vijay.
I agree with you.
गुरु दत्त ने प्यासा में विजय के कैरेक्टर को इतनी खूबसूरती से निभाया है कि यह फिल्म क्लासिक मानी जाती है। यह सोचने की जरूरत ही क्या है कि दिलीप कुमार होते तो क्या होता। गुरु दत्त का अभिनय दर्शकों को झकझोर देता है। वेरी वेल डन 👍👍👍👍👍
शानदार प्रस्तुतीकरण राहुल भाई 👍👍
I can't imagine Dilip saab in "Pyaasa". Guru Dutta saab was so perfect in this role. He was amazingly relatable in the role poet Vijay, none could fit in his shoes in this film.
Great insight about relationship of yesteryear stars Dilip Kumar and Guru Dutt
RIP Dilip Sahab
According to me whatever happened it is good. Guruduttji was perfect casting because we could see the pain of the character was perfactly
Brought out by Guruduttji
This is Guru Dutt's best film ever, as a Director and Actor.Had Dilip Kumar worked in it we would have missed Guru Dutt's histrionic ability which was confined only to crime flicks till then.Dilip Kumar would have given his same old style of acting of which public was familiar with.Fortunately he didn't turn up and we came to know about The Great Guru Dutt.What Guru Dutt gave to Indian Cinema is his short span of life of 39 years Dilip took 70 active years to reach the pinnacle of Indian Cinema
Thanks Prakash for watching the video and commenting 🙏
Guru Dutt nailed it, the movie was made in the best possible manner.
I have watched Pyasa...Guru Dutt was definitely way ahead of his time...his movies speak for it...Guru Dutt movies are always counted among the premier ones among the Indian Cinemas...and Guru Dutt's acting as well direction has always created history...So Pyasa is another example of it.
May be Dilip Sahaab would have done it in his own way.Again Guru Dutt was no less.
LEGEND of bollywood: MARHOOM: GURU DUTT saab 🙏
Great Producer, Director, Actor 🙏
🙏
Don't think Dilip saab would hve done this effectively ...Guru Dutt ji was absolutely suited... thank the Providence for it
Thanks for watching the video and commenting
Rahoul ji,
In 2005, when my Dad (late now) came to live with me in Toronto, Canada after he retired. One fine evening he wanted to watch an old movie. Fortunately, I have a nice library. I asked my father, what movie he would like to see, so we can go, get it. He said hesitating, can we go to video store and get "Pyaasa". I was overwhelmed because I had that. That evening both of us watched it together in one sitting . I did not tell my father that I have already watched that before and knew everything about that movie and that I was a big fan of Guru Dutt ji. I did not want to break the excitement and joy of my father, who was so happy and so emotional at the same time. He was watching that movie years after since he was in University. In between he kept telling me about movie and Dutt Sahb. I very well acted and pretended that I bought it but still was looking for opportunity to watch it. Your video took me in the past.
Thank you so very much Rahoul ji.
Beautiful story 👌
@@70mmwithRahoul Thank you, Rahoul ji.
Excellent performance and unforgettable role by Gurudutt Sahab in milestone movie Pyassa
Hello Amita Tare... Thanks for writing to me. I hope you are enjoying the videos on my channel. Do watch all the videos and comment when you want to say something. I will personally reply to you.
Thank you & Take Care,
Rahoul
Thanks Sir
Guru Dutt was known to me as an actor of PYAASA
No other actor could have made justice to the roll.
Guru dutt was a great actor. I understand halwai doesn't enjoy sweets he make. Maybe gurudutt was thinking dilip kumar could play the character better. But like they say "destiny has better plans". And we got an icon!
Dilip Kumar's loss is Guru Dutt's gain ! The moment one mentions Pyaasa, Guru Dutt comes to mind and noone else 💐
Guru Datt was the appropriate actor for film piyasa. The end scene was superb. The songs written by sahir sahib too good .thanks for uploading the video.
Guru Dutt did excellent and made this film a legend. Thank you again for sharing this information so nicely ❤️👌👌👍🎉
Gurudutt Saheb's role was perfect in Pyasa
Wonderful. A very fascinating story on PYAASA.
It’s a blessing in disguise for Guru Dutt that Dilip Kumar never came for the Muhurat. I have a strong inkling that this film would have remained unfinished if he had acted in the first few days of shooting. Guru Dutt would not have tolerated his interference. Dilip Kumar had this penchant to interfere in every film (after Aan & Andaz) as per his whims.
Finally it was Abrar Alvi, Guruswamy, Sahir and others who advised Guru Dutt, not to wait for Dilip Kumar and you yourself continue with it.
There are a few other stories also, pertaining to this.
Thank you very much Rahoul.
B.S. Narayanaswamy
Welcome 🙏
i cannot imagine how the movie would have fare with Dilip Kumar. Also Pyasa without
Guru Dutt. Genius shone in the Movie not only as an actor but in many respects.
Sir i have read different stories regarding Pyaasa Movie. This story was published in The Illustrated Weekly Of India under the title "The Thirsty man" a long time ago before the making of movie "Pyaasa". Mr Guru Dutt wrote this story before joining the Film Industry. I also read Dilip Kumar could not work in this movie because of the dispute between Madhubala and Vijayantimala regarding their role in the movie. The both actresses wanted to play the role of one character and i think that was the character of Gulabo. When it was not settled between the actresses then Dilip Kumar also did not work in the movie. Later on Mala Sinha and Waheeda Rehman worked in the movie.
Being Ardent fan of Mr Guru Dutt i am very much happy to see him in the lead role. For me he was the best in this role.
I’m sure some of the stories were true… thanks for watching the video and commenting 🙏
i guess you are talking about saahib bibi aur ghulam and not pyaasa
Guru Dutt is only perfect ❤️
Great condolences to Mr Dilip Kumar. RIP. 🙏 Only when you have a vision for tomorrow, you will find power and purpose in your today's work.. we always love watching your video. 👍😀
Thanks 🙏 RIP Dilip Sahab
Pyasa was a great film, I m big fan of Gurudatt films
I can’t imagine any other actor then The Great Gurudatt. Not even Dilip Kumar. In Piyasa. I am a big admirer of Grudatt as Director as Actor his style. Just as he was.
My all time favorite guru dutt sahab 🙏🙏🙏🤗
Thanks for watching the video. Pls watch other videos also of our channel.
Gurudutt looked better in Pyasa it has a poetic look.
Dilip Kumar would have also looked ok ok !!
Cant compare .
In retrospect, Pyaasa was a block buster and popular for decades.
It was a big saving of money to Gurudutt and Dilip Kumar had nothing to lose, as he was already a busy star.
We cant imagine what would have happened after 60 years
Good that Guru Dutt did the film.It was a classic movie and look how it became so good with Guru Dutt as the lead actor.
Guru Dutt was perfect in his role as Vujay in film Pyasa
अच्छा हुआ दिलीप कुमार जी ने यह रोल नही किया, नहीं तो गुरुदत्त जी के अंदर जो प्यासा छुपा हुआ था वोह हमें देखने को नही मिलता।उस प्यासे की परिणति, हमें कागज़ के फूल के रूप में देखने को मिली।
ok
Gurudutt was a great director
No doubt about it... Thanks for watching the video
Guru dutt perfect roll I have seen
Ok 👍
No Rahoul ji..I just can't imagine anyone else singing
*Ye duniya agar mil bhi jaye to kya hai*and playing the role of Vijay in Pyasa except for Guru Dutt ji ...our misfortune to have lost such a legend so soon...wish could have witnessed more Indian cinema like Pyasa on our silver screen....
Guru Dutt Saab ko aur unke soch ko mera sat sat naman🙏🙏🙏
Gurudutt did an amazing job! Cant think of anyone else! What a legend! Dont think Dilip Kumar could hv done better. What use is ego with talent, if he wasnt decent.
👌
Dalip Kumar jee is the Mahan actor, UN ka koi mukabla nahi ho sakta
agar dilip kumar ne pyasa ki hoti to logo ko usmein bhi devdas hi nazar aata aur pyasa ka jo actor chahiye tha jiski nayi aur fresh image ho woh nahi mil pata , isliye baiju bawra , devdas aur pyasa teeno ke liye first time new aur fresh image wale hi actor chiye thay , pyasa ko guru dutt aek naye dimesions par le gaye jo sochne se bhi kahi zyada tha , sirf dark character hi nahi tha woh usmein aek philosopher bhi chaiye tha , poet bhi chaiye tha , aur dilip kumar karte to fir devdas usmein mix or cross to hota hi , isliye guru dutt ne aisa amar role kiya ki pyasa is now a part of film making's text book in various foreign universities like france & uk , such a great honour for bollywood given by gurudutt ji .
Things that are happened are perfect
Guru Dutt in Pyass is ultimate and if something that we can imagin that who can replace Guru Dutt betterly, but perfect things can not be replaced
👍
Guru Dutt really played this role fantastical and he suited this role perfectly well. We are glad that Dilip Kumar did not play this role. This turned out to be one of Guru Duty's best played role and he really looked adorable in this movie. Only if he had lived longer and gi en is many more of such amazing movies!
gurudat perfom very good. And you have to move on , new talent will get chance. gadi kiseke liya rukti NAHI . WELL DONE GURU DAT SAHEB HATS OF FOR YOUR DESION.
Ok
Gurudutt has done well. He is the best Director of Indian films. There are only two legendary producers/ directors in Indian films. They are Raj kapoor & Guru Dutt.
right
So sad, neither Dalip lived up to words, nor couraged to refuse.
It was destined.
Guru played the character to perfection. Perhaps the actor in him matched the director.
It's very good that Dilip Kumar has not played the role. It's someone else destiny.
This is how legends are made by grace of GOD. Dilip ji Played a trick n refuse. Dutt ji created a legendary masterpiece himself. Great Channel.
No director till date has touched the shadow of guru dutt
CLISSIC of the CLASSICS. One of the world's finest movies.
Who knows Dilip sahab could have taken this film to even greater heights، he was more accomplshed actor،no offences meant for dutt sahab I'm a great admirer of his،but even he realised that Dilip kumar suited most for this role،this was his kind of role، ofcource this proved Dilip Kumar's greatest miss۔
It is not a surprising, at least to me, that Dilip Kumar did not do Pyasa. Dilip would not do any movie with a talented director who is also a good actor so that he will not allow Dilipsab to interfere in director's domain. Guru Dutt was a good director and a good actor too.
Another example is that of raj Kapoor who wanted dilip Kumar to play any role (Gopal or Sundar) of his choice in Sangam. Dilip insisted that Raj should refrain from directing the film and someone else should direct this film.
Who will accept this condition? Raj Kapoor? Impossible. And that's what happened also.
yes... you're right. DK didn't want RK to direct Sangam.
आपकी जानकारी बहुत ही अच्छी और सच्ची खबर रहती हैं
Shukriya janaab
Noone else could play this role better than Guru dutt Sahab
Only Guru Dutt ji could do justice to the role..not Dilip Kumar ji.
Thank God Guru Dutt ji acted in the movie in the lead role.
Will comment more later tomortow or day after.
Have been watching many of your vdos since few days..with rapt attention.
You speak ...present so well Rahoul...waah
Guru Dutt Is Officially Considered As One Of The Best Director & His Films Are Some Of The Best Films Of World.
प्यासा मे दिलीप कुमार होते तो फ़िल्म गज़ब की होती और इतिहास रच देती।उस समय दिलीप साहब को उनके डाक्टर ने ऐसे दुःखी रोल करने से मना कर दिया था और दिलीप कुमार कामेडी और दूसरे रोल कर रहे थे।
👍
Dilip was a jerk. Not many people knew about it. Nobody missed him as GD did the role so very well.
Thank you for your report.
Believe me I saw this film with my mom about 40 years back & am sure dilip Kumar may be a actor pat excellence but gurudutt was superb as an actor & director both his camera always works on facial close up where expressions play great role no one can match him
Dilip kumar hote to bhi ek classic hi rehati ye film...gurudatt and dilip sahab both are legends 🙏
Good one. It sounds a little anti dilip kumar, although both the actors were great in their own right. I am an ardent Dilip kumar fan.
Dilip kumar agar vijay ka role karte toh pyaasa phir pyaasa nahi reh jaati ...gurudatt ne is role ko isliye amar bana paaye kyunki woh khud pyaase the.
Very well said Ashwani 👍 . Hamare channel ke baaki videos bhi dekhna!
Guru Dutt Sahab was great in the movie
गुरुदत्त गुरुदत्त है ,उनने जो प्यासा में अभिनय किया प्रशंसनीय है और रहेगा। धन्यवाद् //जयहिंद जयभारत //
Thanks Rahoul for this great Content. Would be grateful if you could name the sources for the conversation between Dilip Kumar sb and Guru Dutt jee. Both were great personalities. Dilip Kumar also had unusual methods to motivate people to do something or to make them aware of their actual potential.
Abrar Alvi’s interview in an old journal… he was GD s close buddy and director of Sahib Biwi aur Ghulam
@@70mmwithRahoulthanks for this Information🏆🏆🏆. It's meant friendly and with big respect to your great commitment (and all the efforts you do). If possible, than kindly mention in your next Videos your source too. This Step will make
a) your content unique than the others in UA-cam
b) it would be easier to trust your content more when you show the source by your own
c) that might be a bit more work, but you will reach a higher class with your videos.
Especially people out of India / Asia would appreciate and value this a lot.
Thanks Bro 😉👍🏆
@@ChangeStartsNowWithAhsanSaleem Thanks Ahsan... Guess you are right... will reveal about my background in the Rafi special on 31 July... watch ... watch... watch.. btw where are u based?
@@ChangeStartsNowWithAhsanSaleem regarding point 3... it won't be extra work actually because none of my content is hearsay... everything that i speak is based on a written documented source... will definitely start to mention wherever i can... in fact watch my DK-Madhubala episode today... will give my source ;)
Dilip kumar was not allowed to play any more depressing movies because he was under anti depression treatment ...We should not try to underestimate a legend after he is no more .This could have been said when Dilip kumar was alive or would not have bothered ...He was not aware to this world. for nearly 8 yrs ...Have some respect to the departed SOULS 🙏🏻
Dilip kumar is first super star
Dilip kumar is the greatest actor Bollywood ever had . Guru dutt is one of the best actor and director who started golden generation of Indian cinema . However there are differences in acting style . Dilip sahabs personality as a tragic rich and upper middle class lover who can argue and gives reply with other person ( quite talkative personality) not extrovert. However guru dutts character in movies depict a less talkative man who talks with his expression rather than dialogues . He depicts a talented underrated middle class personality in movies who is not getting appreciation and recognition in society.
Guru dutt is perfect for Vijay in pyasa it depicts a person who failed in everything .
1: career
2: love
3: finance
However Dilip sahabs character devdas failed in love only . Devdas is a rich guy with good zamindari career and wealth .
So according to my opinion pyasa is more challenging role and difficult role to play . So guru dutt made justice in playing the role of Vijay .
Ye role sirf Guru Dutt ji kar sakte they Un ki aankhen bolti thin Nasheeli aawaz jaadu kar deti thi
Hello Anupama Kumar... Thanks for writing to me. I hope you are enjoying the videos on my channel. Do watch all the videos and comment when you want to say something. I will personally reply to you.
Thank you & Take Care,
Rahoul
Guru dutt made vijay of pyasa immortal
He was out standing
Thanks for watching the video!
Legendary Dilip Kumar sahab. RIP 🙏
Thank you for this video 👍
RIP Dilip Sahab
I couldn’t picture Dilip Kumar in Pyaasa. I think Guru Dutt fitted quite well!
RIP Dilip Saab 🙏🙏 Nice Video👌👌👍👍
RIP Dilip Sahab
Piyasa फिल्म नाकाम हो जाति
@@parvinparvin6236 ok
Agar dilip kumar sahab hote to bhi ye film utni hi hit hoti
Really appreciate on this day yaad karna the legend dilip ji that's shows passion for work of your so take care 🙏
Ok Motu
Thank God...whatever may be the reason...Dilip sab didn't do Pyasa..Gurudutt ji...real Vijay!!
thank you for sharing this Rahul ji...
Wow nice story i heard. Very nice.
Thank you! 🙂
दिलीप कुमार के मुकाबले गुरु दत्त जी ने कम फिल्मों में अभिनय किया है,लेकिन जितना किया है उत्कृष्ट हैं, सो प्यासा में गुरु दत्त जी फिट बैठे।
Just excellent !!!
Guru dutt saheb only man who deserve was pyaasa role but Don't forget Dilip saheb institution of Indian cinema 🙏
👍
अगर दिलीप कुमार प्यासा फिल्म में होते तो.... पत्ता नहीं क्या होता मगर गुरु दत्त साहब को प्यासा फिल्म में देखा तो अच्छा लगा हालांकि यह फिल्म मेरे जनम के पहेले की है जिसे मैंने दूरदर्शन पर देखी थी, और कुछ सालो बाद मैंने जब विडियो कैसेट की लायब्रेरी खोली थी तब यह फिल्म तकरीबन आठ से नव बार देखी है।
Hi
I feel aap camera thoda dur rakhiye... And zoom in zoom out kum kijiye... Its just i feel...hence .... Nice videos 👍👍👍👍
I heard Dilip Kumar himself saying....he has refused many movies and he regret for few movies which he refused Pyaasa was one among them....that itself says the story.