BEST HARDSHELL CARRY-ON | Rimowa * Tumi * Quince * Monos * July * Level8 * Béis (left to right)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 тра 2024
- Find out which of these 7 suitcases, ranging from $120 to almost $1000, will be the winner?
We all have different preferences, so I hope you can use this video to get the data points you need to decide what's right for you.
Carry-on Comparison Excel: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/...
Samsonite: www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...
Quince: www.quince.com/unisex/small-c...
Level8: www.level8cases.com/collectio...
Béis: beistravel.com/products/the-c...
Monos: monos.com/collections/carry-o...
July: july.com/us/luggage/carry-on-...
Tumi: www.macys.com/shop/product/19...
Rimowa: www.bloomingdales.com/shop/pr...
Rakuten Link: www.rakuten.com/r/JINGBR2?eeid=28187
Timestamp ⏱
0:00 Intro
0:21 Comparison Rules
1:26 Baseline: Samsonite
2:57 Quince
8:43 Level 8
13:37 Béis
14:11 Rakuten
18:48 Monos
22:50 July
27:08 Tumi
31:06 Rimowa
35:30 Summary
39:44 The Overall Winner
40:55 The Budget Winner
News Theme by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. creativecommons.org/licenses/...
Artist: incompetech.com/
![Top 5: Best Carry-On Luggages 2024 [don't buy one before watching this]](/img/n.gif)
There’s nothing like a super detailed excel spreadsheet that satisfies my OCD LOL. Thank you for being so thorough!
missing the most important detail of all. what are they made of? polycarbonate, abs or aluminum.
@@rong9090mentioned at the beginning of the video, polycarbonate
One of the best, if not the best, luggage carry-on review videos i've seen 👏
We replaced our 20+ year old Samsonite and Tumi with CalPak (purchased at TJMaxx) and had no issues traveling internationally - 5 flights, 1.4 km run through airport to make connecting flight, through public transportation and across 4 blocks of cobblestone streets. Wheels look like new and no scratches on outside. While I don't expect to have the CalPaks for 20 years and it certainly is not as luxurious as a Tumi, it has worked for both myself and my teen during this stage of our lives. Appreciate your reviews, very informative.
Thank you for this detailed review. The carpet and handle tests came in clutch, helping me make my decision. Thanks again!
Seriously the best review. I appreciate your thoroughness! Really saved me time looking around.
Wow one of the best detailed reviews of carryons. Great video
Ah-mazing review! I love your attention to detail! July wasn't on my radar, but now it definitely is!!
Wonderfully detailed review and you pointed out certain features or flaws that I wouldn't have thought of. Thank You!!!
Wow this is the best review I’ve ever seen and I’ve been looking for. I never comment but I was so impressed 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Thank you for such a detailed review and all the work to put this together!
Thank you for all the time and effort you put into this review. It was so informative and helpful!
You put so much work into this I really felt like you deserved a subscribe!!! ❤❤❤ well done and thank you for all that work!!
AWESOME review! I have tried most of these and you were spot on! The Spreadsheet was EVERYTHING!
Easily the most helpful, comprehensive review👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 thank you! I so appreciate the spreadsheet, too!
This video was so thorough. Thank you for this!
Thank you for this great and very thorough comparison video!
Great review! FYI most large dents in polycarbonate luggage corners can just be pushed out from the inside with little to no evidence of the previous damage. That's the great thing about the material; It is very flexible and absorbs the energy from impact without cracking. So when you see a dented corner consider it a "good" thing vs a piece of luggage made of lesser plastic that instead cracked and can't be easily repaired.
I saw the tons of luggage coparison videos. Clearly, you are the best for sure!
Terrific, thorough review. It has helped me make a decision so thanks!
Thank you for this detailed review. I've been on the look out for a new carry-on and this is so helpful!
I’m glad! Thank you!
Thank you for this thorough and thoughtful review!
Thank you! such a detailed video that narrows down a lot of options.
Debating between the Rimowa essential and hybrid atm
WOW Amazing, great work! I've got a MONO's Medium right now (served me well) and was curious about the (regular) carry on, thanks for the comparisons. I'm now looking into the July based on your amazing breakdown. Thank you
Ahh a spreadsheet. A girl after my own heart. Thanks for doing the legwork!
This is very good review.. Rarely found test on the rugged floor... Good job... Thank you ❤
Great comparison, details are often overlooked but so important!
Thank you for such a detailed review. Outstanding!
I think this is the best luggage review ive ever seen. I'm traveling a lot more than I used to and im looking for a good carry on as my cheap one always gets stuck even on smooth surfaces. I think thats the most important part for me.
This is amazing. I was gonna buy a Beis carry-on but decided not to after watching your detailed review. Thanks so much!
Wow i rarely comment but this review was super thorough and helpful. Looking forward to your July light carry review!
Like you said a very detailed video. Nice I am shopping for a new suitcase. Thank you for the review.
For those wondering why she didnt include away and calpak she mentioned in beginning of vid : she only kept the brands she was interested in purchasing. In the comments she says away and calpak have durability concerns and other reviewers have mentioned as much. I personally have a Monos carryon and love it, I chose it over away based on price and quality. From what I can gather in the 2-300$ weight class July > Monos > Beis > Away, in the Money aint a thing class Rimowa > everyone, as a consolation I think Calpak is the best budget bag - has the aesthetic of the better brands while quality is not much worse or better of those in that 100-200$ range.
I saw a detailed review of Monos and it sounds like it is constructed better than Away.
Thanks for the additional info!
I’ve had a calpak since 2018, it’s gone through multiple trips to Europe and US, and it’s still holding strong.
I love this video, very detailed review and informative. As someone that is looking for new luggage’s to travel. This video helps me choose which brand and model to buy. Thank you
Fantastic comparison! Thank you!
Thank you for the super in depth review!
Good job with these review, appreciate it 👍🏼
this is EXACTLY what I've been looking for, thank you so much for making this vid✨🥲
I’m in Vancouver Canada and went to the Mono store. Salesperson told me Mono is a Canadian company and produces made in China. They also said their suitcases are life time warranty.
Great review! Got my daughters the Beis luggage for their weddings but mostly because they already had the mini weekender and accessories and they loved the style.
That’s awesome! They are very beautiful luggages.
great video! wish I saw this before I bought a quince and monos to compare myself. Going to keep the monos and returning the quince.
This is a great video. Very helpful. Thanks!
I really appreciate that you got the July carry on essential and showed the internal bumpers, i had been wondering what they meant by that on the website and i finally got it when i saw those blobs of plastic. Bought it!
This was definitely the best luggage revenue video I’ve seen yet, and I’ve been watching a lot, lol. Would you consider doing a video analyzing suitcases that are zipper free? They’re supposed to be safer but are harder to find.
you may have few subs,but since you are so new I believe you will grow fast as your vid is concise and clear. I have seen it bwfore with new youtubers. well done.
I love my monos carry-on! Dropped it at DFW top of stairs n made it like a champ!
ok this is the spreadsheet and video that i wish existed when i was looking for a suitcase summer 2022! i ended up going with july (classic carry on - before the essential came out) and have traveled over 20 trips with it. on my most recent trip, i checked the suitcase and the plastic cracked at the corner of the external bumpers but i reached out for warranty replacement and it was a really smooth process! (we also bought a calpak at the same time and the july wheels + telescoping handle are SUCH a night and day difference).
i've been trying to keep longevity/durability documentation on instagram but i've fallen a little behind on keeping up :)
This is soooo helpful!! Nice job
I really appreciate the time spent on making this high quality comprehensive video, I recently got introduced to the world of 'Carry on only' through the UA-cam algorithms as ive transitioned into minimalism and am currently in the market for a case to travel light, you've helped me narrow it down. given the approach and attention to detail in your review, this should have a lot more views, i'm excited to see the coming growth of the channel and your brand, keep it up 🥂
Thank you so much for this!
I’ve had the Monos Carry On Plus for a little over a year now and although it’s most expensive luggage I’ve ever owned it’s worth every penny. I’ve been on 5 trips with it and it’s held up perfectly. The wheels are super smooth, the handle is solid and overall it’s a very high quality product. After 5 trips including being checked in and hauled in the bed of a pickup truck it only has a few scratches on it. Don’t mind that since it shows it’s traveled rather spending its life in a closet.
This is what I’m leaning towards. ❤
The best review on UA-cam. Thank you for your investments and hope they have you as suitcase ambassador. 🍾🎊🎉🥳❤️🔥
Watched every minute! My checked bag was damaged on a recent trip after hilding up to dozens of domestic and international flights. WAITING TO EXHALE when you launch your July Checked bag review!! Until then, Im just going to travel with carry on only 😊. Thx in advance! Great job!
Like the super-duper details 😂🤣😂 got to archive this video. Lol! Thanks for the info & for the laughs I got from the comments here 👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I really appreciate your through review. You are doing the Lord's work
Great review ❤. Thank you 👏
First of all, I love this video so much! What an investment of time and money, and I love the charts and detailed data. I do wish SO MUCH you'd include a current version of Away in the comparisons. They've listened to feedback (I read) and improved various things. But to the point for me, I've used Away, and having that comparison would be so very helpful. I've liked your video on 2 places, and I'll subcribe so I won't miss your great content. Best to you!
Finally, I don’t have to watch anymore carryon luggage videos 😂😂 Your incredibly informative video has helped me make a decision. THANK YOU!!!
Great review! I’ve been enjoying my Monos luggage for a few years now. I really like the look of the Tumi and Rimowa but those prices are insane lol
I just bought a Pelican 1510 for my carry on - it's indestructible. loved you well thought out review. thanks.
12 lbs for a carry on?
Such a throughly detailed video!! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Thank you soo much for your feedback!
Great video, thank you for making this
This is an excellent review using both quantitative and qualitative attributes. While I don’t agree with the overall assessment given the data provided the end results make total sense. Again, excellent review!!
Never heard of July…but I’m sold! Thanks!
What a great video. Happy New Year.
This is my favorite UA-cam video so far! Thank you for sharing!
Start with 22 by 14 by 9. Use 21.5 by 15.5 by 9 for international carriers. Nothing worse than being told your “carry on” is too large, no matter how nicely it rolls on carpet.
Looking for a carry on luggage I have to thank you for the dedication, efforts and details you put into into this review., everything was very helpful. Wish you the best !
Best review I’ve seen!
Another vote for monos here. I have the terrazzo pro plus carry-on & the check in medium. People have stopped me in my tracks to tell me they like my bag. The carry-on has held up to several intl trips including 17 days in NZ being checked multiple times & hauled in vans and busses. I've had things spilled in it, drug it over rough terrain and it still looks great. They were expensive but I have no regrets. Only issue I have is when the suitcase is stuffed you can't lift the handle.
Got the level 8 a couple of years ago on sale. 7 trips later (no check ins), it looks and maneuvers like new. Very happy with it.
Thanks
This is really helpful
Thanks for the video!
If you ever do another one of these, it'd be great to see the Lojel Cubo included. It has a cool front opening design that gives more flexibility in how you pack and needs less space to open; great for cramped hotel rooms... the reason I'd like to see an in-depth review (as you do them) is the carry on isn't the biggest on paper, so I'm curious how it would stack up in usable capacity... IMO, this design is a a game changer for the larger sizes though.
Good review. Thanks !!!! 🙏
this is legit the most informative and satisfying review video ive watched. incredible
Your review was excellent and detailed !!!! I hope your next review of luggages you mention if the Zippers are Water Repellent /Water Resistant, Water proof and Puncture resistant??? You have made luggage shopping a lot more easier for consumers like myself. Please continue the Excellant job you do and include other name Brands. 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽!!!!!!!!
I just bought my July Carry-On because of this video. The quality seems like something that will last and they have some of the coolest colors! I think I watched this video 4 times at different sections before finally choosing July over Monos & level 8
Just started watching and I liked & subscribed.
Nice detailed review. I’ve had Tumi for years then switched to Rimowa, but I have a Made in Germany Aluminum one. I’m not sure why anyone would pay nearly $1000 for a plastic Rimowa. It’s gotta be aluminum.
My carry on is MVST. It is aluminum and looks outstanding. Zipperles. Two TSA locks. Rubber seals. A bit heavier than plastic. Roomy. Lifetime warranty. I could not be happier with it.
I have the older (2007), latch version of your samsonite in 20" and 25". They have served me very well but the carryon was showing its age and it was time to replace it. I refuse to use a zip bag, I will only use a latch case. That made it harder as very few makers use latches now. I got an aluminum level8 this year, which I snapped up on a great sale, and I'm really satisfied with it. It came with a set of packing cubes and a dustbag.
Love the excel sheet! Can you share why you didn’t include Calpak and Away in your testing?
If you’re looking for the smaller sizes for yourself, I would suggest looking at the July Carry On Light Expandable that you mentioned and the regular Monos Carry-On.
My most recent luggage purchase was a Calpak Ambeur and have been super happy with it. I got it during their Black Friday sale for around $150 plus I got cash back from Rakuten. I was specifically looking for an affordable bag that I could roll on 4 wheels to easily carry my dog in his carrier when I travel. My husband and I usually pack for as long as a week in the Samsonite; I don't think we would be able to do that with the Calpak. We've been able to pack for long weekends fine, though. When I'm looking to upgrade my checked bags or get something more luxurious, I won't go with Calpak. I'll look at July or Monos. But, this has been great for short trips and for the ease of rolling my dog through the airport. This is well worth the $150 for me. I also got their compression cubes and they are so much nicer feeling than the ones I had from Amazon. I only got the large ones and they don't fit well in this suitcase but I'll definitely get the medium and small ones the next time they're on sale.
I can't wait for round 2 of the review to see what you actually got!
Wife and i have Rimowas.. we love them...c we have the bybrid ones... ploy exterior wh aluminum accents/corners... beautiful
Bravo! Patient and dedicated-I appreciate your input-In fact, My son, my partner, and me (mostly) own some version of each one of these carry-ons except Rimowa-I am travelling in Europe and I love my monos carry on trunk for eastern Europe trips which include boat, small airplanes, and long train rides.
Amei todas as bolsas lindas e de muito bom gosto.Parabens *yutulux* 😘😘😘
Wow, thank you for this review, I'm looking for a new luggage set. Good luck with your channel and I subbed. I'll let you know which brand I go with.
Thanks for taking one for the team and making this super informative video! It's definitely helped me in narrowing down my choices for a carry-on luggage. I was wondering if you could shed some light on why you decided not to include Away in your comparison? I am actually stuck deciding between the Away Carry On or the July Carry On Essential right now and would like some insight on why you ended up not wanting to review the Away case?
Thank you for the awesome video! I’m small as well so your review with weight and lift assistance helps😅!
Very thoughtful and organized review, well done. Like and sub.. thank you.
This is a really great comparison video! I am also looking for a good international carry-on. Are you going to get the July Carry On Light regular or expandable?
Amazing video!
Hopefully in a future video you can add Briggs and Riley for hard cases their Torq or for soft the ZDX. As they offer one of the best guarantees in the business.
Briggs and Riley is amazing! They are one of the ones I trust the claim of “life time warranty!” I want to check them out soon!
Amazing luggage review. I'm looking for a new carry on and was between July & Rimowa.
Oooh interesting & informative. I was hoping you would compare Herschel luggage too.
I was considering July checked luggage & this helped me decide. I wish you had ranked fit for all of the bags, even the ones that were too big for your needs since you provided all other details already. I travel frequently for work & use the BÉIS carry on … the squishy handle is my favorite part 😂 It’s so comfortable when I’m dragging my suitcase all over the place.
Haha! I totally get it! We all have different personal preferences 😆
I didn’t rank them because it wouldn’t be a fair comparison. Beis and Monos Carry On Plus are not standard sized and will obviously fit more. But between the two, Monos fits more than Beis, and it is lighter!
Amazing, thorough review - so well done, thanks!! I am curious why you didn't include AWAY? That's probably the first brand I'm considering given its popularity so now I'm really interested how that one would stack up to your detailed criteria.
FWIW - I ordered a Monos Hybrid Carry-on Plus on sale. It is smaller inside, considerably heavier and equally if not moreso prone to scuffs and scratches compared to their Classic Carry-on Plus that I already own. Out of the box, I received a scuffed up Monos Hybrid Carry-on Plus. I emailed their laggy customer service team and despite the unsatisfactory product delivery, they impose a $45 return shipping fee on the customer. Poor customer service. I do like their Classic carry-on plus though, just wait for a 15-30% off sale which happens every so many weeks/months.
I do have level 8 and it is fantastic!!!
I’ve had my Away larger carry-on for a few years now and I love it. I just got back from a month and 1/2 trip that took me SFO -> Singapore -> CGY Philippines -> Boracay Philippines-> Coron Philippines-> Manila -> Singapore -> Barcelona -> Madrid -> Seville -> Malaga -> Granada -> Barcelona -> Zurich -> SFO and it held up like a champ. And prior to that I was in Kyushu Japan that took me through the north (Fukuoka), east (Oita and Beppu), and west side(Nagasaki) of Kyushu. Prior to that, I did a trip through Berlin, Budapest, and Czech Republic. And earlier that year I did a trip around northern Vietnam Hanoi ->Ha Long Bay -> Ninh Binh.
I’ve been on every surface from the cobbled stone of Europe, to some of the undeveloped dirt paths of Philippines and Vietnam, stairs of Japanese train stations - used many different forms of transportation from speed boats, small propeller planes, tuk tuks, jeepneys, busses, vans, trains, etc, and I’ve never had a problem. Wheels are still smooth, the shell is in great condition (aside from the scuffs), zippers still zip and have had no issues at all. Would recommend it!
I have had my Away larger carryon for 7 years and absolutely love it!! It is still like new!!
I ended up going with July for all the reasons you listed, but what really sold me was the life time warranty. I reached out to July via instagram and asked I specifically if the warranty covers my bag if the airline damages it and they responded with “ yes it’s covered no matter who damages it”. I got the carry on and checked plus. Lol
That’s good to know! Thanks for sharing.
I'm purchasing luggage right now. (major$) I hear complaints July too heavy. Your opinion. I like July trunk, no zipper. I'm traveling from MI to Ecuador. Tks. Truly appreciate.
@@BPe-ie9je the trunks are heavy. If weight is a concern I’d look at the “light” line.
I just was trying to figure out what luggage to use for a trip next year that includes multiple airlines, some of which have strict size and weight limitations. Since I own a bag that is around the same weight as the Quince carry on, and meets the size limitations of Singapore Airlines, I am just going to purchase one of the Quince check in bags to use. Singapore Airlines has a small size limitation for the personal item, stricter than the other airlines I’ll probably be booking flights on. I’ll just pack my Biaggi Runway Hardside hybrid carry on, and weigh it to make sure it doesn’t go over the 15 pound limit packed. I’ll be gone almost 40 days and will definitely be washing my clothes along the way.
The extended warranty does not cover any defects caused by improper use, cases that were bought second hand or without proof of purchase directly from July and cosmetic damages
Informative video review and as an Excel geek I love the spreadsheet you created for this review. I am a BIg fan of Tumi and I have never had any issues with them and you forgot to cover the Warranty. TUMI will repair any product you buy for up to 10 years and yes, the handles are flimsy, and I did break one, but they fixed it within a few days and now it is as good as new again. BTW Samsonite now owns Tumi. Thanks for showing us the other options out there.
Samsonite owns Hartmann now, too, which means no more "Made in USA" bragging rights.