Pakistanis se Bharat ka koi bhi relations nahin chahiye, woh alag hai aur ham alag, Aaj kal ki generations ko Pakistani yo ko yaad nhi karte hai. Pakistanis se koi cultural, social, trade, economic relations nahin chahiye. Bharat unko bhula hai, yaad nhi karte hai.
I STRONGLY DISAGREE WITH ARVIND JI: South, East & North Indian culture is different from Pak. Only West Indian culture has some similarity eg; Bihar, UP, Rajasthan, Punjab. The similarity is only in language...not in clothing, food habits religion, culture. Culture of Sikhs, Maithli-Bhojpuri traditions, Gujrati-Marwadi cultural values are entirely different. We have a different mindset. You cannot compare culture of east india, assam, nagas, msnipur with Pak. You cannot compare culture of south india; tamil, kannad, keral with Pak. Why should we open our heart & mind for Pak ? By exchange of trade & friendship with Pak why should we risk our life & liberty. Philistine, Arabs also have cultural, religious, historical & other similarities. What Hams did with jew women & children ? What has happened to us in Kasmir ? Learning from History & recent past & current situation also; Why should we risk our life & liberty of our women ? Russians have many similsrities with europe & USA. Both are christns. Chinese, mongols, koreans, japan have many similarities. Why are they different countries? As an Indian i donot want any relationship with Pak & Bang. I have my right to live life peacefully and safety of family is PARAMOUNT. Please keep your fancy ideas to yourself. I respectfully return your ideas. Possibility of reform in islame is 0% and it cannot be modern. They want to live 1400 yrs back. We are looking into future, why to carry their baggage ? Arbind ji I am your big fan....but no friendship with shantidoots.
I can't believe Mr Bashani tried to avoid the crux of the problem😂 The reason of animosity is religious based which comes out of quran. But the reason it errupted during 1920s is ..before brits it was muslim rulers so converted muslims some how felt compensated ..with brits ruling and leaving India muslims wanted to take back what was never theirs ...hence the conflict
प्रत्येक हिंदू घर में बच्चों को यह विश्वास दिलाया जाता है कि सभी धर्म एक जैसे हैं और हर धर्म हर प्राणी के लिए प्रेम, सद्भाव और सम्मान सिखाता है। एक सामान्य हिंदू बच्चा दूर से भी कल्पना नहीं कर सकता कि ऐसे धर्म भी हैं जो वास्तव में नफरत, श्रेष्ठतावाद और हिंसा सिखाते हैं। एक हिंदूबच्चे को इस बात का बिल्कुल भी अंदाज़ा नहीं है कि कोई तथाकोथेत पवित्र किताब उन्हें सबसे ख़राब प्राणी, गंदा और बदजात कह सकती है। चूंकि हिंदू बच्चों का पालन-पोषण खुले वातावरण में होता है, इसलिए उन्हें शिकारी धर्मों की यातना और बर्बरता का सामना करना पड़ता है। हर माता-पिता का कर्तव्य है कि वह बच्चों को बताएं कि सभी धर्म एक जैसे नहीं होते।🧘🤺🛕🤺
इस्लाम में आनंद, नृत्य, संगीत, स्त्री-पुरुषों के इकट्ठेरहने जैसी कोई अवधारणा नहीं है। कला चित्रकला, मूर्तिकला, संगीत, कविता और साहित्य जैसे सौंदर्य शास्त्रों के प्रति सख्त घृणा है। इस्लाम में कोई आध्यात्मिक बात नहीं है, क्योंकि इसका कोईं गहन दर्शन, उच्च विचार और ध्यान की धारणा नहीं है। जबकि ये सभी चीजें भारतीय परंपराओं में सहज रूप में पाई जाती हैं। यही वजह है कि दुनिया में भारतीय संस्कृति का सम्मान हर दिन बढ़ रहा है। इस्लाम अपने स्वभाव से एक राजनीतिक विचारधारा है जो अपने अनुयायियों से अत्यथिक आज्ञाकारिता और समर्पण की मांग करती है। जिस कारण इस्लाम मानव जाति के लिए बहुत ही खतरनाक बन गया तभी मानव प्रेमी लोग इस्लाम को अपने देश से बाहर रखने का प्रयास कर रहा है (उदाहरण के तौर पर सऊदी अरब जैसा इस्लामिक देश)। 🧘🤺🛕🤺
@@jaiprakashnaudiyal9120 to bhaiya un phylosopher ko bhi kha rehne diya abrhamic religions ka to problem hi yahi hai chahe wo Christianity ho ya Islam Christianity to fir bhi change ho gya renessance ke Baad
@@mayankindian3750 When other religions were reforming during renaissance, Islamic communities were going backwards by banning, burning printing presses. Printing of any book other than “ Holy Book “ was considered haaram !
भारत एकमात्र जीवित सभ्यता है जो प्रकृति के साथ पूर्ण सामंजस्य रखती है। यह सभ्यता सहजता और आध्यात्मिकता के बारे में है। यह किसी प्रकार के हुक्म नहीं देती बल्कि अस्तित्व के प्राकृतिक तरीकों का वर्णन करती है। यह मिथ्याकरण, त्याग, धर्मत्याग और यहां तक कि ईश निंदा की भी अनुमति देती है। यह सभी प्रकार की स्वतंत्रता के बारे में है, किसी भी रूप में किसी भी आकार में, खुदा को चुनने या न चुनने और किसी भी शास्त्र को चुनने या ना चुनने की अनुमति देती है। निश्चित रूप से भारतीय ज्ञान प्रणालियों को समझने के लिए ।Q की आवश्यकता होती है। जिन लोगों को मजहबी आदेशों के कारण से पिंजरों में रखा जाता है, वे कभी भी, स्वतंत्रता और गहनता के अर्थ को समझ नहीं सकते हैं जो भारतीय परंपराओं में निहित हैं। भारतीय परंपराओं के साथ इस्लाम की तुलना करना अनानास के साथ पिज्जा की तुलना करने जैसा है...!🧘🤺🛕🤺
आदरणी मै आप की बातों से पूरी तरह सहमत हूं लेकिन अरविंद सहारण जी समय लगेगा । अरविंद जी को लगता है कि एक दिन भारत पाकिस्तान के रिश्ते सामान्य हो जाएंगे। जब भारतीय मुस्लिम को जय हिन्द भारत माता की जय हिंदुस्तान जिंदाबाद से दिक्कत है तो पाकिस्तान से क्या उम्मीद रखे
In every Hindu household, children are made to believe that all religions are the same and every religion teaches love, harmony and respect for every living being. A normal Hindu child cannot even remotely imagine that there are religions that actually teach hatred, superiority and violence. A Hindu child has absolutely no idea that some so-called holy book can call them the worst creatures, dirty and badjaat. Since Hindu children are brought up in an open environment, they are exposed to the torture and barbarity of predatory religions. It is the duty of every parent to tell children that all religions are not the same..🧘🤺🛕🤺
This is a big prblm. Don't be too happy we don't know who the enemy is. Our being a supporter of secularism at the expense of our religion has come back to haunt us.
Please please don't blame Islam . Pakistani mullahs got nothing to do with Islam. Pakistani mullah use religion for their own benefits . Its is big business .
अरविंद जी, "हिंदुत्व" एक "विचारधारा" से ज्यादा एक "रिएक्शन" या "प्रतिक्रिया" है जो भारतीय उपमहाद्वीप के पिछले हजार साल का "गुबार और भड़ास" है, नफरत नहीं। 🙏❤
दुनिया में एक ही धर्म है वह है हिंदू धर्म बाकी सब मजहब है। क्योंकि हिंदू धर्मी है जिसमें सबको स्वस्थ आनंदमई प्रसन्न जीवन जीने के लिए अलग अलग मार्ग बताया गया है वह है संगीत, म्यूजिक, नृत्य, चित्रकला, मूर्तिकला, कविता, साहित्य, योग, आयुर्वेदिक और अलग अलग त्योहारों के माध्यम से जिससे मनुष्य स्वस्थ आनंदमई प्रसन्न होकर जीवन जी सके। यह सब बाहर से आए हुए दूसरे मजहब में नहीं मिलेगा। इसलिए हिंदू जितना कट्टर होगा अपने धर्म के प्रति उतना ही वह हिंदू ओहिंसा के रास्ते पर चलकर मानव से लेकर जीव जंतु और प्रकृति प्रेमी हो जाता है। क्योंकि हिंदू धर्म में किसी से नफरत करने की शिक्षा नहीं देता है सबसे दया प्रेम करने का शिक्षा देता है। इसीलिए हिंदू जितना कट्टर होगा अपने धर्म के प्रति वह उतना ही प्रेमी और दयालु होगा...!🙏
सर आपने जो सवाल किया तो इसमे कोई बडी बात नही कि पाकिस्तान का मसाला क्या है. इस्लाम ये एक ही मसला है. जब तक पाकिस्तान के लोगो के दिल और दिमाग से इस्लाम का भूत उतरता नही तबतक दोनो देशो के रिलेशन कभी अच्छे नही हो सकते. आप लोग कितना भी घुमा फिरके बात करो पर आखिर सब बात इस्लाम पे आके अटक जायेगी.
Arvind Babu, if you read Quran and the Hadith of Bokhari (I suspect you might have) it is rather very clear … Muslims can not be in any relation with non Muslims… you seem to determined to negate the lessons of history of the past and the present. Fundamentally it is not the question of two states but two people.
आसमानी मजहब और इंसान एक साथ नहीं रह सकते" एक सार्वभौमिक सत्य है" अरव अल्लाह कहते हैं गैर-मुसलमानों से तब तक लड़ो जब तक अल्लाह का धर्म दुनिया में पूरी तरह से स्थापित न हो जाए [सुर 8, आयत 39]🧘🤺🛕🤺अल्लाह को हिंदू पसंद नहीं हैं अल्लाह को यहूदी पसंद नहीं हैं अल्लाह को ईसाई पसंद नहीं हैं अल्लाह को नास्तिक पसंद नहीं हैं अल्लाह को एलजीबीटी पसंद नहीं है अल्लाह को फ्री स्पीच पसंद नहीं है अल्लाह को धार्मिक स्वतंत्रता पसंद नहीं अल्लाह को आज़ाद औरतें पसंद नहीं हैं। यह है 1400 साल पहले मोहम्मद 40 साल की उम्र में अपने मां बाप और पूर्वजों की धर्म को छोड़कर इस्लाम मजहब बनाया था एक मर्द को 4 लड़कियों की लालच देकर और मृत्यु होने के बाद जन्नत में खूबसूरत हूर के साथ मौज करने का और जहन्नुम की डर दिखा कर🧘🤺🤺🛕
@@rajendrahaldar1596 आपने सही कहा, हम अगर विश्व के किसी भी पंथ, संप्रदाय या अन्य सभ्यता के लोगो को देखे तो समय के साथ वे स्वम को बदल रहे है। परन्तु इस्लामिकों मे परिवर्तन स्वभाव थोड़ा भी नहीं दिखता।
i love the people of india they are same as we are same civilisation. same traditions. same eating culture . same culture. same calendar for example the sawan. the jaith. the badho etc. actually there are some mindset on our side who are hiding their identity and they want to deteriorate this relation what else i write here except spreading the message of love as the late indian premiere atal ji did but all his efforts was failed by our side arvind dear this man hamid sahib and you are spreading the message of love and also your podcast and content is based on sanity lets hope we saw a rising sun and one day i myself in delhi. agra and you are in my city peshawar but the main think is trust being an ordinary pakistani this is my dream my love to you and your viewers we can not heal the wounds of those who lost every thing in the name of division of india but at least we should go and see towards positivity of this region thanks and regards
No. Indians are not same as Pakistanis. Indian religions are inclusive and diverse and not based on my way or high way. We are very different people. Most of islamic rulers are cruel to hindus so we were different
@@RiteshArora-s9x please read my comment carefully i am saying that i love hindu and you are saying about religion it is your view it is your prerogative you are living in democracy with strong constitution drafted by the brilliant minds of that mind my message to you that before 1947 we were same yes religion matters but you should be thankful to your all premiers living or dead and also your intellectuals i mean those who put india on a right track regards yes mughal emperor aurangzeb did cruelties to the hindus lets move toward the way of the prosperity it is our bad luck or what i can say that our political elite is not sincere to this country neither we have strong parliament or we have great minds for example panditji. atalji. ambedkar we can live as a peaceful. and civilized people thats i want but from the masses i belong the comment i write is my dream and you can not stop the dreams of some one regards
Saharan Sab, as Barrister Sab was explaining, I think there's very less similarities between the two countries. May be Punjabis must be having some similarities but Punjab in India is a small state in India. You must be speaking about a few percent of people with Punjabi origin. The text books, rules, procedures, education at home, society, family and now social media has created a big difference between these people from India and Pakistan. So there's no similarities now even between Punjabis from both the sides.
India is the only living civilization which is in perfect harmony with nature. This civilization is all about spontaneity and spirituality. It does not dictate but describes natural ways of being. It allows heresy, renunciation, apostasy and even blasphemy. It is all about freedom, choosing or not choosing God in any form, any shape and choosing or not choosing any scripture. Of course one needs IQ to understand Indian knowledge systems. People who are caged by religious dictates can never understand the meaning of freedom and profundity that Indian traditions contain. Comparing Islam with Indian traditions is like comparing pizza with pineapple.!🧘🤺🛕🤺
Arvindji, could you kindly pass my best wishes to Barrister Bashani because he appears to have been ill and is still in the process of recovery (I hope and pray). People like him are very precious for us as well as our coming generations to enlighten and educate us. Most of your programmes I watch because of them being very informative. Please keep it going. Kind Regards to you, Barrister Bashani and the rest of your editorial team. Mrs Bangash
Hamid Bashani shud be in the new age education structure especially in th Pakistan education department enlisting his help in restructuring and forming new age books .. Unfortunately people like Hamid Bashani is or was never regarded for his true love for History... Bcuz most of th Pakistani people especially th Islamist Fundamental Forces don't want to bring anything new in Pakistani education system as their entire theory of Anti India and Anti Hindu stance will be demolished and their cash inflow will stop ..
Islam het wreedheid na elke huis gebring. Die gelowiges geniet hul dwaasheid net soveel as hul wreedheid. Die leerstellings van Islam wis die verskil tussen wreedheid en spiritualiteit heeltemal uit.Tot op datum is Islam die enigste ideologie waar wreedheid as sinoniem met goddelikheid beskou word..!🧘🤺🛕🤺
I try to never miss a single word of Barrister Bashani sb . He is one of the saner voices of the subcontinent. My request to Bashani sb is to good care of himself; I want to listen to him for another 100 years. Though , this time I have great disagreement with him. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Pr.
There is only one religion in the world and that is Hinduism, all others are religions. Because Hinduism is a religion in which different paths have been shown to everyone to live a healthy, joyful and happy life. That is through music, dance, painting, sculpture, poetry, literature, yoga, ayurvedic and different festivals so that man can live a healthy, joyful and happy life. All this will not be found in any other religion coming from outside. Therefore, the more fanatic a Hindu is towards his religion, the more he follows the path of violence and becomes a lover of humans, animals and nature. Because Hinduism does not teach to hate anyone, it teaches to love everyone with kindness. That is why the more fanatic a Hindu is towards his religion, the more loving and kind he will be...!🙏
As usual Barrister Bhashani has analysed the issues and presented them wonderfully well. Arvind deserves congratulations for calling him over a for fruitful discussion
arvind ji, 1000 saal ki history kya kaafi nahi hai ye samajhne ke liye ki Islam aur muslim indian subcontinent aur hindu ke liye behtar saabit hua ha ya nahi? 🙏
Pakistan ma hinduo ko koi right nahi ha na bo cricketer president prime minister president armycheif army singer actor ban sakta ha minorities ka liya jahunam ha Pakistan
Arvindji..Sir, I have been listening to you since the time you had less than one lakh subscribers. I have been listening to this wonderful channel. I have heard almost all the guests who have come to your channel. But from Barrister Hamid Basani Sahab, one gets to learn something new every time. Arvind ji please never close your channel. Thank you...Thank you sir
arvind ji, agar aap indian subcontinent ke pichhle 1000 saal ki history ko ignore karna chahte hain to aaj ka europe ko dekh lijiye, newzealand bhi untouchable nahi rahega. 🙏
Arvind ji your subject is always very meaningful and impressive to the listeners.about Pakistans relations with India is a very difficult to reconcile as long as conservative attitude of Islam
Qaid Azam gave speech on 11 August, to give the impression that Muslims should not come in large number in Pakistan. No, Muslim religious scholar or politician of Pakistan said that Muslims of UP, Bihar and Central provinces should come to Pakistan. They were of the view that if muslims in large number comes to Pakistan, they will be economic burden on Pakistan.
Excellent program. I wish people could understand N appreciate what has occurred N what should be done to follow a positive N progressive future, otherwise we would be left behind in the human race. Let’s all be positive N move forward, life is definitely too short. GOOD LUCK🎉🎉🎉🎉❤️❤️
In the age of internet and information Islam is in the danger of becoming first religion to extinct from the surface of the earth . Islam golden time was till half a century ago when people are less educated n unaware of the concept n ideological construct of this Arabic cult with emergence of modern world with multiple sources of information n now internet access leading into an Ex muslim movements all allround the world thereby exposing n disclosing every fault lines n plenty of jugular veins Embibes with in islam.
The primary parties responsible for the division of India and the tragic genocide of Punjabis in 1947 are as follows: the British-60%, the Muslim League-30%, and the Congress-10%.
Sirs, Kashmir is the issue. Although Mr Jinnah only wanted a safe homeland for indian muslims. And then Kashmir acceded to india,and it became the heartthrob of Pakistan.
भारत से अलग पाकिस्तान का इतिहास क्या है अगर दुनिया में शांति रखनी है और इज्जत हासिल करनी है तो सहअस्तित्व की भावना से एक दूसरे का आदर सत्कार करते हुवे मिल जुल कर रहे।
Friends we would really appreciate if you could please like, comment and share this program. 🙏🙏
Pakistanis se Bharat ka koi bhi relations nahin chahiye, woh alag hai aur ham alag, Aaj kal ki generations ko Pakistani yo ko yaad nhi karte hai. Pakistanis se koi cultural, social, trade, economic relations nahin chahiye. Bharat unko bhula hai, yaad nhi karte hai.
The all molana and Ex Muslims drama free comedy king 😂all babay Mr 420 😮😮😮
I pray for good health of Hamid Bashani Ji,
🙏
I STRONGLY DISAGREE WITH ARVIND JI:
South, East & North Indian culture is different from Pak. Only West Indian culture has some similarity eg; Bihar, UP, Rajasthan, Punjab. The similarity is only in language...not in clothing, food habits religion, culture.
Culture of Sikhs, Maithli-Bhojpuri traditions, Gujrati-Marwadi cultural values are entirely different. We have a different mindset.
You cannot compare culture of east india, assam, nagas, msnipur with Pak.
You cannot compare culture of south india; tamil, kannad, keral with Pak.
Why should we open our heart & mind for Pak ?
By exchange of trade & friendship with Pak why should we risk our life & liberty.
Philistine, Arabs also have cultural, religious, historical & other similarities. What Hams did with jew women & children ? What has happened to us in Kasmir ?
Learning from History & recent past & current situation also; Why should we risk our life & liberty of our women ?
Russians have many similsrities with europe & USA. Both are christns. Chinese, mongols, koreans, japan have many similarities. Why are they different countries?
As an Indian i donot want any relationship with Pak & Bang. I have my right to live life peacefully and safety of family is PARAMOUNT.
Please keep your fancy ideas to yourself. I respectfully return your ideas. Possibility of reform in islame is 0% and it cannot be modern.
They want to live 1400 yrs back. We are looking into future, why to carry their baggage ?
Arbind ji I am your big fan....but no friendship with shantidoots.
I can't believe Mr Bashani tried to avoid the crux of the problem😂
The reason of animosity is religious based which comes out of quran. But the reason it errupted during 1920s is ..before brits it was muslim rulers so converted muslims some how felt compensated ..with brits ruling and leaving India muslims wanted to take back what was never theirs ...hence the conflict
प्रत्येक हिंदू घर में बच्चों को यह विश्वास दिलाया
जाता है कि सभी धर्म एक जैसे हैं और हर धर्म
हर प्राणी के लिए प्रेम, सद्भाव और सम्मान
सिखाता है। एक सामान्य हिंदू बच्चा दूर से भी
कल्पना नहीं कर सकता कि ऐसे धर्म भी हैं जो
वास्तव में नफरत, श्रेष्ठतावाद और हिंसा
सिखाते हैं। एक हिंदूबच्चे को इस बात का
बिल्कुल भी अंदाज़ा नहीं है कि कोई तथाकोथेत
पवित्र किताब उन्हें सबसे ख़राब प्राणी, गंदा
और बदजात कह सकती है। चूंकि हिंदू बच्चों
का पालन-पोषण खुले वातावरण में होता है,
इसलिए उन्हें शिकारी धर्मों की यातना और
बर्बरता का सामना करना पड़ता है। हर
माता-पिता का कर्तव्य है कि वह बच्चों को
बताएं कि सभी धर्म एक जैसे नहीं होते।🧘🤺🛕🤺
इस्लाम में आनंद, नृत्य, संगीत, स्त्री-पुरुषों के इकट्ठेरहने जैसी कोई अवधारणा नहीं है। कला चित्रकला, मूर्तिकला, संगीत, कविता और साहित्य जैसे सौंदर्य शास्त्रों के प्रति सख्त घृणा है। इस्लाम में कोई आध्यात्मिक बात नहीं है, क्योंकि इसका कोईं गहन दर्शन, उच्च विचार और ध्यान की धारणा नहीं है। जबकि ये सभी चीजें भारतीय परंपराओं में सहज रूप में पाई जाती हैं। यही वजह है कि दुनिया में भारतीय संस्कृति का सम्मान हर दिन बढ़ रहा है। इस्लाम अपने स्वभाव से एक राजनीतिक विचारधारा है जो अपने अनुयायियों से अत्यथिक आज्ञाकारिता और समर्पण की मांग करती है। जिस कारण इस्लाम मानव जाति के लिए बहुत ही खतरनाक बन गया तभी मानव प्रेमी लोग इस्लाम को अपने देश से बाहर रखने का प्रयास कर रहा है (उदाहरण के तौर पर सऊदी अरब जैसा इस्लामिक देश)। 🧘🤺🛕🤺
Right 👍 bahut bahut sundar
कुछ बातें आपकी सही हैं,लेकिन कुछ मुस्लिम महान कवि,हस्तियाँ ऐसी भी हुए हैं,और आज भी हैं,जो इस्लाम से बिलकुल उलट हुई हैं ।
@@jaiprakashnaudiyal9120 to bhaiya un phylosopher ko bhi kha rehne diya abrhamic religions ka to problem hi yahi hai chahe wo Christianity ho ya Islam Christianity to fir bhi change ho gya renessance ke Baad
@@mayankindian3750
When other religions were reforming during renaissance, Islamic communities were going backwards by banning, burning printing presses. Printing of any book other than “ Holy Book “ was considered haaram !
@@bbhusari wohi to
दुश्मनी की असली वजह आसमानी किताब है। आपके सारे सवालोका जवाब यही है।
Yup but they won’t say that because they are cowards
Ye Arvind bhai shuru se hi confused hai inse koi ye puche ki Europe me kyo ye alag identify aur sharia kanun mang rahe hai
No wrong interpretation of Quran.
@@mehmoodahmed893 ha pta hai kitna history ok invaders islamic hi the na jinhone mandir tode
@@mehmoodahmed893 oh bhai likha to bahut pehle the Nalanda University kab thi 🤔
भारत एकमात्र जीवित सभ्यता है जो प्रकृति के साथ पूर्ण सामंजस्य रखती है। यह सभ्यता सहजता और आध्यात्मिकता के बारे में है। यह किसी प्रकार के हुक्म नहीं देती बल्कि अस्तित्व के प्राकृतिक तरीकों का वर्णन करती है। यह मिथ्याकरण, त्याग, धर्मत्याग और यहां तक कि ईश निंदा की भी अनुमति देती है। यह सभी प्रकार की स्वतंत्रता के बारे में है, किसी भी रूप में किसी भी आकार में, खुदा को चुनने या न चुनने और किसी भी शास्त्र को चुनने या ना चुनने की अनुमति देती है। निश्चित रूप से भारतीय ज्ञान प्रणालियों को समझने के लिए ।Q की आवश्यकता होती है। जिन लोगों को मजहबी आदेशों के कारण से पिंजरों में रखा जाता है, वे कभी भी, स्वतंत्रता और गहनता के अर्थ को समझ नहीं सकते हैं जो भारतीय परंपराओं में निहित हैं। भारतीय परंपराओं के साथ इस्लाम की तुलना करना अनानास के साथ पिज्जा की तुलना करने जैसा है...!🧘🤺🛕🤺
आदरणी मै आप की बातों से पूरी तरह सहमत हूं लेकिन अरविंद सहारण जी समय लगेगा । अरविंद जी को लगता है कि एक दिन भारत पाकिस्तान के रिश्ते सामान्य हो जाएंगे। जब भारतीय मुस्लिम को जय हिन्द भारत माता की जय हिंदुस्तान जिंदाबाद से दिक्कत है तो पाकिस्तान से क्या उम्मीद रखे
@@sachinkumarparsai9077true brother ☺️
व्वा व्वाह क्या सयांनी बात की आपने 🎉🎉❤❤
हामिद बाशानी साहब के बोलने का लहजा और शब्दों का चयन बेहतरीन है
In every Hindu household, children are made to believe that all religions are the same and every religion teaches love, harmony and respect for every living being. A normal Hindu child cannot even remotely imagine that there are religions that actually teach hatred, superiority and violence. A Hindu child has absolutely no idea that some so-called holy book can call them the worst creatures, dirty and badjaat. Since Hindu children are brought up in an open environment, they are exposed to the torture and barbarity of predatory religions. It is the duty of every parent to tell children that all religions are not the same..🧘🤺🛕🤺
This is a big prblm. Don't be too happy we don't know who the enemy is. Our being a supporter of secularism at the expense of our religion has come back to haunt us.
@@JyotiKumari-cn5it very true 💯% Agree
But now you do.
Please please don't blame Islam . Pakistani mullahs got nothing to do with Islam. Pakistani mullah use religion for their own benefits . Its is big business .
Can u show me the versus of hindu book about other religions
Islaam is the reason.
It’s pisslam
अरविंद जी, "हिंदुत्व" एक "विचारधारा" से ज्यादा एक "रिएक्शन" या "प्रतिक्रिया" है जो भारतीय उपमहाद्वीप के पिछले हजार साल का "गुबार और भड़ास" है, नफरत नहीं। 🙏❤
We respect to Dr Bashani sahab❤❤❤🙏😍🇮🇳
दुनिया में एक ही धर्म है वह है हिंदू धर्म बाकी सब मजहब है। क्योंकि हिंदू धर्मी है जिसमें सबको स्वस्थ आनंदमई प्रसन्न जीवन जीने के लिए अलग अलग मार्ग बताया गया है वह है संगीत, म्यूजिक, नृत्य, चित्रकला, मूर्तिकला, कविता, साहित्य, योग, आयुर्वेदिक और अलग अलग त्योहारों के माध्यम से जिससे मनुष्य स्वस्थ आनंदमई प्रसन्न होकर जीवन जी सके। यह सब बाहर से आए हुए दूसरे मजहब में नहीं मिलेगा। इसलिए हिंदू जितना कट्टर होगा अपने धर्म के प्रति उतना ही वह हिंदू ओहिंसा के रास्ते पर चलकर मानव से लेकर जीव जंतु और प्रकृति प्रेमी हो जाता है। क्योंकि हिंदू धर्म में किसी से नफरत करने की शिक्षा नहीं देता है सबसे दया प्रेम करने का शिक्षा देता है। इसीलिए हिंदू जितना कट्टर होगा अपने धर्म के प्रति वह उतना ही प्रेमी और दयालु होगा...!🙏
Root cause is the sky book, which nobody will dare say.
Hindu se nafrat hi dushmani hai
I pray for good health of Hamid Bashani Ji,
🙏
Ha ☺️
मै भी
Barrister Hamid a truly bold and fair minded intellect. 😊
नफरत का कारण सिर्फ इनकी किताब है !! जो पढ़ेंगे वही तो करेंगे !!
Islam mein kaun si achhi knowledge ki baat likhi hai...jara Hume bhi to batayen
𝐈𝐬𝐥𝐚𝐦...
𝐍𝐚𝐟𝐚𝐫𝐚𝐭 𝐬𝐞 𝐛𝐡𝐚𝐫𝐚 𝐩𝐚𝐝𝐚 𝐡......
Magar Pakisthani / Muslim log to bolte hai islam Aman pasand majahab hai... 🙆♂️
@@cmm750 are bhai interview hi dekh lo raste pe 😊
@@mayankindian3750
Bhai........ Gajwa -e- Hind bhi karne wale hai...... Kitab me likha hai..... Road Interview me bolte suna hai..... 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤪🤪🤪🤪🤪
@@cmm750 ha 😅
Muslim philosophy teaches hatre against all other religions
No match for Bashani ji in our region his honesty and clearly explaining the historical facts.
Wish Hamid bashani ji good health.
सर आपने जो सवाल किया तो इसमे कोई बडी बात नही कि पाकिस्तान का मसाला क्या है. इस्लाम ये एक ही मसला है. जब तक पाकिस्तान के लोगो के दिल और दिमाग से इस्लाम का भूत उतरता नही तबतक दोनो देशो के रिलेशन कभी अच्छे नही हो सकते. आप लोग कितना भी घुमा फिरके बात करो पर आखिर सब बात इस्लाम पे आके अटक जायेगी.
Arvind Babu, if you read Quran and the Hadith of Bokhari (I suspect you might have) it is rather very clear … Muslims can not be in any relation with non Muslims… you seem to determined to negate the lessons of history of the past and the present. Fundamentally it is not the question of two states but two people.
आसमानी मजहब और इंसान एक साथ नहीं रह सकते" एक सार्वभौमिक सत्य है" अरव अल्लाह कहते हैं गैर-मुसलमानों से तब तक लड़ो जब तक अल्लाह का धर्म दुनिया में पूरी तरह से स्थापित न हो जाए [सुर 8, आयत 39]🧘🤺🛕🤺अल्लाह को हिंदू पसंद नहीं हैं
अल्लाह को यहूदी पसंद नहीं हैं
अल्लाह को ईसाई पसंद नहीं हैं
अल्लाह को नास्तिक पसंद नहीं हैं
अल्लाह को एलजीबीटी पसंद नहीं है
अल्लाह को फ्री स्पीच पसंद नहीं है
अल्लाह को धार्मिक स्वतंत्रता पसंद नहीं
अल्लाह को आज़ाद औरतें पसंद नहीं हैं। यह है 1400 साल पहले मोहम्मद 40 साल की उम्र में अपने मां बाप और पूर्वजों की धर्म को छोड़कर इस्लाम मजहब बनाया था एक मर्द को 4 लड़कियों की लालच देकर और मृत्यु होने के बाद जन्नत में खूबसूरत हूर के साथ मौज करने का और जहन्नुम की डर दिखा कर🧘🤺🤺🛕
Exactly 💯%🫡🇮🇳
If you want people to become Muslim, set an example to them
Yes
जबकि सब को बनाया अल्लाह ने ही है, अगर पसंद नहीं तो बनाया ही क्यों था, इसका क्या जवाब है..
@@rajendrahaldar1596 आपने सही कहा, हम अगर विश्व के किसी भी पंथ, संप्रदाय
या अन्य सभ्यता के लोगो को देखे तो समय के साथ वे स्वम को बदल रहे है। परन्तु इस्लामिकों मे परिवर्तन स्वभाव थोड़ा भी नहीं दिखता।
भारत से नहीं हिन्दुओं से दुश्मनी
i love the people of india they are same as we are same civilisation. same traditions. same eating culture . same culture. same calendar for example the sawan. the jaith. the badho etc. actually there are some mindset on our side who are hiding their identity and they want to deteriorate this relation what else i write here except spreading the message of love as the late indian premiere atal ji did but all his efforts was failed by our side arvind dear this man hamid sahib and you are spreading the message of love and also your podcast and content is based on sanity lets hope we saw a rising sun and one day i myself in delhi. agra and you are in my city peshawar but the main think is trust being an ordinary pakistani this is my dream my love to you and your viewers we can not heal the wounds of those who lost every thing in the name of division of india but at least we should go and see towards positivity of this region thanks and regards
No. Indians are not same as Pakistanis. Indian religions are inclusive and diverse and not based on my way or high way. We are very different people. Most of islamic rulers are cruel to hindus so we were different
@@RiteshArora-s9x please read my comment carefully i am saying that i love hindu and you are saying about religion it is your view it is your prerogative you are living in democracy with strong constitution drafted by the brilliant minds of that mind my message to you that before 1947 we were same yes religion matters but you should be thankful to your all premiers living or dead and also your intellectuals i mean those who put india on a right track regards yes mughal emperor aurangzeb did cruelties to the hindus lets move toward the way of the prosperity it is our bad luck or what i can say that our political elite is not sincere to this country neither we have strong parliament or we have great minds for example panditji. atalji. ambedkar we can live as a peaceful. and civilized people thats i want but from the masses i belong the comment i write is my dream and you can not stop the dreams of some one regards
@@RiteshArora-s9x true indian civilization is not exclusivist 😊
@@mayankindian3750 it should exclude poisonous philosophy
इस दुश्मनी की वजह एक आसमानी किताब है जो काफिर से नफरत सिखाती है!
Saharan Sab, as Barrister Sab was explaining, I think there's very less similarities between the two countries. May be Punjabis must be having some similarities but Punjab in India is a small state in India. You must be speaking about a few percent of people with Punjabi origin.
The text books, rules, procedures, education at home, society, family and now social media has created a big difference between these people from India and Pakistan. So there's no similarities now even between Punjabis from both the sides.
India is the only living civilization which is in perfect harmony with nature. This civilization is all about spontaneity and spirituality. It does not dictate but describes natural ways of being. It allows heresy, renunciation, apostasy and even blasphemy. It is all about freedom, choosing or not choosing God in any form, any shape and choosing or not choosing any scripture. Of course one needs IQ to understand Indian knowledge systems. People who are caged by religious dictates can never understand the meaning of freedom and profundity that Indian traditions contain. Comparing Islam with Indian traditions is like comparing pizza with pineapple.!🧘🤺🛕🤺
Well Said ❤
True brother phylosophy 🤗☺️🥰🕉️🙏
Bashani sb is a deep individual hence worth listening to
यह कोई पूछनेकी बात है?उनके युट्युबर खुलेआम बताते है की मदरसोमे किताबोमे भारत तिरस्कार सिखाया जाता है।
Dear Arvind ji, your efforts are really appreciable. God bless u. Baister Bashani ji also full of knowledge.
'N' number of debates cant solve this issue of hate. 'Book' is the reason and source of hate and no one can talk about it. Pl read yourself.
Arvindji, could you kindly pass my best wishes to Barrister Bashani because he appears to have been ill and is still in the process of recovery (I hope and pray). People like him are very precious for us as well as our coming generations to enlighten and educate us. Most of your programmes I watch because of them being very informative. Please keep it going. Kind Regards to you, Barrister Bashani and the rest of your editorial team. Mrs Bangash
Hamid Bashani shud be in the new age education structure especially in th Pakistan education department enlisting his help in restructuring and forming new age books .. Unfortunately people like Hamid Bashani is or was never regarded for his true love for History... Bcuz most of th Pakistani people especially th Islamist Fundamental Forces don't want to bring anything new in Pakistani education system as their entire theory of Anti India and Anti Hindu stance will be demolished and their cash inflow will stop ..
Who is responsible? Islam.Period.
Bashani Saab 👏👏👏 you are an intellectual person…I always liked listening to you…keep it going 👏👏👏
Basani Sir is always welcome, Brilliant Analysis Sir❤❤
Islam het wreedheid na elke huis gebring. Die gelowiges geniet hul dwaasheid net soveel as hul wreedheid. Die leerstellings van Islam wis die verskil tussen wreedheid en spiritualiteit heeltemal uit.Tot op datum is Islam die enigste ideologie waar wreedheid as sinoniem met goddelikheid beskou word..!🧘🤺🛕🤺
Arvindji & Bhashani Saheb you guys are great
Thought provoking.Thanks.
आप सत्य बताये खुदा की कशम की है,,स्लाम मक्षब किस देश से किस मक्षब से किस कोम को अच्छा मानता उनसे प्रेम करना सहि लगाव रखना बतायें,
Thanks a lot for a best academic discussion.....
A lot of respect fot both of you. Arvind and Bhashni sahib. We are proud of you .
Barrister Hamid Bashni is really a Great analyst. He's certainly an honest person who describes the relationship in straight forward way.
Truly mesmerizing and eye opener.salute to Mr. Bashani
Arvind ji,bashani ji perfect analysis 🙏
I try to never miss a single word of Barrister Bashani sb . He is one of the saner voices of the subcontinent. My request to Bashani sb is to good care of himself; I want to listen to him for another 100 years.
Though , this time I have great disagreement with him. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Pr.
HE Bashani Sahib valuable comments and analysis are always applauded
इन पाकिस्तानी स्कॉलर का विश्लेषण सटीक और संतुलित है। इस्लाम में ऐसे लोगोंं की निहायत कमी है।
bahut shandar analysis ,
Islam ke naam pe bharat ko toda gaya aaj Bharat se nafrat he
There is only one religion in the world and that is Hinduism, all others are religions. Because Hinduism is a religion in which different paths have been shown to everyone to live a healthy, joyful and happy life. That is through music, dance, painting, sculpture, poetry, literature, yoga, ayurvedic and different festivals so that man can live a healthy, joyful and happy life. All this will not be found in any other religion coming from outside. Therefore, the more fanatic a Hindu is towards his religion, the more he follows the path of violence and becomes a lover of humans, animals and nature. Because Hinduism does not teach to hate anyone, it teaches to love everyone with kindness. That is why the more fanatic a Hindu is towards his religion, the more loving and kind he will be...!🙏
Arvind bhai dushmani is only religion… Islam don’t believe in co-existence. World believes or not.
As usual Barrister Bhashani has analysed the issues and presented them wonderfully well.
Arvind deserves congratulations for calling him over a for fruitful discussion
Thank you so much! It was a pleasure to have Barrister Hamid Bashani on the show.
❤bashani sir is the most relevant think tank on India pakistan relation...
True words from Mr Bashani @@
Long time no see Bar.Bashani saab 🎉 welcome
arvind ji, 1000 saal ki history kya kaafi nahi hai ye samajhne ke liye ki Islam aur muslim indian subcontinent aur hindu ke liye behtar saabit hua ha ya nahi? 🙏
Hamid sir is a great intellectual You should ask him very difficult questions
Very informative.. thanks.
Both you are most intelligent people
Good Discussion 👍🏻
Superb work dear
Partition of best moment for hidu.hindu are saved from brutal religion islam
I don't think so because in Pakistan and in india, 99% people are converted from Hinduism and Sikhism
Very deep analysis by Bashani sahib.
Good discussion bargain sahab
Good debate - Namskar from Indian 🙏🙏
Namaskar Arvind bhai.
From :- A E JAIPUR
Hamid saheb is a most educated person..
Pakistan ma hinduo ko koi right nahi ha na bo cricketer president prime minister president armycheif army singer actor ban sakta ha minorities ka liya jahunam ha Pakistan
Good discussion
Arvindji..Sir, I have been listening to you since the time you had less than one lakh subscribers. I have been listening to this wonderful channel. I have heard almost all the guests who have come to your channel. But from Barrister Hamid Basani Sahab, one gets to learn something new every time. Arvind ji please never close your channel. Thank you...Thank you sir
Kindly convey my good wishes for health to Barrister Basani
Not only india, the entire world
Absolutely right
West me dekh lo bhai 😊
Since Pakistan accepted the concept of Kashim was a Khaliphate....
arvind ji, agar aap indian subcontinent ke pichhle 1000 saal ki history ko ignore karna chahte hain to aaj ka europe ko dekh lijiye, newzealand bhi untouchable nahi rahega. 🙏
Jai Ho Bharat ki❤❤❤❤❤
एक ही है जो इस मानसिकता में है, कि हिदुस्तान को मुस्लिम देश बनाना है.
Arvind ji your subject is always very meaningful and impressive to the listeners.about Pakistans relations with India is a very difficult to reconcile as long as conservative attitude of Islam
Qaid Azam gave speech on 11 August, to give the impression that Muslims should not come in large number in Pakistan. No, Muslim religious scholar or politician of Pakistan said that Muslims of UP, Bihar and Central provinces should come to Pakistan.
They were of the view that if muslims in large number comes to Pakistan, they will be economic burden on Pakistan.
Excellent program. I wish people could understand N appreciate what has occurred N what should be done to follow a positive N progressive future, otherwise we would be left behind in the human race. Let’s all be positive N move forward, life is definitely too short. GOOD LUCK🎉🎉🎉🎉❤️❤️
Islam ☪️️will create new india 🇮🇳by 2050 Alhamdulillah❤☪️🤲
Keep dreaming
In the age of internet and information Islam is in the danger of becoming first religion to extinct from the surface of the earth . Islam golden time was till half a century ago when people are less educated n unaware of the concept n ideological construct of this Arabic cult with emergence of modern world with multiple sources of information n now internet access leading into an Ex muslim movements all allround the world thereby exposing n disclosing every fault lines n plenty of jugular veins Embibes with in islam.
Nice joke 1000 saal ho gaye bharat ka culture nahi badla 😅
Hindu rashtra by 2034
Jai. Hind. 🙏🙏
Barister Bashani is most competent, wise personality and intellectual than thousands of Jinnahs, Iqbals, and other British stooges.
The primary parties responsible for the division of India and the tragic genocide of Punjabis in 1947 are as follows: the British-60%, the Muslim League-30%, and the Congress-10%.
Sirs, Kashmir is the issue.
Although Mr Jinnah only wanted a safe homeland for indian muslims.
And then Kashmir acceded to india,and it became the heartthrob
of Pakistan.
To apne desh me muslims ka kya haal hai pakistan me 🙄🤷🏼
Good job
Why Allies in ww2 , USA & Soviet Union became opponents?
Brilliant Analysis. More clarity will remove cobwebs of ignorance and conspiracy theories. Good interactions by both.
जय श्री राम🙏 डिबेट अच्छी लगी
भारत से अलग पाकिस्तान का इतिहास क्या है अगर दुनिया में शांति रखनी है और इज्जत हासिल करनी है तो सहअस्तित्व की भावना से एक दूसरे का आदर सत्कार करते हुवे मिल जुल कर रहे।
Good lage rahoo
This fact is somehow correct but main fact is Land Lord of Bengal,Sind and Punjab are responsible.
अरविन्द जी,एक डिवेट इस पर भी करें कि इनका कायदे आजम भुने हुए सूवर के टुकड़ों के साथ शराब लेता था। फिर ये सूवरमुसल्लाह हैं।ईमानी नहीं हैं।
Is ke piche ki wajah hai “ Two Nation Theory “
Islam ka ek hi maksad hai duniya me Aman 🕊️
Islamic separatism nahin islamic fanaticism.
Ex muslim sahil adam seeker
❤❤❤ We are still waiting for the relevant answer. Why Islam is the root cause of animosity against India 🎉🎉😅
BASHANI The great 🎉
When you know the answer why create questions. Understand Islam through ex Muslims and western scholars.