Accurascale's NEW Class 37 - Gold or Garbage? | Iron Horse Weekly ep42

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 103

  • @GaryVeryard
    @GaryVeryard 2 місяці тому +1

    It was great listening to you opening the box and seeing your class 37 for the first time. Excellent

  • @davidspottiswoode3831
    @davidspottiswoode3831 Рік тому +2

    Enjoyed this very much… I like the unrehearsed reactions 😊. You’ve convinced me! Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Dave.

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      I wish I had time to rehearse and do a script and everything else like a professional... Sadly I am far too childish and unorganised for such intricacies 😂😂
      Thanks for watching!

    • @davidspottiswoode3831
      @davidspottiswoode3831 Рік тому +1

      @@IronHorseRailways every channel has its own style and I follow too many of them… but your review was pure, honest chat and I loved it. Very refreshing and I’ll look out for more of the same. Erm… I ordered it lol!

  • @Mousehole-Rail
    @Mousehole-Rail Рік тому +3

    I have two on order but haven't paid for them yet which the ones I am getting are the HNRC 37 and 37218 coming next year

  • @fatwalletboy2
    @fatwalletboy2 Рік тому +2

    I get the desk lights might be unnecessary but engine room lights add to the realism if you have a depot scene and operate in dark conditions to compliment coach lighting and scenic lighting for buildings and street lights etc.

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      I must admit, I don't often operate trains in the dark, I find it difficult to see the uncoupling lol

  • @ianuashley2146
    @ianuashley2146 Рік тому +1

    I had to send mine back, didn't like Hornby express points - I have 23 sets - would stay on the track. Anyone else had this problem?

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому +2

      Hornby points are awful 😔 I used to have constant derailments when using them - replaced with Peco SL points and the issues all but vanished mate

  • @sunsetdb7
    @sunsetdb7 Рік тому +2

    I have several Accurascale models on order and so far have only the Deltic, which like the 37, is absolutely phenomenal. Cheers for the video, can't wait for mine to arrive!

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      I have a Deltics in my sights but need to recover financially first 😂 maybe next year!

  • @violinstar5948
    @violinstar5948 Рік тому +4

    That’s why we have choice. Accurascale is fantastic for those who want ultra detailed models that come at a price. I’ve ordered the Harry Needle Tango Tractor class 37. Only Accurascale make this model and I’m excited. Obviously however, I won’t be buying accurascale all the time. Hornby will do.

  • @lord-al-2024
    @lord-al-2024 Рік тому +3

    Nice one Craig. One superb looking and running LOCO.

  • @theangelsmodellingandrailways
    @theangelsmodellingandrailways Рік тому +2

    Nice one Craig, what a stunning looking/sounding loco, top notch by Accurascale. You'll get many hours of fun running your new aquisition dude, look forward to seeing more of it. All the best. Brian @ The Angels

  • @miniroll32
    @miniroll32 Рік тому +1

    How are you controlling the train from your phone? I haven’t owned a DCC/sound train yet.

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      The DCC System I have is comprised of the following Equipment:
      A Windows PC
      A Sprog III with power booster plug
      A Cheap Android smart phone /
      Tablet loaded with "Engine Driver" software.
      😁

    • @miniroll32
      @miniroll32 Рік тому

      @@IronHorseRailways Thanks man!

  • @ferrari355101
    @ferrari355101 Рік тому +4

    Agree stupid that a crew is not pre fitted! I challenged Fran at Warley 3 years ago before the release of the Deltic that crew should be fitted at manufacture but got no response!! With a brand new the last thing you want is to take the lid off!.

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      I agree, however I can see why they don't as they offer a range of crews too, different ends to fit them in etc - you could bet that for every combination that's possible there'd be another half million people who'd want it the other way around 😂

    • @jamesthatcher4190
      @jamesthatcher4190 Рік тому +1

      Which end would you put the crew in ? (hint, either end is the wrong end for half the market) :)

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      @@jamesthatcher4190 which end would you prefer?😂

    • @jamesthatcher4190
      @jamesthatcher4190 Рік тому

      @@BritishRail60062 Weird, your experience is the exact opposite of everything I've read online and experienced myself?

    • @jamesthatcher4190
      @jamesthatcher4190 Рік тому

      @@IronHorseRailways Neither from the factory, I'd rather install the crew I want in the end I want, the way I want :)

  • @jamesthatcher4190
    @jamesthatcher4190 Рік тому +2

    For 169.95 why NOT have dashboard lights and engine lights - not like they are clearly adding any cost?

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      Well it's like I said - I can't see them 😂?
      It's like adding a nice interior to the inside of your engine piston barrel - you're never gonna see it in normal operation - it will add cost even if only slightly - still an absolute marvelous model though, stunning in fact!😍

    • @jamesthatcher4190
      @jamesthatcher4190 Рік тому +1

      @@IronHorseRailways Run the model in the dark :) There are many shots of her online in dark / dusk / on shed with the engine bay and cab lights on. :) If the model was £200 then maybe I'd moan about unrequired extras too, but at 169 quid, and loyalty points (3% off) and free post, its' hard to argue!

    • @jamesthatcher4190
      @jamesthatcher4190 Рік тому

      @@IronHorseRailways Also, I reckon your StayAlive isn't working or enabled - mine goes for nearly half a minute when I kill the power!

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      @@jamesthatcher4190 in the dark eh? Hmm 🤔 cab lights I can get behind 😊😍

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      @@jamesthatcher4190 I'll be checking the settings more thoroughly tonight anyway when I'm home from work 🙂 if not I'll just fit one to the decoder, something I've done countless times before!

  • @johnjmc
    @johnjmc Рік тому +3

    They do sound awesome. Waiting for my all green one from locomotion models

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому +2

      Brilliant 😊 😍 not sure there's much work for you to do with these bad boys though mate!

    • @johnjmc
      @johnjmc Рік тому +3

      @@IronHorseRailways no. I've got the bachmann all green deluxe coming too. I will compare them all, including my current 21pin one, which I've upgraded big time and even has a working fan like my class 24 as well

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому +2

      @@johnjmc I would like to see how the Bachmann stacks up - spinning fans are in my opinion just a bit unnecessary but to each their own!😂

    • @owentherail
      @owentherail Рік тому +1

      Agree about the driver too

  • @andrewharrison5983
    @andrewharrison5983 Рік тому +7

    Craig, Accurascale might want you to run the loco at night without your room lights on!😂

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому +1

      Yeah maybe 🤔

    • @StormmyStormmy
      @StormmyStormmy Рік тому +1

      I really like dashboard and engine bay lights, roof fans too, it adds to the realism in my opinion, I’m sure modellers share your view, the price of locos is very high especially Bachmann, Accurascale offer value for money in my opinion, great video, thanks for sharing.

  • @dafyddthomas7299
    @dafyddthomas7299 Рік тому +2

    Great video - got one on Ordinary BR Blue in 2nd batch crumbled - hopefully arrive for Birthday 2024, seems like right decision; although still like my BR Intercity Class 37 from Bachman.

  • @theeventhorizon-valebridge9512

    Great overview Craig, thank you.
    The inclusion of any extra electronic lighting details is so inexpensive to produce that the manufactures cannot possibly ask extra for it. e.g. dash lights, engine room lights etc. It does make the loco more interesting, flexible and therefore sellable.
    The addition now of a built in stay alive is a fabulous and necessary new base standard a far as I am concerned (Bachmann take note!). The sheer annoyance of locos cutting out because of a slightly dirty patch or on a point needed addressing. This is especially necessary with sound locos as they can stop and then have to go through their entire engine start up procedure on every instance of a temporary power disconnection.
    I didn't think my stay-alive was working until I tried it on a short section of spare track, unconnected to the main layout. It needs a minimum voltage to start charging of around 13.5v. Under that voltage and the capacitors don't seem to hold any useful charge. It gave about a second of motor/sound and lights, about 3 seconds of just sound/lights and about 9 seconds of just lights on.
    My main gripe, other than the widely experienced erratic motor running on numerous Accurascale loco models, is their fragility, on both their locos and other rollingstock. Bits just keep falling off, even arriving with a few bits loose in the box sometimes! Some parts can be poorly glued on too, grills and footplates etc. Other parts are just too fine and fragile to be sensible on working models and so easily get knocked off. They need to be more robust. Bachmann seem to have managed to solve this conundrum and produce detailed and strong models that don't shed their parts. I'd say that the Accurascale class 37 still just beats the Bachmann on the grounds of its sound/speakers and sound file being better and by having a built in stay-alive, otherwise they are fairly comparable, both being really great models.
    As you said though, why the hell don't they pre-fit a driver in all their locos? This needs addressing by ALL the manufacturers.
    Regards Julian.

    • @jamesthatcher4190
      @jamesthatcher4190 Рік тому

      Did your 37 come with any bits off? As for fitting drivers? No thanks! Which end would you like them in ? Just a driver or secondman too?

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      Thanks for getting involved Jules!😊
      The stay alive function on my model isn't working - I've had plenty of experience with stay alives before now and some thing here is a miss! - not to worry though, Accurascale are all over it 😊
      Cheers bud!

    • @theeventhorizon-valebridge9512
      @theeventhorizon-valebridge9512 Рік тому

      @@IronHorseRailways Hi again Craig, have you had any luck in resolving your issues with Accurascale? My 37 has now started to fail badly too. No lights (at all including the dash panel, cabs and engine room) , no stay-alive functionality and the sound keeps cutting out unless you CV the volume down to a really really quite level which is as good as useless! The motor seems to still be working fine though! Regards Julian

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому +1

      @@theeventhorizon-valebridge9512 not yet mate, it's running perfectly other than the lack of stay alive though thankfully!😁

    • @theeventhorizon-valebridge9512
      @theeventhorizon-valebridge9512 Рік тому +2

      @@IronHorseRailways I've just discussed my issues with their customer service and it needs returning to them!....They certainly seem to have a large amount of issues with their locos. I've had 8, of which only 1 is currently problem free. 4 had to be returned for refunds! 2 seem to have intermittent , varying/inconsistent/erratic running which I'm looking into and 1 is with sound cutting out issues. Reliability seems a big problem other than their fragility! Let me know what happens with yours. Regards Julian

  • @martinparkinson3665
    @martinparkinson3665 Рік тому +1

    My Shap Fell arrived today , looks stunning , but will be afew weeks before I run it as I'm moving in a couple of weeks ...

  • @Flymochairman1
    @Flymochairman1 Рік тому +1

    Very nice Loco and great review Craig! The smoothness of it had me! Did you say you'd ordered the Stephen Middlemore one? So did I but have heard nowt yet...nice to see what's coming though! Cheers for the post and enjoy the new model! All the best. Cheers!

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      I did indeed! But I just couldn't wait any longer for it so when these came up for grabs, I jumped 😂

  • @ianstransporthistorystuff8175
    @ianstransporthistorystuff8175 Рік тому +1

    Hi Craig , I am a new subscriber , and this class 37 sounds so realistic and as some one who's been loco crew on one in the past at a heritage railway the spa valley , when we had 37 254 which is now back on the national rail network, I can say this sound is so realistic and fantastic.

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому +1

      Hi Ian! Thanks the comment mate, always good to have a proper driver on board, so to speak 😂

    • @ianstransporthistorystuff8175
      @ianstransporthistorystuff8175 Рік тому +1

      Yes 😂 sadly I never got to drive 245 but just was a 2nd man but did get to drive our railways class 10 quite alot , which was a lovely loco to drive , but just very slow 🤣

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому +1

      @@ianstransporthistorystuff8175 I'd love a go in a GRONK to be fair, I'm not versed enough however to be able to pick out a class 10 over a class 08,09,11 etc .. class 13 I can though 😎😎😎🤣🤣

    • @ianstransporthistorystuff8175
      @ianstransporthistorystuff8175 Рік тому +1

      @@IronHorseRailways the class 10 was just the Blackstone engine version of the 08 rather than the EE 6 cly engine , but the Grongs are lovely and very forgiving too , just at a top speed of 20 mph ( if your lucky ) their no Pocket Rockets 🤣🤣🤣

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому +1

      @@ianstransporthistorystuff8175 they should have got Hornby to make the motors 😂

  • @newdurhamjunctionmodelrail9236

    Fantastic bit of kit

  • @oregonwesternrailroadprodu5239

    while i maybe a us modler you have brought up alot of valid points and the same could be said not just about engines but coaches and rolling stock i mean example rapido makes fantastic items but 125$ usd for a coach with a extreme interior that your not gonna see most of the time or freight cars with detailed under frames that cost 70$ usd that your not gonna see unless you handle the car there has to be some room for other improvements

  • @peterjackson-cheadleheath1182
    @peterjackson-cheadleheath1182 Рік тому +1

    Hi Craig Getting excited there..lol, So it lives upto the quality standards as per the usual Accruascale way, thats all good, enjoy the model. Thanks 👍

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      It's f***ing mint mate, honestly the fact I got 10% off from loyalty points makes it even sweeter

  • @KingTrump2024
    @KingTrump2024 Рік тому +1

    This is the 5th or 6th video I've seen with these models having issues. Funny how everyone shat all over Aurora Miniatures, and yet I see no dealers severing their relationships with Accurascale.

  • @michaeltildesley537
    @michaeltildesley537 Рік тому

    Fabulous models but cannot get the lights (except auto reverse running lights) to work on Hornby Hm7000 21TX Bluetooth decoder. All the sound options work brilliantly with the HM7000 (just as good as the LokSound in my view) but Accurascale won’t help me with mapping the other lights to the Hornby decoder. I think they only want to sell their own decoders. Shame as the Hornby HMDCC app is defo the way to go.

  • @davidford2169
    @davidford2169 Рік тому +1

    I have them both ( inc Bachmann).... both beautiful locos,now in 2024 Bachmann have dropped the price to try to match accurscale a bit too late Bachmann,...i will side with accurscale 👍

  • @oswestryroadtmd4850
    @oswestryroadtmd4850 Рік тому +2

    Sorry I should have entered that last comment here, rather than just a reply,

  • @rudigrest4013
    @rudigrest4013 Рік тому +2

    like a big kid lol im still waiting for mine 37001 great review

  • @anfieldroadlayoutintheloft5204

    Nice loco keep up the good vids on channel thanks lee

  • @formidable38
    @formidable38 Рік тому +1

    Phenominal model, after pre ordering just 1 in the last batch (not yet realeased) and only intending to have just one, Ive now got 3. My bank ballance is a car crash though. Never mind eh.🤣

  • @chrisvaughan159
    @chrisvaughan159 Рік тому

    OK nice model - but how much detail falls of if you sneeze on it?

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому +1

      I've not sneezed on it yet - I'll let you know when I do? 🤔😂

    • @chrisvaughan159
      @chrisvaughan159 Рік тому

      @@IronHorseRailways 🤣

    • @jamesthatcher4190
      @jamesthatcher4190 Рік тому +2

      None - I've three and they're more robust than my new Bachmann one!

    • @chrisvaughan159
      @chrisvaughan159 Рік тому

      @@jamesthatcher4190 Ooo! That's interesting! I have been torn between the two, but I was worried by my Accurascale Deltic, which drops details like blossom. If it's better than Bachmann though, that makes me ponder!

    • @jamesthatcher4190
      @jamesthatcher4190 Рік тому

      @@chrisvaughan159 I have a first run deltic, and as a first ever loco, it's awesome, but the chains had to be chopped off! The 37 however, really shows the lessons learned - chains are fine and robust, not attached to the body, and the wealth of detailing is extremely robust. I also reckon it runs smoother and quieter than the Bach, is heavier, can haul more, and sounds a million % better too. (and its cheaper) no brainer!

  • @banksroadmodernimage7358
    @banksroadmodernimage7358 Рік тому

    Nice running craig😊😊

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому +1

      I really do need to run trains more often, sadly after finishing work of an evening, I find myself wanting to do little more than just recline and watch stuff on UA-cam 🥱🥱🥱😂

    • @banksroadmodernimage7358
      @banksroadmodernimage7358 Рік тому

      Yer im snowed under with commission work from yard towers to weathering at mo,inbetween my night shift hgv work@@IronHorseRailways

  • @JamesPetts
    @JamesPetts Рік тому +1

    I approve of class 37s.

  • @karlharrison6544
    @karlharrison6544 Рік тому +1

    Hey Craig, is it metal? lol

  • @davidbrigenshaw8721
    @davidbrigenshaw8721 Рік тому +1

    A lovely model but too rich for my blood. For the price, crew figures should definitely come pre-fitted.

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      Would be nice but I suppose it is a minor niggle 🙂

    • @jamesthatcher4190
      @jamesthatcher4190 Рік тому

      Which end would you put them in, and would you pay more for them (considering this model is £80 CHEAPER than the directly similar Bachmann ?)

  • @WayneAtkinson89
    @WayneAtkinson89 Рік тому +2

    Good review matey, all Accurascale sound or non sound are pre fitted with stay alive as standard. That’s why the price they charge compared to hornby and bachmann is rediculous

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      I wouldn't call it ridiculous, I'd call the Bachmann ones ridiculous 😂 the accurascale ones are about average these days, sadly this hobby isn't getting any cheaper! 'new' purchases will have to be drawn back to one maybe two a year now, with the occasional second hand or used model thrown in if needed 😂 cheers mate!

    • @Night-zn4ew
      @Night-zn4ew Рік тому +1

      What do you mean? A class 37 from bachmann is about £50 more.

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      @@Night-zn4ew and it's not as nice a model, why waste £50🤫?

    • @WayneAtkinson89
      @WayneAtkinson89 Рік тому +1

      I meant rediculous as in they are giving them away 😂😂37402 arrived today and it’s 👌👌👌

  • @bigfella1952
    @bigfella1952 Рік тому +2

    Calm down, calm down, it’s only a commercial 😮 ..
    But is it ?
    Great review, looking forward to mine being delivered...
    Agree with your comments on details, about useless extras, drivers would ideal....
    Mine not arrived, but received an email about leaving turned on without movement for some time, to allow stay alive to function properly,
    Hadn’t taken much notice, awaiting my deliveries, (yes, hadn’t bought anything for a while, so have 4 on order 🙄). Hope not delivered when. “She who must be obeyed is in 😲
    Regards
    x The Bigfella x

  • @danielsellers8707
    @danielsellers8707 7 місяців тому

    For me it would be the Vitrains as not made in China:-)

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  7 місяців тому

      Most things are made in china 🤣

    • @danielsellers8707
      @danielsellers8707 7 місяців тому

      @@IronHorseRailways That's why I go for vintage items; my laptop was made in Germany & my phone in Vietnam.

  • @davidbell2613
    @davidbell2613 Рік тому

    This loco has stay alive fitted from factory

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      Yes it does, but does not work unless your system has a certain voltage ⚡⚡

    • @davidbell2613
      @davidbell2613 Рік тому

      @@IronHorseRailways like DCC 19v ?

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      @@davidbell2613 probably a bit much, 16 is ideal or so I'm told

  • @johnelliott1146
    @johnelliott1146 Рік тому +1

    If you don't want details don't buy it , most people who buy these models want details .

  • @paulkandi
    @paulkandi Рік тому +2

    Yes, far to many bells and whistles, at a price we cannot afford, this will drive the market down, not up, as Hornby have found, you can easily lose a great number of the functions, who needs carriage doors, frying the drivers breakfast and guard’s whistles, all cheese if you ask me, £350 is a once in a lifetime purchase for me anyway, but we shall see…?

    • @IronHorseRailways
      @IronHorseRailways  Рік тому

      To be fair mate, this is gorgeous 😍
      Well worth the £260 I paid - The Bachmann's not gonna get a look in for me!😎