Knick Knack: 1989 vs. 2003 Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 сер 2021
- spot da diff
For fan-trailers, tributes, intros, compilations, and other mash-up videos, subscribe to me (if you want to)
Check out My Best Work playlist: • Best of CaptainJZH
My Twitter: / captainjzh
My Tumblr: / captainjzh
My Instagram: / captainjzh - Фільми й анімація
![MADTV - Spy vs Spy - Season 2 [1996]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/F-reFzsoHbE/mqdefault.jpg)
John Lasseter, who directed Knick Knack, said that the decision to reduce the cup sizes of the girls was Pixar's, not Disney's. To my understanding, back in the early days of Pixar (and the early computer graphics scene in general back then), the people there were young, and the working culture was frat-like. Nowadays, those animators are older and likely have kids who watch their films, so they are more conscious of what they're including in their films. Lasseter said of the original characters' cup sizes, "It was just crossing the line for me personally as a father."
"The only difference is the colo-... _oh my god-"_
Imagine going back into an animation file from the late 80s to de-honkerfy a couple of the 3D models, lol
@maddox121 it is to Disney as bouncing is to Tigger.
70s and 80s
Star wars and Transformers
I'm having an awful day and your comment made me laugh so hard, thank you
@@Attmay tbf pixar said it was their choice to change it, not disney's.
"de-honkerfy" 😂
The original "pixar mom"
2003: Flat body
1989: *B* *O* *O* *B* *S*
Now I know what the snowman really wanted 😂
Bewb
They removed the honker smokers, dejadejangels, the women's coconuts, the kidney distributor.
Just say [Drake And Josh]
Pixar was Spicy back them
One thing to remember is that the 2003 version was released alongside a family friendly movie, and given how sensitive censors are they would’ve had a field day with that one. Meanwhile the original was released at a film festival or expo, giving the animators a lot more freedom
@@Swampert384 Disney thinks large chested women don't exist in real life. Wokeness is misogynistic.
So is nobody going to talk about the absolute banger of a song in this short
Bro Bobbie mcferrin is talented omg
0:36 ain’t nobody gonna talk about this though?!
That's why I came to watch it.
@@PropellerMarioBrothers2012she lost her boobas rest in peace boobas
Ya the aCapella
The breast reduction surgery was a success, I suppose.
Man, that really is a hard ass snow globe...
Not harder than me tho🗿
Lol
@@chadael622Ms. Miami got me acting up 🥵🥵🥵
@@chadael622Or the snowman 💀
Must be quarter inch thick glass!
I don't see a difference really
EDIT: *WAIT WHAT THE FUCK*
This is officially my favorite comment on this video lol
heh, boobs
Quagmire: Giggity Giggity Goo!
much better quality images, that and she got a boob reduction. LOL
@@mallorymcguire833 reduction is kinda an eufemism lol
Yeah I see a couple massive differences
Two, in fact
Yeah same here
@@CaptainJZH4
The fact that they went from massive magumbos to a completely flat chest makes me think this change was done very begrudgingly by some pissed off animator at the behest of an executive, like "oh you don't like the tits? well here you go!"
It's to tone down from being inappropriate since it was for children
@valhatan3907 but naturally, big breasted women exist in real life. So making her flat kinda erases that representation. Plus, the short was made for both kids and adults. It was also done for artistic reasons and getting rid of the jugs makes it less impactful. Also, plenty of women in animation made for a wide audience have nicely sized chests, so it's ridiculous anyway.
@@william3100 They do exist in real life, but I think the problem mostly came with how she was presented in the first place. For a kid's movie, a tiny bra that ridiculously small IS rather um... out there. The bazungas themselves were also MASSIVE in comparison to how cartoonishly skinny she was! What I mean here is, it was essentially putting gigantic watermelons on a stick figure, which somewhat understandably didn't jive well with the higher-ups.
Arguably, the back arch and wide ass hips definitely changed the vibes with or without the flat chest
The man who made it had kids in between knick knack and finding Nemo and decided to change it for that reason
1989 is better warmer colors and definitely fits the timeline
I also like the bazoongas they put in
I hate it when they censor the past, im not saying remaking the thing is bad but they should make it available for archival's sake. They made the girl with big bazoongas, they should live with it. This screams george lucas original theatrical release of star wars, being lost in the sands of time.
@@rustylarry7465 doesn’t the video you’re commenting on fulfill your request?
@@anth636 no
1989 is better because the SIZE of things
3:13 that blah blah blah is hilarious
It sounds a lot like squidward
Agreed.
@@dreamguardian8320 me too
Me too when I was a kid my cousin of mine says blah blah blah to my great grandma and she said no blah blah blah
@@giovannipenate5325 lol
Bonus at 2:30, that squeaking sound effect in the original 1989 version of Knick Knack is replaced with a “running glass tapping” sound effect in the 2003 edited version.
0:13
yes and i kinda like the tapping sound better
My eyes keep going to the left of the screen
Get a doctor
Same brother, lets ignore it together and appreciate life...
@@Golden_ScrewDriver Amen
There's a dude on YT making a "Courage The Cowardly Dog" game.
So far the gameplay is 😑👌
Wow I wonder why🤔
In 2003, before the short starts, there is a card reading "In 1989, six years before Toy Story, Pixar Animation Studios made this short film." but in 1989, this card is absent.
In 2003, the 1995 logo is used, but in 1989, the 1986 logo was used.
In 2003, the background of the title card's logo is slightly different.
In 2003, the lighting is slightly different as compared to in 1989.
In 1989, the girl on the Miami knick-knack has large breasts unlike in 2003, which she doesn't have them because it was possibly considered offensive. A similar thing goes with the girl on the Atlantis knick-knack but with different lingerie.
In 2003, the Dolby Stereo logo is slightly different as compared to in 1989. The copyright information in 2003 reads "(c) (the copyright symbol) 1989" with an extra "(c) 2003" instead of the word "copyright" followed by MCMLXXXIX (1989 in Roman numerals)", in the Helvetica font rather than the Eurostile font.
After the credits, in 1989, it cuts to the Knick Knack logo then fades to black, but in 2003, it just cuts to black.
In 2003, the sunny jamaica tree has different number of leaves than in 1989.
In 2003, the width of the video is increased compared to in 1989.
0:35 Disney did this edited version in 2003 to avoid being to "adult"
I think I've watched this film on my mom's phone or something because I have a feeling that I remember it
the "different lighting" is the pink tint, which is an artefact because it's super old, sailor moon has the exact same issue
They made Sunny Miami flat as her state. Quite sad indeed
This made me exhale air out my nose.
@@thedudewithasanspfp, your name made me exhale too. Good day kind sir
Damn if only miami had her
Atlantis too 😢
I'm honestly not seeing a big difference between the tw...OH MY GOSH!
Others: Alright!
The woman and mermaid : that's what I look like in the future well we don't have the same boo-
i imagine being trapped in a snowglobe is distressing
Love the color in the original release
Literally only remade this to remove the cannons. Those babies lit my brain on fire as a 5 year old lmao
@yoced1468
I've never heard of boobs being referred to as "cannons". "Cannonballs" would make more sense. How did you see the original version?
@@Optimegatrongodzilla calcium cannons
I suppose it's kinda like calling your muscles "guns"
I suppose they still blind you when they "flash."
@@hondaaccord1399 I guess.
I think we all know the difference
The channel flipping scene in Toy Story 2 features a screenshot from the uncensored version.
Wait, seriously?
Well, now people are gonna be playing the film frame by frame to find it
@@Daboypurplharti think is the scene were ham is switching the channels tryng to find the comercial from Al’s barn
Yup you can see it If youre fast
imagine the higher ups telling the animators what to change
I still feel the coolest dancing object is Egypt Pyramid
"Boobs are offensive, instead we must make an impossibly thin beauty standard."
Blame Disney
Go on a treadmill
@@idkanymore3382 na, pushups (not too many). Then you get the skinny and the boobs.
Unique! 🤌
I would say the previous was an impossible beauty standard as well haha.
Me see the thumbnail: that’s probably click bait.
Me after watching it: that’s not click bait.
At this point, if Pixar is ever going to make another Easter Egg/Reference of this short in any of their upcoming movies, I’m hoping to at least see Miami and Knick being together, maybe even cuddling or holding hands. I just really want to see them happy and in love after being apart for their whole lives.
There’s barely any fanart portraying their relationship and I’m a bit sad about it. You’d think after nearly 40 years there would be plenty of ship fanart, but no, they only draw Miami…
I think its because he never got the chance to be with her in the first place. But I do agree, it be cute to see them together
40 years?!? Barley 32 years lol
Still this is incredible for 1989, before i was even born
Who cares about Knick or Miami.
Sunny Egypt is where it's AT. (I'm joking btw if you're emotionally invested in them, you live ur best life)
@@StoutShako Okay Sunny Egypt is the coolest out of all of them
With help from "Steve Jobs"
Thee steve?
ligma balls
Yeah Steve Jobs and George locuas made pixar
The Creator
Steve Jobs funded Pixar when the founding members left Lucasfilm
It would be interesting if for the 10th anniversary of Toy Story, Pixar would either put in a remastered digitally-transferred version of Tin Toy or a re-scanned print of The Adventures of André & Wally B.
10th anniversary of Toy Story? Toy Story is 27 years old by now.
@M. Zacharias895 oh, I understand. Just bad phrasing then
And Knick Knack is 33 years old
Fun fact: they actually included the first five Pixar shorts on the CAV Toy Story LaserDisc box set, complete with unedited Knick Knack.
Yeah, but then they gave Andre just a humongous ass
This is still my favorite Pixar short. It still holds up pretty well when considering the tech they had in 1989 VS. today. That wood grain on the shelf looks pretty realistic!
The Sunny Miami/Atlantis knick-knacks were basically PIXAR's prediction of Big Hero 6's Aunt Cass mommy-milker-mod incident,
but in reverse.
That was the least of the problems with that franchise, and most of them had to do with the TV version.
The remade/updated version of the short was first made available to the theatrical screenings of Finding Nemo during its initial theatrical runs.
The pyramid do be vibing though
0:36 WHERE ARE THEY
0:59 it explains why the snowman was so thirsty for her 😂
So these are some of the toys Andy’s mom keeps in her room
Only differences I could note were the intro, slight improvements to the lighting, and, well, we all noticed the other one.
The original looks fitting with the warm colors and 35mm film master. Also, more Bobby McFerrin in the original due to longer credits sequence. The 2003 version just looks sad, because the colors are washed out and it looks like an amateur render by today's standards.
Also, everyone else has talked about the obvious at this point, so no, I will not be stating the obvious, here.
I heard that the warmer colors are there due to the film being worn out, or the fact that they had to point a camera to a monitor to record the film,
They should've remastered the colors of the 2003 version.
Regardless of the reason, it wouldn't of taken any effort to just edit the lighting in post... Not sure why they settled with those mediocre, gross, washed out colors.
he could've just ask the others for help to flip over the snow globe and pull him out of there, lol
To them, it might've sounded like gurgles and bubbles, similar to how the fish from Chicken Little talks
And aren’t they like… melded to whatever they’re standing on?
Both have their charms
Sunny had bigger charms in the original.
@@harrymason4300 Almost as big as Jessica Rabbit's.
Knick Knack had a reason to get out of that Snowglobe back in 89
Should've just kept the pink filter, it looks cute
You know what they actually should've kept
1989: no you were used to give her giant knockers and give it a brighter filter
2003: I COULDVE HAD KNOCKERS!?
They really made her chest big in the original version lol
No, they made her chest small in the 2003 version.
Almost as big as Jessica Rabbit's.
@@harrymason4300 did you misread what they said lol
The warm colors in '89 made the original look too bright, so I guess they washed the colors to make it look more "in this time". I don't know why they shortened the end credits for the rerelease. That was their decision.
i think the 2003 version is how the short's supposed to look too.
I know I see a lot of Sunny Miami art all over the net, and now I get why.
Dunno why they had to flatten her completely, maybe just shrink the chest down just a little and it’d still be appropriate.
Nah bro pixar wildin' 💀💀💀💀💀
sim e eu gosto que eles tenham experimentado mais
'' the fuck u mean difference there is no dif- HOLY GUACAMOLI-''
Another proof that Pixar prefers butts
I think I saw the 1989 version in a pirate DVD when *I WAS A KID* 💀💀💀
Ok
I like how knick put in his nose 1:30
2:23 I remember the remastered version of Knick knacks from finding nemo in the theaters and 📼 when, I was 6 years old.
whyd they nerf her???????????????????????
"For kids show" stuff
Because apparently kids can't handle 2 spheres representing a part of a barbie doll's physique
Because they act like kids won’t see women with that physique
si és molest que censurin cada estona
RIP two large circle models
Despite the knick knack girl's "family friendly'ification" she still bad af in 2003
Fr
THEY REMOVED HER BOINGS
04
I always hated this short. I felt terrible for the snowman cuz he's the only one trapped in a snow globe😢
Masahiro Sakurai saw this change and went “I want that for Zero Suit Samus.”
Well, DeviantArt had a field day with the original version. And I should know, I’ve seen them while on that site. TFs, Breast expansion, NSFW stuff and all! Why are they drooling over a plastic Miami knick knack again is far beyond my comprehension. As a DeviantArtist myself, it eludes me.
They want to see the snowman rail her is my guess
At this point, I'm not even surprised any longer. It's the internet. 'Now I've seen everything.' Is a phrase I've found myself repeating every time I see something new online.
@@princesscadance197 Mmhm.
1:45 i think i like the original better..
14 years after Knick Knack released.
Not sure, they were first appeared on Toy Story 2 since 1999. This lady had big boob in there.
My siblings and me used to love this short when we were younger :3
Man I'm surprised that they didn't rework toy story 2 when it came to the 1989 version because in the modern version of toy story 2 they didn't redid the parts where they smallen the area
3:00 bro was tryna pull a quagmire
This lady with big boob still there on TV at Andy’s room in Toy Story 2(1999)
Damn, the budget cuts were enormous.
*film by: John Lasseter*
That explains it
Did anyone else realize that this short was in Toy Story 2 except me?
Yeah along with other Pixar shorts
Basically in 1989 they uncensored it and in 2003 they censored it
Disney sucks
@@parkercowan8648 It was Pixar's decision.
Lol awe hell yeah I see it 🤣🤣
cencoring art is wrong to me.
@@dandycrow2821 artists should be prevented from retroactivly cencoring theyre own work, its no longer just theyre personal property once they have released it to the public.
Honker badonkers got me gloingeling my shploingidy
I think the 80s/90s had a stroke that day on women's watermelons.
They look to me like most vintage Playboy models.
Loved this short
The 2003 version is definitely better. But I suppose the 1989 version fits in better with its time. Since people did seem to have a thing for characters with big breasts back in the 80's and 90's. I watched this short film in the Cinema along with Finding Nemo. I watched it again after seeing what else was on my Finding Nemo VHS and found it rather boring. I was only 8-9 and didn't understand what the point was.
I watched it again when I was 15 and I actually wondered if I was out of my mind, allowing myself to rewatch it. I couldn't remember anything from it the last times I saw it except the characters Knick Knack, Sunny Miami, and Sunny Atlantis. Only that I remembered finding it boring. However I understood what the point of the short was.
And I actually found it a lot more interesting, especially after finding out that there were two versions of it. I actually thought that Sunny Miami and Sunny Atlantis were the same character originally, and that Sunny Miami somehow got into the fish bowl so that Knick would have another chance to reach her.
I find it irritating that none of the uploads of the 1989 version are in good quality. Since it complicates seeing if there are any further differences besides the breast size and the clam bra in the place of starfish pasties.
Theres bo differences they kept it pretty fairhful.. just removed the girls Double D’s for A cups.
@@chrisbeach423 Bo differences?
@@c.syde65 I believe he meant no differences
@@Berbo22 Oh, okay.
@[GD] Annoe it was a tech demo more than anything
Ok they dehonkified her but you gotta remember, they only did it because the short was shown in front of a g rated Pixar film. It makes sense.
no more booba..........
Me sad [Insert monkey noises]
Nope :(
D:
:(
Booba is Useless
so im the re release shes flat chested and the colors are more enchanced, tink sounds are made when the snow man is running when the snow globe is falling, plus the mermaid wers sea shells insteand of starfish, and the credits cut the ending song short
I still find it ironic that years after it was censored, John Lasseter would get the boot. And mind you; he did the changes to be a little more mature than just boob jokes.
The girl in the 1989 version was crazy💀💀💀
The big guns were removed in favor of little pistols.
"WHERE ARE THEY?!"
Small chested women need love too! Glad they showed some appreciation towards us!
That snowman is simping so hardly💀💀
This short film gives me such a visceral uncanny feeling that I can't even explain. It makes me feel so damn uncomfortable
Maeby is claustrophobia
disney was fucking wild back then 1:57
"what, it's just an ordinary- OH MY GOODNESS"
"SQUIDWARD!"
Goodness this very moment this comment is posted I never knew the changes from the original were made nor I knew the original version
0:01
1:26 DISNEY PIXAR!
Ngl, not a fan of the original. It just looks odd. Flat chest also puts more emphasis on the legs. That being said, though, some booba wouldn’t have hurt!
congrats to them on their top surgery
Why did they make her flat
So you are telling me. The same dude that made the iphone,helped produced this film
no wonder why he wanted to escape
I had no idea the Sunny Miami chick and the mermaid had big cans in this short film.
Omg! I forgot about this old animation of pixar.
Only because adults would enjoy this original version, John Lasseter wouldn't like this.
Really have you watch John Lasseter newest movie, Luck, the body design of Sam Greenfield.
@@josephtafur she is beautiful regardless
My mom would hate the original. She is always badmouthing and complaining about how all female characters have huge boobs every time she’s sees me and my brother watching anime.
this looks like something that big idea would make