Israelis: Was your family here before 1948?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 жов 2015
- This project is made possible by donations from viewers like you. Please donate to the project at: www.gofundme.com/Ask-Project
.
Want to know what Israelis and Palestinians in the Middle East really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers.
People ask Israeli Jews, Arabs and Palestinians questions. I go out and ask random people to answer.
poland italy germany hungary russia tunisia morrocco yemen georgia bulgaria irak turkey romania.......i didnt realise palestine was such a popular holiday destination
I like you
DJ - trouble is, they won't go home.
@@horacetwiddlepass2714 probably something to do with the fact that Jews aren't welcome in Iraq, Algeria,Egypt,Poland etc.
israel lived all over the worl and then they started taking ober cuntrys
LMAO 😂
I am a Palestinian Christian born and raised in Jerusalem as my father and his father and his father before him and so on. I left abroad after high school to study and when I wanted to go back the Israeli government will not allow me entry and I was sent back. Now if I want to go back only on a tourist entry. Same thing with my sister whom she married to a Greek and the Israelis will only permit her a tourist visa.
Are you Orthodox?
@@scorpiong0 Really, not Orthodox? Too bad?? I cannot believe
@@scorpiong0 I do not believe this. Most Palestinians are Orthodox! Not roman-catholic.
@@robinsteendam1311 most christians in the middle east and palastine are orthodox
Respect from an egyptian muslim
@@hemafalcon629 Yes! That sounds better!
Orthodox is real Christian! Orthodox is much, much better than Roman-Catholic and or Protestant.
Next question:Ask them why did they came??
This is why they came:
"And the Lord said to Abram after Lot had parted from him, "Please raise your eyes and see, from the place where you are, northward and southward and eastward and westward.
For all the land that you see I will give to you and to your seed to eternity."
(Genesis 13:15-16)
@@saarodedharan7963 Most of the Israelis are atheists dude, they dont care about this. And for the religious Jews they came because of Zionism and not because of what you mentioned
@@karimm2 "Most of the Israelis are atheists dude" - According to the Guttman Center of the Israeli Institute for Democracy, 80% of the Israelis believe in G-d. What is your source? As to the Zionists, where do you think they took the idea of coming to the promised land from?
@@saarodedharan7963 Most teenagers are atheists from a survey which i read a while ago, i dont remember which one. But Jews are not supposed to have a land till the Messiah come, but Zionists want to take God's plan in their own hands. Why do you think there still 6 million Jews in the US who refuse to come to Israel, thats more Jews than in Israel. They at least follow the real Tora instead of the Torah of the Zionists where they changed it so they could take land by force.
@@karimm2 OK, you have some point. But now that Jews live in Israel (me included), do we have the right to live here according to the Torah or not? According to the Torah, since I'm here, not only that I have the right to be here, I'm not allowed to leave (except in very specific conditions). And yes, according to the Rambam, most of the Jews will live here (Kibbutz Galuyot) ONLY AFTER the holy temple is built.
Identity crises level 100000 😂
😅
🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😁😁 yeah yeah yeah
You wish.
I'm Palestinian, my mother's side has been in Haifa since the early 1800's and God knows how long my father's family has been in Gaza
Nora Daoud my origin is Palestinian my family is there since the start of Palestine that my city isn't in the map any more but if u searched family name u will find it was since the start of Palestine I can't give the name cause dose not allow me to
LOL!!! But if you ask them where their ancestors came from, you probably gonna hear Syria, Egypt or Saudi Arabia!!! The Arabs are NOT natives to that land, no matter how many times you will repeat this lie!!! There are many Jewish families in Israel who's ancestors never left their land since ancient times, which is much longer than the 1800's FYI.... so what exactly is your point???
@@lellablue , Please, spare us your false and idiotic Islamo-Fascist propaganda. No one is buying your twisted history facts and nonsense, except for loonies like you! Thanks.
@Gabro Ego First, I do not believe in a book written to suit certain interests. Incidentally, to be quite honest, archaeologists and historians have no evidence of Abram's existence. And in that sense, a book with all possible absurd facts is even less lawful as proof. And at the possible time when Abram existed, his family's probability of being Arab is far greater than that expressed in this book of mythological fables. For the Arabs were nomads. It is clear to anyone who supports this genocidal state called Israel any excuse is good
Mariam Alammar ,
Sorry to break this for you... Most Israelis today are of Middle Eastern origin and from Arab countries. The fact that some of them returned to their original homeland from the rest of the world, including Europe, doesn’t make them less Jewish, or less belong to that region! So much for your bullshit propaganda against Israelis. Learn the facts before you come here with your nonsense!
hello multinational peoples..... is this a country or a fifa world cup!?
kadi zenda well said my friend 😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Hahhhahha
can you please make it even less clear??
hahahahaha 😅😂😂😂😂😂
Where was my family before 1948?
Oh, just before 48 they were in concentration camps.
Woman jewish israeli soldier, laughed hard, feel bad, bet my grandparents hate me right now.
tunisian jews came from the fall of Jerusalem (roman empire) compare how they look and speak hebrew to ashkenazi ;)
I am a Palestinian Arab from the city of Hebron. We have extant documentation of the presence of my family (ancestors) in Hebron from the 17th century, and consecutive and continuous documentation of our presence up to the present day, with my family being one of the larger families in Hebron currently. All of these documents are kept in the Islamic Court of Hebron and are available for research purposes upon inquiry. Other Palestinian families have documentation that even precedes that of my family, standing as a testament to the roots of the Palestinian people in Palestine.
so is it Hebron or Al Khalil?
@Dave Amer From the 17th century. The Jews were there in the 1st century. And except for a 70 year visit to Babylon for 2000 years before that.
Most of the "Palestinians " are descendants of farm laborers who came to work for Zionist farmers.
@@markhorton3994 Right like who cares is the Palestinians have been there for who knows how long. Britain gave Israel to the Jews.
@@cracked1006 Not only are most of the Jews there because of Zionism ( most other peoples have homelands, they want their historical homeland) so are most of the "Palestinians ". In 1900 there were very few people there. A few towns inhabited by people whose ancestors had been thete for millennia. And Jerusalem.
Then the Zionist movement led to Jewish farmers buying land. Those farmers needed employees, farm laborers. Those employees are the "Palestinians ".
Actually Britain and the UN tried to split the land between Jews and Moslems. ALL of Israel's neighbors attacked the very day Israel was declared a country destroying that first plan. "Palestinian" violence has destroyed every agreed upon plan since.
@@markhorton3994 Right. Excellent summary. Most people dont know this and go off of the lies in the media.
israelis came from all over the world, plaestinians are the true origin of the land.
mohd harith I am a devout Muslim. How can you say that the Palestinians are the original inhabitants when Allah says in the Quran: "Bani Israel", meaning "the children of Israel", referring to the Jews?
sure Palestinians were there first but Palestine was not just arab, jews Christians and muslim arabs all lived in palestine
Deciduous Horn dear first prophet Abraham came the land was called Palestine....not the land name was islarel
MAAZ SHAKIR Mughal
Let's see if what you say is true or propaganda. One of the earliest mention of Israel can be found in the 9th Cen. BCE archaeological find the Mesha Stele, commissioned by the king of Moab (present-day Jordan), where he mentions Israel and a king of Israel, namely, Omri. The Mesha Stele is housed at The Louvre in Paris, France.
If you claim Palestine precedes Israel, and that the land belongs to the "Palestinians" then it should be reflected in the archaeological records. Cite one archaeological evidence for the "Palestinians."
Deciduous Horn dear I said that the prophet ABRAHAM was sent to the land which was called Palestine way before the born of 12 groups of islarel...
even the French when they stole Algeria, did not pretend they were from there
Darius B 123viva Algeria 🇩🇿
There wasn't a country called "Algeria" when the French colonists came there actually, it was a territory in North Africa ruled by the Ottomans
jloo75 I’m not Jewish and I’m anti-colonialist actually, I’m just sticking to historical facts, we could still discuss about them but there are also accurate facts with which we have to agree together btw
NightcoreEutopia I was initially replying to a comment mentioning Algeria, why do you bring Palestine in ? Palestine was and still is the territory of Palestinians, which means the arab-speaking population autochthonous to this region
Because the French really weren’t from there, while Israel is the ancestral home of the Jews
I met a guy who is Israeli. And when I asked where his parents are come from he doesn't want to tell me. But I'm so curious because of all this things that's happened. I want to understand and know more about Palestine.
Probably their grandparents suffer from after ww2... If they are mainly Jewish people who came from Europe.. you don't need to ask them. They have their own horror if they escape Europe after Ww2 or around that timeline. It's obvious enough.
@@ladycommentor2536 still they came from somewhere and so ungrateful to the palestinian
if your so curious i can tell you my story. well im from israel and both my grandfather was born here in 1929 and my grandmother were born here too before 48 but i dont remember the year
my grandfather and my grandmother both fought in the PALMAH that was the israeli rebel army before 48. my grandfather did fight in 48 arab israeli war. then in those times my grandmother and my grandfather moved and build a house that i actualy live in right now, later in hes live he became a sailor. my grandfather is still alive hes 91 and hes very fit going to the beach every day to talk to his friends he goes on walks and help us if we need him. and for my grandmother she died.
@@sarina4903 what do you mean palestine? you mean in gaza? or somthing else
@@sarina4903 well first palestine was never a country it was just a land that other empires and countrys controlled in so i belive israel was the first country here, i dont realy care if they will make a country here. but i just know they will use there power to hurt us but theoretically i dont mind it unless they want any of our land back.
secend i dont support taking somone home but war changes the borders and you need to deal with it realisticly, this war happened alot of time ago and there isnt mutch to do with it now, the only thing they can do is come with peace to us because we are far more stronger. other than that i love israel and i love the land.
Notice how most of the people don't really know when their family came, but want to believe it was before 1948.
My grandfather was born here in 1933 but I do not remember when his grandparents came. They don’t need to believe anything if they know their grandparents were born here pre 1948. If you know you’re third generation to be born here for example, wouldn’t it make sense their family was here pre 1948?
The question is so biased.... why would it matter if they were there for 20 generations or not? Britain gave them the land, it's theirs. End of story
Correct
Britain didn't give the land to moroccon 🤣🤣
@@cracked1006 It wasn't Britain's land to give tho. End of story
so basically most of them are not from palestine and are recent immigrants
3rd generation is not recent
That is recent. NONE of them have ancestors that continuously lived in Israel
The same can be said for most Palestinians.
That proves they are just a bunch of invadors, as you see multiple races coming from all over the world and colonising the palestinian land
No, the palestinians lived there for thousands of years, look at their faces, they all look the same because they are the native people of that land. The british colonisation of Palestine brought the jews from other countries before 1948 to colonise the palestinian land.
Haha see ? They all came from different countries , yet say it's their country 😂😂
+falesTEEZ somebody's mad . Truth hurts man :/
+falesTEEZ kos om israhell :)
Were expelled from Israel to Europe and other countries, all because of the Romans Because of the history , jewhis
Like most countries. In NYC, almost no one is more than 2 generations in the US. The left: we can't kick illegals and anchor babies out of the US because it's all they know.
Also the left: We should kick Jews out of Israel even though it's all they know.
You can say that about every country in the world
How could someone sleep in a stolen home...I just can't believe it that there are humans like that
maybe Muhammad can tell you
@@jerryk6587 no one expected a better answer from a moron like you
@@jamalikram7806 Because you dont know how islam colonized israel, doesnt mean you could accused someone disagree with you...
@@septcinq1931 I am assuming he is talking about any of the numerous times this area has been conquered and changed hands. More than 20 times.
For some perspective here this would be like the mayans or aztecs showing up today in the Americas and claiming the land because of their religious texts. And then all the governments of earth agree with them and start giving them aid and then only reporting news from their perspective.
I don’t think anyone would just bend over and let them have your homes. I wouldn’t.
@@gr3g3t the Christians took the land from Jews, we simply took it from the Christians not he Jewish know your history dumbass
Fake it until make it lol they just try to say we are born here as much they can.
Or....maybe they actually were born there 😱 Just because u repeat a palestinian lie a million times doesnt make it true.
The area was only called Palestine for 27 years when the british had the mandate. Before that it was the ottoman empire.
Perhaps u should read a proper history book before you go spreading false information about matters you have no knowledge about other than what you’ve probably just heard from your arab friends.
@@GearHeadz101 actually look back in time and you can see on the map of old biblesand ottoman maps before biritish owned it. most of these people have no ties to israel only the original arab jews should be allowed to stay the rest should leave.many ofthese people are given free adnthat are taken away from palestinians. the palestinians jews arabs and christians were living there peacefully untill zionists came and many of the arab jews even claim that.
Again! When you read history, this was never a country named Palestine. Arabs who come out to the media holding a key and weep, yes they used to be in this land- same as those who are Arab Israelis today. The truth is: Arabs were never the permanent inhabitants of this land, yet they were immigrants from the surrounding areas, mainly from today's Syria for work and business, only after the Jews started to plow and plant the arid desolate land!
Arabs lived in this land for 3 or 4 generations at tops!
Go read some real history and stay away from your Islamic Arabist narrative!
It's hilarious how you make that connection between the ancient enemy Philistines to the very recent Arab immigrants in the land as if you are talking to illiterate!!
No one has faked nothing! Again, the lack if knowledge and plunging into the sea of illiteracy and misinformation your media is full of have resulted in this kind of fanaticism! You guys need to educate yourself! Jews were expelled to everywhere in the world... the fact that you mock their return and wonder how this could be is so ridiculous and means one thing: illiteracy! How on earth all these people coming from all directions would "pretend to be Jews" and come to "occupy" your "country", if we go with your sick narrative??
How would anyone convince them to disguise as Jews (lol) and tell them: guys come on! Get your talits and kippas on and let's take this land that "belonged" to the Arabs?
Very sick illogical narrative and so baseless!
Da**n it man! You definitely have something wrong with you! Logic is not in your lexicon!
If you tried to ask them in which year they came ? without mentioning 1948 you might hear different answers.
Favorite true
I dont think so . They didnt know the purpose of the video. And anyway in Israel it doesn't matter when you came. It doesn't ring any bells.
Yes their faces can tell the lie
damn true
strongly agree
cant get it !! they all came from different countries and they still saying that palestine is their country ?!!! 😑😑😑
because thy all have something in common, their cam from same pupil
it's not fair, palestine was good to them, to give them some space in their land but now they're against palstine and swallow palesting with a boom, there were many of children of palestine that now are living without their family... and america and PBB try to cover israel,
you can say the same thing on american people
You can say the same thing about turks
The Almighty said in his sacred book that he was going to gather his children from the four corners of the world. If you don't like it, that is very bad. Your hatred will bring heart problems and they you will die. Once you go to the Most High, be prepared to answer him for your hatred.
When you realize they are ALL settlers..... 😳
All impostors 😅😅😅so where are d original ppl of the land 😂
@@skobodabaws8946
Palestinian are the right owners of the land
@@sultansaeed9163 its a fact
@@sultansaeed9163 They started calling themselves Palestinians in the 1960's.
@@LaidBackDeveloper
I don’t know about that, but I know for sure that Arabs were there before Jews
47% no family before 1948
53% family before 1948
Other then the last guy so let’s say 99% all have family originate from either Europe or Africa or Russia (Asia)
I would also be confident to say that if you ask Palestinians the same question they can comfortably say for more then 5-6+ generations have family who are Palestinians. I would be confident enough to say even 95%
This includes myself. I am first generation born in Britain, my parents were refugees from Tiberius ( al shajara ) my grandfathers uncle is the famous Naji Al-Ali may he rest in peace. My family roots dates back to Palestine for maybe thousands of years. But I know even though I was born in London and I have a British passport if I was to try to return to my homeland it’s not exactly going to be a walk in the park :/
61% of Israeli Jews are Mizrahi, from Arab countries. 800,000 Mizrahi Jews were ethnically cleansed by the Arabs Nations. As refugees with nowhere else to go Mizrahi Jews went to Israel. Cynically Arab leaders knew these Jews could only go to Israel and this would cause more problems for the Palestinian Arabs. What's you thoughts on that double betrayal and do you believe these Jews should be allowed to live in Peace in their historic homeland?
So your family is **Ottoman**
@@davidroscoe3815 You mention arab jews but not the millions of Jews Europeans killed and then later gave a new land to pay up for it? most of the jewish population were in Europe as these countries had bigger population than rest of the countries around the world with the exception of few like those in Asia.
most russians are from the european part.
@@davidroscoe3815 Mizrahi is a political sociological term not ethnic.
So basically almost all people you interviewed are not natives to the land. They just came from other countries. Great, nothing strange here, we all know this.
Yes, they all came after Balfour declaration during the british colonisation of Palestine. I find it ridiculous that there are still people out there who defend Israel!!!!
El Mutilator breaking news Einstein : Islam is a religion not a race . People convert it s like saying All european christians came from Bethleem . U r so dumb
El - Mecca is a much more recent location. The Palestinians derive and have evolved from the Natufians, and have lived on the land continuously for 17,000 years. They have never lived anywhere else.
@@mrsbrownandhercat So called Palestinians are relatively recent immigrants to the land. They were the real thing Invaders and imperialists.
@@RK807 from where exactly?
So nobody in this video has any roots here beyond a century?
i have roots of more then a century in israel
@@user-zb8yk3gh1e then ure the only rightful Israeli but the others r just occupation
Everyone in the video is a descendent of Abraham and Isaac and therefore has their roots in Israel well beyond a century. The Jewish people have had a continuous presence in Israel for over 5000 years.
@@yahiaelshakhs4283 All the Jews have roots in the land of Israel. Their ancestors are from that region. But thanks to the Roman Empire, they got exiled all across the world.
They are Invadors
As a brazilian it's crazy to see so much people knowing about their ancestors so well. Here in Brazil the most of us are so mixed that we don't even know rightly the dates or from where ours ancestors came. I had do make a DNA test to discover this part of my history.
how about them telling half truths?
i think you missed the point of the video lmao
@@aeeshadedic3742 I just commented about my personal reality, but I got the message of the video.
brazil is easy to undersand, some native, some africans, some japanese, some portuguese and a ot of 2nd world war nazis xD
@@evertonpereira14 so what were your Dna results ?
I am an Israeli Jew and my parents' families came from Syria, Morocco and Poland. I was born and raised in Israel and have no chance of living in any of these countries. So where do you expect me to go?
You shouldn't go anywhere Amit, your home where you rightfully belong. Shalom sister.
@@davidroscoe3815 yes but the palestinians should not be kicked out of their rightful home
@@kamsulaman7007Everyone shouldn’t fight all the time because they are all one big family, yes?
And Palestinians? they are refugees all over the world displaced and under occupation?
Not Syria, but maybe Poland or Morroco. There are Moroccan Isrælis who have returned bc of a desire to reconnect to their culture or to seize economic opportunities. Many Arab Jėws were pressured by the Zi0nist movement into leaving comfortable lifestyles. Many realized that they had given up their upper-class statuses (in Arab countries), to become second-class citizens in Isræl, where now most of those in poverty are the Mizrahi & Sephardic Jėws. Ashkenazım hold a majority of positions in academic, corporate, and political power.
Idk why Isrælis act like they have nowhere to go, when America, the UK, France, Germany, Italy, Argentina, etc. have been safe for the millions of them. In fact, Pªlᵉstıne was one of many countries that were on the list for settlement, so the colonial project was generally a political movement - not a religious one. It was a geographic convenience and one in which Britain was a willing partner in advancing Zi0nısm as a colonial collaborator. As many as 600K Isrælis have fled the country over the past 4 months, so it's not like there's any real emotional attachment to Isræl. Most would willingly abandon it in favor of security, especially when the entirety of the nation was sold as a "safe haven". If it can't fulfill this purpose, then clearly Jėwısh people will seek out other places.
Jėws are well within their right to seek safety and security, however they shouldn't do this at the expense of another people's safety & security, especially when Pªlᵉstınıans are natives with full heritage, culture, history, and tribal identity that is rooted to the land. Pªlᵉstınıan native culture has been appropriated by Jėwısh immigrants & settlers, who originally did not practice Levantian customs in the diaspora. They had completely different cultures that they practiced, and then upon moving to Pªlᵉstıne, many of these Jėws seized a culture that wasn't theirs and co-opted it as "Isræli". That's typical of most colonial states, so this behavior comes as no surprise, if I'm being honest. But it's a shame bc for centuries, Pªlᵉstınıan Jėws lived in harmony with Pªlᵉstınıan Můslıms & Xtians, before Zı0nism came along and disrupted a peaceful community.
According to this Video Cleary Most of The Israelis are not indigenous to the Land Palestine or whatever you might like to call it.
by your standarts most palestinians aren't indignous as well
most of them have immigration in their roots. They just immigrated a bit earlier.
+Nathan Abraham most of their families can be traced back to at least 500 years ago we are talking about at least 8 generations most Jews can only 1 generation or 2.there are some Jews who are natives to that land but most aren't and are basically occupiers
+Najah Faysal that is incorrect most Palestinians can't track very far. most came during 1890's the Ottomans and later the British promoted migration to the land. before that it was just uninhabitable with few people
Nathan Abraham Palestinians are Arabs and they all have been livng there since Christianity
+Ansariz Bros most Palestinians are descended from regional migration from other Arab countries induced by Ottomans and British.
People around the World, imagine you live in a country where your grand-grand-grand parents were born, a country lived for centuries by your ancestors that was the majority clearly, and then someone comes from abroad claiming he or she is part of the minority which is ok, but then after 60 years you wake up in a closed area with bombs flying into your house!? How would you feel about that? I mean, everyone migrates, changes land and homes. But what happened in Palestine is a very well organized scenario that doesn't care what was there before.
That's not what happened. The Palestinians are also largely descended of 19th and 20th century Arab immigrants.
nope, most late it's 8th century
I was born in Australia and my parents and some of my grandparents born in Australia. Does that make me indigenous Australian?
Alex Bors
Alright now what's your solution to this?
These children of those people who came should go back where they came from?
Many of them are a mix between Arab Jews and European jews what about them?
xo_silentrealm_xo then does a religion make you indiginous ? It’s like saying catholics are indiginous to italy so if a muslim converted he is somehow considered italian? Can you freaking think before you speak .
Next question: can you show me their visa entry to Palestine?
Can you name me one ruler of Palestine before Arafat?
@@TheDaniel675 Salah aldeen alayoubi 1187
I will be happy if you will tell me the order and history of Israel land....It will be my pleasure
@@DailyTravelGuy King David, King Salomon, Benjamin Zeev Herzel, David Ben Gurion
@@TheDaniel675 you missed alot
More respect needs to be shown to the Palestinian people.
Even more respect should be shown to the Jewish People.
ua-cam.com/video/9Gkm7DOTa7Y/v-deo.html
@@geozap4518 great video thank you for sharing
@@dannyrockdale3915
You're welcome, sir.
But not Israelis?
@@kashoutlenox you mean the immigrants? No they should back to Ukraine and Poland and morocco they got no place in Palestine 🇵🇸
1% before 1900
what is really amazing is the fact that before war a large number of them just came and bought some desert.why ???? if somebody is telling me to buy now some piece of shit in sahara i ll send him straight to hell.unless i have an information ??????
i don t know about any killings ,i know they bought before war ,so they had the information
+Jason Gheynowa we stole europe>?
you are so stupid and monster facked.
*****
so how their is fucking 10 milion of them?
wow what a bs.....
they was in 1948 1.300,000 and know they 10,000,000.
we didnt killed milions only 36,000 in 67 years.
you are or stupid or on drugs.
on you logic their was 10 milion palestinians in 1948, and 600,000 people was killed milions of them....
what the next lie will be?
thet we occupeing the world?
oh yes you maybe think thet to...
*****
we didnt stole what was our land.
it doesnt make any sense.
oh whit i know the land is palestinian land thet they stole this land from us.
accutelly they occupeing the entire middle east and know all the arabs and muslims are try europe :)
thets the true.
so actually who should be called refugees?
@David Miles
No your grandparents
If you want to see refugees then go to Europe.
Only the first generation of Palestinians have the legal right to be called refugees. Only they could technically have the right of return of receive compensation. That is standard for all other refugee groups. Why is it that only Israel has been targeted for abnormal treatment? This double standard is pure and simple Antisemitism.
@@XXX-XXX-XXX-XXX25 : 20 generations? I seriously doubt that. Show us the evidence, deeds, etc.
the old jewish refugees didnt get any sympathy or help, nowadays grandchildren of old palestinian refugees are STILL being reffered to as refugees and recieve billions of dollars from the EU and USA
And you forget to conclude that 100% palestenians were here before 1948. Have a good day
And you forget to conclude that most Arab Palestinians are themselves immigrants to that land from other countries, mainly from Egypt, Syria and Saudi Arabia. Learn history and don't be a hypocrite! Thanks!
@@GPBKM I'm from Haifa , my family has a house there was bulid in 1740 . So wtf are you talking about? You must be ignorant to actually say that Palestinians came from Egypt Syria or whatever. Read about Levant then start pulling that shit out of your mouth..
only one fourth of nowaday palestinians have forefathers, that lived more than 120 years in this country.
3/4 of nowaday palestinians came into the country after 1880, forced by the last sultan of ottoman empire.
He, by the way, tried to ban jews coming to 'palestine' from 1885.
Arabs that came to 'palestine' came from all regions of ottoman empire, morocco, syria, turkey, aso.
You can see it today very often (but not always) at their family-names.
Have a good day.
@@egelisk4943 statistics do not lie: in 1925 only 600k people lived in 'palestine', 1/10 were jewish.
But jerusalem, as stated by a british diplomat, was up to half of jewish residents.
There were even more christians in that time than muslims.
How about that?!
@@andypower5245 Some put the number of jews at 1/20 around that period. Those statistics do indeed not lie, but British diplomats always do. But anyway you are talking about 5-10%. Do you know how many countries in Europr have a Muslim population of more than 5%? It does not give anyone the right to take over the country and treat others as shit and expell them. France has a share of more than 10% Muslims. Should Britain make a balfour declaration for them as well?
It’s the same logic as going to your neighbor’s house and claiming ownership because in 1920 your great grandma lived there.
So not a single Jewish person in this video is originally from Israel. But all other Palestinians are.
+falesTEEZ there are u stupid !
+Neven Tomičić Most Jews were expelled from the land a long time ago, and have slowly made their way back.
He did the same question for Palestinians I believe most of them were from other places. Jews have been in Israel longer, historically speaking, but also in recent history.
Yeah right
What is palestine?
since when it's existence?
Jeshua came to the land of Israel 2000 years ago NOT to "palestine "
so none of them are from there but trying to kick people out lol
theyare trying to put people out? after people kicked them out somehundred years before.
actually the return of the jews is nit a question
What is palestine?
fayssal benhebba no thst would be Hamas who are called terrorists who have proved it by using there so called own people as human shields and killing there own hell even there 3rd in command was killed for being gay lol
@@exdx4138 People which had been killing their prophets during the world history are really terrorists!
The modern and previous masters of puppets took this world in their filthy tentacles. They are controlling nowadays human minds by their mass media and by other sources. Most of people only just puppets for them, but these puppets are in the dark abyss of unconsciousness!
Breuer Imre they could have returned a long time ago, where they were treated better then in the countries where they were in. But they didn‘t move
The majority of those Jews who were in Palestine before 1948 migrated during the British Mandatory, they are European settlers too, if you see Ottoman census there were less than 40000 Jews or around 5% of the total population by the end of WW1.
Theodor Herzl approached the Ottoman Sultan Hamid(Caliph of Muslim World) and said " I want land for Jewish People in Jerusalem. Give them land in Palestine, so it can be home to them. As you know there are some Jews very strong financially, they will not leave your favor without a return. We can pay off all the Ottoman Empires debts that have accumulated in Europe. The only thing we want from you is to sell a little bit of land in Jerusalem. "
Sultan Hamid roared and said " I will not sell even a single inch of land. Because this homeland is for my people not for me, my people got that land with their blood, without it leaving us or going away we will cover it with our blood again. The soldiers of Syria and Palestine were martyred in Plevna one after the another. Not one came back, they all died on the battlefield. It's not for me or the high state, it is for the people, I will not give a piece of it. You will only be able to divide this empire by cutting up our bodies. I will not allow operation on an alive body. I do not allow the establishment of a Zionist state in Jerusalem."
Theodor Herzl says " We do not want to establish a state " Abdul Hamid signals his secretary to show him the photo of Theodor drawing the start of David and says " In the middle is the star of David and asks " What about the two blue lines on top and the bottom?" Theodor says " Its only a sign, there is no meaning for it at all " Abdul Hamid responds and says " Let me remind you of its meaning if you have forgotten Mr Herzl, By Drawing this Flag, you announce your wish of the promised land, Between the Nile and the Euphrates. You screamed that you want a Zionist state between the Nile and the Euphrates. And now I'm announcing and here I'm screaming! SUCH A STATE WILL NOT BE ESTABLISHED AS LONG AS I LIVE! I WILL NOT ALLOW IT, GET OUT! YOU IMMORAL PERSON!
@@samihachem3212 . if someone came to me one day and said hey instead of living with you in your house(which i will accept) i will own half , i would say no no matter one, bc of what right would i give half my home to an immigrant from europe. (i do support immigrants btw just not those like herzl planning to colonise)
@@thetruth9939 i agree with you 100 percent
In the end of ottoman rule their were 85,000 jews there
the Ottomans colonized it from the Romans and the Romans colonized it from the Jews . 2000 years ago Judea was %100 Jewish !!!
Everyone knows what the question means! They all come from different countries and make a different country! Nice!
and stole others country*!
Stole historical land for wars in middle east then play jew and Muslim card
they all came after the balfour declaration, that says it all.
Tommy Steel yes
Tommy Steel that why Iran say always Death to Isreal and his supporter America.
but the DIDN'T.
Tommy Steel Wtf did you watch the video? I cant believe that 118 people are this stupid...
It doesn't change the fact their ancestors were from here.
So all those people are from European origin
How did you arrive at that conclusion? Most of them were of North African origin
North African who came from the Arab invasion.
***** If you follow the Torah, Israel or " land of Caanan" is the caananite africans land, not yours.
But their is no proof that the Jewish or Israelis was EVER in Israel before the Palestianians. So it´s the Palestianians land.
***** According to torah , Abraham was Chaldea in Iraq. The ancient israelittes was really from Iraq not even Israel..So Palestinians and Abraham come from Iraq.
Abraham came from Ur near Harran in northern Mesopotamia, not Ur in southern Iraq. This is a silly modern misconception. All the ancient source point to north Mesopotamia. The rest of the Israelites'' ancestors came from modern-day Syria and Lebanon. But when Israel invaded Canaan after Egypt, many intermarried with local Canaanites. This is why modern Jews are so closely related to other Levantine groups like Lebanese and some Palestinians. The only Jews who resemble Iraqis genetically are Mizrakhi Jews who intermarried with Mesopotamians.
I am Palestinian Christian from Ramallah and my family book has names that go back to 1300 we don’t know before that
ure very lucky. family trees interest me a lot. ive been able to get to (what i think) is the last years of the sikh empire
Why Christians are minority in Betlehem?
@@andikafabian A lot of them was exiled after 1948 because of Israelis, and moved to the west. Palestinian Christian reporter journalist Shireen Abu Akleh, she was murdered by Israeli soldiers this year after coming back to Palestine from America. She never stopped fighting for human rights of her people (regardless religion -Christians, Muslims or Jews, all Palestinians)
Israelis = immigrants Palestinians = natives got it!
Clearly these Israelis from European backgrounds are not Semites. It's written all over their faces.
+Mengani Meerent The "semites" have never existed as a race or an ethnicity. It's a myth anyway.
"Semite" is not a race, it's a linguistic classification just like "Indo-European".
they look shy to answer xD
Mengani Meerent yes
Semities are from africa(haplogroup t and e1b1b and j)
Not from europe
they grew out of northern egypt and never classified as a race but the original semitic language speakers were black
First they came as naked refugees and now killing the one who welcomed them & gave them shelter
Callum Williams you really need to work on your history subject
Callum Williams jews were enemy of prophet who tried to kill him every moment possible
By "welcomed them and gave them shelter", do you mean "shut the doors in their face when they needed shelter the most", like they did in 1939?
***** go to school kid .
zig jonas Let's clarify a point, there was British regime, the British decided to accept the Jews or not, just as the British have received Arabs from Syria and Lebanon and Saudi Arabia and they let him rise .. So do not say that it was the responsibility of the Arabs that is not!
Just search :The Jaffa riots , 1920 Nebi Musa riots ,1929 Hebron massacre ,1929 Palestine riots ( this is call history dude)
So to say that the Arabs embraced the Jews and received them, just check all these events and tell me if that counts for you "welcome"
"If I don't steal your house someone else will"Jacob you friendly neighbour
you mean that he got his house back by law ? because they built their illegaly and took his grandparents property after the intifada.....poor Myriam with no actual education :(
Slavery was legal in USA if you didn't know that
The haulocost was legal in Germany if you didn't know that
Secondly, he said If I didn't "steal it" not "have the right"
Did you understand anything piggy zionist?
@@DailyTravelGuy even Jacob himself didn't say it was his house, he admitted to be a thief. Why can't you be more like Jacob? 😂
@@hazaraudi7488 you don't know law I see...its fine I didn't expect from you to be smart
How are their grandparents born in “Israel” if it didn’t even exist then..?
They were all Palestinian before they were ever anything else
Yes
Can you, or could you EVER point to “Palestine” on a map? Why not?
@@chrispoe8404 how about you google “Palestine map” and see for yourself, Chris.
@@rariyami Palestine was never a country however- it was a territory created by the British in 1920.
@@doat2130 Actually the Roman Empire after 70 AD when they destroyed Jerusalem, renamed Judea and Samaria to Syria-Palestina (Roman province) named after Israel's worst enemy the Philistines (who are ethnically descended from Mizraim / Egypt) - see Genesis 10:13, 14
Today's "Palestinians" are ethnically arabs and don't have a true connection with the original Philistines, they only inherited that name because the land of Judea and Samaria was called Palestina from 70 AD to 1948 AD, thus whoever was living there whether jew or arab was called a Palestinian.
During this period Palestina has been in the control of many powers and nations, the last such being the Britain.
Having 1 of 4 grandparents being born in Israel pre-1948 isn't saying much. That means 75% of their lineage immigrated there after 1948.
Its the other way around actually, the grandparents were imigrants, the kids not
Thats why they never want the refugees to return.. taking the ethnic cleansed instead
%98 OF THE Jews Ancestors came from Judea , DNA PROVES IT
@@thomasvos138 the kids are living in the houses that theirs grandparents stool from the owner of the land.
@@thomasvos138 their grand ma steal the land from Palestinians you idiot
Jews : God gave us Palestine 4000 years ago
Hindus: Vida gave us Europe 10, 000 years ago
According to their logic, Hindus have the right to fight for their land when the get powerful LOL
So how are we going to solve this
Most South Asians have indo-European ancestry traced back to the steppes of Ukraine/Russia above the Black Sea. I guess we can all go ghar wapsi because some of our ancestors left there 4-5000 years ago.
Quotes from Quran Showing that the Land of Israel belong to The jewish People:
5:21
يقوم ادخلوا الأرض المقدسة التي كتب الله لكم ولا ترتدوا على أدباركم فتنقلبوا خسرين
10:93
ولقد بوأنا بني إسرءيل مبوأ صدق ورزقنهم من الطيبت فما اختلفوا حتى جاءهم العلم إن ربك يقضي بينهم يوم القيمة فيما كانوا فيه يختلفون
17:104
وقلنا من بعده لبني إسرءيل اسكنوا الأرض فإذا جاء وعد الاءخرة جئنا بكم لفيفا
@@OrHava6562 When the Quran talks about the children of Israel it is mostly historical Jews. Not 21st century Jewish converts from Europe.
@@CGetRight 60% from Jews in Israel are not from Europe, they are from North africa and the middle west but its doesn't matter because most of Jews today are not converted but native to the land of Israel.
@@OrHava6562 I disagree, many dna tests of regular Jews in Israel show a disproportionate European background even though they may be of Middle Eastern origin. If you study history you would know that the original Jews were almost obliterated by Justinian, and Jewish numbers only swelled when the Khazar Empire decided to convert their whole kingdom to Judaism as they didn’t want to be under the rule of the Muslim Caliphate and the Roman Byzantine empire.
These khazarian Jews went on and populated much of Europe and the Middle East. Then 500 years later, claim the land of sham or Judaea because their European neighbours went on a murderous spree, while the Muslims have almost always gave protection to Jews under their realm.
Im a palestinian and my whole family tree since the great great great grand father they were farmers in this land tell me why again they have more rights in living more than me .
I agree with you, but as a Palestinian Why do you think that is?
Sooo im Irish from 1800s and I can’t go get Irish citizenship from America grow up and move on you’re parents probably lied about your ancestors too
They don't have more rights but the same amount of rights since you've never had your own country and legal immigration is, well, legal
if you ask Palestinians the result will be 100%...thats the difference!!
Oh, really?? So how come their, the so-called "Palestinian" Arabs, have last names such as "al Masri" (the Egyptian), "Halabi" (from Haleb, Syria), "Al Baghdadi", "Souliman" (those who came with Souliman the Magnificent"? Ha???
Most of the so-called Palestinians here, came as cheap labor during the Turkish era and British Mandate. Many of them are also, and it's a well known fact, descendants of Jewish families who remained here during the Roman Empire era and converted to Christianity and then to Islam under the terror imposed on them by Christians (Crusaders) and Muslims.
My family returned to our homeland in 1828 and 1882 out of pure Jewish yearning to the Land of Israel, nothing to do with Zionism at its secular form. There are Jewish families across the country who have never left Israel.
Man, how stupid and ignorant can ppl be??
There are for sure many Jews who stayed in that area for generations, but the majority of Israeli Jews are either from Western Countries or the Middle East if you go 3 or 4 generations back, 90% was not born in Israel or Palestine. But if you do the same thing with the Arabs, 90% or even more have ancestors who were been in Palestine or Israel.
From the 6,5 m Israel Jews the half is from, Europe. Ashkenazi Jews. At least 50% of Israelis Jews have ancestors which had no connections to Israel or Palestine at all before they immigrated.
מרדכי ונעמי כהן A very small minority To find a justification.
מרדכי ונעמי כהן names are influenced from other nations based on similar beliefs, I could argue "Why do many Israelis name their children mohammad?" Is it because they're all Arab? I could ask "Why do Israelis name their children Lod?" Is it because they're all Polish? A name doesn't determine an entire ethnic group.
アニメはクールだ I haven’t met a JEWISH Israeli with Mohammad in his name only the Arab Israelis.
100% originally came from somewhere else, thus non-indeginious. Give Palestine back to its indeginious owners
Most Palestinians' families came from somewhere else. And no, 75% of Israeli Jews are native.
No, there was no nation called Palestine, it was a backwater province of the Ottoman Empire. And my point was that Palestinians have not been living in this place for thousands of years. If you want to say most people in most countries came from elsewhere, the same applies to Jews.
Jews started coming 35 years before the Balfour Declaration, when it was still under Ottoman rule. And Jews came legally buying land. Not to mention the fact that there had been a Jewish population before Zionist pioneers began arriving, and the Jewish presence is thousands of years old. They came peacefully buying the land and revitalizing it to the point many Arabs from other countries wanted in.
The people who seriously tried to kill and steal were the Palestinian Arabs, who attacked the Jews in the 1930s, and then again in 1947 which sparked warfare. It was an attempt to kill and steal, and prevent Jewish independence.
And then what? Turn Israel from a developed country into a vile hellhole breeding more and more barbaric Islamist terrorists trapped in the 7th century in the stupid name of "indigenous owners"?
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
فَإِذَا جَآءَ وَعْدُ الآخِرَةِ جِئْنَا بِكُمْ لَفِيفاً
[الإسراء:104]
سبحان الله وبحمده، كل شيء في كتاب مبين.
@@kararfadialkadwy8838 انت الي وبعدين؟
When we see the commentaries, we can understand that people don't know the means of "diaspora" and the means of "return".
The Morrocans look Moroccan, the Yemenites Yemeni, Georgians Georgian. As you look at the ethnic compositions of countries,Jews are almost always listed seperately. They are regarded as a distinct ethnic group. Why?
@dopamine orbitals No conversion to Judaism is extremely hard if in fact impossible. That is why they are considered as an ethnic group because you are only jewish if your mother is jewish.
Because you can still tell the difference between a mortician Jew to Muslim. Or with all the countries. Also considering we have been dispersed for 2000 years there’s no surprise
@@bendavila3253 no not really you can't lol, religion can't be an ethnic ..
@@firas3634 Judaism is an ethnoreligion much like Hinduism and Sikhism. Under Jewish Law anyone with a Jewish mother is a Jew regardless of whether they practice Judaism or not.
then why are there so many blond hair blue eye Palestinians and Syrians and Lebanese??
Just remember the earliest Jews to migrate back to the Levant were from Yemen not Europe.
So what? Some Jewish communities (Egypt, Yemen, Iraq) are of 1500-2000 years, and they all were looted and uprooted. No Arab government and not a single Arab person were ever remorseful of this. And every one is waiting Jewish apologizes for their presence in the Holy Land. It may be funny, but actually this is tragic and Orwellian
It's better to download this video,in future will not available.
This makes me realize, most of them are from Yemen, Iraq, Tunisia, Marocco, Algeria... Are most israeli jews actually arabs ?
+kitkitbobit no most are russian and from poland
1WildlandFirefighter real jews are people who believe in the jewish religion, nothing more.
1WildlandFirefighter No but I agree with you in the fact that they are all mixed.
Although being hebrew doesn't mean being arab, it means being semitic, like arabs but not exactly the same.
1WildlandFirefighter just like i have the same DNA as a golden retriever.
1WildlandFirefighter What I mean is that all humans share a DNA so searching for identity in a DNA is not relevant.
I'm lebanese but yet if I search my DNA I might find out i'm ashkenazi jew, scandinavian, ethiopian, phoenician or arab, it wouldn't change the fact that I'm lebanese.
Just like you said, those jews are mixed, but just like any other people. DNA searches don't prove anything.
Hahah please! My family still has a house in Nablus which was built in 1878. And we are a relatively a small family.
Still have a house... not for long hahahahah
Wow! Such mentality much wow!
Woe to him who builds a city with bloodshed and establishes a town by injustice
Woe to him who sets his nest on high to escape the clutches of ruin!
Jew can't answer this lol
You have a point. You are making them angry
This is disturbing!!!! These people are so lost it’s unreal. Anything that allows you to sleep at night I guess
What do you mean by lost? Because they don’t know exact years? Do you think that Israelis are scared when they are being asked when their families came to Israel? We love it, that’s what makes our country so unique. We are made out of so many traditions and colors. I am a quarter Lebanese, Iraqi, Polish and Hungarian. My grandfather was born here in 1933 but his grandparents came from Iraq in the late 19th century. My grandmother came from Lebanon when she was 19 and that was several years after the war (after 1948), but idk when exactly.
From my dad’s side my grandmother was born here in 1930 and her parent came from Poland. My grandfather however is a holocaust survivor, born in Hungary and came here right before the war in 1948. We love our lineage and we are proud of it. Do you really think we are scared to talk about it? Do you think we feel guilty for something?
good for you dude. I don't know how you can talk about how you have a family member that survived the fucking holocaust and also say you don't feel guilty for what your government is doing to a whole population. All in the same post. Imagine that man surviving ethnic cleansing only to live under a government who's doing the same to others. 😳
They aren't lost. They are living safely in their homeland, away from angry people like yourself.
Quotes from Quran Showing that the Land of Israel belong to The jewish People:
5:21
يقوم ادخلوا الأرض المقدسة التي كتب الله لكم ولا ترتدوا على أدباركم فتنقلبوا خسرين
10:93
ولقد بوأنا بني إسرءيل مبوأ صدق ورزقنهم من الطيبت فما اختلفوا حتى جاءهم العلم إن ربك يقضي بينهم يوم القيمة فيما كانوا فيه يختلفون
17:104
وقلنا من بعده لبني إسرءيل اسكنوا الأرض فإذا جاء وعد الاءخرة جئنا بكم لفيفا
@@zeenat1196 The quran doesn't mention "Palestine" to land of Israel even one time, you canr rewrite the Quran just for your own purpose.
When I lived in Germany I used to ask Germans if their parents told them about Jewish neighbours who "disappeared" during the Nazi era. (Almost all said no).
I ask a similar question to Israelis: Do you think the land of modern Israel was vacant for 2000 years until the foundation of Israel? What do you think happened to the Christians, Druze, Muslims etc etc who lived there before the foundation of Israel?
Do you care?
It wasn't vacant. Jews still lived there. When the Muslim invasion occurred on 633AD, many Jews were slaughtered again.
@@michealfriedman7084 Palestinians exist there before Islam and before Judaism and even before Abraham. And we all know how Israelites occupied Palestine in first time. And how they got kicked out of it and how they back to steal the land from the Palestinians again.
@@FrauElegante
The Arabs living in Judea/Samaria are not Palestinians.
They are from Jorden, Egypt, etc.
The Canaanites have longed disappeared.
You're more than welcome to go to Israel and see for yourself: the Arabs, Druze, Circassians, Beduins and others still live there. Some are parliament members at the Knesset, some are military officers, the hospitals are full of Arab doctors, nurses and physical therapists, most construction contractors are Arabs, both Muslim and Christian, living a lifestyle you can't even imagine. Oh yea, and if you see a Corvet, Mercedes or BMW in Israel, it's probably owned by an Arab.
The area was barren because it t was controlled by Muslims and it wasn’t considered there #1 holy place compared to Mecca, Medina and Damascus.
Mark Twain writes about how barren the land was prior to ww1.
honestly this land doesnt belong to them as they claim .
that land doesn't belong to any of them
Clarence Leggett that why Iran say always Death to Isreal and his supporter America.
In the clips the trend is that people whose families came from Europe came before 1948 but those from other middle eastern countries came after 1948. This makes sense because once Israel was established in 1948, mainly by Europeans, there was a return to Israel movement in the middle east, some voluntary some not so voluntary.
800,000 Jews were ethnically cleansed from Arab counties, people don't talk about that much as it doesn't suit their narrative.
BUSTED!!!
George Stinney Jr. 😂
The fact they say the came from another country proves that there were no Israel , of u ask phalstinen they well said from phalstine
Like Yasser Arafart, the king of Fakestinians?
He was from Egypt :D
cecil123 he was not from Egypt but he spent his young age in Egypt
Killuminati Army He was an Egyptian. There is no debate about this.
+cecil123 ok what about the rest of the phalstinen 😂 ? All the Israelians are not from Israel are not from this land
+cecil123 they came to this land and the one who was living in this land were originally from Phalistain and then they become israel
It's important to recognize that even before 1948 there was some immigration to Palestine that was discouraged. The British actually stopped Jewish migrants when they realized the social tensions it was creating. Some of those that arrive in Palestine before 1948 were 'illegal'.
Yup. That and the Havara agreement the Na*is made withe germany's J*ws. there were only 56,000 in 1919 and that number jumped to 649,600 in 1948. That wasn't from fertility, that was from immigration.
My father's great grandmother's family had been living in Jerusalem since 1620. My father's great grandfather's family immigrated from Ukraine in 1909. My maternal grandmother immigrated when she was 3, in 1946. My paternal grandfather was born there in '51, his parents immigrated from Ukraine in 1946.
lies 😂
3% population was Jewish during Ottoman Empire time in Palestine. Then your grandmothers family lived back in that time.
Your fathers great grandmothers family were Palestinian Jews , Old Yishu. It s
nice to see examples of their existence. Its really not talked about enough. Jews were an integral part of Palestine along with the other anthemic religions. Wish it stayed taht way. All Palestinians do
How can they say they came to "Israel" before 1948 when "Israel" was established in 1948,before that the whole land was called Palestine !
@David Miles Isreal are the children of Moses not a place... Those who named Palestinian lands as Isreal are subjugators and tyrants...
Actually ... Zionists were being pumped into Palestine ... This was pre Planned Invasion . They could have Given them Florida or Ireland or any other christian country ... but they gave them a Muslim country.
@David Miles By who ?
Jews always lived in Palestine even before Islam.
Palestine is a Roman name for the land of Israel. Arabs didn't call themselves as "Palestinians" until the 60's, and also they are descendants of immigrants from Syria, Saudi Arabia, Egypt (remember Yasser Arafat?), Iraq, Jordan...
Wow Amy Winehouse has come back alive at 6:42 of the video !!
+thevinyls78 Exactly what I thought lol!
+thevinyls78 Yup and Amy Whinehouse was an Ashkenazi Jewess ( Jews who were exiled , ethnically cleansed from Israel and ended up in Europe) while this young woman is Mizrahi ( Jews who were exiled from Israel and ended up MENA -Middle East, North Africa)
+Jacob K Ashkenazi only means German, Most North African Jews are Sephardi which means Spanish, while Mizrahi means Oriental, or Middle Eastern Jews... This mere divisions proof that there is no such thing as a "Jewish people" but a Jewish religious tradition practiced by people from different places.
+Grace Regalado a Jewish religious tradition which is shared by people from all the world speaking the same language alongside the local language, and share the same history as a united people living in Israel. * * * They share this history so profoundly that they read every year the Hagada (which is the story of the Exodus from Egypt) for the past 3000 years(!) either if they live in Yemen, or in Argentina. whether they are religious or secular. * * * It's not a religious act, nor isn't about religion. The Jewish people is so incredible that if it isn't entitled to be called "people" - then no "people" do. * *
+Grace Regalado
Typical Antisemite / historical revisionist
Its funny how they look so much similar to ppl of those countries ..
They look exactly like people in countries their grandparents came from
White people we're not even with Noah
@Juley beeb wait , who killed Jesus , who slaved these people , who genocided these people , who wrote history ,who started as pagan and later on appropriated religion , who created propaganda to enroll pple in the army/crusade
@Juley beeb who modified the bible ? The first Jews and Christians both got massacred by the babylonian and roman empire cmon now and the egypt pharaoh were greek at one point... Cmon now it's pretty obvious that the first inhabitants were black have you read about king David? Solomon? Queen of Sheba?
They are haunted because of their Religion.
If I dont steal your home, someone else will.
you really should go read some books and educated yourself instead of watching the media and not researching for yourself you like a kid that watching tiktok and believe everything holy shit you sad.
@@DailyTravelGuy Jacob summed it up for us all.... Gotta admire a self admitted thief, why can't you be more like Jacob?
Its important to learn history and to know the meaning behind things, After The First Jewish-Roman War (66-73 CE), The Roman's destroyed the second temple and massacre million Jews and exiled the rest from the land of Israel in return for the Jewish rebellion they called this Land Palestine in the name of the biggest enemies the Jews once had which are the Philistines, they were from the greek islands and no longer exist and have nothing to do with islam or arabs. "Philistines" named after a Hebrew name which means Invaders, as it was described by them beacuse they were the enemy. Now that you understand the history of this word please stop insulting Israel by this lie.
@@OrHava6562
History from Zionist side....
Try real scholarship next time...
www.google.com/amp/s/api.nationalgeographic.com/distribution/public/amp/history/article/dna-from-biblical-canaanites-lives-modern-arabs-jews
Who are the invaders again?
@@DailyTravelGuy
Trying to justify ethnic cleansing?
How sad....
My parents told us such nice stories about the jews when they were back in iraq how loyal and honest they were, i wish i can make friends with jewish people and attened the ceremonies eat with them and hopefully visit israel
Shabat Shaloum
Greetings from Iraq , Babylon
My grandfather said the exact same thing. He said he had some class mates that were Jewish and then one year they all disappeared. Such a shame
haha. .paid stooge zionist wearing Propaganda name.
@@imadafghan6825 that was true, Jews were protected by Ottomans and even lived side-by-side with Muslims. But, after the 1948, all changed
@@__Man__ No dude, it was never a peaceful region
@@Rectangleblue where are you from? Are you Levantine locals?
we cant blame israelis for the mistake their grandparents did by coming to palestine. but they must be blamed for continuing obressing palestinians. electing a fundimitalist right wing prime minister. I believe in a one state solution where all refuges have the right to come back and every body is equal in a secular democracy
I would luv to see Jordan annex what is now called Israel and Palestine. One state, free. Palestine.
I love the people saying their parents were born in Israel before it was made a state for WWII refugees.
Yep and yet Arabs welcomed them.
Not really, they are saying they were born "here", literally.
After a time of being preserved in all the countries of the world, the
Jewish people would begin to return to their own land in the last days.
One of the prophecies that states this is Isaiah 11:11-12. It says, “And
it shall come to pass in that day, that the Lord shall set his hand
again the second time to recover the remnant of his people, which shall
be left, from Assyria, and from Egypt, and from Pathros, and from Cush,
and from Elam, and from Shinar, and from Hamath, and from the islands of
the sea. And he shall set up an ensign for the nations, and shall
assemble the outcasts of Israel, and gather together the dispersed of
Judah from the four corners of the earth.”
This religious argument does not hold. Its just a matter of coincidence
in the last days not now ;) now they gotta stop colonizing land
It’s best to read the Old Testament in the original language. I came across an English bible and read through it and found two different passages where in one, a Syrian women comes to Christ and begs him to heal her daughter. Christ in the bible refers to her as a dog. He said: I cannot take the food from the children (the Jews) and give it to the dogs (the Syrian and Palestinian in another passage). So the lady begged him and said even the dogs will pick the food crumbs that fall on the ground when the children eat. Christ told her, you faith is strong woman and he healed her daughter.
In short, the translation/interpretation of that bible was distorted to foster Zionist belief in Christianity.
The passage you quote is also distorted from the original language to give you false belief that this return to the holy land was prophesied in the bible.
See nobody is from here originally ,, there were just Palestinians "
There are Jews in Israel today who's ancestors never left that land. And by the way, the Arab Palestinians of today are themselves immigrants to that land from other countries, mainly from Egypt, Syria and Saudi Arabia. They never referred to themselves as "Palestinians" before 1948, but by Arabs of greater Syria! It is the Jews of Palestine who used the term "Palestinians". Learn history and don't be a hypocrite! Thanks!
@@GPBKM
How come they never left the land
And when the crusaders take the land from muslims killed everyone including the jews
this guy is Israeli sided
he attacked the Palestinians when they said Israel never existed before 1900
but here he is talking so friendly
fuck off
Actually, that was other guy. This one is Palestinian that one was Zionist.
"failry" 70 % of the land for 30% of the population doesnt seem fair to me, get your shit together
It’s obvious. Everyone knows.
Although he does an admirable job in acting “impartial,” since it’s virtually impossible for any human to be “impartial” whilst having absolute authority over “objective reality” and “truth.”
But watch out, the NaZiOnists will call you “biased” and an “Arab Ishmaelite.”
The better question is: Was your family here before 1880? I bet 99% of the arabs/muslims cannot trace their family's history in what is now Israel, Judea, Samaria and Gaza to before that year.
Exactly. In 1850 it was thinny 300k people here, so Turks desperately tried to increase the Muslim population here, British succeed much more.
It's very stupid to calculate generations and who is more and indignant, anyway
@laila H I sleep bad, coz goddamn leaders of both sides are greedy idiots. Israel is here to stay, Palestine(west bank+ rGaza) should be independent. Gaza should be cleansed of the retarded HUMUS (A=U) and all of us must be provided with free passage throughout and have the right to work and to travel on both sides.
#freepalestine
#freeisrael
Just for some context: The people who say they were from countries like Yemen, Morocco, Turkey etc. and came shortly after 1948 (1949 or 1950), likely came because the countries that were at war with Israel either forced Jews out, or made life so difficult that they had to flee (There were around 850,000 Jewish refugees from these countries). Israel fulfilled it's roles as a safe haven for Jews suffering persecution and took many of these Jews in.
not in Morocco where im from dont know about Yemen Turkey and athors country, Israel helped and kidnaped young people to go there and for that there is a lot of moroccan tunisian couple cause they meet there in such a concentration in palestine
That’s not an excuse for Israel to steal Palestinians homes and land …kill Palestinians and commit war crimes against them. There is no justification for that.
They claim to be indigenous but none of them are even from there.
Why do they lived in that counties for hundreds years Norma and suddenly they became undesirable? Isn't because they are Zionists and waited to steal the land of Palestine? So all that happened after stealing the land from his owner.
I immediately felt bad for the guy at 5:38. He seems really friendly.
+Afghan same here
+Jonah Karlen he said he has no family
+Afghan he has a family , just no members than were here before 48 .. he started saying it and then got cut by the interviewer
+waleed khalid r u jew??
Buddy how to send you questions? Any email or any other source?
so many people in the commnets don't understand the meaning of diaspora it's embarrassing (and the jewish diaspora was the first one to happen)
all jews are native and indigenous to this land, we were exiled and many others took it
just because a colonization happened a long time ago it doesn't mean its not a colonization, so of course many arabs can trace their ancestors from before 48, because they colonized it earlier
"White Russia" 😂 What about Belarus?
That's what he meant it was just the translation cause Belarus means white russia
same in Chinese
@Delano same in Switzerland (German)
also in russsian, bela is white
There's an error in your translation of the girl at 7:00. Bukhari Jews are from Uzbekistan, not Georgia. My grandfather was Bukhari.
@fouzia jama This is incorrect. Bukhari Jews came to Uzbekistan about 1000 years before Khazaria came into existence. Look it up.
@fouzia jama Also Bukhari are a relatively small minority in Israel
Indigenous or not, these people have lived there for 2 to 6 generations. We would find it weird to ask americans when their parents immigrated as a prerequisite if they can stay or not. History is filled with land grabs back and forth. Focus on a fair & just future for everyone.
Um, Israel has 7 million non-Arabs, Gaza+West Bank+Israel make up 6 million Arabs, there are still people living who were there in 1948, unlike America where it happened over 350 years ago and the ratio is 300 million US Americans to 5 million natives.
Israel was literally created yesterday.
I support the existense of the state of Israel because it's a great state, but please let's not deny the reality here, the Palestinians still exist in numbers and they deserve an end to the West Bank occupation, reparations + human rights.
Okay what about the Palestinians Hamas admits are Egyptian Syrian Jordanian. “My brothers half of us our Egyptian the other half Syrian” is recorded from a Hamas minister
so the key word is that "they came". does not matter if it was in the 1900's. the point is that they are occupying lands of the indigenous Palestinians
Maybe if some of the Muslim countries hadn’t treated their Jews so badly, there wouldn’t have been so many come to Israel. Egypt evicted their Jews in the late 50’s. Algeria denied citizenship to non muslims( Jews and christians) when they got their independence. Others interviewed here had families come from Tunisia, Morocco, Yemen. I wonder if these people here have a “right of return” to the countries of their ancestors.
At least some Jews from Arab countries were allowed to leave for Israel on the condition that their citizenship in the Arab country they were leaving from would be cancelled. I believe I heard about that happening in Iraq?
All of those happened after israel ethnically cleansed palestinian plus there were operation eq planting bomb by zionist to cause fear & force iraqi jews to migrate to israel. Thats well documented.
Why is Israel in the middle east and Jews are blond with blue eyes and mainly with east European ancestry? That is quite intriguing!!!!! Doesn't make much sense!!!!!!!!!
here is the answer to the puzzle "Jews, as part of the Jewish diaspora, migrated to Rome and Roman Europe from Palestine, Asia Minor, Babylon and Alexandria in response to economic hardship and incessant warfare over Palestine between the Ptolemaic and Seleucid empires." between 27 and 476 AD. During this time THE JEWS LEFT THE LANDS NOW CALLED PALESTINE ET AL. Prior to this time they had a 4000 year old culture in what is today Israel. This is verifiable by a mountain or archeological and literary evidence. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Jews_in_the_Roman_Empire
Did watch the video.Blond Jews are not really Jews , they are eastern European, at those days they became Jews and today they are becoming British , American and western European.Money talks a bit louder for them.
There are tons of blondes in Syria and Lebanon too. In Turkey as well. That's not really a valid argument.
Test their DNA to find where they are originally from!
You just look fucking ugly but unfortunately some mothers do have you!!!!!!!
I think the last guy is from Ariel, the same guy with some friends that answered the question 'how much do you hate Palestinians'
I am an Israeli Jew and my family has lived in Jerusalem for generations and they never left
did arab and jews live in peace before israel?
@@goobin9125 Yes most of the time, mostly Oriental and Spanish Jews.
So they were jewish Palestinians, i guess you have the right to say that you’re native to Palestine unlike other 97% of other jewish Zionists
@@rayyanabualia4500 look, as an atheist Israeli who lives here in his Third generation. I want to give you a reason why I do have a right to stay here.
Yes I too don't actually believe Israel needs to exist, at least not here in palstine.
But yo know something? I don't want to go. In a sense. I am a native too. Even if my ancestors don't go as dip. I have still grown in here, I leaned my first language. Made my friends and grown in the house my parents built. I went and graduated from my local school and now I am going to study cinema. I was born and grown in my home. And I didn't expelled or hurt any Palestinians. Why do I need to leave? And if I do leave, where to? My mother side is from France and yogoslavia and my father side is from Libya. And beyond that I don't know the language and culture of both Libya and France. I am not to just throw all my life work away. And you know another thing? There is actually enough space here for both Israel and palstine to live together. In my book, it doesn't matter to me if its a settler or a refugee. If you are a human being who is willing to live along side me with peace. Then please be my neighbor.
Great job. Thanks
THIS MESSAGE IS FROM AN Algerian Amazigh native of North Africa, I am not an arab but I'm Muslim
for your information in 1830 (the beginning of French colonialism) the population of Algeria was 9 million , and after 132 years of French occupation the population has remained 9 million in 1962 . you know why? because the Algerians never give up and they have never been afraid of the French advanced military technology . more than 5 million martyrs was paid for our freedom .and that was the case with the Romans and the other occupant.and be sure that your presence on Palestinian land will not last much. because the Palestinians are not your only enemy but we also Algerians.
My message is for the Zionists and those who believe in the state that you called "israel". and not to the Jews because koran commands us to respecte their belief and invite them to this :
coran 03 / 64 Say, "O People of the Scripture (Jews and Christians), come to a word that is equitable between us and you - that we will not worship except Allah and not associate anything with Him and not take one another as lords instead of Allah ." But if they turn away, then say, "Bear witness that we are Muslims [submitting to Him]."
Amazigh ⴰⵎⴰⵣⵉⵖ Algerien ⴰⵣⴰⵢⵔⵉ well said
براك الله فيك
How can you believe your Allah when he gave Palestinian lands to the Jews? Its a fact that land belong to Israel not Muslims.
Well, it depends how do you define reality. According to your book, there is one sovereign. What does your book say about the concept of time?
What does the book of Habakkuk say?
Just because you’re an atheist who believes only in what s/he can prove empirically, rather than one who acknowledges no human will ever have full supremacy over absolute truth and knowledge, doesn’t mean you will ALWAYS be “right” and “truthful.”
Ask, was your family here before the Balfour Agreement in 1917? I noticed only 1 pre 1917 family.
I’m Mexican, my grandfather was born in Palestine, his grandmother was born in Palestine and I’m Jewish
Also the important thing here is half of these people are from Middle East too. Middle Eastern families who were persecuted and forced to leave their homes, some of them living there before Islam was even invented.
it shouldn't be 1947, but people born before 1910.
at 8:59 isn't that the same guy from the "how much do israelis hate palestinians?" video?
🤣🤣🤣 i remeber this man it was so funny
Theodor Herzl approached the Ottoman Sultan Hamid(Caliph of Muslim World) and said " I want land for Jewish People in Jerusalem. Give them land in Palestine, so it can be home to them. As you know there are some Jews very strong financially, they will not leave your favor without a return. We can pay off all the Ottoman Empires debts that have accumulated in Europe. The only thing we want from you is to sell a little bit of land in Jerusalem. "
Sultan Hamid roared and said " I will not sell even a single inch of land. Because this homeland is for my people not for me, my people got that land with their blood, without it leaving us or going away we will cover it with our blood again. The soldiers of Syria and Palestine were martyred in Plevna one after the another. Not one came back, they all died on the battlefield. It's not for me or the high state, it is for the people, I will not give a piece of it. You will only be able to divide this empire by cutting up our bodies. I will not allow operation on an alive body. I do not allow the establishment of a Zionist state in Jerusalem."
Theodor Herzl says " We do not want to establish a state " Abdul Hamid signals his secretary to show him the photo of Theodor drawing the start of David and says " In the middle is the star of David and asks " What about the two blue lines on top and the bottom?" Theodor says " Its only a sign, there is no meaning for it at all " Abdul Hamid responds and says " Let me remind you of its meaning if you have forgotten Mr Herzl, By Drawing this Flag, you announce your wish of the promised land, Between the Nile and the Euphrates. You screamed that you want a Zionist state between the Nile and the Euphrates. And now I'm announcing and here I'm screaming! SUCH A STATE WILL NOT BE ESTABLISHED AS LONG AS I LIVE! I WILL NOT ALLOW IT, GET OUT! YOU IMMORAL PERSON!
This is a very good question! It releases who occupier is! :))
you guys based a state on a religion!
Congrats for figuring that out
Late military commander of the PLO as well as a member of the PLO Executive Council, Zuhair Muhsin. said the following to James Dorsey in a 1977 interview in the Dutch newspaper "Trouw": - There are no differences between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. We are all part of one nation. It is only for political reasons that we carefully underline our Palestinian identity....yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity serves only tactical purposes. The founding of a Palestinian state is a new tool in the continuing battle against Israel.