Oh wow, this is incredible. Emma’s vocals have come such a long way. Plus the whistle as a hook is genius. Usually I skip over acoustic versions but this one is just too good.
Your voice makes me MELT! I love this version just as much as the original! Amazing Emma! I cannot wait for the release of more new music! I’m so excited I can’t stand it! 🖤
You know what, Emma? I appreciate the heck out of both the original and acoustic. I admire the effort and funds you're putting into this era. Keep being you x
I know Emma said that she didn't really enjoy the "I prefer the acoustic version" since it took a fraction of the time it took to make the official mv, but I really do prefer the original. Dirt is just such a bop of a pop song. Don't get me wrong, I really like the acoustic version, but I'm gonna keep on bopping the original. Can't wait for single #2!
The original wasn't for me, not my thing, but I really do like this. Then again I'm a sucker for acoustic songs so there is that bias. I can understand where Emma's coming from with the time/effort taken stuff but a lot of that time overlaps. For the acoustic version the lyrics are already done, the composition is done, the song length is basically done, there's less instruments and mixing to deal with and so on. All that should be taken into account when an acoustic version is created. Also, speaking generally, just because something takes more time and effort, doesn't make it better. A great song written in a few hours can be just as great as a song slaved over for weeks.
wow emma sat still without blinking for a long time ok but in all seriousness i love this, the changes are great (especially to the pre chorus i really liked that)! gonna listen to this version on repeat.
I hated how the original was produced, but this sounds beautiful! It really lets Emma's voice shine through :) I feel the change in tempo also helps make it feel more impactful. Overall a great improvement IMO. PS. I've come to love the lyrics after about a month of the original being out. Yes, I kept listening to it despite saying I didn't like it originally, in case I changed my mind (like after the first few days). This is definitely taking its place in my Blackery-Playlist.
I just realized the «I've got dirt on you» leitmotif is the «na na na na na na» that children sing to make fun of others. Simply great, this made me love the song even more!!!
Alpacalaca the other version took a lot of hard work. We should be very great full we even have both versions instead of fussing over what one was better
I've been listening to this non-stop since it came out this morning - what a tune! Gotta say I adore both and they each suit different moods/vibes. Love how well you've done - you're just going from strength to strength, Emma!
I genuinely love anything Emma makes because it's Emma, because I can hear her in her work. Am I an acoustic girl? Yes. Have I told like seven customers at work who like pop about the original Dirt and then showed them it and got them hooked on Emma? Yes. Either one have just landed among my pop or my acoustic tracks that I love to listen over and over. Rock on, Emma. Pop rocks are pretty kick ass, too. ;)
Alan Spicer - UA-cam Tips & Tricks Emma actually prefers to keep this opinion to yourself because it hurts her. She put so much more effort into the original so when preppie say this her self esteem drops
If me COMPLIMENTING her music and buying her music upsets her then maybe she's looking at it wrong. I love the new music, im just sharing my appreciation for this version.
Aaaaa the acoustic is so good!!! I love how it kind of has this like? Sickly sweet feeling to it, like the notes and instrumentals are saying "kill them with kindness" but the lyrics aren't and its such a good alternate take of the feeling for the song!
I looooveee the original version, but Emma's vocals really shine through on this version. I was SHOOK.
I Like u
Oh wow, this is incredible. Emma’s vocals have come such a long way. Plus the whistle as a hook is genius. Usually I skip over acoustic versions but this one is just too good.
Was wondering how you'd do the vocal hook, but a whistle fits it really well c:
are they voice whistle's that she does or are they like normal whistles?????
normal whistles, definitely
Your voice makes me MELT! I love this version just as much as the original! Amazing Emma! I cannot wait for the release of more new music! I’m so excited I can’t stand it! 🖤
Her voice is bearly medioca, its just average.
Ayesha Millar Stop being negative. Emma has a great voice.
I literally can't handle you voice, it's too angelic. The switch up of the runs from the original to this one are so dang pretty.
You know what, Emma? I appreciate the heck out of both the original and acoustic. I admire the effort and funds you're putting into this era. Keep being you x
People saying "i prefer acoustic/electronic ver."... i would like to say that i just prefer emma blackery.
absolutely loved how sassy the original version is but I love this version so much.
I know Emma said that she didn't really enjoy the "I prefer the acoustic version" since it took a fraction of the time it took to make the official mv, but I really do prefer the original. Dirt is just such a bop of a pop song. Don't get me wrong, I really like the acoustic version, but I'm gonna keep on bopping the original. Can't wait for single #2!
The original wasn't for me, not my thing, but I really do like this. Then again I'm a sucker for acoustic songs so there is that bias.
I can understand where Emma's coming from with the time/effort taken stuff but a lot of that time overlaps. For the acoustic version the lyrics are already done, the composition is done, the song length is basically done, there's less instruments and mixing to deal with and so on. All that should be taken into account when an acoustic version is created.
Also, speaking generally, just because something takes more time and effort, doesn't make it better. A great song written in a few hours can be just as great as a song slaved over for weeks.
Will there be another single?
+Pixel Popper Yes, no idea when though. I don't even think Emma knows based off her last IPOAD.
wow emma sat still without blinking for a long time
ok but in all seriousness i love this, the changes are great (especially to the pre chorus i really liked that)! gonna listen to this version on repeat.
Even the acoustic version is a bop I'm shook 😭💖
This.Is.Beautiful.Music
the whistling here is so cute 💖
I prefer this, I prefer that. I think is just as good as the original. Love you Emma. 💖
Excited for the next single!!!
pegicorn302 I love this version 🙌🙌
pegicorn302 sameeeee
+
I hated how the original was produced, but this sounds beautiful! It really lets Emma's voice shine through :) I feel the change in tempo also helps make it feel more impactful. Overall a great improvement IMO.
PS. I've come to love the lyrics after about a month of the original being out. Yes, I kept listening to it despite saying I didn't like it originally, in case I changed my mind (like after the first few days). This is definitely taking its place in my Blackery-Playlist.
Hear that? Thats real talent😍 even without all the editing and everything her voice is completley real and stunning
Skylar S This was heavily edited though??
Yeah man, this is really pretty heavily edited. Hearing a lot of pitch correct.
you obviously havent heard her sing live then?? lmao
Emma Acoustickery 😍
I just realized the «I've got dirt on you» leitmotif is the «na na na na na na» that children sing to make fun of others. Simply great, this made me love the song even more!!!
The whistling at the beginning has already melted my entire heart and existence. I’m 3 seconds in and I can’t breathe.
"and yet you say you're self made honey" ooooooooo that gave me shivers so goooood
Love this even more than the origional
This is amazing Emma. You should be so proud. A very good nod to the high production version. Love love love them both ❤❤
Actually freaking love both versions of this song, as usual cus Emma is great, it's a bop gurl
Emma literally has the voice of an angel😍
I LITERALLY CAN'T, What The Heck ?!?!?!?! I THOUGHT THE ORIGINAL WAS GOOD BUT THIS ON ANOTHER LEVEL!
This was love not hate btw
Alpacalaca the other version took a lot of hard work. We should be very great full we even have both versions instead of fussing over what one was better
Damn, Emma's voice is so fluttery and gorgeous :,0
I love Emma’s voice so much in this acoustic version!
Emma's voice has come on in leaps and bounds over the years. I love this!
The whistle fits so well! This so perfect now I've got two songs to jam to.
I seriously love this version so much! I will never stop listening to it...
this version of dirt really gives me a halsey 'badlands' and country vibe ♡ i love it
Those whistles 💙
I love them both so much I genuinely can’t pick a favourite
I've been listening to this non-stop since it came out this morning - what a tune! Gotta say I adore both and they each suit different moods/vibes. Love how well you've done - you're just going from strength to strength, Emma!
The way you say “honey” in this has me just YES
Oh my stars this is amazing 😍 Emma seems to be one of the few I've heard that can sound the same live, acoustic, and in the original.
emma's voice is so beautifuuuul
This is what real music is😉😉😉 good job Emma! We're soooo proud of you!
I genuinely love anything Emma makes because it's Emma, because I can hear her in her work. Am I an acoustic girl? Yes. Have I told like seven customers at work who like pop about the original Dirt and then showed them it and got them hooked on Emma? Yes. Either one have just landed among my pop or my acoustic tracks that I love to listen over and over.
Rock on, Emma. Pop rocks are pretty kick ass, too. ;)
I’m in love with this I swear. Her voice is just amazing. ❤️❤️
I LOVE both versions I think it depends on my mood : chilling hanging around - acoustic , driving or wanting to dance or feel sassy - original ❤️❤️
That vibrato tho
Honestly both versions are amazing. Love the cheekiness to the original and I love hearing the story told a bit clearer here. It's amazing! ❤️
Ahhhhhh it's so good!!!!!!
Damn w that whistle, reminds me of LP!!!!
I love this version so much!!!! I don’t really like poppy songs but I love Emma’s voice so this is perfect for me !!
OMG I loooovvvveeee!! Especially the "I got I got I got" bits 💙💙
Both this and the original are beautiful
I love this song! Acoustic and electronic, it's beautiful!!
You're so talented Emma. I'm loving your music.
I really like how crunchy this version feels. Thanks for sharing!
Love that the Song pronounces the quality of your Voice ❤️
Omgggg. I love this so much.
Almost more than the original.
👏👏👏👏
This is going to be a blast live. Love from India
I love them both EQUALLY!!!
wow i love this version so much too!!!!
This puts a whole new feel to the song, both are amaaazzzinggg. This album will slay me
I love this version!!!!!
I really like this version!!!!!! xx
I LOVE THEM BOTH EQUALLY I CAN'T DECIDE!! 😲😍😲😍
Got some serious chills listening to this
MAN I CAN'T DECIDE WHICH VERSION IS MY FAV IMA LISTEN TO THEM BOTH OVER AND OVERRR 💚💛💙💜
LOVE this! Emma's vocals are just amazing!
I absolutely loved Dirt, and now this, I can’t decide which is my favourite version because they’re both amazing!
I LOVE THIS VERSION!! Emma your voice is so beautiful!!
ACOUSTIC >>>>>>> Original
Love this new style :)
Alan Spicer - UA-cam Tips & Tricks Emma actually prefers to keep this opinion to yourself because it hurts her. She put so much more effort into the original so when preppie say this her self esteem drops
If me COMPLIMENTING her music and buying her music upsets her then maybe she's looking at it wrong. I love the new music, im just sharing my appreciation for this version.
Alan Spicer - UA-cam Tips & Tricks Youre complimenting her music by saying the other version was bad, which hurts her
no need to bring something up by putting something down (: glad you like this version though!
Alan Spicer - UA-cam Tips & Tricks why can’t you just say you like this version , and not insult the original
Love Emma well done. Didn't think the track could get even more catchier. I was wrong. Love it. Well done.
emma's voice shines here i'm in love with it
I love both versionssss!!! Yes, that’s possible. Just wanna say I heard this song first from Stevie Boebi’s snaps. And I’m thankful! 👏👏👏
ok but the vocals in this r so good...........
I love the vocals. And the whistle substitution
i love this omg like its so soft and like so passive aggressive omg queen
I've been listening to this version non stop, Emma, oh my god! Makes me feel so sassy singing it too 💯
love this version
Both versions are amazing! I love it
Can’t wait for the album!!!!!
Aaaaa the acoustic is so good!!! I love how it kind of has this like? Sickly sweet feeling to it, like the notes and instrumentals are saying "kill them with kindness" but the lyrics aren't and its such a good alternate take of the feeling for the song!
Dayuuum that voice 😍
Emma you have a gorgeous singing voice 🎼❤❤❤❤
Love this and the original ❤️❤️❤️😍😍😍
Both versions are great!
Fair play Emma! Both versions are amazing, it's only a matter of deciding which one I love more 💟💟xxx
HER VOICE SOUNDS SO GOOD
I love this acoustic version!
WHAT A QUEEN
I'm in love with this, your voice is just so soft and beautiful but somehow still sassy
I LOVE YOUR VOICE. Plus this acoustic version is really nice. Keep making music Emma ♥️♥️♥️
Omg just release an album please 😍 your voice is beautiful
Purchased! Download Interrupted! Fixed! Love it! ♥
Love love love love
I actually love this song like this
Great acoustic translation. Go Emma.
we love a queen
oh my god the prechorus sounds so so so good
I can't decide which is better. I love both so much! Love you Emma!
I immeadiately fell in love with this
The bridge is goals
I love it so much it sounds wherid without the background vocal it really sounds great
I don't have a preference of this or the original, but this one truly showcases how amazing your voice is.
I love the whistle!
I clicked and heard the whistles and was instantly shook, Emma will always be one of my favs 👑👑👑💖💖🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻