@Conjoh Ly How, in my comment, did I belittle the famine? I made reference to when the film was made. The words were most likely written in 2006, when this country was 'booming'. When we get rid of the English, all will be better, was Ignatius's belief. Well, the English are gone, almost a hundred years now. The names changed and Irish people are being evicted. As Myles said, Greed, indeed did, stay the same.
Its shocking, still very little of the population speak Irish and all the place-names are anglicised. Is náire iomlán é, ba chóir dúinn a bheith ag labhairt ár dteanga dhúchais gach lá, sa bhaile, sa siopa, leis na comharsana. Ní teanga a thug ionróirí Gaill chun tailte íon
Black 47 brought me here,didn t know this was made before.And this scene is artistically much stronger than the new remake.Respect to the Director and the actors.A shame hollywood is plagiating everything.
@@StephenGraves Turns out I'm not in luck! lol. Black '47 couldn't even do a good job of the scene in this film, let alone the whole feature:( It fails to get you emotionally invested in the protagonist's goal, to sympathise with him. Don't want to spoil anything but it misses out big time! So much tension and suspense here! and you discover viscerally along with the hero just how bad things have been for his family whilst he was away, Black '47 doesn't really do that. I'm genuinely really disappointed seeing this great short film again and what potential there was at a feature film adaptation:(
@@richardadesmond black 47 does it more through visual representation than exposition. The protagonist barely speaks but I think his dark past was, I felt, represented well through environmental storytelling. It's also more focused on his revenge and perceived sense of justice than on him as an individual. But I agree that they could have done a bit more to you invested in him. Also, it is focused just as much if not more on Hugo Weaving's character.
"Ach cén difríocht a dhíona é sin? B'fhéidir go n-athróidh na hainmneacha, ach beidh saint i gcónaí ann." - And what difference would that make? Maybe the names will change, but greed will always exist.
@@GhostEye31 Why would you make a Irish film and concede to British oppressors? When the BBC makes a film about Ireland it's always in English, when the french make a film it's always in French, regardless of what the characters would have actually spoke based on their nationality.
Tá an scannán go hiontach! Is aoibhinn liom An Ranger! Obair go maith mo cairde. The bit with the pig's head on Ignatious body made me jump with fright alright but tiz a fantastic film overall
"The names will change, but the greed will stay the same". How prophetic that sentence was in 2008, for what was to come.
@Conjoh Ly How, in my comment, did I belittle the famine? I made reference to when the film was made. The words were most likely written in 2006, when this country was 'booming'. When we get rid of the English, all will be better, was Ignatius's belief. Well, the English are gone, almost a hundred years now. The names changed and Irish people are being evicted. As Myles said, Greed, indeed did, stay the same.
Its shocking, still very little of the population speak Irish and all the place-names are anglicised. Is náire iomlán é, ba chóir dúinn a bheith ag labhairt ár dteanga dhúchais gach lá, sa bhaile, sa siopa, leis na comharsana. Ní teanga a thug ionróirí Gaill chun tailte íon
Well for those that want more your getting more. Black 47 movie is out this year.
Was Black 47 from the same director? The Dialoge is almost identical.Even the judges name
The Irish language sounds really badass. Irishman with a kukri, I like this combo.
This is as important now as it was when made.
The greed is still the same.
Great piece of film, thank you.
Great to see the origins of BLACK ‘47 expressed so clearly - tonally, narratively and visually- in this potent short film.
Black 47 brought me here,didn t know this was made before.And this scene is artistically much stronger than the new remake.Respect to the Director and the actors.A shame hollywood is plagiating everything.
The Wikipedia article for Black 47 says that the people who made this, An Ranger, also worked on Black 47.
left wanting more.....beautifully written and shot!
Well, you're in luck!
Stephen Graves I know, haven't seen it yet, thanks.
@@StephenGraves Turns out I'm not in luck! lol. Black '47 couldn't even do a good job of the scene in this film, let alone the whole feature:( It fails to get you emotionally invested in the protagonist's goal, to sympathise with him. Don't want to spoil anything but it misses out big time! So much tension and suspense here! and you discover viscerally along with the hero just how bad things have been for his family whilst he was away, Black '47 doesn't really do that. I'm genuinely really disappointed seeing this great short film again and what potential there was at a feature film adaptation:(
@@richardadesmond black 47 does it more through visual representation than exposition. The protagonist barely speaks but I think his dark past was, I felt, represented well through environmental storytelling. It's also more focused on his revenge and perceived sense of justice than on him as an individual. But I agree that they could have done a bit more to you invested in him. Also, it is focused just as much if not more on Hugo Weaving's character.
"Ach cén difríocht a dhíona é sin? B'fhéidir go n-athróidh na hainmneacha, ach beidh saint i gcónaí ann." - And what difference would that make? Maybe the names will change, but greed will always exist.
Love the music.
so is this just a short film? Is this not a full movie? Is this scene what inspired black 47?
88th foot... Conought Rangers ✊🏴🇨🇮❤️
Go hiontach ar fad. Looking forward to Black 47.
Black 47 was a great movie about our ancestors terrible times.
Howdy from Texas ! This was superb!
Fantastic language!
this is verry good they are making a movie based on this
it should be completely in Irish
@@thenextshenanigantownandth4393 It was about half and half. A bunch of gaelic and a bunch of English since half the characters were in fact English.
@@GhostEye31 Why would you make a Irish film and concede to British oppressors? When the BBC makes a film about Ireland it's always in English, when the french make a film it's always in French, regardless of what the characters would have actually spoke based on their nationality.
Tá an scannán go hiontach! Is aoibhinn liom An Ranger! Obair go maith mo cairde. The bit with the pig's head on Ignatious body made me jump with fright alright but tiz a fantastic film overall
What an amazing film! Does anyone know the name of the song that plays at the end during the credits?
Tá an scannán go hiontach, is aoibhinn liom Black 47. Léiríonn sé an streachailt a bhí ag An Ghórta mór
Black 47 took this on and made a great film sure .
An maith ar fad
I had no idea that the movie black 47 was based on another movie
An Landlord
Faugh a ballagh
does anyone know how i can get to watch pj dillons movie 'most important'?
What’s the name of the slow air?
Can anyone tell me what the dish is that he serves him at 3:51? Go raibh maith agat!
Looks like a bit of chicken
Black 47 brought me here!
Lads! Go raibh maith agat!
ta'se' go hiontach agus dubh caher seacht !....
Was this before "Black '47" ?
Black 47 inspiration i think
Bit late to reply but the same lad who made this made Black 47
An maith!
A google search after watching Black '47 on Netflix sent me here
Black 47 was inspired by this
Does anyone have the script of this scene?
Was this proof of concept for Black 47?
Yeah. This scene heavily inspired the part in Black '47 where Máirtín confronts Bheartla. It's practically a shot for shot rehash
Ar fheabhas ar fad
Is breá liom seo!
I don't get Why we is wearing the red coat
He was a soldier in the 88th regiment of foot 'connaught rangers' british army so red coats
obair iontach. is breá liom é.