Sorry nerdstalgic, but had to make a comment and ask why you didn’t say a “truly LEGEN…..wait for it…DARY” episode in the thumbnail. Small detail missed lol
@@Karan_Thakkar I feel you on that but to be fair this video may be a revaluation to someone new to the show or is early in their sitcom experience. Just because something isn’t new doesn’t mean it’s not new to someone if you know what I mean. People make super similar video videos in interesting ways because there is a chance that they could be the first time a viewer experiences that conversation about himym or any show for that matter.
@@Karan_Thakkar to be fair if I was someone without that knowledge or had never seen a video on this show of this topic I would prefer someone to act as if it’s a revolution because if I’m like the person I described then it would be a revelation
When I read the title, the playbook was the one I remembered immediately. But I'm actually fine with it being the Pineapple incident. I love this episode.
Absolutely love himym for their backwards and forwards storytelling and misdirects! Burning beekeeper is one of my favorite episodes because of the format and how it keeps unveiling something new in each room, so good!
@@olavjorvik94 one of the main fun things about the show is that 90% of what he tells the kids he had no motive to tell them, and probably should not tell them at all
@@tasmayshah5539 me neither but it’s obviously formatted like one of those type of shows, the laugh track is so silent you barely notice it but the format in which it was shot like there’s an audience in front of them like Friends TBBT and Two and a Half Men hurts it, I wish it would have been shot more akin to modern sitcoms like B99 or Modern Family
At least they had a goal in mind. Not many shows do. Would have probably with at least a season with the actual mother and gang ,though outside of the wedding season.
@@tasmayshah5539 because in friends they are filming infront of a live audience. In HIMYM theres no audience, so they can edit as much as they want, also newer technology and better editing tools in 2006 than 1994 tbh.
'spoiler alert' is the best episode, highlighting the annoying habits we don't notice until someone points them out, culminating in Marshall's bar exam results. smart, funny, sarcastic, witty, brilliant and touching? an excellent episode indeed
Now that you mentioned Chekov's Gun, I now realize why I love this show. They used this concept quite a lot that makes a seamless storytelling. The purple giraffe, blue french horn, the yellow umbrella, Ted's cowboy boots, the slap bet and more.
@@yousefshamaelh8776 Second episode, when Ted throws three different parties for Robin. The first night, Robin couldn't make it because she was covering a story about a kid got stuck in one of those toy vending machines where a robot arm grabs a random toy and slips it out. The kid wanted a purple giraffe, but kept getting other toys, so he somehow found his way inside the machine, but couldn't come out. Robin was stuck there until they could the kid out, which led to her missing the first party. It was sort of a parallel between Ted and the kid, Robin being Ted's Purple Giraffe, as he wouldn't let go of her despite failing to get her again and again.
@@shaimawahab5916 ahhh ok lmaoo that purple garaffe thx for reminding me and also how was I supposed to remember that I finished the show 2 years ago but I still love it and friends and modern family and big bang theory 2 broke girls
That episode at season 8 that he was in the bar the hole time at his elution about time traveling was a master peace And the last speech makes you feel alone and connected
thats a top 5 episode for sure, maybe the best. it's not the absolute saddest sitcom episode ever (see all of MASH), but in comparison to a given show's average episode it might be the saddest
@@hellica8802 that scene was improvised. Jason had the scene direction that he would have to hug Lily but he didn't know what he would be responding to. Jason's reaction as Marshal is pretty much real in that scene and they kept he original take that's why they use the original audio and not the dubbing (you can hear that the audio is not perfect in that moment if you hear clearly)
I feel like this is one of these Shows that just gets better the more you rewatch it. Because you get all of these small things and callbacks. The continuity in this Show is so freaking amazing. Love it.
While I totally agree with you, I have always been confused about the number of slaps Barney gets. I can't help but wonder if there was something personal from Lily in that decision. Or something the writers consciously choose to draw out the comedy. I think it would have been really cool if we had found out later. Lily abused her powers as the slap bet commissioner to get back at Barney for a personal vendetta. Which would have been totally in line with her personality and some of the things she does throughout the series. My reason for this is Marshall prematurely slapped Barney, and he also tried to hide the fact that his slap was premature from him, and his punishment was three consecutive slaps. One for lying and two for a premature slap. So one can't help but wonder why Barney was giving the choice of ten slaps all at once or five at random? Should it not have been two slaps for the one premature slap committed by Barney? Based on the precedent set by Lily in her ruling of Marshall's premature slap. I don't know. This is just something I have always wondered.
i dont know if its perfect but the most memorable for me is the "The Best burger in Newyork" episode i mean i was invested in that one..and also when lilly and marshall moved out of newyork and settling into the house those ones were great too
My favorite HIMYM episode was the one where Marshall dad passed away. It was very good drama, very great character development for lilly and marshall. It was very dramatic and tragic. Easily 10 out of 10
What I love the most about this episode is when Ted , phone in hand goes to the room to wake up the girl who he thinks is robin .. and Robin calls .. says it's her and Ted looks at Trudy confused and asks "are you sure?" This little bit of comedy .. lovely
@@AlienDemonKing im sorry u feel that way but i understand why they picked this episode in particular, its the point of the whole series and this is no exception, its a perfect episode in terms of showcasing what makes the show good, i think it makes perfect sense
The Pineapple Incident is when HIMYM turned the corner for me from a mildly amusing sitcom to a great, weekly-appointment show. The turning point of Season One. Love this episode!
I think one of the most overlooked elements in the series is the fact that almost always in every episode, you'll see a prop, clothing or any element that's colored yellow OR purple. A scene where a purple prop or clothing or something can be seen, it kinda means that it leads Ted more into Robin. While a scene where a yellow prop or clothing can be seen means that sequence leads Ted more into finding the one aka the mother.
One that is perfect and is truly overlooked is The Burning Beekeeper. For me, it's impeccable, and maybe my favorite episode (at least among the funny ones)
I'm not gonna lie, I tend to forget about TV shows after I watched them, so I wasn't anticipating any particular episode of HIMYM as "the perfect one", but as soon as you said "the pineapple incident" I was like "yep, it totally makes sense", that was a classic!
Every single episode is amazing but my most fav one is episode one. It had such impact on me, especially when he introduced Robin as the kid's aunt. I started watching this show in 2017 with zero expectations and that particular episode made me so intrigued i watched the entire show in 2 months. Its easily now my favourite sitcom
Great choice! Although I believe the perfect episode is the one with “Blah blah” all around twists and turns in the best himym style. And incredibly hilarious
One of my favorite episodes is episode 1 of season 6 "Big Days". It takes place almost completely from the booth at Maclarens. Usually they always jump around. but this episode took place in one location and was kind of a simple episode. always enjoyed it
Wasn't that the one, which was supposed to be the final Episode before it got more episode and seasons? Victoria has always been my favorite, the actual mother being a close second.
@@puaykimteo2997 I still love victoria at the time of the ducky tie episode where ted bumps into her at an event. Then after that they had to make up weird quirks for victoria for ted to break up with her again. This is after victoria left klaus at the altar for ted. In the later seasons, Later seasons were just bad with a few good episodes sprinkled here and there. I wish they introduced the mother character earlier since she was the best part of the last season.
One aspect that also went full circle is the song that Ted karaoked to Robin from Cheap Trick. When Ted blacked out, it was one of the only hazy memories he had and when they concluded the episode the song was playing faintly in the background. Cool song btw.
The last episode of the 2nd season (the one with the blue horn) follow a similar structure, but there we got to solve the mistery alongside Barney. One of my favorites too. Oh...and I like the new voice😀
I love two amazing episodes - everyone's bad habits being talked about building to a crescendo in which they're all about to kill each other but Marshall remembers his password. And (spoiler alert) tiny clues around them counting down to when Marshall receives the saddest news of his life.
I think he brought on a second collaborator to take on some work for him, so he can be more consistent with uploading on UA-cam. Still sucks thought because it misses the mark on why I love Nerdstalgic videos. The pacing and narrating done by the original creator is some of the best Production UA-cam has to offer and his videography takes are some of the most educated on this platform. No offense to the new but the original nerdstalgic creator is irreplaceable.
This show is the best for using set-ups and callbacks - not just within episodes or even seasons but throughout the entire series. Even the most insignificant detail becomes integral to a later event.
Who is doing this video? Doesn't sound like the normal host of Nerdstalgic Wait a second if the pineapple was on The Captains front porch doesn't that mean he is a swinger?
@@ZenithKnight yeah I was hoping to fall asleep to this video because there's something about the original voiceover guy that is so relaxing. This one didn't do it for me
Oh I actually really love where everyone except marshal and barney himself, are stuck in Barney’s closets.. such a hilarious episode with uncontrollable laughing starts from the very initiation scene.. and everytime, when robin calls ted and says, “how’s my favourite and most handsome architect?” And everytime ted replies, “hi mom”😂😂😂
My favorite episode (I forget the name) is where Ted's date is someone he met online. The pacing and writing of that episode is incredible, with unique jokes firing off every minute and landing every time, culminating in the revelation that the method Ted met her "online" was actually World of Warcraft (and that Ted's character was the petite female elf was the cherry on top).
My favourite episode was when Robyn found out she can’t get pregnant. Soooo impactful and nuanced ♥️ But also the one when Lily says that sometimes she wishes she weren’t a mom. Oh that episode is gutting ♥️
How I Met Your Mother is my favorite sitcom, and while I'm not sure what my favorite episode is, this episode for all intents and purposes, *is* How I Met Your Mother, with the use of flashbacks, incomplete (at first) stories, and different perspectives all fitting together like a jigsaw to tell the story - it's very likely this was the episode they were using to explain that this is the kind of show they wanted to do. Great video, I really liked how you described things and how the episode works - very well done. Slight correction though, the characters were in the late 20s to... somewhere in their 30s for most of the show (Ted turned 28 in Season 1.) Also, Ted's a beta male? Awesome, I knew I was like Ted!
0:25 they were supposed to be in their 20s? I thought everyone was in their 30s and 40s. I think most of the actors were in their mid 30s when the series started
Check out Curiosity Stream for yourself at curiositystream.com/nerdstalgic
Code: nerdstalgic
One of the best episodes of the whole series
you pinned yourself... so pins are for self-promotion rather than audience engagement. cool
Sorry nerdstalgic, but had to make a comment and ask why you didn’t say a “truly LEGEN…..wait for it…DARY” episode in the thumbnail. Small detail missed lol
What happened to your voice
you solve greatest mystery to all of us "The pineapple Mystery"
The pineapple incident isn't overlooked at all, it's basically top of every top 10 episodes list
Came to comment this lol
Seriously.
Came here to comment this. These videos they make are nice but it’s kinda annoying that they’ll behave it’s some sort of a revelation
@@Karan_Thakkar I feel you on that but to be fair this video may be a revaluation to someone new to the show or is early in their sitcom experience. Just because something isn’t new doesn’t mean it’s not new to someone if you know what I mean. People make super similar video videos in interesting ways because there is a chance that they could be the first time a viewer experiences that conversation about himym or any show for that matter.
@@Karan_Thakkar to be fair if I was someone without that knowledge or had never seen a video on this show of this topic I would prefer someone to act as if it’s a revolution because if I’m like the person I described then it would be a revelation
Wouldn't say it's an overlooked episode, but very solid video!
Hey it's Oscar! ❤️
Knew I'd see you here :) Greetings from a subscriber
Heyo we got Oscar here
Heyyyy Oscar ❤️
I know right. This is my favorite episode
“The playbook” episode is easily up their with the best episodes in the series
When you make them believe you have a plan so they act as if you have said plan,that is the plan to have them act that way.
When I read the title, the playbook was the one I remembered immediately. But I'm actually fine with it being the Pineapple incident. I love this episode.
I believe it’s a top two or three episode, because even though I know the twist is coming it’s still just as good as the first time I saw it.
I also really like the fight. I really forget about that episode too shockingly
I consider the introduction of the Playbook the start of the downfall of HIMYM.
Absolutely love himym for their backwards and forwards storytelling and misdirects! Burning beekeeper is one of my favorite episodes because of the format and how it keeps unveiling something new in each room, so good!
I think I would have liked the format more if maybe the events had more weight rather than it just being a dinner party
It’s a clever episode, but I don’t really like it. It’s one of those you can easily skip. Ted really didn’t need to tell that one to his kids haha
Now THAT is an overlooked episode! I get it’s not for everyone but the storytelling is still impressive to me every time
I love that episoed
@@olavjorvik94 one of the main fun things about the show is that 90% of what he tells the kids he had no motive to tell them, and probably should not tell them at all
HIMYM is devastatingly overlooked because of the finale and its laugh track format
Have to say it was a guilty pleasure of mine in my twenties. Don't care for it much now
tbh, the laugh track is unoticeable. It isn't nearly as bas as friends and I don't even notice it.
@@tasmayshah5539 me neither but it’s obviously formatted like one of those type of shows, the laugh track is so silent you barely notice it but the format in which it was shot like there’s an audience in front of them like Friends TBBT and Two and a Half Men hurts it, I wish it would have been shot more akin to modern sitcoms like B99 or Modern Family
At least they had a goal in mind. Not many shows do. Would have probably with at least a season with the actual mother and gang ,though outside of the wedding season.
@@tasmayshah5539 because in friends they are filming infront of a live audience. In HIMYM theres no audience, so they can edit as much as they want, also newer technology and better editing tools in 2006 than 1994 tbh.
Ah yes my comfort show
Same lol
Same with Community and King of Queens
I've been rewatching it couple of episodes every night just to relax my stress before sleep
@@shibineb :O I do that toooo! HIMYM and Community are my comfort shows. Sometimes I feel like I'm the last member the gang who doesn't talk.
'spoiler alert' is the best episode, highlighting the annoying habits we don't notice until someone points them out, culminating in Marshall's bar exam results. smart, funny, sarcastic, witty, brilliant and touching? an excellent episode indeed
Apple orchard banana cat dance 8663
@@calebjackson2490 cat's funeral, miaow, miaow!!!!
THIS!
@@raoulhery
“it was an accident
and not entirely my fault”
3 days of snow is the perfect episode. Change my mind
That episode is definitely a masterpiece of non-linear storytelling
it threw me for such a loop when it revealed marshall and lily werent actually sitting next to each other
@@wlgyl493 the first time I saw that episode I freaked out
@@matthewbryan9020 Same with the robots vs wrestlers, a little more predictable but still cool
It's one of my favorites. I loved that Marshal has to bring the marching band to the airport every time.
The Time Travelers will always be my favorite episode
Definitely
T I M E 😯
that a cappella at the end, still haven’t heard a better version of that song
Same
Same here
Now that you mentioned Chekov's Gun, I now realize why I love this show. They used this concept quite a lot that makes a seamless storytelling. The purple giraffe, blue french horn, the yellow umbrella, Ted's cowboy boots, the slap bet and more.
wtf what purple giraffe remind me of it
@@yousefshamaelh8776 Second episode, when Ted throws three different parties for Robin. The first night, Robin couldn't make it because she was covering a story about a kid got stuck in one of those toy vending machines where a robot arm grabs a random toy and slips it out. The kid wanted a purple giraffe, but kept getting other toys, so he somehow found his way inside the machine, but couldn't come out. Robin was stuck there until they could the kid out, which led to her missing the first party. It was sort of a parallel between Ted and the kid, Robin being Ted's Purple Giraffe, as he wouldn't let go of her despite failing to get her again and again.
@@shaimawahab5916 ahhh ok lmaoo that purple garaffe thx for reminding me and also how was I supposed to remember that I finished the show 2 years ago but I still love it and friends and modern family and big bang theory 2 broke girls
dont forget the goat that came seasons before..
The entire show is the definition of Chekov's gun. I mean, have you seen the throwbacks and references?
Exactly what I was thinking
Touche..👍🏻
Chekov's armory, man
Even the series' title is a setup. One that takes 9 seasons for the actual reveal, but I digress. Impeccably produced and edited.
Exactly!
That episode at season 8 that he was in the bar the hole time at his elution about time traveling was a master peace
And the last speech makes you feel alone and connected
It made me cry like a little girl, and I loved every second of it(:
The time travelers, hands down the best HIMYM episode of all time.
thats a top 5 episode for sure, maybe the best. it's not the absolute saddest sitcom episode ever (see all of MASH), but in comparison to a given show's average episode it might be the saddest
Time travellers hits hard at the end. It's soo good
I feel like S6E13 definitely deserves a top 5 spot. The countdown to (in my opinion) the saddest moment in the whole show makes it a true masterpiece
A beautiful episode, and the countdown makes it feel all the more tense when you know what it is for..
i still watch that episode sometimes, but everytime that number countdowns to 1 I still can't handle that moment. I am not ready for this
Are you sure it’s S6E13? The one with lily and Marshall unable to get pregnant
@@hellica8802 that scene was improvised. Jason had the scene direction that he would have to hug Lily but he didn't know what he would be responding to. Jason's reaction as Marshal is pretty much real in that scene and they kept he original take that's why they use the original audio and not the dubbing (you can hear that the audio is not perfect in that moment if you hear clearly)
I feel like this is one of these Shows that just gets better the more you rewatch it. Because you get all of these small things and callbacks. The continuity in this Show is so freaking amazing. Love it.
"Often overlooked episode" - it had literally the highest viewing figures of the entire first season, and indeed of the entire show bar the finale.
I still feel like the pineapple has an asterisk since it was a deleted scene that came 8 years later
plus it is always much more fun when it remains a mystery
For me the perfect episode is slap-bet 1. Story line is unique and entertaining 2. Funny 3. Barney getting slapped is legendary
And we got robin sparkles
... and we got to go to the mall.
@@RobertJohnson-bj5lk and we also got space teens and two beavers are better than one
@@RobertJohnson-bj5lk today?
While I totally agree with you, I have always been confused about the number of slaps Barney gets. I can't help but wonder if there was something personal from Lily in that decision. Or something the writers consciously choose to draw out the comedy. I think it would have been really cool if we had found out later. Lily abused her powers as the slap bet commissioner to get back at Barney for a personal vendetta. Which would have been totally in line with her personality and some of the things she does throughout the series. My reason for this is Marshall prematurely slapped Barney, and he also tried to hide the fact that his slap was premature from him, and his punishment was three consecutive slaps. One for lying and two for a premature slap. So one can't help but wonder why Barney was giving the choice of ten slaps all at once or five at random? Should it not have been two slaps for the one premature slap committed by Barney? Based on the precedent set by Lily in her ruling of Marshall's premature slap. I don't know. This is just something I have always wondered.
"DAMMIT TRUDY WHAT ABOUT THE PINEAPPLE?!?!"
This is my favorite episode from my favorite show, thanks for this vid❤️
The Time travellers of Season 8 would always be my favourite! Out of nowhere it hit me really hard!
Thank you i was looking for this
Wait for it and I hope you’re not lactose intolerant because the next word is DAIRY, LEGENDARY
"We licked the Liberty Bell..."
- "We did?"
This show is overall well written. You can see how much time and care the writers put into this show from looking at the first season.
the writers used this episode to pitch the show and its unique narrative conventions. They also knew it was gold
i dont know if its perfect but the most memorable for me is the "The Best burger in Newyork" episode i mean i was invested in that one..and also when lilly and marshall moved out of newyork and settling into the house those ones were great too
I don’t think he “accidentally” called Trudy - he says things that are specific to his earlier conversation with her before she even says anything
THANK You
Man, I didn't remember HIMYM being that old. They're still using wall phones!
05
‘05
Smart phones came out right, after cellphones were a thing but not as widespread then still had people clinging to wall phones as you call them.
Spoilers: The pineapple came from Santa Barbara. Some psychic detectives sent it.
How do you know?
@@Ndriep17 Psych reference. Only cultured people get it
@@aquaepic4768 ahh you’re that type of person, alright
They did an episode that was like exactly like this tho
So wait, doe that mean Shawn is actually psychic?;)
My favorite HIMYM episode was the one where Marshall dad passed away.
It was very good drama, very great character development for lilly and marshall.
It was very dramatic and tragic. Easily 10 out of 10
I love that episode too(: The countdown is so eerie and disturbing, and I love it
One of my favorites is "The Ashtray". I love how it plays with perspective!
What I love the most about this episode is when Ted , phone in hand goes to the room to wake up the girl who he thinks is robin .. and Robin calls .. says it's her and Ted looks at Trudy confused and asks "are you sure?" This little bit of comedy .. lovely
as soon as i saw the title i knew exactly what episode you were talking about, i saw it the other day and had the same thing to say
Well yeah. It's basically the most talked about episode... TBH I'm getting disappointed with this channel.
@@AlienDemonKing im sorry u feel that way but i understand why they picked this episode in particular, its the point of the whole series and this is no exception, its a perfect episode in terms of showcasing what makes the show good, i think it makes perfect sense
The Pineapple Incident is when HIMYM turned the corner for me from a mildly amusing sitcom to a great, weekly-appointment show. The turning point of Season One. Love this episode!
I think one of the most overlooked elements in the series is the fact that almost always in every episode, you'll see a prop, clothing or any element that's colored yellow OR purple. A scene where a purple prop or clothing or something can be seen, it kinda means that it leads Ted more into Robin. While a scene where a yellow prop or clothing can be seen means that sequence leads Ted more into finding the one aka the mother.
Wow! That's too deep!
I thought this would be an episode on the Slap Bet. The first time we met Robin Sparkles
This was good. But nothing tops "The Blitz."
The episode where Marshall is tailgating at his dad's grave telling him a story and people keep asking him for food and drinks is the best one IMO
awwww mannnnnn
@Gichini Studio I see what you did there.
"The gentleman!"
@@xant8344 Agreed!
As a huge fan of the series, I’m glad this video exists.
I would also say that the 'Three Day Rule' is incredibly well-done and overlooked
One that is perfect and is truly overlooked is The Burning Beekeeper. For me, it's impeccable, and maybe my favorite episode (at least among the funny ones)
"slap bet" is probably the best episode. Slap bet starting and Robin Sparkles in one episode, hell yeah
so glad you did this, it's my favorite sitcom ever
S02E09 is the best episode, cmon. The introduction of both the slap bet AND robin sparkles? it cant be topped.
I’ve been waiting for the day HIMYM would be covered on this channel
"The Erickson boys" is my favorite. It is light-hearted and easy to watch
What about the best burger in New York?! That’s gotta be the top episode!
I'm not gonna lie, I tend to forget about TV shows after I watched them, so I wasn't anticipating any particular episode of HIMYM as "the perfect one", but as soon as you said "the pineapple incident" I was like "yep, it totally makes sense", that was a classic!
I think How I Met Your Mother had a few more Legendary episodes that was just great from beginning to end.
I just cant describe how amazing this show was.
How Can you say this episode ‘went under the radar’ - it’s quite literally the most viewed episode of all in this Series?
Great video btw!
One of the best episodes of the series
This episode let me discover "Voices" by Cheap trick. Great song.
Every single episode is amazing but my most fav one is episode one. It had such impact on me, especially when he introduced Robin as the kid's aunt. I started watching this show in 2017 with zero expectations and that particular episode made me so intrigued i watched the entire show in 2 months. Its easily now my favourite sitcom
Great choice! Although I believe the perfect episode is the one with “Blah blah” all around twists and turns in the best himym style. And incredibly hilarious
One of my favorite episodes is episode 1 of season 6 "Big Days". It takes place almost completely from the booth at Maclarens. Usually they always jump around. but this episode took place in one location and was kind of a simple episode. always enjoyed it
brilliant episode
Definitely not overlooked, it’s my favorite episode!
DAMMIT TRUDY! WHAT ABOUT THE PINEAPPLE!?!
Can't believe no one's mentioning The Race to the Stakehouse eoisode. Absolutely hilarious
"Drumroll Please" is the perfect HIMYM episode for me. I love Victoria. Her character was ruined in the later seasons.
Yes. That's the episode that made me a HIMYM fan. I dun think Victoria was ruined and it was great that she was brought back.
Wasn't that the one, which was supposed to be the final Episode before it got more episode and seasons? Victoria has always been my favorite, the actual mother being a close second.
@@puaykimteo2997 I still love victoria at the time of the ducky tie episode where ted bumps into her at an event. Then after that they had to make up weird quirks for victoria for ted to break up with her again. This is after victoria left klaus at the altar for ted. In the later seasons, Later seasons were just bad with a few good episodes sprinkled here and there. I wish they introduced the mother character earlier since she was the best part of the last season.
This episode, The Time Travelers and 3 Day of Snow are the single three best episodes of How I Met Your Mother.
My favourite episode is "Ted Mosby, architect"
dude! that is not an overlooked episode. it was voted one of the top 3 episodes by fans, and i believe, it took the top prize!
'Frasier' is worthy of a video
One aspect that also went full circle is the song that Ted karaoked to Robin from Cheap Trick. When Ted blacked out, it was one of the only hazy memories he had and when they concluded the episode the song was playing faintly in the background. Cool song btw.
The last episode of the 2nd season (the one with the blue horn) follow a similar structure, but there we got to solve the mistery alongside Barney. One of my favorites too.
Oh...and I like the new voice😀
Personally love this series as a whole.
Two in one week! Keep bringing it, Nerdstalgic!
I think the most hilarious episode is either Swarley or Slap Bet mainly because of the comedic relief but wholesome moments as well
My favourites is when lilly does a play and barney does his own to upset her and teaches her a lesson.
I love two amazing episodes - everyone's bad habits being talked about building to a crescendo in which they're all about to kill each other but Marshall remembers his password.
And (spoiler alert) tiny clues around them counting down to when Marshall receives the saddest news of his life.
ig this is the episode that kept me hooked to the show, perfect episode also perfect placement in season 1
The ducky tie episode is a master piece in storytelling
I prefer the burning beekeeper one. I like the way all the storylines slowly start to make sense
From Season 7, just seen it xD
What happened to the original nerdstalgic narrator???
I think he brought on a second collaborator to take on some work for him, so he can be more consistent with uploading on UA-cam. Still sucks thought because it misses the mark on why I love Nerdstalgic videos. The pacing and narrating done by the original creator is some of the best Production UA-cam has to offer and his videography takes are some of the most educated on this platform. No offense to the new but the original nerdstalgic creator is irreplaceable.
Thanks for finally clearing up the mystery of the pineapple
This show is the best for using set-ups and callbacks - not just within episodes or even seasons but throughout the entire series. Even the most insignificant detail becomes integral to a later event.
This episode is what got me into HIMYM and still one of my faves. The others being Everything Must Go and The Platinum Rule
Who is doing this video? Doesn't sound like the normal host of Nerdstalgic
Wait a second if the pineapple was on The Captains front porch doesn't that mean he is a swinger?
It's a new voice over artist who'll be voicing videos alongside Tyler.
@@MaverickMyth mans mouth is a little too wet.
This guy sounds so stilted. Tbh I mostly followed this channel for the flow of the original voice
@@ZenithKnight yeah I was hoping to fall asleep to this video because there's something about the original voiceover guy that is so relaxing. This one didn't do it for me
Yeahhhhhhhhhh I'm not interested in the new guy. I'm here for my main man Tyler. 😥
Right Place, Right Time and Lucky Penny. I love the story in reverse and how the smallest random moments end up being the game changers.
The 3 days of snow is awesome
4:18 Ted's sleeve is rolled up but there's nothing on his arm. Never realized that
Oh I actually really love where everyone except marshal and barney himself, are stuck in Barney’s closets.. such a hilarious episode with uncontrollable laughing starts from the very initiation scene.. and everytime, when robin calls ted and says, “how’s my favourite and most handsome architect?” And everytime ted replies, “hi mom”😂😂😂
My favorite episode (I forget the name) is where Ted's date is someone he met online. The pacing and writing of that episode is incredible, with unique jokes firing off every minute and landing every time, culminating in the revelation that the method Ted met her "online" was actually World of Warcraft (and that Ted's character was the petite female elf was the cherry on top).
"Overlooked" Literally is one of the most talked about episodes.....
I was just watching this episode for the first time and thought "This would be a great episode for Nerdstalgic to make a video about"
"Ted, it's Robin."
Dumbfounded and uncertain, Ted quizzically responds, "Are you sure?"
Please do the best Malcolm in the middle episode. It's really hard to decide on that one
Two episodes that stayed with me through the years are Hal's family reunion and when Lois daydreams about having girls instead of boys.
My favourite episode was when Robyn found out she can’t get pregnant. Soooo impactful and nuanced ♥️
But also the one when Lily says that sometimes she wishes she weren’t a mom. Oh that episode is gutting ♥️
This is literally one of the highest rated episodes.. if not THE highest.
The Burger always makes me craving for a burger
BRO I WAS LITERALLY YESTERDAY LOOKING FOR "how i met your mother video - nerdstalgic" AND NOW U POST THIS VIDEO IM SO FUCKING MIND BLOWN
Not overlooked at all. Widely recognized as one of the best episodes in the series.
Leaving pineapples in the front porch as a symbol of hospitality its such a humble and nice gesture (akin to the captain himself!!)
Damn it Trudy what about the pineapple?! One of my favourite Marshall moments :D
Perfect week is the best episode
RIP Bob Saget
You were Americas dad indeed.
How I Met Your Mother is my favorite sitcom, and while I'm not sure what my favorite episode is, this episode for all intents and purposes, *is* How I Met Your Mother, with the use of flashbacks, incomplete (at first) stories, and different perspectives all fitting together like a jigsaw to tell the story - it's very likely this was the episode they were using to explain that this is the kind of show they wanted to do.
Great video, I really liked how you described things and how the episode works - very well done. Slight correction though, the characters were in the late 20s to... somewhere in their 30s for most of the show (Ted turned 28 in Season 1.)
Also, Ted's a beta male? Awesome, I knew I was like Ted!
I'ts a legend wait for it dary
it ll be legend and you better not be lactose intolerant because the next word is dary
@@_bestcharacter_3654 Why does everyone include the d in legend when quoting this line?
I suppose it could be autocorrect
i first watched this episode when i was 13 and years later almost every week a voice inside my head said 'nothing good ever happens after 2 am'
0:25 they were supposed to be in their 20s? I thought everyone was in their 30s and 40s. I think most of the actors were in their mid 30s when the series started
0:05 sec in the video and I already agree, this episode was so good!
finally! I was waiting for your take on this
This episode was perfect for one reason - it featured Winnie Cooper!
There! I did your whole video in 5 seconds!
Don't you mean "Mrs. Tom Cruise"
😃
👍