Sparkle is BAD compared to BRONYA! | Honkai: Star Rail Character Analysis

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 85

  • @Nuttyjuice01
    @Nuttyjuice01  8 місяців тому +31

    Forgot to mention this in the video, but Sparkle attacks using a spinning back kick - just like the trashcans in Penacony.
    If that's not Hoyoverse calling her trash themselves, I don't know what is.

    • @EsporHB
      @EsporHB 8 місяців тому +1

      Not really. Seemingly it was Sparkle who invented those fighting trashcans and gave us the dream bubble. Not sparkle has the trashcans move, the trashcans have her move. Also trashcans are great and so is sparkle.

    • @chesterkuro15bernoulli75
      @chesterkuro15bernoulli75 8 місяців тому +1

      Ye, the trailblazer wants to marry the trashcan, now that's powerful trash, how can you dis the trash ... that is solid ... and I'm also salty about Sparkling water, she didn't came to my account too, she lost to ... Clara ... who did you get to get this salty... oh write, ye, you got Bronya, she cool I guess ... 🎉🎉🎉🎉😂😂😂❤

  • @DolusVulpes
    @DolusVulpes 8 місяців тому +29

    says "stop coping"
    precedes to cope

  • @SONICplayer001
    @SONICplayer001 8 місяців тому +15

    10:35 “Bronya replaces the need of sustain” I’m dead…💀

  • @SkyBlue_32
    @SkyBlue_32 8 місяців тому +30

    *the bait has been set*

    • @JordanU375
      @JordanU375 8 місяців тому +3

      That "Jing Yuan is the second best character in the game right now" was gold.

  • @Albin021
    @Albin021 8 місяців тому +27

    Thank you kind sir I'll use the 100 pulls I saved up for the standard banner

    • @Nuttyjuice01
      @Nuttyjuice01  8 місяців тому +8

      You're welcome!

    • @NightmareRex6
      @NightmareRex6 8 місяців тому +1

      i got like 150 or so pulls saved right now on standard....... i dont want to e7 the chars that allready e6 so waiting on more 4-stars to pool into the standard before blowing my standard pulls, the ONLY reason cam think of to save standard pulls.

    • @Albin021
      @Albin021 8 місяців тому +1

      @@NightmareRex6 that’s so based

    • @chesterkuro15bernoulli75
      @chesterkuro15bernoulli75 8 місяців тому

      Trashcan forever!!!! ... viva le trashcan !!!!

  • @qhtlz
    @qhtlz 8 місяців тому +16

    i hope this is sarcasm t-t

  • @achill_cf9082
    @achill_cf9082 8 місяців тому +14

    Ya but her trailers a LSD trip so sparkle better

  • @seikijin2308
    @seikijin2308 8 місяців тому +4

    I knew it was bait but sometimes the bait can be a funny meme. The serious tone of the joke didn't do it xD

  • @IdeasAreBulletproof
    @IdeasAreBulletproof 8 місяців тому +5

    If I got to say this, Bronya's only probably better with Jingliu Comps, (She can also totally suffice for other SP Positive DPSes like Blade and Arlan) and she has a Cleanse, and you can Wombo combo with her a lot better then Sparkle, You can make Bronya work in a lot of Comps
    but Sparkle is so much more Comfortable in many more SP Negative Hypercarry comps and Unlike Bronya (Her Eidolons/LC make her really good in Dual Dps (I want you to Try to explain to me how Bronya's E6 is Better at Dual DPS then anything Sparkle without Mentioning the Dual DPS one herself) She works so much Better in Jing Yuan comps (Lightning Lord don't benefit from Bronya (and almost Every F2P don't have the Eidolon 6 where LL would benefit from Bronya) Sparkle is better in a lot of Comps. The main thing one could argue about Bronya is she's better in some ways as a unit (Not Every way) and The fact you used Passerby to prove Bronya Better then Sparkle is utter Hysteria
    + Sparkle has way more Amplification then Bronya. (Similar Amp at E0S0 while way ahead at E2S1+)
    Also, I wonder how your gonna tell me Hanya is better then Sparkle.

  • @deku8966
    @deku8966 8 місяців тому +5

    Well… this video didn’t age well

  • @samsnell5899
    @samsnell5899 8 місяців тому +2

    as someone who just skipped sparkle for jing yuan (i dont have dhil and my bronya/hanya/ruan mei are doing fine), i got him on my first 10 pull. good call, luck in HSR is undoubtedly skill based. time to roll for some true offense HP relics to match. i wish i rolled for blade but i couldnt pass on ruan mei

  • @satwatchatterjee8633
    @satwatchatterjee8633 8 місяців тому +2

    with sparkle u can use higher sp consuming units in one team without using all sp and she is almost a must have for anyone who uses Imbibitor lunae or qinqque. bronya' skill is atk boost which last only in current turn but sparkle lasts 2 turns and u can use 2 dps in a single team without having any sp trouble. With proper speed tuning of other characters her 50% action advance can have same effect as 100% action advance. overall she is not bad to bronya . she can be on same level but never bad if not good. one more note any character which doesnt scale of atk but need that cd for damage like blade will be benifitted from sparkle

    • @alluvion_.s
      @alluvion_.s 8 місяців тому +5

      okay, i'm 80% sure that the video is satire or just bait for views so you're really just feeding the fire but I don't disagree with your statements. maybe just tone it down a tad bit :D

    • @satwatchatterjee8633
      @satwatchatterjee8633 8 місяців тому +1

      The video itched the star rail nerd self inside me
      So i wrote it

  • @alluvion_.s
    @alluvion_.s 8 місяців тому +2

    In all honesty, I'll still be rolling for her so I can have Sparkle and Bronya on the same team and get double buffers. Or I can just have two really good buffers to use for seperate team comps. ( also im praying this is satire )

  • @skipthewave
    @skipthewave 8 місяців тому +2

    💀
    Trolling or not, don't we have enough misinformation already?

  • @trashercraft2636
    @trashercraft2636 8 місяців тому +9

    the video is sarcasm right ? cuz its about the mask fool i get it you're really funny

  • @dreakney
    @dreakney 8 місяців тому +14

    he doesnt need oxygen, oxygen need him
    my man starting world war 3

  • @gunturafriefendi2576
    @gunturafriefendi2576 8 місяців тому +2

    the most important bronya kit is she can cleansing debuff from her skill

  • @banir3736
    @banir3736 8 місяців тому +23

    This is probably the most uninsightful take I’ve ever heard. 😂 I don’t know if it’s a joke or not, but I have a c3 bronya and Sparkle is alsready leaps and bounds better than her in my Mono Quantum Team (the team I play the most).

    • @IdefinitelyExistIThink
      @IdefinitelyExistIThink 8 місяців тому +3

      Tbf a speed tuned bronya can bring out a really amazing value. Sparkle however is unreliable with speed tuning.
      Sparkle does however outscale bronya if you use mono qunatum QQ or Dan IL or some heavy sp using teams
      However, we have to remember the most value of bronya doesn't come from buffs but instead from her skill, when used perfectly and speed tuned, the skill does wonders

    • @IdefinitelyExistIThink
      @IdefinitelyExistIThink 8 місяців тому

      also, sparkle is not for hyper carry unless you use QQ/Dan IL. Sparkle opens a new way of playing. of course I believe she'll be under Ruan Mei. since ruan mei is way more universal.

    • @keneunaegbu851
      @keneunaegbu851 8 місяців тому +4

      ​@@IdefinitelyExistIThinkBoth of your comments are complete nonsense, respectfully 🙏

    • @IdefinitelyExistIThink
      @IdefinitelyExistIThink 8 місяців тому

      @aegbu851 I mean, maybe they are.
      But i do believe speed tuning with sparkle would be unreliable. Also, I believe Ruan Mei would still be better.

    • @keneunaegbu851
      @keneunaegbu851 8 місяців тому +3

      @IdefinitelyExistIThink How would speed tuning with Sparkle be unreliable? I'm pretty sure that so long as she isn't more than twice as fast as your dps they will always take their turn right after her skill

  • @OdysseyNaafiri
    @OdysseyNaafiri 8 місяців тому +2

    You want Sparkle? Run Bronya and Hanya

    • @sunnyhelloguy
      @sunnyhelloguy 8 місяців тому

      DHIL is gonna be ☠️☠️☠️

  • @kyoga5714
    @kyoga5714 7 місяців тому

    you can could tell he was trolling as soon as he called bronya a FREE unit (at 300 standard wishes)

  • @stribijev
    @stribijev 8 місяців тому

    It is not really necessary to say who is better. They are both quite interesting and useful in specific teams, I even tried to play them in a single team, but have not quite figured out what the best strategy is then. One thing is certain: 0-cycles are madness, achieving 0-cycle victories is far from being a criterium how well you play HSR. Only whales can do that, with E6S5 or close to that.

  • @altogrey9712
    @altogrey9712 8 місяців тому +2

    I love me my satire, rage bait 😂

  • @cookies23z
    @cookies23z 8 місяців тому

    "Sparkle is a terrorist, she isnt good for the community" XDDD

  • @mismagia
    @mismagia 8 місяців тому

    bronya just feels like such a good bargain you get so much for so little i dont see why id pay out the ass to replace bronya for that small upgrade from S tier to SS tier when instead i could invest in a character like jingliu or DHIL and gain free bronya LC stonks at the same time which i feel overall would provide a bigger vertical boost to your account
    obviously sparkles numbers are better on paper but how much time and money and resources are worth investing into that upgrade when you could be spending them on a part of your account that needs it more than bronya does i think characters like Huo Huo or Fu xuan or kafka are much higher value for your account than replacing your bronya with a sparkle is

  • @dante19890
    @dante19890 8 місяців тому

    Bronya is better for Blade and Jingliu but all other supports benefits more for e0 Sparkle than e0 Bronya

  • @stephennegron7560
    @stephennegron7560 7 місяців тому

    The like to dislikes ratio is hilarious

  • @IdefinitelyExistIThink
    @IdefinitelyExistIThink 8 місяців тому

    i think sparkle is op depending on the team you use. But unlike bronya she makes it hard to speed tune. Not as reliable unless you use her in a team with QQ or Dan heng IL.
    I think she'll be awesome in a mono qunatum QQ team.

    • @NightmareRex6
      @NightmareRex6 8 місяців тому

      so like silverwolf seele fuxuan and sparkle.

    • @IdefinitelyExistIThink
      @IdefinitelyExistIThink 8 місяців тому

      @@NightmareRex6 eh, she works out well enough with everything, except those who don't use crit damage like Kafka.
      The funniest team will be sparkle bronya blade sustain(lynx/luocha who don't have to span their skill).
      You can also replace blade with jingliu. And if you tune them well, it's unlimited blade works

    • @IdefinitelyExistIThink
      @IdefinitelyExistIThink 8 місяців тому

      @@NightmareRex6 but mono quantum is the best

  • @OrbitalForce
    @OrbitalForce 8 місяців тому

    Feels like you're tryna talk crap about her set and presenting nitpicks as your evidence whennn you actually have nothing to base it off of
    Edit: Oh you are actually trolling

  • @Blood-Moon-Pack
    @Blood-Moon-Pack 8 місяців тому

    and bronya has no trailer she is the background charecter in seles trailer

    • @AIA222-yu5ml
      @AIA222-yu5ml 8 місяців тому +1

      You do realize it's satire, right?

  • @xicor2082
    @xicor2082 8 місяців тому

    first of all bronya cant use her ult on first turn so no cd and sparkle can with skill and at the starting and for action forward u need high need spd anyways for 0 cycles so the 50% action forward wont affect much if u have 160 spd sparkle . secondly blade is not the best unit in the game . DHIL who needs all the skill points will be benefited who deals alot more dmg than blade and their no way bronya will work with DHIL . your counting blade a skill neutral unit too be paired with sparkle nice. With bronya u need to use basic several time for the lack of skill points and thats dps loss. with sparkle u can, almost all the time use skill on dps and skill on sparkle generates more energy for her and more energy give give ult faster and ult gives more skill points and ciper lasts longer. ciper helps deal more dmg . brronya's basic is just cope 10k game changing xd. 4 piece healing instead of a 2piece spd for 0 cycles . sparkle will be future proof having 7 skill points and generating skill points is game breaking mehanic not hitting 10k with bronya . sparkle is not bad she is better than bronya than many scenario. the only good scenario i think of bronya is better is direct action . and I using bronya since DAY 1. ZERO POINTS

  • @Noamy092
    @Noamy092 8 місяців тому +2

    You burned the kitchen with this video ngl. Your whole take has 0 sense. I think you dont even know how advance forward works haha. Just because sparkle has 50% she still advance forward the dps below her unless she is 2x faster than the dps which means you cant do -1 spd unlike bronya but its not even needed. With 160.1 spd ur dps can act 4 times if u r trying to 0 cycle WITHOUT spd boots! That is huge and dont underestimate that. Bronya doesnt work with fua characters, sparkle does. Bronya def trace and crit trace are trash haha she does 0 dmg and if ur bronya doesnt have enough hp or def she can easily get one shotted. Sparkle doesnt need that because she is already tanky. Jl+blade will still prefer bronya but every single other dps wants sparkle. These are facts! Also saying that blade is the best dps is the biggest cope I have heard in 10 years lol. He is mid maximum. Next time please do more research before posting a meme video like this! 😂

  • @andry6164
    @andry6164 8 місяців тому

    Dude Bronya eats all skill points leaving dps with no skills to use losing damage a lot and braking team rotation so she’s not that op

  • @necromancerscarlet5954
    @necromancerscarlet5954 8 місяців тому

    i will pull her with light cone only because i like the character.I dont really care about power of character.

  • @sm1L3maker
    @sm1L3maker 8 місяців тому +4

    you're goddamn right 😎

  • @marclenraymagdaraog691
    @marclenraymagdaraog691 8 місяців тому +2

    Nc bait.. ur really trying ur best. but nah better try next time bro.

  • @galaxyrunaway
    @galaxyrunaway 8 місяців тому

    Least obvious bait

  • @Nomoreadrenaline
    @Nomoreadrenaline 8 місяців тому

    no wonder why you barely have subscribers.

  • @AzureDrag0n1
    @AzureDrag0n1 8 місяців тому

    This is some bait.

  • @jonathanmatthews8862
    @jonathanmatthews8862 7 місяців тому

    I don’t know why content creators think otherwise but Sparkle was made for a mono Quantum team. Ideally a Qingque but Seele works as well. She can also be a support for DHIL if you are bad at managing his SP use.
    Qingque is not the greatest unit around unfortunately but is definitely the best DPS to use with Sparkle. If we ever get a ST Boss mode at the end game then Sparkle + Seele in mono Qua will tear bosses apart.

  • @Blood-Moon-Pack
    @Blood-Moon-Pack 8 місяців тому

    realy scummy behavior its a gacha game its gambaling what do you mean realy scummy they get cash by a gacha system if they dont make us buy charecter they will have no money to pay the bill

    • @NightmareRex6
      @NightmareRex6 8 місяців тому

      i think the point is they got TONS to "pay the bills" becuase genshin came out durring BS covID lockdowns, im sure this was planned moment they caught wind of this they decided to release game then. lockdowns screwed over lots things but games lockdowns increased profits.

  • @MiroriYamata
    @MiroriYamata 8 місяців тому

    just wait for robin whole team action forward

    • @AIA222-yu5ml
      @AIA222-yu5ml 8 місяців тому

      I love my maniac, but I have to get the angel siblings first.

  • @Seance117
    @Seance117 8 місяців тому

    pup is fishing hard

  • @jesusantonionavarroespinoz4447
    @jesusantonionavarroespinoz4447 8 місяців тому

    bruh

  • @nkosiezikalala5267
    @nkosiezikalala5267 8 місяців тому +1

    Yeyeye, Her kit feels a bit redundant since pretty much all harmony units are SP Positive (Except Yukong, who's mid and Broyna, who's Neutral when played well). She Feels like a unit who'll have to work overtime to (or have crazy numbers) to compete with Broyna. It's mainly a comfort thing.

    • @heyjay1438
      @heyjay1438 8 місяців тому +4

      "All Harmony units are SP Positive" while true is irrelevant to your point because the SP she generates are not just for her but for the whole team especially for characters that like to spam skill or consume multiple SP per turn e.g. DHIL, QQ, seele and future characters.

    • @TerraTheWise
      @TerraTheWise 8 місяців тому

      SP positive and SP positive while spamming skill every turn aren't the same thing. Ruan Mei for ex has a 4 turn ult compared to sparkles guaranteed 3 turn with just an ER rope. She doesn't have to do any work to compete with bronya she's straight up better. She fits more teams without needing eidolons and doesn't burn through all your SP. Keep up.

    • @lazytanuki6174
      @lazytanuki6174 8 місяців тому +1

      she Increases the CRIT DMG of a single target ally by 30% of her CRIT DMG plus 54%,
      for 1 turn(s). And at the same time, Advances Forward an ally's action by 50%.
      bronya's is 18% plus 24% CDMG

    • @lazytanuki6174
      @lazytanuki6174 8 місяців тому

      her ult recovers 4 sp

  • @BelialRus
    @BelialRus 8 місяців тому +4

    Despite this vid is better than the last one, I am surprised that tc of your caliber missed the GLARING problems with Sparkle
    1) Monoquantum sucks: you can only squeeze 3 out of 6 existing quantum characters most of which are terrible. If she somehow expanded amount of characters you can deploy in battle she could be decent, but this is a joke.
    2) Nobody needs skill points, bc to zero cycle you only need starting 3. You never even use SP generator in zero cycle. As someone who strives to become a professional endgame player I think its important to remember. So she is useless in most powerful teams...
    3) Action advance is overrated. Most powerful characters already can attack twice. Dhil with bug/hacks, Jingliu E and then enter stance E, Seele resurgence, QingQue double attack. So why would you want advance when enemy is already dead? Also you can just replace Sparkle with another DD. DHIL + QQ will attack 4 times!
    4) Crit damage buff lol , if you dont crit its useless, no need to say anything else
    5) tiny damage and atk buff, you get more from planars. sure if you run planarless Seele i guess then Sparkle is good for you at trailblaze level 1 or 2, but at pro levels its worthless.
    PS: the Sparke carry for Bronya is really smart tho. I'm considering pulling her for that tech

    • @Nuttyjuice01
      @Nuttyjuice01  8 місяців тому +4

      I can understand where you're coming from with these points. Although I do feel like there are nuances to some of the ideas here.
      For example crit damage isn't as bad as it might seem. If you don't crit, sure it's 100% useless. But even on 5% crit rate you can either crit or not crit, making it roughly a 50% chance for crit dmg to be effective.
      But yes, I do see your points with a lot of these. For example, DHIL certainly does not need Sparkles action advance seeing as how he can do it on his own. And skill points being super overrated seeing as how you can just end battles early by being better.
      That's why I make such videos - to encourage discussion. Thanks for the input! :)

    • @hienphamnguyen
      @hienphamnguyen 8 місяців тому

      I think she was meant to be for challenge in MoC btw, just image a team with one DPS, bronya, her and maybe one tank, one healer, it will be crazy for the skill action advance to work, and how many attack our dps can do. For me, you can skip her if you already have decent support unit like Ruan Mei, Bronya. But with her, it can be easier to complete MoC since it requires to separated team for each floor.

    • @oskarclausen9408
      @oskarclausen9408 8 місяців тому +2

      Thank you for your take on the crit dmg buff, now i know not to go for crit dmg relics since it's useless if i don't crit.

    • @russianbot7853
      @russianbot7853 8 місяців тому +1

      1. monoquantum is genuinely one of the most solid teams in the game, bc it's good in both single target and AoE situations, and can brute force almost any single fight, plus sparkle literally has a free quantum% buff in a trace
      2. SP generation is one of the most important aspects of HSR combat, that's why March is regarded as the worst sustain, since she's heavily SP negative. Sparkle + DHIL/QQ will definitely be a good combo with high ease of use
      3. Action Advance is legit the reason why Bronya's as broken as she is rn, having yet another turn to do damage on your main dps will always be good on a unit
      4. crit damage buffs are always good, since it's just more damage. if you miss a crit that's on you
      5. atk/dmg buffs are always good since yet again it's free dmg

    • @russianbot7853
      @russianbot7853 8 місяців тому

      @@oskarclausen9408 i meant to reply to OP not you