Always hated how companion activities only showed up for a limited amount of time (usually like an hour), they're too easy to miss. Literally have 200 hours on the game and I just found out about this and another companion activity with Pearson.
If you follow Mary-Beth, she slows down at Dewberry Creek and you can join her for a pleasant moonlit ride back to camp. I got some terrific photos from that. Don't tell my wife.
@@joshuaballard6013 @hrdman2luv if it’s the pen the black water guy gave to you then for some reason you can’t you can find the real pen is a home with dead children
@@hrdman2luvif it’s the pen you got from Jimmy Brooks when you first go to Valentine, you can’t give that one to her. There’s another one to find and give her.
Huh? "Start drama"? Arthur did not even start drama with anyone in the gang. The only trouble he started was against John leaving the gang once for his own selfish reason and the other obviously being Micah and Bill being stupid. Those are the three that he has issues with and would often bicker with them about but he didn't start shit with anyone else.
I’ve found the easiest way to get this side mission as well as bill and Tilly’s robbery is to do all of the Braithwaite and gray missions first and keep the Molly mission at camp for last
I love Tilly, but it was not smart of her to start insulting the short tempered lead on a job involving killing, especially when he is of below average intelligence and suffers from cripping inferiority issues. Let alone doing so in front of someone he undoubtedly respects, admires, and seeks the approval of. I always got the feeling that Bill was Bi, heavily leaning towards men and given those times that must've done hell on the man's mind. He doesn't want to be seen as weak or stupid, so he tries to intimidate others for respect and later as a way of showing it isn't personal he becomes very friendly and brotherly to the same people he talked shit to earlier, but he's terrified of being honest, of being ostracized by the only people that accepted him. Dutch's Boys are the ones most likely to be accepting if it came out that he preferred men over women romantically, yet even still his fear paralyzes him, so he likes others but isn't close to anyone. Liked, but never loved. Friend, but never family, never a brother to the brothers he chose and unable to see that they treat him the way he does others in the assumption that it must just be how Bill is; teasing him, bullying him, challenging him, then laughing and fighting and drinking with one another. He trusts these people with his life, he'd kill and die for them; same as Arthur, Davy, Mac, Jenny, Sean, Lenny, Hosea, John, and Javier...but after being rejected by everyone in his life, he can't be honest about who he is so he plays an exagerrated version of himself then grows angry when others believe it or play along because it isn't getting what he feels he needs and wants. "I am angry at myself", as Bill put it when he was afraid everyone thought he was pissed off at them. He never wanted the gang to think he hated them or was angry with them, despite being an angry guy in general.
@@ladyvexx7034 If only that companion activity wasn't bugged. On my 1st or 2nd playthrough, once everyone was dealt with and the wagon was stopped, Bill would not move his horse so I could blow up the safe on the wagon without killing his horse and failing the mission. It was stuck like that for the longest time no matter how many times I retried. I tried everything to get his horse to move, and nothing worked.
@@robertphillips213 That's all true of Bill, but in this instance he started it, and Tilly merely stood up for herself. Was she supposed to be the submissive woman?
@@TheOceanBearer Yep, to get the job done efficiently. She can insult him 'till she's blue in the face afterwards. If you can't stay professional during a job and work together to achieve a desirable result, despite disliking them, then you shouldn't be doing it or anything dangerous that requires team-work.
@@robertphillips213 Tilly likely didn't feel like doing that since how obnoxious Bill can be in general. I do feel sorry for the guy but not enough to excuse his behavior towards others, Tilly has had her own share of issues, she likely had the Foreman brothers talk down to her in the past and she likely doesn't like feeling helpless like she used to before she found the gang. Yes Bill deserves some sympathy as he likely is self loathing and insecure and his experiences during the Indian American war likely traumatized him and it's why he has such a grudge against Charles, but he also antagonized Tilly so she jabbed him back, its only human nature for things to escalate back and forth, I could argue Bill was just as stupid for angering Tilly even though he brought her along as a distraction, he sort of pissed in his own plan.
I can confirm you don’t need ultimate edition to get this mission you need to finish (the fine joys of tabaco & friends in very low places) be in the camp around 1pm also do not do the mission with bill if you want this part of the mission to work
This side mission does come up more than once. I spent a bit of time between each story mission so I can try to get as many random events between each lvl as possible. This would come up every few days if you don't move onto the next mission.... so don't feel like you have to reload if you miss it.... I also did not wait so long for Mary Beth's distractions, I just shot them all in the head. Lol.
Kinda annoys me this mission is in the ultimate edition and not the base edition. Like is there a way to buy the mission or is it like exclusive? Because it sucks that this mission has them talking about one of the gangs origins and it’s a bonus mission for certain editions of the game
Not true, it doesn’t matter if you got ultimate edition or not for this one but there is another camp activity with Charles and Uncle in chapter 4 where you go rob the bank in Rhodes, that mission is sadly only available in the ultimate edition of the game so I think you might have mixed those 2 up
I remember seeing a spoiler that Sean dies so I sat at camp and waited until the option to do the stage coach with Sean came up (I thought it'd be nice to bond with him) and then Mary-Beth joined and I was excited, I later did it with Bill too and his argument with Tilly was funny af but I felt Mary-Beth and Sean did it properly and had a plan while Bill just made the player do most the work imo
@@abraxas511 I can't tell if you're joking or not but you know you can't shoot allies, right?? When you aim at them, the game greys out the crosshair and prevents you from firing. You can literally see this happen at 5:07.
lol that man holding Mary Beth hostage was about to prepare a dramatic intense moment to give up or he’ll shoot her, but Arthur shot him before that moment even happened 😂
The mission is available for a very short amount of time if a player is blazing through story missions. There's very few missions after The Fine Joys of Tobacco before Sean becomes unavailable for this.
Dude I completely forgot about this mission. That and the other missions like this with Bill and Tilly, and the Pearson mission too. Apparently the were going to be companion activities such as going out drinking with Uncle and Bill I think, and also a hunting mission with John. I’m sure there were more but I’m forgetting what they were.
2:44 ah yes the annoying bug where your horse randomly goes in a circle. Also happens when the camera is untouched and straight behind in default position..
thank you =) btw you can do almost the exact same mission with Tilly and bill right. after this one, the difference is that bill is rude to Tilly so she refuses to go along with the mission and you have to jump on th wagon instead
*sean voice* I’m hoping someone can tell me what jacket that is and I’m praying it isn’t anything that involves further installs or having to buy some special edition this or another
can you do the 2nd encounter with the man that asks you to rob a hotel room in Valentine? UA-camr Winston Willamette did a video of the second encounter and did the outcome where you beat the guy up after he confronts you for cheating him out of his share of the money and i'm hoping to see the outcome where Arthur peacefully resolves things by giving back his share.
It will be unlocked after the "The Fine Joys of Tobacco" mission. You must complete this before the "Blessed are the Peacemakers" mission. It will be available at a specific time (afternoon) There is not much gap between those 2 missions.
Don't get me wrong rdr 2 is a good story. But I rage rage bloody rage hate the controls and health and combat and movement because there is no running you have to walk everywhere. And every time you get of the horse Arthur's weapons reset without your permission. I hate that oh and the bounty system. I rather play Skyrim
@@Alduin3914 that's just a small portion of the game, it's unfair to judge the whole game just on that. I love Skyrim too, in fact, the reason I love RDR2 so much is basically because it reminds me of the wanderlust sensation Skyrim gave me all those years ago. If we're nitpicking here, Skyrim has a lot less to offer than RDR2 tbf
One thing i noticed after replaying this game again after dropping it several times because of some of the reasons you mentioned, its's the most enjoyable game when you actually play the game at normal pace and not rush the story, do some random stuff, side missions, there's so much to do in this game for example i recently found about increasing satchel capacity so started hunting animals for pelts at first i was rushing it felt so annoying took help from internet on where to find them, which i should use etc, halfway through i stopped doing any missions and kept hunting its quite fun tracking animals visiting different places with amazing scenery stumbling upon abandoned houses finding rare weapons and if you don't use trains for travel you will get random events which are quite fun and some of these events reward you special items that can be used to craft something useful like animal trinkets i've really come to appreciate this game.
@Trane141Kingz he's really not. He was dumb enough during a hissy fit to threaten to kill Arthur while he slept. Relentlessly tormented Kieran. He was loud, obnoxious. Entirely unlikable. For me at least.
@@mrkemrk I’m pretty sure the threat was a joke. They are outlaws so it’s like dark humor for them. The rest of the reasons? Fair enough even though I don’t mind Sean.
Always hated how companion activities only showed up for a limited amount of time (usually like an hour), they're too easy to miss. Literally have 200 hours on the game and I just found out about this and another companion activity with Pearson.
Hunting woth Pearson in the swamp had alot of fun
I just found this after 2100+ hrs wtf
Which one?
I still haven’t robbed the Rhodes bank….
Yep, I just found the crawfish one in my third playthrough last night, not really worth it but it was cool
If you follow Mary-Beth, she slows down at Dewberry Creek and you can join her for a pleasant moonlit ride back to camp. I got some terrific photos from that. Don't tell my wife.
I did.
Wtf
Are you calling your anime pillow "wife" now? LOL.
@@samuraidoggy Clever. Now go splooge on your Taylor Swift poster for the third time today, incel.
@@stflaw secrets secrets are no fun, secrets secrets hurt someone.
Heck, this might be the only time I've seen Mary-Beth outside of camp besides that early Valentine misssion and end-game
Yep. I wish you could run into them in town more like that Uncle encounter in Valentine.
@3:12 “While you two write about that in your journals” Well, both Arthur and Mary-Beth are writers.
Yeah That’s the joke
thanks captain obvious
I have the pen but it never let's me give it to Mary Beth.
@@joshuaballard6013 @hrdman2luv if it’s the pen the black water guy gave to you then for some reason you can’t you can find the real pen is a home with dead children
@@hrdman2luvif it’s the pen you got from Jimmy Brooks when you first go to Valentine, you can’t give that one to her. There’s another one to find and give her.
I love how Arthur is peoples favorite character even though he’s start drama with at least every person that isn’t Charles or Mary-Beth
Huh? "Start drama"? Arthur did not even start drama with anyone in the gang. The only trouble he started was against John leaving the gang once for his own selfish reason and the other obviously being Micah and Bill being stupid.
Those are the three that he has issues with and would often bicker with them about but he didn't start shit with anyone else.
@@MrLolx2ui think they were joking ❤️
@@DoyleFrankenstein yeah I was
@@MrLolx2u ahem: Uncle
Arthur doesn't start drama, he just be sarcastic or a smart ass but he always help everyone in the group and earns money
I’ve found the easiest way to get this side mission as well as bill and Tilly’s robbery is to do all of the Braithwaite and gray missions first and keep the Molly mission at camp for last
I like this one, but I love the companion activity with Tilly and Bill even more. Tilly definitely knows how to put Bill in his place in that one. 😄
I love Tilly, but it was not smart of her to start insulting the short tempered lead on a job involving killing, especially when he is of below average intelligence and suffers from cripping inferiority issues. Let alone doing so in front of someone he undoubtedly respects, admires, and seeks the approval of. I always got the feeling that Bill was Bi, heavily leaning towards men and given those times that must've done hell on the man's mind. He doesn't want to be seen as weak or stupid, so he tries to intimidate others for respect and later as a way of showing it isn't personal he becomes very friendly and brotherly to the same people he talked shit to earlier, but he's terrified of being honest, of being ostracized by the only people that accepted him.
Dutch's Boys are the ones most likely to be accepting if it came out that he preferred men over women romantically, yet even still his fear paralyzes him, so he likes others but isn't close to anyone. Liked, but never loved. Friend, but never family, never a brother to the brothers he chose and unable to see that they treat him the way he does others in the assumption that it must just be how Bill is; teasing him, bullying him, challenging him, then laughing and fighting and drinking with one another. He trusts these people with his life, he'd kill and die for them; same as Arthur, Davy, Mac, Jenny, Sean, Lenny, Hosea, John, and Javier...but after being rejected by everyone in his life, he can't be honest about who he is so he plays an exagerrated version of himself then grows angry when others believe it or play along because it isn't getting what he feels he needs and wants.
"I am angry at myself", as Bill put it when he was afraid everyone thought he was pissed off at them. He never wanted the gang to think he hated them or was angry with them, despite being an angry guy in general.
@@ladyvexx7034 If only that companion activity wasn't bugged. On my 1st or 2nd playthrough, once everyone was dealt with and the wagon was stopped, Bill would not move his horse so I could blow up the safe on the wagon without killing his horse and failing the mission. It was stuck like that for the longest time no matter how many times I retried. I tried everything to get his horse to move, and nothing worked.
@@robertphillips213 That's all true of Bill, but in this instance he started it, and Tilly merely stood up for herself. Was she supposed to be the submissive woman?
@@TheOceanBearer Yep, to get the job done efficiently. She can insult him 'till she's blue in the face afterwards. If you can't stay professional during a job and work together to achieve a desirable result, despite disliking them, then you shouldn't be doing it or anything dangerous that requires team-work.
@@robertphillips213 Tilly likely didn't feel like doing that since how obnoxious Bill can be in general. I do feel sorry for the guy but not enough to excuse his behavior towards others, Tilly has had her own share of issues, she likely had the Foreman brothers talk down to her in the past and she likely doesn't like feeling helpless like she used to before she found the gang.
Yes Bill deserves some sympathy as he likely is self loathing and insecure and his experiences during the Indian American war likely traumatized him and it's why he has such a grudge against Charles, but he also antagonized Tilly so she jabbed him back, its only human nature for things to escalate back and forth, I could argue Bill was just as stupid for angering Tilly even though he brought her along as a distraction, he sort of pissed in his own plan.
I LOVE Mary-beth gaskill
We all do
I'm sitting at 1,101 hours in this game and I've never seen this one. This is the best game ever made.
Mary Beth is the best looking woman in that game in my op
without a shadow of a doubt, there is no contest
@CeizoBro exactly
Tbf the bar ain't high.
@@Hyrule409 wdym
@@Hyrule409 she sets the bar imo, the 5 star meal in a world of McDonald’s
I can confirm you don’t need ultimate edition to get this mission you need to finish (the fine joys of tabaco & friends in very low places) be in the camp around 1pm also do not do the mission with bill if you want this part of the mission to work
And this is why I love this game I’ve never done this mission before
This side mission does come up more than once. I spent a bit of time between each story mission so I can try to get as many random events between each lvl as possible. This would come up every few days if you don't move onto the next mission.... so don't feel like you have to reload if you miss it.... I also did not wait so long for Mary Beth's distractions, I just shot them all in the head. Lol.
One of my favorite companion activities, along with the robbery with Javier 🤠👍
The bill stage coach robbery is pretty fun too, it’s got some amusing dialogue as well
Where can i get that horse? It’s beautiful?
@@Pixie_2002 I’m pretty sure it’s the one you get for free for one the editions of the game, can’t remember which
@@Pixie_2002that horse is probably dapple black throughbread. İts only for special and deluxe editions if i remember right
"he was like an annoying little brother to me..."
This is actually one of the last missions you can do with Sean before the doomed Gray family mission 😢
I hate how hard it can be to get these side missions to show up.
This is ultimate edition
Yes but the mission is available for everyone
I never miss this on any playthroughs.
The wagon falling out of the sky after you shot the guy who took her hostage 🤣
There was a lot of things i missed on my first play through of the game i recently found out you can do a mission with uncle and pearson.
Kinda annoys me this mission is in the ultimate edition and not the base edition.
Like is there a way to buy the mission or is it like exclusive? Because it sucks that this mission has them talking about one of the gangs origins and it’s a bonus mission for certain editions of the game
Not true, it doesn’t matter if you got ultimate edition or not for this one but there is another camp activity with Charles and Uncle in chapter 4 where you go rob the bank in Rhodes, that mission is sadly only available in the ultimate edition of the game so I think you might have mixed those 2 up
I got the regular disc version back in 2018 and did this mission just fine. I don’t know if it’s honor dependent
@@XDMIIIIIIIII shit then I guess I just missed it
this is base game
The log they were hiding behind is the same one the donkey zebra mission was used.
I remember seeing a spoiler that Sean dies so I sat at camp and waited until the option to do the stage coach with Sean came up (I thought it'd be nice to bond with him) and then Mary-Beth joined and I was excited, I later did it with Bill too and his argument with Tilly was funny af but I felt Mary-Beth and Sean did it properly and had a plan while Bill just made the player do most the work imo
Use your binoculars. You never scope a friendly.
It's a fucking video game, genius.
Nope, can’t protect friendlies with a binocular.
@@youngnat cant shoot them either
@@abraxas511 I can't tell if you're joking or not but you know you can't shoot allies, right?? When you aim at them, the game greys out the crosshair and prevents you from firing. You can literally see this happen at 5:07.
Take it easy, Fudd
“Wouldn’t dream of it” 1:27
Arthur loves the sarcasm
Sean was actually a funny guy
I really wish Mary-Beth would have ride with Arthur
if it wasn't for arthur this would have been the end of mary beth
Everyone that died before Arthur had it easy. Arthur watched almost all of his friends die before he joined them
admit I like how Mary-Beth's horse has bangs
lol that man holding Mary Beth hostage was about to prepare a dramatic intense moment to give up or he’ll shoot her, but Arthur shot him before that moment even happened 😂
I miss this part 😢imma do another 2nd playthrough
So..what’s the mistake?
Idk
Not having the Ultimate Edition.
@@rustyforceps1012u don't need one to do the mission
The mission is available for a very short amount of time if a player is blazing through story missions. There's very few missions after The Fine Joys of Tobacco before Sean becomes unavailable for this.
One of this charater uhh exits the main story, so if you do the main quest, there is a really small window to get this event
Dude I completely forgot about this mission. That and the other missions like this with Bill and Tilly, and the Pearson mission too. Apparently the were going to be companion activities such as going out drinking with Uncle and Bill I think, and also a hunting mission with John. I’m sure there were more but I’m forgetting what they were.
And also I mean you go drinking with Uncle and Bill separately, not all together.
guys just letting you know me and Mary-Beth are married
💀
💀
@@Player_7 yoooo
😂😂😂
Bro better stop playin this shit
Damn, this is such a nice activity. Thanks for sharing this.
had this game since it came out and never seen this mission, thanks!
2:44 ah yes the annoying bug where your horse randomly goes in a circle.
Also happens when the camera is untouched and straight behind in default position..
It looked like a stylish flourish after Arthur dropped a decent line.
thank you =) btw you can do almost the exact same mission with Tilly and bill right. after this one, the difference is that bill is rude to Tilly so she refuses to go along with the mission and you have to jump on th wagon instead
I didn’t even know this was a mission
I'm guessing you might need to complete the John and Dutch missions first? Up to Blessed are The Peacekeepers mission.
I was pissed when they shot Sean 😢
6:27 what happened there? the stagecoach respawns mid air?
The merry Beth heist I done that lots but worth it everytime love her
love this mission, luckily i been through this during 2nd playthrough
Wait ! I've done all the side missions in RDR 2 why can't I find the missions in chaper 3
My favourite activities were Strauss'. Easy and harmless.
4:20 I love the accent change
I'm a firm believer that Mary-beth is 1 of the hottest characters in this game. Not that it matters but still
6:24 is that Trevor?
Trevor in the 1800s? I think he time traveled because he was tired of the GTA universe
Where did you get that jacket??
“Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called sons of God.”- The book of Matthew, chapter 5, verse 9.
how did you get that reverse dapples black horse in chapter 3? is it mods?
or ultimate edition?
Ultimate
*sean voice* I’m hoping someone can tell me what jacket that is and I’m praying it isn’t anything that involves further installs or having to buy some special edition this or another
can you do the 2nd encounter with the man that asks you to rob a hotel room in Valentine? UA-camr Winston Willamette did a video of the second encounter and did the outcome where you beat the guy up after he confronts you for cheating him out of his share of the money and i'm hoping to see the outcome where Arthur peacefully resolves things by giving back his share.
What horse is that you have with Arthur??
Its not showing up for me is it because ive completed magicians for sport before the tobacco mission?
It’s for the special edition I think
@@NuevaCalifornia1769 aw man
Oh yeah, I did this one. Arthur just wanted a free cut 😂
Where did you buy this dress that Arthur was wearing? All black dress
Special / Ultimate edition bonus
@@Player_7 Should the game be the final version?
What jacket is that? Never seen it
where can i get that black jacket?
Isn’t this only with some special edition of the game?
6:24 wtf happen there 😂
I need another playhtrough where i dont speed throigh the story... Make camp visits more often
Second playthrough I did every companion requests and mission I could what a masterfully made game
What is that jacket
Why does short hair Arthur look like channing Tatum?
Oh I got this on my last playthrough
i accidentally did this before by accident
What was the mistake to miss it though? Dumb clickbait bs
Well obviously not doing it when it pops up, might've been a clickbait but attacking this guy for nothing is wrong
@@0902_It’s only for special/ultimate edition. He probably forgot to include that when editing the video.
@@replosite3571No, you can do it on every version you just need certain Honor level.
1:08 😂😂
I got this mission with Lenny.
no
Wtf how do you get this mission let me know 🙏
Where do u find that horse at?
ultimate edition
And what's that mistake?
It will be unlocked after the "The Fine Joys of Tobacco" mission. You must complete this before the "Blessed are the Peacemakers" mission. It will be available at a specific time (afternoon) There is not much gap between those 2 missions.
@@Player_7 Thanks mate!
Tne mistake is watching this clickbait video.
How did the get the coat?
pre order
That's crazy. I skipped this because I find Sean annoying... 😢
Insist?
Lol arthur looks like a simp with short hair and no beard
Ive literally never gottwn this
Hella gay that I never got this mission
Aw man, i wish i knew about this :c
Ivè done this several times
3 ❤️s in a row 😶
❤
Don't get me wrong rdr 2 is a good story. But I rage rage bloody rage hate the controls and health and combat and movement because there is no running you have to walk everywhere. And every time you get of the horse Arthur's weapons reset without your permission. I hate that oh and the bounty system. I rather play Skyrim
There is no running? What are you talking about?
@@wanharrysanjaya7259 when in the gang camp or inside houses.
@@Alduin3914 that's just a small portion of the game, it's unfair to judge the whole game just on that. I love Skyrim too, in fact, the reason I love RDR2 so much is basically because it reminds me of the wanderlust sensation Skyrim gave me all those years ago. If we're nitpicking here, Skyrim has a lot less to offer than RDR2 tbf
@@wanharrysanjaya7259 ok mate I get what you mean.
One thing i noticed after replaying this game again after dropping it several times because of some of the reasons you mentioned, its's the most enjoyable game when you actually play the game at normal pace and not rush the story, do some random stuff, side missions, there's so much to do in this game for example i recently found about increasing satchel capacity so started hunting animals for pelts at first i was rushing it felt so annoying took help from internet on where to find them, which i should use etc, halfway through i stopped doing any missions and kept hunting its quite fun tracking animals visiting different places with amazing scenery stumbling upon abandoned houses finding rare weapons and if you don't use trains for travel you will get random events which are quite fun and some of these events reward you special items that can be used to craft something useful like animal trinkets i've really come to appreciate this game.
YOU PLAY ON STEAM
VERY AMAZING GAMEPLAY Robbery stagecoach MY FRIENDS WELL DONE SUPER incredible ❤❤❤❤❤👍👍👍👍👍
Ok
Turn off your capslock, fool.
I can't be the only one who hates Sean.
WHY. Sean's awesome. I don't get why you'd hate him. He's a good, likeable guy
@Trane141Kingz he's really not. He was dumb enough during a hissy fit to threaten to kill Arthur while he slept. Relentlessly tormented Kieran. He was loud, obnoxious. Entirely unlikable. For me at least.
@@mrkemrk I’m pretty sure the threat was a joke. They are outlaws so it’s like dark humor for them. The rest of the reasons? Fair enough even though I don’t mind Sean.
❤
❤
❤
❤