The girl group in this video is called Cignature, and their company c9 has mistreated them several times, and it's honestly disgusting. These women deserve to be respected. You should be protecting your artists c9.
@@McDinglefart_69 the issue is they probably dont get paid and they were forced to consent (because kpop agency can threaten to harm you or end your career without legal action if they say no or disagree to anything bc they are ur employers and make u sign tons of contracts where there are hidden agreements in them) Did you know what happened to loona? They were active since 2016 and now that the members finally filed a lawsuit against the label and left they said that didnt even get a paid a single dime for 7 years, also photos of them not being able to eat by their record label and being heavily bruised. This is fairly common for kpop sadly.
A common victimisation card many women play... They joined and shot and acted and were paid with mutual consent and now acting shocked... Sadly more common than we think
Why they only got uncomfortable then? It's a planed shot, not a sneaky undershot through mirror floor like other more deviant ones? They went through with it, they should have known it'd be like this. I don't claim to be known-it-all but if it were me, I'd already feel uncomfortable since the beginning or keep my fake smile throughout the whole thing.
@@McDinglefart_69 Well if they agree to do that then it's up to themselfs. Unless they were tricked somehow and that scene wasn't supposed to be there. 😁😁
The fact that their faces changed so DRASTICALLY just goes to show they had no idea how that shot was filmed or why? That’s so weird and creepy. Save them.
They are very manipulative. They probably told them "Jump at the same time and this camera will capture your faces" When in fact the camera captures their underwears.
FYI, this clip was stitched together, and only the first girl's reaction was to that segment of the clip (the other girls are actually laughing at that jump). The other girls' reactions here were to other different segments in the clip at different times, but the way it is shown here leads people to believe they were all reacting to the same part. I want to be clear that I personally think the MV itself was creepy (irrespective of how they reacted) but all I'm saying is this is overdramatised if someone thinks this was their collective reaction
Now seeing this a lot of parents won't be fyn with their daughters joining the industry no matter how talented they are, these instances are only stifling women , and is grounding them more and more
@@ngghnkmhvdhnibvccbnktrusfa5376 There is actually less and less kids signing trainee contracts in Korea so chances are it will get better since companies with have less chances to exploit girls since it'll take better conditions to entice kids.
I think Jin Hyeonju was a cignature member with Belle as a stage name, so happy she left to a better group ( unis) wish her the best for her activities
@JoeDempsey-ld5bc Most idols take what they earn to give to their family so that they'll be able to pay for things like rent, air conditioner, or water
If that is what they thought then the "jumping action" wouldnt be necessary. If it is a zoomed shot to the face then they could have just looked down to the camera without moving. Maybe just a smiling shot.
@@asdsadsd-db6xx the jumping is probably a falling in the sky effect thinking it would focus on their face as they fell down the sky. I did it with classmates in one of our group project music video.
@JoeDempsey-ld5bc Don't use common knowledge for ur excuse... every kpop stan knows this AND you have NO rights to hate if you're actually kpop stan...
They definitely should, but it’s a trend in K-Pop right now to have the artists react to the MV at the same time as fans. Like a “we do this together” thing
They don't unless they own their own creative rights which few do. Some do have companies that allow more control over their art, but its not many. Its like this in numerous jobs. Models dont always get to approve every shot or outfit for a catwalk. Authors often dont get a say in the covers of their books. Actors arent approving the scenes that make it to the final cut. Etc. Its fairly common in the creative industry, but also happens in other industries. Not saying its right, just how it is. That said, I always negotiate rights to approve any covers and if going to audiobook, I negotiate the right to approve/disapprove the voice actor they use. Without those rights(and others like time of returned rights, percentage, rights for motion pictures/merchandise, etc), I won't sign any contract. Now, if these girls were indie, theyd have more control. But they aren't. Many times, they don't even get to approve of the songs they sing. They're handed the lyrics and melody and told to sing. Someone else composes for them, dresses them, makes their schedules, decides what brands they'll represent, even what they say in their behind the scenes/vlogs. They're singers and dancers but not necessarily artists. They hand all that over when their parents sign the contracts for them. And in some companies, they get a very small percentage of the profit. A good many kpop idols have zero say in their lives. Think about it- theyre told when to go on a diet, when to sleep, when to film, what plastic surgery to get, where to go, what to say, what to sing, how to dance, when theyll even get to record a song or have a comeback, what shows to go on, what to wear, what hair color to have, etc. Even on their off time, theyre told what not to do. Of course, not all idols or companies are like this but many are. Its similar to becoming a nun(who is 24/7 controlled by the church) or....well, I can't think of any other modern job like this right now. Frankly, its a bit like glamorized slavery and people eat it up, thinking how fun it looks or how cool it is to be so pretty and famous. But is it?
If they own the IP and put up their own money? Sure. You have to remember these companies aren't just a free check for women to go collect if they want to make a MV. They get the say because they take the monetary risks.
@@sortaamy3003To add on to that, even the personality fans see may be "fake" image the company made up for the idol to sell. It is well known that some idols are forced to have "cool girl" or "feminine boy" looks by their companies as well as actions. Some are packaged as rich/luxurious. Some are sweet innocent image and some are gentleman "princely" image. Even their friendships on screen can be faked or even scandals they get into may be manufactured by the company to increase traffic.
1000%. I think it was stellar? one of the members were forced to drink milk in a séxualiséd way in a music video and she said she was literally scared of milk after doing it... like literal trauma by milk.. its insane
@sortaamy3003 Just because that's how it is doesn't mean we can't be angry or try to fight it. After all, death is inevitable, but it's not like most people will just sit and wait to die. It's important to try our best either way.
Lmao. They know the shot was made. It wasn't like a hidden cam or anything. Every group. Not one group or artist in the kpop industry isn't sexualized. It is the main reason why they earn money.
You can see how instantly their expressions changed from excited to absolutely disgusted...some of them look like they are about to cry 😭 what's with their company and management TwT They don't deserve this at all.
.. They knew they were forced to record that shit and were waiting to see how bad it was.. they knew at some point in that day, they were asked to jump over a camera that was positioned on the ground. They already knew hat footage would be used. I'm sure each of them has already had to deal with WAY TOO MUCH nasty BS from the GROSS ASS MEN around them in the industry. SAD
This short is 100% out of context, you can literally go watch the original reaction video, and their reactions are based on several MV's. It's a few weirdos who are fetishisizng a Music Video and being upset.
nope, they make them sign contracts so they can secretly abuse them how much they want as a promise to make them debut, but they just make their lives a living hell
It gets worse one of them (I think the girl in the black and white checkerboard top in the mv) was on a show and they invited a Japanese adult star who said the idol would “do well in her industry” (meaning 🌽) it was really gross and you could tell that the idol was uncomfortable 🤢
It's a horrible situation that this has to happen for some people to finally understand that it doesn't matter that all the members of a group are of legal age 😒 short, low-cut and sexy clothes and concepts should be something that Idols can choose; just because "they are adults" doesn't mean they are ok with this type of clothes or videos. Also, i don't understand why is so hard for the companies to allow their artists watch their videos BEFORE it comes out so they can give their opinions and make changes to avoid conflicts.
I hate when 10 year old kpop stans make those excuses, like they think young adults don't need to also be protected and throw all their energy onto idols their age
It’s what they’re signing for…. . Take it or leave it. This is how the show industry works. Lookism and sexualisation is the key for success in these kind of industries. Yes talents is important too but in the end it’s about gathering viewers/ consumers. I know many here will get mad what I said but this how reality works( sadly).
those poor girls, im not an avid kpop listener anymore but ive loved a few songs from cignature. nobody deserves this and you can tell just how upset they were and how uncomfortable they felt about it but its not like they can say anything which is the worst part
The song was released 2 weeks ago I can't believe it eww disgusting company c9 did to the cigarette _9 disgusting I thought the would delete it after sawing this but the didn't eww Gross 🤢🤮
Every idols is human being, they should be treated well . We must let them feel love and safe. They're not robots to be e used in money making industry 😔
Come on seriously... These girls knew what they were doing.. right? I mean look at the video... what makes you think that these women are unaware of what was happening? ... the clothing and the acting makes me think otherwise.
@@jihheonn there is always an option to walk out... Always... If all of them together told I am NOT gonna do this and walk out do you think any director can do anything about it?
@@entername3840 They can't walk out. They have contracts that last 4/7 years and they can't break contract. I'm pretty sure they have a fee to pay if they back out early. Besides, the damage is done whether they leave or not.
@@jihheonn You cannot go and say these women didn't read the contract properly, they didn't know that this shoot event was gonna happen and even more after all these shooting happened acting surprised that this is what they done? Come on you expect me to believe that?
I've noticed a trend in kpop, if there is a negative reaction by fans, the company sometines finds a way to villianise themselves and vindicate the idols (as pure innocent victims). A lot of kpop companies are painted as the bad guys over & over because it barely affects their business compared to the groups reputation.
I feel for them but this is nothing new for Cignature they've been doing this to them for years... Especially Jeewon... It also kind of makes sense why Bell has left the group.
Bell has not left the group. She's in hiatus with cignature and currently promoting with unis. Once their contract ends, she would go back to the original group. This is done many years by active idols to promote their group more (by being in another popular group that came from a show)
@@obsessed2754 she was on hiatus long b4 Universal Ticket Show n it's been no secret she wants out n has only been in legal negotiations to terminate her contract. C9 allowed her to enter the show for the free publicity. Hence you will never see her with Cignature again. I'm quite aware of how these shows operate ty
Man this is truly heartbreaking... despite not knowing these girls just by seeing the look of disapointment on their faces ruined my day. What their company has done is disgusting. I someone knows how I can help to put an end on this cruelty do share
They might have thought it would be a close up face scene.They can only do what the director says. And many scenes are cut in MVs, this should not have made the cut.They just debuted, this is no fault of theirs.
just take a look at their faces - says all you need to know. and that shot is pretty common, but it's supposed to focus on their faces & a bit of the upper body and def not like that. they look uncomfortable and shocked.
just take a look at their faces - says all you need to know. and that shot is pretty common, but it's supposed to focus on their faces & a bit of the upper body and def not like that. they look uncomfortable and shocked.
it's an awkward af shot that barely shows their faces. Do see exploitation for what it is for it's strange to think that smth like this doesn't occur in the entertainment industry, which is known for things like this. Not to mention, these idols know the kind of reaction they'll get. Idols are attacked every day for being too "sexual", they wouldn't do it on their own when they know they'll be called sluts and attention whores etc for this.
Dear Lord i never said the angency was good. My question, if u read my first comment correctly is that THEY KNEW WHAT THEY WERE SIGNING UP FOR! Terrible uncomfortable thing but they knew it. And dont give me some bullshit they had no idea the angle is here or there. Many girl group from previous generations have displayed this from 2nd gen 3rd gen. To act innocent and suprised is wrong! To think oh the agency wouldnt do this is their biggest stupidity. The industry is doing this from the beginning and its get more sexualised. To act naive is ridiculous. Im part of the problem? Im against. You are they babying them and they know people like you will support their decisions so they keep doing it. At the end of the day they banks are paid!! Yet them keep doing more MVs like this. Think!!!
The smiling through the pain, hurt and embarrassment just killed me. How sad. They can't even react with thier true feelings. Please stay strongly ladies. Working 12-16 Hours a day with practices and scheduling. Starving them self only to get betrayed by thier company, disgusting.
On camera their reaction is like this ,like they have been used .. then how difficult are for these girls in real life dealing with the people in this company or their industry... Protect those poor things
They're quite literally all (groups) sexualised in their mvs. Look at the clothes, the dancing. It's so blatant every single time. They cannot be shocked. Mvs would be VERY different if this was not the case.
doesnt make it okay, they didnt consent to it it looks like they promised them something different like a cool shot but it ended up as that, sure they might've signed a contract but it doesnt mean they knew that abuse would be included? Did you know what happened to Loona? They were told they would be famous but in reality the company refused to feed them and hurt them physically and they didnt get paid a single dime the 7 years they worked.
![[ZICO LIVE : JOIN THE PARADE] 241124 SPOT! -ZICO with JENNIE](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ry-19_BmhM4/mqdefault.jpg)
The girl group in this video is called Cignature, and their company c9 has mistreated them several times, and it's honestly disgusting. These women deserve to be respected. You should be protecting your artists c9.
what makes me afraid for them that the fact this agency was where jjy had been (case burning sun)
NOT THEM SEXUALIZING CIGNATURE OMFG..
Isn’t CIX also under them?
They're not really nugu or unpopular. Anyone in kpop long enough knows them.
I cannot believe the company is tarnishing their name like this
@@dokessezeaka5159 and epex, which they had references to the Holocaust in one of their mvs. Crazy company
their expression says everything…it’s so sad that these girls are being mistreated like this
For real, the company is doing nasty stuff for the girls!! I don’t like that. A company needs to keep them safe not do crap like this
Sad, but not surprising to anybody with a modicum of knowledge on the K-pop industry
They were happy to shot those scenes and get paid.
@@McDinglefart_69 the issue is they probably dont get paid and they were forced to consent (because kpop agency can threaten to harm you or end your career without legal action if they say no or disagree to anything bc they are ur employers and make u sign tons of contracts where there are hidden agreements in them) Did you know what happened to loona? They were active since 2016 and now that the members finally filed a lawsuit against the label and left they said that didnt even get a paid a single dime for 7 years, also photos of them not being able to eat by their record label and being heavily bruised. This is fairly common for kpop sadly.
They’re literally wearing shorts what are you people talking about???
Poor girls...they looked so uncomfortable
I would be too, I would probably not even agree to that
Why did they act though
A common victimisation card many women play... They joined and shot and acted and were paid with mutual consent and now acting shocked... Sadly more common than we think
They wanted easy money and fame
Why they only got uncomfortable then? It's a planed shot, not a sneaky undershot through mirror floor like other more deviant ones? They went through with it, they should have known it'd be like this. I don't claim to be known-it-all but if it were me, I'd already feel uncomfortable since the beginning or keep my fake smile throughout the whole thing.
The first girl really broke my heart. You can tell she was excited for having a comeback only to see that...
She was like "Ohhh happy song" 😊and then "Wait...they film our underwears"😨
@@MishaDalila But they did that themselves. They agreed to do that scene for MV.
@@McDinglefart_69 Well if they agree to do that then it's up to themselfs. Unless they were tricked somehow and that scene wasn't supposed to be there. 😁😁
@@McDinglefart_69 They probably didn't know it was a wide lense and thought it would've been like from the waist up
@@MishaDalila No underwear was filmed. This was also a shot of they knew about. OP is making shit up to bait people who are dumb for outrage clicks.
That’s disgusting… I feel so bad for them
Why they wanted to be in that business
@@saisanjanagurram1423Trainees sign contracts as children. It's doing as she's told or getting a massive debt.
@@yukikanegawa7470 how they get into debt??
@@saisanjanagurram1423 by getting trained by the company for singing and dancing
@@Beojkkoch_Capybara hmm so it's common isn't it
Poor girls and they’re probably not even allowed to leave the company😕
they have already had 2 members (yeah/haeun, and sunn/jiwon) leave the company and group, but they were replaced by dohee and chloe.
@@cherrijoong1765 Oh ok😅 I don’t know their story but good for the ones who left
I think one of the member join unis
@@greenboy5314 belle is in unis, so she is on hiatus to promote with them. after unis is over, she’ll be back
@@cherrijoong1765 ohh, thanks for telling me
The fact that their faces changed so DRASTICALLY just goes to show they had no idea how that shot was filmed or why? That’s so weird and creepy. Save them.
They are very manipulative. They probably told them "Jump at the same time and this camera will capture your faces" When in fact the camera captures their underwears.
@@MishaDalila wow how inappropriate on so many levels. #freecignature
FYI, this clip was stitched together, and only the first girl's reaction was to that segment of the clip (the other girls are actually laughing at that jump). The other girls' reactions here were to other different segments in the clip at different times, but the way it is shown here leads people to believe they were all reacting to the same part. I want to be clear that I personally think the MV itself was creepy (irrespective of how they reacted) but all I'm saying is this is overdramatised if someone thinks this was their collective reaction
@@MishaDalilathey’re wearing shorts you can’t see their underwear?? What are you people talking about
they def had no idea how the shot was taken that why they look at the camera.😂
Bro i wonder how their Parents feel how angry and sad their fir their daughter who is forced to do this poor girls they deserve better
Now seeing this a lot of parents won't be fyn with their daughters joining the industry no matter how talented they are, these instances are only stifling women , and is grounding them more and more
@@ngghnkmhvdhnibvccbnktrusfa5376 There is actually less and less kids signing trainee contracts in Korea so chances are it will get better since companies with have less chances to exploit girls since it'll take better conditions to entice kids.
@JoeDempsey-ld5bc look at the tops it's clear they were uncomfortable
They are forced to do this!? Are they slaves?
Honestly this music video seemed extremely tame compared to most these days.
@@lowkeyloaded793 kind of because a company can do anything to them
I think Jin Hyeonju was a cignature member with Belle as a stage name, so happy she left to a better group ( unis) wish her the best for her activities
she’s still in cignature she’s just on hiatus in the group to promote unis
She is still in the group tho ain't she?
Is Jin Hyeonju former GG Viva? Her stage name was Viva there. I know her in The Unit Rebooting Idol
@cro1ssaunttWait, is Unis like IOI and Izone where they're forced to disband after their agency's contract expire?
Unis literally has a 12/13 year old in the group😭😭😭
Im absolutely disgusted by this, this company needs to be taken down!!
#JUSTICEFORCIGNTURE
Sadly if you try to take the company down these poor girls will be out of a job which some use the money to send to their families .
@@SUN_MOON_SKY93 let's just hope they get signed to a new company if this ever happens
@@JasonJames-ti7hwOf course, it's that easy and simple, how did you not think of it before? (Sarcasm)
@JoeDempsey-ld5bc Most idols take what they earn to give to their family so that they'll be able to pay for things like rent, air conditioner, or water
@JasonJames-ti7hw Yes, lets make hundreds if not thousand of people who work for this one company unemployed. Best idea ever.
That is absolutely minging. No one should ever have that done to them.
Edit- Never had this many likes on a comment before lol.
Welcome to the Kpop industry.
Can you tell me mining means? I'm learning english😅
@@faustina.5767 people from Liverpool (scousers) say minging when something is disgusting
@@13nainaa24 oh thank you
@@faustina.5767 no worries
They probably thought that their face was zoomed in the shot
If that is what they thought then the "jumping action" wouldnt be necessary. If it is a zoomed shot to the face then they could have just looked down to the camera without moving. Maybe just a smiling shot.
@@asdsadsd-db6xx the jumping is probably a falling in the sky effect thinking it would focus on their face as they fell down the sky. I did it with classmates in one of our group project music video.
My smile immediately turned into a frown of disgust with them... witaf is that shot???
I feel bad they don't deserve that💔
@JoeDempsey-ld5bcYou know NOTHING about kpop💀
@JoeDempsey-ld5bcthey AGREED aka they were forced or they will be fired and all the work was for nothing
@JoeDempsey-ld5bc Don't use common knowledge for ur excuse... every kpop stan knows this AND you have NO rights to hate if you're actually kpop stan...
Shouldn't they be given a chance to view the video and approve it before it is disseminated?
They should but apparently they didn't got that chance.
They definitely should, but it’s a trend in K-Pop right now to have the artists react to the MV at the same time as fans. Like a “we do this together” thing
They don't unless they own their own creative rights which few do. Some do have companies that allow more control over their art, but its not many.
Its like this in numerous jobs. Models dont always get to approve every shot or outfit for a catwalk. Authors often dont get a say in the covers of their books. Actors arent approving the scenes that make it to the final cut. Etc. Its fairly common in the creative industry, but also happens in other industries.
Not saying its right, just how it is.
That said, I always negotiate rights to approve any covers and if going to audiobook, I negotiate the right to approve/disapprove the voice actor they use. Without those rights(and others like time of returned rights, percentage, rights for motion pictures/merchandise, etc), I won't sign any contract.
Now, if these girls were indie, theyd have more control. But they aren't. Many times, they don't even get to approve of the songs they sing. They're handed the lyrics and melody and told to sing. Someone else composes for them, dresses them, makes their schedules, decides what brands they'll represent, even what they say in their behind the scenes/vlogs. They're singers and dancers but not necessarily artists. They hand all that over when their parents sign the contracts for them. And in some companies, they get a very small percentage of the profit. A good many kpop idols have zero say in their lives.
Think about it- theyre told when to go on a diet, when to sleep, when to film, what plastic surgery to get, where to go, what to say, what to sing, how to dance, when theyll even get to record a song or have a comeback, what shows to go on, what to wear, what hair color to have, etc. Even on their off time, theyre told what not to do.
Of course, not all idols or companies are like this but many are. Its similar to becoming a nun(who is 24/7 controlled by the church) or....well, I can't think of any other modern job like this right now. Frankly, its a bit like glamorized slavery and people eat it up, thinking how fun it looks or how cool it is to be so pretty and famous. But is it?
If they own the IP and put up their own money? Sure. You have to remember these companies aren't just a free check for women to go collect if they want to make a MV. They get the say because they take the monetary risks.
@@sortaamy3003To add on to that, even the personality fans see may be "fake" image the company made up for the idol to sell.
It is well known that some idols are forced to have "cool girl" or "feminine boy" looks by their companies as well as actions. Some are packaged as rich/luxurious. Some are sweet innocent image and some are gentleman "princely" image. Even their friendships on screen can be faked or even scandals they get into may be manufactured by the company to increase traffic.
Kpop companies are getting worse and worse day by day shame on them mistreating idols disgusting
For an MV reaction, their face said a lot, so many even... To the point they become speechless. This how company usually destroy these girls dreams
1000%. I think it was stellar? one of the members were forced to drink milk in a séxualiséd way in a music video and she said she was literally scared of milk after doing it... like literal trauma by milk.. its insane
As a cignature stan, im happy people are finally talking about their mistreatment. They deserve better
Wow, this is truly disgusting any company that exploits their idols is just truly disgusting generally.
Welcome to the world. Most companies exploit their workers. Not saying its right, but thats how it is.
@@sortaamy3003 FR 🤦♀️
@sortaamy3003 Just because that's how it is doesn't mean we can't be angry or try to fight it. After all, death is inevitable, but it's not like most people will just sit and wait to die. It's important to try our best either way.
They were so proud until they abused them.. disgusting
@JoeDempsey-ld5bcthey were sexualised without consent ?
The dawning realisation on their faces 😢 This is heartbreaking.
See how all the smiles & excitement dropped to frowns & uncomfortableness, that company needs to do & be better.
Poor girls, they looked shocked and about to cry... that company is disgusting to say the least 💀
Lmao. They know the shot was made. It wasn't like a hidden cam or anything.
Every group. Not one group or artist in the kpop industry isn't sexualized. It is the main reason why they earn money.
You can see how instantly their expressions changed from excited to absolutely disgusted...some of them look like they are about to cry 😭 what's with their company and management TwT They don't deserve this at all.
.. They knew they were forced to record that shit and were waiting to see how bad it was.. they knew at some point in that day, they were asked to jump over a camera that was positioned on the ground. They already knew hat footage would be used. I'm sure each of them has already had to deal with WAY TOO MUCH nasty BS from the GROSS ASS MEN around them in the industry. SAD
Lmao and in the end the blame is towards men 😂
1) They are not forced
2) They've been exploit
There huge difference
@@princejunyoung4495its the same
@JoeDempsey-ld5bcthey ate forced or they will be fired all work blood sweat and tears lost
@@ohmypeenus1332when men take these underskirt shots its the mens fault if they refuse they get fired and blacklistet
What's worse is after, their company CUTS THE PART OUT
The 4th girl... You can see the fear in her eyes
Damm She was so scared she swallowed hard....😬
One of them.....
Her smile faded but still put on a fake smile:-(
That’s absolutely insane and weird overly sexualizing there own idols like that’s going to help them omg that company is insane
The exploitation of it all 🤮
This short is 100% out of context, you can literally go watch the original reaction video, and their reactions are based on several MV's. It's a few weirdos who are fetishisizng a Music Video and being upset.
Thanks
Kpop fan let's protect them.
Who knows what happen later
It looks like they weren't even aware of that. Isn't that illegal?
No. Its not illegal.
They are aware. I have a youtube shorts to show u that they know about the shot and they even prepared for it.
ua-cam.com/users/shortsU4xbFUADmPU
nope, they make them sign contracts so they can secretly abuse them how much they want as a promise to make them debut, but they just make their lives a living hell
@@SagaRydbergthey don’t make them sign contracts, they sign contracts
It gets worse one of them (I think the girl in the black and white checkerboard top in the mv) was on a show and they invited a Japanese adult star who said the idol would “do well in her industry” (meaning 🌽) it was really gross and you could tell that the idol was uncomfortable 🤢
Their reactions 😮😮😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
It's a horrible situation that this has to happen for some people to finally understand that it doesn't matter that all the members of a group are of legal age 😒 short, low-cut and sexy clothes and concepts should be something that Idols can choose; just because "they are adults" doesn't mean they are ok with this type of clothes or videos.
Also, i don't understand why is so hard for the companies to allow their artists watch their videos BEFORE it comes out so they can give their opinions and make changes to avoid conflicts.
I hate when 10 year old kpop stans make those excuses, like they think young adults don't need to also be protected and throw all their energy onto idols their age
That's really sad. They shouldn't be treated like that
Hyeonju of UNIS was a former member of Cignatute under the name "Belle." she was half filipino and half korean as well
She's not a former. She's still a member on hiatus and currently working under the group unis (w/contract)
they are trying to gain more fans using the members that's disgusting, sorry they have to go through this😢😢😢😢
That’s disgusting, embarrassing, and absolutely ridiculous !! doing that !! , these girls needa leave that company asap
They look so upset. Shame on that company.
They deserves better 🥺💔💔💔💔
It’s what they’re signing for…. . Take it or leave it. This is how the show industry works. Lookism and sexualisation is the key for success in these kind of industries. Yes talents is important too but in the end it’s about gathering viewers/ consumers. I know many here will get mad what I said but this how reality works( sadly).
The girls deserve recognition for their talents, not their bodies!
What kind of company is that...poor girls, the government must save those girls from the companies who treat them like that, no respect at all
why are they actin surprise? weren't they there when taking a MV?
...they probably didn't know very well about the camera placements.
those poor girls, im not an avid kpop listener anymore but ive loved a few songs from cignature. nobody deserves this and you can tell just how upset they were and how uncomfortable they felt about it but its not like they can say anything which is the worst part
They looks so shocked and disgusted
The disgust on thier face says everything i fell so bad for all the kpop idols
The song was released 2 weeks ago I can't believe it eww disgusting company c9 did to the cigarette _9 disgusting I thought the would delete it after sawing this but the didn't eww Gross 🤢🤮
Every idols is human being, they should be treated well . We must let them feel love and safe. They're not robots to be e used in money making industry 😔
Come on seriously... These girls knew what they were doing.. right? I mean look at the video... what makes you think that these women are unaware of what was happening? ... the clothing and the acting makes me think otherwise.
How is it their fault when they jave no say in video directing? These girls are victims.
@@jihheonn there is always an option to walk out... Always... If all of them together told I am NOT gonna do this and walk out do you think any director can do anything about it?
@@entername3840 They can't walk out. They have contracts that last 4/7 years and they can't break contract. I'm pretty sure they have a fee to pay if they back out early. Besides, the damage is done whether they leave or not.
@@jihheonn You cannot go and say these women didn't read the contract properly, they didn't know that this shoot event was gonna happen and even more after all these shooting happened acting surprised that this is what they done?
Come on you expect me to believe that?
@@entername3840 Ah yes, the contract says "we will take panty shots". Thats Definitely how it works.
The genuine shock on the first girls face:(
The 4th girl with the long hair and bangs looks like she was about to cry ☹️(sorry I don’t know their names) 😅
God this is so sad for our Kpop girls
wtf is that mv? How can they sexualize idols like that? Companies these days are SICK
I've never wanted to burn down a company building this much. TF ARE WRONG WITH THESE PEOPLE?!
Hyeonju from UNIS (Belle from cignature) is save from getting s3xu*lizing, I felt bad for cignature😢
I hope Hyeonju doesn’t come back
I've noticed a trend in kpop, if there is a negative reaction by fans, the company sometines finds a way to villianise themselves and vindicate the idols (as pure innocent victims). A lot of kpop companies are painted as the bad guys over & over because it barely affects their business compared to the groups reputation.
I feel for them but this is nothing new for Cignature they've been doing this to them for years... Especially Jeewon... It also kind of makes sense why Bell has left the group.
Bell has not left the group. She's in hiatus with cignature and currently promoting with unis. Once their contract ends, she would go back to the original group. This is done many years by active idols to promote their group more (by being in another popular group that came from a show)
@@obsessed2754 she was on hiatus long b4 Universal Ticket Show n it's been no secret she wants out n has only been in legal negotiations to terminate her contract. C9 allowed her to enter the show for the free publicity. Hence you will never see her with Cignature again. I'm quite aware of how these shows operate ty
The poor second girl trying to hide her discomfort with a smile...
Bruh wtf c9
Dis is FK UP ...
Man this is truly heartbreaking... despite not knowing these girls just by seeing the look of disapointment on their faces ruined my day. What their company has done is disgusting. I someone knows how I can help to put an end on this cruelty do share
Did they not think doing that scene at that angle was for anything good? At some point we have to stop being naive and childish when we are adults.
You make a lot of sense there.
I agree with that.
Same.
They might have thought it would be a close up face scene.They can only do what the director says. And many scenes are cut in MVs, this should not have made the cut.They just debuted, this is no fault of theirs.
They thought that it could just be a close up scene with their faces and not gonna show their loins like this. 😢
@@mikyas392 this group debuted in 2020. 3 of the members already debuted in 2017.
it’s so heartbreaking seeing their change and drop in emotion.. 😰
Well what did they think when they did the choreography where they jumped together and a camera is at the bottom. Why are they suprised?
Stop the victim blaming. The company was supposed to protect them, not sexualize them. Your response shows you're part of the problem.
just take a look at their faces - says all you need to know. and that shot is pretty common, but it's supposed to focus on their faces & a bit of the upper body and def not like that. they look uncomfortable and shocked.
just take a look at their faces - says all you need to know. and that shot is pretty common, but it's supposed to focus on their faces & a bit of the upper body and def not like that. they look uncomfortable and shocked.
it's an awkward af shot that barely shows their faces. Do see exploitation for what it is for it's strange to think that smth like this doesn't occur in the entertainment industry, which is known for things like this.
Not to mention, these idols know the kind of reaction they'll get. Idols are attacked every day for being too "sexual", they wouldn't do it on their own when they know they'll be called sluts and attention whores etc for this.
Dear Lord i never said the angency was good. My question, if u read my first comment correctly is that THEY KNEW WHAT THEY WERE SIGNING UP FOR! Terrible uncomfortable thing but they knew it. And dont give me some bullshit they had no idea the angle is here or there. Many girl group from previous generations have displayed this from 2nd gen 3rd gen. To act innocent and suprised is wrong! To think oh the agency wouldnt do this is their biggest stupidity. The industry is doing this from the beginning and its get more sexualised. To act naive is ridiculous. Im part of the problem? Im against. You are they babying them and they know people like you will support their decisions so they keep doing it. At the end of the day they banks are paid!! Yet them keep doing more MVs like this. Think!!!
all entertainment company are same so this is normal n this is how they make money..the choice is yours whether you want to join or not
Full support for the artists...they put in so much time and effort they deserve better
They look so upset and uncomfortable.
What company are they in this needs to be taken to court.
That's really messed up. That definitely doesnt look like it was given with their consent
I’ve watched this like 4x and can’t find the “horrible and disgusting thing” the MV company did 😅
That's so degrading. I feel for these girls.
Why are they acting so surprised. The whole industry is about sex. It’s been going on for decades
because they didnt consent to it?? the label obviously promised them something different
Thank you for letting us know. The men of culture will investigate this thoroughly!
That’s so sad, it was without consent too😭
U can see how uncomfortable they're
Shame on every single person who is FAILING AND DISRESPECTING THESE WOMEN
Those poor girls look so upset and I don’t blame them
You even see they didn’t know about this shot. They probably filmed it and thought it was going to be edited somehow.
Hope there's still justice for these type of group
Camera was right uder them, how they are surprised now!!
The second trying to force the smile back up, wow
what’s more sad is I heard they’re seeing the MV for the FIRST TIME… and it’s already out… 😭
The smiling through the pain, hurt and embarrassment just killed me. How sad. They can't even react with thier true feelings. Please stay strongly ladies. Working 12-16 Hours a day with practices and scheduling. Starving them self only to get betrayed by thier company, disgusting.
That’s absolutely terrible
Let’s hope that the MV can get taken down and get that scene deleted
What do they think when they were recording that scene😭
The fact that we will feel bad but cant and wont do anything about it...this thing is more disgusting 😕
They're so beautiful :(( the way they were so excited at first
They are facing the camera , the surprise is more likely due to direction they were promised rather than what was shown
Them poor girls have been well and truly had I guarantee they won't be able to do anything about it. I feel so sorry for them.
On camera their reaction is like this ,like they have been used .. then how difficult are for these girls in real life dealing with the people in this company or their industry... Protect those poor things
They're quite literally all (groups) sexualised in their mvs. Look at the clothes, the dancing. It's so blatant every single time. They cannot be shocked. Mvs would be VERY different if this was not the case.
The way their smiles dropped dang
Come on people, THEY knew what they signed up for.
doesnt make it okay, they didnt consent to it it looks like they promised them something different like a cool shot but it ended up as that, sure they might've signed a contract but it doesnt mean they knew that abuse would be included? Did you know what happened to Loona? They were told they would be famous but in reality the company refused to feed them and hurt them physically and they didnt get paid a single dime the 7 years they worked.
The first one didn’t even look sad, maybe a bit but she mostly looked straight up concerned and shook
wait.... did they think their fans liked their music? lol
Yo i feel so awful for them😢😢