Love this,his death has actually affected me deeply, I've been dedicating peace in the valley in my own shows without really knowing why.RIP Shane🇮🇪🎵xx
Hi. I think alot of us are feeling that way about Shane. " Peace in the valley is a gorgeous tune and very reflective and timeless . It's a great way of feeling some solice about his passing. And you don't have to know why. Beautiful. All the best to you and Thanks for the feedback. 🕊️🇮🇪
I am a black American, 59. I have always been deeply drawn to Irish music. When I see pictures of Ireland it feels like I need to go home. I did my DNA and found out I'm 21 percent Irish. This song has been a favoirite Christmas song since I first heard it. Mr. McGowan's death hit me hard. It's a hard candy Christmas for me this year. I will take this time to bathe in my melancholy, then I'll pick myself up, dust myself off, pack up my melancholy for another year and try and muddle through.
Hi. That's really interesting to hear that you found some Irish in your lineage. I was feeling that same melancholy ,as alot of people are and started watching UA-cam videos of where my dad was from and thought about returning home after a long long time of being away. I hope you get over there at some point . There is a magic to it somehow. Thanks for the feedback. 🇮🇪🕊️
My favourite The alluring lights of O’Mallys Screamed another last one for the road For there’s no time quite like a good time And there’s no place more sober than home Great analysis my friend
Interesting take, he is utterly brilliant. I'm floored by Misty Morning Albert Bridge, again a sense of place anchoring some distant memory that explodes into a euphoric yearning dream of something past. You're right, the time is all over the place, is it memory or dream or now? It all blends. And why it knocks you over sideways. In so few words. I did my time in London as a drinker and lover and all of it like so many and he is the poet laureate of London for sure.
Yes Indeed. Shane was so great at capturing those scenarios in words with simple language. When you see him being interviewed ,you can see that he's exactly the sort of person that is genuine in his statements. In this case there is no difference between the person and the writer . He wrote what he lived. Thankyou so much for the great feedback . I appreciate it . All the best .
@@MrRolandgent Yes I read that last night, just goes to show what a great band they had. It was Jem. Sloppy of me, but I assumed it was Shane as it was so good.
Yeah everyone’s got tons to say about what a great guy he was because he’s died. But frankly he chucked his talent away, the joke was that Shane macgowan died ten years ago but nobody bothered to tell the corpse
Hey John, Met him a few times , good soul! There are still genius songwriters out here, undiscovered. check dave tommo here on this platform! RIP me old Mucka, party a go go , great day's! X
Hi Dave. Must have been good to meet him. Will have a look at your stuff . Feel free to have a listen to my own stuff. I'm on Bandcamp John Gallagher UK. 😊
Apparently when they made the video the NYPD choir had to sing Humpty Dumpty because they didn’t know any songs. So the video has to keep cutting away from them so it’s not too obvious! I’m impressedthatthey’ve started a choir since.
My 81 yr Irish Mum is arriving from abroad in 1.5 hrs. I am tidying and prepping dinner. I dare say we will be watching the recording of Shane’s funeral tonight. My Mum really touched my heart when last time she was here we watched Sinéad’s funeral together + said it was more important than the Queen’s 💚🍀🕊️ Love to All + Slainte + Be Kind xxx (I know Gaelic spelling wrong my uncle who teaches it at 85 would tell me off!)
It's a beautiful message. I was also up till the early hours watching the funeral. I like the sound of your mum. I agree with your sentiments entirely. This world is a better place for both Shane and Sinead. My father didn't know a word of Gaelic despite his Donegal background . All the best to you and your mum.
Thank you . I don't know Christy Dignam. I'll have to check him out. Benjamin Zephaniah I do know and he was wonderful, great with words and the heart, just like Shane . Thanks for the feedback. Take care . 🎶🙏
Im sorry, but why is everyone lauding someone who was an absolute train wreck? Why is it when someone dies there instantly the best thing since sliced bread, im amazed this guy lived to 65, that is his best achievement after caning his life to the max!
Shane WAS a train wreck...no question. He was also phenomenally talented,humble,generous and funny.They say people die twice really,right? Once when your spirit leaves your body.Again when the last person ever speaks your name.Actually in that sense Shane will live forever. Others will just disappear having been nothing but sad bitter internet trolls.
Love this,his death has actually affected me deeply, I've been dedicating peace in the valley in my own shows without really knowing why.RIP Shane🇮🇪🎵xx
Hi. I think alot of us are feeling that way about Shane. " Peace in the valley is a gorgeous tune and very reflective and timeless . It's a great way of feeling some solice about his passing. And you don't have to know why. Beautiful. All the best to you and Thanks for the feedback. 🕊️🇮🇪
Great stuff , we lost a true poet and musician . He left just in time as evrything collapses .thanks shane for evrything
We did indeed. The world is still a better place for their presence on this earth and they'll never be forgotten. Thanks for your feedback.
And to all who have had a Fucker of a Year, I give you all a great big hug x RIP Shane
Thanks for the great message and love . I fully appreciate it . Thankyou .
There was never an NYPD choir until this year and they did just record Galway Bay. RIP Shane❤❤❤
Hi . Ah that's interesting to know. I'll have to check that out. Thanks for the feedback. 🕊️🇮🇪
I am a black American, 59. I have always been deeply drawn to Irish music. When I see pictures of Ireland it feels like I need to go home. I did my DNA and found out I'm 21 percent Irish. This song has been a favoirite Christmas song since I first heard it. Mr. McGowan's death hit me hard. It's a hard candy Christmas for me this year. I will take this time to bathe in my melancholy, then I'll pick myself up, dust myself off, pack up my melancholy for another year and try and muddle through.
Hi. That's really interesting to hear that you found some Irish in your lineage. I was feeling that same melancholy ,as alot of people are and started watching UA-cam videos of where my dad was from and thought about returning home after a long long time of being away. I hope you get over there at some point . There is a magic to it somehow. Thanks for the feedback. 🇮🇪🕊️
@@thesongwritersdropin2565 I really want to go. I hope I get there too.
you have great taste and interesting things to say, thanks for sharing
True genius. Don't book a judge by it's cover, writers don't need to do covers.
Great play on words ! Alot going on in that one . Thanks for the feedback.
My favourite
The alluring lights of O’Mallys
Screamed another last one for the road
For there’s no time quite like a good time
And there’s no place more sober than home
Great analysis my friend
You'll have to remind me from which song these lyrics come from . Thanks for the feedback.
Interesting take, he is utterly brilliant. I'm floored by Misty Morning Albert Bridge, again a sense of place anchoring some distant memory that explodes into a euphoric yearning dream of something past. You're right, the time is all over the place, is it memory or dream or now? It all blends. And why it knocks you over sideways. In so few words. I did my time in London as a drinker and lover and all of it like so many and he is the poet laureate of London for sure.
Yes Indeed. Shane was so great at capturing those scenarios in words with simple language. When you see him being interviewed ,you can see that he's exactly the sort of person that is genuine in his statements. In this case there is no difference between the person and the writer . He wrote what he lived. Thankyou so much for the great feedback . I appreciate it . All the best .
He didn’t write misty morning he was a wreck by then
@@MrRolandgent ok thanks . I didn't know that. I was not specifically speaking about that particular tune directly but thanks for info.
@@MrRolandgent Yes I read that last night, just goes to show what a great band they had. It was Jem. Sloppy of me, but I assumed it was Shane as it was so good.
Yeah everyone’s got tons to say about what a great guy he was because he’s died. But frankly he chucked his talent away, the joke was that Shane macgowan died ten years ago but nobody bothered to tell the corpse
A great tribute 👏
Thankyou for the feedback . Much appreciated. 🎶🙂
Thanks john .
Great tribute and film .
You're most welcome. 🎶🙏
Great break down of the song writing and poetry of shane .
Hope you are havings good morning
Thankyou very Much for the feedback and kind words. You too.
Your explanation is wonderful to listen to. Thank you!
Ah ,Thank you . Glad you enjoyed the video. All the best . John
Hey John, Met him a few times , good soul! There are still genius songwriters out here, undiscovered. check dave tommo here on this platform! RIP me old Mucka, party a go go , great day's! X
Hi Dave. Must have been good to meet him. Will have a look at your stuff . Feel free to have a listen to my own stuff. I'm on Bandcamp John Gallagher UK. 😊
Apparently when they made the video the NYPD choir had to sing Humpty Dumpty because they didn’t know any songs. So the video has to keep cutting away from them so it’s not too obvious! I’m impressedthatthey’ve started a choir since.
My 81 yr Irish Mum is arriving from abroad in 1.5 hrs.
I am tidying and prepping dinner. I dare say we will be watching the recording of Shane’s funeral tonight.
My Mum really touched my heart when last time she was here we watched Sinéad’s funeral together + said it was more important than the Queen’s 💚🍀🕊️ Love to All + Slainte + Be Kind xxx
(I know Gaelic spelling wrong my uncle who teaches it at 85 would tell me off!)
It's a beautiful message. I was also up till the early hours watching the funeral. I like the sound of your mum. I agree with your sentiments entirely. This world is a better place for both Shane and Sinead. My father didn't know a word of Gaelic despite his Donegal background . All the best to you and your mum.
And another good irish singer how went Christy Dignam and benjamin zephaniah English poet
Thank you . I don't know Christy Dignam. I'll have to check him out. Benjamin Zephaniah I do know and he was wonderful, great with words and the heart, just like Shane . Thanks for the feedback. Take care . 🎶🙏
@@thesongwritersdropin2565aslan was the band (crazy world) fantastic song
@@thesongwritersdropin2565just wondering did you look into Christy Christy Dignam. Just watched a documentary on rte about him. Take care
Did you keep a watch for a dead mans wind, did you see the woman with a comb in her hand.
To get on the lucky "one" is gambling parlance
Im sorry, but why is everyone lauding someone who was an absolute train wreck? Why is it when someone dies there instantly the best thing since sliced bread, im amazed this guy lived to 65, that is his best achievement after caning his life to the max!
You'll live to 100 a never do fuck all. Enjoy your long mundane life sweetheart.
I doubt he’d want to switch his life for yours.
Shane had compassion and loved by many. Don't throw stones in glass houses.
Shane WAS a train wreck...no question. He was also phenomenally talented,humble,generous and funny.They say people die twice really,right? Once when your spirit leaves your body.Again when the last person ever speaks your name.Actually in that sense Shane will live forever. Others will just disappear having been nothing but sad bitter internet trolls.
@@sharonviale8423 I'm entitled to my opinion exactly the same as you!