Nakba remembered: What is the right of return? | Al Jazeera Newsfeed
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 тра 2024
- 76 years on from the Nakba, Palestinians continue to demand their right of return after they were expelled from their homes during the creation of the Israeli state in 1948. Al Jazeera’s Nada Qaddourah breaks down the situation and looks at the parallels with Israel’s current war on Gaza.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
@AljazeeraEnglish
#Aljazeeraenglish
#News
#nakba1948
Very sad wallahy...😢
Stop Genocide..🇵🇸
Free Palestine..🇵🇸
Nekbat 2 palestinian life
Wasn’t Gaza its own thing already? I thought walls were around it. Please tell me if I’m wrong.
May Allah grant them freedom
First, return your keys...
Ameen
May Allah protect all Palestinians.Aamiin❤❤❤
May the Palestinian people be granted peace and their own state to live happily as families should.
They already have a state, they don't want it.
They were offered their own state numerous times and turned it down every time.
@@user-oz7hu3sb8land you know the reasons why?
The Nakba was due to the Arab chiefs asking the population to leave ("the time they win the war..."). Those who stayed pacifically in their home became Israelis...
@@user-oz7hu3sb8l what were the reasons they turned it down?
The world has woken up and seen Israel's true color and the horrific atrocities they are carrying out against the Pa1estnian people.
Tough beans.
@@JackFieldBand. What a Childish response.
Maybe starting a war with Israel was a bad idea?
@@joancooley1387they are all bots 🤖 🤖 🤖 🤖
@@Rose.878 Ha Ha Ha ! ! Beanstalks on steroids.
This is so evil and wrong to this to anyone.
🇵🇸🇵🇸 will be free.
🇵🇸🇵🇸 💖💕
Disenfranchising people and making them oppressed and homeless is grossly immoral and unacceptable to any true human being
That's what happens during a war. Arabs have tried and failed to destroy Israel over and over again, and still haven't learned that pursuing peace will get them so much more.
When Germany lost WW2, they also lost land and 15 millions Germans had to move... Do you hear them??? No.
The Quran mentions in many different chapters those who are forced out of their homes and are oppressed. They are told to be patient, to be true believers, to resist because they have special place in paradise with Allah. That's what we see in the patient and the noble characters of the Palestinians. May Allah bless them, forgive us for our inaction and grant us His eternal paradise 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
All# is a hypothetical character and son of Muhham..@& bcs to fool people like you he created this hard fkr.
Live In reality and not in stone age.
Reality is that Hamas just destabilize a dormant volcano which is Taking lives of innocent people on either side.
Subhanallah
I cried a lot, it's really terrible
I laughed a lot 😂
@@richardgillette5759 because you don't have a huminty
Don't cry, the culprits are 5 Arab countries attacking Israel and telling the population to leave "the time they win the war". But they lost... Those who stayed peacefully in their home became Israelis.
Ahh same like Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nagorno-Karabakh, Kasmir, etc.
All stolen by Islam
Will keep praying and doing what we can for their freedom! Will never give up!
One of the world’s most hideous anniversaries.
The Nakba, too, has been downplayed and misrepresented, time and again, in the mainstream media across the world. And beyond that, it is in fact the official policy of the state of Israel to systemically and consistently deny Palestinian suffering. In fact, the whole Israeli settler colony is built on the denial of the very existence of a Palestinian people, let alone their Nakba.
Humanity stands in solidarity and demands justice for the Palestinians!!!
Makes me sad and angry, Izrael‘s denigration of a whole nation and its rights for more than 70 years, but there will be soon liberation inshallah, oppressed people can not remain oppressed forever..
'inshallah'
Way to give yourself away lol
@@mkzhero it will be liberated for sure 💯 and Izrael as an occupational colonial racist corrupt state will falll
@@Amcan839 why to the river? Don't you care about Palestine? Why forget it's Jordanian part? Then again, why am I expecting a brainless fanatic to know what they're cheering for lol
@@mkzheroin jordanian part they are Palestinian jordanians and are already free, protected and equal to other human beings, and not occupied exiled colonized and without rights as in the West bank
@@Amcan839 the west bank and Gaza prior to the first intifada had no borders, free movement and none of the current restrictions in place either.
U are only complaining because things went sideways
So Israel showing it’s true colours, is sideways.
Hasbanallahu Wa Niamal Wakeel!!!!
Very few are people from 1948. Give that percentage. The area cannot fit all the descendants of the Arabs of 1948. Both them and Jews might be idolaters of land….fighting forever for an area that looks like nothing compared to Switzerland.
❤
Palestine will be free🇵🇸
A misrepresentation of the facts to be kind. At that time, all over the world, civil wars were occurring. In Europe, millions of people were displaced. Millions. Yet there is not a single "refugee" camp now in all of Europe. They were all resettled. People moved on. Three options exist (everywhere except in Palestinian minds and Arab countries who use this as a tool to destroy Israel): 1) refugees stay in the country they fled to, 2) they move to a third country that will take them in and 3) they move back to where they were displaced, IFf that country accepts them. There is no "right" of return anywhere!
As an American, I am sorry for all the harm my country has done to the Palestinians. My thoughts are with all those who suffered the Nakba of 1948, as well as those who are being brutalized by Israel's g______e today. I will continue to raise my voice until my nation stops obstructing justice and Palestinians are able to return to their homes with the full protection of all fundamental rights.
Let me take out my violin 🎻😭
@@JackFieldBand I suppose you feel the same about the Holocaust. To each their own.
I don't suppose you support people's rights to return to Constantinople? How about the return of land to the Jews exiled from Muslim countries? Or perhaps right of return for all the christians and others displaced by 1400 years of Islamic conquest? Oh, I know, maybe you feel like deporting yourself and every single American in favor of native Americans that you 'stole' the land from?
The 'nakba' is just a piece of propaganda. In reality it was a literal civil war, one that Palestinians started over disagreement on being finally given the land which didn't belong to them (first it belonged to the ottoman, and the the Brits, with only 12~% of Israel being actually owned by the 'palestinians' (then known just as arabs and not caring for their supposed identity in the slightest), and 8~% by the jews).
And that's all on top of the land being literally unoccupied, back then there where hardly 700k people displaced over a war they themselves started over the land that currently holds ten times as much people with no problem. They could have coexisted peacefully and have the land, they refused and went to war (which they lost), it's that simple. The 'Palestinians' that DIDN'T go to war live peacefully inside Israel as citizens (20% of the population). And even Gaza and wb that where eventually returned to those people wheren't initially closed off, instead having fully open borders and next to no control, all up to the first intifada. So I'll repeat, they could have had peace and a good chunk of the lands they lost, maybe all of them with time. Or maybe could have integrated into Israel fully in which case it the land would be 'theirs' to the same exact extent that any citizens own the land of 'their' country (which they don't, try not paying your property tax and find out how quickly you'll be evicted from 'your' land and house)
@@mkzheropeople in Constantinople were never kicked out and exiled to begin with
nickmolinary2044 In the hope that your comment is genuine. Well Said 👏
Free free Palestine
💯 right to return 🤲✊
No right of return to a country that you keep trying to destroy.
@@user-oz7hu3sb8lUN resolution 194 the international law order the displaced palestainiam should be permitted to return to their home immediately and pay for the property damages. Its their country they can do what they want to do
@@user-oz7hu3sb8lIs this a confess that it was theirs before they were displaced 😁
For a long time, Palestinians' blood mixed with soil of this land, generation after generation. Evil of Zionism will ends and the righteous people to this land will return.
@@nanifatani Palestine never exist. They can return to Ramallah and live with their palestinain bros
When Germany lost WW2, they also lost land and 15 millions Germans had to move... Do you hear them??? No.
Against UN mandate, Arabs and Palestinians rose against Israel and lost the war...
With that everything ended.
😢😢🇵🇸🇮🇩
😂😂 🇮🇱
Free free hostages. .
Sadly no one talks about the jewish nakba - the exodus of jews from arab countries.
Arab countries had an opportunity before and during 1948 to form a Palestinian State (many times since). They refused. They attacked the new State of Israel. Well off Palestinians left before the war, those in villages that agreed not to fight Israel stayed. those in combatant villages were either told to ;leave by Arab invaders, fought and died, or were forced out by Israel - this happens in WAR!! The term Nakba was not used initially because it actually referenced the FAILURE of Arab countries to eliminate Israel - that was the catastrophe! It was not until 1964 that Arafat and the PLO decide to flip the term to mean the catastrophe of loss of living places - basically to FLIP the narrative from the accurate SELF-INFLICTED catastrophe, to being victims of Israel.
You are parroting bad history. Even Benny Morris admits that the Palestinians were forced from their cities and villages either directly or by fear as news of events like the Deir Yassin massacre reached them. This evacuation was mostly before the neighboring states attacked, not after. And the attacks were hardly the David vs. Goliath story that they were previously portrayed as.
And the point of the video is that while it is normal for non-combatants to evacuate regions in conflict, it is also expected that they be able to return to their homes afterwards. That is the "right of return."
Israel denies this right because it insists on maintaining at least a 70:30 Jewish ethnic majority within its borders so it can be both a democracy and a state officially of the Jewish people.
You claim that the Palestinians were offered a "state" which they refused multiple times. If you looked at the details of the negotiations over these offers, maybe you would have a better understanding of why they broke down. Calling the failures a one-sided refusal is a bad-faith description.
@@pinealservo Not parotiing bad history. There was a civil war going on for years. Arabs killing Jews and destroying their villages no difference than Deir Yassin. The difference was the Palestinian Jews hod no were to go! So no option to flee.
There is no such thing as a legal right of return. That is a mde up concept strickly for the Palestinians.
There is no quota in Israel that restricts the birth rate of Arab Israelis. It does not "control" the ratio of jews to arab citizens. It is a Jewish state and will remain so. Otherwise it is a demographic existential threat to the lives of Jews.
Hmm, perhaps you need ot look at the UN Partition plan of 1948. Then opverlay the malaria map of the Israeli portion - very similar. Arab Palestinians had much more viable land than the Jews. And Jerusalem was an "international" capital. They refused. Mutliple times after they refused, Even when they accpeted Camp David accords are they got most (of course not all) Arafat turned around back home and started the second intifada. Becuase of course there is NO way he could go home and ask the Palestinians who had been told their whole lives that all the land is theirs, that they had to accept anything less. They do not want to accept a State with Israel. No deal is perfect. But the threat to Israel's security is something that can never be acepted until the Palestinians change their narrative.
British government 1921 and Hagana forces committed killing and migrating Palestinian people to neighbouring countries for 27 years. The British army left Palestine 1948 after the UN 1948 approved the occupation of Palestine.
She is looking like Bisan
Hamas mouthpiece
GET OFF GAZA AND PALESTINE! Return their lands!!
This is Israel . FKOF
Palestinians with self respect will not accept any haram aid😂😂
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I have no doubt that you will return to your homeland, to your homeland liberated from occupation, the Almighty will help you in your noble cause.
Actually their original homeland was Egypt Jordan and probably Saudi Arabia.
@@user-wq9eg3nm4c No, this is their land, the Palestinians are descendants of Canaan, and from a historical point of view this is their land, and even if you don’t delve so deeply into history, they lived there for generations, for many millennia in a row, without leaving this land, and those who came there after 1880 years, migrants from Eastern Europe have nothing to do with these lands, and have nothing to do with the ancient Jews genetically at all, what they do is shake old texts, interpret them falsely and claim that someone once promised them this land and that’s why they they can come now and drive its indigenous inhabitants out of there, this only speaks of their severe mental illness, they have sick heads and vicious morals. Anyone has more rights to this land than these atheists and impostors.
@@user-wq9eg3nm4c No, this is their land, the Palestinians are descendants of Canaan, and from a historical point of view this is their land, and even if you don't delve so deeply into history, they lived there for generations, for many millennia in a row, without leaving this land, and those who came there after 1880 years, migrants from Eastern Europe have nothing to do with these lands, and have nothing to do with the ancient Jews genetically at all, what they do is shake old texts, interpret them falsely and claim that someone once promised them this land and that's why they they can come now and drive its indigenous inhabitants out of there, this only speaks of their severe mental illness, they have sick heads and vicious morals.
Anyone has more rights to this land than these atheists and impostors.
Palestinians have a right to return to their homes the same way Jews have a right to return from exile.
🍉
The Palestinians' insistence on the right of return is the guarantee that there will never be peace
Take them to your home then.
@@pari521
Israel offer 100,000 which stated clearly that they resettle in areas degrade the security or ecomomic of Israel. Israel never offers right of return these war time calls. In pratice, the Palestinian resettle gaze strip and West Bank should provoke the Israelis. Arab hand over Jerusalem to Israel.
No right is lost, if there is a sincere and continuous demand for it. Palestinian has the right to their ancestors' land and they are paying with all what they have.
I don't blame them - I can't imagine someone forcing me out of my home. Another fun fact: No one wanted to take the Jews in after WW2 - except the Palestinians. 😢 No good deed goes unpunished! 🍉💔
@@jensoph That not historical account they did not want take the Jews and beside Israel is the Jewish people homeland. Also we talk something 70 years ago bothside done things that hardly a excuse for not just make painful comprises and done with it. Accept Jerosaelm part of Israel drop right of return and accept security fence along lines as borderline and stop complain 1948 war. Bothsides ethic questionable say the least hardly Zionist even Plan D did evolution ethic cleasning I hardly blame Zionist for do that to Palestinian over white papers.
Today better ..... voucher get
Vaaaaaayyyy nekbaaat
all Muslim only country Israel full boycott 100% salutation 😢
So I can go to my ancestors land. To how I am Israeli n Palestine I call it Canaan Palestine
Never steal people's home & dance when civilians & children are killed..otherwise u face the Merkava & F-16 music😂😂😂
The world agrees - Pstinians have brought it upon themselves. no ceasefire, no evacuation, more 2000 pounders!
That so hindu? Yo hindus dance when israelis eat beeff?
Sweet sweet music to my ears. Like a symphony
When u wanted to do nakba of israel but got nakbbad urself
😂😂😂 allah has been nakkb@@d😂😂
You live in alternative reality i am afraid...
Who attack first?
Did the Palestine attack Jews in Eruope?
Or the opposite?
Palestines already inhibit the land... No matter what you do...
You can't say it's Palestines fault for fighting back...
Oni su opljackali zemlju od palestinaca
@@painkeller20 u live in alternate realities jews rnt from Europe . Jews always lived here . Palestine is just colinial name of israel . Arab before 1948 never called themselves as Palestinians infact it was insulting for them .. palestina is colonial entity not a country
@@painkeller20 Jews always lived here . Jews arne from Europe .. so called Palestine was never a country tell me one ruler of Palestine before 1948
Free Palestine
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Hello, Iran, Qassem Soleimani shot himself dead and acted in a movie. He makes me alive. I don't know much about atomic rector or atomic bomb. Please help me..
Israel was created for more than 3000 years. It doesn't give such a thing as " historical Palestine ". Palestine was a name given first by the Roman Imperator Hadrian. Before that, there was any Palestine! It was only the Kingdom of Israel and Judah.
You're lying and believing your own lies! If we use your logic, America should return the land to the original nations lived in the land for hundreds of years. What about you, where did you come from, where is your original land? You can't wipe out the entire nation and steel their lands, culture, dishes, etc. and claim they are yours!
Ah, the good ol' "3000 years" argument. Because, you know, if something happened 3000 years ago, it totally justifies everything that's happened since, right?
And yeah, let's just conveniently ignore all the people who've been living there for, oh, I don't know, the past few centuries. Who cares about them, right? They're just a minor inconvenience in the grand scheme of things.
Oh, and let's not forget about that classic move of blaming the Romans for everything. Because, obviously, if the Romans did it, it must be totally legit, right? Never mind the fact that it's been recognised as Palestine for centuries by, you know, actual people who live there.
But hey, who needs facts when you can just cherry-pick history to fit your narrative?
US, Australia, UK, Denmark, Netherlands, New Zealand etc were home to their native people for more than 3000 years. Give their lands back you kolonyzing theevs.
Land belongs to Israel, its written in the book. Btw I am not Jew.
‘The book’. Open your eyes. It has no place in the here and now.
No no and No again.
Then the Quran does have no place either@@joancooley1387
@@user-wq9eg3nm4c No.
@@joancooley1387 You haven't read any book and doing the AlJazeera's false propaganda.
West bank and Gaza can become a Palestinian state.
You think they would agree?
@@user-wq9eg3nm4cOf course not. They want the whole land.
@user-wq9eg3nm4c What do you mean by they? Both side wants the entire region.
@@JackFieldBandand they’ll get nothing
The Quran says the land belongs to the jews and not refugees who are not the native of the land
While you are quoting the quran, let's hear a couple of verses about the brutality of women and children. Because I know for a fact the Quran speaks against this.
Amen
Palestine suffered the worst Nakba 1400 years ago when muhamedan Arabs invaded ,and destroyed the religious and linguistic diversity of Palestine
What nonsense are you talking about?
Mecca and Medina are on stolen Israeli land
Hamas carried out the October 7th massacre for one reason only: to release their murderous friends from Israeli prison. Not the liberation of the Palestinian people, not the breaking of the blockade
Of course Humus told you that. You are kidding yourself.
Sooooooo, you dont support Nelson Mandela's struggle too you razits cutn?
I swear to Allah!
Shame on all Egypt and Jordan who are doing nothing and looking at these genocide!
The Palastines are YOUR neighbors! No matter Muslim or not! They need help and you Munafiq doing nothing!
Hasbunallah u Nemal walkil!
We have no choice but continue to resist the occupation of the Palestinians land. YASSER ARAFAT PLO
🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦
We know too well that the freedom of S. Africa is incomplete without the freedom of the Palestinians. --NELSON MANDELA.🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦
Those who deny the freedom of others deserve it not for themselves & under a just God cannot long retain it. I think slavery is wrong morally & politically. --- ABRAHAM LINCOLN.🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭